Bahubali was pouring Turmeric powder on the elephant, Turmeric is very sacred and used for religious purposes all over India and Hindus across the world.

‘Curry powder’ is a total white invention and we don’t use it in India. We use garam masala (a blend of spices) or combine multiple spices our own self which cooking a dish. He is throwing turmeric powder if I’m not wrong… turmeric has cooling properties too and most probably helped cooling/relaxing the elephant on a hot day.

In part 1, during flashback both baahubali and ballaladeva went to a place to find out the murderer. In that scene the bar tender is the director of the film, ss rajamouli.

The woman sitting with you pronounces the Indian names very well one of the few foreigners who's this good at it!

Nice discussion! One thing though. It is very common in Indian movies for one actor/actress to play multiple roles. This actually reduces the movie-making cost and also shows the skills of being an actor/actress.

❤️ love you guys. Rajamauli made babhubali just to see if he can make a big epic or not. Because he wants to make 5 or 6 part movie of the indian epic Mahabharat. Yes indian culture has those palaces and structures and civilization. Indian civilization is the longest and oldest surviving and continuous civilization. India was the richest civilization of the world. These last 3 century were an aberration in indian history. Because of colonizers British plundered india to abject poverty. When British came to india in 1700's. India had 25% of the world gdp. And when they left in 1947 it was just 4% of world Gdp. By that time more than 90% population was under poverty line. From being the richest country to the poorest in just 100-150 years. India was so rich that around 11th 12th century it had around 35% of world Gdp and was the center of scientistific and astrologic innovation then of course the volley of Muslim invaders started and decline of india started. they started with the destruction of indian education centers. Taxila( the worlds first university ) 5- 6 BCE Nalanda university was destroyed around 1250 or something by bhaktiyar kilji i think. It is said that the university library was so big that it burned for months. Students from every corner of the world came to study here.Mughal invaders destroyed every single big university and education center of india. India was under Mughal rule when British reached its shore. Every invaders tried to Fun fact Colombo reached America because he was also trying to reach india.

The “love goddess” he was chasing was a premonition of Avantika.. whose face he saw in the mask that fell off the waterfall. his desire to find her led him up the mountain to his destiny.

"just send us a reference of what we just said"

RRR is an exception.....superb just superb film but Bahubali is an emotion....never forgot those days of Bahubali 🙏🙏🙏

I feel that comparing Bahubali and rrr is not fair cause Bahubali had so much time to make you care about the characters. The characters are more fleshed out in Bahubali when compared to rrr. When comes to budget of Indian movies actors take the biggest cut of the budget they rarely rely on vfx most of the stunts they perform are real people.

My initial thoughts are Kelly is just here as a eye candy , however after Watching older videos I can say , she knows what she is talking about ..

Movie chatter Podcast here is the list of Indian movies i will suggest u to watch and that will give u a Ridiculous, amazing, spectacular movie experience. 1-Bahubali Part 1 & 2 2-RRR 3-KGF Part 1 & 2 4-Enthiran & 2.0 5-Tumbbad 6-Dangal 7-Eaga 8-Pushpa 9-Vikram 10-Drishyam 1 & 2

RRR obviously better. Everything is perfect in RRR. Bahubali the 1st's backstory is the only amazing thing in it. RRR is a standalone film. Bahubali can't be compared with RRR which has 2 film and more duration. Everything RRR shown in one film is impossible for any film in the world. And they ended it perfectly.

RRR has references from Ramayan. And Baahubali has references from Mahabharat. Just FYI. You cannot imagine the goosebumps that we get while watching these movies. The tears don't stop. The joy never subsides.

Bahubali demonstrates the power of empathy & the importance of it in a leader. Bahubali had empathy for people, whereas Bhallaladeva lacked empathy. He was a Narcissist who only cared about self glorification & power over others. This is the core of every Hero vs Villain story.. Empath vs Narcissist.

Prabhas from Bahubali is 6 feet tall I think. The actors in RRR were a lot shorter but it doesn’t show on film , like your Tom Cruise comparison

Bahubali is a hindi word which means... A person having strong arms

Not sure if others already recommended these movies but you should try Eega/The Fly (Makki in Hindi) and Maryada Ramanna, both made by the same director SS Rajamouli. Trust me you will enjoy both.

