This was SO compelling! I was on the edge of my seat when Edward found the both of them gone, and it REALLY got eerie at Brendam when Edward began to hear that slow, unnatural creaking, only to find that _Gordon_ was making it... And things got REALLY creepy when he got to the quarry, and witnessed the true unexplainable madness that unfolded. Edward's courage and need to explore is admirable in this; I love the line "I know what I saw... I don't know what I _witnessed_ ." He's confident in what he saw, but he knows that the truth might be beyond his senses and more complicated than he knows. That's so Edward; humble enough to consider all the options, but intelligent enough to have some good theories. I loved the dream sequence too, that really did feel like an eerie dream that feels a little _too_ meaningful, very immersive! I'm wondering what role Lady plays, and if she's malevolent in this... I'd really love to see more!

"remember what happened when you went down that Branch line at 70 mph Gordon. I do. The farmer does. And so does his lawyers. I do not need another lawsuit Gordon." That one was personal.

If Flying Scotsman herd that his only remaining brother has disappeared, I don’t think he’ll be too happy to hear about that.

Bro when I saw Edward got the buffers after chasing Oliver I immediately was like “Ok Gordon and Oliver went into the magic railroad”

I’m noticing that characters who’s paintwork becomes dirty are the ones to either get taken or affected by Lady. It may be coincidence, but it seems to be mostly consistent across all Forest Horrors episodes.

Two things I noticed: 1) Gordon's eyes were white at the end but Oliver still had pupils 2) Oliver wasn't steaming at the end but Gordon was This likely means he wasn't yet affected by whatever happened to Gordon, which only raises the question of why he ran away from Edward in the forest

"I don't need anymore lawsuits gordon" made me die laughing

Watching this again just makes the writer in me giggle with joy. I love all the little reveals of your "specter", especially when Gordon FIRST rolls up and finds her shed, and she's THERE...listening to her next prey. This was all so brilliant, and I can't wait to see how you've re-wrote her story. (To anyone who might have missed it and any other "reveal", here's my points of reference; 6:10, 14:05, 20:44 though I think that one is intentional, look hard and you'll spot her...) I'm such a fan of little details in horror, and you did it perfectly. Can't wait for part 3 of this adventure!

"I dont need another lawsuit gordon" Is to funny to me!

Chilling absolutely chilling. As soon as Gordon discovered that shed i had a bad feeling

Anybody else noticed that Oliver was in his scrap paint work when he was pushing Gordon out of the tunnel

for those who cant hear what he said when praying edward says "dear lord you are our sheperd and defender please deliver us home safely."

Intresting... Lady being the villain..? That doesn’t seem.. right.

Noice. Gordon wanted to take the Express again. Little did he know, that he'd never take it again.

I'm honestly hoping Hank stays to help out while "the two" are missing. It is rather interesting that Hank knows about the legend than Edward

22:44 After watching all installments of this series, I've realised that we can see Diesel 10 in the corner. More than likely scouting out for Lady.

I watch a lot of "Sodor horror", but this was one of the rarities that made me actually spooked. The apt choice of music, the fact that you never see what exactly happened to Gordon and Oliver in that shed which brings a sense of mystery, and the (i hope intentionally done!) eerily creepy smiles of the 2 engines at 20:56 which you harnessed to add to the horror aspect, all blend for a truly spooky experience. Also, I love the editing, as in camera angle, background etc. It is incredibly reminiscent of the original Thomas series. You sir have really done your research.

Why do I feel like this is all adding up to A certain secret organisation that deals with these sort of things

This is so well written, like, it starts normal, but then take a very turn... I loved it! I'm commenting here just to boost the algorithm really

"I don't need another lawsuit" I truly can't not comprehend how many times the fat controller has had to say that line

I was recommended this, and as someone who is both a Thomas fan and into mysteries and has seen several videos on the missing 411, I had to click on this to see what it was about. I enjoyed it, and from reading the comments, it seems that this is part of a series. I shall have to check out the rest of it!

23:42 I was like “oh you’re joking” after Gordon crossed that mine I thought he was gonna fall for my big brain Then Oliver just comes out of the hole like an unearthed Dream

loved this very much, one of the best ttte horror shorts I`ve seen in a while, would be absolutely thrilled to see more, honestly it surprised me you didnt use henry in place of gordon or oliver (i DID like the scrap touch at the mine scene) as he loves the woods and i feel would be more inclined to blow off any warnings of his favorite place, only to pay what looks to be the ultimate price as gordon and oliver have, also, it gets me thinking about thomas`s little adventure at the lead mine, had he been left over night as a "punishment", he very well could have been waiting for gordon and oliver upon their arrival, also thinking along the 411 lines, a part 2 that showed them being found eventually, in a ragged state or no longer functional, or even just a pile of enough parts to be unmistakably identified as the 2, for example maybe one is at the top of the geared train line up the mountain and the other maybe at kirk ronan or something?, spurring even more questions, it would be pretty awesome if done right and it seems to me like you`d be able to pull it off rather nicely as well as this came out

We need part 2 and hopefully we could see how far the story goes, this was a very very good story

Dang this is going to make for a great part 2. Definitely kept me on the edge of my seat. Great job Daylight!!!!!!

