Alan, you gotta be more careful having your blinds open in the towers of Coruscant. There could be death worms crawling behind you at this very moment.

High republic fans when the sober republic comes in

I thought there’s a lot of Jedi in the High Republic but sometimes I think during the prequel era the Jedi Order felt a lot smaller since most of them are killed left and right.

That is the best green screen window effect I’ve ever seen.

Alan is one of the few KZfaqrs that can say thought exercise and I will continue watching.

You are the last bastion of decent Star Wars channels on KZfaq. You're the only one I still regularly watch when you upload. Your analysis on this franchise is unmatched.

Your background game is on point

Small note: I don’t think Vernestra Rwoh is a Grandmaster, I think she’s a senior and respected Jedi Master, maybe even on the Council, but I don’t think there’s any evidence she’s one of the Order’s leaders. Having said that it’s not impossible either, during the High Republic Era Yoda did share the rank of Grandmaster with two other Jedi Masters.

12:20 Adding to that: Since the Jedi practice abstinence they basically don't get children. But it is known that the children of someone who is force sensitive are often strong with the force as well. So by just "collecting" those strong with the force and training them, without actually doing anything to increase the supply of new ones, they only get the ones that randomly appear. So the number "10.000" is probably the highest they can get with that strategy, and there simply aren't any more.

This is interesting, as well, because Huyang seems to indicate in Ahsoka that the training of only high m-count folks, and by implication only young children, has been happening for only “a millennium.” I suspect that at least during the Sith Wars, if not for all of history, the Jedi Order (as well as the Sith, presumably) would train basically anyone of any age group. It will be interesting to see how and why the Jedi chose to only train high m-count children. My guess is that it has something to do with the Sith discovering (rediscovering?) midichlorians and going after highly powerful-in-potential children; that the Jedi responded by trying to find,shelter, and train these kids first.

The thing about the low number of Force sensitives can partly also be attributed to the Jedi's practice of not having children or families (with a small number of exceptions). Especially when we already know that Force sensitivity is congenital (see the Skywalkers, Kanan Jarrus's son Jacen Syndulla, Rey, the Dathomirians in general, etc). The small number we see is simply the general amount of randomly occurring examples. The Jedi being the only major force using society left in the galaxy means that their practice of non-procreation has removed the natural passing along of Force capabilities on a wider scale that would be expected of any other genetic capabilities.

Quite the view of the coruscant skyline for someone who isn’t a politician.

Thanks for making this video. It would also be interesting to count given the proportion of force sensitives in a population and the total galactic population, how many force sensitives there are in average in the Galaxy

The Jedi membership was limited by their m-count requirement, I think it's 7000, but I'm not sure if that's the current canon number. During wartime in the Old Republic they didn't have that requirement which resulted in millions of low tier Jedi and Sith.

Absolutely infatuated with the background 🥹😍😍😍

Great topic. Thank you for posting!

I'm still amazed by the way you've done your backdrop! Other than that - another very informative video, Mr Senator.

Incase no one told you today, you’re goated

And then Yoda had to drop the ball....

I like your home window's view. Totally cool CP'ish / Star War'ish 🙂

It was my understanding that that 10,000 jedi quote was about knights and didn’t include Younglings/ Padawan, but could definitely include the masters!

Love the scenery from the window.

You have to remember we learned from the very stat that the force is in everyone and made by all living things... the Jedi just chose to only focus on the most natural talented individuals to make their job easier. It was the Jedi order choice to never try and improve their training system in order to drawn in well any living being.

Whoa, that thing they're working on in the military factory at 2:49 looks like some kind of miniature Imperial Walker! 😮

Can't wait for that review upload

Hi there, I just wanted to say how shocked I was when I saw Wrocław included in Alan's video 😮 have a nice day everyone ^^

Its sad to see how vernestra ended up falling after the occlusion zone. She had such promise.

Maybe another reason why the Jedi numbers were so low is because most people in the galaxy were less willing to give their kids up to a weird cult that plans on turning them into space Interpol agents.

