1 director is needed

1 director n 1 composer

Whoever criticising they are jealous of this program

They'll go backrupt it they get all 3on one stage for every week 😂 . All of them are highly paid

@@denmaths9245 hm bhai Saregama pa se koi jealous nahin hota ... Isliye 25 years se chal raha hai Aur sahi winners bhi banae hai Indian idol ne bhi ache winners banae Aur woh aaj bhi acha gaate hai Vipul mehta (season 6) Kya mast gaata hai live Par unko yeh industry kaam kyun nahin deti pata nahin

Not good acting....over acting 😀

Overacting by nehi didi

Anu Malik or Neha Kakkar?? 😂😂😂

@@vinitbabariya7294 bhai... Uske kitna bhi Mazak.. Udalo.. Aur wo baatein bhi wesa hi karte Hai... Per.. Abu Malik ki bahot sare achhhe composition Hai bhai....

Yes , and that too in shedding crocodile tears..

And tthe shitty comedy that they do on the show

S U BOTH SAID 100% ACCURATE. 👌👏👍

Shweta mohan also

Of course but Monali,palak are also good

@@truthalwaystriumph yes Monali too

Chitra ji alsoo

There are so many good singers other than sunidhi ,Shreya....in the industry...they might best singers in bollywood. But not the india wide singers... we have Chitra, sunitha, janaki,sailaja...and the list goes on...in south India....

Indian Idol chooses mediocre singer like Neha Kakkar to judge the show. What a pity..

@@jaishreebyerugjee2285 true

Yup

Javed Ali

Yes because they all ,i think, refused to praise the contestants unnecessarily

Absolutely right we waited for the next season before but now like aya gaya pata bhi nh chlti

@@durgagupta05 exactly

@@professorelixir3351 today everything is about glamour, I mean talent isnt even necessary now a days, sing as u like, nd then 200hours of editing, and a new song is out. I donot even call them songs! They r basically some rhyming lines said aloud in a particular rhythm. There is no singing, I hate the fact that I have to live in such a generation where there is noooo more song, raag, taal, murkiyan, no more talking about thaat. Why!

@@professorelixir3351 some, some! The number of such songs r soo less, that when u find semi-classical songs today, u jst gulp it, its so rare! U dont even get a chance to critisize any of those songs, or choose between them, bcz they r so rare now.

@@sarbanimukherjee_Yesofficer I wont agree with you here. If you want to listen to raag, classical stuffs, obviously u ll get few. Songs like Laal ishq, aayat, Ab ke sawan, Ek dil hai, baithi hai etc.. are perfect examples of songs with semi classical approach in them. Yeah, i agree that the number of such songs has reduced dramatically but we get a few in between. As long as directors like ARRehman, Shankar mahadevan, Amit Trivedi, and singers like Arijit, Shreya, etc.. are there in the industry , we ll get such songs... About the current fast beat, hip hop , rapp songs, its trending now, so, obviously, songs of such kinds would be produced more...

Absolutely

These days reality show are just for entertainment and not actual competition 🤷🏻‍♀️

Neha Kakkar is the right person to reply on this bro... 😂😀😛

people also responsible for this mess, look neha kakkar has highest follower on SM, i dont even consider her a singer

@@snehal7001 fake. Hai 🤣

javed ali was also good

Very true..honest judges hai dono..unko accha nahi lagta to wo bol dete hai samne...jutha praise nahi dete kisi ko show me bhi

Tell me on singer name whome they promoted! Nobody! They only think about themselves.

@@anjumanarakhan5263 How will they promote, they are not composers 😑. Still Rakesh from II5 is still part of Sunidhi's concerts. Divyansh, and so many people she invites them to tour with her Fyi.

@@anjumanarakhan5263 promotion is not their job it's about judging accurately

Very true. Contestants those days really had tough competition. The different rounds were judged very stringently. Today, we do see very good fresh talented participants, but the judges sound so fake. Their reaction to every singer is "arre baap re! This is the most sensational talent the world has ever come across. Out of the world, outstanding, kya baat hai, blablabla" ... Same for almost every performer out there. In fact, my question is, why are the judges sitting there at all, if all they are doing is aahaaing and ohoing and crying everytime a "pyari ma" song is sung?

@@sujadutta haha, the way you wrote aahaaing ohoing made me 😃😃 Thank you 😅🤗🔆

@@tintintintin576 thanks for liking my comment. These shows are getting very bad nowadays.

