"Time has proven the fire correct" is the most beautifully succinct way to describe what happened re: Skupin

I think Neleh offering her tribe mates the mint from her mouth is iconic if it's paired with her "I didn't start playing the game until day 22" final 2 speech. She was our first sweet heart turned semi-villain and a pioneer of the game, among many others, for their flip on the Rotu 4. That was a first.

For All Stars, I probably would’ve also said Shi Ann’s ‘Stupid people’ speech after she crushed the immunity challenge is up there. It kept the underdog alive one more round and she wasn’t gonna keep it quiet. Always brings a smile to my face

Honestly for Survivor One World, Kat asking for a blindside is probably one of the most funny and iconic moments of the entire season😂😂😂

*shows David proposing to Carolina for 10 full seconds* “I thought it would be cruel to subject you to the David Murphy jump scare again”

“Time has proven the fire correct” perfect line

If Cagayan’s isn’t J’tia pouring out the rice then this video is factually wrong

My pick for Africa is Ethan playing hacky sack in the village. It was a moment that solidified him as a lovable figure to America, so much so that my mom still remembers it, and she hasn’t watched it since it was coming out live, as she watched back when Survivor was still huge but stopped watching sometime around Vanuatu (she doesn’t remember the season that she stopped, but she remembers loving Rupert and that he won $1 million, so it’s safe to say she saw All Stars)

“You have made my life hell from day one! Forget you! Go home! Good bye!”

I still remember watching Adam looking at the podium with his gears turning. It was definitely worth a shot.

Most iconic moment from Cagayan: “Kass.. zErO pErCeNt cHaNCe oF wInNiNg tHe gAMe”

Two Iconic moments not mentioned: - Courtney's "sh*tty apartment" - "Talkking to God Lord, I mean Jeff."

I think Noelle winning the reward challenge in Survivor 43 has to be more memorable. Winning that challenge when she was so far behind and also being so hard made it very heart felt. I brought tears to my eyes.

My changes: Borneo: Honorable mention to Rich dropping at final immunity challenge Marquesas: rock draw All-stars: Rob betraying Lex at the merge and the speech he gave at Final Tribal paired with it Vanuatu: Chris Final Tribal Guatemala: Judd leaving the game Cook Islands: Mutiny or Penner flipping back after merge Gabon: Corinne Final Tribal speech Redemption Island: Matt's second blindside Blood vs Water: Rock draw tribal Cagayan: Woo taking Tony to final 2 2nd chances: Final 6 tribal Davids vs Goliath: John Henigan Blindside Island of the Idols: Dean's Sluth of Advantages at final 5 or a Noura moment (Janet going out at 5 also considered) Winners at War: Sandra Blindside 41: Shan blindside

I actually had no idea that Gabon spawned a famous gif, I was hoping for you to mention the Randy blindside (and all the iconic voting booth confessionals therein). God, what did we do to deserve a gem like Gabon?

I would've said "stick to the plan" for San Juan Del Sur's iconic moment. For starters, it was hilarious, but also, I really believe Keith changed the outcome of the season by saying that

For Nicaragua I’d probabaly say the moment right after Naonka told Jeff at eh the reward challenge and Jeff says rhetorically “Would anyone else like to quit?” …..Only to be met with Purple Kelly answering him seriously

Africa's most iconic moment is Ethan playing hackysac with those kids during the reward. It's the moment that both highlighted his very heroic win, as well as the inspiration of his entire career post Survivor.

I really think an underated iconic moment exists in Survivor:AO of Tina battling nature and fate to get the rice. That woman fought a river and won.

Ya know... it's odd that Jeff saw the Zeke outing, the Dan situation, and a few other questionable atrocities, and yet, yeah, he was the most enraged to see those girls quit. Y'all gave one a bikini and threw her in Nicaragua, what did you think would happen?

