This is the best informative video of the 3 holsters! Thank you for posting! Helps so much!

To me Safariland is far superior I have rolled on the ground too many times and thankfully my firearm was never taken from me and I am now retired.

Just ordered a Safariland 6360 for my FN509. Can’t wait to try it out. Thanks for the review.

I can’t believe that these companies are still putting out the basket weave pattern….. it’s damn near 2023!!

Great video, really good camera angles to show the guts of all 3 holsters. Appreciate you 👊🏼

Thank you for the comprehensive comparison.

I had hard time holstering my P320 with TLR1-HL the problem i had was the bottom of the TLR would rub entering the holster causing the sights to catch the locking system. Once I figured that out i switched to SureFire X300U-B and it cleared the holster with no rubbing on weapon light and no sight catch. Smooth as butter.

Nothing is wrong with the blackhawk, you’re reaching, it’s just as good as safariland

Great video! Thanks

Great video!

The blackhawk rds hood opens all of the way if you drag the front sight on it as you come out of the holster. This concept forces you to immediately have your weapon pointed in the area of the threat as soon as you come out of the holster. Modern drawing techniques teach you to do this. The holster forces you to do this if you want the hood to open all of the way. I prefer it but to each their own!

That was great thank you!

Review works for me. Thank you.

Awesome review!!!!

Great video thank you! I have the Alien Gear lvl 3 with the rmr hood. I run a sure fire x300 and I’ve never had an issue with re-holstering it’s always holstered very smoothly and quickly. The one thing that I do agree with is the scuffing of the slide…not sure why it does that but I’ve come to terms with it lol.

I appreciate the detailed comparison however the fact that you advocate for the 3rd lock on the safariland tells me you've never had to draw your gun in a time sensitive manner or been involved in an OIS. Seconds matter.

I run the alien gear shoulder holster. It’s been fantastic for the past 2 years. Wear it literally every day and the only wear that has bothered me has been the wear down where the belt clips are. There’s an elastic type band that connects the belt clips to the leather bands and on one side it’s frayed a bit but hasn’t come apart (and if it did it could be an easy fix). Just from everyday use really. I haven’t exactly been “easy” on this harness either. All in all alien gear has stood up for me so far. You can even see me wearing it in my profile picture lol

Excellent review my friend.

I use the Alien Gear Rapid Force QRS with the slide belt, drop leg and paddle. It accommodates my TLR7-A and the Olight Baldr S or no light at all. All with 1 holster and 1 QR system. Your review left out alot of great points, as well as faults with all. Good as your opinion I guess.

Nice video

Safariland for life. I like it that its more mechanism to secure. I would always go with level 3 safariland

All them levels of retention locks on the Holsters, to have a quick detach system (QLS) on the holsters that can be defeated in seconds… That’s worth 2 good jobs. 👍🏻👍🏻

I’ve been on the job for 30 yrs. I’ve carried lots of Safariland and Blackhawk holsters. But the Alien Gear is by far hands down the best holster I’ve ever carried. Super fast natural draw. Been carrying for 2 yrs now. Just wish they made it for something other than Glock. I use Olights on my Glock 19X and don’t have hang up problems like you are getting.

Great comparison. Got me closer to a choice. What belt are you running on them. Thanks

I have 2 comments for you: Thankyou so much this was informative and shaped my decision on which one of these to buy. 2nd have you sent this video to all three manufacturers for their Engineering Process to perfect a better version of their current one?

I'm sure u are aware of this. But if not... the safarilans QLS reduces the holsters retention in that it can be ripped off the belt easier. If u are worried about gun grabs research this. Also. Different types of QLS parts are specifically made to break so operators don't get hung up fast roping. Make sure u have the proper parts if u were not aware of this.

The problem with the Safariland ALS (IMHO) is that I have to break my thumb position, and thus a firm grip, to release the firearm and then reposition my thumb back to where it needs to be to either get a good one hand or two hand grip and/or flip a safety. Whereas with just the SLS hood, I can drive the hoop forward and out of the way and the webbing of my hand is now firmly up in the beavertail of the grip, with my thumb in the right spot to flip any safety even as I'm coming out of the holster. The multi-movement (however miniscule) of the thumb to remove the firearm just adds to the difficulty of getting your firearm out in a panic. Same for the Alien Gear. Yes, you have a good argument with your experience of people trying to get your firearm. It's a matter of personal preference. To me, it's a matter of 'acceptable trade-off': being able to get your weapon out in a high-stress, high adrenaline emergency vs preventing any gun grabs/stripping.

