Sorry for the late upload. This video was... difficult to get up. I spent quite a while on an opening intro skit, similar to last video's and it pains me to say it all had to go in the trash. Believe me when I say I genuinely love making KZfaq videos; the whole process, writing, recording, editing etc. but with all that said, dealing with the KZfaq copyright system is hellish. Genuinely sucks up all my joy and motivation. Now if it was a claim I wouldn't mind but with a block there's nothing I can do. So in the end I just decided to cut the section entirely. As I mention in the video, all this forced me to delay the release by a day and for that, I'm sorry. But still, I hope you all enjoy this bonus video and I'll try not to let this happen in the future Edit: I hope people don’t genuinely believe I think Jeremy Fitzgerald is 2 years old.

All Jeremy's have a facial related injury. Withered bonnie is missing his face, night guard Jeremy has his frontal lobe bite, and developer Jeremy cuts of his face.

The moment you mentioned memories, I remembered that duffel bag message: "Why did you reopen? Everyone remembers what happened to those kids" Maybe this is the primary reason why Fazbear Entertainment is trying to cover the history, because it will keep repeating itself until everyone forgets it. And WOW, this theory is so different from any other I've seen, it's definitely a breath of fresh air for the theory community, thanks!

This theory feels satisfying, makes Scott look like a genius, makes a lot of things that can’t work together normally actually work together, 10/10

11:22 for the record, I cut out a WHOLE tangent here about how the 8-bit minigames are in the same dimensional plain as FNAF World and how they are the memories of certain events (if you don't know, FNAF World's hub was originally 8-bit as well before it was updated) which would've been really cool to help prove my points but it would've ruined the whole flow of the video :(

I remember hearing a theory that Baby speaking after Henry kills himself means that Henry made Baby. If so then this might explain so much Why William Kills Charlie. I know there is the Blueprints. But it’s possible That William might’ve stole these Blueprints and made The Funtimes programmed to kidnap sometime after for his experiments.

11:25 spoiler warning for when the new book that got leaked: you know you are possessed if you get dreams that are not dreams but they are memories of somebody else

This makes Scott look like an absolute genius

I absolutely love this for one reason, I have found evidence for this but you have put made better points then what I did before. In Ruin we see "Forever and Ever" spray paint alot mainly in chapter 1. After beating Ruin my save data for SB had gotten reset so I played it again. I then came across Michael's room in SB and "Freddy and Friend's on Tour's theme is playing, and the big part this song keeps repeating Forever and ever and is named after it. This then sent me on a hunt for more and the more I play the more I find. What I'll end on here is the one that sticks out the most is graffiti which says "FOREVER AND EVER, THEY ARE STILL HERE" and once I saw that it made me think the same exact thing you mentioned in this video. Also I think it wouldn't be called memory and just be agony, it would mean the same thing but would make more sense for fnaf lore as memory is never mentioned.

There is something you didn't mention, but which actually supports your theory. FFPS presents several processes that you can receive. One of them is precisely a bite that happened to a child. Another process also refers to the frontal lobe. And the pizzeria in FNAF 6 is Fredbear's Family Diner, where a child (Crying Child, precisely) was bitten by a robot. These processes are not canonical, but it is interesting to think that, even in something "non-canonical", these memories are destined to happen. Good video.

Your argument actually matches my multiverse theory(not spatial but a temporal multiversal of countless timelines going on) anchored on Freddy's and spiralling into itself (which is why so many things repeat because of this spiral

oh frfr lots of repeated events, id say personally its a memory/agony influencing things, spirits lingering, a curse, or people enforcing it and making it so (ex: children repeatedly go missing because william repeatedly is a killer)

14:29 This could also explain Why the Nightmarrione Plushies are there, A Endless loop of memory.

Asides from the basic meaning of reincarnation, especially given the repeated names, it almost sounds like a location that is simply cursed. Cursed by the immense amount of agony caused by a great amount of pain (and maybe even regret) during a specific event. Said curse dooming the same tragedies to repeat over and over again.

reminds me of Cannon events from into the spiderverse and ley lines from genshin impact. cannon events are things that repeatedly happen throughout different multiverses. Ley lines from genshin impact are memories that infect time in a certain space which can distort or change the events in that point in space.

I’ve always asked myself why isn’t these haunted/possessed events only happening at Freddy’s instead of all over the world, and why do they keep building at the same location. Maybe the actual location is cursed or something, and that location is the reason these special events can happen.

