She is saying exactly what's written in the book. Just because this is a time where people are empathising with evil people, it doesn't change facts.

The most important quote i found in ramayan is " he who pursues sensory pleasures neglecting his discipline will soon fall to distress "

यावत् स्थास्यन्ति गिरयस्सरितश्च महीतले । तावद्रामायणकथा लोकेषु प्रचरिष्यति ।। As long as the mountains and rivers exist on this earth, the story of Rāmāyaṇa will prevail among the people. Jai Sri Rāma 🏹🙏🙏🙏

We live in a yuga where Rāvan & Karn are admired even tho most people have not bothered to know what's in our itihaas.

As a Hindu I feel ashamed.... for not knowing the real Ramayan & believed in Leftist narratives of Ramayan. I have many friends who still don't know the truth. Thank you Ami ji 🚩👍

A podcast that clears many misconceptions related to Rāmāyana👍🙏

Thanks a ton Sanjay Sir, Ami Ji and Jaipur Dialogues Team. Jai Shree Ram, Bharat Mata ki Jai.

I love to listen to Ami ji. Please have regular discussion with her. She gives positives vibes and energy.

Ami Ganatra is challenging the West Indic-ideology-music's west-conferred-maestro Devdutt Patnaik. Ami Ji must do such talks more often to set the interpretations of Devdutt about books of this Dharma Land, Bharat.

This was so much needed .... in bengal there is a version of ramayana written by micheal madhusudan dutta ... glorifying ravan and meghnad to extremes .... i hope this podcast reaches every home in india ...

Ravan is a perfect example of what happens when an undeserving person gets knowledge, wealth and power. Very comparable to present day politicians, celebrities and top businessmen.

This is called a real satsang 😊

Yes.Ravan Raped Apsara Punjikasthala, it's mentioned in Valmiki Ramayana, Book VI : Yuddha Kanda - Book Of War | Chapter [Sarga] 13 | Sloka 12 Ravana Raped Apsara Rambha, it's mentioned in Ramayana, Uttar Kanda | Chapter [Sarga] 26 | Sloka 28

Jai Sri Ram🙏I got to learn a lot from this video about Sri Ramayana. The most important point that Bhagwan Sri Rama revealed is that you can't judge a person by his/her education, money or even his family....an individual only can be judged by his acts or Karma. Happy Deepavali🎊

It's amazing how a search operation of such a scale was conducted in the world to find one human and the fact that she was eventually found and could be brought back.

One of the most beautiful episodes of Jaipur Dialogues!! Jai Shri Ram!! Jai Sanatan Dharma!!

I love how Sanjay ji lands punches on current affairs/people. An illuminating episode, thank you Ami Ji.

अमी जी को सुनकर ज्ञान प्राप्त होता है। लोग जो कहते हैं कहें क्युकी वाल्मीक जी राम जी के समकालीन थे तो उन्होंने अधिक सत्य लिखा है।

Thank you sanjayji for inviting this fabulous person. She has so much clarity.

बहुत सुंदर, सटीक, और स्पष्ट वर्णन। धन्यवाद अमी जी एवं संजय जी 🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳

अत्यंत प्रेरणा दायक और प्रभावकारी चर्चा। आप दोनों महाविभूतियों को नमन्। ऐसे विषद विषयों को जन जन तक पहुंचाने का दायित्व हम सभी का है। तभी हम सनातन द्रोहियों के मुंह को बंद कर पाएंगे। सभी से निवेदन है कि इस संवाद को अधिक से अधिक लोगों तक पहुंचा कर धर्म रक्षा के अपने दायित्व को पूरा करें। जय श्री राम 🙏

Ami Ganatraji is blessed by Mata Saraswati. Her knowledge about Sanatan is unparalleled. May Ishwar bless her.

Mind blowing conversation. Learnt so much in juat an hour. Koti koti pranam... Ganatra ji 🙏🙏

Thank you very much. Yeh hamara Divya Granth jitni bhi bar sune itni bar aur sun ne ka maan karta hai....it's so important to learn Sanskrit to understand our history.

