I wouldn't be surprised if just like Netflix, Disney ignores the prodigal son's advice and sends him off in place of someone more subservient.

Hopefully he can finish a project though.

Freddie Prinze Jr is like this too. these two must have had epic discussions during Rebels

Thankfully it seems they have. Sam’s playing Marrok in Ahsoka.

sams 10x though

I hope so. They’ve been giving him small voice cameos in the films. He deserves to be a main character in a show or movie. Maybe not Starkiller, but he can do someone totally new.

I'm one of the biggest SW nerds out there. I just don't have Witwer's talents. If I did, I'd be right there next to him, and IDC if I got paid.

He's literally been Darth Maul for years @@coloneluseless524

@@coloneluseless524Definitely as starkiller

@@chrisstetsko5020ok

I love this concept too much. I would love to see two force users just fight for their lives, using the same technique and share a deep twisted connection. It's a Ying Yang concept in this case. I also would like to see Vader just observing his apprentice, cause he told the emperor HE would kill the next target, but in reality his apprentice would deal with Vader's orders, just as a test or training sort of to prove himself. Vader needs to observe him,to know his skills but also to guarentee there are no survivors, also Vader would be able to tell the emperor all the details about the situation, cause he was really there.

Duel of the fates

No Disney screwed this up yet again, they gave a character who could be starkiller and they made it a hollow suit full of smoke according to leaks

This would be amazing. It'd be like poetry, they rhyme. 110% would love that to be the case, but sadly it won't be. I'll be more than happy to eat my words, but it most likely won't be the case, afraid to say. ;/

This is what we need

That's just stupid.

Agreed. Idk why Disney keeps hiring people who have no clue what starwars even is.

Because the amount of people who can act well and know as much about the franchise as you and everyone else that agrees with you would want, is incredibly small. You all would end up complaining about how the acting is killing the franchise.

@@Fever_Ghoul first of all your are so wrong it’s not even funny. There are so many actors that know a whole lot about Star Wars, and it’s not even about that because it’s the directors job to get the actors to know and care for the material and if they don’t ya get the sequels… hell even Samuel Jackson “badass actor” took the time to learn about every little last detail to make his character perfect.

@@Fever_Ghoul and people complain BECAUSE it makes no sense even for Star Wars. How is a sith artifact that is a dagger that’s at least a couple hundred years old show the exact location of the way finder or what ever it’s called that’s in the wreckage of the Death Star. Not to mention YOU LITERALLY HAVE TO STAND IN THE EXACT RIGHT PLACE IN MORE THAN A ONE MILE RADIUS. You have to be brain dead to think that makes any logical sense.

As a Disney+ show maybe. Would need to decrease his power level. I personally don’t find Starkiller to be the most interesting but I love Sam’s knowledge and care for the character and universe.

​@@coloneluseless524why?

Like last surviving youngling that joined the empire to become a inquisitor

​@@coloneluseless524He's the closest glimpse we have ever gotten into what it would be like if Luke had truly joined Vader. No redemption, just a cycle of hatred and despair. While at the same time, he is a parallel to Anakin himself. A young boy taken from the only life he ever knew, only instead of being a public member of the Jedi Order, he is a secret ally to a Sith Lord, plagued with a lot of the same identity problems that Anakin had, only these similarities are an echo of the Dark Lord's tragedies. It gives us a great glimpse into the evil that Darth Vader was truly capable of, he wasn't just some misguided soul, he was a truly evil man who adopted a small boy just so he could try to kill him every single day, on the off chance that he would survive and grow strong enough with the Dark Side to aid Vader in overthrowing the Emperor, only to betray Starkiller to prove his loyal to Palpatine. The fucking trials Starkiller goes through in his tragically short life is enough to make him a Top 5 Expanded Universe characters. Disney had to spend the last 10 years trying to make multiple stories to fill in the era that The Force Unleashed occupied and failed to deliver on most of those fronts, and ironically the closest they came to achieving a compelling narrative set between Revenge of the Sith and A New Hope is with Ahsoka in Season 2 of Rebels, but they admittedly botched that with the World Between Worlds(Which is an interesting concept that will hopefully be expanded upon in the Ahsoka series), it felt like a cheap way to bring Ahsoka back without having to explain "She was alive all along just busy or in recovery or something blah blah blah" Was Starkiller overpowered? Yes. He was a video game character trying to compete with the hack n' slash genre juggernauts like Dante from Devil May Cry and Kratos from God of War, no doubt he would not have those crazy stupid levels of power in any other adaptation, but the idea that he is a force to be reckoned with after a lifetime of being tortured by Vader every single day is not at all far-fetched.

