For more on the ground voices from China, please visit www.thechinaacademy.org

We are deeply grateful to Mr. Mahbubani for his untiring efforts in the preservation of world peace and the avoidance of WW3.

MR Orville is such a joke, he still lives in his own old world.

The majority of US citizensdon't even know where South East Asia is.

Jealousy and envy, if you can’t beat them drag them down…

It was lovely to see Jose Vega speak out at a meeting of war-mongers (and subsequently get jumped on and hauled out) two days ago! He gets it! I wish I could vote for him.

Many people in the US are still hoping that the world will change to suit them instead of them changing and to figure out a place in the world!😎

Thank you, Mr. Mahbubani for sharing your wisdom and insights. Sadly, I fully agree with you that the US and the Collective West have already decided that they must confront China as an "enemy" and have closed their minds to any voices arguing for a more constructive approach.

Greeting from multipolar world

The average shelf life of all past Empires is about 250 years, and their fiat currency average shelf life is about 100 years. US is already about 2 years away from these 2 thresholds. However China 5,000 years ago is still the China today by its long resilience, culture and civilization, continues to grow, expand and prosper.

When one cannot compete, it resorts to sanctions and political interferences.

Former PM of Malaysia , Mahathir Mohamad told WSJ in Sept , 2018 , " We have traded with China for nearly two thousand years . China never conquered us. We have relations with Europe. The Portuguese came to Malaysia in 1509. Two years later, they came and conquered us. So I always feel that I’m safer with China than with Western countries " . Australia should have no problem with China as well , unless US Missiles were launched from ports in Australia . It is advisable for Australia to pay for the nuclear submarine and keep it in US ports permanently . Try to keep distance from the Warmongers !

Absolutely correct. As a westerner working in Asia 30 years, I can say that the way of doing business in Asia is completely different from the way it's done in Europe and US. At it's core, culture creates the difference.

Should be all South East Asia countries know how to deal with China. Except PH.

How to 'deal with China'? How about diplomacy? Economic cooperation agreements? Cultural exchange? Or are you drumming up business for arms manufacturers?!

American guy : as twisted as his body.

Very well articulated 👍🎯

The Western world has a collective conscious, based on a colonial past and neo colonial attitude past on by social genetics. This is the fundamental reason why so many western intellectuals are not able to analyze other cultures or reflect on their own culture with a open mind. The dominant culture is always the “good guy” and the strange culture by definition the “bad guy”. It is deep entrenched in the hearts and minds of the mayoralty of western people. We can see a deep obsession under western politicians and population about the war in Ukraine. They do not have a clue about their responsibility and involvement. Like trowing stones at a bear for decades and blaming it that one day, it fights back hard.

I have experienced Mr Schell and his message on several occasions, and on each one of these occasions he has presented himself as someone so quicksanded in Western ideology that he really cannot even begin to understand what someone like Kishore is actually saying. The result is that while Kishore is elevating understanding, Schell is being sucked deeper into the illogical ideological sand of un-understanding. And worse, Mr Schell accurately represents the view and vision of the 12%.

This Orville is the one who asked security to arrest the audience in one of his forum

3:54 Showing Nancy Pelosi and Mike Pompeo when Mr Mahbubani mentions “Western intellectuals” was a very good joke. It *was* a joke, right?

Orville Schell is living in the past and has closed his mind many moons ago.

Qing dynasty was once the greatest empire on the planet, but they declined relative to Europe, and made the mistake of still holding on to that areogant and ignorant view even after the European industrial revolution. We are seeing the repeat of histroy, just with the roles swapped. The latest industrial revolution in China will take some time to become blatantly obvious, and in the mean time the Western world would continue to slowly self isolate and close themselves off from China, until it is all too late and over.

Thanks for sharing

We circled back for a repeat smack down (intellectual) on poor out of touch Orville Schell.

What does he mean by 'wolf warrior diplomacy', when he talks about China? China is VERY diplomatic.