That background is so cool😊

I love the background

*Qimir* *is* *Smilo* *Ren.* This has been leaked for a few days already but it’s only stating the obvious that we all saw coming a mile (or a smilo) away. There’s a leaked photo with the helmet off and I believe that’s Mae holding a lightsaber to give back to Qimir. I wonder how Mae reacts to Qimir since the first few episodes, she does treat him like a bumbling loser. You can see Mae talk down on him. Treats him like her clumsy sidekick. Then she will discover he was her master all this time. I already expect all the haters on the Internet to trash that reveal saying they saw that reveal coming from a mile (or a smilo) away. How the writers are so stupid making it so obvious. I would’ve preferred if Qimir was a red herring and Smilo Ren was someone we haven’t seen yet, but alas, it’s as predictable as it comes. Now is Smilo Ren/Darth Venom/Qimir the acolyte, apprentice, or the master? That Force push was pretty strong for him to only be an acolyte. As for the Star Wars fandom, is it really fandom if you truly hate it or mock it all the time? I think The Acolyte is overHATED as I don’t feel it deserves a 13% audience score. Is it really worse than The Rings of Power S1 with Galadriel acting like a Mary Sue and Karen? Is it worse than She-Hulk: Attorney of Law where the writers had no clue of She-Hulk’s origin story since they never read the comics? Did we see Mae and Osha twerking next to Aniseya? 🤣 I was reading a comment on Thor Skywalker and it was saying how grifters/extremists makes a nice profit if they’re basing their channels on hate/cancel culture. Look at The Critical Drinker and Nerdrotic full of hating if it happens to be WOKE. I think both sides are morons, the shills and the grifters/haters. The WOKE and the anti-WOKE are ruining people’s enjoyment to watch stuff. The more negative it is, the higher the clicks. Star Wars Theory who used to be about talking Star Wars. Now he’s becoming a grifter like The Critical Drinker since they do live chats all the time. While TCD needs to be careful not to always sound toxic with his reviews because he’s directing a short feature. He doesn’t want to alienate the Hollywood industry he mocks. It’s why Chris Stuckmann went completely soft and can no longer be considered a critic. He will no longer CRITICize bad movies. The haters just want to be funny. The worst the show is, the funnier these KZfaqrs will try to be. But I will say The Acolyte hasn’t lived up to my low expectations. The Boys had an Episode 4 and House of the Dragon had an Episode 2 I thoroughly enjoyed. What good episode has The Acolyte given us? Nothing. Zero. Zilch. Nada. No bueno. And I’m not sure Episode 5 is going to save it with that very predictable reveal. I say to THINK FOR YOURSELF. Form your own opinion. You never let anybody do that for you in this social media beehive mentality we live in. Don’t hate or enjoy something because someone else does it. I follow Tyrone Magnus but I don’t always agree with his opinions and he’s a Trumper like me. I think mocking movies started with How It Should Have Ended which started in 2005 before most of us started using KZfaq. Then Honest Trailers in 2012 and Pitch Meeting in 2017. Originally, Will Jordan’s KZfaq channel didn’t start off as him as “The Critical Drinker.” He found his niche once he bashed The Last Jedi in 2017 (which I think everyone did) and he’s never looked back since from that niche he found. He’s even more malicious than Siskel & Ebert from 1986-1999 until Gene Siskel’s death in 1999. But Will takes the mocking humor from Honest Trailers and Ryan George’s Pitch Meeting. Find the false logic from the movie’s story and mock the hell out of it. Since 2017, the trend of mocking Star Wars or anything bad from Disney or mainstream Hollywood began. Hating, cancel culture, anti-WOKE, and parody accounts are a good business for them. The more negative, the higher the views. Add more facepalms in those thumbnails like Unbox Therapy has done for years. Most people on the Internet want to bash someone or something, not praise them. Hate humor: that’s what they all aim for. I can understand the hatred towards The Acolyte. I saw Furiosa for the 5th time yesterday and I think it’s a modern classic. While not as great as Fury Road and maybe not as great as Mad Max 2, it’s still a helluva movie. My favorite movie of this summer so far. The pacing and action are relentless. Barely any time for quiet conversations. Furiosa is a box office flop led my a female not named Max, but I still enjoyed it. So I’m not being sexist if I think The Acolyte sucks if I enjoyed Furiosa. I think the WOKE crowd are calling viewers sexists or racists as an excuse to defend a bad product like The Acolyte. While the anti-WOKE crowd might be too extreme with their hatred but they will still watch it weekly anyway so they can generate those views when they make a video mocking it. I also think the WOKE stuff in it is why The Acolyte never got a fair shake. Was never given a chance from the start. Lesyle or should I spell it Lez-lie? Haters wanted to hate it before it ever premiered once Nerdrotic pointed out “space lesbians” after the trailers dropped. They wanted The Acolyte to fail from the start and it has. There’s excuse making from one side and then there’s overhating from the other side. I will watch Episode 5 tonight but if it sucks again like Episode 1-4 has been, I’ll stop watching it. I don’t need to waste anymore time finishing the series if I think it sucks. Favorite Movie/TV Series of the Summer 1. House of the Dragon S2 2. The Boys S4 (moved up after Ep. 4) 3. Furiosa (favorite movie of the summer) 4. Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes 5. Bad Boys: Ride or Die The Boys S4 has also got it’s share of anti-WOKE criticisms even though The Boys has always been political since S2. Audience score is at *52%* rotten. But since The Acolyte is so bad, The Boys S4 doesn’t generate as much attention for having a low audience score. I’m giving The Boys S4 about a B so far, so it’s at 85%. S4 is better than S2 but not S1 or S3. House of the Dragon S2 currently has a 92% audience score. It’s safe even with Black actors casted for white roles. Baela and Rhaena being Black and being Daemon’s daughters looks weird to me. But I digress because the production values, writing, and acting are all excellent. The same things can’t be said for The Acolyte. Is it 13% bad? No. More like 50% bad but not 13%. I give it a 6.5 which is 65% because I’m quite forgiving.