It’s really a challenging thing to decide which movie is better because they both have their advantages and disadvantages over each other. 1. The budget of RRR is lot more than the budget of both Bahubali 1&2 COMBINED. So that’s an advantage to RRR 2. RRR movie has a lot of content that was told in just one movie. So it’s going to be very sharp and focused. So it’s an advantage for RRR again. 3. On the other hand Bahubali was made in two parts so it has lot of scope for lot more in-depth back stories and the characters being more flushed out etc. so that’s one advantage for Bahubali. But it also means there was also some unnecessary padding to the movie that doesn’t necessarily need for the over all story. So having 2 movies has an advantage and disadvantage. 4. Also Bahubali is set in Ancient India, so the makers have lot of scope to go crazy with the locations, set pieces, costumes etc etc. even penny spent can be seen on screen so Bahubali looks rich despite being spent significantly lot less money than RRR. Anyway, I LOVED Bahubali until I watched RRR. I thought RRR was my new favorite and a lot better movie than Bahubali UNTIL I watched Bahubali again and I was like “no way, RRR is better than Bahubali”. I guess the point is they both are great in their own way and it’s not really a fair comparison between the two.

"SARDAR UDHAM" NEXT!!!!

Hey guys, I am from Tampa.. Love your podcast... Btw Movie Chatter Elephants.. Yep Still watching. Keep making more content on Tollywood films. Subbed.

If you think India only make over the top movies then you should watch sardar uddam ,the Kashmir files For me sardar uddam is the best movie of the year

Awesome podcast, enjoyed it all 🙂👍🏻

It's turmeric powder...... To calm the aggressiveness on the elephant ..... Turmeric powder calms the aggression when poured on head..

He was pouring turmeric powder…which ,yes, is used in curries 😂

I'm from India (Hyderabad) ss rajamouili is a tollywood director who is known for Indian epic RRR director. has no flaps or failures till the RRR movie. Right from his first movie. 1. Student no.1 (2001) Hero. Jr NTR Budget_3cr Box-office collection_12cr 2.Simhadri (2003) Hero. Jr NTR Budget _8cr Box-office collection_26cr 3.Sye (2004) Hero. Nithin Budget _5cr Box-office collection_9.5cr 4. Chatrapati (2005) Hero. Prabhas Budget _10cr Box-office collection _21cr 5. Vikramarkudu (2006) Hero. Ravi Teja Budget _11cr Box-office collection _19.5cr 6. Yamadonga (2007) Hero. Jr NTR Budget _18cr Box-office collection _28.7cr 7. Magadeera (2009) Hero. Ram Charan Budget _44cr Box-office collection _150cr 8. Maryada rammanna (2010) Hero. Sunil Budget _14cr Box-office collection _29cr 9. Eaga (2012) Hero. Nani Budget _26cr Box-office collection _43cr 10. Bahubali the beginning (2015) Hero. Prabhas Budget _136cr Box-office collection _600cr 11. Bahubali the conclusion (2017) Hero. Prabhas Budget _250cr Box-office collection _1917cr 12. RRR (2022) Hero. Jr NTR & Ram Charan Budget _550cr Box-office collection _ more than 1150cr

You guys were confused about Bahubali because of the irregular timeline (or whatever you call it), imagine how I (as a non-English speaker) would feel watching Pulp Fiction as a kid. I was so lost but still very entertained. (Don’t ask me what am I doing watching a Tarintino movie as a kid. It is what it is.. lol 😆)

I love this podcast 💯 And the topic of discussion

Babhali is always better than rrr in every aspect ,but with the experience of Bahubhali rajamouli made rrr action sequences more smooth We don't need anyone to say BB is great

Hey guys, Mary and I were wondering how we can get an autographed sticker by Kelly because we were avidly watching when you waved it at the camera! Great show as always--cheers!

Watch SS RAJAMOULI's another Film Eega it will blow your mind because it's a revenge story of a fly but don't judge the VFX of Indian movies because Indian movies have limited market so budget are low

The festival where we throw colours at each other is called Holi and it is one of my favorite festivals ever!

Watch TANHAJI Movie It is base on true history of 16 th century India

Sardar udham it's on Amazon.

Do we send them the cinematic ‘Incredible India’ video to showcase our forts?