Brilliant presentation. Thank you Sanjay Ji for organising this interview. The current dispensation in Tamilnadu epitomises kamaasakthi and ahankaar . Hence the kind of statement about sanathan dharm eminates from there. विनाश काले विपरीत बुद्धि । तमिलनाडु का हिन्दू समुदाय अन्य राज्यों की तुलना में गहरी नींद में है। अबकी बार भी केन्द्र में हम सनाथनीयों की सरकार। जय श्री राम।

Jai Shree Raam🙏🏻🙏🏻 Whatttt a personality. We Bharatiyas are soooo blessed to have these histories, dhanyosmi dhanyosmi 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

Ami is incredible wealth of knowledge. Please keep bringing her back!

Excellent episode. Always nice to hear Ami Ganatra's Ramayana and Mahabharata. Thank You.

I am very happy that young generation is re searching Ramayan & Sharing the facts based on Valmiki Ramayan. Sab Shri ram ki krupa our ichhaase ho raha hai. Ami beta great job. Jay shriram

बहुत देर से..पर एक अत्याधिक महत्वपूर्ण podcast..ये मात्र प्रारम्भ होना चाहिए... भारतियों के लिए एक आवश्यक पहल.

Ami Ji ne bhi jitna bola sab true hai 😍Maine ye padha sab exact baatya hai ami ji ne ❤

I don't know why but for me it is impossible to listen to Ramayan without crying, everytime. Such high moral values people can have, I just cannot believe a human has written this.

it's a subtle effect of kaliyug that the majority of people supporting & getting attracted by evil personas even though the truth is clear in front of them

One can listen to Amiji for ever.

🙏🙏🙏 Gem of discussion and analysis between two profound scholars of Hinduism. Very enlightening !!!

Grateful for Ami Ganatra jis Prasang katha. ईतना रस इनके स्वर शब्दों में हम कृतज्ञ हो गए 🙏🏼🌹🙏🏼

Ami has beautifully explained Valmiki Ramayan. Thank you

Extremely interesting. I was glued to the conversation. Point is even without these explanations, my mind tells me that our epics have hidden pearls on human dynamics. Thanks Ami ji for diving deep. And Sanjay ji you are right about krantijeevi. Jai Sri Ram

I understand ravana as an example that says that you could be extremely talented, skilled, brave person yet you could be evil. purity and innocence are a greater than any skill. sadly ravan didn't understand this. Blinded by arrogance.

रामायण का इतना विस्तृत विवरण व विश्लेषण तो व्यासपीठ पर बैठकर धन कमा रहे साधु संत भी व्याख्या नही कर पाते हैं बहुत ही सराहनीय तार्किकता निर्भीकता सकारात्मकता साहसिकता संवेदनशीलता विषय पर परिचर्चा का आनंद मिला है धन्य हूं आज मैं

Beautiful. This narration brought tears to my eyes.

Salute you Ami Ganatra ji , for really enlightening us. Intend to read your books as soon as it is possible... I always thought that Ahilya was a stone ( thanks to Amar Chitra Kathaa) .. 🙏

She is just spitting facts from the Book Thise who have read the Valmiki Ramayana know this 🧡🙏

Always a pleasure listening to Ami Ganatra. She is filling up the gaps which remained in the knowledge of my lifetime thus far.

Superb we want to hear more discussion like this again and again on our sanatan

Ravana had high 'worldly knowledge' but low character !! Intelligence = knowledge + character He was unable to subdue the shadripu (six enemies): kama krodha lobha madd moha matsarya.