My head canon is there were considerably more Jedi, but many of them are among those who wouldn't have made the innate talent cut in the prequel era -- that as the High Republic ebbed, casualty rates increased as problems mounted, and the Order faced pressure to shrink and focus on quality, and received more Senate oversight, forcing it to keep a smaller footprint in how it interacted with regular people, and what it got involved with. Jedi doing mind tricks openly, willy nilly like on The Acolyte would eventually catch up with the Jedi Order, especially after embarrassing incidents when there was the political will for reform. Mandating subtler and rarer use of powers in most situations, with fewer numbers of overall Jedi, would also explain why even 10-15 years after the Jedi Order fell, many thought their powers were nonsense or dramatically overstated, when they're used surprisingly conspicuously -- in a way that very feels intended by the creators -- in The Acolyte. It's hard to imagine the public second guessing how 'real' the Jedi were 10-15 years later in the time of The Acolyte. It feels very much like the Order was nudged into or tried to make itself smaller literally and figuratively by the time the prequel era began, in comparison.

I believe another reason the number of jedi was around the same is during the high republic times the jedi could be more selective with those they trained, in most star wars media whenever there are times of war and such someone complains about how lax standards are for force sensitivity usually by a pureblooded sith or an old jedi.

Also keep in mind that Jedi wasn't the only order of force users in the Galaxy. Like the Dagoyan Order and the Baran Do Sages of the Kel Dor, both continue to grow in number, despite the Jedi staying at a set number. Also keep in mind the Jedi had 4 non-combatant corps Agricultural, Medical, Educational, and Exploration which we never see them. Dooku's backstory he was part of the Agricultural corp (Agri-corp) before Yoda chose him as a Padawan. That would limit their combatant number far less.

I’m honestly not even sure how to process Star Wars content that’s well researched and well reasoned and not about flame wars at this point…

Bro, you were right!

given that force sensitivity is *extremely* rare, but also *highly* heritable - there's an obvious solution to the scarcity problem. this is probably overthinking a fictional franchise that has sort of been world-built backwards and at times haphazardly... but it really is a gaping logistical plot hole. the living force maintaining some kind of (galactic? universal?) homeostasis feels a little handwavy and is hard to reconcile with the extreme heritability shown on screen.

how much was the new Coruscant apartment and are you on the upper levels?

I don't remember where, but I definitely remember reading somewhere that the Senate dictated the number of Jedi during the Prequel era. I assume it would be the same in the High Republic era.