Well you Guyz are little confused.. Bahubali senior (Amarendra Bahubali)'s father was the king.. And that man with crippled hand is his brother.. But after death of the king and queen Bahubali senior is adopted by Sivagami (queen mother) who is also the wife of the man with crippled hand.. So the main antagonist (Bhallal Deva) is Bahubali senior's cousin and queen mother and that cripple hand man's son.

Great review!

Amarendra Bahubali's(father) parents died and his aunt(queen mother) adopts him.

Relationships in Baahubali: Sr. Baahubali's father and the crippled hand guy are brothers. Sr. Baahubali's father and mother are died at his birth, so his Aunt (Queen Mother) raised him. Crippled hand guy is Queen Mother's husband. So Baahubali is not her own son, Bhallaladeva is her own son. Baahubali is much more emotional and has very strong female characters and multiple layers of characters and character arc. RRR is more linear and simple. If you understand fully, Baahubali very rich in content and better.

Prepare yourself for ADIPURUSH Movie

Shiva - the first Yogi who taught Yoga. He was born Rudra - the screaming howling raging one who found ways to find peace. During "Samudra Manthan" - churning of ocean - a project undertaken by gods and demons together - many wonderful things came out. But at the same time this deadly poison came out too - which was fuming and threatening the whole world - and Shiva was the one who decided to take it and stop it in his throat by his yogic control. His throat turned blue and he felt burning in his body. That's why his devotees always pour water or milk on his linga (symbol) to soothe him. Shivling - symbol of Shiva - is cylindrical because of the shape of his yogic energy I am not well aware of. Some people say it's phallus but that's not right. In Sanskrit there is a word called Jyotirling which means symbol of Spiritual Light.

Bahubali is not a family name.. it’s a title.. an honorary descriptive.. meaning the strong one.. literally strong arms.

Well Baahubali is made in telugu and tamil and dubbed into hindi and other languages...

Movie suggestions 1)Vikram(2022) 2)Thani oruvan 3)Enthiran Robot 4)2.O(part 2 of enthiran robot) 5)Indian 6)Master 7)kaithi(prequel to Vikram 2022)

Yes women are shown powerful in Indian Movies and mom are very powerful figure

You should react to eega movie where a rebirth man becomes Mosquito and revenge on his murderers.

watch geography of india video to understand how diverse india's culture is

Well actually yes bahubali is getting a series which either will be directed by SS Rajamouli Or his son karthikey for which Netflix gave them 100 crs or 13 million which is a lot in Indian rupees for a show! And the title will be called Bahubali: before the beginning which would be a prequel to bahubali universe!

Not completely sure if India has the earliest civilisation but it is the only civilisation that still exists. And talking about History. India have the largest history in terms of important events and it might have been the most advanced civilisation.

It seems now they have found totally different world while watching Indian movie

The smile you guys are taking about is the reason that now bahubali actor Prabhas is cast in movie Adipurush to play Lord Ram. The movie is based on epic Ramayana.

Curry Powder: Prepared from variety of spices (orange to brown color) Curry Leaf Powder: Prepared from Curry Leaf (Murraya koenigii) Green leaves. Looks like Bay leaves.Citrus family. Turmeric Powder: From Roots - yellow color(Indians & most South East Asian countries use in all their Curry dishes) Sandalwood (GANDHAM) powder/Oil: From Trunk of the trees-For Medical & Fragrance related products (Yellow+Orange color). Hindus worship God with this sacred Powder.

Please watch 🙏 3 idiots (one of the best Indian movie ever made)

This RRR is a TELUGU Movie from TOLLYWOOD and not from Bollywood

Its great to see your discussion from start to end. Its really amazing that you people are loving indian movies and indian culture especially you people are doing your research after watching these movies.Also slowly and slowly you started pronouncing most of the words correctly. Ms marvel movie plot is a very sensitive subject to indians and the partition they have shown in the movie is a black day in the indian history that is why Ms marvel is not very much popular in india. Indians love watching American movies/series but a web series directed by pakistan origin director have shown many things which were very much opposite what actually happened. Since you are watching indian movies and you are smiling and loving you can plan to watch some of the below movies . 1. URI 2. Padmavat 3. Bajirao Mastani 4.TanhaJi

BAAHUBALI 3, I Don't Think That's Happening, It's More Clickbait Than Anything. NETFLIX Was Producing A Series On Life Before Baahubali, But They've Cancelled That Series, It's Not Happening. Rajamouli Has Already Announced His Next Project.

