Every time I hear it as "New York IS in New York" and I'm like "That's true".

I love the hint of a smile on her face as she tries to get the swan to cut it's shit out

That colour palettte is everything my eyes need to see.

To any young photographers or cinematographers who view this: _THAT'S_ how you use color as an element of composition. What an incredible artist we have in this young woman.

that voice

St. Vincent really makes me feel sorry for people my age...40+...that just listen to their 80's or 90s playlists over and over. You're missing some amazing new music. I could listen to 'Prince Johnny' on a loop for an hour straight.

I come back to watch this every once in a while cause it’s just so pretty.

this album is so powerful to me bc she still has her classic stiff, almost robotic delivery and crisp aesthetics that she def still has in this video but the vulnerability of the lyrics keeps seeping through in her face and her voice. such a beautiful contrast!!! love love love

Is it ok that I cry every time I hear this song?

I love the tone of the lyrics - the begrudging remorse and not wanting to admit wrongdoing but still doing so in the choruses anyways - really complex emotion for such a short peice. God I love St. Vincent - easily one of the best projects to make it big this past decade.

THE WINK AT THE END

Obsessed-- I love everything about this. I think my favorite part is when she gently pulls the swan away from eating her sequined dress

This is one of my favorite music videos of all time. The artistic direction is sickening and flawless. The song itself is beautiful and catchy. When I’m feeling some type of way this song comforts me. Thank you St. Vincent for sharing your brilliant mind.

IVE DECIDED TO STAN FOREVER

Great music video; the visual aesthetics, the eye-popping colors, the costumes, the scenery, the directing style, and of course, Annie's performance... all incredible.

Any Bold Type fans here? What an episode. Excited for the new season!

Annie gave us 3 minutes of rich white woman on hallucinogenics doing errands in Manhattan

Man, I am so bummed I'm just really catching on to Annie's work. What an amazing journey for all her long-time fans. Better late than never I guess.

this is so good it physically hurts.

omg Annie can play guitar AND piano with her legs

Everything is bright and flashy but her eyes show deep sadness. I love this song.

okey... this is beyond of what my mental capacities are able to process

It’s so…sad? the lyrical work makes me sob but the colors make smile.

Welcome back, Annie. We missed you.

The artistic ambiance is absolutely astounding.

1:30 the girl in purple with the cyan balloon looks amazing in those colours holy shit

I keep coming back to this song and it still makes my emotions shake. The artistry, visuals, lyrics tell that story so well.

If you contrast this video with her video for "Los Ageless", a song about the city of Los Angeles, you can see that there's so much difference! Both videos are very colorful and beautiful, but in "Los Ageless", St. Vincent is visibly disturbed and even disgusted by organic, natural things. It's about plastic surgery, aesthetics, looking beautiful and synthetic. In this video, you can see her freckles (more of a natural makeup style), there's FIRE, a live animal, live flowers, a breeze blowing through her hair...the difference is so remarkable! Maybe that's why Annie Clark prefers to live in New York City =)

The colors remind me a lot of the Digital Witness video. It's cool. Very cool!

Seeing her live was awesome

“I’ve lost a hero, I’ve lost a friend, but for u darling I’ll do it all again.”

Absolutely LOVE the visuals from her "Masseduction" era!

Pssst - your lettuce is on fire.

The fire on the green vegetation as microphone is nice magical. Reminds of the red lights around town burning the green ones. Neat tune minor editing would makes it shine.

I'm so thankful I heard this striking song years before I saw the video. Music is less subjective.

Yaaas ❤❤❤❤❤ 😭😭😭 I love this song so much

so many underrated artists in the world ugh;-;

I missed her!

Here after the WeCrashed ending song, what a MF amazing show!!

We crashed sent me here

How did they make that swan not kill Annie and everyone else on set?

2:00 OKAY i'm melting

She is pure art in human form.....I can't warp my head around how amazing she is! How sad the lyrics are and meshed with the amazing visuals punches you in the face with everything!!

1:55 - Anyone else at this point in the video from Ann Arbor, Michigan say “hey that looks like our Cube!” And then research it and realize there is an exactly the same spinny Cube in NYC? See, St. V is educational as well as insanely talented. 👏🏼

that wink at the end cured the last 12 years of my depression

I’m from Russia but I lived in NYC for a couple years and fell in love with this city. And this song makes me cry and miss it so bad. Love it with all my heart.

This music video is so gorgeous! The color blocking is amazing and she looks so beautiful, defintely a new era and side of Clark I've never seen before. Excited for more!

