🌟 Hey there, fellow music enthusiasts! 🌟 If you found yourself mesmerized by Dimash Kudaibergen's 'Story of One Sky' and crave more exclusive content and behind-the-scenes insights, consider joining our Patreon community! Your support not only helps sustain 'The WordSmith' channel but also grants you access to special perks and benefits.✨ 💫Let's deepen our musical journey together - join the Patreon family today and unlock a world of exclusive content! - www.patreon.com/user/membership?u=65687481

An important fact: Every three years there is the ‘Congress of the Leaders of the World and Traditional Religions’ who meet in Dimash’s home city. This Congress reports directly back to the United Nations and the final message at the end of ‘The Story of One Sky’ was a quote from the report submitted in 2019. In September 2022 Dimash was invited to perform at the ‘Seventh Congress of the Leaders of the World and Traditional Religions’ and actually premiered (singing ‘live’) ‘The Story of One Sky’ to over one hundred religious leaders at this ‘closed’ event. These leaders responded with a standing ovation and referred to ‘One Sky’ as the unofficial anthem of the event. The following day Dimash was presented to the Pope and was given a medal and received a blessing from the Grand Imam of Al-Azhar, Whamad el-Tayeb. Therefore, choosing both the quote at the end of the the MV and what he chooses to do in the ‘vocalise’ section of the song then becomes, to me anyway, more poignant and powerful. In the ‘vocalise’ there is,at the very least, the Muslim call to prayer, the Jewish shofar, the Om of Buddhism and Hinduism and the bells of the Christian church so he has woven musical references of the world’s faiths into one - WOW! Plymouth UK 🇬🇧

Dimash was the drowning boy. The general is the one who saved him. The girl in the beginning is the woman giving birth. She is the wife of Dimash's character. The child who was killed was their daughter.

I have seen hundreds of reactions of this masterpiece. Very, very few reactors have made such as in-depth and relevant analysis as you. Congratulations! From a Dear and a fan of your channel.

You could easily make one of the best , most outstanding speech writers, easily surpassing those who have spent all their lives learning to form perfect sentences ! You just naturally talk so very extremely eloquently and “accurately”, using exceptionally beautiful, elegant and precise words and such abundant use of a very wide range of vocabulary is commendable! I know this comment has nothing to do with your reaction and even your profession as a musician, but I just had to mention it! Maybe it impresses me so much more than others because English not being my first language, I automatically pay more attention to how people speak the language!🤷🏻‍♀️ peace

In The Story Of One Sky he composed and sang the whole soundtrack himself. The video shows once again that Dimash is an absolute genius. In composing, in singing but also as an actor and as a storyteller. The powerful message conveyed by this video is more relevant today than ever. I think this video is mostly about the message. This message however, is for the first time more important than his vocal abilities. His voice is just the tool in this video. But simply unbelievable. His singing is indescribable and I don’t have the words to express it adequately. That's your job😅. But it is only the mediator of what this video is about. This is so heartbreaking and sad and an awesome masterpiece. Pure goosebumps. You probably have to see it more than once to understand it. He worked on this composition for three years and also wrote the screenplay. The premiere was on September 24, 2022. As some have mentioned, this video should be seen by many people. It may be very brutal for some. But let’s not forget that for many, including children, this is everyday life in some countries. And Dimash relentlessly shows us how ugly war is. During his concerts he always tells the audience he loves all people in every country. He visited so many different counties with his concerts and he realized that there are no bad nations (only bad leaders). And OMG he is such a phenomenal actor. Dimash was the little boy who was drowning in the beginning and he gave the necklace to his childhood friend (and future leader) and the girl. The girl on the beach was his future wife. She was pregnant and in the end of the video she gave birth to her and Dimashs' (character) second child. The littel girl who was shot was Dimashs and her first daughter. When he came home and saw his daughter dead on the ground, he had to assume that his wife and unborn child were also killed. Desperation and maybe revenge has led him to kill his former friend. When I first saw the video, I was shocked. I didn't think he was going to shoot his friend. But in the end that all made sense. Dimash wanted to show what revenge can do. Violence always breeds violence, and because of this, not only is the leader dead, but so is Dimash. It was so heartbreaking to see Dimash drown at the end. Dimash in the last sequence of the video was the baby that was born and now as a grown man unites people of different nationalities and religions for peace. In this video you can see how the main religions are represented mostly with his voice. Islam with the type of Arabic melisma (unfortunately I don't know the correct explanation for this type of singing), Buddhism with the monks and the enchanting "Om", Judaism with the shofar and the Christian church with the soprano singing, which often can be heard in churches. If you want to know more about this video check out dimashnews. com By the way, Dimash has received an award from Pope Francis personally at The Congress of the Leaders of World and Traditional Religions held in Kazakhstan on September 13, 2022. He performed the song there in connection with the congress before the premiere. Can you imagine, a Muslim receiving an award from the head of the Catholic Church. How wonderful is that🥰. He also gave a speech at the first Central Asian Media Forum, in which he once again strongly advocated peace. But I#‘m afraid it i You can see it with English subtitles. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/aKllaMRk0tzKgH0.htmlsi=99iF8ltfNARzaZAn The official live version of his concert (on September 23, 2022 in front of 30,000 people from 68 different countries) is available on his channel, Almaty concert part 3 from minute 23:15 with a short speech in which he performed the song for the first time. You should definitely see this. There are subtitles in English kzfaq.info/get/bejne/j7ZhpZyo0dHReIk.html And he's been singing it in all his concerts ever since. But always a little different. Greetings and love from Germany👋❤️

