"We didn't know how precious each other was"

The thing I love about this song is... it's sad but hopeful. I feel like the song is telling us to just hold on, because bad times don't last. What's meant to be will work out well and everything will be fine again.

얼마전에 컴백도 했고 태민이도 이제 훈련소 들어갔는데 그 무엇보다도 가장 원하는건 종현이 웃는모습 한번더 보고싶다... 팬미팅때 날 보고 웃어줬던 모습이 아직도 기억이 남네....보고싶다 종현아.....사랑해

I was right in front of them when they sung this song. I was crying, and still can't believe to see them up close singing one of my fave song...

it's been 3 years since i first heard this song and trust me i haven't found any other song that sounds so beautiful like this and literally haven't found any band that sings like SHINee ! PRINCE'S OF KPOP for a reason ( KINGS To me )

Jonghyun: Like the two stars that end up together after all. It was all connected! He's beside the MOON. He is now a star that was now beside it. Now he says LET ME OUT to his last BREATH. He became a SHININ star, as beautiful as SHE IS. He started to become CRAZY over the Depression through the Darkneds who finally Devoured him. Our final fearwell and his final GOODBYE. So all of us made a decision. FROM NOW ON, We will stay beside Shinee. We will take care of Onew, Minho, Taemin and Key. They made this year a BEST CONCERT 2018.

After the darkness goes away, you and I from the sunny days will replay itself ♡ Thank you Kim Jonghyun. ♡

Song has true story inside. It also has their feelings and brightness too. Jonghyun’s voice made it shine. We, fans, will miss you forever. Rest In Peace, Jonghyun

The song’s climax is so powerful, Jonghyun’s vocals are so beautiful and emotional

As a Babywol, I still can't listen to this without tearing up. I hope that one day, this song, and thinking about Jonghyun, will bring smiles, and not tears.

우리 더는 정답 아닌 길로 가지 말자

거꾸로 시간이 흐른 듯 오히려 선명해져..너무나도 보고싶은 사람아..

물감이 번져 가는 듯 하루씩 또렷해져 거꾸로 시간이 흐른 듯 오히려 선명해져

This song always gives me goosebumps. And then it makes me cry. Every time.

No wonder this is Taemin's favorite SHINee song. This is such a beautiful song to sing together as SHINee, all 5.

Yesterday i had one of the most wonderful and most beautiful dream i ever had, and this song was playing in it, i was singing along, with pain, with emotion and with hope. The hope to see my loved one once again, the hope that i will reach to him and keep him company, and to let him know that he is loved, that everyone loves him... I miss you a lot Jjong

One of my favs, a timeless ballad.

길었던 이야기만큼 허무했던 우리의 안녕

I've only heard ot5 sing a few songs live, and this one was the last one on that day. It is one of my favorites and it was painful to listen to for so long, but now i think i can finally come back and remember the beautiful memories♡

Thank you Jonghyun. You will forever be missed :(

I keep hearing this song now as if I’m hearing it for the first time It has a whole new meaning now

Why im crying.. I really love this song.. My SHINee

진짜 핵명곡....

Shinee: From the day the world started. ❤

물감이 번져 가는 듯 하루씩 또렷해져 거꾸로 시간이 흐른 듯 오히려 선명해져 기억의 강을 건너면 잊을 수 있을 거란 헛된 믿음도 헛된 희망도 이젠 버렸어 침묵의 메아리 그 속에 잠긴 메마른 두 입술 그 안에 담긴 길었던 이야기만큼 허무했던 우리의 안녕 익숙함이 준 당연함 속에 우리 사랑은 야윈 달처럼 희미해져 진심이 아닌 모진 독설로 그리 서로를 아프게 했던 시절 자욱이 쌓인 무관심 속에 우리 사랑은 시든 꽃처럼 초라해져 얼마나 소중한 줄 모르고 쓸쓸히 바래진 너와 나의 계절 세월은 무섭게 흘러 모두 변해가지만 변하지 않는 단 한 가지만 분명해져 가 어설픈 방랑과 낯설은 여정 오랜 표류 끝에 그 길의 끝에 마지막 숨을 내쉬는 내 결론은 오직 한 사람 익숙함이 준 당연함 속에 우리 사랑은 야윈 달처럼 희미해져 진심이 아닌 모진 독설로 그리 서로를 아프게 했던 시절 자욱이 쌓인 무관심 속에 우리 사랑은 시든 꽃처럼 초라해져 얼마나 소중한 줄 모르고 쓸쓸히 바래진 너와 나의 계절 그래 아직도 난 꿈을 꿔 짙은 어둠이 걷힌 후엔 아침 햇살 위로 빛나던 그날의 너와 나 재연될 거야 되물어 봐도 늘 같은 해답 길을 잃어버린 듯 여전히 널 찾아 헤매 태어난 순간 혹 세상이 시작된 날부터 정해진 운명처럼 되돌려보자 다 제자리로 우리 더는 정답 아닌 길로 가지 말자 다시 막이 오르는 무대처럼 눈물 났던 영화의 속편처럼 결국 이뤄지는 두 주인공처럼

우리에게 이렇게 멋진 노래를 선물해줘서 고마워요~^^! 비록 별이 되었지만 5명이 항상 반짝반짝 빛나길!

샤이니 노래는 가사랑 멜로디가 너무 좋다 시적이야 아름다워 sm 사랑합니다

this song is one of my fav from them,it was sad. and after all that happened,it got more sad. sighs

I got to know you with this song. I'll miss you.