Gabon easily is Crystal's voting confessional about Randy

For season 40 (while I love the Adam podium moment), I would go with Tony vs Sarah fire making. The emotion behind these two friends with such a history knowing one of their dreams was over at the hands of the other hit hard. Definitely hard to choose in some seasons though, either due to too many moments or absolutely none haha.

my favorite moment from exile island is when bruce is constipated and courtney goes "one time i was so constipated i thought i was having a..." and danielle says "A CHILD?!"

I think the idol betrayal on Koah Rong with Tai and Jason and Scot. That moment changed the entire season for the rest of the season

In regards to Erik giving up immunity in Micronesia: While I agree that it is the most iconic moment of the season, it is NOT the dumbest move in the show's history. I don't even think it's in the top 3 dumbest moves of that season. Personally, I think that Jason falling for Ozzy's fake idol, Jason dropping immunity at F9, and Jason buying Natalie's story after coming back from Exile and not playing his idol at F8 are all dumber. Yeah, top 3 dumbest moments of Micronesia are all Jason Siska moments. EDIT: I have realized that while Jason falling for Ozzy's fake idol is still very stupid, it doesn't count as a move. I would therefore say Erik giving up immunity would indeed just barely make my top 3 dumbest moves of the season.

A few moments I would pick over yours: 1: Richard Hatch taking throwing the FIC Probably the first thrown challenge ever, it surprised Jeff, and it's only made more iconic from Boogie copying it in BB all stars. 22: "He's literally carrying his family on his back!" One of the most memed lines ever, also not much to choose from here. 30: The Auction The turning point of the season, a shocking turn of events, and the reason we don't have the auction anymore. 33: Adam and Jay in the hammock One of the most heartfelt moments of Survivor ever. I tear up every time I watch it. 37: Minority split vote The best use of advantages ever, a Brochacho blindside, and a big turning point of the season. 40: Sarah vs Tony firemaking A moment three seasons in the making, to cap off a season thirty nine seasons in the making.

In season 4, my most iconic moment definitely has to be Vecepia at the Fallen Comrades challenge. Using her one pre-game luxury item to win a late game challenge definitely stuck in my mind for a long time

Some Honorable Mentions: Borneo: Wiglesworth coining the phrase "I didn't come here to make friends" Outback: The flood washing their camp away Pearl Islands: The naked cannon challenge All-Stars: Mogo Mogo Boat Exile Island: Shane and Courtney talking about her sh*tty apartment Cook Islands: The Mutiny Fiji: Blindsiding Edgardo China: "DAMN!" -Chicken Micronesia: "It's a f*cking stick." - Eliza Gabon: Randy and the cookies Tocantins: Coach telling the story about being captured by cannibals Samoa: Russell finding the first idol without a clue HvV (So many): JT's letter / Tyson telling Coach "Don't wear feathers in your hair at tribal. Don't tell your stories, people don't believe your stories. They mock you. There's no reason to tell them. And do your tai chi in private where nobody can see you." / Colby: "COME ON, REED!" / Sandra winning her second game Redemple Temple: Matt's 2nd blindside South Pacific: Watching Jack & Jill One World: Colton's Quit Philippines: Carter: "Hey Penner, who do you want to vote out, Katie or Penner?" Penner: "Well, I'd hate to lose Katie." Cagayan: "Kass, zero chance of winning the game." -Spencer / "Get a fat dip of that guac." -Woo SJDS: "Stick to the plan!" -Keith Nale Worlds Apart: "As a coconut vendor, I seek truth." -Vince Cambodia: Hiding idols in challenges Kaoh Rong: Tai refusing to create the Super Idol and eliminating Scott MvGX: David playing an idol for someone who wasn't with him in order to win them over Game Changers: Advantagegeddon HvHvH: Ben finding an idol because the spot where he had been doing confessionals all season suddenly had a big sign that said "DIG" Ghost Island: Jacob Derwin putting the whole tribe's food supply in his gross sweaty sock DvG: The David tribe's minority vote split to blindside the Mayor of Slamtown EoE: The Pilots & Passengers live tribal / "The twist is not on trial here!" -Wardog WaW: Ethan on the Edge 41: Brad talking about broccoli trees / The Shanthem / "That is Naseer!" -Naseer 42: Maryanne at FTC revealing the Hidden Immunity Idol and announcing that she kept the only secret in the entire game 43: Owen getting mad and furiously chopping wood in a blind rage 44: Frankenship 45: Kaleb's Shot in the Dark