I'm a big FNaF fan and an even bigger, life long Doctor Who fan and I have to say it's cool to see others with those same interests. I've come across quite a few other individuals now who incidentally like Dr Who as well as FNaF; an odd mix but I love them both. Maybe it helps being a Dr Who fan and being able to understand and comprehend all these convoluted timelines and plot points. Seems us Whovians are drawn to stories like that like moths to flames lol. Love this theory and is very thought provoking; looking forward to the next part!

The moment you mentioned thick long B&W wires going all around the pizzeria, I got reminded of an ancient theory from the times of SL about Ennard being EVERYWHERE, in EVERY location of previous games because of the similar wires his body consists of.

Im incredibly late, but here's a possible extra nugget for your theory: the phantoms are burned, despite the fnaf 3 fire not having happned yet, implying there could have been a fire before. Not confirmed, but still. Great vid!

Fun fact: if your device sucks and has low memory, the story of fnaf will stop it's loop, meaning that memory is indeed what's keeping this story going.

Adding on the the Jeremy Theory: Jeremy stuffed in Withered Bonnie is missing his face Jeremy The Guard was bitten in the frontal lobe of his face ( I believe it was him who got bit) Jeremy the Game Tester cut off his face Coincidence? I THINK NOT

Thx for the shout out mate, can't wait to possibly help you in the future 😊

I've been talking about reincarnation since S.B came out!

One of the best theories I’ve ever seen fr. I’m open to ideas but this seem legit (for now at least) Keep up man 🎉

I'm still happy every time I see a person who both does a doctor who and fnaf just like me every time I see these. I feel like I'm not the only one who likes both

Stranger in the internet, your theory is fucking insane, however i actually fucking love the ideas, themes and concepts that tie into a shell of the story! While i dont really believe this IS whats happening in the fnaf story, not that really matters since this is already a really compelling concept, like i am totally pocketing the whole "repetition by memories" idea and putting it in my own fanworks. Anyhow i really like your take on this whole fnaf thing and i would love to hear more! Keep it up dude!

This could actually be argued. In Fnaf World Update 2, Jack o Bonnie mentions to come from the Fnaf 4 Halloween DLC but he was transported to the backstage in Fnaf World, his code now being used by Desk Man to create more of his Mini-games. With FnaF 57 being Freddy in Space, we learn about the concept of code being a real concept and something even our real world fnaf is working with here, code exists in simulations and video games but codes can also exist in nearly all aspects of reality, with the exception of animdude, who sees the game as completely imaginary, the characters, creations are not real to animdude, yet he was still beaten in his own little world and dethroned, no longer having creative freedom. in fnaf world's universe end ending, we see that when two fredbears come into close enough contact, they self-destruct along with the universe, this being orchestrated by animdude who literally isn't affected by this universal law when we use a playable animdude to fight the boss animdude. the thing is, this references the real idea of a real life concept known as "pauli exclusion principle" where that no two electrons in the same atom can have identical values for all of their quantum numbers. in other words, no more than two electrons can occupy the same orbital. we know that fnaf uses real world concepts as a basis for reality for the majority as scott himself states that fnaf is completely grounded in real world science, which leads to a whole rabbit hole which i am getting people to research on, this includes all scientific and mathematical theory that can be applied. fnaf world leads to more interesting gateways into the lore than you may even think.

Yep. The books are indeed canon. But, they are also not designed to answer questions for the games. Which IMO is a strike against reincarnation theory. They take place in the same world, at different parts in time. And FNAF World is indeed very important.

been subbed since the first fnaf video and i love all your videos (not just fnaf) 🐣

I agree that there are themes of repeated memories, but reincarnation isn't a part of it, its an echo enforced to the best aproximation in the area, Nightmarrione isnt canon in UCN, it only became canon in Help Wanted, as Ruin tells us that its "from that old Headset game" its implied to be Gregory what created it. Also im sorry but glitchtrap and burntrap arent afton, the echo as i propose is for aproximations. Afton was gone, which led up to corporate greed causing the mimic1 ai to become him, its fate, but not literally afton, its just that at some point, a killer using rabbit imagery will appear, thats why Glitchtrap needed to create Vanny to fully fullfil that. This obviously wouldn't be something the characters are planning for to repeat, it just does.

Nice theory man 👍

Oh boy can’t wait for people to say “Scott said that Fnaf World isn’t cannon” no he didn’t he said that he regrets making it cannon.