Vernestra Rwoh (played Headland's wife Rebecca Henderson) is the Sith Lord. Smiley is the acolyte.

For those who came from the post or just don't care about anything before 11:48 there are only around 10,000 jedi left.

It makes sense that there are only around 10,000 Jedi at one time

Edit: nvm, I though you talked about the building for before. Before watching. Well... It's tell quite big. It's no small building

It’s like the US National Guard of the 90s vs the experienced hardened military branch of the 2000s

I like Coruscant outside your window.

Coruscant looks so Blade Runner styles . Cue the dystopian dialogue. Military industry spending makes no sense if you don't take enslaved workforce . They still talk about the fall of Rome . Edited bit: I forgot to add the rise and fall of Han peoples .

I don't know if it's still a canon due to... disney; but couple of pre-clone wars books and stories mentions that during the high republic era most of the planets with decent medical level made the midichlorians test on birth and then sended results of a force sensitive to a nearest jedi temple (there were more than one back than). That practice was largely abandoned due to Sith machinations around ~80 bby, and that leaded to a drastic decrease in numbers among jedi.

while you're talking about military spending in Europe, i would like to point out that 30 countries from Europe is part of NATO, and 20 of those said 30 have less than 2% of GDP spending in military, while NATO requies 2% at minimum

I love the coruscant nighttime backdrop in the background. Are they ai or green screen?

Interesting information. I assume that it would also be different numbers if the Jedi order had different standars on how powerfull theyre recruits should be with the force. Like if they could create a "Militia Jedi" or "Light Jedi" in times of crises with those individuals who usually just not made the cut. J.

I thought around the high republic the number of Jedi was around 100,000. The numbers around the Jedi number around 10,000. Inquiring

Grand master Oogway. 🤣 OMG I'm dyin!

Did Luke or Jabba have TV They seemed pretty informed. How. Come in never see grocery stores in star wars just open air markets. How sci-fi concepts don't fit in that sci-fi series

8:10 I though they were normal village guards💀

Mandalorian S1, Ep4. Time, 19:20 Something nice there.

One thing. Simon Emanuel talks about the Acolyte times. If the jedi have suffered a lot of loses to have 10 000 members than it could have already happened(I didnt read a lot of books yet but maybe the conflict with the path of the open hand did some damage and for certain with the nihil). I heard that there were 100 000 jedi in the high republic(maybe around the phase 1 high republic books)

The Mandalorian War and Jedi Civil War permanently reduced the number of Jedi in the galaxy.

Does that mean during all the sith wars, there were only 10000 force users between both factions

Alan, this canon quote by Darth Sidious may be the foundation of the Acolyte show: "Since kyber crystals are naturally attuned to the light side of the Force, those who serve the dark side must follow a different path. First, they must seize a pure crystal from the lightsaber of a Jedi they have vanquished in combat-for the saber of a Sith is not given. It is taken. Then, they must infuse that crystal with their pain, anger, and hatred, bending it to their will. This corrupts the crystal, aligning it with the dark side and making it bleed with unbridled crimson power. The bleeding process can yield unpredictable results. Some crystals shatter, making their energies unstable and unpredictable. Others resist their realignment, refusing to be bent toward the darkness. Once a crystal has been properly bled, the primal power it releases becomes not only a deadly instrument in the hands of a Sith Lord, but a symbol of their true strength in the dark side." ―Darth Sidious Maybe "The Acolyte" describes the pool of potential recruits for the position of Sith Apprentice. The Sith Master keeps this pool of acolytes to ensure a high quality apprentice. We all know the Sith Master can be replaced by the Apprentice at some point when their skill gets high enough but the Apprentice can also be replaced if they're weak or if a more suitable acolyte can push them out of the position. Since an acolyte isn't a Sith yet it doesn't violate the rule of two. Maybe one of the criteria in moving up in rank is passing the test of obtaining a lightsaber from a Jedi. Notice how Mae keeps trying to grab the lightsaber when she's in combat with Indara and Sol. Then they have to bleed the crystal which means doing more Sith things as mentioned by Sidious in the quote. So maybe Qimir and Mae are both in the acolyte pool of potential recruits. A pool of people that the Sith Master "collects". The Sith, if it is one, who arrives to fight the 8 Jedi might be the Master, the Apprentice, or even an exceptional acolyte who already started the process of getting a lightsaber. The reason Mae is after the particular Jedi she targets is because she has to invoke her "pain, anger, and hatred" and pour it into the crystal in the crystal bleeding process.