Do watch Tumbbad . It's made in 6 years. Totally mind-blowing.

*In India we have 12-16 weeks of Summer. Also its about 45-50 degree celcius.* :)

PRABHAS is the biggest Star of India right now. He is the highest paid Actor in Whole India. Charges 150 Crore Indian Rupees per film and a share is profits. He is playing God Ram in his next film Adipurush.

Sad news. Bahubali 3 is not officially confirmed.

Ms Marvel is not popular in India so much.., BTW there is no Part 3 for Baahubali planned. Its fake news.

Trust me I watch the whole podcast

If you liked RRR and Bahubali then you should definitely check out 1)Pushpa 1 the rise 2)KGF Chapter 1 and 2 3)Makkhi 4)Magadheera 5)Sahoo 7)Amarichit 8) Maari 1 and 2 9)Vikram Veda These are few ya'll need to check out

You can get to see the bahubali shooting sets in the worlds biggest film city - Ramoji film city.

*After watching Tumbadd I had no idea that the kid's role and old ghost lady's role was done by the same actor who is a kid.*

SS Rajamouli's ultimate goal is to make Mahabharata which is similar to Marvel universe. Mahabharata is Clash of the Cousins! And they're demigods. Bheem is the son of Wind God, posses strength like Heracles. Arjun is the son of Thunder God Indra. He's the king of all gods, he's the ruler of heaven. Krishna is the most iconic and charismatic being in this war.

its not fountain guys it is lord shiva

Amarinder Bahubali (the father) and Mahendra Bahubali (the son) are lookalikes played by the same actor (Prabhas). Amarinder Bahubali and BalalaDev are cousins. The father of Bahubali Sr. and the father of BalalaDev are brothers. The mother of BalalaDeva adopted Bahubali Sr.

marvel fans love ms marvel in india .

Let's talk powders: RRR: The powder used (green) was a concoction extracted from a special kind of thistle that has sedative properties to subdue the tiger (and other wild animals) Bahubali 1&2: Avanthika uses the same plant directly to sedate bahubali to proceed with her mission. a)The red powder that was placed under the giant gold statue... b) the mound of red powder from which Kattapa draws out Bahubali senior's sword... C) powder used by the mother during coronation scene (both times)... ...is called Kunkum/Kunkumam (Vermillion powder). It is very auspicious powder used in Hindu rituals celebrations and also worn on the forehead as a tilak by men and women alike. The yellow powder thrown on the elephant is turmeric. It's an equally auspicious powder in rituals, medicine, cooking and day to day life of Indians. It has cooling properties and its anti bacterial, anti inflammatory, promotes gut health and also used on open wounds to speed the healing process. P.s. If your curry powder looks as pale and yellow as that, then PLEASE ask an Indian friend who is a cook to get you the right spices and make a proper curated blend for you OR youtube it. 'Curry powder' is a British invention from their colonial nostalgia that lacks serious amount of spice and flavour (to cater to british palete). Much like their chicken tikka masala (again not a thing in india)

Bahubali 1&2 - pan indian blockbuster RRR - Pan Global Mega Blockbuster

Watch "Endiran"

Kindly look through the kailasa temple ajanta and elephanta architecture to understand ancient India.these are highest epitome at that time and age

Bahubali birth father and Bijala Deva (Balala Deva's Father) are brothers. As per tradition, the eldest brother (Bijala Deva) supposed to be King. Bijala Deva was over looked and Bahubali's father is made the King. Bahubali's father is died (before the story started, may be could be a good prequel) and Sivagami (Bijala Deva's wife & Balala's mother) is made Queen for Mahismathi. Bahubali's mother died during the child birth and Sivagami adopts Bahubali and raises along with her son. Bijala Deva hates Bahubali (never accepts as the son) because he might become King by denying his own birth son. All these things are mentioned through direct & indirect references in both the films.

Kattappa killing Bahubali was the most haunting cliffhanger in Indian film history.

Watch "Sardar Udham Singh", real story.

Watch "Kesari"

Yes there is Disney+ in india and ms Marvel is very popular

Why call it baahubali vs rrr when you're gonna just talk about baahubali 99% of the time?

you have to definately watch eega (2012) movie directed by ss rajamouli

Indian/Hindu scriptures give a lot of details about war formations, medicine, political structure, morals, ethics, cosmology, the age of the umiverse, arts, crafts, branches of sciences, etc.

