Thank you. He's got a lot of impressive qualities, I think the main point of my video is that it does him a disservice if people are only checking out a video of his because he can hit a crazy high note in it. He has a lot more to offer than that and personally I hope people are aware of that.

@@Grays_Plays I think people like the song and the fact a D8 is hit in it is just the icing on the cake, most people have never heard a D8 including some world vocal coaches.

To me, his performance at the singer 2017 is more impressive because it is how it is supposed to be sung; just my opinion. I love how you react to Dimash’s songs! You are quite talented yourself! Aloha from Hawaii.

​@@casperwallace9685 100%❤

He didn't write the lyrics, although the melody is his creation

This song on kazak language, his native language.Dumash is from Kazakstan. He is author of this song.

Totally agree, Some people like to recommend the first reactors just for Dimash's D8.It's not wise if reactors aren't familiar with Dimash. They can't stay interested just waiting for one high note even though this song is still good. I prefer the version on Singer 2017, too.

В Китае Димашу звукоинженеры подрезали эквалайзером верхние частоты и D8 не прозвучала... А вообще, врачи запретили Димашу использовать свистковый регистр, потому что воспаляются связки и рушатся зубы. In China to Dimash audio engineers cut with an equalizer higher frequencies and D8 did not sound... Doctors prohibited Dimash to use the "svistkovy" register because sheaves inflame and teeth fall.

Thanks Sara, appreciate the kind words. I'm really enjoying doing these reaction videos. They keep me striving to improve my singing and I love it. Catch you in the next video.

Ok! Gray, I'm extremely glad that I'm with you again !!!

+1 to this - i also like the love is a dream section where he flips up into some really high notes for just a few seconds - for me it works with the song there too

you prob already know - after all, I stumbled on to this reaction years after the fact (btw lovely reaction Gray) - the D8 was accidental according to Dimash himself in an interview..... he missed the note directly before a D or E 7, adjusted an the famous D8 occurred - apparently it's the highest note ever sung live...... I saw D live in 2019 in NY & his skill is otherworldly

Oops IAM bad wrong song it was "daybreak" that I was talking about the parents handing their baby to a Stranger . And it was a cable car , not a train sorry about that ,,, everybody!!!! I brain farted

Лучше не знать ,что он сказал.Перевод есть.

@@user-im4jn9rt9n А ссылку на перевод можете дать?

Татьяна Зыбинская а где перевод? ссылочку дайте! или сами озвучте что он сказал ,плииииззз !!

As it always will be.

I know, he's adorable sometimes. You should see him when I play Disturbed or Def Leppard. He loves those 2 bands for some reason and he's always flapping his tail in time with the music, haha.

remarkable.... he draws you in.... such a Gift

Yeah having seen a couple of other performances of this song it seems obvious it wasn't typical. Impressive range for sure, but I like that his focus isn't on the extremes as I've seen plenty of singers that were fantastic technically at the extreme ends of their range but were bland beyond belief to listen to for a whole song. It's really impressive to see such a wide range implemented tastefully and musically like with Dimash. Very inspiring.

Не правда. Я также покрываю свои ошибки сумасшедшими высокими нотами. Это работает блестяще большую часть времени.

In China to Dimash audio engineers cut with an equalizer higher frequencies and D8 did not sound... Doctors prohibited Dimash to use the "svistkovy" register because sheaves inflame and teeth fall.

@@user-np7tg6je1u you English is bad man I'm sorry , what I understood from your words is that they advised Dimash not to use his whistle register a lot but the word " prohibited " you're so wrong about that Dimash said multiple times that he will never allow someone to force him on anything , if he wants to whistle then he will , if he doesn't then he won't .