2,000 younglings… damn Anakin had a lot of work 😦

I don't think Master Rowe is a grand master, unless that was stated somewhere. According to the high republic comics Yoda and 2 other masters were given the rank of GM in like 230BBY onwards, so Yoda would atleast be one of those as of the Acolyte show, again maybe I'm missing something that Alan knows that I don't but i thought i'd point it out

Alan! How much did you pay for that Coruscant apartment?

I think reformation set up weakness that end up with clone wars. Since republic lack central military the Jedi become the military force. it why the Jedi got trap in the clone wares. also count dooku was also bait. Become once it found out he was a Sith it would be very hard for Jedi to stay out of it.

I actually really like the way they design the Jedi Temple with less building compared to when we see it in the Phantom Menace a hundred years later?

Vernestra Rwoh isnt the grand master that would be yoda, its only 100 years before the phantom menace

100 quadrillion people in the galaxy, wow! Some math shows that with 10,000 Jedi that's 1 Jedi for every 10 trillion galactic citizens. Or roughly 1 Jedi for every 1200 Earth-sized planets.

The low number could be due (in many parts) to a prolonged knock-on effect from the sith wars. Its possible yhat the jedi were once far more open to who they traind (age, level of force connectivness etc.), so long as thr force guided them to the order (i mean, why argue with the force?). But then the splintering off of, and the subsequent wars with thr sith changed their priorities - suddenly spending a lot of time to 1-on-1 training of someone who has as much force sesitivity as a sea sponge, but who trully believes in the jedi belifes (and who could one day achieve thr rank and skill of a frand master) was seen as wasteful as the jedi needed knights on the battlefield asap. So they focussed on M-count to fast track training. As they were fast tracking they couldnt depend on individuals with above normal to hig M-counts to come to the order "by the will of the force" (especially with a plethora of other force relgions spread across thr gaalxy), so they went out into the galaxy, found children who could be taught (indoctrination) the jedi ways and fast tracked them to the battlefield. Following the sith wars the jedi re-assessed their methods (and casualty numbers) and likely decided that they should only train those with high M-counts as they seemed to do better. This, of course, shrunk the orders numbers, but also created an arbitrary line by which force chikdren were selected. We see innthe high republic that even those who had hreat natural talent could be dismissed by the order because their M-count was too low. It also pissed-off other recognised (and unrecognised) force religions in the galaxy as a) the jedi were the only ones who could officially train force sensitives and had republic support to take high M-count children from families living within other force religions, and b) those who had the belife and will to become great jedi knights yet were not allowed to due to their low m-count (sea sponge level) found their ways to other religions (such as the guardians/diciples of the whils) who, whilst happy to work with the jedi also viewed them as elitist... Which they were. If this were the case, the funny thing (and possibly a crux in the fall of the jedi) is that the millennium of peace that marked the end of the sith wars and the high reoublic in its.entirety would have been tthe. Ost opportune time for.the jedi to return to teaching those who wanted to join the order no matter their skill - they literally had the time (although they probanly didnt know it at the moment) to dedicate themselves to 1-on-1 teaching, which would have opened the order up the the whole galaxy "you to can become a jedi!", yet sticking tk sith war M-count determination limited them to roughly 10,000.

It would make sense that the Jedi kept a certsin amount of active members. Like younstated. The cosmic force will maintain balance so there might only be a certain amount of force sensitives born every generation, especially if Jedi themselves aren't procreating with each other.

Ah the blockade days, good times. Good times

While I appreciate the work done, I think that there is a much simpler explanation than the living force curtailing the number of force sensitives, two actually. Since Jedi don't have children high midichlorian counts are not passed down. And since it's been peacetime recruitment policy is much higher standard than wartime. The Clone wars did not last long enough to see major changes but if it had gone 10-15 more years I would actually predict long term growth as standards drop to replenish lost ranks.