Just got here from “A Part of Me stayed behind”! There’s much horror potential between seasons 1 to 6 to be mined for! Perhaps there could be a sequel with Glynn at the forefront since he was number one many decades prior to Thomas’s arrival.. Perhaps Glynn being an old engine knows things others *do not!*

Interesting story you’ve concocted here. There are a few things that could be improved on for a sequel, some of the dialogue repeats the same specific words, I thought the opening was a bit too long, in a few scenes the viewer can’t see clearly enough (although I’d understand if this was intentional), and although this is often the limitations of mics, some of the VAs needed to be louder. I like the editing and directing here. Nice long shots and then poignant close ups. The writing has a way of conveying the story without the narrator but in a fashion that doesn’t cause any of the moments of silence to drag on.

I’ve seen many horror stories, especially from this fandom, but I mean it when I say this had me scared out of my wits. I already find the idea of going missing to be a terrifying one, but you’re execution with the lighting, tone and pacing (not to mention the creaking noises) had me shaking and squinting at the screen. Well done!

Do make more. I've seen my fair share of horror but this way eerie

I feel like Sodor is cursed with all these ghost sightings and mysterious disappearings

Oh this was nice,no outright horror,just errieness,i hope there is a continueation to this,you and your team did a great job

Daylight, I watched this when there was no daylight, I’m very unsettled and in need for more, this was absolutely grand and incredible, if you make a sequel to the sequel also grand, but take your time and thank you for the wonderful content

0_0 Wow. This was something. Didn't know it was a sequel to Henry's Forest. I kinda got confused in that part. Hopefully we'll find out if Gordon and Oliver will be found again. Or they're lost to whatever this being is.

i just noticed something at the time 22:53 you can actually see diesel 10 and a guy in suit possibly mr persivel being near to where edward and gordon go by

This was a very very good watch, I hope we see more videos like this from you! Very refreshing to see more of these unique original stories. You have a very compelling video style and these slow builder mystery stories are always a treat.

That was a very well-made video, I was on the edge of my seat the entire time.

I do hope if there is a part 3 that Thomas gets a big role, not only because Henry’s Forest stared Henry whose ‘number 3’, this story starred Edward whose ‘number 2’, I’d figure that means the next lead would be Thomas ‘number 1’, but also because Thomas is the only engine on Sodor who could recognize Lady.

My god that was amazing, the mystery behind it was incredible, I hope there ok tho and did anyone notice that when Oliver came out the ground, he had what I think said “ scrap “ on the side of his tank, may have been the lighting but I think it said that, not sure.

😨 this was genuinely soooo good! I'm probably now a genuine critique when it comes to horror/scary fan made thomas stuff, and this is one of those stories that creates that ever-present season 3 "Ghost Train" aesthetic we so desperately love. That sense of dread as well as genuinely creepy atmosphere is on full throttle in this one! It also managed to make me laugh hysterically in one of the most tense moments, when Edward actually sees them disappear like ghosts into the abandoned mine and is like "dear heavenly father, help us escape this area untouched" or something like that, I DIED LAUGHING LMAOOO. I mean, who can blame him?? I would be doing the same exact thing 🤣 Anyways, hoping there's a sequel to this in the near future!

"Remember that time when you went down that branchline at 70MPH? I do, that farmer does, his lawyers do too."

damn this scarred the shit out of me…and im not easily scarred from watchin thomas vids…i want to hope for a good outcome with oliver and gordon are safe but…i dont think that is where any sequel is going unless lady is involved. i liked the showing of buffers behind the boulder as if oliver disappeared through them after edward gave chase. reminds me of the magic railroad.

This feels like it became an scp video

Hope you continue this in the not too distant future. I very much enjoyed this.

7:57 the track is broken, could this be in relation to the engine we see in the bottom of the ravine in Smudger and the Magic Mirror?

what the hell did i just watch and please make a part 2 i need more details

The forest has a secret that by the looks of this horrifying. First D261, now Oliver, and Gordon. Who’s next?

The thunder claps sound very realistic 👍👍 Watching this while a thunderstorm was passing overhead and had to replay some parts to be sure where the audio was coming from 😂

Hank had the whistle of the Galaxy Express 999.

Keep it up Daylight3 Great The Missing 411 Video You Made There I Wonder What Lady Did to Gordon and Oliver?