Oh yeah I get that, and I can't blame him for it as he's bound to get some individuals laying that criticism at him and it must be irritating. Just sounded quite abrupt with how quick it cut in and out when he moves the mic, but it's probably just because of a noise gate with the threshold set quite high as there must be a massive amount of crowd noise to have to filter out with that many people there. And yeah I was inclined to think that the D8 wasn't really his original intention after listening through to the performance again. Dimash's sense of musicality, or at least what I get the impression of when listening to the rest of his singing doesn't give me the impression that he makes random 2 octave jumps in the middle of his melodies on a regular basis, haha. The D8 worked well given that it was to cover a mistake, as I don't think anyone would of remembered any blips at all after hearing a note that high, haha. And cheers, I appreciate the compliment. See you in the next reaction video.

@@Grays_Plays From what I understand there was 150,000 people in attendance and knowing Dears, there was probably a lot of screaming going on.

Having seen a few other performances of this song it makes sense him blaring that D8. He missed the note he was going for so figured why not let it rip, and it worked well in my opinion with that in mind.

@@Grays_Plays Agreed. In the other words it's not necessary. Matter fact, he can hit that note without pitchy at all. That's why we don't need to worry about. So don't let people get wrong understand with ur reaction.

Noted, thanks for sharing.

It's always fun to let rip with the extremes of waht you can do vocally, as it's always impressive to see. My comments were aimed at pointing out that there's a hell of lot that's going on other than just the whistle note, because a lot of people forget that and I think it's important especially as an asipring singer to remember that the extreme high notes aren't what make Dimash a great singer. His great singing is.

@@Grays_Plays By the way, of his most iconic and above all "appropriately" versatile performances you are definitely missing Ogni Pietra, and perhaps Love is like a Dream. Obviously, there is something good in all of them, but those would be the elemental ones in my opinion. Secondly I would put his own songs, Passione and Your Love. I hope it helps you. Successes.

@@cesar4729 Been meaning to check all of those out and I'll definitely get round to it soon. Cheers for the suggestions. Catch you in the next video.

Generally he's incredibly tasteful with his use of his extreme ranges in my opinion. I was just making a few comments because more or less every single compilation of Dimash's best moments includes the few seconds of this performance where he hits that note, and I just feel that as cool as it was I think how good the rest of his singing is isn't worth overlooking for that as he's got a lot more going for him vocally than most singers who posses that kind of range. I don't think there's anything wrong with hitting high notes at all to be clear. I have more than an average singer's range and use my higher range all the time because it's easy to impress people with it, just wanted to add some context for people who'll focus on Dimash's high notes over everything else he's doing. Cheers for commenting, and thanks for the suggestions. I'll definitely give them a look.

@@Grays_Plays Luv your reactions Gray - I just recently stumbled upon them & you really bring a diff perspective b/c of your Rock Vocal background.... I feel that you are tasteful & mature beyond your years...... the D8 was an accident according to Dimash - he missed a D7 immed B4 (if you look close you can see it) then hits the D8 - no it doesnt fit in the piece but it's just more evidence of his freakish technical ability - Reactors used a Frequency Device to identify it for certain - just crazy... personally, my fav version of this song is 2017 on the Singer - it's brilliant - though I do luv this version also - watching Dimash hold a 150,000 person audience in the palm of his hand like Svengali is just amazing......

If you're saying Dimash cares about that , you don't know him as a person at all . His voice did break for a moment for the first time in his professional career that his voice fails him in front of a huge audience , so he raised his hand to the sky and went as high as he could at that moment . I'm sure if he cared about the stupid title he would've done that at the very beginning of the concert with his voice completely rested and his body relaxed so he could even go higher than Georgia Brown who has the highest ever recorded note ( which we have audio proof for ) with ( F8 )

@@kolgerrard1964 and you know him personally? I am actually quite close to his inner circle, so please don't preach. He did not sing this note for the melodic value. There are a few theories about how he ended up singing it but yes, sometimes he also just has fun. I see that my post may have been interpreted as him doing it to set a record. I should have worded it better. It didn't really have melodic value and however he ended up singing it, the result was a record and it still draws attention for the shock factor. That's all. Please just don't attack people using an angle of how they don't know anything about him etc. You don't always know where people fit into the picture and it is a little disrespectful

@@kolgerrard1964 and I was actually referring to a whistle within a song during a live performance. Many people have produced whistle notes much higher than this. I think up to the 10th octave, but it's basically just a screech.

