now who do you think would win an army that is second to the most richest faction, with no problems losing men and are easily able to replace them with billions in their army and without palpitine interfearing, would have easily won the clone wars against over 10000 jedi or a single splinter faction of the crippled empire

@@at-bazelgeuse The Pentastar Alignment was lead by an Ex-Grand Moff with his own star dreadnought, had enough industry to create their own purpose-built line of frigate class at home, survived to the very end of the Imperial Civil War, and had many other heavy ships to help defend.

@@fainyance11 whats 1 executor to 8 malevolences i mean the cis had everything they needed to succeed against the republic x10 i mean palpitine did have his secerat fleet at byss with hundreds of capitle ships but the republic would still have lost due to the confederacys extreme production capibilaties plus it would still have tons of credits left over

I am pretty sure the Pentastar had more than just 1 ssd, we know of at least 3 when including Jerec.

@@at-bazelgeuse Only 3 Subjugators (the class of ship the Malevolence was) were ever made. Not only that, but those three ships were in total about 1/8 of the resources of the confederacy. The confederacy were the richest in terms of liquid wealth as well as stocks, but the Republic actually had more resources at their disposal just less money. This is why it took so long for the Victory and Imperial class star destroyers to get made, a lack of funds for the company. While numbers can be a good tactic, the Republic 's military officers were generally better and thats without the Jedi being added to the mix. This is why the Republic generally won ground battles, and why the separatists tried to reach planets first, because their capital ships were better and as such they could (usually) win the space battles. Well, the capital ship fights anyway. Starfighter fights the separatists won usually due to numbers. The Pentastar alignment is honestly like an odd mix of the CIS, Galactic Republic, and Galactic Empire. They have the finances and the resources, as well as the skilled officers and powerful capital ships. As such, they'd most likely kick the collective ass of the CIS.

Not to mention better! Disney adds a gun to the bottom and upscale and call an ISD a completely new ship.

Is the resurgent class star destroyer a joke to you?

@@americanspartan2420 Thats just one ship , Its a good ship mind you. The issue is more with other lasy designs. Xyston : Big imperial one with superlaser. , Mandator 4 another lasy design ship. Resurgent is an amazing ship but the lazynesss of other designs and disney stealing fan created images is where the bad rep comes in.

stfu

@@Erolsaurus stfu

Port and starboard = left and right. Ventral and Dorsal = top and bottom/belly and back

Jesse the unending Only the top left side has guns, obviously.

Yeah the executor is more of a command ship

i really like that it doesnt fall into the star wars do it all ship problem. its meant as an in your face slugger

Nope. Disney's in charge. The ship will slip on a banana peel, fart and then fall into a gas giant off-screen while a cardboard cutout takes us on a space-vespa ride through a desert town.

Nope, he hated and always disapproved ships that were bigger than an ISD

Nope. The only one he might and that is a big if would be a Bellator.

I agree. It's practical and well rounded. Yes he disliked large ships, but this would have been a formidable opponent during combat against Alliance ships

Joseph Clarke the Bellator would have been more likely to be had than the assertor in thrawn’s eyes

@@codename1176 So, I still don't see why he wouldn't have enployed this ship to it's fullest. Especially with the amount of fire power it had, without being massively flawed

Foregone conclusion. Stargate is (on some level, at least) scientifically grounded. Star Wars is not and would be OP by comparison.

In my view the Ha' tak would destroy the star destroyer quite easily.

I feel that stargate ships like the daedalus, ori or ancient ships (orion and city ships) could easily tear through ISDs. Death star however is a different question all together

The power levels are no where near close to compatible for a fair fight. ISDs regularly glass planets. The Goa'uld needed superweapons to do the same. Their entire threat base in the show was how far above human tech they were, but they're ridiculously weaker than Star Wars tech.

replicators would play havok on an ISD. No bio-signs to track and they upgrade themselves based off the materials/technology they consume.