Excellent analysis of Dimash’s opus. It has probably already been said, but worth repeating, that last month Dimash was appointed as a regional Goodwill Ambassador for the United Nations’ Migration Agency. They could not have selected a better person for this position.

Dimash and the English language....so many reactors get in a tangle about it. Personally, I love all his idiosynchrascies, and hope he never gets to the point of having perfect English. In foreign audiences, his English gets a bit more stretched than in English speaking audiences, and so I think he remembers more of our vowel and consonant sounds when he is surrounded by them. He learns foreign song languages using phonetics, and when he was young he would retire to his bedroom for a week with each new song. I doubt he has time for that now, so what he is presented with and how it is presented would be what we get to listen to. For someone that is so popular in so many countries, and such diversity in language types, let alone idiosynchratic tones that he tries to adjust to.....I know that he has to have the highest IQ and probably a photographic memory to achieve such a high level of success as he does, plus supernatural help and perfectionist drive and focus. But.... I hope he never loses his beautiful Dimashness and Kazakhness by raising his bar too high for those who should be Dears and should understand him better.

Wooow I've seen this MV 10000 times, but none of previous reactors has ever gone so deeply and precisely technically !! Your insights are very important for all us Dears!! Greetings from Albania 🇦🇱

Самый лучший анализ этой композиции! Очень рекомендую посмотреть живую версию. Браво Димаш!

This is the first and only reaction that does this masterpiece of Dimash justice.

In the end Dimash wants us to follow him and choose life. Turn away from the piper.

At one point Dimash sings, “We are past the moment of “Imagine” (John Lennon’s song.)”, which I see as being past Imaginig a better word and that NOW is the time to do it or else.

Amazing and in-depth reaction! I just wanted to point out that when he sings "We have passed the moment of 'Imagine'" he is referring to the Beatles song "Imagine" (think of those lyrics) and how we have now passed that moment to just imagine world peace. Thanks again for your wonderful reaction ❤❤❤

In the live concert, he immediately followed with “El Amor En Ti”. The hologram Dimashes helped him rest his vocals until the very end.

Dimash introduced this song at his Almaty Concert. It was the most powerful performance I have ever witnessed. It was overwhelming!❤😊❤

Probably why this took him around 4yrs to complete! It is so very much! But everything we need! However the 2 boys you have switched, Dimash was the one drowning in the beginning and the ending..the boy that saved him became the dictator using the symbol of their friendship as the symbol for his issues..the girl who was shot was their 1st child she had to leave her to give birth. She is the one from the beginning as well and was his wife.😢❤ One World 🌎 One Love ❤️ Peace, Love and Light to you all always ❤️ 💖

You really are a wordsmith. I could never express the emotions and feelings I have while watching TSOOS. And I like your explanation of Dimash's singing choice and skills so much. Thank you for your reaction. Love from Germany

Thank you for your reaction. PLEASE review Dimash's newest MV, "When I've Got You". I can't wait for you to see it.

