Sky sports should also talk about non performing British players in man united.

These guys think united can be revived in 1 year this is a minimum 3 year project with any manager no matter the calibre.

He started the team very well Finising 3rd last season to me the question should be Who should Manchester united sell and buy in the summer

MEDIA DRIVEN SACKING

Sky sports wants ETH to be sacked 😢

They should get rid of the dead wood players first.

man utd life long supporter here! the question should be more „Should ETH stick with man utd?“… its not a healthy thing to do from personal experience but I - unlike ETH - have no chance but sticking with the club

How many times will sky post the same videos about eth asking the same thing?

Those guys at the sky sport studio are bunch of hypocrite. As a MAN UTD fan, i ask them this question. Why aren't they talking about the loads of injuries that has destroyed ten hang season? If ASENAL had had half of his injury problem, they probably would have been sitting in the second half of the EPL table.

This is Arteta's 5th year as Arsenal manager. As far as trophies go, he only has one FA Cup to his name. He has only finished in the top 4 once. In a top club he'd have been out of a job a very long time ago. Please discuss this too.

United need to give a Manager time. They are NOT a massive win everything club no more. They have to build back up to that level.

Tactically, Ten Hag seems unable to make tactical adjustments before and during games, that actually work not simply to win a game, but to avoid calamity and humiliation.

United fan for 35 years; im backing the manager. He deserves to be backed in the summer and given next season. If no improvement by Christmas, sure, get rid. The amount of injuries this year has been unprecedented

im sorry but there's far too much press about Manchester United , its really over the top the amount of coverage they get, seems like its more when it isn going well. There are 19 other clubs in the league .

Yes, definitely. 100 percent. Hes doing a great job

We had the most clean sheets last year, then everyone else, some. people think injuries don't affect your season full fit team top 4 no worries all day long

He should get a reign as long as Fergie

He will go in the summer. Would not be surprised if Tuchel ends up there.

Club has changed managers constantly they cant all be bad Makes sense to change other positions around recruitment and medical staff before looking for the next best manager. Doesnt matter how good the manager is they come to united and fail

Once humiliated 7-0 by Liverpool, he’s finished…

Ten Hag is the only manager in the world that plays a false 1, let him stay.

A video where they aren't saying he should be sacked, but asking the question instead. +1 Sky. Far better content than just saying he should go.

3rd and a trophy? He was getting criticised for that last year, not a great return everyone said. I'm sure the media will be saying how amazing Klopps last season has been though, 3rd and a trophy... what a guy

Why should they sack Ten hag when he basically has the same number of trophies as Arteta? Give him more time and trust the process.

In this comment section you will find 3 types of people 1. Manchester United Fan - who priorities the CLUBS well-being and try their hardest to maintain our standards which should be on par with club like Real Madrid seeing as commercially and size wise we are neck and neck with them but clearly not in ambition 2. Erik Ten Hag fans - who have this weird obsession with repeating a Fergie and having one manager for 20 years regardless how awful they are at the EXPENSE of the club because they think that's what a "good/real fan does" 3. Rivals taking the piss

ETH has his faults, but when you have almost 3 quarters of your players injured at 1 point or another, you can’t do much. Not to mention he also inherited some players that got Mourhino, Van Gaal & ole fired. His biggest problem is clearly his emotional signings, like Antony. Otherwise he deserves another season with players healthy, and new signings to replace the underperforming players. They can fire him but they will be putting immense pressure on themselves too, because there aren’t many better & proven managers than ETH in the market. And even if there are, how many of them would are willing to take on this job that has recently proven to be a career killer for most. I say keep him 4 at least next season, but don’t hand him the final say on new signings because he’s clearly been a hit & miss on those with signings like Antony, Malacias, Amrabat, Eriksen, Casemiro, etc.