中国人不寻求战争，但是不一定不擅长做这个。当压力到来的时候，才是全国人民上下团结，清除金融、传媒、教育、医药、科技等各个领域里面的渗透和腐败分子，自我更新的一个过程。老实说，我不觉得是一件坏事情 。谢谢马凯硕教授，为了世界和平 ❤

The issue for these western scholars and politicians is they don't want to hear the voice from outside of the western world or USA.

Western countries people lives inside the box , while some of them lives outside the box ◼️

100% agreed on Kishore. Schell seems to use the western ideologies and criticise China why it is being different.

Mr. Mahbubani...As always true & to the point explaination👍

As they wanted everyone to be their slaves. My way or highway.

I am afraid to tell you, Dr. Mahbubani, your well intended effort will be futile. Because the american does not learn this way, it would only learn through suffering a painful defeat 😊

Thank you for sharing the truth

US / America calls it "Liberation" instead of "Invasion". That was what US call it in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Yemen, Somalia and the list goes on... Why the double standard? Confused... Please enlighten. Genuine question... Instances of the United States "liberated" or overthrowing, or attempting to overthrow, a foreign government since the Second World War. (* indicates successful ouster of a government) China 1949 to early 1960s Albania 1949-53 East Germany 1950s Iran 1953 * Guatemala 1954 * Costa Rica mid-1950s Syria 1956-7 Egypt 1957 Indonesia 1957-8 British Guiana 1953-64 * Iraq 1963 * North Vietnam 1945-73 Cambodia 1955-70 * Laos 1958 *, 1959 *, 1960 * Ecuador 1960-63 * Congo 1960 * France 1965 Brazil 1962-64 * Dominican Republic 1963 * Cuba 1959 to present Bolivia 1964 * Indonesia 1965 * Ghana 1966 * Chile 1964-73 * Greece 1967 * Costa Rica 1970-71 Bolivia 1971 * Australia 1973-75 * Angola 1975, 1980s Zaire 1975 Portugal 1974-76 * Jamaica 1976-80 * Seychelles 1979-81 Chad 1981-82 * Grenada 1983 * South Yemen 1982-84 Suriname 1982-84 Fiji 1987 * Libya 1980s Nicaragua 1981-90 * Panama 1989 * Bulgaria 1990 * Albania 1991 * Iraq 1991 Afghanistan 1980s * Somalia 1993 Yugoslavia 1999-2000 * Ecuador 2000 * Afghanistan 2001 * Venezuela 2002 * Iraq 2003 * Haiti 2004 * Somalia 2007 to present Honduras 2009 * Libya 2011 * Syria 2012 Ukraine 2014 * 2014 - 2022 - 9 countries yet to verify. Pakistan 2022 * Haiti 2022 * Niger 2023 Haiti 2024 Congo 2024 *

Alway love to hear Mr Kishore Mahbubani

Fascinating! It is like Hollywood movie. But this time it is reality.

Yes.Phillipines should avoid the WWW3

Empires perish if they favor wars--The Chinese art of war. The US has 800 military bases around the world. You know what will happen.

YOU SAID IT. THANK YOU SIR!

This is the first time I heard someone say that loud and clear it's over. Thank you for the insight ❤

Orville is still living in a cave with his close mindset

Well, the looser will not accept the facts.

Hear, hear! 👏👏👏

300 years US is a microcosm of 3000 years China. China passed over everything US had in short time. All the neighbors around China know about Chinese behaviors through real encounters. Equally they know how to treat China very well. Why does not China demand the compensation from Japan about Nanjing massacre?

their own arrogant blind them

TQ, Kishore, for your repeat analysis and hope your messages gets into the ignorant Western hawks and wake up to a new world order spear heading by China for world shared prosperity for mankind.

Calling them 'intellectual ' is being kind.

Arrogant and disrespectful!!!

