Excellent speech . I am 81 and a retired physics professor . I feel I have a lot to learn from this young modern Philosopher , like Bertrand Russell . I can listen to him for hours .

I am from Delhi, and I have a huge amount of respect for Muzammil. Many Indians like him because he is critical of his country Pakistan, but I like him because he teaches his listeners to be self-critical and critical of his own society. Whereas I am not sure whether Pakistan is in a state to become a normal country with constructive critiques like Muzammil, India for sure can learn from him and avoid treading the path of becoming another Pakistan. Hyper-nationalism, hyper-religiosity and hyper-communism are all horrible. Rational thinking with scientific temper is the need of the society.

I am proud Indian but I Can not ignore intelligent people like sye Muzzamil Shah. I adore him , respect him. You cannot mock Pakistani people just because their political class is corrupt. They are part of us Indians , they are our brothers and sisters. I wish them good luck and I hope one day they will also be Happy and free from this corrupt regime. Love from India ❤️. We don’t hate you, we only hate terrorism.

We Hindus of India thank Jinnah for creating Pakistan and saving us

Syed Muzammil Shah is the real, and probably the only, intellectual in Pakistan. He is an intellectual because he READS and THINKS. I'm happy to see so many young Pakistanis wanting to hear him.

From 🇮🇳... But to listen you is beyond boundary....

Indian American here, whatever Muzammil says is of cross border concern. Even in the US we need to remember these first principles. Rational thinking is under attack everywhere. Very few are able to think straight anymore and such a community needs to be nurtured wherever they are. I live in the Bay Area, and you will be shocked to know there is almost no internet connectivity in the areas where the tech community lives. Why? because they realise the untold harm that the moving images have caused to human brain; they dont want their kids exposed to it. That is why schools in the Bay area esp Los Altos, Palo Alto, the home where tech billionaires live, do not allow the use of phones and computers. What do they know that they are not telling the res of us? What do they know that they dont let their own children use tech?

The audience crowd is over flowing, a tribute to Shah, a favorite of mine.

I am a 88 year physician in Canada and learning more from your lecture than I would from a visit to my gurdwara

سید مزمل کو سن کر لگتا ہے، گویا یہ بھی مرے دل میں ہیں۔ کتھارسس ہو جاتا یے، شانتی کا احساس ہوتا ہے اور آرام سے سو جاتا ہوں۔ کیا آپ بھی میری مانند تنقیہ اور آنند کی خاطر سید مزمل کو سنتے ہیں؟

Love from India Muzammil! The key learning I always take from you is critical thinking! Thank you

Happy to see the crowd in Pakistan for listening Logical thoughts.

Whatever he says applies to the entire Indian subcontinent

we need million more like you sir, excellent work!

Muzammil sir u r my Guru beyond borders❤ ….its unfortunate that I can’t meet u 😢 due to rivalry between India 🇮🇳 Pakistan 🇵🇰

Watching from india❤

Muzamil shah is a blessing for Pakistani youth

Finally rises a bright young intellectual! Save him Pakistan ✌️

Smart kids and totally involved. Intelligent questions and answer.

I think more Indians should listen to Syed Muzammil...

Greetings from India, always a pleasure to listen to you. Many of the your country’s problems are also prevalent here & your views are relevant to us!

You can migrate to save yourself but migrating with the same mindset you acquired in your country can yield no difference.

Thanks Muzammil! Your thoughts are beyond the boundaries.

This lecture is very much relevant to Indian society and Indian politics

Excellent sir thanks alot for Educating our people

Syed our emotional part of the brain has been with us for millions of years. It is called limbic system. It helped us survive fight or freight situations in forests. The thinking part is neo cortex and it has been recent addition so it can easily be over run by limbic system in most people except those who develop critical thinking. Religion and patriotism are big stimulants of limbic system. Great talk.❤

Rare to see full house like this. Indicative of popularity of SM Shah among youths of Pakistan.

Always a pleasure listening to Syed Muzzamil...what a clarity of thoughts!! Not only very well read but applies it to his discourse too.

