So we have the British SCP Foundation, lady being some evil entity, Engines are dying, Other assorted ghost locomotives, and Smudger/Stanley has an anomalous friend.

Percy getting a farmer investigated for insurance fraud is so funny, and Thomas's delivery of that line just makes it a 10/10

The moment Percival came on screen, my eyes were drawn to that damn fine looking racer. Champion one might say.

Sir Topham Hatt was devastated. The first losses were Gordon, Oliver, & Toad, and now, Toby was gone. Sir Topham was devastated, as he remembered him taking his father onto a trip. But unfortunately, the losses, weren’t going to be the last….

Never has a change of tone been so sudden. Please make a canon backstory on how Mr. Percival bought Herbie.

I’ve got a theory about Lady is doing, I think she’s after Thomas or some reason. That reason, idk, but it makes sense so far with the characters who’ve been killed or disappeared. Gordon, was taken then killed because he was like a older brother to Thomas, Oliver was a witness so loose ends had to be taken, people were taken from Ffarquhar who had some sort of relationship with Thomas (both positive and negative) and turned into trucks, Toby and Percy killed to break Thomas. And finally those that line near Kildane is her little hideout/portal entrance after the previous two were presumably destroyed. As for the mirror, I’m assuming it has something to do with getting rid of Lady, permanently. Predictions for future episodes: The next one to go might be Edward for his father-like relationship to Thomas (and witness status), Wilbert starts to put the pieces together, Thomas and Lady have their meeting and shit goes down, after Thomas is gone Wilbert and several engines finally put an end to Lady. What happens after anything goes.

27:38 Toby's in the shed. Really enjoying this series! 42:38 Lady's behind Percy at the back of the shed. I love this so much.

Thomas now regrets all the things he said to Percy. I saw that coming.

The ending sort of makes me feel nervous and concerned for Percy. I hope he’s alright, but evidence of him going with Lady in the forest and him with Toby really makes me wonder… Is Percy gonna die or not? I can’t wait for the next one!!!

I’m sure he was more of a cameo but I think herbie would be a cool addition to the story, what with him treading the line of being a sentient and nonsentient machine

This series keeps getting better and more mysterious with each story

This series really needs like a wiki or a TVTropes page or something - I wanna keep track of all the lore and all the stuff I'm missing! I'm really excited to see where this goes (but mostly just hoping Stanley and Lapis make it out okay - their friendship is just

Man the island is never gonna be the same after all this, poor toby and Percy and the worst part Thomas never got the chance to apologize to Percy 😭 and the news of sir topham hatt taking his own life was so sudden, his engines were like family to him and to lose some of them to a mysterious force really hit him hard. So many unanswered questions, I hope you make a 2nd part to the story👍

The Killdane Experiment. That's GOT to be it. That's why engines are disappearing, found dead, etc. That's the ONLY thing it could be. When the engine finally appears, it will have all of the confirmed dead engines' parts attached to it. Including their souls, all in one horrifying engine. That's the only conclusion I can come to.

Well, I just hope there are no more deaths in this series. We've already lost Gordon, Oliver, Toad, Toby, Sir Topham Hatt, and now Percy. I hope the other engines are lucky enough to survive. Anyway, great series and keep up the good work!!! Can't wait for the next installment!!! :)

First Gordon, Toad, and Oliver now Toby, I hope the others are going to be safe from whatever has taken Gordon, Toad, and Oliver.

I've never seen any series that's this dark or depressing. It's honestly incredible, the atomosphere just feels so different. It's a very quiet series.

Your music selection was sublime. I felt every amount of heartbreak, depression and anxiety with every plot point. Quite a masterpiece you have here.

i cant wait for more, this is so interesting!!!!! I was mad at Thomas at first, I get we all have our own ways of coping with loss, but he was blaming Percy for actions that he had no control over. But now I feel bad for him because he realized his wrongs.

The foggy ambiance is done *soooo well* in this one. It's unsettling even when nothing supernatural is going on, like the shot of Shen appearing out of the fog.

AT 3:51 TOBY IS IN THE BACK GROUND!

These videos are worth living for! If anything they are a true masterpiece.

The mystery deepens further.

These videos are always a thrill to watch! Granted in a few places, the lighting could use some improvement but not much else. Really want to see what you have planned for this series! Spoiler: So Toby is confirmed to be dead… shame.

