aight I can't be the only one who enjoys far more acnl's soundtracks over new horizon's

Wild world has to be S tier for me personally. Sunk soooo many hours into it

We're still missing the Froggy Chair in nh.

I got really burnt out with New Horizons and decided to revisit the original GameCube version. And I have to say, I was in love. The game was so wonderful to play, and it had nothing to do with nostalgia. The villagers were alive, they played sports and everything. I really think it just has such a good spark that newer games couldn't compare to.

Love the series. Definitely gotta say new leaf is my favorite.

If we had everything from New Leaf when NH was launched, I’d say New Horizons was the best. Otherwise, it’s New Leaf for me. It introduced so many core features that are just important to the series now, and the welcome amiibo update slapped. Wild World is a close second, I’d even say *that* was number one; if not for the faulting online connection and the fact I had to share my house.

Good list, I personally would have put new leaf in tier S and wild world in tier A but other than that I agree completely

It’s gotta be New Leaf, New Horizons has the potential if we get the missing content that New Leaf had at launch, like the Nintendo items, the roost, interesting furniture sets, the flower clock and maybe some more returning special villagers like Gracie, Kappn or even the mechanics from pocket camp (I can’t remember their names) and froggy chair of course

am I the only one that loves Happy Home Designer. It could have used a bit more features to make it less repetitive but as someone who likes interior design I had so much fun with it.

i've only played pocket camp and new horizons, for some reason, to someone i know, animal crossing was a way of saying "haha u suck lol u dont play actual real games" but animal crossing is pretty fresh now that i've played it. new horizons is now my second favorite game next to splatoon 2. im really glad i found animal crossing channels to help persuade me into getting the game.

The issue with ACNH is the lack of personality in the villagers. That was one think that was slowly lost as we got into later game.

Ngl city folks will always be my favorite part. The city always had this feeling to it there was more than just this.

As someone who skipped Wild World, I cannot agree that City Folk deserves anything less than an “A.”

personally, i would've given City Folk an S. like you said it's probably nostalgia, but it's the first Animal Crossing game i've ever played and i've spent hours doing nothing on it because i didn't understand how to play.

Imo it's nl It might end up being nh if it gets all/most of nl features in updates or something 🤔

The perfect game would be: - New Leaf's activities and NPCs - Gamecube's villager dialogue - New Horizons customisation and events

City Folk is my favorite. The fact that it's Wild World on Wii with remastered music + the city is super cool.

Only problem I have with NH is the hourly music just doesn’t feel like animal crossing and I would also like to not be classified as a island rep mayor sounds cooler

The soundtrack alone makes Wild World deserving of at least an A tier spot.

I like them adding stuff in regular updates, pacing gameplay like that is very in keeping with the chill vibe the game is going for and if it means developers aren’t being overworked in crunch time hell even better!

Did you know that when you smile you can’t breathe? Just kidding, hope you smiled though! 👋

Maybe not the best but wild world will always hold a special place in my heart, it was the first ac game I played and I remember being so excited to get up each morning and play

imagine waiting for 7 years for a game that has less than the half of mechanics the game before had-

New Leaf is an S tier for me, it was my childhood... Even though I was born in 2010- it’s my childhood!

The repetitive dialogue in New Horizons though

Wild world has by far the bests villagers in the series, they never run out of things to say. And that music is glorious. But I do admit that new horizons kept me engaged for longer periods of time.

I would really want to see this when NH will be out for a year.

last time i was this early we were still playing new leaf

i'm going to give it an S when we're finally getting Brewster back xD overwise i love this game. i spend my life on it. litteraly

1:07 what Tank said made me say out loud, “Wow Nintendo you really broke the fourth wall huh?”

I love City Folk but I defs agree it’s just a Wild World clone. However, I think what City Folk added is enough to just push it up into the A tier. Other than that, I agree with these ranks.

New horizons is my first animal crossing game, but I'm learning more about other games like new leaf, and thinking "Wait, that wasn't already in the series?" and realizing how much new stuff there was in new horizons

My favorite animal crossing is Mario party, I mean, amiibo festival.

I think Animal Crossing is such a hard game to rank since we all share different nostalgia with each game

I would have given City Folk a higher rank, because that's where the nostalgia hits me. Plus, it is a lot like Wild World, but it has the option for more things to do. Like patterns, hairstyles, and just little things.

