same here. i love her.

I love rose it's just tht people who do think rose was the doctors only companion

I don't hate Rose, but she got kind of annoying in Series 2 IMHO, and I do feel she's rather overrated. She definitely doesn't make my top 5 ( 1. Donna, 2. Leela, 3. The Brigadier- yes he counts- 4. Ace and 5. Tie between Romana and Clara, mainly as the different versions of these two make them difficult to judge). Then again neither does the legendary Sarah Jane, so maybe it's just an indication of how many great characters there are in Doctor Who. 😃

I don't hate Rose, but she is one of my least favourite companions. I liked her in season 1 but in season 2 it honestly felt like a teenage love story to me, it just annoyed me, she seemed so immature there at times (especially in the werewolf episode if I'd have been the queen I'd have banished them too). I know there's lots of people who enoyed it but I just didn't *shrugs* I loved Martha because of her intelligence, and Donna because she takes no shit and Jack because.... too many reasons. But Rose especially with 10 just didn't work for me

I think fans were split about what Rose became. In Series 1 she and the Ninth Doctor went around like best buds flying around the universe and having a Fantastic time serving her role as the companion just as anybody would've in the classic series. In Series 2 whatever romantic undertones RTD might have hidden in the Eccleston Era became full blown overtones in Tennant's Era (particularly during Tooth and Claw and The Impossible Planet) leading to long time fans disliking the idea of The Doctor having a love interest (Yet surprised at the fact that he has a Granddaughter in Susan and by extension a Wife and Child) To most people the one common rule established (and humorously quoted by John Nathan Turner back in the 80s is) "No hanky panky in the TARDIS" which is why most people grew up with the conception that The Doctor should have no romantic ties to anybody, especially not a human who he will outlive for eons after she dies. And Rose being the companion that RTD Chose to romanticise The Doctor lead to a massive split between the fans who came in 2005 vs Fans who've been watching since the 60s, 70s and 80s. Discounting whatever meaningless life she lead before she met The Doctor, I tend to disagree with the notion that Rose was as selfish as many claim considering that Rose could've been easily substituted for anybody else on Earth and I think most people would act as she did in those circumstances regardless of connections (A Boyfriend in 'Rickey' Her mother Jackie, wasting her life eating chips, watching telly and going to bed) And lets be honest here if you saw The Doctor turn up, all smiles and leather jackets, offering you a chance to travel through space and time I sincerely doubt you would easily pass that up if you could suddenly be lifted out of your shiftless, boring life. What I think some older fans also had trouble getting to terms with was how RTD's soap opera influence meant that The Doctor wouldn't move on as easily from companions as he did in the Classic Series. To use an apt comparison, Adric. He died in Earthshock and immediately after in Time Flight he went with the mentality of. "Adric's dead? Oh dear... Ah well, must dash!" Whereas Ten brooded (for understandable reasons considering that he was still healing from the Time War) and to have that which comforted him ripped away would clearly leave some mental scars leading to Martha's unfortunate situation of being "The Rebound" But despite Ten's mistreatment of Martha it was because of that which he learned to no longer contrast everyone he came across to Rose and as such became accepting of Donna and eventually did recognise Martha in her own right rather than look at her as "Not Rose" By the time of Series 4 with the constant hints of Rose returning I think this was where their hatred came to boiling point because of how it showcased that Tennant's era was entirely defined by Rose rather than Classic Who's tendency to move on once a Companion either died or said "Fuck this I'm leaving" And once the whole romantic sub-plot was dealt with by leaving her on Pete's world with the Meta-Crisis Doctor I think fans were sick to death of her hogging so much attention. For me Rose is far from the worst companion I've ever seen (That honor goes to Turlough) and while not exactly my favourite (Tegan Jovanka gets that honor) Rose is still pretty cool as far as being THE companion that managed to kick the show back in gear in 2005.

I want to edit that in now.

@@EuroMIX2 SAME

I hate rose in my head cannon shes dead

@@mattjones6578 I bet in your head cannon Matt Jones is also dead

@@mattjones6578 your head cannon is shite

@@mattjones6578 Your head canon is shit

@@mattjones6578 You have a shitty head cannon then.

I can't remember. Was it because of Rose??

@@tatianapadervinskaite2982 it was because Donna was meant to stop him, the reason he needed stopping was because he had just lost rose and didn't want to continue saving a thankless universe, Donna showed him there was something to live for

@@mickys8065 ohhhh that makes perfect sense, thank you

@@mickys8065 now I love Ten even more :-'(

I always interpreted the scene differently, losing Rose may have had a huge impact on the Doctor, but I don't believe he would have gone suicidal because of it, he has lost a lot of companions in the past. I always believed the reason he never made it out in time was because he hated himself, more specifically he hated what he has just done, essentially killing a bunch of innocent children who were not responsible for the racnoss queen's actions, essentially in that one scene he commits genocide against a species and this causes him to have a severe PTSD episode about when he killed the Time Lords and the Daleks. Donna was the one to bring him back to reality just in time to escape.

Bisqwit she was hardly put on the bus as she can’t return without her head burning up and her dying. Being put on the bus implies they can return quite easily with no consequence. Donna cannot

It’s sci-fi. There are _always_ methods. Genetic alteration, upload consciousness to a computer, savant brain tumor, parallel timelines, or even just simply telepathy. Fantasy writing has liberties like that. You can literally make things up to justify whatever you want to happen.

Bisqwit So i guess nothing matters then. I get what you mean, i fucking cried when donna went. But think how annoying it'd get if everything could be solved just like that.