Damn this is a long video. I love it. Then again I and a whole bunch of other people love your videos.

The editing on these videos has been incredible. I live for those "blink and you'll miss it" sightings of the missing engines in the background. The lightning effects in the last episode where Toby meets Lady was exceptional. Really amazing work.

These videos are always great to watch! This is some strange lore, cant wait to see what else is going to happen!

Man we need more people like you in the fandom who do mysterious and dark stories. Like I was at the edge of my chair when watching this. This is awesome. Keep it up

This is showing an understanding of tension and intrigue few are able to pull off, and it is refreshing to have something that isn't just an onslaught of loud noises and jumpscares in this niche little subject matter. Some audio issues still gotta be ironed out, voices should always be a little louder than anything else going on, and the "whisper screaming", while I'm sure you have your reasons for doing, can be a bit of a mood killer. Despite this, this series has been largely very well done. Rosie managing to get a picture and a description of Lady out there changes things. She has operated largely under secrecy until now. This might give the engines something to look out for now. Will someone remember something seen in passing, or be on the lookout for signs of her more diligently? This might be where some long awaited answers may be forthcoming. Another thing I've noticed, any time Lady "recruits" someone, another body is found. Could it be there's a limit to how many she can control at once? Did Percy go willingly perhaps, on a promise of "releasing" Toby only to realise the Faustian bargain too late? Did the changed Toby get into his head and perhaps make him a willing participant even now? Will, as Thomas put it, "sorry not be enough" when percy returns? What is Lady's endgoal? Suffering, worship, simple greed? What "long and inhuman" thing did Rosie see? Some kind of ShyGuy/Rake figure maybe? So many questions, so few answers, both the best and most painful part of the series. Definitely keep on this, as there is a lot of good things so far, and plenty of potential to be even better.

This mystery is only getting deeper and deeper, as always outstanding work 😃👍

These are getting really good, im hooked! 👍Cant wait to see the next one! 😊

Just finished watching this whole series a couple of days ago after stumbling across it, and I must say, well done! This series is quite the emotional rollercoaster, with plenty of creepy moments, heartbreaking moments, and some light-hearted moments in between. I will say, this is an interesting alternate timeline you've come up with. Although some of the timeline changes initially did confuse me a bit, such as D261 filling in for Spencer following the events of "Bowled Out", but I think it's great you're creating your own canon for this and not specifically basing it off any pre-established canon. Personally I headcanon that events which would have occurred prior to this series, such as Oliver and Toad's escape from scrap, Gordon's crash through Kirk Ronan, and even Percy's chocolate crunch, which he himself mentions in this episode, occurred while Sir Topham Hatt I was still controller, in what would have been the NWR's "golden age", so to speak. After all, Sir Topham Hatt I remains controller throughout the entirety of the television series. But alas, nothing good lasts forever, and dark times are descending upon Sodor. I've seen some but not all of Steven Universe, and normally I don't like crossovers in fan works, but this series pulled it off in a way that wasn't entirely "cringe", if you take my meaning. Lapis somehow feels like she belongs in this universe, in some strange way. And speaking of blue characters... I really like Flying Scotsman in NWR blue. I don't really know why, I just do. Something else I loved were callbacks to real-life events like the Halifax Explosion. Awdry tried to make Sodor a place that you could easily imagine as existing in the real world, and bringing real-life history into this series definitely makes it feel more grounded in realism, even with the fantastical and supernatural elements. Overall, it was a pleasure seeing this, and you've earned yourself a subscriber, because I can't afford to miss any new installments of this. Well done!

Not gonna lie i am so glad i stumbled upon this channel its so interataining and i cant wait till the next

I got to admit I love this series and I can't wait for the next installment

Please continue this!! I am HOOKED

Im now balling my eyes out, because percy is gone, and rosie said he looked dirty, which could mean one thing, he was taken... And Toby's death didnt help either, i have actual tears falling from my face

I love it how Mr Percival is driving Herbie the love bug, I even own my 1968 VW beetle that looks like herbie, but besides that poor Toby and sir topham hat

i just love this series, not too many i see a new video from and think "ohhh,heck yes!,i know this is gonna be good!"

I guess Topham passed away of heartbreak and grief in this series. But no matter what happens going forward, we are ALL really useful engines and people. Please comment if you agree.