I think the providence would win at least more than half

Not the old republic but the sith empire

The eternal fleet vs the new empire fleet in the rise of skywalker (if there is enought information) or any other fleet, I think of not destroyed by some kind of bullshittery this armada would have devestated every fleet matched agaist it.

Eternal Fleet is one of the most busted armies in the whole franchise. It would destroy everything else

@@SilverMontegiu maybe put up against the reapers from mass effect?

@@SilverMontegiu The one from SWTOR right?

Cool 😎

US marines vs Germans set in ww2

That's a long time

@@juanluis8947 depends non unit size and when in the war (let's assume platoon in the mid war for the US). They could be a match early on but add in American radios and it shits significantly in the Marines favor. Assuming handy-talkies are in the Marine Corp platoon TOE.

@@juanluis8947 damn thats a good one? SIKE Marines 😆

Nice

Disneys navy would get trashed against a single light fighter

@@brycewilliams9700 I dunno man I think a few first order ties can take down a light fighter

Hands down disney Gonna lose

@@brycewilliams9700 It already did lmao

Masters of biological manipulation vs Constantly evolving swarm. Sounds very cool!

I think I have the same answer when someone asks "who would win, the tyranids or the zerg". What would emerge after the dust settles would be some strange hybrid of the two factions, and the galaxy would be doomed.

Not that weird, they're both the mainline frigates of their respective factions. Though doing the Acclamator II would probably be a bit more likely since otherwise it's two Clone Wars Era ships fighting each other

The Acclamtor I and II can beat it.

Munificent would beat either one

Munificent could even threaten a Venator...

@@vulkanlives9776 are you sure. Munificient may have more weapons but the Acclamators have powerful quad turbolasers.

Omg yessss!!!!

They get inside the Coruscant underworld: The End!

Pedro Kantor the planet is pretty much screwed immediately.

Antonov A-40 what if it was when all the clones were there AND ALL THE JEDI

@@thysquid2157 palps would sense it and depending on the era hold them to the underworld or destroy the planet to defeat them

yesss although he kinda touched on this in his top starfighter episode

TIE/PR vs. TwinTails?

I remember that episode, though I don't remember the order ranking right off. It was a good one.

Its all about how the story flows...

That's just all their ships

That's so true

@@raptor07wm39 lets be honest Most imperial ships are about ship firepower.

*MOAR DAKKA!!!!!*

I love this ship until I see 1 thing and go "so it's dead when it fights against a suitable bomber squardon" The huge ass reactor bubble on the under side, basically means its reactor is only protected by the hull armour and shields, and its so big it's hard to miss. Just send a large squadron of Y wings, with a mix of Ion and Proton weapons, which will breach sheilds and the reactor in turn. You don't put your reactor, your ships most fragile (and prone to explode) system were the enemy can hit it without having to smash through half your ship to do it, it's bad design. That though is why it works as a good imperial design in SW, the Imperials can't do good design, they always leave a massive flaw in everything they build.

Pretty sure he's answered this, and the answer was "the UNSC wins."

L. Clay Manley which video was it?

@@josephburbank7293 Sorry, I don't remember.

Easy win for the Flood. The Reapers are primarily Armored using Compressed Organic Tissue, which the Flood would swiftly consume. They are also AI, which leaves them vulnerable to the Logic Plague. The Flood would eventually tire of playing games with the Reapers, and would use Precursor Neural Physics to shred them.

Already been said, but easy win for the flood

anything like this? kzfaq.info/get/bejne/oaeGdpBp2bibdY0.html

@@coromark That’s a pretty cool fan design. Not quite what I had in mind though. If I ever get around to it, I’ll make a rough sketch of the ship.

Your concept sounds like a Secutor Class

You mean a Battlestar?