I think a Top 5 or 10 hardest Survivor seasons video would be really interesting. I was thinking about Survivor 41 and how people kept saying it was the hardest season ever and it got me thinking about what is the hardest season

Dude did not have to do Jeff Kent like that the hall of fame line is crazy😂

Luke, you always do a great job with putting these videos together! I always enjoy watching them 😊

For island of idols I would have picked reactions to applebees. I’m Canadian and when I travelled to Phoenix Arizona I actually sought out an applebees to try the food that made Karishma and Missy so excited. And even ordered a shark bowl after Tommy’s endorsement

Such a good vid, I just disagree with Exile Island, most iconic moment has gotta be the whole Touchy Subjects sequence from Courtney getting every question to Cirie's reaction and then having Courtney and Shane stuck at camp and Shane threatening to go to Courtney's apartment and then Cirie still laughing at reward. It's one of my all time favorite sequences, funny enough to top a game-changing strategy imo

Sorry but I have to say Guatemala’s moment has to be that brutal opening challenge. I get it if you left it out cause it was kinda graphic, but it was a jaw dropping peak into how real the show was for me. Kinda like Skupin and the fire or beast mode cowboy’s evacuation.

I'm revisiting this after the end of 45 and I'll say I. That season Kaleb's shot in the dark as the iconic moment for this season

I think for Survivor: One World, the most iconic moment for me is Kat going on about how cool it would be for a blindside to happen during final 8 tribal only to get blindsided in that very tribal. For Survivor All-Stars, the Big Tom final speech with the fake out handshake was pretty iconic. San Juan Del Sur, I loved Reed's speech to Missy. For Survivor Kaoh Rong, it's Tai refusing to use his idol on Scot. I'm surprised you didn't go with Cirie getting idoled out on Game Changers.

I would have picked the purple rock from Marquesas. Not literally… I mean, knowing my luck I probably would have.

Personally I think for Vanuatu the most iconic moment is Leann's blindside due to how it completely changes the season's endgame and even final 2

I love the Michaela blindside, but I’ll also nominate Adam and Jay’s hammock conversation about their moms as one of the most powerful moments in survivor history.

This video was so iconic and I will never forget it, It was just such a fantastic video.

I still think I have to give it to Karla and Owen outlasting the tide during Last Gasp for 43. I still feel like that is one of the coolest moments in recent Survivor.

I think Guatemala's most iconic moment has to be Judd's salty reaction to getting blindsided. I'd also pick the Auction just as a whole for One World. So many awesome moments there like Kat's reaction to the BLT, Kim bidding on chocolate in the shower, Tarzan just not wanting to spend money so he gets $500 after the season only to break down in tears and spend it all when the letters from home show up. So many good moments.

Rodney doing dish on his birthday is such an iconic moment that I was watching a video unrelated to Survivor and they used that clip. For Winner's at War I would have chose Tony runny like a cartoon character to read his Extortion advantage. though that's just cause it makes me laugh just thinking about it

i’m glad i’m not the only one who’s obsessed with this sort of survivor content. great stuff, guys!

In Survivor 45, everyone wanted a man named Kaleb out, and he played a shot in the dark, was safe, and every single person voted for him but had to revote. That was incredible.

Survivor 45 most iconic was Kaleb surviving a unanimous vote no doubt

I’m sitting here enjoying this with only having seen Survivor Gabon in the last decade.

Blessings on you for remembering Rodney’s birthday, it’s truly one of my favorite C-plots in the show’s history.

I prefer the Debbie Waner choice of constantly changing occupations and for Marquesas it’s gotta be Kathy peeing on Johns sea urchin sting. Great video!