A Doctor Who/ fnaf channel is the perfect blend of my interests 😂

You just got a sub sir, I've been wondering about this for so long but i was wrong about the who because i thought these memories were from William's but it turns out are from Baby's

Duuuuude ive been talking about this for months on my twitter everyone told me i was wroonngg i agree with this completly its very neatly packed together and the story all fits as well as the books legendary theory and i have some images to back some of your claims on my twitter its under this name

I know I'm quite late, but that was a very interesting theory. I also have a few theories regarding the significance of the box, of putting things back together, concealing things and the FFPS fire. They also tie into some phenomenology stuff. In short, the FNAF lore is also symbolic of how hiding and concealing things away rather than actually properly confronting them does not make those things cease to exist, which eventually causes them to "errupt", to come back worse than before. Examples of this include the kids' souls haunting the animatronics, William (supposedly) always coming back etc. It is only after the FFPS fire, when the horrors of the past (in our case, the relevant characters) have been properly confronted that the dust finally settles (at least not taking into consideration anything after FFPS or UCN). If you're interested in more, you can tell me. Anyways, KUDOS!

I know this is a fnaf video but I'm just gonna say it: Class is great and I'm still salty that it didn't get another series after THAT ending

@9:45 ..and a face that gets cut off 😮 I can't help but wonder, whatever keeps these cycles going, are we ever going to stop it? Or cure it? I mean, is it the big bad? Where does this story end, if it ever does !

Hmm been watching Funaff’s theories, and now this idea keeps repeating in my mind but what if desk guy from fnaf world is our Edwin character. That Fazbear entertainment, more specifically Afton robotics, buys out Edwin’s small company and he makes the mimic line and other inventions, including the invention of Eleanor/Baby. It needs more research and planning but I think it’s a good starting point

i think you could very well be right about this. From my perspective it's either this or the robot kid theory. But considering we have characters like Vanessa which share direct connections to Elizabeth but are even less likely to be robots than say Gregory and Cassie, I'd say I'm leaning towards this theory. My one nitpick is that Cassie shares far more similarities with Charlie than Cassidy the Vengeful Spirit (Don't mean to plug but if you are curious about what those are, I made a video on it). So if she is a reincarnation of anyone it's definitely Charlie.

What are the doctor who lore implications though?

I do agree to the majority of this theory and video in general, mainly i feel some of the evidence is a bit loose, like the majority of connections to the past events, and that if they are reincarnations then wouldn't it make sense for them to be around the same age as Vanessa is easily in her late 20s or early 30s meaning she would have to of been born at the very least 8-10 years before when FNAF 3 and 6 take place while Gregory is 12 meaning he would of been born/made around the time of FNAF 3 and 6. Michael can still be very much alive as well (despite it being from a deleted message in a game where they basically gave up with adding lore to) and if he did die he would of been at least in his 60s during FNAF 3 and 6 and we can safely say he is in Glamrock Freddy. Despite this, everything else was awesome and i saw alot of stuff i may need to take into account for when i get my FNAF theory mojo back.

This theory is so bizarre but so interesting at the same time.

this is the best theory i heard in ages 10/10

Nice theory

William Afton took "I always come back" a lil too serious

The mangle is in fnaf 4(in the 2nd bedroom) so maybe mangle is stuck on repeat with the 911 phone call that happened back in 1983. It’s possible that mangle got possessed some near time after crying child’s death which may have been what caused the looping 911 call. Mangle would be possessed because(and I’m going into matpat territory I think) William was experimenting with remnant since his child recently died and saw that it caused Fredbear to come to life so decided to kill susies(I think it’s susie, the one in the maze game from FFPS) dog and put it in the mangle. TL;DR mangle is in fnaf 4 meaning the 911 call may be from 1983 and happened because mangle is possessed by susie’s dog from afton experimentation of remnant which he started because his son recently died. I hope whoever reads this understands what I mean

3:18 you got this part wrong,b7-2 is in sister location and scott showed it in the breaker room sl bit and more evidence

This is not dr who , wait you have other interests than the great dr. Jk glad you are branching out

I... i had a similar theory i had. But it instead was this... William Afton was reincarnated... and is Cassie's dad, no one else was reincarnated in my theory that i had but it could still happen. And its because Cassie's dad likes Bonnie

Can we get a midnight motorist theory from you anytime soon⁉️👀

I think this is very unlikely but I like this take

hello i'd like to ask why a lot of ur videos are unlisted?

W theory

This theory works with history repeats itself theory I made

Multiverse

Haha this title, sounds crazy

Ok. I haven't finished the video. But you said William was Glitchtrap and Cassidy was the Puppet... if Cassidy was an editing mistake. Thats fine. But for Afton... ehhhh, its kinda been disproven

Bro think he pepe silvia

I like your speech impediment

Vanny kan't be Elizzhe'z 2 ugly 2 b.

second

Glitchtrap is not william afton, but a mimic.

I am popular!