I was just looking to upgrade my safari land holster to a blackhawk but after see your video I keep safari land

While this can also be done on the Blackhawk and safariland if you have tiny fingers, the alien gear looks like it would be really easy to pull the trigger while it’s in the holster

I agree , what has the up date been on this issue???? I'm wanting to make a purchase.

Change the retention screw on the trl-1. Stream light makes a flat replacement screw that was similar to the ones on the trl-7’s. I was having the same issue reholstering, changed the screw and all is well. You can get it on Amazon.

I think they expect you to pull the gun out fast of the black hawk and the force to make the part get out of the way. Slow draw doesn't have the force but bad design should work fast or slow

AGH got the keys man. Never going back to SL

Is it possible that the retention arrow indicator on your holster is actually too tight? If the mechanism has an arrow on it indicating how much tension you are using, in the video it shows your tension is at the top of the arrow (to me that suggests maximum amount). It may make it easier to holster your weapon with the alien gear if the tension indicator shows it's at the bottom of the arrrow, meaning it has room higher tension in the arrow. I hope this makes sense as I do not own any of these holsters but I thought it might help. Thanks for the video

I like the that the blackhawk has the one release. Imo it's just faster. My rds hood opens all the way. Haven't tried drawing really slow. Maybe that would cause it not to open all the way, or maybe it's just some holsters.

The RDS Leupold deltapoint pro is a lil higher, and realease the rds cover all the way, and dont have the problem that you said. Talking about the Blackhawk holster.

on the Alien Gear, the hang up is the elevated sights. The newer versions have accommodated for the elevayed sights.

“Retention” & “Release” are TWO TOTALLY different things…. My draw is faster from Blackhawk holsters!!! Just like you train for the extra step with the Safariland, you can get the rds hood to lock forward during the draw. Your SL “bias” shows, but all in all a good video!

Nice video safariland and alien was my top choices… I know Safariland is the #1 but I’ve recently purchased the alien due to the positive research I’ve did I know that one person opinion experience doesn’t fully matter until I’ve tried myself So once i get mind for a test I’ll update you and this platform for a review so if I don’t like it I’ll be strictly Safariland

The Alien Gear Rapid scratched the hell out the slide on my G19.

What about UrbanCarry Leather Lock holsters for CC? I'm thinking about getting one. PS just ordered my first SafariLand holster. I only went with the Level 1 ALS

Not a fan of safariland. That being said, I use both the blackhawk and alien for patrol and they both work just fine. No hang ups or issues through multiple on the job calls. It's all personal preference at the end of the day, along with training. Among other things.

There is something wrong with your Alien gear. Mine the can be let go and the gun drops right in when holstering. Check to see if the screw for the thumb lever extends to far. There should be spacers and screws in the box.

Would loosening the alien gear holster help? Idk that feature could be causing the difficult reholstering

The optic shield is just a matter of moving it forward on your way back

I bought 2 Safariland. 7367 for my SW MP 45 6390 for my Sig p320 Full RXP

The old thumb snap nylon holster is best and most comfortable.

The alien holster yes has two mechanisms, but it’s almost as if you disengage both at the same time. To me the safariland holster is better.

I don't understand why holster companies don't allow opening or a larger muzzle area for compensator.... we are in 2021 going into 2022 and no one offers this with having to heat, bend or dremel your $300 holster like safariland and Alien gear.

What holster has anyone used for a 1911 5” no rail pistol that they’d recommend??

The Blackhawk is perfect if your not worried about weapon retention during a struggle.. Therefore while I wait for alien to have a few years to refine their system it's Safari to protect my weapon!

As you have pointed out, holsters will react differently when it is off the belt. Does the Alien Gear have that same problem reholstering when it’s properly on the belt? It would be interesting to see a draw stroke video of all three holsters. I have the Alien Gear for a P320 equipped with red dot and TLR-1 HL and have not encountered the issues you are having. Very smooth holstering. Safariland just came out with a redesigned RDS holster which IMO has a significant design flaw in their RDS hood. They also need to improve on the ALS spring as it has a tendency to break due to its undersized diameter. Blackhawk can easily remedy their hood issues by placing it in front of the strap vs behind the strap in the open position.

Safariland uses way better materials then any of the competitors. I dont like the new 7TS line as they are flimsy like the Blackhawks. I haven't used the alien gear but it looks like it's made of simular materials as the above mentioned holsters.