Jesse eliminating Cody in 43 is very good, but I personally really like the bucket holding challenge where Gabler just starts name dropping everyone he looks up to. A very emotional and memorable challenge moment for me! (Also Cody took another 2nd place in an individual immunity challenge, I don't know if anyone has been as consistently 2nd as him in any season ever)

Rob saying he will keep Lex safe if he keeps Ambuh and then betraying him is more iconic in terms of Survivor, the game, than the proposal

Is it weird that I live in Nigeria, never been to the US, and know pretty much all of these iconic moves. Been a survivor fan for only eight years, but watched almost all the seasons except four or so. My family knows not to mess with my survivor binge time. Thank you for this

I feel like for Africa it's just... seeing the contestants surviving in Africa on like the first night. The fact that they're THERE. It was before every survivalist show you can think of. No Naked and Afraid. No Bear Grylls. No Survivorman. This was like... one of the first times we saw something like this.

All survivor channels are great but Idoled Out is by far the funniest On the actual topic of the video, I don't have many notes however I'm sad you didn't include the full Stacey copypasta speech even though I do know it by heart. I have no idea why "halloween jokes, chucky the cheese jokes" gets me but it is hilarious every time

There's few changes I would make, but I'll mention just the one Marquesas! It's the FIRST rock draw, for Rob's sake! Otherwise awesome video, as usually! For me, Idoled Out is Top 2 Survivor YT channels 💚

As always, well done Luke!

THE VIDEO RETURNS

great picks! although, it does admittedly hurt my heart to see no keith moments for either of his two seasons.

45th season is the best new era who’s with me 👇

This episode will be iconic, part deux!

For Australia, I would also include the camp completely flooding and washing away after coming back from Tribal. It was like this tribe kept getting kicked even when they were already down

nice work

Great video, thanks for sharing! My opinion Tocantins should be Taj at the auction.

"At least you are in the Hall of Fame for something..." OUCH!

Calling Cagayan Oops! All Iconic is the best thing I've heard this week, and school was cancelled this morning

Timestamps for each season Season 1 - 1:02 Season 2 - 1:50 Season 3 - 2:28 Season 4 - 3:02 Season 5 - 4:03 Season 6 - 4:26 Season 7 - 4:48 Season 8 - 5:31 Season 9 - 6:03 Season 10 - 6:20 Season 11 - 7:07 Season 12 - 7:23 Season 13 - 8:03 Season 14 - 8:25 Season 15 - 8:57 Season 16 - 9:23 Season 17 - 10:03 Season 18 - 10:07 Season 19 - 10:38 Season 20 - 11:04 Season 21 - 11:31 Season 22 - 12:00 Season 23 - 12:29 Season 24 - 12:42 Season 25 - 13:07 Season 26 - 13:41 Season 27 - 14:07 Season 28 - 14:24 Season 29 - 14:53 Season 30 - 15:14 Season 31 - 15:37 Season 32 - 16:03 Season 33 - 16:32 Season 34 - 17:09 Season 35 - 17:44 Season 36 - 18:13 Season 37 - 18:53 Season 38 - 19:24 Season 39 - 19:47 Season 40 - 20:09 Season 41 - 20:58 Season 42 - 21:24 Season 43 - 21:44 Season 44 - 22:26

DvG is my most favorite season. i love it so much. everything but the winner.

Was soo hoping for Adam using the podium 😊❤😂

Video Idea: The Funniest Moments From Each Survivor Season

for me, micronesia has to be the nataile-parvati jury question, i was flabbergasted the first time i saw it and gabon has to be the sugar's & crystal's confessionals & my favourite "nataile, can i have your jacket nataile?"

with micronesia idk if i woulda been able to chose between erik giving up immunity or the scene of the black widows stirring the pot

Mike falling into the fire in Season 2 is for me THE most iconic scene in ALL of Survivor. It is literally the first thing that pops into my head whenever i think about the show.