Please watch the live version Almaty concert! Most actually even prefer the raw fancam version! 🙏🏻it is the most captivating masterful emotional display of an artist EVER!❤

Thanks for such detailed reaction. I highly recommend the live version from his Almaty concert where Dimash premiered this song. It’s unbelievable performance! It’s in 3rd part of the concert.

Спасибо за превосходную реакцию на лучшее, не побоюсь этого слова, произведение Димаша Кудайбергена.

I was one of the lucky people who listened to this masterpiece live at his concert in Antalya last year! It was beyond amazing! Imagine how his voice resonates with every cell in your body! ❤😊

Great reaction. Yes, please, react to the live version. It is unreal and he is exhausted at the end on his knees. You can tell he puts his soul into the performance and he is totally drained at the end.

You have done a MOST AMAZING dissection of this masterful work. As someone said, Dimash’s voice, while breathtaking, is secondary to the message he is conveying. What is so sad, is that this transpired between childhood friends. We see this happening all over the world. People have been massacred by their leaders. The people of any particular country, just want to live, care for their families, and give their children a safe place to dwell. Dimash shows the atrocities against humanity. We DO LIVE UNDER ONE SKY! We have the duty and responsibility to preserve not only our own life, but the life of our fellow humans!

The live version is even better and more emotional. You have to see it. And how into the song Dimash is. With his head, heart, body and soul. It's a fantastic performance. Never ever seen anything like it. Best regards from Norway 🇳🇴

Thank you!!! You did a spectacular job, not only with your insights but also by the way you laced them in throughout the short film.. However, there is one thing that astounds me is that very few reactors mention what a skilled actor Dimash has become. His acting abilities to me are stellar. I am the father of two grown daughters and the first time I watched the scene where Dimash realizes that his child has been brutally murdered did me in. At that moment I lost myself completely into the character, because I know that if I had been in that situation years ago I would have responded just like Dimash. There are many things I love, admire and respect about Dimash, but his ability to get totally in touch with his own truths coupled with his honesty is what i like the most. Whether singing a song or playing a part in a short film, Dimash does not "act", Dimash "becomes". All "A-level performers have this ability and it is what sets them apart from the "B-list" people. Over the seven years I have known about Dimash, I have never cried more. I have since come to realize that Dimash touches my soul, not just my heart (although the little "effer" can do that to me too lol). I apologize. I didn't mean to drone on for so long. I'll finish with this. Carl Joshua, you are excellent at what you do and I'm honored to have found you, particularly as it relates to one Dimash Qudaibergen!! Thank you.

This video makes my heart hurt. Calls to my soul. So true. Kanat A is Dimash Qudiabergen's father. A masterpiece. ❤❤❤❤

Hola!! Dimash en su gira de conciertos Stranger ha interpretado esta canción:! La primera vez la escuché en vivo en Almaty, kz y fue increíble… dio su vida en esta interpretación !!! También la escuché en Armenia y en Hong Kong donde se escuchó de manera Magistral … puedes ver su presentación de esta canción en el concierto que publicó en su página donde divide esas 4 horas de concierto en 3 videos! Gracias por tu reacción y Saludos desde Chile 🇨🇱

There are live versions you can watch which make it a lot easier to focus on his vocals; this video is so intense, it's difficult to separate the vocals from the dynamic story he's presenting to his viewers.

“For now I’m reserving comment, but I don’t like this guy.” 😂 Perfectly said with perfect tone. I have tears in my eyes, but had to laugh at that comment. 😢😂

Dimash's live performance was very cool, very powerful❤❤❤ Живое выступление Димаша было очень мощным, очень крутым!!!

Dimash new video when I’ve got you very different AMAZING 🙏

Magnificent reaction and disection of the song, probably one of the best I've watched. You do it with so much knowledge, understanding and respect towards the artist. Thank you. ❤

Thank you for dissecting this homage to live and unity! You really grasp the message in such a profound level, such a wise music and lyric analysis! Thank you so so so much!!! I enjoyed it as if I was having a delicious feast! 🫶🫶🫶🫶

Please react to the live version. He does the whole thing and it's unbelievable! It's so much more emotional than the movie because of his direct energy!