It don't make a difference which manager comes in, it will end the same.. Its the ridiculous contracts that players are getting. Its the scouting and recruiting department. Not the manager.Liverpool signed players on Low Basics, very high goal and assist and clean sheet bonuses. Get the incentives in place. They need to prove themselves before getting better contracts. Not making millions if whether they play or not. Stop signing mercenaries. Stop signing players with bad attitudes. Every manager will fail with this structure.

Put it this way. Last season they played as a team. This season they have not bothered.

Shut up Sky!!! We still want ten Hag!!!

As a NUFC fan i love ten hag!

But don't forget to talk about the injuries United has and the board, which has been signing players like mount

Am neutral.truth is the best thing He has to get time in fact the new player didn't go well as he expected however with two or three signing he will do better

It's disgusting. ETH had a good first season. Now a bad second season and you all want him gone? Booooooo. You forgetting how bad Arsenal, City, and Liverpools performances were when their respective managers came in? United fans have to grow up. Now you want a new manager, you start the cycle again, if he does bad in one season you want him out? When does the cycle stop?

0:43 That's all you need to say - The players have let him down, and several of them have let other managers down who then faced the sack. This time round it needs to be the other way round. Players need to be sold who do not put effort in, then if Ten Hag isn't working, he's had a fair shot with good players move him on, but not now, not before the players go first. Starting with Rashford, seen enough to warrant him leaving and it's a statement piece as well to the other players no one is safe.

Only if they can replace him with the great Gareth Southgate. Otherwise no. I love watching his delusional press conferences.

We truly trust erik and love him so much and he gonna a legend coach at man utd

His biggest mistake is not buying the leading number 9. Who can score 30 goals a season with Bruno as the number 10. This would gave him some time to find the Number 8 who can scorers and assist with the current team. They missing the two key players. The number 9 and 8. They have the backup players for those poistions but not the first choice team players.

Eth and onana , especially Onana , definitely need to go to the championship league

Arne slot finishes in the top 4 with liverpool next season will that be considered a failure?

Players not the manager need to go. ETH will develop the youngsters and get rid of the dead weight. New owner structure has been needed for over 10 years and ETH has got United back into finals and playing in an unpredictable manner. With the players he will win big trophies 🏆

Yes.

Its the players .. how is logical to know the players are not trying hard enough for a manager again, then go a fire the manager .. Crazy .. Surely you just get better players , sell the old ones .. And let fix all the other issue before we even think about managers .. ETH just needs help build his vision like he had with Ajax in Van der Sar and Marc Overmars ..

Yes

How do you expect a manager to perform miracles with the number of injuries we've had. Who do you replace Erick Ten Hag with. The guy needs time, what happens if we bring in a new manager and things don't work out. Like we have to come to terms with reality, because we have new ownership it does not guarantee success. Football does not work that way, Brighton is well structured club but the team has struggled this season because of injuries. Ajax are horrendous at the moment after Ten Hag left. We've had Van Gaal and Mourinho. They both failed but they are brilliant managers. British Media don't actually want Man United to succeed. This proves how much Man United traumatized many people when we were successful.

The question the the new manager do any better? Does any thing good happen after the initial good period. Remember the season before ten hag, and utd finished 6th with 0 GD and the worst goal conceded in our PL history.

He is a master tactician, but he doesn't have the resources of players who are both cooperative and uninjured.

Arteta was in the same state as ten hag not long ago until he turned things around. Arsenal were far worse than chelsea then they suddenly rose back up and all the arteta haters were silenced. I'm not sure what to think of ten hag but we sure did have many injuries. A final season would make sense.

When it was stated that Ten Hag was being appointed manager, I thought he has not got the personality, the ethos, track record or knowledge to manage a team like MU, I was totally right, he has created to total mess at the club, the players have not stepped up either.

Manchester United should compare their greatest team of 1998-1999. Too today team of 2023-2024. Notice the difference. If same level or weak or great then the 1998-1999 team.