@@Watchamacallit000 You're right about the record for a live performance on stage , it's belongs to Dimash . The highest for a male in general in the Gueniss world record is ( E8 ) The only notes higher than the ( F8 ) I mentioned previously are ( A9 but barely audible and a lot of critics don't count it because it wasn't intentional whatever that means but just like some don't count the C2 in sinful passion for Dimash for the same reason ) and the same woman with the ( F8 ) Georgia Brown with ( G10 ) but here comes 2 major issues with that , first , there is no available audio recording for that note . Second , even if there was one , we wouldn't be able to hear anything because the frequency is way above 20 KHz the human ears simply can't pick up frequencies higher than that . And my point was that if Dimash wanted the record , why didn't he go for the whistle at the beginning of the concert ?? Why wait until you're tired to the point of losing your voice for a second ??? And why didn't he try again after that one in 3 years ?? Why not give it a shot until he gets the official Gueniss world record from Georgia Brown ??? I don't know him personally but I know enough about what he's like as a person to say he doesn't give a shit about how wide his range is or what people say about his range at all , he said multiple times that no matter what your voice type is bass or triple and no matter if your range is 2 or 3 or 6 octaves , what matters is singing beautifully and delivering the message and emotion you want to communicate with you audience . If you wanna hear that from him I'll be glad to find some of the interviews for you .

@@kolgerrard1964 Gakku concert consisted of only 3 songs, so there was no fatigue. I don't really understand why you want to find me interviews and educate me about Dimash when I already indicated that I'm close enough to have insight. I'm not going to elaborate but please, not everyone wants to continually be lectured and educated about Dimash, which is a tendency a lot of Dears have. I understand that one might feel the urge to share what one knows, but rather ask if the person would like more info. Please let it go now. I'm not going to comment on this any further. 👍

i think thats a playback fail he used to lipsync all his whistle songs before 2017 except from kinalama where he did it live in practice and on a TV show at 5:21 i think hes doing headvoice staccato but the sound engineer turned his mic off too early if you notice just before that part he was also doing headvoice so i think he just wanted to finish it off but ofc it was too late at that point also he has over 8 unforgettable day performances past the 4 min time mark where he does headvoice staccato in that area and some which align with it perfectly and some he has also waved the mic at the same time while doing headvoice staccato and in most cases while on his knees to and his hand in a similar position so i think this is just a mistake ppl mistook for being a live fail but actually its a playback fail :) and ofc he checks to see if the mic is back on at the end by having it super close to his mouth so no one can see by doing the low falsetto also i think it would be perfect to do it at gakku to since its like the biggest music concert of the year there and hes definitely a pro when he does a mistake like you said the mt emei he had me giddy all through that with him talking to the fans so much every reactor should see that side to him i noticed most just react to him when hes playing a serious character they dont really get to see his funny and down to earth side :)

Yeah it makes sense having seen a couple of other performances of this tune. I had very little to go on when I first saw this other than that it makes everyone's Dimash compilation videos specifically because of that high note, and as a singer I felt it needs pointing out that obsessing over range won't make you as a good a singer as Dimash cause a lot of beginners get confused I think. Cheers for commenting and clearing a few things up for me.

​Gray I'm not a singer, so I'm not good with terminology, but I meant 'whistle' as in 'tea kettle' not the whistle register that sounds like "singing", if that makes sense. DECEMBER 10TH ITS DECEMBER 10TH NOT THE 20TH for his concert. I have NO IDEA what I was thinking.

Ogni Pietra is a masterpiece! He totally needs to hear that...

Too true.