Very true

That's true that's why some singing stars are born but not today's shows

So true they are shown like they are already ready to sing in bollywood 😂

I think we should stop these shows boycott them all these innocent children are used for them self and they put them to sale drugs and they use them for child trafficking We need to stop all shows boycott

@Learn each day they will not 🤣

@@Azx12345 vishal says Woh contestant gaate hi waisa hai Ki hum unke per chune ke liye majboor ho jaate hai TRUTH :Indian idol contestants are caught lipsyncing the dubbed performances And in this year 's final too I have seen some parts,.in that anu malik tribute, except sree Rama Most lipsynced

@@swadeshswadesh2904 emotional janta hai apni aur woh show dekhna wala age group bhi 40-60 wala hai

Kavita Krisnamurti. Such superb voice. Just disappeared. By now, I'm not surprised. Sad.

@@johnparbhu5128 she left professional singing after her marriage. So it by choice

@@abhyudayas2342 Ok bro. Thank u. Stay safe & blessed. 🙏

000 00

Nah Shreya is still getting enough songs. KK has become so selective, and his prime is gone as well, he can't sing anymore like Dil ibadat and haan tu hai as he used to. But yeah I hope Sunidhi get more.

All are bussiness but singing is real

Indian Idol ist was only real season

why do you think so ...all contestant are singing

@@Nhusoulgamer1136 bcz there was sonu nigam ..and he never praised singers who did not sing well... In one episode he insulted rahul vaidya like how...he told him you sung worst bcz rahul did not sing well In another episode he told rahul vaidya ...this is the best singing bcz rahul sang well in that episode... He correctly judged contestants ...that is why now Bollywood is not supporting sonu nigam bcz he cant praise useless singing

@@farayui448 Is there any certified statement legal or any thing that sonu nigam donot lie or not a human....sorry if you feel bad ..time is changing if we stuck in old format no one will see the show..people want just entertainment wheather its flim ,real ,fake ...they should not get bored thats all....all judgea are good not sonu nigam ..HR is legend who have given thousands of songs..Anu malik is also genius ....but neha i think seek to be judge ...but in fact neha is super star because of fans.. And one thing the true broker are indian media ..

My favourites (People who sing, not necessarily are composers): Male - Vishal Dadlani, Arijit Singh, Shaan, Sonu Nigam, Armaan Malik, Hariharan, Udit Narayan, Kumar Sanu, Abhijeet, K.J. Yesudas, Shankar Mahadevan, Siddharth Mahadevan, KK, Mohit Chauhan Female - Sunidhi Chauhan, Shreya Ghoshal, Asha Bhosle, Lata Mangeshkar, Neeti Mohan, Shilpa Rao, Chitra, S.Janaki, Dhwani Bhanushali, Alka Yagnik

Yes in Telugu industry also the judges r worst n the only one who gives perfect judgement is spb sir

Neha kakkar just comes to try acting on indian idol because she knows that she will never be able to do singing in her life 😂

Absolutely

I have not seen her say anything except "aapne mausam badal diya". This is the only comment I have seen her give whenever I have watched Indian idol .

Ghatiyaaa neha Kakkar . Bkwas aurat .

Yessss

And Salim Sulaiman

Neeti Mohan too!!

@@gaurishashrivas6310 yes Salim Sulaiman ..both are genuine person .

@@veenamalhotra8687 thanks I forgot to mention her name . she's also good no overdramatic reaction .

@Pranay Rane thanks, forgot to mention him.

Kyu bro??

Me too ✋

I too

@@anilmural2971 Kyuki Indian Idol kam Sasural Simar Ka zyada lagne laga hai

@@shibineb 😂😂😂

No need of voting

@@shreyashtodkari908 that is also good, but again that may lead to Nepotism, so it's always good to have right balance

@@Lol-qy1dy no but if 3 different judges are there then nepotism doesn't arise and in music industry, usually judges aren't of that mentality (I'm talking about good judges)

@@shreyashtodkari908 that's true, Musicians are always true to the Music and will do fair decision.

@Just Chill I totally agree with you especially people vote based on sentiment/region/religion Mera dil ki baat kahi aapne

Right bro

Lol 😂

😂

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Cheerleaders 😂 well said

You cracked me on this 😂😂😂😂😂😂

I m not against it but cuz of it's style SAREGAMA got distroyed. SAREGAMA was a OG show and in TRP save thy too got down.

