I take a look back at the Hobbit trilogy, and talk about what works and doesn't work about each film. My Christmas Short Film: • Charlie's Christmas - ... My Films: www.youtube.co.... Letterboxd: letterboxd.com...
Пікірлер: 55
@oranwilson29604 ай бұрын
Quality of this video is so insane for your subscriber count and how many views, keep it up bro more of this please
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
Thank you so much! That made my day. This video randomly blew up in the middle of the night, when I went to sleep yesterday it was 16 views with 0 likes lol. I have no idea what happened.
@ItsMartinez1414 ай бұрын
I hadn't even noticed it was a small channel, it definitely has the same quality as some of the bigger channels. Subbed less than halfway through the vid
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
thank you! That means a lot to me
@skrappothemonster14364 ай бұрын
The Hobbit is overhated.
@symn.26024 ай бұрын
They are pretty decent movies, it’s just super hard having to go up against and being compared to lord of the rings, which had an entirely different kind of source material.
@davemack75774 ай бұрын
@@symn.2602 True - I remember reading the Hobbit though and thinking what!? Where is Gandalf going? What's he doing? Why isn't he going with the dwarves and Bilbo? So I loved those gaps filled in!
@OldBaldWookieeАй бұрын
I was introduced to the hobbit cartoon movie first then the masterpiece trilogy
@user-yevheniia.Ай бұрын
You did a great job on this video! Wish you more followers and views!
@guillaumeinjjuz17444 ай бұрын
The hobbit trilogy is still better than prequels starwars and sequel trilogys
@yorkiboy7354 ай бұрын
I just watched this hour long video and thought you were a big commentary KZfaqr the whole time. Was shocked when i realized you had that little subscribers! The video was really good and I agree with you on almost everything you said. Nice work
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
Thank you sir! I really appreciate it! This video literally had 16 views last night and 0 likes. I wake up today and it had a significant spike in views. I’m happy, but very confused lol
@ericgardiner4212Ай бұрын
I liked the Sauron bits :D
@davemack75774 ай бұрын
18:50 - Dwarfs are tough! That's the point!
@JohnPeacekeeper4 ай бұрын
I still loved it And this is as someone who read all the source material between the Hobbit, Unfinished Tales, Silmarillion, and ROTK Appendices several times Only gripe is that Beorn shoulda offed Bolg instead of Legolas
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
Beorn is criminally underused lol
@willbyrob65824 ай бұрын
I hear there’s an edit called the MK4 Book Edit that cuts out all of the bloat, but I haven’t been able to reach it.
@chamberlyian4 ай бұрын
Don’t usually comment but just wanted to tell u you deserve way more subs crazy the quality on this. Hope ur channel grows soon!
@davemack75774 ай бұрын
The Stone Giants are in the book!
@ishrotkahn54723 ай бұрын
The Hobbit trilogy atleast felt like it was from that world. I never had a problem with it simply because aside for Tuariel all of the extra shit was taken from the appendices
@davemack75774 ай бұрын
The songs are in the book!
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
I know, I mentioned that in the video a few times actually. Thanks for the comment!
@davemack75774 ай бұрын
Richard Armitage slaying it like a Klingon!
@tangerine44264 ай бұрын
you perfectly wrapped up my feelings about these movies!!!! i also love Martin Freeman and simply enjoy watching the trilogy just to see him as bilbo!! THE WAY I SCREAMED FINDING OUT THEY LEFT OUT HIS SPEECH ABT THE WAR ANSNDNFNJF
@tangerine44264 ай бұрын
(also your video is amazing! i was so happy that you ACTUALLY analyzed it instead of doing a recap like most "analysis" commentary vids.... thank YOU sm
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
@@tangerine4426 aw thanks so much! I really appreciate it. Yeah unfortunately you have to watch the extended cut for Bilbo’s speech. There’s some good scenes in the extended cut, but there’s some bad ones, like a scene where Alfrid gets shot out of a catapult and into the mouth of a troll, and the troll crushes him with his jaw. I’m actually not kidding, that’s a real thing. I considered talking about it in the video, but it was already running long. So very similarly to the theatrical cuts, there’s good and bad in the deleted scenes lol
@tangerine44264 ай бұрын
@@StupidBeagleReviews LMAO YEAH i saw that one too, on streaming sites some hobbit movies include the extended scenes... I thought it was a fever dream honestly😭
@user-ls4wm9jj1v4 ай бұрын
Very well made video! Subscribed and waiting for more
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
Thanks so much! I have a full time job so it takes me a little while to get stuff done, but I’m trying to revitalize the channel a bit. Doing my best. I’m glad to have someone looking forward to more videos from me!