Not sure what your comment means but i appreciate the time you took to write it. Cheers.

Certain it's on my list somewhere. Thanks for the request mate.

Haha, would be a bit too clickbaity, even if the 2nd half of that is true.

Not really given that the average request for me and for most reactors to react to this video went something along the lines of "please react to Dimash Unforgettable Day in Gakku. He hits his highest note ever, it's a D8 and it's amazing. You need to see it!" That and whenever anyone makes a compilation of Dimash's best live moments they always include a short video of that specific note makes it pretty clear where most people's focus is when watching this video.. I can't not comment on it with the context around people wanting to see others reacting to this video, lol. The average listener will assess a singer's capabilities largely on the vocal range they hear them display. It's understandable but it's far from everything that goes into making a great performance, and that definitely warranted commenting on given the audience I'm focusing on when making these videos. Aspiring singers quite often get lost trying to develop their own vocal range and they'll neglect other aspects of their singing because of it, and that's what I'm commenting on more than anything in this video, because that high note doesn't make this performance great (it's merely a cover up for messing up the note he was actually aiming for after all,) the rest of his amazing singing does. The high note naturally gets attention as they always do in vocal performances, but singers watching and learning from it should focus on the other aspects of what the singer is doing as well and not assume that being able to hit those kinds of notes will automatically make them equally amazing singers. Speaking as a guy with more vocal range than average I can say from experience that it's a wonderful thing to have, but it's not everything by any stretch and it doesn't make me an amazing singer. I've seen a lot of vocalists in my time spent studying singing that can hit the notes Dimash can, but none of them gained an audience anywhere near as big or as passionate as he has and it's his abilities in other areas than pure range that make that difference. He's an amazing singer who can also hit crazy high notes, not a singer who is amazing because he can hit notes like that, and the distinction is very important for those that are trying to learn to sing themselves. I'm afraid I can't agree with you, just saying I didn't care for his high note wouldn't of been anywhere near enough with all that in mind (also would of been a lie, I never said I didn't care for it.) This is a conversation that has probably been going on for centuries among singers at this point, and it'd be incredibly flippant of me to not comment in the way I did given what a big subject this can be in the singing community. Cheers for commenting, I appreciate your input.

Yeah, having watched a few performances I get what he was doing now. I'd of done something similar if I missed a note like that to be honest, it worked well to cover the mistake up, haha. And I prefer his lower range as well, sounds absolutely lovely. Don't get me wrong I'm a big fan of vocal range, spent most of my time as a singer trying to get more of it but these days I've learned to appreciate the expressiveness and emotions that you can convey in the lower range and I take note more of that when I hear a singer do that well rather than flashy high notes.

@@Grays_Plays Completely understandable. And for me, someone who's trying to learn singing, I'm just focusing on controlling my vocals. Like, hitting notes is cool, but having absolute control of how it sounds and how long it's sustained, that's just on another level.

@@Zaneyy030 Funny enough as you get control over the tone you'll get more control over your range and your voice in general. Biggest thing to bear in mind with singing and range in my opinion is that the way you use your voice when you sing low will affect how you can use it when you sing high, so be aware that there is a balance to be had between the different ranges to make things work efficiently, and just keep experimenting and practising and I'm sure you'll do great mate.

@@Grays_Plays Thanks! I mostly learn from videos, can't afford real classes lol so this is helpful to know!

@@Zaneyy030 Happy to give you a free lesson if you want mate. How long have you been learning to sing?