New horizons is my first and im 100% in love with it, but you sold me to try out new leaf and im loving that too!

Personally, I think Let's Go To The City is the best! It's probably mainly due to the nostalgia as it was my first Animal Crossing game, but I love it!

I just can't get myself to like new horizons as much as new leaf. it just feels so half baked

CITY FOLK IS SUPERIOR ALWAYS, until we get a city in a future game, if we do... It added so many unique characters in the city! personally love it. and its not nostalgia either wild world was my first game so...

for the next game i want something similar to city folk and NL. the style of those games along with the ways they built on previous games is just amazing. A city folk remaster would be ideal

City folk is my childhood and will always be perfect in my heart!

New Horizon sure was great. But yeah, they really need to have more character interactions. After the month of July, my villagers have been saying the same things every day. Something related to their personality, what I'm wearing, what was I doing yesterday, the upcoming events. It's so frustrating. They should correct this problem in the futur updates.

My Animal crossing list: S: - A: New Leaf, New Horizons B: Wild World, Lets go to the city and Pocket Camp C: Animal Crossing (the first one; never played it only saw a let’s play), Happy Home designer D:- F: Amiibo Festival, Animal Crossing Plaza

Is it just me or did the OG animal crossing games have such a nostalgic but eerie feeling. I Remember playing Wild World a lot as a very young child and I loved it but it was also kinda eerie but in the best way possible, it was a good eerie vibe but as a child I didn’t notice too much back then. To be honest, idk if it’s the graphics but all previous AC games have that eerie feel, except new horizons.

I just think animal crossing new leaf deserves a S it’s my favorite I’ve only played 3 animal crossing because I wasn’t borb in exactly the time the first animal crossing game I’ve only played 3 animal crossing games new leaf is my favorite wild world is my second and pocket camp is my least favorite

ok, i had to go back so many times for what i heard in 9:45 sorry, but it sounds SO SIMILAR TO, uhhhhh... *you'll see*

"I know you're going to disagree with me" WELL THATS WHERE YOU ARE WRONG.

I’ve seen a lot of hate for NH online for pretty good reason but this really puts it into perspective and I love seeing people gush about this game hahahah. I’ve loved it so much honestly, and can’t wait to get even more play time out of it

New leaf will always be my favorite. I’d be so happy if the next AC game was nl with a few things from nh like placing furniture outside and paths. Ik this will never happen but 🤷🏻‍♀️

Wild world was my first game and it is SOOO nostalgic to me

I wish all the animal crossing soundtracks were in NH and could make your own list of songs to play throughout the day, and also sometimes I wish I could turn off the music just to enjoy the sound of the wind and rain. 😊 I also want the police station in NH, I miss the GameCube original police station. 😫

1- New leaf and Wild world 2- Animal crossing GC and New Horizons. 3- City folk and happy home designer. 4- Animal Crossing Plaza and Amiibo festival.

i get excited when I see a new upload from you. You're the most entertaining AC related channel

I think Let's Go To The City is easily the best game in the series. It builds upon everything Wild World did fantastically, and more-some - with a remastering of the soundtrack, especially a plethora of new content that enhanced the Wild World experience, and still maintained detailed, life-like animals

My favourite is wild world, i spent more time on that one, plus nostalgia i guess

So, this is the perspective of someone who's first animal crossing game was new horizons, and then went back and played the others afterwards. The inventory is a game changer. In ACNH you can make 50k coins in 10 minutes. In ACNL it takes 5 of those minutes just to go and sell your inventory. After experiencing ACNH's expanded inventory I cant play the old ones. It's just not very fun. If they ported New Leaf to the switch with the expanded inventory and with paths, I think that would be my favorite because the outdoor furniture is a bit overwhelming at times, but I can ignore that just because the extra inventory is so good.

