Lisa every time!

No disrespect to anyone, they’re all very good in their own right. I didn’t know Sara Dash was one of them, but this is all really just a tribute to Merry Clayton. It’s as much her song as it is TRS. She elevated this song with her studio version, I don’t think it would be where it stands today without her. Then of course there is Lisa Fischer, who is a Goddess, blessed with just about everything from those vocal pipes to gorgeous physical attributes. Perhaps she, the only one IMO, could have walked in that studio back in 68 and have t it out of the park like Merry did.

To me Lisa Fischer the best, I like a lot of her.

Ms. Lisa Fischer for me, hands down!!! Thanks for posting this compilation of a truly classic RS song! Miss Charlie, RIP sir. Thank you for keeping that beat all these many years ~ 👣

Lisa Fischer - The best

Interesting compilation. Thanks. Merry, first because she was first and nailed the audio in a couple of takes with no rehearsal (so legend has it anyway). Lisa, for making it her own and owning it with excellence for all those many years before saying goodbye to touring and hello to doing her own thing. Chanel's version has captured me. She has a real presence on stage, enhancing the music and the lyrics not only with her voice but facial expressions and gesture.

Lisa just owns it

Thank you for putting this together. What power!

I watched that HBO documentary “20 Feet from Stardom” that features Lisa Fischer and it unlocked a memory of when I saw the stones in the late 80’s. Her performance wasn’t just great - it seemed superhuman. All anyone could talk about after the show was her, but of course we didn’t know her name because you couldn’t just look it up like you can today. What a privilege to go on KZfaq and relive that moment at least a little bit.

Merry Clayton’s original version with the incredible vocals is definitive, Lisa Fischer has an outstanding voice and tremendous stage presence. Great video and compilation to compare and contrast. Thank you.

Lisa is No 1 forever!! The best of all!🎉🎉

Lisa, the one and only:-)

LISA 🔥🔥🔥🙏

the best performance

.....i enjoyed them ALL....however...i have to say that MERRY....is the ONE....that opened the door for all of them...SHE is the ARCHITECT...then LISA....walked in....and SHE DOES WHAT SHE WANTS TO DO....as the PLANET APPLAUDS....

Great compilation! The Chanel version from 2022 in Milan is insane. That blew me away!

Merry clayton was on another level...then as a stones fans i think is good to have back singers in studio but not alive...the stones i love have few people on stage, bobby, jim, nicky, or billy or stu or mac...but no othher singers than mick, and back vocals by keith and ronnie

Lisa without a doubt

MERRY CLAYTON….THE BEST!

Nicht zu ersetzen..... Was ganz besonderes..... Habe über 30mal erlebt.... Die Nachfolger nicht schlecht.... Aber Lisa für mich unerreicht... The best....... ROCK ON

Wow lady gaga esa presentación fue sensacional

It’s Jenny Douglas all the way for me. I think she and Mick had the best chemistry of all!

Mary Clayton !!!!!!

Saw Lisa doing that part so often and she was breathtaking every time. Chanelle is also superb. Sascha is not my favourite. Fergie wasn't also very good.

Chanel will go out with the Stones in 2024 🎉

Thanks for posting!!!

It’s interesting seeing the young boys on the guitars over the years and also thinking of Charlie and seeing his style of Drumming but you have to give it to Mick and Keith to come up wth a great array of song writing. Unbelievable 🙊🙈🙉🔥🇦🇺☮️💟

Beautiful one

AT "1:58 " MS LISA BLASTED OFF< TOOK MICK ALONG FOR THE MOMENT< KEITH & RONNIE REMAINING ON EARTH< W/CHARLIE & BAND !!

KEITH HOLDS HIS OWN COVERING FOR ILL MICK< THEN HE " WAILS AROUND 21:00!!!

Lisa Fischer!

Lisa la classe…….❤

I got to see Lisa Robinson back in '99

Merry!!!