This song is so underrated

It kind of seems like she's leveled up. This has a really strong vibe, like a perfect transition and growth from her previous work (not that her previous work wasn't strong I've loved all of her stuff but this song is seriously badass). And the video is to die for, it's beautiful

This is visually magnificent. I've been loving this song for a quite a while 💜

1:53 cube shot was pretty cool

Good lord this is amazing, St Vincent has blessed us yet again and my life will never be the same

I love the aesthetic of the video! 💜💜💜

perfect NY music... reminds me of a time where searching for love in all the wrong places and partying all night long was a runaway train the youth could never escape.

this is quite emotionally vulnerable

The song has definitely grown on me. The atmosphere in the chorus is just on another level

Just incredible. Such an amazing work of art. I love you Annie Clark!

This video is so beautiful, Annie! Thank you so much for sharing it with the world.

New Love wasn’t true love back to you love That line resonates with me so much

Thank you! From: Scranton, Pennsylvania

As a painter who studied art, I must say that her videos are very innovative and reminiscent of pop art and her style is unique.

Who is here from WeCrashed? Also this song belongs in Billions

New York is simply brilliant, denoting a compositional ability that it is not absolutely common. I listened to the song many times before watching the video, this because the creative force distracts from pure listening. Music and images create a new structure for the song, the result is magnificent. I bought the vinyl, I'm too old and I still love listening to the Music sitting in an armchair. Many thanks St. Vincent.

I can't believe the real power this song has on me. I been hearing it during weeks without getting any upset of it💙💚

I think that swan likes you.

Looove the colorplay in this video!!! I can't wait for the album and to see the tour!!!

One of the best songs ever made.

This song grows on you. And the visual, STUNNING!

New York isn't New York Without you, love So far in a few blocks To be so low And if I call you from First Avenue Where you're the only motherfucker in the city Who can handle me New love Wasn't true love Back to you, love So much for a home run With some blue bloods If I last-strawed you on 8th Avenue Where you're the only motherfucker in the city Who can stand me I have lost a hero I have lost a friend But for you, darling I'd do it all again I have lost a hero I have lost a friend But for you, darling I'd do it all again New York isn't New York Without you, love Too few of our old crew Left on Astor So if I trade our 'hood For some Hollywood Where you're the only motherfucker in the city who would Only motherfucker in the city who would Only motherfucker in the city who'd forgive me I have lost a hero I have lost a friend But for you, darling I'd do it all again I have lost a hero I have lost a friend But for you, darling I'd do it all again

Best female guitarist in my opinion...

absolutely beautiful, what an interesting and unexpected visual direction for her! When I watched it I felt like it was a tribute to the protagonist of the song.

This is a masterpiece.

Every shot in this vid is so visually appealing

"New love wasn't true love, Back to you, love."

I usually just listen to songs whilst reading the comments mostly but this video is just so aesthetically pleasing i keep watching it over and over.

I LOVE the song !!!!! Congratulations to st vincent

This is so aesthetically pleasing and beautiful! ♥

I come back to this video at least once a month, it gives me so much inspiration.

The definition of creativity

This is perfect. Just beautiful on every level

Queen

I'd do it all again, too

She's giving me FROOT vibes with some Solange influences, and that's all I needed in my life

I LOVE YOUUUUUU...... GOD BLESS YOU....

I could literally break down crying to this song. My interpretation is a little cliche, but. It really feels like an incredibly vulnerable confession of pure sorrow, mourning and regret. A heartbreakingly familiar portrayal of how fucking horrible it feels when you finally lose someone who really was special to have in your life, and you in theirs; but you just couldn't make it work despite all the positives, and you'd give anything to them back living and apart of your life in "New York". The loss of that kind of Friend or Relationships is terrifyingly numbing, the calm, dead expression throughout such a vibrant environment in the video is how it can feel being somewhere you love and cherish, but something still feels missing; 00:19 New York isn't New York without you love .

My favorite song and video, iconic Annie

I love your color of music. You're the hero to me like the light of covering Astor. Really thanks to you.

The aesthetics are just incredible and this song is my favourite, just phenomenal

I hope the record contains a hyper-psychotic track. Like how 'Marry Me' had 'Your Lips Are Red', Strange Mercy had 'Northern Lights', 'St Vincent' had 'Bring Me Your Loves'

Such a perfect song for the perfect city. I want to be back in New York City.

What else can you say - this is a fucking beautiful song with a lot of heart

Oh Greggy Jamie, thank you for this gem

I was jamming to this in the car and come home and find this. Hell yes.

O clipe está lindo e a música é linda! 😍😍😍😍

This song was written for me. It had to be. I don't even know what genre this is, I mainly listen to heavy stuff. These lyrics bruh.

This always reminds me of a couple of people who, without them my hometown just lost the zesty flavour and in spite of what I tried couldn't replace it. Great stuff

This shit is beautiful

SUCH A GOOD VIDEO

Absolutely adore. Bravo Annie.

This song + visual masterpiece Breaks my heart Annie! In a good way. To the horizon.