Just think where the galaxy would be if the separatists won the war interesting timeline it would be

David Ordaz they’d get independence first off lol

Fake Sense true don’t know what the Jedi would do after the war without Palpatine intervention

Architects hands down

Roger Roger

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/gtilqdSmrp_Fl58.html

ISD would probably take it, I don't know the exact numbers but I remember Eck talking about how the ISD has somewhere over a hundred guns while the Venator had less than a hundred, maybe if they were outfitted like the Liberation (Ram Kota's Venator which he specifically modified to outgun an ISD-1) it would be a bit more even

@@thomaskhan2933 multiple venators changes the a game though as a fully launched venator compliment can defeat a star destroyer however 5 can take a much larger fleet

Blue Robin Iirc, a single venator, fully stocked, carries over 400 fighters, while an ISD carries less than 100. If they each came in outside if each other's respective firing arcs, and the venators launched, it's game over for the ISDs

I think it’s important to note that if the Venators unleashed every ship they had, they’d have over 1500 star fighters and 5 corvettes on their side with the ISD having no point defense besides the Tie fighters which are severely inferior craft, even the Tie defender isn’t enough to save it in this much of a numbers disadvantage, my money’s on the Venator with that massive star fighter compliment

@@LoneWolf20213 the venator cant carry the spha and corvette together as they use the same hangar bay

Yes

Dew it

Eclipse would crush, unfair for Infinity

Yall seem to forget that star wars vessels have to be in line of sight. Unsc does not. Shiva nukes and Mac rounds aren't deflated by Ray shields. So infinity would win the day ino

Yes I agree. I doubt star wars shield protect against physical projectile.

Thor's Hammer wouldn’t the unsc win instantly since the chimera don’t know the unsc have a fleet, and the unsc could just keep bombarding the surface

@@frost1262 The UNSC wouldn't result to immediate bombardment like that they would likely result at first sending in marines to investigate several massive disappearances of populations like villagers and towns that turn up empty in several areas around Earth and first contact is made between the Marines and Drones in secluded areas and engagements are made. It all depends on the timing the UNSC learn about them and their response. Likely at first containment and evaluation of cities and several towns will be their first course of action.

@@thorshammer7883 They'd use passive sesors and use RADAR and LIDAR from orbit before sending in reconnaissance using drones or Pelicans, reviewed and refined by ship smart AI's. If not, they'd dispatch a Prowler and go from there.

Not if the domain is in orbit, though they could stop the chimera, just by bombardment and they would overwhelm them right

@@jigolocana7492 What domain?

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/qbmfqNmosa7OYH0.html It is kind a full analysis

Probably the mandibles that have you the vibe. I think it could be interesting, but mainly in a large-scale. What I know of elites, they'd probably win easily one-on-one.

I'd say the Turians would win in a military engagement (mass accelerator guns can get past their shields if unsc bullets can). But would potentially lose a 1 vs 1 as Elites are bigger and stronger

Ive built a 1km ship in SE and im pretty sure that no current pc could process a 16.5km ship.

Well I'm building a 300m ship on Xbox so imagine a 1km

@@quarterstogether2005 yeah, its pretty big.

@@riesenfliegefly7139 hey you could build it if you just had the frame of the ship and nothing else

I tried building a Borg Cube with some friends. It couldn't even handle a frame and hull covering, forget an interior with functional systems (that said, I didn't expect to be able to pull off a 27 cubic kilometer ship).

yeet!

Ai sir

Dew it.

Yes sir

Aye sir!

Depends douse the venitor get its fighter complaint out first if so the venitor would win

Yup. Venator wins if it gets its fighters and bombers out before it gets into range of the main batteries of the ISD-II. That thing literally has no point defense; Palps should have taken the guy who designed it and used his corpse as reactor shielding, that was such a dumb design flaw.

Would the Daedalus have beaming technology?

What variant of the Daedalus? Rail guns or Asgard beams?

@@maxpower3990 doesnt the asgard version atill got rail guns

@@mirandalynch4877 naw it was all beams after the Odyssey was upgraded with beams and the computer and the Asguard an heroed. That said it should be the Odyssey with the beams and the asguard computer core and a ZPM or 2.