I have no doubts that by January, 2021 new horizons is gonna be even more amazing than it already is. Can't wait for my brewster boi to be back

I honestly really like Pocket Camp. Sure, the villager interactions are really repetitive, and the events get old after a while. But, the events make it fun. There’s new furniture for every event which can help you customize your campsite and or cabin. It’s a pretty good time waster if you’re bored. I’ve played it while waiting 5 FREAKING HOURS for a blood draw and while I was on long road trips. I’ll probably play it a lot more in the near future…

Now.. I don’t wanna take a dump on your opinion on pocket camp but... I think pocket camp is a piece of crap that had flies all over it and then a horse stepped on it. Thank you

My first game was New Leaf so idk if my opinion is exactly valid in this tier ranking because I was only like 7 or 8 when I first heard of what Animal Crossing was lol. New Leaf has been my favorite (probably due to nostalgia) but it’s what officially got me into this game series and I can’t wait for more. Julian was on my New Leaf island and I loved him and now I have him in New Horizons ✨✨✨ I do wish that character dialogue and stuff was better in New Horizons so that’s probably why I put it lower than New Leaf. Dialogue with characters and other features was what really made me love the game so much and I couldn’t feel the same way about New Horizons because of it :( I hope they update the game at some point so every personal type sounds more unique.

7:30 and also here we are the ones who never got to play the game because it didn't reach our regions. Wiii ;c

I...really liked some mechanics introduced in happy home designer. The Best part of that game was definatly the buildings decoration. I loved it! I put my heart in every building I designer the interior of. And it gave me such a satisfaction seeing the animals be there, live their lives! Like, heck yeah I love seeing the villagers enjoy a night at the opera, or seeing them nervous for school, or at work during a meeting. I would absolutely love an updated version for The switch where yes, you can design homes, but you have loads of buildings to design too! And There are polenta of buildings they could make you design! There could be Kicks'shoe shop, the able sisters, Brewster ' s café, Gracie Grace's boutique, Leif's Plant Shop, the nooklings's shop! They could also add things, maybe related to other characters too! Like, an office where Raymond could work with other buisness-related villagers, like, the monkey with weird make - up (can't remember what's her name) could be a secretary and stuff! Maybe, you could befriend the villagers in a building you design, And then they come up with an Idea for a new building!

Personally new horizons is gonna beat out nl when some more updates come out in the future

I have a certain nostalgia for wild world I was never able to buy Nintendo products so going to my best friends house, playing on her ds and just asking villagers to meet up to then never do it because it wasn't my ds was just fun With new horizons being the first Nintendo related thing I have ever bought it adds another feeling of happiness Being able to do what I want without asking my friend while still having a certain nostalgia for specific villagers

4:06... does anybody knowing she’s getting chased... oh my literal lord..I-👁👄👁

My favorite is New Leaf. I still play it to this day (there area few badges I wanna get). New Horizons is excellent but we all know it is not complete yet. Maybe when it's complete, it will replace New Leaf as my favorite

I love new herizons but personally i love new leaf more XD

My main complaint about the later animal crossing games is the animals lack the personality depth the original has. I got called a nit wit by my neighbor, you can't get that experience in New Horizons. Less cute, more mean.

Yeahhhhh.... no way you put New Horizons on S tier. It's an alright game but so lacking at the same time... ESPECIALLY when you did this video 3 years ago lol! I respect your opinion though even though i highly disagree with it.

I would put Wild World, City Folk and New Leaf to S, PG to A and HHD to tier B Too much nostalgia:(

personally, my S tier is also NH. there’s just something about it, and i’ve spent SO many hours in it and it never gets boring. love it!

Somehow I felt the series should've leaned more on the simulation aspect (like the sims) as it went on, but it became more & more a garden-scaping tool. But I guess it worked well for them lol.

Haven’t seen the vid super excited ❤️

i only have wild world and new horizons, i like wild world but the amount of stuff you can do in new horizons is amazing. i mean we can put stuff down outside and start from scratch :)

not first not last but early, have a nice day.

happy home designer id my favorite, and i think it's actually a really good game. i can see it not being fun for people used to the formula of the original, but it's great for people like me who play sims and stardew valley for hours on end just to power through. it's not the same as the waiting and challenge of the mainline games, but it's the most accessible animal crossing game for players like me.

As a relitively new fan, I actually would have to go with New Leaf. I was really disappointed with New Horizons; New Leaf just had so much variety, and I personally found New Horizons a little lacking in that regard. I can see why so many people like it, but it just doesn't appeal to me as much unfortunetly. :/

NH is definitely my favorite out of the series, I know new leaf is a fan favorite but when I got the game when I came out I got bored and put it down, I have hundreds of hours in NH and it’s just personally my favorite

wild world is incredibly underrated

Fun fact: In Asia the first animal crossing was actually released earlier on the N64, hence why it looks much older than other GameCube games

Wild world was my intro to animal crossing. So I've got nostalgia for it. I hated being mayor in new leaf but the mini games were great. New horizons is...a work in progress.