@@Bisqwit and do you think she would want any of these alternatives? change dna or becomes a computer, wtf? Of course, fantasy can take you anywhere, but it also needs to stay intertwined with the surrounding universe. facts: the problem: her head can't stand the mind of a time lord. (which can look to the future and the past at the same time, even though it is never explained how it works) solution ?: Of all these she wouldn't want, the most likely is that Gallifrey has some kind of technology to reverse the process, but guess what? The whole planet is BURNING. understood?

Would she want it? To keep all the knowledge of her adventures with The Doctor _and_ to possess his smarts? All for the cost of having to wear a cellphone-sized gadget on her waist for the rest of her life and maybe a little implant in her brain, storing the excess of her intellectual and allowing for wireless communication between the two? Absolutely she would. As for Gallifrey, guess who’s got the flagship piece of Gallifrey technology _and_ all of their knowledge in the size of a telephone box, and much of their technological education in their mind as well, as evidenced by the 13th Doctor’s ability to manufacture sonic devices + a time-spatial teleporter in an earthen garage.

Every time I get sad about that, I think about the Ood, and that makes it just a little bit better. After all, she did make a huge difference, even though she doesn't remember.

"There are worlds out there, safe in the sky because of her. There are people living in the light, and singing songs of Donna Noble."

veeganboy This always gives me shivers. One of my favourite lines! :)

They really are, my favourites too but along with Martha that's my top 3

Gamelover254 *and Martha

I like Martha, but something just seemed off about her. She never felt real to me. I think it has something to do with the actress but when she was in trouble I never really believed it.

Gamelover254 martha jones was the most realistic one she was a medical student, she had a dysfunctional family and had to over raceism. Intelligent and actually useful she saved the doctor and the world on multiple occasions.

Gamelover254 donnas my 2nd or 3rd and rose is my last out of all the companions I’ve seen I liked her in these episodes and season 1 but season 2 I wanted to throw her of a cliff

It can always be worse.....

Oh its gonna get soooooo much worse, buckle up

One day we will look back at Corona and say:"Yeah, what a weird decade that was!"

US Marine on Normandy beach: trust me it could be worse.

The proper term is "Time Lady" Or atleast, I think.

Francesco Salvia Probably. I call her the lady time lord because that's a rough translation of Donna Temple-Noble, lady time-lord

IT WAS FORTOLD, Donna is lady in a different language, temple came from the word tempus which is time, and noble another term for lord :D

+Will Stewart Rose did do that but Martha walked across the world, very independent and saved the world with love and faith.

Will Stewart It's alright, I'm just watching different videos and looking at some comments. I've kinda became obsessed with DW again especially 10's era which is my favourite. I loved the comedy Donna brought too, she was funny, sassy and a loving caring person underneath. Martha was serious at times, she was sassy and caring also. Martha didn't have an easy time with The Doctor, the way he treated her etc. Martha did prove that she was a great companion in the end all the things she did for The Doctor. I love 10's companions, Rose, Martha and Donna for different reasons, sometimes I favour one more but regardless of that, they all were good companions for different reasons, I'm also glad they all got along when they met, no rivalry at all. :)

Same here, I miss Martha too.

This all makes me feel nostalgic, all these videos. :(

Yeah ikr! Been watching them as a de-stress from exams but it just makes me either really sad or really happy

+GG Dragneel Me too it just brings it all back for me how much I loved 10, Rose, Martha & Donna it makes me feel a mixture of happy & sad emotions the ending of his era is bittersweet but I will always go back to it at some point each year they were a part of my childhood too honestly hope one day I can meet them all in person & thank them for the impact they've had on my life & get a photo with them too that would definitely be something I would treasure, apologies for going on a bit lol, hope everything has been okay with your exams! :)

Awwwww same! Gosh, how much I'd love to meet them! Ahhhh don't worry, I do it all the time and tbh, I love reading other people's opinions, especially when they are so passionate about it! I totally agree with you :D Thank you so much! I hope you are having a wonderful week

Yes but she never says he's good looking

@@seandabest6353 don't you mean, single headedly?

Master of Gwent I literally have no idea how that interacts with my statement.

Sean Da Best sorry...meant to reply to the original “single handedly” comment

Sontarans don't have sex.

So do I. The 70s were the best ;)

PompeiiProductions Shat it

***** Um... what?

+blackham7 David Tennet was the best he will always be my doctor

Erm ok?

MUCH different after Moffat left.

Bootiful

I Am The Doctor -RUN- leave out "love you"

Roses are red, The T.A.R.D.I.S. is blue, The Doctor one said "Rose Tyler-" But he couldn't say "I love you"

CRYIN'

and then he married another girl, the end

Kelly Carberry He absolutely loved River

It sure is

Yeah it adds to feeling of hopelessness when it hits you there’s no one left

*starts singing ABBA, Thank you for the music*

That would be brilliant. We could see their reactions to all the atrocities that happened in this episode. We could get some funny quips from Jack about how the Sontarans look like potatoes. We could get a heartfelt scene between Gwen and Ianto saying goodbye to each other before they sacrifice themselves. And finally, Captain Jack transports himself to the Sontaran homeworld to avenge his friends.

Josh Nesbitt Its still good

Josh Nesbitt this was such a beautiful and real scene, a great character moment. I love Donnas ‘I’m so tired’ line because this version has just faced hell after hell and you can see on her face she’s just absolutely exhausted with life, brilliant dialogue and brilliant acting. Such real characters. Nothing in moffats doctor who has come close to this scene it’s embarrassing, he’s too obsessed with sticking as many one liners in his episodes as possible and solving episodes with nonsensical timely wimey ‘everybody comes back to life’ endings.

shafi islam it was up to Series 10. Series 11 was an abomination imo.

I hope the next cast and writers are good

I agree its lost its edge 😡

OMG OH YEAH GOOD EAR

Thankfully in the restored timeline all in Torchwood . . . oh, nevermind. :P