I can see why it would be easy to beleive jedi are evil.. no one has seen one.. only hearsay.. what? Like 1 jedi per planet?

Well they don't have kids, and limit themselves to only training infants. Look how many Jedi that Luke was able to train up in just a decade by ignoring that these limits. Not to mention the Army of Light was able to maintain a small army by just grabbing anybody they could find.

"It has inches"

So the Grand Master isn't the 800 year-old Yoda?

Estimates of habitable planets in our galaxy rage from a conservative 300 million to an inconceivable tens of billions. Assuming the Star Wars galaxy is roughly the same size, we use the minimum estimate, and the Jedi did their best to collect all force users, that works out to roughly... One force user for every 30,000 planets. Truly the force spreads itself thin.

When was vernestra made grand master?

What if it the Republic itself limits the Jedi numbers? If there are Sith in the Senate, i could see the Sith wanting to jeep the Jedi below a certain number.

why did obi one go to Tatooine which is in the outer rim away from the mid rim where they are on naboo

I hope Disney and authors are able to write new sequels, and announce them in new series for the return of galactic empire with choosing 1 of 2 options beside the new rise of “Gray” Jedi Order. (1) the reborn of Darth Sidious ( aka Palpatine) after his ultimate defeat in new movie. Subsequently, he successfully reborn into new body ( maybe his other clones or his descendants in his pedigree ). (2) or at least descendants in his bloodline, even the son or daughter of his daughter in theory or just another biological kinships can be considered for presumably declaring as new heir of GE and being the new leader of all empire’s remnants. These options only serve for the purpose to save and reclaim the throne of galactic empire for the new future of entire SW galaxy.

I think it was a bad idea that the Galatic Republic to disband their military they should just sifted a large amount of the funs away form it and divided up amoung more member areas’, social programs and other important needs for the public need.

Yord is Jar-jar in Acolyte

well, especially now

Is Vernestra Grand Master though?

🤔 . . . Odd. Maybe the exact number of force sensitives in the galaxy is due to some ‘reincarnation’ of, well, force users. Maybe, for whatever reason, there will always be only one force sensitive Wookiee at any given time; should a force sensitive Wookiee die, by age or whatever, another force sensitive Wookiee is born short after. Maybe that is how it specifically works…

How come we don't see Journalist in star wars

With roughly a quadrillion people in the whole galaxy, I feel like there should be a few million Jedi, but it seems finding force sensitive kids is harder than you think.

We all like to think the best of jedi. The fight never ends. Much like life. Jedi life lesson is be in the moment rather than one's existence. Yeah jedi.

If the Force tries to keep a constant number of Force sensitives in the Galaxy, there's going to be a lot of _untrained_ Force users born once the Empire falls. And what about after TROS, is Rey going to single-handedly track down and train about 10,000 Force sensitive kids?

What about the old republic how many were around then. It’s not specific they just say thousands. Same with the Sith

Jedi's are keepers of the peace, not soldiers.

Man the acolyte is so much worse now that i know HOTD is back.

3:38 "one could argue, atleast in the past, that we could handle the burden" im sure there are other details in the mix, but IMO, i think america could still have handled the burden, if they didn't favor globalistic economic policies (while also pursuing hostile / awkward and annoying foreign relations policies) and offshore basically the entirety of their production capabilities to china, india, and other east-asian countries (while also low-key pissing off said countries, in addition to also pissing off middle eastern countries), and had instead kept to a home-front production capability, regardless of what sort of foreign relations policies were had.

Soobby Loobby? I don't shop there.

I’ve always thought it’s far too large…. as if anyone could just enroll inJedi school

Alan your apartment how mush do you pay in republic Currency or are you a traysmen os smuggler. I hope you have a good blaster. if you need one I know Vader i can get you on the cheap

ok now tell how u got that amazing flat on coruscant

❤

I’m like why is Alan commenting on Hobby Lobby

Those Jedi were not out of shape. They were body positive.

I'm honestly surprised they are that small I blame the those dirty Dolphins. Also why does the Republic remind me a lot of the EU in our world a loose confederation of member states.