We aren't beating the Matpat allegations with this one.
@PatreonPreviewsofVictorTanzig3 ай бұрын
Ha I see what you did there
@fanofeverything304653 ай бұрын
What's the joke @@PatreonPreviewsofVictorTanzig
@bluebellsforever3 ай бұрын
Not that we even should
@jakobnorman3153 ай бұрын
I think that when Geoffrey tilted over on his side he struck his smoke box on a very large rock and as science shows us a hard enough blow to the head is enough of a death blow and smoke boxes are pretty much the heads of non faceless steam engines
@aplane96253 ай бұрын
In my rewrite his crash was less severe, however his tender was too battered up and had to be scrapped as o he needed a new one It was when Patrick was sent packing when he returned
But Here is a question, On what side was Geoffery coming from
@TheTrainTheoristOfficial3 ай бұрын
So Geoffrey came from the Right side of Gordon's Hill, which is a very sharp turn, compared to the middle or left track.
@mary.of.mares.14703 ай бұрын
@@TheTrainTheoristOfficial well the right side is to Welsworth
@henriquefernandesbreves60033 ай бұрын
I think he means the right track@@mary.of.mares.1470
@mary.of.mares.14703 ай бұрын
@@henriquefernandesbreves6003 uhh no it doesn't check the map
@ThomasFisher-jr6bn3 ай бұрын
How about a theory about how Thomas survived getting blown up while other engines like Colin, Lilly, Benson and Mickey couldn't? Unlike those other engines, Thomas' body was mostly intact and he was still alive.
@joestuffProductions50063 ай бұрын
I think he survived because he was moving away from the explosion when it happened so he was probably at least a little bit far from the tanker unlike lily Collen Benson and Mickey
@ThomasFisher-jr6bn3 ай бұрын
@@joestuffProductions5006 I don't know about that. It looks like he was less than a meter away from the tanker. Mickey was further away from the bomb yet he still got blown to pieces.
@pugtrainmaster53263 ай бұрын
I agree Mickey should be injured but not dead bring back Mickey
@joestuffProductions50063 ай бұрын
@@ThomasFisher-jr6bn true
@ThomasFisher-jr6bn3 ай бұрын
@@pugtrainmaster5326 I'm sorry, but Mickey was blown to pieces, so he is not coming back any time soon.
@fanofeverything304653 ай бұрын
We just need Victor to watch this video and say you're half-right
@sir.confident3 ай бұрын
Allow me to explain. Metal fatigue was a thing with the engines in the Stories of Sodor. But it was more common with the Midis as they had to work twice as harder than the other three during the days of the big four. Adam, Randolf and Peter all had metal fatigue as an underlying illness prior to their incidents. Given the former, I'm assuming that metal fatigue for engines is like having an anuerysm or heart disease for humans, which is the result of too much stress. That's rare to survive for humans. As Adam, Randolf and Peter - who were all Midis obviously had metal fatigue as an underlying illness prior to their incidents, its likely that Geoffrey had it as well. Thus why he died on impact.
@kommandantgalileo3 ай бұрын
My friends, there is fatal force, and there is that.
@ThomasSirHandel2 ай бұрын
Um, Gordon's crash from Gordon Takes a Tumble?
@brothacontext3 ай бұрын
How’d Henry survive? He fell from a higher distance then Jeffery
@SoundwaveDevastation3 ай бұрын
Bro is becoming Matpat
@ReviCat3 ай бұрын
He ran down the hill at a quick speed and ran down the pipe off the rails, the fast impact killed his crew and the force of the impact had like cracked his firebox and boiler, maybe his smokebox too. (this is just my theory) not to mention the fact he ran off the slope near the rails and then fell off
@tudorbrancuturcu59963 ай бұрын
Please do the same for the Arthur crash
@tudorbrancuturcu59963 ай бұрын
I’m sorry but i’m a 6th grader that doesn’t like physics lesson cause it’s the last lessons of the last two days so this is quite the head scratcher! I do not understand a lot of stuff in this! I can simphy Geoffrey’s death like this: Geoffrey was pulling the flying kipper for Henry, but when going down Gordon’s hill he derailed cause of a pipe coming off the track, smashing into the ground, bursting his boiler and dying. It’s way more complicated, yes, but i’m only 12 and I don’t understand much!
@southerncoastproductions75872 ай бұрын
go away. ur so annoying.
@jaanshersaeed45413 ай бұрын
I wonder how Henry survived though, could’ve been since he wasn’t going down a steep hill while on the tracks and even the slope he went down while derailing wasn’t that steep plus he also likely wasn’t going that fast (I can’t do math to save my life but I’m getting a general idea from what we’ve seen visually). Though the fact his crew and guard getting killed was glossed over though and not brought up, wonder how he reacted once his repairs were done
@fanofeverything304653 ай бұрын
Maybe we'll see in Recovery
@ImNotnaloN3 ай бұрын
Hell what about JAMES?! (On his first day specifically.)
@fanofeverything304653 ай бұрын
@@ImNotnaloN James wasn't going downhill
@fanofeverything304653 ай бұрын
@@ImNotnaloN James wasn't going downhill
@jaanshersaeed45413 ай бұрын
@@ImNotnaloN It wasn’t that severe though
@robertbalazslorincz82183 ай бұрын
>The "main body" A.K.A. the 'engine' >12T means it can load 12 tons (what variation of ton, long, short or metric?) of cargo Theoretically if the cargo is in long tons that gives us a max weight of 12,192 kg (yes I can't be bothered with the bullshit that is the imperial system) with a tare (empty) weight of 10,150 kg, so 22,442 kg per van assuming they're fully loaded BR Dia. 801. Insulated Fish Vans. >it's probably a little heavier than 20 tons, safe to assume 20.2 tons, so we'll assume 20,524 kg >assuming the train was heading down the hill, it would have been going about 35-39 mph. >safe to assume we do not see the entirety of the crash, just snippets of it, I would assume it took at least 25 seconds from initial impact on the pipe to Geoffrey settling on his side. >last I recall, Joule is a unit of energy, not force >Assuming Geoffrey's driver diameter is 4'8", that pipe would be about ⅔s the size? It would probably be best to use this method of calculation for when Henry crashed into the part of Donald's train that broke away.
@TheTrainTheoristOfficial3 ай бұрын
It'd be tonnes, I didn't go into specifics because the math is already a cluster fuck, I'll run these calculations to see what I get.
@oliverhood17323 ай бұрын
Is there going to be a theory on how Peter died after being diagnosed with metal fatigue.
@brentgibson81983 ай бұрын
I didn’t know about metal fatigue till Adam requested the final firing cause of it
@oliverhood17323 ай бұрын
@@brentgibson8198 Yeah.
@pendremacherald67582 ай бұрын
Goeffrey should still be alive. End of.
@TheTrainTheoristOfficial2 ай бұрын
Geoffrey is made out of componets less durable than steel.
@pendremacherald67582 ай бұрын
@@TheTrainTheoristOfficial sounds like Robinson did a skill issue.