I'm not bashing on him, Dimash is a phenomenal singer and one of the few that I feel is generally speaking almost above criticism, haha. I think my fundamental point in this video is that he went for a crazy high note and a lot of the people watching this performance are so busy being amazed by that that they're overlooking so many other things that he did an amazing job of here, and I just wanted to highlight that issue. High notes are fun, but I've heard quite a few singers that can hit the kinds of notes that Dimash can, and Dimash is way more interesting than all of them to listen to and it's not because he can go higher. His skills as a singer are phenomenal, not to mention his ability to express himself and convey emotion with his voice, and I just hope that people don't overlook how rare that is because they're too busy focusing on how high he can go. To put in context of the example you used, Eddie Van Halen at one point was hands down the most technically impressive rock guitarist on the planet, but he wasn't popular because he was able to shred his brains out in front of an audience (definitely didn't hurt though, haha.) His skills as an overall complete musician allowed him to write and play interesting and catchy songs, and his reputation as a musician is known largely because of how well he could apply his technical abilities in a musical and tasteful way.

@@Grays_Plays This is much better than the way you came across before. I'm glad you were able to set your previous self straight a but better. It's going to be important moving forward for his fans to allow him to go off where his Muse takes him. I have tickets for the Igor Krutoy concert in Brooklyn where Dimash will make an appearance!

I don't think it was an accident.I think he tried to give a g7 but couldn't somehow and tried to make it up with something higher.

Not many.

@@Grays_Plays That is the wrong answer. You should have written "no one". Because no one has ever done anything like this before. Others used glissando from the sixth octave to easily reach the note but Dimash started singing directly from the eighth octave .

@@shalllll7261 Georgia Brown comes to mind. I've heard a few clear examples of her nailing 8th octave notes (F8 being the most notable,) without sliding into them from lower octaves. There's a handful of others I've heard over the years, but their names elude me cause the rest of their singing was remarkably unimpressive honestly. So like I said, not many.

@@Grays_Plays Yes, I know that, but the eighth octave C8 and F8 are only recorded, not the live version, so I didn't take them into account.

@@shalllll7261 that's fair, I can't imagine how difficult it must be to try to nail those kinds of ranges live in front of a noisy crowd compared to most of the environments I've seen singers attempt those ranges. Couldn't dream of attempting to use 6th octave notes (or above,) in that kind of setting myself, and it's a testament to how smoothed out the rest of Dimashs ranges are that he can manage it as consistently as he does.

Thanks very much for commenting and leaving feedback for me, I appreciate it. I definitely made a point of pausing less during this video, mainly because I was getting more aware of youtube's policies in regards to fair use and copyright in general and was wary of having too many sections of video where it's just me watching the original without any input from me. And petting a cat doesn't tax me mentally to the point that it impairs my hearing, haha. Appreciate the feedback though, and I tend to lock him out of the room when I'm trying to record. He can make some noise when he wants to though and he's ruined plenty of recording sessions of mine, as I'm only in a tiny flat and it's impossible not to pick him up on my mic when he gets pissy, lol. And no I wasn't aware he had throat issues, though some people have mentioned that some of the performances I've reacted to are ones where he was unwell. That would help explain the random high note, as he missed the one he was actually aiming for and that was obviously him trying to compensate. Makes more sense if his voice was not responding as it normally might for him. And I really enjoyed the rest of the song as well, that's mostly why the high note was jarring for me. Was still a great performance though. Cheers again for taking the time to watch my video and for commenting. I really do appreciate it when people do.

It definitely can, my point wasn't that whistle voice is pointless. Dimash is brilliant at implementing it musically, but my main point was that a lot of people focus too much on the extremes of how high he (and other singers like him,) can go. I think it's important speaking as an aspiring singer not to overlook how incredible the rest of his abilities are even without the flashy high notes. Interesting what you say about some singers with being negative about head voice. I've seen similar things in my circle of my musicians and I can't agree with putting something down just because I might not be very good at it.