These stories genuinley make me scared, my heart speeds up when im watching it

bro i can’t stop watching your videos i just love them soll much

these videos are awesome, please PLEASE make more

I'd pay for another episode next week

I am glad Henry hasn’t and wasn’t the first to disappear cause almost everyone kills him in there dark times or horror series

Dang. It's really getting intense. Many mysterious and scary things happening in this universe. Like with this evil Lady and her actions. Wonder where this series will go next? You're slowly improving the series here. Keep up the great work and take your time on this.

Bruh. Shits starting to get real and hitting the fan

15:13 That horn came in right on the note!! I'm thinking it was part of the music. Great video!!👍❤️

First person camera while chugging threw the forest naaaahhhh man had my hand infront of my face l was ready for something to jump out. So now that’s Percy taken and Toby already killed? I can’t even try to figure this out Lady isn’t making any sense great vid mate can’t wait for the next one. ❤❤

Incredible work as always. NOOOOOOOOO TOBY, PERCY AND STH 😭

At 22:28, you can see Oliver through the shed window next to Stafford. (Yes, it might be hard to see, but you can see the difference in the next camera shot of Stafford, when he's not there.)

God rip Topham Gordon Oliver Toad Toby and Percy

Well lets hope thomas doesn't end up dead

So we have: 1. Glowing red monster 2. Lady 3. Military The glowing red monster was first seen in the video Henry's forest after Molly had crashed. Later when Class 40 Bowler and Henry met in the forest they both saw red glow in the forest, Henry reversed backwards whilst Bowler derailed and was later killed by that same light. Few minutes later the glowing red light came to henry but due to feeling tired he fell asleep and ignore it. In the video Missing 411 we see both Gordon and Oliver being possesd by Lady and entering in the glowing mineshaft on Thomas's branchline and once they got in the red light disappears. In the episode The Ffarquar Siren during the beginning we see Toad slowly sliding behind line of trucks at the Scrapyard. Later we see that Lady is not just a engine but a human as well who turn anyone else that she suspects into truck or kill. She notices that one porter begins to question her role in all of this so she decides to eliminate him but before she can do that, porter takes refuge in military base. Lady arrives at the bridge with Proteus blocking her way and then we see lightning striking Proteus which changes his face into something twisted. We don't know why that happen but maybe we will find in some other video. In this video we see some abounded engines on the entrance to the forest who were probably killed by lady because she does not like them one bit and at the standing stones dig site later we see once again that glowing red monster but we don't know what he looks like. After Percy removes those engines from the siding during the storm, he is told to investigate that siding however Lady has noticed that earlier and once he enters the forest he is abducted by Lady. Maybe one day Percy will be discoverd but it will be too late. For me the format of all these parts reminds me a bit of Shed 17, but unlike shed 17 where Thomas discovers he was a clone, here he will have to confront Lady himself or with Diesel 10 which he is probably working for the military. Still we have a lot of questions: 1. What really is that glowing red monster ? 2. Is Lady the product of that glowing red monster by somehow entering a mineshaft on Thomas's branchline out of curiosity ? 3. Is the magic railroad a place where all the souls are trapped ? 4. What's the role of that female character which had escaped from the mirror ? 5. What happen to Proteus ? 6. Why does every engine follow that strange red light ?

Sir Topham Hatt: Is Toby safe? Is he alright? The guy: It seem in your anger, you killed him. Death Hatt: Impossible! He was a live I felt it!

This is amazing!

Very nice editing and making,I loved the plot but I would like a part 2 to see what actually happened to the engines. Ps this was a very nice and spooky movie. Keep it going

This episode actually made me cry

Hey, this was released on my 21st birthday! How cool!

You know when TTTe horror videos and episodes are good when they make you cry

Bro this series keeps geting darker and darker

Don’t know if anyone’s picked it up but at 5:20 as they go past the signal box Toby is parked behind it … literally a blink and you’ll miss it … love these background finds

That was Freaking Incredible!

Iron Lung lore but very different indeed

The best thing Daylight 3 will be known for, is this very series.

20:23 “tarred and fleathered” that got me 😂 I never really thought of the woolly bear story like that

A Killdane Reassignment, Oh my a god!

