I first saw this clip on your channel, now i found the full vid + some tuba

AWESOME!

Oh, George!!!!!

I would love to hear this transcribed!

PLSSSSS

Nah that tuba is outbassing that bass by going an octave lower than the bass💀

@@Tacoman542 Therefore, an inaccurate performance

Plus, double bass has a deeper resonance. While not lower than the tuba, theres no need to go that low. Its tone alone makes double bass a more reliable bass instrument for orchestras

@@NevertahnProduction he’s not even talking about the double bass, he’s talking about the guy in the video, if anything you can barely hear the damn basses and not mention they’re always late, the tuba provides a much more resonant sound than them.

@@Aduysvmncmkouyf 'Outbassing' either means being lower or sounding deeper. the double bass for sure has more resonance. its literally how it makes its sound, just like timpani. bass being late has nothing to do with the instrument and everything to do with the player. them not being audible only applies to tutti sections with low brass which take priority in tone. if anything, every instrument in existence has tonal priority over the string bass, however, because of that, it makes a far more fundamental sound than tuba, even though its really buried. the tuba is like the floor of a house. its the ground that people can see and understand. the double bass is like the foundation of the house itself. you cant see it, but its integral for the whole house to sit on, at least in an orchestral setting. even if you claim this to be untrue, string bass has superior blending capability simply because it has more favourable harmonics and sits at a lower volume. the double bass was never about being heard. it thrives in quieter sections, which music definitely has. even loud sections, they create the grand floor that tuba cant quite create themselves. even the function of the instrument itself allows itself to be a more reliable bass instrument for its adsr, transients, and the fact its bowed, thus longer notes. overall, the string bass plays a different role than the tuba. its the more reliable bass instrument. you should read some scores and notice that the tubas are normally tacet for longer than string bass is. source; i play double bass. but back on topic, 'outbassing' mostly means both deeper and lower. the singer can hit more impressive low notes for a voice than tuba can hit for an instrument. while an instrumentalist can hit pedal notes after a few days of practice, a singer would need to train for years to even think about hitting pedal notes. source; i played tuba and was able to hit contrabassoon Bb in about a week. i also sang bass in my high school choir. my voice was settling then, but i knew i couldnt reliably hit those low notes. even years later, i cant get much lower than E2. its not like you can buy an extension for your voice or look up tutorials to make your voice deeper. a naturally deep voice is given by chance, obviously, and being able to use that is far more impressive than pedalling on an instrument that already has that capability

Vocal fry is how it’s done, no human could sing such notes with a chest voice, even subharmonics

@@Tacoman542 have you ever heard of jd sumner

@@greenytoaster JD Summer cannot sing a C0 in chest voice

@@Tacoman542 that was a c1

@@greenytoaster most definitely not a C1. It was a C0. Any tuba player would effortlessly play a C1, A C0 is hard for professionals like this guy too.

Jajajaj

I think yes

@@someguywithhair6439 yeah I picked up on it, every tuba player that has 4 valves can easily play a C1, this guy is a pro and it looked like it was challenging to play it and plus I can hear the frequency better now, so yeah it’s a C0

@@Tacoman542 pretty sure he is using a C tuba, he wouldn't need any valves to play a pedal C, not sure about the C0 tho.

Perhaps it is a false harmonic or something like that

@@matijajerman2005 pedal tone

Also as a tuba player I can confirm that the singer is not playing a tuba

Also one here, can confirm.

Almost have to bite your tongue, puffing is a requirement, not easy

Olha qm ta ai kkkk salvee Paulão

@@alejandrofilhodoaltissimo5085 Salve! hehe

Embrasure

I can't even get past F2-

i was thinking the same lol its an octave below at some parts

@@M0ntie 💀

@@Aduysvmncmkouyf I'm serious any lower in you'll get a botched E0

The Tuba is always a Kontrabass and sometimes a Subkontrabass ;)

This is brady

A C1

Correct me if I’m wrong, but I think the tuba might’ve been playing an octave lower than ken turner.

@@lukesakurai8403 I don't really know all I'm saying is its impressive

Tuba is as long as a school bus if you take on the piping out, so it takes much more

@@lukesakurai8403 Yeah he was playing an octave lower.