Doesn't a ZPM or two let it tank coronal mass ejections?

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7qJnsafr8qomaM.html there you go, close enough

That's a win for the ISD no contest

They are working on it.

@@fancyblackpantz well my point is that the Helicarrier we see in 2015 Avengers Age of Ultron that they can cloak and the weapons they use would be able to beat the ISD's shield because they're not energy based

@@awesomeness1941 You are aware that particle shielding is standard on all spacefaring vessels as a protective measure against micrometeor impacts, yes? Furthermore, we know that capital ship particle shields can stop large masses traveling at great velocities as shown in Star Wars Ep. V: the Empire Strikes Back; those Star Destroyers just plowed through the Hoth asteroid belt, ramming anything they couldn't be bothered to blast to bits.

They'd probably crash one of their shielded frigates or destroyers through the dome of High Charity and barf out a legion of Spartan-IVs into the holy city. They ain't Spartan-IIs or IIIs, but they absolutely outclass anything shy of the Silent Shadow, or particularly 'roid-raging Brutes. One problem: During the age of Halo 2, Jackal snipers are literal death-gods deciding who lives or dies. If Legendary difficulty is representative of the actual events of the Halo series, there are going to be a LOT of "missing" Spartans.

Yeah... That's what she said.

Flood wins. Period. End of story. No, seriously, giving the Flood access to a full galaxy of biomass BEFORE the fight starts means that they have Keyminds from the get-go. That means they have the ability to abuse Neural Physics, which is for all intents and purposes the Halo equivalent of real-life cheat codes. They'd need to LET themselves lose.

Eve ships are mostly based on how they're fit though, they dont have any canonical fits. Also, the A.I. controlled versions of the ships are... atrociously bad, usually.

The CIA of the internet Are you talking about the mandator 4?

Yeah ( I’m really bad with the names )

That'd be kinda fun. I'd probably give it to the Executor-class Star Dreadnought though; clearly, the point defense on the Mandator-IV is so pitiful that it might as well not be there, and the Executor carries HUNDREDS of fighters and bombers. And I'm talking about actual military vessels, not the ragtag, poorly designed scrap that the Resistance reduced itself to using (seriously, no Y-Wings?!). Maybe if it wasn't captained by a total moron, the Mandator-IV could get off a few shots from its phallo-cannons before it got swarmed with TIEs. Given how it survived asteroid impacts at-speed while pursuing the Millenium Falcon through the Hoth asteroid field, I'd say the shields on the Executor could tank a couple of those shots before it started taking actual damage.

Anthony LaMonica i agree with here

Which Imperium? 30k or 40k, because both are very different beasts.

@@nweasels dousnt matter forerunners stomp

After all those '''Hyperspace Kamikaze'' no battleship is star war is worth anything, a reasonable development of plot would be everyone start using hyperspace capable torpedoes, war become a duel between scouts and spies. But we all know Vice Admiral Gender studies need her nice big ship to assert dominance over the white male supremacist running the Empire, so nothing would happen.

My exact thoughts.

It gave a nice beat poem effect in the minutes near the end, though.

Erlend Andenæs very true

They'd fair quite well, actually. They have the ability to systematically destroy entire solar systems by destabilizing the central star; this is their primary tactic, in fact. Not to mention that the average Cabal soldier could probably tear an Imperial Stormtrooper's spine out, barehanded, and proceed to then beat it to death with it, laughing the entire time. Furthermore, Cabal soldier armor will actually protect them from direct hits, while their guns are decent enough compared to the E-11, which means that they are better at killing and worse at dying.

@@anthonylamonica8301 , True, their main ammunition is essentially a mini rocket that explodes inside the target.

Nice, which model did you commission?

@@Hannezia it was a wallpaper of an Imperial fleet above a city planet. I asked him to do something reminiscent of the naval Task Force 38/58 pictures from WW2.

Cool! I think I know which piece you're talking about.