@@Grays_Plays absolutely... My opinion is basically that , when you criticize something... It's good if you know how to do it first... In my videos(I am a terrible singer at mix range) I hit notes in the 5th octave, and am constantly mocked at by people who can't sing anything above a g4... I always reply to them by asking them to demonstrate how to do it... They usually reply with ad hominem 😂😂😂

@@Worshipsatch Know that feeling mate, and I agree completely on having some insight on what you're criticizing if you want to be taken seriously when doing so. Everyone's an expert when it comes to internet discussions about vocal technique though, and the most incompetent are normally the most confident in what they're talking about on the subject which is a massive shame. When I'm reacting to singers in these videos I try to only comment on stuff that I've attempted myself so that I can speak with at least some basic insight on what I'm talking about, as I've seen way too many people act like experts when really they have absolutely no experience with what they talk about. There's a million vocal coaches out there that claim to have knowledge on the perfect way to sing, and most of them sound terrible and also have no major experience singing outside of a studio. It's absolutely maddening, and I really don't want to contribute to that problem. Obviously I haven't attempted everything I see in a Dimash video (the guy is a freak of nature, haha,) but I have enough experience hitting notes above what the average singer probably can, and I'm also used to doing so on a regular basis live, so even though I'm not an amazing singer by any definition yet I have at least a vague idea of how much work it takes to get to a decent level. Please don't take my comments on Dimash's whistle notes in this video as condemning that range, I'm just well aware of how much time and work he's put into sounding as good as he does in the rest of his range and I don't want people to overlook that because of a one off crazy high note. I feel that those kinds of notes get all the attention and the point of my video was to point out to other singers that Dimash is popular not just because he can hit whistle notes, (there's plenty of singers that can hit those notes if you go looking for them,) but he's popular because he's an amazing singer and sounds incredible even without those notes to lean on to impress people. I'd love to see some of your clips mate, I'm always keen on seeing other singers who are working on their voice. I'll check your channel out.

@@Grays_Plays okay then , you can check out some of my varieties of covers like steelheart's she's gone or soft songs like I'll follow you into the dark... I also am a lead guitarist so I have guitar covers too.... Just to inform you before hand, my tone and vowel modifications are pretty bad but it's hard for me to change that(after 9 years of trying) because I was born with a medium high level tongue tie....

@@Grays_Plays also if you want to see non-singers make fun of my tone and tell me things like speaking Axl Rose's name from my mouth is an insult to Axl 😂 you can check out my cover of Dilnawaaz(Hindi song) but the comments are half in Hindi, you will know what as hominem and internet pseudo expertise I am talking about

ПРАВИЛЬНО НАПИСАЛИ В АДРЕС БЛОГЕРА. ТАК ГОВОРИТ,БУДТО ОДОЛЖЕНИЕ ДЕЛАЕТ.ДИМАШ НЕ ПО ДЕЛУ НЕ ИСПОЛЬЗУЕТ СВИСТКОВЫЙ РЕГИСТР.

Да,вы правы!!!Кто его знает?Может,в узких кругах.А Димаша знает весь мир!!!!Прям брат сестры баян🤣🤣🤣

@@vikatereshenko1442 Не расстраивайтесь...зависть...любование собой...и...ничего.

Мне например ни одна его реакция на Димаша не нравится.

@@nataliukraine я посмотрела ещё 2 и тоже не в восторге.Только себя показывает.Тогда бороду козлиную сбрил бы,что ли????Как то непрезентабельно выглядит для самолюбования😂😂

I don't expect everyone will. Thank you for your feedback.