@@setyx.Yeah, no point in reducing his power level...you could quite literally keep his power level the same... Next, someone should actually ask him if they've considered making Star Wars The Force Unleashed 3, knowing it would've been Legends anyways?

Cool but Canon Starkville should be at Ahsoka level, not that game bs, and make him Kal Kestis.

​@@charlesafonso5567i think he works better in legends he's to overpowered bringing him in would just make people mad because he isn't more powerful

@@charlesafonso5567 I think making him an exceptionally strong inquisitor would already be satisfying enough for the community. I immagine his canon power level to be around RotJ Luke

That idea would be sooo dope and engaging!!!

@@SamG_007 tbh there's no problem with Starkiller being stronger than Vader and whatnot if there is a well written story attached to it and why he ends up dying/not helping the good guys for some reason in the main films.

i want tfu1 as a the first season and then so on

It's annoying hearing people say "well he'd have to be nerfed" like SO WHAT? We just wanna see starkiller SOMEHOW

that would hit different

That would be sick

Lol

Black fog goes wooosh

i haven't consumed star wars content since the disney deal, but i'd totally come back for a starkiller show

Absolutely agree with that. I've been a fan of his since the Force Unleashed, and I have seen a lot of his stuff that he's done since. He's really amazing, and the fact he's a Star Wars nerd himself just makes his roles in Star Wars that much better because he can easily figure out how to get into the mindset of the character. One of my all time favorite actors/voice actors 😊

From The Force Unleashed to Days Gone and everywhere in between, before and after, I’ll be a fan of his for sure.

First time I saw him was on Supergirl & even though the writing was trash his acting & presence was doing some heavy lifting. Hopefully he gets a big movie role one day whether in SW or not.

@@PruthviG8 he was pretty damn great in The Mist

@@AntiBellum Yeah but I wouldn't call that a big movie role & it came out a long time ago. He needs something big to make him an A or B-list celeb (although maybe he's already a B-list celeb from all the SW & other superhero stuff he does).

he also plays a main zombie in episode 1 of the walking dead - he originally was going to have a larger role in it

Same here dude I remember grinding the life out of the force unleashed series back when I was in middle school. Then I randomly saw “the mist” movie years later like holy shit that’s him!

@@_d295he seemed so familiar I couldn’t put my finger on it.. till his yell before he died and I’m like oh shit!! 😂

Same, I saw him in Dexter and was freaking out because I didn't know he was a real person 😂

@@gfc_wd0129he also play as the main vampire character in a show called being human.it’s about a vampire and a ghost and a werewolf moving in together

That would definitely bizarre & relatively sneaky. As if he really prepping the Star Wars audience for such a plot.

@@Arkh-Lightning-Musician yo, imagine if this was a plot point/arc in the Ashoka show. The Apprentice vs The Secret Apprentice. I'd actually tune in for that.

As much as I love this theory, if it is a plot point in the show, he wouldn't be talking about this because of NDAs. They may still bring him in, maybe even to be the character, but many changes would have to be made in order for this video to not be a violation of said NDAs.

@@mechaCrusader17it’s not a violation because he’s speaking hypothetically he’d have to essentially leak the real plot (if there is one) if he’s in violation of an NDA.