Peeran da peer sain Muzamil shah bukhari ❤️

I think you are doing great work for the undecided part of Bharat...❤

Substantial and fabulous. Muzzammil sahib, you are convinced that printed works are serious thing and media shows aren’t. So please write down your thoughts and print. Society needs your methodical thinking in book form.

I have read comments of many Indians here appreciating you but only appreciating you is not enough , hearjng you is good but actual implementation of it in one's life and society would be actual success of hearing you . We should focus on our society it should not become a popularist leader's country , as I feel today it js , while people becoming extra religious , and some section of society not criticising the government wherever it is going wrong but rather than defending them . Developing Rational thinking in the people is the only solution here . And I agree with you about the fact that understanding the difference between real and fake information is challenging and the most important in such a high flow of information nowadays . From Delhi , India 🇮🇳

First time Hall is jam packed.Best discourse by Muzzamil Sahib.

Very rational in his talk and forced me to think and challenge my ideas especially politics, but I diifer slightly in the Imran khan case with the current situation, whatever rational you are does not matter when you have to choose for a certain option, like Nawaz, Zardari, and Ik, peaple have reacted against Nawaz and Zardari more rather in favor of Imran Khan. Love Muzamil work, May Allah bless him great asset for us

Muzammil sir awasome , good 👍

I need a person like this in india also who is critics of everything.

If Sayyed muzamil ever come to India.... he wouldn't be able to walk on road 😅.... because we Indians love to listen him.. much more than his own countrymen because of his top notch critical analysis of various issues........😊...... As always 💕 and respect 🙏from your ancestor's land....

I dont believe in borders but humanity God bless bless you my lndian brothers

That's why Hinduism says change is the only permanent thing in the universe. That's why Hinduism teaches us the term coexistence with other individuals, new technologies etc.

So revealing and enlightening

I really enjoyed the session. Thank you TBH Team for organizing such enlightening program and making it available to me although I am from a rural Sindh. More power to you Muzzamil Sir!

Muzammil is a bright spot in an otherwise depressing state of Pakistan on all fronts. His critical views equally apt for India as well.

Muzammil is always my favourite. He has borne before time

@48:11 : It was correct that it was Beethoven. He lost his hearing later on in life, when he was composing one of his greatest works, the Ninth Symphony. He used to immerse his head in water regularly to help with migraines or headaches, and that accelerated his hearing loss. It is said that when the Ninth Symphony debuted, he was also conducting the orchestra himself, but he had assistance from others. The musicians all still played it to perfection.

Indians can also learn a lot from this ... though we are on right track , big part of society is away from rationalism

mai hamesha pak ke chanel par coment me likhta hun ki pak me 99,99% LOG JAHIL HAI AUR YEH SACH HAI:Akhir unme se aap jaisa koi nikalta hai jo ko 00,01% hai sun kar bahut achha lagta hai.achha lagne ke baad usi samya dimag tension se bhar jata hai aur bhagwan se prathna karte hai ki aap jaha bhi ho sahi salamat ho.kiyo ki hum ko yeh bhi malum hai ki sach bolne wale ki jindgi bahut bade khatre me aa jati hai pakistan me.aap ki baate sunte sunte ek baar to ankho me paani aa gaya.aap jaise sache log hum bhi hai par farak hai .jaha beth kr aap sach bol rahe hai waha par sach ki saja hai aur jaha hum sach bolte hai waha kisi ko koi farak nahi padta.aap mahan hai .par sirf 00,01% HAI:LIKHNE KO BAHUT HAI PAR JAYDA LIKHNA Sambhabh nahi hai. dil se aap ko lakho lakho DUAYE:MERA BHAGWAN AAP KA ALLAH AAP KI HAR SHAN AAP KI RKSHA KARE:

the best part of Muzammil is that he never disappoints. May Allah protects him , my prayers are with him ❤❤

Always lovely to listen to Muzammil… Great thinker and thought’s share

Wonderful talk. Mind-blowing.

common pakistani should learn from him. Nice to see that pakistani youth are listening discourses. .. allaha bless him always

I just love to hear him Who talk about Facts Just

Quality discussion, question and answer. Appreciated.