Who was Ravana? Ravana’s birth-name was Dashanana. His father was Vishravas s/o brahmin sage Pulastya, who is believed to hail from village Bisrakh in Haryana. His mother was Kaikesi, daughter of the Rakshasa King - Sumali. Ravana married Mandodari, the daughter of the divine architect Maya. Thus, contrary to what the leftists tell their confused followers, Ravana was neither Dravidian nor a sudra nor oppressed. He was a North Indian brahmin, very well connected and belonged to the royalty. What did Ravana do? Ravana did tapas and got a boon from Brahma that none but humans could kill him. Empowered by this boon, he took away Lanka and Pushpaka Vimana from his cousin Kubera, conquered many regions with the help of his family and even subjugated the devas. Marching north he reached Kailasa and threatened Nandi that he would throw Kailasa away with Siva. To carry out this threat he put his hands under the mountain, but Siva put his toe down, trapping Ravana’s hands under the Kailasa. His fingers painfully caught, Dashanana then sang songs praising Siva so loudly, that Siva gave him the name Ravana (which means crying or roaring) and the sword Chandrahasa. Puffed up by his success, powers and boons, Ravana turned into a bully, serial rapist and eve- teaser, misbehaving even with gods and rishis, earning eighteen curses in the process. It is because of these curses, that some of his atrocities are still known and remembered. The many rapes by Ravana When Ravana molested Vedavati who was engaged in penance to obtain Madhava as husband, she cursed that he and his family would be ruined by Lord Narayana on her account. Since he no longer feared gods because of the boon from Brahma, Ravana went on with his depredations. He raped Madanamanjari, wife of Rtuvarman, a tapasvi of Marutta forest, who cursed then that Ravana would be killed by a man. Finally, he raped his own would-be daughter-in-law, Rambha, betrothed to be wife of his nephew ‘Nalakubara’ s/o Kubera. Furious at this, Nalakubara pronounced this curse “You, who have become blind with lust, shall not touch a woman who does not reciprocate your love. If you do so your head will be split into seven pieces.” It is this curse that later kept Sitadevi and many other chaste women safe from Ravana’s depredations, although they still were victim to molestation and insults by him. After this curse, Ravana resorted molestations, humiliation and abductions to cater to his lust, but never committed a rape again. Rape, Rakshasas and Human Civilization Rape is a part of Rakshasa culture, and ‘marriage by rape’ is known as ‘rakshasa vivaha’ to the Hindus. Ramayana, which is a story of the destruction of Ravana, is an eternal reminder that rape can have no place in human culture, and that the culture of rapists is bound to be destroyed by divine forces. Molestations of women by Ravana Ravana tried to humiliate Punjikadevi, the daughter of Brahma, who reiterated the curse of Nalakubara that he would die with all his ten heads broken if he touched unwilling women. By way of revenge, Ravana took to molesting and misbehaving with women in the presence of their helpless relatives. He humiliated Svahadevi, in the presence of Agni, earning Agni’s curse. When he molested Dvaipayana’s sister in the presence of Dvaipayana, the latter cursed him with humiliation by monkeys. Similar curses were pronounced when he molested Atri’s wife in his presence, and he misbehaved with and humiliated brahmin girls who were bathing in the sea, in the very presence of their mothers. Once Ravana tried to catch Sulekhadevi, the daughter of Brihaspati after conquering Devaloka. Then Brhaspati cursed that Ravana would die hit by the arrows of Rama. Some other atrocities of Ravana Ravana committed innumerable atrocities, some of which are remembered only because of the curses that they fetched him. He kicked Astavakra, the sage with eight hunches, saying ‘Oh ! handsome fellow ! I shall cure your eight hunches”. This earned him the curse of the sage: “For kicking me, a poor innocent sage, you will be kicked from head to foot and foot to head by vanaras.” Knowing his perverse proclivities, Vasistha turned down his invitation to teach him Vedas. Owing to this, Vasishsta was imprisoned until the solar King Kuvalayasva rescued him. Vasishta then predicted that Ravana and his family would be destroyed by those born in the solar dynasty. When Narada refused to explain the meaning of ‘Om’ to him, he threatened to cut off Sri Narada’s tongue, earning the curse, that all his ten heads would be cut off by a man. Maharsi Maudgalya was once doing the svastika asana, resting his neck on the yogadanda. Seeing him thus, Ravana cut the yogadanda into two with chandrahasa sword. The rishi fell and broke his backbone. This earned Ravana the curse that the chandrahasa (given to him by Siva) would become ineffective. Once Ravana invited a Vedic brahmin to install the idol of Tripurasundari given to him by Siva. For being late, the brahmin was imprisoned for seven days. This earned him the curse that he would be imprisoned for seven months by a man. King Anaranya of the solar dynasty sought shelter with him. In our culture, one who takes refuge with us is protected, but Ravana killed Anaranya with a blow on the chest. The dying king cursed him that he would die from the arrows of a prince of the solar dynasty. Sage Dattatreya had collected water which he consecrated with mantras, in order to bathe the head of his Guru. When Ravana saw this water, he poured it on his own head. Dattatreya cursed him that his head would be polluted by the feet of vanaras. Conclusion It can be seen from the above that Ravana was not an admirable character, in spite of his boons, lineage, royal power and worldly success. He was a serial rapist and tormentor of the weak. Vālmiki says mighty Ravan like other rakshasas he defined himself by his power to subjugate. He ruled through fear, if he wanted something he just grabbed it not bothering whether it was the right thing to do and so he took his stepbrother Kubera's kingdom including the fabulous capital city of Lanka. Ravan captured any woman that took his fancy, however for all the big talk about being strong and powerful he did not have it in him to take Rāma head-on. He would disrupt sacrifices at their climax, then murder the brahmans. He was savage and wicked, cruel and ruthless, delighting in the misfortune of others. He was Ravana, "he who makes all creatures wail," the terror of all the worlds.