“We will be waiting for you where hard things are unearthed and heavy things are retrieved” hard things like lead? Heavy things like Thomas?

I am surprised that only Edward and His Crew only heard it the cracking sound coming from Gordan while Philip was still sleeping like You'd think both engines would've been awake by the sound

Great Job With This Project Video.

I like this a lot, but I would love a part 2 to what would happen aka if Gordon and Oliver God replaced or somehow they got a demon possessed out of them. That would be awesome

This is intriguing! A mystery I definitely want to stick around with to see solved

Porter and puffa where the engines hank was referring to when he first brought the cast up to Edward

I like how Oliver sounds like Kermit the Frog.

“I know what I saw, I just don’t know what I witnessed” is an EPIC sentence dude

We definitely need a part 2 here...I wonder what happened after at the end Edward said about this place at the mines when Oliver and Gordon dissapeared on the red light...it got me more confused...

We need a part 2

Only realize halfway through that 411 refers g to Gordon and Oliver specifically

2:16 funniest part

So what happened to Edward, Gordon and Oliver?

Thomas and Friends meets Twin Peaks. Clearly not for kids. Well done👍🏻

I still was gonna to go, I am be scared..

Hmmm I wanna know you make those ttte videos with this!

Great job great story man i will waiting for part 2 and for use its a awesome horror movie i just will waiting for part 2 and i understand its hard work

The thing I don't get is: WHY the heck would Lady do all this??? She's never harbored any ill-mannered feelings towards the engines for as long as I've been a Thomas fan.🤔

I NEED TO SEE THE TRACK TO THE LEAD MINES GETTING RIPPED UP!

You already know it’s going to be a good horror story whenever it’s at the forest!!!!! 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶

Something unholy happened to lady P.s Edward said "dear Lord you are our saviour and defender so please deliver us home safely"

It took me three days to realize why it was gordon and Oliver involved in this story because Oliver is number 11 and gordon 4 and the video is titled the missing 411

I feel like lady has something to do with tbh, the consent sighting of her

is it me or in the center of the camera after it gets dark is there an engines face or was i seeing things? honestly not sure what that part has to do with the story but it was definitely eerie.

Some background catches 0:58 A bed is next to Edward and if you pay attention to the left of Tidmouth Shed (later on in this video), it's there. 18:23 Oliver appears next to Hank's dome 19:19 Is Lady or someone else hidden between those boxcars?

I figured out it was evil version of Lady... dark purple tank engine is linda Reason Corrupted by dark magic and stuff and turning good engines into bad ones, supernatural Entity, or worse dead ones, or something... because she gets bored or she want to have fun or something and the other one is Lady who is purple like normal shade of purple and she doesn't got corrupt by dark magic she follows the light and use it for good but... also use gold dust as well... then there's other Lady one in red or at any color because she doesn't know or have learned any magic yet but she brings everyone's spirits up and ect.

Lady gone rogue

"I don't need another lawsuit gordon"

Wow that was mysteriously interesting so many unanswered questions and I like it i wonder what’s next? 🧐

Spooky. I like the supernatural element, and I must say I’m looking forward to more!

I think this is like my third or fourth watch of this, but I only now noticed the movement in the security cam feed at the very end of the credits(28:00) XD

I NEED A PART 2 I NEED TO SEE WHAT HAPPENS

Nah you can't end it like that! What happened to Gordon and Edward, where are the tracks and what did Edward encounter that night!? I NEED ANSWERS

this was creepy, but also a very good story. was that Top n hat in the truck? ( NM ) feels like there is a illegal operation going on now...

We need a follow up on this.

Is that secret military base at 26:12

Oof seeing lady there, thats the start isn't it. What a great role reversal for her and D10.

Edward just started spouting every prayer in the book ehen he saw that devil shit and i do not blame him

Soo I noticed The Kelstein Tunnel made an appearance

I've seen a lot of fan made Thomas horror in my day, and I think this one takes the W

Ladys evil sister has been awakened

GOOD EPS I LOVE IT

Whatever Corden was running from could it be and Diesel 10 a corrupted version of him in Oliver show me old magic railroad I think they're trapped in it with lady

Well this was just TERRIFYING

2:13 Most normal thing I’ve heared

Edward - I don't thing that's a good idea Gordon. Ho how right he was 😢.

The workman sounds like Zak from tugs 4:33

This was really good but we need to know what happened to Gordon and Oliver. Also WHERES TEWD. And another thing I get why you would choose Gordon and Oliver to go missing since the title is called “the missing 411” and since Gordon is numbered 4 and Oliver numbered 11.

I don't understand what happened to Gordon and Oliver?

I hope to see More of this because this is amazing! Earned a Sub

Is D261 one of the victims or is Henry's Forest not a part of that?