Merry Clayton's intense vocal was integral to the tremendous power of the original recording, but I remember seeing footage of her performing live, and feeling that she did not project herself as strongly as her voice alone would suggest. I wondered if this might have kept her from achieving the success she clearly wanted and felt she deserved? Lisa Fischer has an explosive stage presence that can go toe to toe with Mick. Although he is rightly recognised as one of the best frontmen in the history of rock'n'roll, it's the whole package that won him his reputation rather than the quality of his voice _per se_. He's not Celine Dion, but that's not the point. Lisa Fischer deivers the goods vocally, and in a way that complements Jagger very effectively, but whether she could or would want to keep it up for 2 or 3 hours a show over the course of 50 years is another matter. Singing like a goddess is one thing, but being Mick Jagger is a lot of work. This song on its own is a tough assignment for any singer, and Merry Clayton casts a long, almost regal shadow. The expectation of audiences, together with the urgency of the message makes it easy to oversing, as some of the ladies heard here demonstrate I think. Mick did not set so high a bar for himself. It's not as if he phones it in, but the part of Mick Jagger that is a bit of an insufferable prick serves him well on stage, and it suits the songs that he and Keith Richards have written over their many tears as writing partners. There's a kind of FU nonchalence to his strutting coq, shameless and horny, like the eponymous little red rooster he sings about in one of their signature songs. It wouldn't be right if he sounded like he'd had singing lessons.

One Gimme Shelter singer they are missing who would have blown them all away with the exception of Clayton and Fischer is Patty Labelle.

I love Lisa Fischer’s singing in this version but what concert is it from and year??? 🙀☮️💟🇦🇺

This is mot my favorit song 😮very screaming and all women are jelling so much😢❤and Mick are alwsys so intressted off all women he sing with❤❤❤Speciell Lisa Fisher and Sasha and other one to think they have some relationnship together after the show❤❤❤😢no not my song to heavy to listen to they made other song Who is much better i think..😮😮😊

Lisa Fischer# 1, Merry Clayton close 2nd, others all good but lady gaga refund my money.

Hi I was hoping you could please the Grace Potter version of Gimme Shelter. Greatly appreciate it

All are great but Lisa is the greatest in my opinion. On a side note, Lady Gaga was awesome with her stage persona as usual.

Lisa fischer best for me but would love to see Fergie from the black eyed peas have a go at this.

And Fergie with Mick on U2's performance of Gimme Shelter

MY STONE FAVS+ STREET FIGHTIN MAN< GIMME SHELTER(WITH MERRY CLAYTON< & WITH MICK TAYLOR AT MADISON SQUARE GARDEN(I WAS AT BOTH MSG GIGS(MY EX 2ND BEST FRIEND(STEVE KITCHEN CONVINCED TO CATCH BOTH> UNHERALDED SHOWS< ONLY EQUALED BY THE WHO< CSN< JEFFERSON AIRPLANE & SADLY< MY MUSICAL IDOL> JIM MORRISON AND THE DOORS(CAUGHT " 4" SHOWS_ NOTE " "@ @ DOORS CONCERT HAD A RIOTOUS ENDING> AT THE WORLDS FAIR SHOW< THE WHO OPENED< CLOSED WITH DESTRUCTION OF EQUIPMENT< JIM ARRIVED 1/2 HOUR LATE< W/DOORS WAITING ON STAGE< ONLY TO SAUNTER TO STAGE EDGE & GET A SMOKE FROM SOMEONE> THE NIGHT WAS CHARGED W/THE FORCE OF A LIGHTNING STORM STRIKING TIME AND AGAIN>

Fergie with Mick and U2 was excellent.

Where is Fergie?! Was goooood ...

Lisa Fischer will always be first because she played with it more. Chanel is second and she only had a day to learn the song. She also channeled Tina Turner. And then who cares about the rest

Sorry guys its saha for me

(IMOHO): GRACE SLICK & PATTI LABELLE WOULD SURELY " KILL" THIS & ANY OTHER SONG>>CATCH GRACE< MARTY BALIN ON " WOODEN SHIPS" LIVE AT ORIGINAL " WOODSTOCK CONCERT"< ALSO " TODAY" AT " MONTEREY POP"< PATTI LABELLE W/MICHEAL MCDONAL LIVE: "ON MY OWN"< + LATE LAURA NYRO & LATE TEENA MARIE< & TAYLOR DAYNE< ON CANT GET ENOUGH " VIDEO & LIVE>

You missed also Fergie kzfaq.info/get/bejne/iNSUkquftprdaIE.html

Σεβασμός σε όλες αλλά η Lisa Fischer είναι η καλύτερη.

Both are amazing anyway they are black people so music and talent is their nature