Thank you for paying special attention to the lyrics of Dimash's song this time!

You must do his live performance at the Almaty concert. He laid his entire soul on the stage 3 hours or more into the concert. Please do the version from the concert itself which he starts with a very heartfelt speech. The drone footage adds a lot as well. This was followed by El Amor En Ti with the 3 Dimashes on the 70' and 50' screens to give him a bit of a rest. People there said they were so stunned and emotional from The Story of One Sky they could hardly comprehend it being immediately followed by El Amor En Ti. This is a LOT, as you said and there is such symbolism. The metal piece is a gnomon, the vertical portion of a sundial. The hole in the center allows the light to shine through so it can be used for navigation. The piper bent his and on his uniform there is no longer a hole. He has lost his moral compass. The people in the desert represent those from all religions who have fought and given their lives for peace, including Jesus. In this section Dimash is "singing" the world's great religions. Some interpret him at the end as the boy grown up. I am convinced Dimash gave his life and joined the others, marching toward the light. It is a LOT is pretty much an understatement.

Carl, thank you for this beautiful and insightful analysis. You are wonderful!

Hellor friend! Thank you for your sincere reaction, you've got it figured out really well! When I first watched this MV, it broke me, I became very emotional, it was heart wrenching, to say the least! Have you noticed that Dimash is the main solder right from the very beginning of the war scene, when he was walking under the overpass, also when he was shot in the arm, many people miss that? Dimash has worked very hard for 3 years composing the music for this song, and around 20 days to make this MV. It turned out to be his most valuable MV, in the ideological sense, ever made, a real Masterpiece! I believe that Dimash deserves THE NOBEL PEACE PRIZE for his selfless hard work and tireless efforts, not only for this MV, but for trying to bring the world together in love, peace, and harmony and through his many charities. He is a Legend in the making and will go down in History. This is my breakdown of the story, as I see it: This mini movie is full of symbolisms, it's the story of 3 youths, and the necklace which was created by the young Dimash and shared with his friends symbolizing lifelong friendship and unity. The boys both loved the same girl, but she loved Dimash, so the other boy grew resentful over time, started a war, using the symbol of the necklace given to him by his friend Dimash, as the crest on his army uniform. 1) Dimash, was the boy drowning at the beginning and at the end. 2) The Piper, is the one who saved Dimash, became the leader, and was killed by Dimash at the end. 3) The young girl, who died in childbirth, became Dimash’s future wife, had two children together; a daughter who was killed by the Piper's army; and the birth of a son who inherited the necklace from his mother…, they were all affected by the war. “People are the caravan…. Life is the way”: Dimash spoke these words in Kazakh, when he found his daughter dead. For the symbolic aspects, Dimash is showing the different cultures and religions (Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, Hindi, etc.), through throat singing, which is called the REQUIEM (mass for the souls of the dead), from different religions. The Pilgrim or (Shepard or a Wise Man) at the end of the video was Dimash’s baby boy, born in his image and grows up to guide the Representatives of different religions and race from different Nations to the light, for a new beginning living together in peace, tolerance, love, and harmony. I’M CHOSING LIFE!! 🙏🙏 See you in your next reaction. Love from Canada 💖

Thank you very much for your indepth analysis and comments on this masterpiece that Dimash brought to us. Many blessings, have a great day! ♥️👍🎵🎶🙏🖖

Thanks for your reaction. Such emotional video.

Wonderful reaction! Can’t wait to watch the live version with you! ❤

Thank you ❤!

I think he’s done it live twice after that scream he literally collapses on the stage Some say the first time he did it live he only sang parts live but I don’t see it. The second time is definitely all live and I find it a little different but still intense. Dimash very rarely sings the same song the same way Which as dears we love not knowing what we will get but always amazing

I enjoyed your astonishing reaction sooooo much 😂❤ This is a masterpiece. Imagine experiencing it live... It is overwhelming and unique. Thanks again for such a respectful and caring analysis.❤❤ Greetings from GREECE 🇬🇷

This is a movie video that needs the story line to be seen. Both the music and acting is incredible, this this masterpiece was meant to give everyone a very important message that could be lost if not paid attention to. Please do watch it again after interpreting the lyrics and music. You will not be sorry you did, Sir. Trying to soak in both all at the same time can be very overwhelming. What a wonderful reaction and review you gave. This should be seen many times by everyone.

best reaction I've seen so far about The story of One sky. Your analysis of the meaning of the song is so deep and show your sensitiveness, and your language is so accurate... really amazing!! I hope to see other reaction from you about Dimash and not only 🙂greetings from Italy

I love your reactions ! Going to watch first, then comment. Wait until you hear/see his new song. When I’ve got You, unreal !! Great reaction btw, love how you explain.

