I'm convinced everyone falls in love with her the first time they hear this song. It's unbelievable

You Sir, have the look of a man who has been "Reinharted"

I love that stunned look people get after hearing this for the first time. It’s priceless. Scott Bradlee is a genius too. PMJ is his creation and it’s incredible. So many fantastic vocalists.

I loved the way you held onto your pillow for support while your entire world view shifted. Makes me wish I had a support pillow when I heard this for the first time. Some people are just lucky I guess.

5:10... that moment when every musically inclined reactor realises that she's going to keep dragging that note out and doing sexy things with it is always hilarious to watch.. as is the appreciation of her scatting shortly thereafter

I feel this is the best cover of creeep i have ever heard,i watched this video at least 50 times in the last year. It makes me feel like i am watching a movie,where the mobster are in a club,watching her perform ,and they would have called her a dame. lol like a fight breaks out in the lounge, and she just keeps on singing lmao, but dont miss Seven Nation Army with her,and its all about the bass,is a great one also. thanks man good choice

That was about my reaction. This song has brought me to tears before. It's magnificent! Top 5 best song for me of all time.

Someone else said that Haley is the living version of Jessica Rabbit.

There is magic that comes out when Haley sings.

This blank stare is the most appropriate reaction I've seen to this performance!

A great "lounge" jazz performance by Haley is with Jeff Goldblum "My Baby Just Cares". I don't know what the copyright issues would be since the video is a VEVO but even if you can't post a reaction, I would highly recommend that you give it a watch.

Another phenomenal singer they feature is Morgan James. Her 70' soul cover of Maroon 5's 'Maps' and her epic cover of 'Dream on' by Aerosmith are must sees. Don't be fooled by her appearance, this girl has soul for days.

PMJ are masters at this, and Haley... is a goddess. Gorgeous song, best cover of this hands down.

One take, she did it in one take. Damn. PMJ is an amazing concept.

legend has it that this was done on the 1st take.... my favorite part is the scat section, and then that mesmerizing key change.... wow.

I love to watch reactors when they see Haley for the first time. Now try Haley and PMJ doing "Seven Nation Army".

Lmao that pillow hug 😂😂

I agree, it really is perfection! Incredible!

She is absolutely stupendous! I just love her.

The expressions on your face were epic!!! I have seen this one a few times over the years since it’s release and I just love her and the style! I’ve only seen PMJ videos with her and one where there were 2 other women with her. I remember her from American Idol, too! She was one of my favorites from that season. She’s so in control of her voice and I love the texture in her voices! I really enjoyed your reaction!!

I love her take on this song! She's an epic talent! I also love Brian Justin Crum's version from AGT who must have been channeling his inner Haley. I will also add my vote for Dimash SOS as it was the first song I ever heard him sing and I believe EVERYONE in the world needs to hear him sing this song. It's that good.

I love her cover... Her cover of oops i did it again and seven nation army

One of my favorite performances ever! I love Haley. Why she is not at the top of the music industry is a crime and an insult to music.

Love your reaction. This is one of my favourite performances........and to think it was done in one take!!!

In my opinion, this is the BEST COVER of this song. Bottom Line. She is amazing.

You hugged a pillow!!!! Priceless! :D

Done in one take on the morning after a show in Europe. Haley wanted to do it again, but Scott persuaded her that this take was just fine.

Totally laughing out loud. Great reaction. The clown from AGT, Puddles Pity Party, has a duet with Haley and PMJ of Mad World that you must check out. Ahhmazing. And Seven Nations Army, of course.

Here’s the best part, she did this in one take. Wham, Bam, Thank you Ma’am, let’s get a beer!!

I'm loving your commentary. I'm loving your reaction. I subbed. Now I have to check out what else you reacted to.

Brad - You can (and probably will) listen to this over and over and over...and it's just as exciting every time. I've been listening to pop music since the mid-50s and can't remember a single performance that I liked any better than this. When it begins, you have no idea what lies ahead...and then she starts to roll out one type of vocal excellence after another. At the end, you still get the idea that she was still holding back a few tricks for another time!

Their Mad World cover is also great! (and the same girl is singing it)

I love watching people fall in love with her prowess.

Great reaction man. love the Burt Macklin shirt btw

She is wonderful

Dude! Awesome reaction! Your face says it all. I feel like I need a drink and a smoke after listening to this cover. You should check out their cover of Seven Nation Army. Also with Haley and yet another masterpiece.

I JUST LOVE WATCHING THESE GUYS REACT TO HALEY & PMJ🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Scott Bradlee's arrangement is genius. Haley's performance is stunning and breathtaking and awesome, but the arrangement gives her space when she goes soft and support when she lets loose in just the right measure. And that first full stop gets me every time. In short, I agree - this performance of this piece is perfection. I never get tired of it. What I enjoy about watching people react to this song is watching that "oh, wow" look of amazed surrender each time Haley goes a little higher or growls, or scats, or belts for 20 seconds on one breath, or goes from typhoon to a whisper at the end.

True perfection!

she is amazing , love she is bringing back the 30's and 40's music back

The best cover of Creep? More like the best cover of any song!

One of my favorites!!

Thats the way i felt!

The irony of listening to this eargasm, is that you will never get the shock of hearing it for the first time ever again. Haley has achieved perfection with her voice. Cheers on a good review.

Love the reaction.

I concur...perfection!