The team clearly are not playing for him. That's on the players, and I think the lot should be moved on, but that's not happening. The results haven't been there, and the performances are inconsistent. Injuries have played a part, but every manager deals with that, and ten Hag has not adapted to what he's had available. The players HE brought in (Anthony, Garnacho, Casemiro) have been a bust, and Sancho is out on loan and staring for a club in the CL Final. Sorry, but that's all on him. Not a fan of "dump the manager" but I don't see how he stays on.

That first bit , it’s cheaper to get rid of the manager , doesn’t solve the problem though does it , until UTD decide to actually sell problem players nothing will change , it was never gonna be plain sailing for ETH but we have to stick with him , he’s had no proper backing from the hierarchy since being at the club , now all that’s about to change , he deserves our backing

Nobody talked about Ten Haag Being sacked UNTIL Chelsea went ahead of them on the table. Lol All season They've been poor EXCEPT they've been ahead of Chelsea UNTIL .. lol . Benchmark.

Why are they always talking about sacking coaches ?

Eric ten hag is the best manager out there for United,

ETH Must Stay! Give the man the players he want and need!

That totally makes sense. When employees of the company don’t perform as they are expected to, let’s fire the manager and keep the bad apples. You know there is this thing called “brain”, it’s actually pretty awesome once you know how to use it.

He should go - not able to manage English league only champion league or other league except Spain or Germany league

They say it costs less to get rid of the manager than to make wholesale changes to the squad, but the last ten years have proven that wrong, because this happens every few years. The players will continue to let the manager down

give ERT time give him what he wants and Manchester will be good team

The British media are obsessed with him being sacked

Erik should be given more time under the new structure imo. The off field issues and lack of structure he’s had to deal with over the last 2 years is more than what some managers would face in multiple jobs. I’m not saying Erik is perfect, but I don’t see a better alternative out there either. Tuchel? No thanks. Potter? Southgate?… Seriously!? This would be a huge mistake for INEOS. These players have shown in the past they’re lazy and will throw a manager under the bus when it suits them. I’d much prefer to see most of the squad sold before a change of manager. We need players with a positive mentality, unlike most of the overpaid divas we currently have. If the manager keeps being changed every 2 years the club will never move forward. Patience is needed.

Really glad MU took him before any other team in Manchester

I am a united fan and i had played football for many years professionally. MU failure is a team failure( Management- coach- players-medicals).Unfortunately,it is easier and cheaper to sack the managers. Bring pep to MU and these players will play for him just for 3 month and then regress.If these players are so good why are we not selling them easily and why do we get annoyed if the former 2 sacked manager are advocating for clear out and these players are still here waiting to sack another manager.

Man united are conceding so many goals its almost like they don’t have fit defenders

Key points why are the numbers damming what’s the reason

There's bigger things to fix right now

And not one of them mentions the countless injuries like they did with Liverpool last season

For 11 seasons, changing the manager has not worked. Every manger Manchester United has hired were good managers until they came to united. The problem is with the board.

Yes. He should get until Christmas. He deserves that at least

No! Sticking with Ten Hag, will be disastrous. In takung deep decisions, he is often clueless. Can you imagine playing lead strikers choices for teo seasons now?

If you were the manager, with that number of squad injuries, would you meet the expectations?

Ten hags trainning program makes players injured, that's all I can see

The wrong with Utd is one thing this club is a commercial club first and foremost. Thanks.

You guys get other things to do and leave united alone, you can't see the injuries, just on our manager. We want him more than yesterday

Erik Ten Hag is good manager but he needs proper players to execute his assignment

Why are people talking abt ten hag? Can you race if you don't have a clutch and steering wheel? The squad is not good enough if we're at full strength and we even have injuries, what to expect? 🤣

If you think about it , Ole is still to blame for a lot of Uniteds problems. The backbone of our team : Rashford, Varane, Maguire, Mctominay, Martial, Sancho ,Dalot and Lindelof. These were all players that were either brought in by Ole to be leaders or young players in crucial phases of development. Ole was supposed to guide these players and instill them with professionalism and a desire to be winners. Instead, he created a culture of laziness and unwillingness to take responsibility. A bunch of cowards who wouldn't flinch to throw a manager under the bus. Now, these same players are turning against Ten Hag and forcing him out of the club. And the main media provider does not say a single word about them. The world is a really funny place sometimes!