Happy Home Designer is underrated in my opinion. The only reason the game wasn’t “challenging” was because it was a literal sandbox! Challenge is not the point, creativity is! I put hours into this game because I had so many ideas and so many items to make them a reality. I still crack my 3DS open sometimes to play it! This game was also a test run for many permanent features including the home decorating controls in New Horizons. You can use New Leaf custom designs, it added ceiling furniture, window styles, background noise, and the house requests from each villager gave them all a little much needed character! It was really relaxing and I still use Pocket Camp for a similar experience!

New leaf is my favorite. I love almost every aspect of the game. I enjoyed the public works projects, I love Isabelle, Leif, Reese, Cyrus, Luna, and Digby, I loved the sewing machine, the online play, Tortimer island, all the shops characters and upgrades, the events and so so sooo much more. I loved playing this when it came out and for the most part I really enjoyed the welcome amiibo update so it’s my favorite and an easy s with Wild world in a for being and hour taker and nostalgic. City folk it also a because it’s basically wild world I just wish they would do more with it. A for new horizons. I love new horizons and placing furniture outside and the terraforming and the fact that some of your favorite villagers will ask to move instead of in previous games were you revive a heartbreaking letter from them. But the lack of characters, shops and over all features brings it down also crafting is VERY tedious so A tier. Happy home designer was fun and decent but not a game I would come back too so b tier pocket camp also is b tier cuz it’s not the best nor something I’d typically play but I had my fun with it. AC Plaza was cool I loved Mii verse and I miss it and I liked seeing what other people had to say and I like all the little special characters and villagers that showed up so C tier. I have never played the original(or e+) but I know a bunch about it so b tier. Finally amiibo festival and easy F.

So this is probably pure coincidence but at 2:17 the one of the names on screen is Anna banana, which is an old childhood nickname. So that just kinda freaked me out and I thought I would share it, 🙂😬

I feel mildly offended because my first Animal Crossing game was Happy Home Designer

I never knew about animal crossing considering I grew up when city folk, AND new leaf came WITH a 3Ds AND a wii but from seeing my cousin playing new horizons persuaded me into buying it and now I have almost 200 hours in from just a month of having it. It’s the best game from Nintendo for me

I miss the old soundtracks 😭

For the mainline games: Animal crossing gamecube -S Animal crossing wild world- B Animal crossing city folk-B Animal cross new leaf-A Animal crossing New horizons-A The first one was a lot weirder than the others, which I love. collecting furniture sets, Nes games and special Nintendo items was on another level.

Only seen the first 10 seconds but I can tell it’s gonna be a great video Edit: Finished it

happy home designer is my s tier, i was up at 5 am trying to get a copy and i played it through twice i think,,, a fucking gem bro

I started with Wild World and man, what a beautiful game that was. City Folk was a total "meh" in my opinion. New Leaf was better than WW but it made me really miss touch controls and now that I'm playing New Horizons I can also say that it is gonna be my favorite of them all!

If they combined the customization of New Horizons with the dialogue (and NES games) from the original, it would be the perfect game.

The series itself deserves to be S tier. It is one of the best game series ever. I like every game, even Amiibo Festival.

I’ve played new leaf, happy home designer, and new horizons, (because I wasn’t alive when the first few came out) and I agree with you on these three.

i think new horizons is so underrated, people give it such a hard time but it’s generally such a good game

NEW HORIZONS TOP TIER FOREVER

i only got new horizons and it became my favorite of all times by far

Me who's just dipping my toe into the series and only has New Horizons: uhhhhh.... yes

I play new horizons now but new leaf really changed my gaming personality, I used to spend around 6 hours everyday working on my progess and trying my hardest to make a nice place to live. Before, I used to like the Call of Duty and all that stuff, but when I first played new leaf, it blew my mind. I kinda stopped playing my 3DS around 2019 and decided to focus on my switch. But new leaf will always have a place in my heart. Like if you had the same experience with new leaf :)

me right when i click the video: time to see the hate comments!