Do watch Sardar Udham, it's based on a true story

I love elephant statues too. If you know what I mean..

The love goddess in the song you're referring to is Avantika herself

prabhas is not a dancer so you won't see much of a dancing from him in movies.

*Actually greek and hindu cultures are not conflicting because Greek and Indian Culture have shaped by each others influence upto some point.*

*Being a RRR fan I can say thay I love Bahubali more than RRR, Then just imagine how much I loved Bahubali. RRR is phenomenal and Bahubali is Magical.*

Guys, Indian civilisation is the one of the oldest civilisation if not The oldest one. The proven history of our civilisation is 10,000 years and there are many researches going on about Indian civilisation

watch "eega " movie directed by ss rajamouli released in 2012

*Come to India visit few temples which are about 5000-10000 years old and believe me u will be shocked to see how advanced their technology and architecture is.*

India contributed the following in regards to literature and spirituality: *) Vedas *) Upanishads *) Mahabharata (BORI edition recommended) *) Bhagavad Gita (a portion of the Mahabharata) *) Ramayana

wait for the Mahabharata movie which SS Rajamaulli's will make in coming years...That will break every records of movies out there

Zenobia Shroff plays Miss Marvel's mom Muneeba Khan. She was introduced to America in the movie The Big Sick playing Kumail Nanjiani's mom. By the way, considering the fact that hundreds of languages are spoken in India, there is no way that movies could be dubbed or subtitled in all of them, The films are created in a way that even those who don't speak the language can appreciate them.

Baahubali's set in 3k years ago

The Bahubali movies are from pretty earlier ago but it was definitely before pre islamic invasion of India. Islam started around 7th century in arabia and islamic invasions started in north indian states like kashmir, punjab,etc around 11th century. But in one of the movies there is a trader from Arabia who was selling swords to katappa. So the movie is set between this 7th and 11th century but including an Arabian trader is a formality, just like you see a muslim family in RRR who adopts Bheem. Time is still irrelevant in my opinion because its a purely fictional film.

Sorry folks - don't want to overwhelm you but if you really want to understand India you need to have a basic understanding of two epics which we consider our itihasa (which is history but with less emphasis on chronological accuracy and with more emphasis on story telling and messaging and relevance to the reader) - 1 Ramayan and 2 Mahabharat. If you are interested in understanding the contrast between Western and Indian systems - please read "Being Different" by Rajiv Malhotra. These will help you immensely in what you are doing here. Because there is NO way you can wrap your head around this system of philosophy which is so vastly different. 🙏🏼

You should visit india , you guys would be amazed by the sheer size and architect of Indian palaces and ancient temples .

i will suggest you guys two movies from Bollywood: 1. Bajirao mastani 2. Padmavat.

Ancient Indian architectures are way advanced, it's so advanced that it feel alien. even today with all the so called technology we have in our what we call a modern world, it's impossible to recreate such architectures, i mean it's even stupid to think that we can recreate that level of architecture in next 5000 years.. you need to visit India to see it for yourself, to see the architectural wonders of far advanced ancient Indian civilization.