Phenominal

CLUB BOBALOO featuring HALEY!!

I love this version of Creep by Haley & PMJ!

Check out their version of Seven Nation Army. Another great reaction!

Your Burt Macklin shirt is amazing 🤘

Hahaha, what a cool reaction

oh my god this lady can SANG

Makes me want to order a whiskey and have a smoke. And except for an occasional margarita, I pretty much quit drinking and haven't smoked in nearly a year, lol.

Rumor has it, that was the first take...kudos Haley

Shades of Mae West! (Yeah, I'm old.) Of course, PMJ also harkens back to that same era. She's fantastic! Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying she reminds me of MW, she's much much more than that. It's the vamping style she uses that's reminiscent of that era.

Haley Reinhart owns this song. Radiohead who!

Love how the exclamation at 5:00 was in key, like it could be part of the song :D

Next up "All about the bass" with Haley Reinhart, Morgan James and Ariana Savalas. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/l7KejZR_ttOWpZ8.html Another Postmodern Jukebox hit. This one only got 62 million views. The 3 girls together are unbelievably perfect for this song.

Some highly recommended songs: PMJ - Dream on feat. Morgan James And if you don't know Nightwish and Floor Jansen: Nightwish - Ghost Love Score live Wacken 2013 Floor Jansen - Beste Zangers 2019 following songs Shallow Phantom of the opera - with Henk Poort Same Show: Henk Poort - Sound of Silence Background Info: Beste Zangers is a dutch Tv show where dutch singers sing songs for each others. Floor Jansen is Lead singer from Nightwish and Henk Poort is a dutch Opera singer. There are some more great performances from this show. Floor Jansens performance of Shallows hits Nr. 1 in iTunes charts in the netherlands 2 hours after the was aired...

Love PMJ!

I'm ready for some more Voctave!!! Star Spangled Banner!

do those "belts" come in size 36......?!?

Heard she was sick and did not feel up to sing this song. The convinced her, and she did that in one take.

What did you do at 3:13 ?

Try this beautiful performance: Wicked Game by Chris Isaac Live!

She was seducing you! And it worked. This was absolutely flawless. Your reactions are also fabulous, you remind me so much of my youngest son. 🤟👏🤟

I simply LOVE Haley AND this Creep cover. That commercial you were trying to remember WAS a cover song of Elvis Presley’s ‘Can’t Help Falling In Love’. It was for an Extra Chewing Gum commercial: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/ldt-o6iT2Z3bj6M.html

Your face says it all!! lol

Please react to Shoshana Bean “Make It Rain” Live at the Theatre at Ace Hotel.

Definitely a big improvement over the original by Radiohead. PMJ and Haley did a superb job.

Check out Shoshana Bean singing “make it rain” Any of her stuff is amazing. You won’t be disappointed!

Try to react also to SARAH GERONIMO's cover of CREEP. It's also a different taste of Creep.

React to PMJ's All the Small Things feat. Puddles.

I’m sad you had to skip parts. That’s the worst. Definitely check out her rendition of Seven Nation Army.

Over 87 million views. You might react to Haley Reinhart LAY IT DOWN

Never thought Creep would be a torch song, huh? lol

Try out PMJ and Maiya Sykes cover of Green Day's Boulevard Of Broken Dreams. Not as sexually charged, but it will make you think Green Day covered it.

Eargasim

Have you checked out Yebba yet?

I know how you feel brother...same for me when I first saw it. It was a crime and a national disgrace when she didn't win American Idol. I think Simon Cowell thought she was too arrogant. F Simon Cowell. 😛

Ok gotta be said how you gonna jump over a little of the song just saying. Yeah she’s amazing

She was sick and did this in one take

If you want something different try Road of resistance live in japan by Babymetal

Isn't she just INTOXICATING? I could listen to her all day. Actually, you should really check out something she did with Casey Abrams (also from PMJ) where they did Steamroller Blues at Jazz in the Pines and Haley does a freaking TRUMPET solo using her voice. Yeah, wrap your head around that one!

I have adored Haley for the last few years. The whole PMJ crew, for that matter. The list is just _so_ long that there's no point in going through it here. Do yourself a _huge_ favor and just go to their website and start working your way through their playlist. That should keep you busy and blissed out for a _long_ time. On the other hand, you could radically switch gears and go listen to two of the hottest, most beautiful and talented shit-kicker roots-rockers of your generation: the Lovell sisters, performing as Larkin Poe. Turn up the volume, strap in, get ready, and ... well. Just listen: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jd9ghaqkyZiRenU.html 😈

I know you, in 5:20 minutes you wanted to leave and not come back anymore, I have it too :)

It is a gum commercial.

PMJ is a KZfaq creation for the most part. Their videos have never been blocked as far as I know. Too bad you felt like you needed to skip. A dozen other reactors left it alone -- or maybe they were just flummoxed.

She's so....seductive!

Every time I hear her sing this song I feel like I'm being seduced

1940’s

Haley is like the best vocalist no one has ever heard of because she won't sign a record deal.

Don't look into the camera. We can see your reactions without you doing that. Do you have ADD because you keep looking everywhere except the video

Thumbs down. One, don't chop the video, two, stop looking off to the right at your chat or whatever that is. It detracts from your reaction because it means you are more interested in something off screen than the video you are supposed to be watching.

YES! Please react to more from PMJ!! They’re my fav! 🥰🥰