​@crowfather3838 They should do a Anakin apprentice versus Vader apprentice? Yes! That could happen in Ahsoka season 2, but hear me out... Starkville is... Kal Kestis. You could set it in "Jedi: 3"

Watch Ahsoka episode 3! We got to hear Marrok’s voice.

@@coloneluseless524 I'm excited for it! My wife is out for work until tonight, but we're going to a friend's for dinner and to hang out, so we might not be able to watch it until tomorrow. Can't wait!!

​@coloneluseless524 marok is played by someone else tho, at least according to the credits

​@@loreking486no shit they would put that. They didnt have tobey or andrew in the no way home cast list lmak

@@loreking486 the man in the credits you are referencing is the stuntman who is wearing the costume of Marrok.

tbh if you look at his game and novel feats he isn't that busted his only truly bonkers thing is just behind palpatine he has the greatest uses of force lightning seen in a sith or dark jedi but if they added him to star wars they need to give him a r rating like cus he is just too dark for a pg 13 movie or tv series

​@@lordsathariel4384its also that you play as starkiller so hes as powerful as you let him its like kal in a way since you can beat a boss flawlessly and then the cutscene shows you getting dominated lol

So, recently Marrok died 😂 goodbye all the theories

And this is why dumb fans don’t write the official lore.

I never watched him as an inquisitor cuz I don’t think it works well with how they work and they would nerf him or not make him the same tbh It could work maybe with how Sam explains the hypothetical sure but as he said it would be hard to do tbh Yet I admit it sounds interesting and the conflict and risk is great since he’s in plain sight ofc But without Juno or Proxy or Kota then he’s missing out a lot of his character and what pushes him, his trials makes him who he is, so I don’t think it works in the end. I think they should just take the games and the Novelizations to make a live action adaption if they ever were to do it and just be as accurate and loyal to the material as you can which sadly I admit is very hard with how the canon plays out since he didn’t make the rebels nor the symbol, and with the inquisitors it makes his role half filled, and as Sam said Erza & Kanan also fill part of his role and story so it’s not easy to fit into canon. So at best I’d like a non canon adaption that’s good enough yet I doubt it so what I’d settle for is a remaster or remake of the games plus a 3rd one to continue then finish the trilogy they never finished back then.

Actors (except Tom Holland) are great liars 😂

It's unsure but it's a growing theory

Sure sounds like him

There’s a very good chance

Nope

@@TK-Commander-5672 probably yes nonetheless, but just for the few gutteral noises we hear Marrok make before -poof-

I have to agree with you. Your point on the fandom: hard agree. But thinking back to the Marrok theories, I have doubts the theory of Starkiller, and instead believe he’s probably a new character. I asked this question to Sam months ago for fun, way before we knew the details of Ahsoka. Maybe it will come true, maybe it won’t.

Very unlikely. Like Sam says in the video, you need the connection to Vader and in Ahsoka, Vader is dead for like 7 years. It's more likely Ezra in there. Thrawn corrupted him, turned him into an Inquisitor and sent him back to tell his allies where to find him.

@@chamoo232 that theory has some plotholes with it too though

@@coloneluseless524 That could be explained with the reveal that it's Ezra. More likely than having them reintroduce Starkiller at the very end of his story in a show that's not about him. If it was Starkiller, why would they hide that it's him for some grand reveal? Story wise it wouldn't have any impact on the other characters. Taking off his helmet, AHH it's me the guy none of you know! But if it's Ezra that changes a lot of things.

Ezra makes no sense at all. The whole deal with finding Thrawn and Ezra is the fact that they are stuck there and can't return to their native galaxy on their own@@chamoo232

​@@chamoo232I mean, I could see it working if Marrok is taunting Ahsoka about his training, she responds by saying she was trained by the great Anakin Skywalker, then he goes "so was I" (or something that might fit the situation better) and then we get his backstory and he's revealed to be Starkiller and actually awesome.