3:23 that harmony with the background high note tho >>>

To infinity and beyond i will be a shinee's fans frvr

샤이니는 종현과 멀어진다해도 샤이니는 결코 흔들리지않을거구 버리지도않을꺼구 떨어지지도않을꺼야 우린 계속 샤이니야 망가지지도않을거구 무너지지도않을꺼야 샤이니는 우주를향해끝까지 달릴꺼야 힘차게 말야 종현이와 함께 너와 함께😀😁😂😃😄😅😆😉😊😋😍😙😚☺🙂😇😇🤔👍👍👍👍👍🖖🖑🖐👋👏👐💅🖎✍👂👃👣👀👁👅👄💋💘❤💓💕💖💗💙💚💛💜💝💞💟❣💌💍💍💍💍💎💎💎👑👑👑👑👑

익숙함이 준 당연함 속에 우리 사랑은 야윈 달처럼 희미해져

This song makes me feel so sad for his passing like if only I can bring him back because he is not just an idol... he is a true artist. His voice is so powerful that it can convey so many emotions that can pierce one's soul by just listening to it. 😢

my god my heart hurts so much can't believe jonghyun is gone.. coming to the realization that there is a voice that belongs to jonghyun in some verses in this song and every other SHINee songs! but the angelic voice is gone

this album was full of such good songs

something about this is timeless, actually everything

Thank you, Jonghyun oppa for everything ☺️

Im still dreaming,, After the darkness goes away You and I from the sunny day..... I miss you Jonghyun 💎

늘 기억 할께요 잊지 않고 남겨준 노래 들으며 위로 받으며 사랑 할 거예요 행복하게 잘 보내줘요❤

53초 "허무했던 우리의 안녕" 여기서 안녕은 이별을 말하는 것이기에 "Hello"가 아니라 "good bye"로 번역해야함 "Our good bye felt empty"

Just found this song.. love so badly.. sadly Jonghyun not gonna performs this song again.. but I am not gonna forget your voice.. 😢💕

Beautiful song from beautiful singer

The lyrics are beautiful ❤😭

shinee is so good omg

This truly deserves to be a KDrama OST. Or maybe I just didn't know that it has already been used? Enlighten me.

종현아 잊지 않을게 그곳에 있어줘서 행복해 행복하자 5HINee

Happy Birthday Kim Jonghyun

This song is beautiful though it gets me all emotional😭 I feel like crying when I listen to it but it's okay I will smile instead 😊😊

마음이 너무 아프고 그리움^^

one of my favorite songs

It will reply itself.......... Miss you Jonghyun 💟😭

First time reading the lyrics. I love it so much.

i like this song and i like this video... Thank you because making this video to every Shinee fans

내결론은 오직 당신들 뿐이였는데...그동안 고생 많았어요...종현 ❤

노래 너무좋다❤️

12월만 되면 종현이 목소리가 담긴 노래를 항상 들으러와. 너무 보고싶어

Kang Taehyun, thank you for recommending this song 😭😭😭

HAPPY 11 YEARSSSS!! SHINee is always my legend.

such a beautiful song

가사도 멜로디도 다 좋다

가사 너무 멋있어요ㅜㅜ

Perfeição de música. ..

I love there music every one of their songs are amazing there music is every thing to me ❤

좋다 진짜

Que saudade da sua voz meu anjinho perfeito , obrigada por todo esse tempo conosco 💕😢 Shinee my live my love ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Masterpiece that show the future feelings.

노래 진짜 좋다

Minho deserves more lines

5명일 때 가장 빛나던 샤이니~ 천국에서 나머지 4명을 지켜줘~ 종현아!

0:02 이 부분 왜케 아련하냐ㅠ

how i love jonghyun's voice... i really, really miss that guy...

Miss you so much my Jonghyun 😥 😥

SHINee por siempre amo a SHINee ellos son los mejores y mi hermoso angel Jonghyun viviras por siempre porq tu eres leyenda.

Here i am regretting not staning them before 😭😭

not me crying

I'm always so sorry, and always thank you for your hardwork

THANK YOU, I LOVE YOUR VID :)

The lyrics are great

Me encanta mucho esta cancion la verdas esque todas sus canciones me cautivan los amo .....😍

많이 보고싶어요 종현님 너무 보고싶어요..

종현이 보고프다....종현아♡

Thanks Jonghyun 😢

This song make my mind feel "peace" 😇 don't know what secret recipe they have

7 years. I’m still missing you 💚🪽

It's been a year but it still hurt so much 💔😭

보고싶은 종현아

onew and jonghyun pareho ng boses nkakainlove😍😍😍

Why am I tearing ❤️💎 Love you JJONG You did well ❤️

And you'll always be, the only love I ever knew. I'll forget many things in my lifetime But my darling, I won't forget you

Its a beautiful song with deep meaningful lyrics.Thk you for English subs

I miss shinee 2020

종현아 보고싶다.

종현아 사랑했어

이노래너무좋다...

*#JONGHYUN* 😭❤

my comfort (?) song sa tuwing nalulungkot ako at gusto mapagisa; hanggang ngayon. :))

I read in your comment that you do this for fun.I want to let you know that I am from the USA . I got a interested in songs from Korea when I watched Boys over flowers on Netflix. The songs in the series were very appealing and I found myself trying to sing them because they touched my heart. I am not a youngster anymore so my family thinks I'm crazy because I found this fun. Anyway I have now watched 30 Korean dramas and look for new songs to learn . This particular song got my ear right away.I speak.only English so when I try to sing the words I often make mistakes pronouncing. So I play this multiple times a day practicing to get the words right.I would love to be able to speak Korean I love the flow of the language. Thank you for giving me joy in my life.keep up the work . I look forward to learning more.

Woke up from a beautiful night's rest and this song plays in my head. Finally, I read the lyrics...sad but true. I'm seeing the cares of only one but, there is another that requires of my presence and yet, we are on opposite sides of the world. In the end...we are the two stars who are fated to meet from birth.

jonghyun l miss you