Remember when liverpool lost van dijk and ended there season 6th? They lost ONE big player. LOL and yet ETH has only one CB to work with. Who by the way was meant to be like 4th choice.

I didn't even have to click and see what they would say...it's obvious the "pundits" are ETH out

Im sick of thiss panelists...we r united fan n we want him to stay... don't cover this unnecessary news

"Should man united stick with there players" is what it should say

Man Utd should get rid of more or less all first team players. Garnacho is worth keeping but the rest?

No!! There at least 8 better managers who can do better ..

Yes we should stick with ETH. If we get rid of ETH then what's the point in starting over again. We have no team due to injuries so it's harder for him to get a decent squad and we've had no LB all season

If he wins all games from here... But for him he should resign for Bayern immediately after that

The reality is the same issues have plagued every manager we have had, its time to understand that sacking the manager doesnt work. back him, clear house, get rid of the bad apples and petulance in the dressing room once and for all. People can blame Ten Hag, apparently Mourinho was no good, Van Gaal, Ole, Moyes, how many more, who do we turn to next, Potter? How long would Potter last? The same things would happen, we need to get rid of a core of spoiled players, Sancho, Rash, Shaw, Martial, to name but a few for whom when the going gets tough, they clique together and undermine. The work rate and effort the willingness to do anything they don't understand or want to do, isnt there, weve seen it time and time again nobody can fix this squad without clearing the decks. I dont believe for one second Ten Hag is a bad manager, I believe the club is rotten in the dressing room and for once the manager needs to be backed and the rot stopped, a message sent to all incoming and remaining players that there will be zero tolerance for attitudes and petulance going forward, if we sack yet another manager it sends the opposite message that once again, the laziness and weakness won. Those players have had their chances, clean house, im sick and tired of making excuses for players who wont run, wont fight, wont play, id keep Bruno and the younger ones, Martinez, even Casemiro who I dont blame for the lack of anything around him to work with, but overall, just get rid of the trash.

Hi,my opinion, ETH should give another, Season cos, true this,MU performance, There do many players. 1st 11. Injured.sometimes it’s unfair to Manager, To run the show Thnks. 😊🤝👍🇸🇬🇸🇬🇸🇬🤝👍Muslim Singapore.🇸🇬

Broken record question. Knock it off.

Always blame comes to the coach and that will not be fair. Managements of the team is the problem

Eth needs to leave. The players have lost respect for him. Its part of why the performances have been tame. The lack of authority is telling. Even if we try to refresh the squad there's no guarantee he can lead them to glory.

Ten Hag started off his early tenure with a humiliating 4-0 defeat at Brentford, and he may well end it with a 4-0 defeat to Palace late in his tenure. We appear to be back to where we stated, except that on balance his transfers (£400m) have weakened the squad, rather than strengthened it.

Why is the no accountability from these Players?the has been 4 different managers who cannot get the best out of this lot

Support him… support him… support him, stick with him

Keep ETH . Its the club structure and ethos of players not the manager

Easy answer: could you see Alex Ferguson in any match recently?

Ten hag said all his critics have no knowledge of football, sky sports has been one of his biggest critics 😂

As a Liverpool fan, I hope ETH stays. 😊

Back him injuries all season and controversial var decisions

ETH ain't a great coach. Watched him in Dutch league and European cups over the years, nothing amazing. I always knew was going to flop at ManU especially with that board. Just same as Slot to Liverpool. Will be a flop, dutch league have not produced great coaches for years. If you want great young coaches Italian, German and Portuguese leagues are the place to be.

It will be ridiculous to sack Ten Hag.. You can't change an old car by only painting the outside of the car..