The line, We have passed the time of "Imagine" is reference to John Lennon's song. I've been bawling since the dictators speech but this line really gets me

The woman dies in child birth. Now, all 3 of the original characters have died. Dimash's son, in the end, is leading all people to the light.

React to his live version plzz ❤love your reactions

Thanks for your reaction. And yes, he performed it live at the Almaty concert. Be sure to look, he is not human. He sings even better live)

I'm also struck dumb. All I can say is Thank you, thank you, thank you. I've been waiting for this. I'm incredibly impressed your insightful powers of analysis and how you get the essence first time round. Please grace the Dimash world more often!

Yes, that's Dimash. So suffering and longing for peace 💔 There is nobody like him 💜 Thank you for your appreciation 💜

osh, you have all my respect for your work, your special celebration for your subscribers couldn't be better than this masterpiece. With this video I discovered Dimash a few months ago, and I fell in love with his art. With this piece I felt a punch in my humanity, it confronted me with the question of "what am I doing in particular to save this one sky?" This young man, with the powerful images of him, the story of him, the music of him and oooh God!! That voice confronted me with that question in a forceful and beautiful way at the same time. That is the power of Dimash, he lets us enter his spirit, our own and always with that torrent of power and beauty. This analysis that Josh makes is also forceful... as you mention, Dimash deserves it. He should have much more recognition, thank you for helping to make him known more and, in the process, you enjoy it and pass it on! Thank you very much and congratulations on the growth of your channel, you also deserve all the recognition!

The Story of One Sky: A new composition by Dimash Qudaibergen September 24, 2022 6506 On September 23, the solo concert of Dimash in Almaty saw the premiere of his song “The Story of One Sky”. On September 24, at the artist’s fan meeting, the audience saw the MV to this composition for the first time. This complicated composition with a variety of music themes and tricks is a result of three years of compositional work of Dimash Qudaibergen. Today, at the Kazakh artist’s fan meeting with his fans, the audience saw the MV to this work for the first time. The film is based on a story written by Dimash, with his own screenplay. The director, Alina Veripa, told about the creation of the music video for the new song. The clip is divided into several parts. The first one is about childhood. The main character, his 2 friends, is connected by childhood stories and symbols of eternal friendship. One day, the friend saves the protagonist when he drowns. However, there is already competition in this children’s story, as the boys are in love with one girl, and she chooses one. The second experiences a kind of psychological breakdown and transfers the children’s problems into the adult world of totalitarianism and struggle. By becoming president, the antagonist carries the idea of a saving war: “Only war will lead us to peace. Only the strongest can find love in their hearts. You must be strong enough to give the world freedom. A world where every city, every home is one. We will lead all who are ready to begin this new life. Anyone who resists has no place with us. I choose freedom. The world is open before me, and I want to give it to you. War for the people is the way to unity.” The main character also speaks of unity, of peace, but through the lens of kindness and love. While fighting, he is confused. He is in shock, but he has to save his family - his pregnant wife (the very girl from his childhood) and his daughter. Once home, he is horrified by the picture of the dead and realizes that his family is also dead. After surviving this drama, he moves on to the antagonist to seek revenge. However, the Protagonist’s wife survives with the help of people who know that she is the one who must give birth to a special boy who can save the world. These are people of different nationalities and faiths who have united for peace. A parallel line of pilgrims are people of different religions, walking the hard path to some place of power where they could unite and discover the Heavenly Eye that would illuminate the world. By uniting, they create a common energy in which the protagonist’s son is born, as Hope and Faith for the Better. Their journey is a symbol of faith in general because it always goes through trials. When we go to the truth, we go through certain lessons, and our way to God is difficult, but it is only possible if we come together. This clip is not about waru’s about peace. War here is a means of expressing the contrast of what happens when we lose love for one another. It is about the call to unite, to stop dividing each other along national, social, and religious lines in order to preserve life, love, friendship, and the land for our children. Dimash sings this live at all his recent concerts. He sang it at the concert in Dubai, just a few days after the death of his beloved grandfather who raised him. It was too much for him, and he sang it quite subdued. You missed the fact that the little girl in the passage was shot. She was Dimash's daughter. The baby boy his wife delivered grew up to lead the pilgrims to the light ❤ you have the two boys mixed up, Dimash is the boy who was saved and who married the girl later, and they had 2 children. The taller boy who saves Dimash's character became the dictator. All this because he lost the girl!