Does Safari Make any Lv 3 Holsters for M&P 10mm 👀

I have the Aliengear holster for an sig p320 full size

Being from South Africa, I am having difficulty online to find a duty holster for a CZ PO7 with a Red Dot on it. I am looking for one that has a hood that helps protect the Dot sights. Any CZ PO 7 guys out there that has found a solution? Safariland holsters looks great!

I am not sure why you skipped over the other great aspects of the Aliengear holster. The ability to switch between sizes of the releases, which are included with purchase. Also the ability to use the light bearing holster with or without a light attached to the pistol. Definitely geared with a large bias towards safariland which is stated in the video. I used to be a huge Blackhawk fan but have switched to Alien Gear and haven't looked back since. Future videos should have a similar approach to each product. Instead of the love fest with one and bashing others. I am still trying to find out what is wrong with Safariland. I know very well the issues with the other two in your opinion.

Alien gear has fixed the holstering problem with tall sights. Instead of complaining, email them and they immediately fix it.

I have used both Safariland ( which I currently use) and the Blackhawk. One thing that you are not hitting on is that both manufacturers, when you are pulling on the pistol grip the als will not release. It's important to mention that because it is another level of security . So the statement " if they have your grip, they have your gun" it's completely accurate.

I have Safariland Basket weave pouches and level 3 Retention holster 6360 on a QLS. I carry a Sig Sauer P 320 45 ACP. No flashlight or red dot. I shoot sharp shooter at my dept. How is that red bead?!!!

I love my RDS holster very fast and easy to use and it's surprisingly tough .

Safariland is better but it will also scuff the sides of your side I have solid lines one on each side of my Gen 5 g34 from mine and I've only been using it a week

É possível usar tlr 7 no coldre blackhawk?

Tlr7, will any of these holsters fit it? Got a ppq and cant find one

Why not just go to level 10? That’s when you cement the weapon into the hostler so no one including you , can remove it. That’s known as the sss, mls, cvs, tns, g4s, iss, sat, and bbs system.

I dunno, I have zero problem with my alien gear one, my duty pistol is glock45 with pl350, it’s been perfect for 3.5 months now. Love it!

Can’t use neither of these holsters because none of the companies make a holster for any XD’s !!

Alien Gear is unable to except mods too slides !! The Holster becomes a level one ! Just went through the whole system on this. Not secure for duty use in that configuration.

Question: I've been looking at safariland holsters but on their website I can't find one that accommodates the TLR2. If I order the holster for the m&p 2.0 with the tlr 1, will it fit the tlr 2?

It's a level 4 because of centurion lock

Some officers be having wayyyy to much retention

Sure looks like basket weave, maybe I’m old school and that’s what I immediately think of😊

I run a o light and mine dosnt do any of that I promise mine runs really good .

👍

Cannot find a 23 hen 5 with tlr1hl duty holster to save my life

You either like Blackhawk or you don’t

Safari land has 3 motion. Your counting 2fluild motions on the release button as 1 motion.

He’s clearly trying to make the safari land look good. He was putting the gun in at an angle in the alien gear holster…

Do you think the alien gear duty holster will fit a olight baldr pro rl

Maybe yours is defective. I've never seen anyone else having any issues holstering with the Alien Gear holster. I don't know why you need a laser on your light...

what duty belt is this?

Safariland and Alien Gear all the way

This was very informative as I was looking for exactly this kind of comparison between the 3! Gotta ask though, In this video the guy doesn't seem to have any issues holstering his gun: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/irWKeLuV0arUlaM.html Did you contact AlienGear about the tolerance issue? If you did, would you please share the answer?

Safariland all the way

Good god. I feel asleep and he's still rambling with the 1st holster. Sweet baby jesus.

Alien gear lo mejor

Thanks for the video. Just fyi… you say “umm” too much

Try it on a belt dude

Put this video on 1.75 for a normal speed. Come on man, write a script next time if you have to. Too many pauses.

Glock 19 Gen 5 Blackhawk Light Bearing Holster: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/g9OIgsxk382peoU.html

The Alien Gear holster is trash and needs more trial and error research. Maybe a 2 or even 3.0 version will make it better.

The problem is that junk light on your pistol. I have this very holster and it flawless. Of course i have a Sig 320 with the Romeo 2 and i love it.

Your trigger discipline is horrible

Alot of talking but not saying anything

Safariland ✅✅✅