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

It always has been Sunidhi

@@manjukesh1 If I am not wrong (which I am not), her early childhood and original name was 'Nidhi'. Some music Director or Composer (I am not sure which one) changed her name later; as I learnt later. But I am sure for more than correct that her appearance during 'Meri Awaz Suno' was 'Nidhi' - give or take more than 100 percent.

@@lijumnochi8203 yes Anandji of kalyanji Anandji changed her name to sunidhi

@@manishisingh1504 Thank you for the missing piece of info.

Totally agree. Sunidhi was a pioneer when she first came onto the scene, nobody sounded like her. I used to watch some of these audition programmes but I feel like there's no creativity because everyone is expected to cover a song in exactly the same way that the original singer sang it. Right down to the same vocal inflections and adlibs. Additionally I can't think of many recent winners who have gone on to properly build successful careers in music after the show. I shouldn't be surprised but the producers keep prioritising ratings and entertainment value over actually nurturing talents.

Sunidhi Chauhan Can't do fake judging like Neha , himesh, Vishal , that's way she left indian idol. In session 5,6 sunidhi chauhan is very straight forward like sonu nigam , Acche ko Accha bolti thi aur bure ko bura . Best judge ever ❤️🙌

Exactly and the contestants should be evaluated based on singing NOT drama and fake love stories

Whenever tv is on and i watch indiam idol i see every contestant in the show god knows how will they even end the show 😂 and there's no criticising comment ever on any contestant 😂

@@Azx12345 Yeah lol I prefer the dance shows now.

It's not a show but a Sony TV Serial where judges cry, cry and cry on the poor contestants 🤪🤣🤣

Monali is good singer but neha is definitely not

@@msbisht1483 right bro..but i m talking about judging..both have not so much experience to judge any singing reality show

Both cannot technically point out mistakes at first place, how will they criticise.

Monali is very good as judge. Not every reality show can make experienced Shreya and Sunidhi as judge.

Monali is 100 times better singer than Neha Dukkar

Matlab aap ne audition diya thaa??

Mam can u tell what else they tell the contestants to do, Like we see in this season 12 of indian idol

Haan audions diye hain or Gujarat se diye the or har baari pure gujarat se select ho k gai thi. Or waha jo dekha hai uska humein. 1% bhi sach nhi dekhne ko milta. Unka selection process pehle dusre reality shows k top 40/50 contestants mein se chunna rehta hai. Mujhe sabse pehle bulaya gaya tha final round k liye. Matlab k subah 7 ka samay diya tha or main jab pahochi waha koi crew bhi nhi tha. 3 baje k aas paas Anu malik, sunidhi chauhan or salim merchant aaye venue pe. Or 2 baje aaye huye the sa re ga ma k top 50 contestants jinme pavni pandey bhi thi. Un sab ka audition pehle liya gaya or sabko select kiya gaya. Or har Ek contestant k baad judges 30/40 min ka break lete the. Ese karte huye meri baari raat k 12:30 baje aai. Us waqt un logo k mood na hone ka bahana de kar kaha k agli baar aaiyega hum khafi thak gaye hai.

Bakayda waha k contestants or crew or jo judges humara selection initial stage pe lete hai woh bhi shocked the yeh sun k . Tab ek bande ne aake puchha ki tumje kya lagta hai tumhe isse bollywood mein chance milega? Or bole ki anu malik k bhai dabbu malik k band mein mere papa dholak player hai or main khud kayi baar apne pair ghis chuka hu industry mein tab jake mujhe sa re ga ma ka top 40 banne ko mila or ab yaha select hua

Or crew ka bhi ek he kehna tha tum apne khud k album banao bahot jald KZfaq he ek platform bada platform ho jayega

Hahahaha...🤣🤣🤣🤣

Frankly speaking I don’t think Neha is a good singer , she had an nasal accent , I wonder how she became a judge . , honestly, she needs intensive training in vocals , same goes with Himesh Reshamiya too

😂😂😂😂😂

@@fatimabaig7160 I fully agree with u abt Neha kakkar .... she sounds the same in all her songs .."nasaly" and "lusty" tone...

Neha is really pure soul, n judges vaise toh sare ache h aaj k bhi, HR bhi