Me encantó tu análisis, reacción y principalmente la interpretación del videoclip. Coincido totalmente con el análisis del mensaje que has hecho y te agradezco por poner en palabras tan claras lo que yo no podía expresar. Gracias

Me encanta tu reacción. De las mejores que he visto. Como siempre Dimash maravilloso. Y esta canción una obra maestra. Saludos desde España

Por fin Carl reaccionaste a esta gran obra maestra de Dimash!!! gracias por tu gran análisis! Dimash es miembro de la resistencia a su amigo que se convirtió en un dictador (al principio del video, en la infancia, se ve que el amigo estaba enamorado de la niña, pero ésta lo rechaza porque a ella le gustaba Dimash, por eso se nota tensión en el niño cuando Dimash le regala el collar) Dimash al ver que mataron a su hija, y piensa que también a su mujer embarazada, toma la decisión de matar a su ex amigo, eso el video lo muestra como algo que no está bien (el cielo se vuelve tormentoso y ventoso) El bebé que nace, rodeado de personas que rezan, se convierte en un salvador que une a todas las religiones y las guía a un mundo de paz. Abrazo desde Argentina

I got chills several times.The best break down of this song I have seen.Very important ❤

Love your excellent explanation. ❤😊❤

Very much the wordsmith.

Thanks for a very profound and knowlegeble reaktion. I agree with your interpretation of the story, bur i dont Think dimash kills the diktator for revenge but because he wants to stop the diktator from more warring. I dont think Dimash do in revenge. Greetings from Danmark. I subscribed.

We aren't rushing you thru this masterpiece 😮. Take your time, we are here for it ❤❤❤❤❤!

You are an amazing reactor. You cover all the bases/ notes!!! Thank you. 🇺🇸

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🎉 Brilliant and wonderful analisis to hear in your lovely english ! It only confirms what most Dears know already, Dimash is even better than what we thought, he Keeps breaking the limits! A Masterpiece with an even greater message 🙌 Like Picaso painting the horrors of war in Gernika, Dimash's art transcents all boundaries and sends a message for the World to wake up ❤❤❤

Exellent reaction to Dimash's work(both mussical and vocal) Отличная реакция и разбор произведения Димаша(как музыкального, так и вокального)

Thanks for all the work you put into this lovely and lengthy video. It was so nice to have a reaction that didn't rush through things but actually took the time to look at the video in so much detail. 🇨🇦

Спасибо за реакцию!!! Посмотрите пожалуйста концертную версию, уверенна, что вам понравится

Your reaction and in-depth analysis and how eloquently you spoke, even though at times you were at a lost for words, is very much appreciated and I find it very enjoyable and insightful. Thank you, Carl. This was Dimash’s baby sort of speak. He worked on it for 3 years. It’s his tour de force. He pour his heart and soul and money into this epic project to get the message of peace and choosing life to the world. Yes there is a live performance at his Almaty concert and he gave his ALL. Must see. ❤

The best reaction and analysis❤

Gracias por tu hermosa y completa reacción a esta obra de arte, Llore todo el video, pase por todos los estados de ánimo Desde la pena, tristeza, llanto, rabia, rencor, impotencia, indignacion,frustración ,etc. Decir que Dimash es mágico, es pura Genialidad!!! Un prodigio de la música!!! Espero que este mismo tema lo hagas en VIVO en Almaty Concert. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏Te volverás a emocionar.😢 Saludos de Ninoska una Dears Chilena 🇨🇱 que ama ❤ y admira mucho a Dimash bendiciones 🙏🙏