What a mesmerizing podcast! 🙏🏽 I will definitely listen to this again because so much has been clarified. Aap dharam ke liye bahut acha kaam kar rahe hain, I would pray you keep doing this as beautifully as this.

I like how she explains❤❤❤

One of the best discussions on Ramayana 🙏🙏

Ami ji changed my pov about many characters of Ramayan as well as Mahabharata. Thank you so much Ami ji an TJD, will always be greatful of you .

Fantastic podcast and immense knowledge of Shree Ramayan! Please do more such podcasts on other Hindu scriptures, Puranas and Ved🙏🙏🙏

This podcast is great gift to us.. With valuable eye opening analytics knowledge

It's so amazing. Now I want to read valmiki ramayan myself. Such a great podcast❤❤❤❤❤ loved it

Ami ji, you need to get this across to everyone Your explanation is so beautiful and simple Please do share this with the rest 🙏 The destiny part ... I felt this was meant to be for me today Thank you 🙏

What a wonderful podcast, packed with revelations. Loved it.

💪💪💪Brilliant and thought provoking. Thank you. 🏹🇮🇳🏹🕉️🏹 Jai Sri Ram. Jai Hind. India First.

When people can't behave like hero...they try to find similar incidents in villains to be relevant in the society 😂😂..same happened with few people in arjun vs karn.. they can't become great like arjun..so they try to establish karn as hero..

It's great to listen Amiji. Thank you Sir for this dialogue with Amiji Ganatra.🙏🚩

Ami ji seems to be not only well read but also a practitioner of Dharma. Her knowledge and realisations are very enlightening. 👃

According to Wokes and Urduwood, Raavan was a Legend.

Ami Ganatraji's enthusiasm is contagious. Joy on Expressions Sanjayji and Amiji - Eeshwar Banaye Rakhe. Dhanywaad to Both...Ram Ram

👌👌 Hats off for this particular discussion that clears the cobwebs in our minds formed through the narrative peddlers. Salute to Amiji. 🙏🙏

Ami is so talented, please Ami write a book on Arthshastra, whats stopping you?

Jai Shree Ram 🚩🕉️🙏🏼🙂 Happy Diwali to everyone 🙏🏼🙂⭐

Excellent analysis jai Sri Ram

Thank you so much So wonderfully explained I hope this goes across to the rest of our Bharat vasis So wow Thank you

I am in love with her...purest form of love...I love u Ami..ur voice is so karnpriya

please stop telling others before reading, read rishi valmiki ramayana, ravana was a serial offender, he did the rape activities not once , but multiple times, it's because of the apsara curse , he was scared of matha sita. no need to glorify ravana when lord rama is a born hero. dont give us unnecessary gyan reading woke scriptures and glorifying ravana . ravana might be a pandit but that doesnt make him a great. some people are perturbed just because ravana truth is coming out . great conversation need to be shared across hindus , people who think they are Hindus will be disturbed for sure. jai shri rama