Excellent Excellent Excellent Talk. Love it. Syed Muzammil is doing a great job. I am inspired by this gentleman and hardly miss the talks I find on KZfaq.

Muzammil is bright person n interesting facts n truth about social contact of Pakistan culture

Syed bhai has inspired me to read Nietzsche. I listened to his podcast episode on the Pakistan experience and since then, i have been a fan of him. Wish you the best. Your talk is very relevant to Indian political scene too. Critical thinking and rationality has decreased and govt is actively promoting pseudoscience.

Good discussion. The actual truth is telling us. God bless you for better Human Resources Development...

One of the best conversation.. Thanks from India... Total respect..

Jazakallah

I am from India.... You are something unbelivabley well read. Clreear in your own vision thoughts planning .You do say some thing bitter without break ... God bless you. This time I was impressed by the standard int. level of audience as well...

Glad to hear you Muzamil. Amazing work. Keep enlightening Pakistan.

Life changing ❤

Very very right, read and read , think, rationalize,

fantastic, intelligent talk. worth listening every time, Muzamil Shah.

what an intellectual and thanks jinnah.

Brilliant Jazakallah

49:25 😔 i left pakistan in 6th class so i avoided a lot of this abuse lekin it is so hard to listen to. My heart goes out to everyone one of your who went thru humiliation and abuse in school system .

Well, He put a lot of things in very well way.

someone pls include these lectures in Indian school curriculum. It will go a long way in creating awareness in general.

Dear Muzammil... Whatever you said is perfectly correct... However all these philosophies are only applicable once general masses are capable of understanding these .... That means the core issue is lack of education...!!!

After listening this brilliant lecture I'm now your fan... because of your factual base knowledge means you explain everything with facts.. you're a real gem ❤

Excellent Lecture

Muzzamel good job.ladki boli west se inspire hain aapne Sahi answer diya

Philosophy gives us universal vision.

Awesome. Stay healthy. People may need you for a long time to come in their quest for growth and development relevant to its time.

I hope more people listen to Syed Muzamil

keep inviting Syed Muzammil. He is the Greatest thinker Pakistan have ever Produced .

Muzamal sir you have got a nice sense of humour may God bless you.

سید صاحب نے رجیم چینج آپریشن کے بعد جاری بدترین فاشزم پر ایک لفظ تک نہیں کہا اور وہ فسطائیت جو تاریخ میں پہلی بار ہو رہی ہے

Excellent just perfact 😮

Sir I dont know how pakistani are getting this lecture but for me its a life changing lecture.

Thank you both, Black hole and Muzammil

And I love that people are now becoming part of Black Hole due to Syed ❤️. People are getting awared , I am regular listener of this platform and First time see the hall is full of people ❤️

Addicted to this man's thoughts

V good topic .

You are doing well..Need of the hour..

Your Thoughts are useful for Indians also.. Blood is same but mentality difference Islamic & Social.

Sir u are Great ❤ i like your lecture .love u sir❤

Listen Dr. Rasheed Arshad sab ❤❤ a real philosopher and Ahmad Javed ❤❤. Heros!!

What a clarity 💜🔥

Hey Muzammil,you doing a fabulous job of enlighting the youth of Pakistan. I pray that someday there will be a regime that will not operate under the establishment and will actually save Pakistan and May actually treat India as a friendly neighborhood

Love you Sir, you make me critical thinker Love from Allahabad, india

muzzamil sir your thought of process is incredible...your vedioes are very informative 😊😊😊🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

Brilliant!!! ❤

EXCELLENT

Very nice discussion.

Beyond Uzmat Reason

Great discussion, love your critical thinking process. Hope your health prevails to do more productive works.❤from India

More power to you sir ✨

School, technology,,, you have raised micro level yet universal problem. No one in India (except Acharya prashant) advocate for it. I also advise you to read upnishads and vedant...

زبردست گفتگو ❤❤