❤❤❤ you are a wordsmith. this is definitely the most indepth and detailed reaction of this amazing MV, other than getting the two boys backwards, which I also did initially, to see and get so much out the video in first watch is pretty impressive. I was in Almaty and saw this live in 2022, and have seen it live in subsequent concerts, you should definitely check out the live performance, the Almaty one probably the best since it was his first performance in a live concert (other than performing for the pope early that month in Kazakhstan at the meeting of world religious leaders, but the MV was premiered the day after the Almaty concert), probably the fancam version by Vietnamese dears.It is hard not to cry at this song every time. There is a lot of movie making to talk about for this MV, and the symbolisms throughout, this is a DEEP MV. And I do believe Dimash showed all his vocal abilities up to that time in this song. And his acting, super too. Thank you for your reaction, ❤

I really enjoyed your excellent analysis! Thank you!

Even if you don't react to it, please watch his live version. It's incredible and impactful. After seeing the live, I don't watch the music video anymore, except it's you so I'll watch because I know I'll learn something listening to your reaction. Excellent you just said you might do a reaction to the live. I'd definitely watch that too.

This is the most detailed and convincing analysis! Thanks!

Dimash is a genius ❤❤❤

Masterpiece! Everything Dimash does is amazing! ❤

Grat for 5K! I follow you since SOS, so I can predict that when you reach 10K, we will be lucky to see your left ear and arm in the screen. For you are as humbled as the grandfather of Woody Allen, who's cartridge with his coffin was following the people to the cemetery😅. You move out more and more, for you don't want to disturb your viewers with your face.😊

What I see the most in this is the absolute senseless destruction of war. 3 children friends, happy, carefree and in the end both boys are dead, one even - driven by pain and loss - killing the one who once saved his life and while the girl survives, her life is in ruins - she lost her home, her husband, her daughter and yes, a former good friend. You could see how Dimash's character simply gives up after shooting his former friend, he is completely broken, he lost his child and must believe his wife and unborn child are probably dead as well. He is not trying to run or to fight, he just stands there waiting for the guards to kill him too. In a war even the winner looses so much, everyone looses... but we still did not learned the lesson apparently.

I haven't read the comments on this but from what i understand the "shares" are not only commercialism it's also how digital everyone has become... Very rarely are people getting together physically they're just "sharing" on Facebook and Twitter...

Thank you for the lovely and interesting reaction. Please, react to Dimash’s live version, too.

This was epic! 😊❤ I don’t think I can add anything. You said it all and I loved every minute of it! 😊 (Except: I think Dimash was the kid that drowned) Great decision to celebrate your 5000 subscribers milestone with a reaction to Dimash. ❤ This should become a tradition! 😉

Dimash was the one saved.

Very emotional ❤❤❤Amazing! Love this song and MV.

Gracias por tan interesante análisis, eres de los mejores reactores, abrazo desde Argentina

You need to see this live

Happy to see you back Carl. 😚 Can't wait for your reaction to his live performance of this masterpiece. This story carries so much meaning especially right now with these senseless wars and death.

Wordsmith: Dimash has pulled out all his tools Dimash: hold my beer

Congratulations to getting to 5K subscribers.

A lot of children look like their parents 😊❤!

👏👏👏👏👏🤗

Very intense, powerful, emotional, upsetting........

Una obra maestra de un artista extraordinario. Felicitaciones por tu reacción y comentarios. Me alegra también que crezcas en suscriptores. Saludos desde Argentina 🇦🇷

Great analysis. There are four areas to study here. The story, the analysis of vocals and the emotion that is fescribe by all his musical tools. 😊

Ох, какой же интересный и подробный разбор! Давно не сталкивалась с таким качественным анализом. Спасибо

❤️❤️❤️ LIVE 🙏🙏🙏 PEACE 🫂💞🫂💞🫂 UNITY

What an intelligent and thoughtful analysis! THANK YOU! This is a masterpiece!

Si, es el mensaje más potente, poderoso y real a través de la música. Gracias por tu reacción 🎷🎻🎺🇪🇸