By "great strategic mind" describing Henry Kissinger, I think you instead mean "mass murderous war criminal"

This is what Indonesia has experienced for trying hard to be the USA allies in Suharto era. One question to UN. In 1969 Freeport McMoran started to invest the biggest gold mining in the world in Papua Indonesia. It gave 9% of its Indonesia subsidiaries branch to Suharto, the 2nd Indonesia president, while Indonesia only got 1%. In 1998 when Suharto was toppled down, Freeport gave those 9% shares back to Indonesia government At that time, 1969 - 1998, Suharto was 1. The leader of Indonesia army 2. Head of Golkar council where Golkar was the biggest party in Indonesia parliament at that time. Parliament made laws. 3. Head of a country where ministries to the lowest government branches, head of a village, were paid to follows all laws made by parliament and executive orders from the president. Imagine if 9% shares with thousands billion profits each year were earned by Freeport Indonesia, what would that effect to the above 3 points? The questions are who asked Freeport to give shares to Suharto and why David Rockefeller also owned Chevron and Mobil who operated in Indonesia too at that time and why didn't UN and Transparency international defined this give away shares as a corruption made by a private company. This also happens in all over the world mainly in non-USA allies. However, Indonesia is not my country.

यह वक़्त तोह आना ही था चाहे किसी भी शकल मैं हो क्योंकि नया दौर मैं नया कथा लिखा जाता है न कि पुराना😅😅😅

Remember the last time we had a multipolar world? The Endless Waltz continues.

They get spoiled too much

Listen to Prof. Kishore Mahbubani at the ECSSR forum 2024.

Is that human beings right, wars on other countries

The guy living in the past .

Its not only China is rising up but whole Asia is rising up. Just look at Vietnam, US invaded them in the sixties and practically almost destroy Vietnam but Vietnam still won the war and look at the exponential growth they are now.

The wests are staring at their death😂

Totally agree with this man

Have to add the word LOBBYS. In the US is legal and it's part of their country's Beacon of democracy. For the rest of the world it's illegal and we can called this The Beacon of Corruption.

THE CLOSING OF THE WESTERN MIND

Well explained

India-China issues should be resolved through dialogue, not through the military.

Kishore Mahbubani👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪

Mr. Orville is such a clown.

The term "Wolf Warrior" is an unfortunate one chosen by a Chinese spokesman. What it really meant is "being assertive, but not necessarily warmonger like". I will tell you who fit that "war monger" tag...it is the US. Everyone knows that except not daring to openly articulate it. It is like Joe Biden has past his cognition "used-by date", but no one is talking about it until now, it took a debate to expose his ineptness. Take human evolution as an example. The accepted theory is that Homo Sapiens emerged from the African continent, and gradually emigrated across the world. But in reality, it didn't happen all at once. Some went earlier, and some followed later. That is why the pattern of civilization in not uniform all across the world. While the various groups settled in, they began to evolve in the way best suited to their needs. China evolves into the civilization which suit the Chinese culture and mind set. But China didn't suddenly become what it is today, it took decades and centuries. One of the most noteworthy period was the industrialization of textiles when silk industry dominated the world. That is not a flash in the pant either because Chinese are, traditionally, prided themselves on hard work and aptitudes. Being pragmatic also helps. Naturally the west sees the rise of China as a threat to its dominance. So instead of working out how to out perform, or in Janet Yellen's words..."overcapacity", the US and the west deploy the "Tonya Harding" tactic which took the leg out of her opponent "Kerri Kerrigan" in order to win the competition. While the US cannot use its trialed and tested military tactic to subdue because China is no longer the easy-beat it once was, the US deploys the schoolyard tactic by sledging China. With a president like Joe Biden, I doubt that China has too much to worry about. As for Trump, he is a one trick pony. He only knows MAGA by slapping on tariffs. I think China has both Biden and Trump measured.