@ishrotkahn54723 ай бұрын
So what up with the Orcs, are they also Goblins? Or are Goblins Orcs...or are Goblins and Orcs 2 entirely different species? I know the Orc were tormented elflings... be is the same lore for the Goblins of the dark places ehh???
@skyo12014 ай бұрын
good
@ddess20304 ай бұрын
If anybody is interested: the 5th army are the wargs (at least in the book)
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
I think the Rankin/Bass movie they say it’s the eagles, which I guess is wrong, but it stuck in my brain so that’s why I mentioned it. Despite reading the book several times as a kid, it’s been a long time since I re-read it so I forgot a few things. Appreciate the comment!
@reimaginethesounds66944 ай бұрын
The five armies issue it's the same with the two towers, it's very subjective. Aren't the eagles or the bats another army? They play a substantial role on the battle.
@user-ec1pd4ud5n3 ай бұрын
I suggest you search for M4's fan edit.
@lovesoderpalm15554 ай бұрын
RIP kili 🙏
@Zellis6662 ай бұрын
Hey, I liked your video but I have a few notes: Tol-keen not Tolkin, Smowg not Smog. And you should have reread the book.
@StupidBeagleReviews2 ай бұрын
I have a busy life outside making these videos so it’s difficult to find time to read an entire book just for this one video. I get what you’re saying though, and that’s just how I always pronounced those names, I probably won’t break the habit even if I tried
@guillaumeinjjuz17444 ай бұрын
Nice video
@nick_trains_dogs4 ай бұрын
I love the books, but even with all the changes the lotr movies were still good. The hobbit just wasn't as good 😂
@NZealandАй бұрын
There were obviously 2 orc armies. Azog from dol guldur and bolg from mount gundabad. How could anyone not get that?
@StupidBeagleReviewsАй бұрын
@@NZealand I did get that, I just didn’t feel like listing every possible 5th army. Also, Azog’s army isn’t in the book, so I knew his army probably wasn’t the 5th army being referred to. It literally wasn’t necessary for me to bring up. Thanks for the nice comment!
@NZealandАй бұрын
@@StupidBeagleReviews but you were asking if the fifth army was the eagles or if there was suppose to be two dwarf armies as if you didn’t know
@StupidBeagleReviewsАй бұрын
@@NZealand I was making the observation that it could be confusing for audiences. The movie never makes it completely clear. I also genuinely thought the eagles were the fifth army because that’s what the cartoon says, and that stuck in my mind. I didn’t realize the cartoon was wrong until later. It’s been a while since I’ve read the book, maybe I should’ve researched that the book says “wild wolves”. Even so, it shouldn’t matter, I was just observing how the title easily could confuse people who are watching these movies without reading the book.
@davemack75774 ай бұрын
Legolas is great in this - Subtract Tauriel!
@StupidBeagleReviewsАй бұрын
@@davemack7577 I honestly thought they were both unnecessary. If Legolas had a much smaller role I would’ve been more ok with it, but it becomes obvious they gave him a big role for no reason other than fan service. He doesn’t add anything of depth to the actual story.
@andrealara9944 ай бұрын
"I tried to write a sequel..." Just say you wrote fanfic and move on, lol, joke-
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
That’s what I meant lol. You’re right, that probably would’ve been a better term to use, I just didn’t think of it.
@andrealara9944 ай бұрын
@@StupidBeagleReviews Oh and I didnt mean this to sound rude, i just thought it was funny how it was worded. Anyways, totally agree with you on Martin freemans performance which is FLAWLESS and the main reason i come back to these movies so much. I could literally watch a fan edit of the movie but its just Bilbo 24/7
@jonathanpidock30064 ай бұрын
And acid. You’d need lots and lots of acid.
@RockerT10004 ай бұрын
You never beat the hobbit game? It wasn't that hard.
@StupidBeagleReviews4 ай бұрын
I was a VERY young child. Like really really young, and therefore stupid lol. I should try going back to it one of these days.