Most reactors have no experience whatsoever with singing, and I never put down whistle voice at any point to be fair to myself. You can't draw a comparison between the musical and very melodic application of the whistle voice range that Mariah, Ariana, or even Dimash in most of his performances uses to a random 3 octave jump that comes out of nowhere in the middle of an otherwise very sedate song. To me personally it's as weird as doing an acoustic cover of a ballad and then throwing an ACDC rock scream in out of nowhere, it just sounds odd. There's room for debating musical taste here though. To me that kind of extreme range is like a circus trick as there's absolutely room for musical application with whistle voice up to a certain point (in spite of what a lot of singers will say,) and Ariana sounds absolutely fucking incredible when she uses hers from what I've heard, but the higher you go the less and less room there is for musical application as the vowels become so limited that it becomes hard to call it singing. Personally I love high notes, and over the years that I spent trying to improve my own vocal range I spent many hours listening to all kinds of singers that can hit notes in the 8th octaves, but they typically all sounded terrible in the rest of their ranges as it's such a large amount of time and effort to develop that kind of range that everything else tends to suffer for it. Dimash is an oddity in that he can hit those kinds of notes and still sound like an interesting singer when he's not relying on them. His voice is freakishly well developed and balanced, and he's one of very few that have put the time in to acquire that kind of range while still sounding equally as good in his other ranges, so my advice to singers (speaking as a guy who's spent over 10 years chasing range,) is to focus lower down on the notes that you'll spend most of your time using rather than wasting all of your time and energy on things that you won't be able to apply musically in most situations. By all means chase high notes, I'm even working on my whistle voice myself at the moment as I'm enjoying listening to Dimash's whistle register so much and I have to say that it's fun to start being able to develop some power and control in that range to be able to wail on E6's on a daily basis, but don't focus on those kinds of things as the be all and end all with singing because they're not. Those other singers you mentioned, along with Dimash are all incredible singers but it's not their whistle voices that make them amazing. The extreme range they can display is the cherry on the cake, but they've made the cake first and it's obvious.

Gray, you are great in your comments and remarks about singing in the whistle register and not only !! You are divine, as always!

Kiedy już będziesz w stanie uderzyć kilka dźwięków w szóstej oktawie, uczucie zazdrości szybko zniknie, ponieważ nie jest to zbyt imponujące w porównaniu z wieloma innymi rzeczami związanymi z aktem śpiewania.

@@Grays_Plays profesjonalni eksperci muzyczni są innego zdania... Nie na takiego drugiego Dimasha na świecie ,jest po prostu najlepszy🙂nie ma sobie równych...dziękuję.

The music is fine, not what I My biggest gripe with that whistle note is mainly that for amateur or beginner singers watching these videos they'll tend to fixate on the highest notes and lose sight of the bigger picture, that being that crazy high notes won't make you an amazing singer if that's all you can do and they're not worth the time it takes to learn to do them compared to working on your main singing range. That was pretty much it to be honest. I think this clip of Dimash gets overhyped because people fixate on the numbers, and it does him a disservice as he's got a lot more going for him than just being able to hit 8th octave notes. In context of him covering for missing the note he was going for before the D8 it makes sense to me and I've got nothing to dislike about it even though musically it comes out of nowhere. My comments are just what they are because most singers that are inspired to practice by Dimash would probably be better off not wasting hours trying to hit his highest notes, they'd be better off working on all the other things that go into singing first, as those kinds of notes are only useful for impressing people with if the rest of your range is interesting to listen to as well. I've seen a lot of crazy singers over the years that hit those kinds of notes and they've all had their 15 minutes of fame and vanished because they just weren't very good from a musical perspective because they focused so much on the extremes of their range and their actual singing was lackluster. Dimash is different as the rest of his range is as interesting and well developed as his high notes, and that was worth pointing out in my opinion. Cheers for your feedback, and thank you for the dislike. I like honest comments and I enjoyed reading yours very much. Take care.

@@Grays_Plays "As those kinds of notes are only to impress people", This is what you think and I respect your opinion. But, in his case "those notes" are not to impress anyone, because he knows his worth, he doesn't need to prove to someone that he is a great singer! That's it his imprint, and he did that to show to the audience that his talent is for real not like many singers are using auto-tune or are doing phonograph. He is a person who wants to deliver through his voice and music emotions to the people, that's his way of expression and spread love around the world. He is passionate about music and using those high notes in the songs, which are not very oft is something that makes him remarkable and unique. I don't know how much you know about him, but he is singing since he was 5 years old, and his training doesn't mean a few couples of hours per day. It means more than 8 hours of training, he has been a hardworking, devoted to his passion, and he wants to overcome himself, that's why he has been pushing himself so hard. His vocals range is huge and incredible, but not that is what it makes his especial. But, that's his nature, he was brought up in a close-knit musical family, and his grandparents played a major role in his upbringing, which follows traditional Kazakh custom. He can sing any type of music, genre if he wants, and he proved. He is just at the start of his career, one of the reasons that he is not so famous as compared to other artists. PS: Thank you for taking the time and reply to my probably rude comment (but wasn't). Take care of yourself too! Peace.