Deepavali ki shubhkamnaye jai shree Ram 🕉🙏

अब तक का सबसे ज्ञान वर्धक एपिसोड । बाबाओं और पंडो बूलीवुडियो ने इतना मिक्सिंग कर दी है कि जो असली काम की बात है जो मार्ग दर्सन कर सकती है वो छूट गई पीछे। वालमिकी रामायण में अतिसंयोक्ति नहीँ है इसलिए वर्तमान और दैनिक जीवन मे धारण करना आसान है। बहोत बहोत धन्यवान मैं संस्कृत सीखूंगा ताकि किसी तीसरे की जरूरत न पड़े। कास ये पॉडकास्ट 20 साल पहले मिला होता।

Deepavali ke shubh avsar par Ramayan ka sahi gyan dene ke liye bahut bahut aabhar. Jai Shri Ram🚩

जय श्री राम 🚩🚩🚩 दिपावली की हार्दिक शुभकामनाये🪔

संजयजी आप का लाख लाख धन्यवाद कि आपने इतनी अभ्यासपूर्ण और सच्ची बाते हमे बताई। अमी गणात्रा जी सचमुच विदुषी है। उन्हे शत शत नमन

बिल्कुल अद्भूत है आमि को सुनना इतना गहराई के साथ विश्लेषण अबतक कभी भी नही सुना ,धन्यवाद आमि जी और संजय जी को

Simply amazing. We want a full series on ramayan and Mahabharat with her.many Pranams to this vidushi lady

The more analysis of The Ramanaya the better. Ish tarah ki manthan chalna chahiye doost Rajniti hattane ke liye. Jay SriRam

She's brilliant narrator and knowledgeable women, what a superb said real ramayan

Whatever she said is absolutely true. .

Just mesmerising... 🙏🏹जय श्री राम🏹🙏

nice podcast .we want such type of podcast.Jai Shree Ram😍

जब दो विद्वान साथ बैठते है तो ठिक ऐसा ही सुंदर और सुलभ ज्ञान का दर्शन होता है। बहुत ही ज्ञानवर्धक एपिसोड था और आगे ऐसी ही ज्ञान की अभिलाषा करता हुँ आपसे ... धन्यवाद🙏🙏🙏🙏

After years of confusion finally I got real story of ahilya❤

Ami ji ko baar baar sunne ka man karta hai, her diction is so good 👍

Mesmerizing podcast.. loved it

Ami Ganatra is one of those gems who I can listen to again and again 🔥

बहुत सुन्दर प्रस्तुति दी गई है और इस तरह की विदुषी महिलाओं या अतिथियों से जयपुर डायलॉग खुद में गर्वित महसूस करता होगा।

We want another podcast with her....!! ❤Bring her back.

I have started reading the Valmiki Ramayana (Gita Press translation). It is so different from the popular versions, and so much deeper. Just too many variations that bastardize the original Ramayana.

Wonderful podcast.. Got goosebumps

I really wish Valmiki Ramayan to be introduced from 1st standard till higher classes in schools part by part. Like this we can inculcate this gem of a knowledge into kid’s mind from a very early stage.

After listening to her I feel like what we learnt about Ramayan is like learning abcd of the English language. The depth and essence of Valmiki Ramayan is destroyed in subsequent versions and current movies are taken to opposite direction of the motto of the ethihas. Like Ravan is a good man and Ram has bad qualities.

I just love Amiji 👏👏🥰🥰.. Beautiful😍 soul.. Pranaam Acharya🙏🙏.. Such an amazing👍👍🤩 Outstanding mind perforating narrative of REAL RAMYANAM.. JAI SHRI RAM🙏🙏 🌸🌸💐💐

संजयजी, बहुतही सुन्दर ज्ञानवर्धक चर्चा केलिये साधुवाद 57:34 this reminds us, of description of beauty of rani Padmini by an expelled Rajput? 1:03:21 artificial intelligence deep...

Ami ji ko SiyaRam ji ka ashirwaad sadaiv praapt rahe, ucch koti ka gyaan aur avlokan. Aur Bharat ke Devarshi Dixit jee ko sahastrapranaams 😊

We love listening to Ami ji.. Thanks for such blockbuster podcast..🙏🙏🙏

Don’t want this podcast to end. Such a beautiful conversation. 🙏🏼

I'm feeling like I'm enlightened ❤,thanks to our legends and their destiny ❤

Ami ji is amazing! A fountain of knowledge. Could listen to her talk on our epics for hours.

Enlightening discussion ❤