27:37 toby in, the sheds with the electric engines

Okay. I'll finally admit it. I'm hooked 😭

Thomas saying "YOU TOLD PERCY A GHOST STORY!" at 19:40 genuinely made me laugh.

I love your videos

This was great, but the only thing I think needs improvement is the dialogue volume because I can barely hear the characters talking over music or other sounds, but other than that, this series is great!

The start was so emotional I almost cried

Yo this my fav Thomas horror series, like lady as a villain is so unpredictable! Most people ether use a crappy oc or d10. Can’t wait till the next installment!

Loving the series. The story is going well, with many questions to make sure it's gripping. The one thing I have to say is that the audio quality/mix seems to be off. The voice work isn't a problem, but there are plenty of times where the ambient sounds or the music plays over the voices, making it hard to listen to and understand. If this is done on purpose, then keep at it (even if I don't understand it). But other than that, beautiful series and hope you continue with it!

It all makes sense now.

If you would have uploaded it last week from now, it would be your 10 Year Anniversary Special, really. Maybe you haven't even noticed it. I'm still watching it currently, and so far it's awesome, i just hope that there are no Jump scares coming in this. Because then i can't forget about it for weeks during rhe night

“Chumish I’m ending my life” ☠️

22:24. Nice touch on Timothy the Ghost engine

I'm a big fan of Lady, but this is a creative reimagining of Lady.

The way Godred was protrade was pretty good. A lost soul trying to keep Thomas from making the same mistakes he made. I love it

Now we have more reasons to believe lady killed Dirty Percy

This is like Victor Tanzig's SCPs of Sodor but a thousand times better.

Wow!!! 🤯The end pages are just..... out there, somewhere! It's creepy stuff! You and your friends/helpers should look at doing another chapter with this theme. Perhaps you could set it a year or two later? The mystery needs to be resolved, somehow...

Its creppy that at 3:51 you can see toby with pale white eyes in the backround

I wish they could have made amends, this brings back my own horrors. What Godred said is true, you never want your last interaction with someone to be a negative one. Especially when you love then dearly

This was cool! Were you were inspired by actuall missing 411 cases? Because it is really unsetling and nysterious like all 411 cases. Toby being discovered where he was not supposed to be, Percy being spotted at random locations with missing or dead engines. Maybe another engine will claim he or she was running away from something in the rain but the engine is dry and there was no rain the previous night, similar to 411 cases. I like the world building. I like how the Peel Godred locomotives are named after mountains and other sites on sodor. Culdee's wisdom. Godred has a very interesting character. He is very different from his normal potrayal and he seems to know about Percy's dissapearance before anyone else. Somehow he was on mainline track talking to Percy in Rosie's photo? I wonder what Culdee will say about that. Lady is weird as hell. Magic buffers might be a thing. Proteus still remains a mystery along with that entire plot. Those dam lorries are still there. Overall this was a blast of a story. The downside is that the audio is hard to understand or hear because of the background noise like puffing or music which makes it hard to hear what characters are saying and their tone. That scene in the cavern is also pretty hard to see. This was cool and I'm excited for more installments! Truly a unique Thomas series.

I think we all know what the fat controller's death is caused by: TOBY! RIP to both of them as well as all other victims.

Wow this is so good and intriguing Now I’m fully invested So much has Happened What happed to Toby? I’ve must’ve missed somthing Otherwise this a great story Way better then what is on regular tv

Hopefully, there will be a sequel to continue this story.

This series actually makes me sad I kinda reared up on this one also I wonder if lady is doing because the engines forgot about her

I can't stop binging this series and waiting for the next big part is killing me, let's hope that the question of why lady is doing this and the "army" is doing to try and stop will be answered soon Casualties so far: Gordon,Oliver,toad,toby and Percy All that's left of the original steam team are Thomas,Edward,Henry and,James

Once again you've outdone yourself.

Herbie! My day is made

I did work on the original woodhead line and the bo-bo and co-co ran all the time wit both Pantographs Up at all times

Holy crap is that’s godred’s ghost?! Looks like he has unfinished business

Like zoinks Scoob another scary vid

Maybe Diesel 10 was trying to do a good thing before it’s too late (trying to finish off lady so nobody else was killed or found deceased) IF we think Lady is the antagonist of this story.

i love those videos but i also have many many questions

Woah this is crazy I want next vid come out 😮 this was too much

Percy, my sweet angel…