I'm recycling a comment that I left on a video by the 'flaccid pheonix' channel, which was comparing scenes from RRR to scenes in Bahubali. I'm sure you can see why I'm cutting and pasting it here. The rant would never come out the same again, and I think I addressed the esoteric aspects of the Bahubali movies well enough to intrigue the interested. There are references to RRR as well, but knowing that you guys recently watched that movie too, I think they don't seem too irrelevant to leave out. Here you are: "Bois!! You are missing out on a lot of esotericism in Bahubali. But first up, you wanna talk unique fight sequences? Frikkin Bahubali sr. and Kattappa have an entire exchange about camaraderie and loyalty while fighting a horde of bandits, oh and Bahubali is in a besotted haze smiling to himself thinking about Devasena. SS Rajamouli is the best I've seen, in moving the story forward during an extended fight scene. But actual dialogue? fkn next level! As for the esotericism, the whole screenplay is rife with it, but I'll give you a few hints. Bahubali sr has a moon tilak/tattoo on his forehead - identifying him as Shiva, or the pure undifferentiated Self and Sentience. Jr on the other hand has a snake tilak/tattoo i.e. the kundalini, identifying him as an initiate setting off on the path of spiritual evolution. The mountain he climbs in the beginning is the spine, which kundalini has to ascend, that is why he encounters so many setbacks at first and has to show unwavering persistence - just like a Yogic initiate. The events that happen to him in 'The Beginning' mirror the chakras...he climbs first motivated by lust/infatuation, representing the mooladhara charka, or sexual/animal centre. Moves on to take on the mission of the woman he loves, to save a person in distress that he doesn't even know (although she is actually his mother, hence the Divine Feminine which is in crisis in the modern world - think Neo bringing Trinity back to life, although that symbolism uses two lovers to convey its idea). This then grows into Bahubali jr leading an oppressed people, and finally killing the Ego - his uncle Bhallaladeva - both physically, and decapitating the statue of gold (materialism, envy, pride etc.) which falls down and crashes before Shiva - pure undifferentiated consciousness that encompasses all sentience - completing the Yogi's ascension from instinct to total awareness. Want some more? chart out the sequence of the animals that are a featured part of a scene. The bull Bhallaladeva kills (Taurus), the Scorpion that stings young Bahubali sr, the Goat's head device (Capricorn) that locks in the shield barrier in the war against the tribe, the Lion head (Leo) that Bahubali grabs the tribe's leader with....follow the sequence, do your know your equinoxes and solstices? It's the Astrotheology that sweeps across esoteric ideas, from Vedic astrology to Imanuelle Velikovsky. I mention Velikovsky because that battle isn't Maheshmati vs 'freaks in black face', it is the most ancient of all myths, older than the global flood...that of the Sun (Leo, the Lion, in the Maheshmati flag and the golden head Bahubali uses as weapon) vs Saturn (Shani, the dark one, the ancient Vedic ruling planet for Scorpio which is the symbol on their flag, although the Vedic Astrology of the last couple of thousand years uses Mars as the ruling planet of Scorpio, so the flag is also red). This is also the battle between Shiva and Shani (Saturn)....ultimately it symbolizes the victory of the higher meditative nature over the primal instinctive being that each species manifests in its own way. In the Archetypal story although Shani loses he is not destroyed - because both the higher self and the primal nature are important to preserve. I'll let you discover for yourselves why Devasena, apart from being Shakti, is also Venus (it's in 'The Conclusion' and has something to do with the first scene she appears in, when she fights the bandits, and is then confirmed in the scene with the gigantic painting that Bhallaladeva is infatuated by). So all the song and dance and violence apart, the two Bahubali movies were about the initiate/disciple/apprentice/padawan rising up to emulate an Archetype (that being Shiva the Adiyogi, for a Yogi - hence the son in the father's image), to destroy the Ego (Bhallaladeva), who temporarily obscured undifferentiated Sentience and Self - his father - from him, and was the reason that the initiate came into the world as an infant unaware of who he truly was - i.e. his true nature. RRR is definitely a more accessible script that you don't have to dive into quite this deeply. Although, it does indeed have esotericism as well, just not as much as Bahubali, which is practically drenched in it. Both movies share that penchant SS Rajamouli has of conveying quite thoughtful things using an approach you would never think could be the medium for something as delicate as the ideas he presents - boombastic, exaggeration! Both movies use Archetypes. But Bahubali goes so deep into symbolism (the palace floors have parts of Tantric Yantras as patterns ffs!) that those things are just very very private insider easter eggs 'for those with eyes to see'. I don't really know very many people at all that picked up on these details. But that's the power of cultural symbolism, it is part of the ocean your subconscious is already. Esotericism is the invisible alphabet that conveys ideas to you, even when your conscious brain doesn't pick up on them. Oh and one last thing. Fkn get a life America. RRR does not have gay undertones you 'tards - I call you that in all affection - please start appreciating your male friends and brothers more. We men rely on unspoken communication and connection, but why not also show simple spontaneous affection for each other, and joy in each other's company? Maybe that's why male bonding can come out instead as stupid phrases like 'bros before hoes'!! I'm sorry for coming across as judgmental to your wider culture (not individuals of course), but seriously, reclaim your masculinity and show love for each other. You are NOT toxic, the world would not come to its full holistic and healthy fruition without your masculinity fuckers. Be your brother's keeper."