Yes totally agree with you for speaking out for all of us asians

❤👍👏

Orville is a bigot

Agree

Western liberalism has taught many in the West to see to the limits of your believe. For the rest of us, seeing is believing.

The goal is to maintain US hegemony. I think it is loud and clear.

the US thinks they know everyone hahahahaha...'think'.

I thought you guys were going to discuss Native americans.

Mr China to the rescue.

Western intellectuals????

Actually what Kishore say is common sense. Do not need Professor Kishore to arrive at this thinking that the western dominance is over. Western domination over 200 years is due to aggressive nature once the western develop modern weapons and modern economies and manufacturing process etc. Now China & India have a rude and brutal awakening and same with Africa which bear a brutal slavery period. Now all have the same playing field. Gun vs sword conflict is over. Horse vs armour carrier is over. Trading war is a new battlefield. Working 4 or 5 days week with 38hr per week sure to lose out to Asian hardworking attitude & strong education with strong family and high saving habits. For example Chinese are working 7 days a week and 9am to 9pm.

How can UK Citizens move to China and have a stay visa and work in China?

It's OVER!!! WAKE UP SINGAPORE!!!

Our government has been stolen....So it's not us you are dealing with.....And be careful because Eternal hell is abound.....God did not forsake us 💖

Selfish preservation

Om 🕉 🕉 🕉 ❤🎉

Orville should change his surname to "Shrill".

South East Asia know how to deal with US also.

यह वक़्त तोह आना ही था चाहे किसी भी शकल मैं हो क्योंकि नया दौर मैं नया कथा लिखा जाता है न कि पुराना😆😆😆

We are in Age of Aquarius 👌👍it’s a HUMANITARIAN Age ergo our world witnessing Multipolarity gaining Momentum 👌👍US Unipolar world is over

It has been over since 1971 when Nixon took the US$ off the gold standards. Since then the most productive part of the Western countries is the money printing machines otherwise they would have imploded already. However by printing money beyond their capacity, the inevitable is just going to get worse.

Well said. That's why Japan and the Philippines have signed a bilateral security pact. And why prime minister Modi did not attend the SCO meeting in Kazahstan where Xi ordered the group to stay loyal to China and "resist external interference". China likes to have things its own way but does like its own security blocs and has various free trade agreements with ASEAN since 2002 many specifically targeting tariffs.

That guy is a typical arrogant with superiority complex.

Talk more about the silly wolf warriors. The world is in stitches, laughing

Kishore Mahbubani said at 2:36, "The Western intellectual cannot accept the reality that 200 years of Western domination of world history is over is over.' He also said at 0:41, "12% of the world's population live in the West and 88% ... outside of the West... And how the 12% view China is not how the 88% view China. He obviously wants to make the point that the 12% want the 88% (minus China) to be wary of China's rise and fear it as well, and to help the 12% contain it .

Mr Kishore 👍👍 Western must 'try to accept' Eastern country had capability N intelligence .to be advance country; made own 🚗 🚝✈️🚀... Don't jealous. PEACE

Not naive, but evil aipac

I am extremely sad for their total ignorance and naivety of China, choosing the lazy way out to understand China and that is become haters.

big nation to share world wealth do not follow were west gone wrong

I am sorry to disagree with you ! The western model is good, if they followed it. Regretfully they say one thing and do the opposite. As in one native Indian saying goes " the white ma speaketh with fork tongue" History repeats itself, the Red Indians were repeatedly deceived and this is a character flaw plaguing the so called developed countries.

I hate it when someone both sides it! It is clear that there is only one side which wants hostility and looks to be headed towards conflict. And that is the US and West. China has nothing to do with the escalation of hostility and conflict. China is only responding to the aggression. This is why I do not respect this man. He says a lot of reality based analysis. Then basically muddies his own arguments by both siding it.

Pay more attention to that silly man and the red coat. he is Wumao

Here's the full conversation: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/hq-WlZpzus_VeI0.htmlsi=8Aa6vEfqQp5Nwy8R