I just realized exactly how much I'm disengaged with the new era: was totally into this video until it got to 41. Great coverage though! Hopefully 45 and beyond begin to fix the issues of the last 4 seasons

My changes: 4. challenge that’s shows hierarchy 8. You take care of her I’ll take care of you 9. Chris final tribal council 13. Mutiny 19. Russell second idol play 22. Voting out Matt a second time 23. Sophie final tribal 24. I’m the king of the island 26. Dawn showing teeth 28. Sarah vote out 33. Going to rocks 34. Advantage geddon 37. Christian immunity / jacket / minority split vote 40. Extortion 41. Hour glass

For One World, I got Leif sleeping in the trunk and Kat’s weird dog-talking thing with her relative.

4:09 You were so close to my pick for an actual good iconic moment from Thailand, which was Robb’s character development in his boot episode.

i have thought of colton's "i'm so dehydrated, my pee is brown" from his med evac episode at least once a week since one world aired. most iconic moment of that season to me for sure

At 5:56 I agree with that anytime Lex the hypocrite is mad is fine with me as well Cough Colby and Ethan!

Waited the entire video for MOTHER STACY POWELL'S MOMENT. YES. THANK YOU. chuckee the cheese jokes

Africa had some awesome rewards I woulda went with but the auction was great too. I also respect that less of these were strategic moves than lists I'm used to seeing

I would have Devin’s “That is not an advantage.” on here for HHH

I still think one of the most iconic moment of Borneo is the Gretchen vote out where halfway through she goes "Oh my god its me"... the berth of how alliances trump survival skills in the game as the person who probably would have won if the "worst person at surviving" was voted out each week gets clipped immediately come the merge.

I think I'd go with Gabler donating his winnings. I cried like a baby in the best way.

God, I love old school survivor 😂

Not me cheering myself on every time I correctly guessed what the moment would be, as though I just won immunity 😂😂

I cant believe that the Applebees wasn’t the most iconic from IOTI 😭

for season 30, id probably give the edge to the auction, though dunking on Rodney is always a good choice. One world has so many options. Kat and her cousin, Troyzan celebration, Colton crying are all awesome and iconic moments in my book.

What's his name❓ What was his birth 👶 name❓It wasn't Coach⚽, it was Benjamin👨. And you know they're children 👦👧; 2⃣6⃣, 2⃣2⃣, they're over there listening 👂 to all of Benjamin’s👨... 🎃Halloween Jokes🎃, uh, 🐭Chuckie The Cheese Jokes🐭, they- 👅 eu-h, they want it 🙏. He goin off of loyalty ⭐ got them fee- "😰Oh, Benjamin👨, you so loyalty😓" ... Come on now 😑... Everyday📆 he got a story 📚. I wasn't ❌ buying 💰 it. [scoff] 😤 [giggle] ☺... Eh😒... No. 🙅 So... They tr- like yesterday ↩ the tribal 🔥 was all kahoots 👌 Benjamin👨,"Let's give a hug 👪." ✋PFF.✋ Keep that hug. Boop!🔫 For me. Cuz it wasn't real❌

Idk if you’ve already made a video like this but if you did Best strategic moments from each season I think that’d be a really good video

IMHO Season 46's most iconic moment is Maria getting Liz and Q to do rock paper scissors after saying it was about who needs it most, even though Q had recently won a food reward, Venus was wrongfully excluded having eaten less than Q, and Liz being the obvious choice being malnourished from her food allergies.

New era is getting better and better

I can't believe after making so many videos, you fianlly remember then name of who won Edge of Extinction!

12:05 Luke, we're never going to be able to forget this, are we?

For season 4, the most iconic moment (IMO) had to be when in the episode 6 reward challenge "dumb and dumber" lost it for their tribe. (As rob would put it) which caused the underdogs to go on a challenge winning streak

I had forgotten abt the Carolyn cold open… it gave me chills in the moment

One world should have been "THIS IS MYYYYYY ISLAND"

The fire said just wait on it I promise this will make sense later 😂

At 7:41 now she playing Big Brother and doing very well so far!

I think an argument for 42 would be Marianne's reaction to zack getting voted out being as funny in that she would later go on to win and become really good friends with zack

Winners at War - Ethan during the log challenge on exile. David and Goliath - Christian solving the slide puzzle and discussing it in confessional