@@JetLion Cheers for the reply, I appreciate a good discussion when I can get one. I said "those kinds of notes are only useful for impressing people with if the rest of your range is interesting to listen to as well", and the context of what I said is is important because I don't think there's anything wrong with hitting high notes, they're a lot of fun and a great way to get a reaction from an audience (I do it myself a lot at my gigs too, though nowhere near as high as Dimash can go, haha,) but the point I'm making is that if that's all you've got then they won't help cover the rest of your singing if it's lackluster. I've seen a lot of singers get popular on the internet because of their ability to hit crazy high notes and they all came and went in terms of popularity because at the end of the day they just weren't particularly interesting to hear when you weren't hearing them at the extremes of their range, which is incredibly limiting for any artist and it's something to bear in mind. I remember about 10 years ago when Adam Lopez was popular on singing forums because he was hitting crazy whistle notes (his highest was a E#8 according to the info I found back then which is higher than what I've seen Dimash hit kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pslji8pj1JiaeXk.html) but people quickly stopped talking about him because the rest of his singing wasn't as interesting as hearing the range he can display. He was and is a really really good singer, but compared to the extremes of his range the rest of his voice just wasn't as engaging to listen to for most people and he as a result lacked mainstream appeal compared to someone like Dimash who is exceptionally skilled in every range and knows how to use them all musically to their best effect as well. The point I'm making in this video and these comments is it's really cool to see a singer with the kind of range that Dimash has be able to apply it in a musical way, but I think that a lot of his viewers are under appreciating how immensely skilled he is because they're focusing too much on the highest notes he can hit. There's nothing wrong with that, but having seen many singers who were popular because of their ability to hit similar notes I think it does Dimash a disservice to assume that his popularity is down to the theatrical stuff he can do with his voice, as many have already displayed similar abilities things in that area and they have not enjoyed the popularity that Dimash has. I agree in particular with your comment that "in his case those notes are not to impress anyone, because he knows his worth, he doesn't need to prove to someone that he is a great singer!" Dimash seems to carry himself in a way where he knows he doesn't need to lean on his highest notes all the time to impress and it's refreshing to hear, as that confidence really comes across in a way that elevates everything he's doing in my opinion. Every part of what he's doing stands out well and nothing comes across as desperate or overly showy and I'm learning a lot as a singer by watching that and I'm sure I'll continue to do so. Thanks for commenting again mate, and no I didn't find your first comment rude. It was honest and I always enjoy passionate honest comments on my channel. Have a nice day.

@@Grays_Plays Well, that's what I call a reaction. I'm pretty sure that many out there think about Dimash that he is popular just because of his high notes. Also, about E8, he already did in one of his songs. Actually, the level of his range that he can reach is can't even be found in a piano as far I saw. If I recall it right a few years ago when nobody knew about him, he performed to a show in his country and the jury there they criticize him so hard that, to be honest, if I were in his place I was giving up on singing. But he didn't and after years in 2017 when he got famous thanks to China, his own country started to be proud of him. So imagine how he must be feeling that time. I will not expect that everyone will love his songs, but for me he will always going to be, my number one. I wasn't even into opera or classical style, but I am modern and open-minded, and I do appreciate quality music, but each of us got a different taste. Once again, I'm thankful to you for your time taken by your reply. I enjoyed talking to you. Have a nice day too.