I picked up this book without knowing much about it and the lady from the bookstore told me it was a beautiful story. I thought "Right, she's supposed to say that." But boy was I wrong. One of the most gorgeous atmospheres I've ever read about!

That scene where isopelle opened her eyes and she was in the woods “but to the people of the streets of London, they look like any other pair of lovers” is the most visceral thing I’ve ever read.

I love the atmosphere of this book and the circus itself, but the romance fell flat for me. I shipped Poppet and Bailey more than I shipped Marco and Celia tbh

The only problem I have with the book is that the way their relationship development was skimmed over a little bit. But I totally agree that it has the most real characters.

" I wished for her"

I really did not care AT ALL about the relationship between Marco and Celia tbh The book is really great and I love it very much but the actual main protagonists were the weakest of all the characters.

I'm so sad. I really wanted to love this book. And I was disappointed. I loved the magical atmosphere of the book. The writing wasn't bad at all. The characters, some were good some were not. But there was no meat to the plot. Why is everything happening? Why is there competition? why is it important? What happens if they decide not to let anyone win, The previous competition went on for thirty-something years .. Why they couldn't stay together and live without creating dramas that would cause their deaths. There are so many holes in this book. Simple unanswered questions. Which is so sad. Because I really wanted to love this book. In a brighter note... I really like your channel❤

Tsukiko and Widget were 100% my favorite characters

I would love to know if hannah ever re-read the book recently and her thoughts about it now.

I only had one problem with the book. Literally only one. Unfortunately that one problem happens to be Marco. I found him to be an insufferable asshole. The way he treated Isabelle was just...atrocious. So because I didn't like Marco I wasn't a huge fan of the romance. Celia was too good for him. The setting was frealing finominal though, the circus was absolutely my favorite character lol.

I wish it had a whole series dedicated to it, explaining all the loopholes the whole mechanisms of how the magic worked, the relation between Alexander and Prospero, more history on Tsukiko's par etc etc etc. But, then again, for me all of the unanswered questions add to the mystery and that magical atmosphere, kinda like a world that I was introduced to but could never fully understand, that makes it a bit beautiful and tragic

I just finished Night Circus right now and I can say with out a doubt I have never read a single book that was even half as magical as this one.

Why is so one talking about Isobel? It is so weird that out of all the people I know who have read the book, me and my friend are the only ones who feel so strongly about her. Are we crazy??? 🤷🏽‍♀️

Just finished reading the night circus and I CAN NEVER EVER thank you enough for getting me to actually read this book!! I don’t think i can make you understand on how much this was all i ever dreamt it would be and more. Ever since i started watching your KZfaq channel I’ve always made up this picture of night circus inside my head on how magical it would and reading it literally full filled my heart and at this point I don’t think there’s any more reason for me to live anymore because this book was all i ever wanted from this life lol!!

That ballroom scene was just so amazing , I couldn’t breathe😍

I just finished this book and immediately decided to come watch your review ahah. I'm commenting before even watching to say thank you. Thank you for making me discover this book. It became my favorite book immediately, I read it in 3 days (the fastest I've read anything over 100 pages) and... wow. You've talked in other videos about how you read some books at the right time, and The Night Circus was exactly that for me. It's the book I needed in my life right now. I love it so, so dearly and I think I'm going to be like you and hoard TNC merch and different editions ahah

I found your channel about half a year ago and now I have finally managed to read this book. I just finished it and had to come straight back to this video and say Thank You! I really loved this book. The atmosphere is amazing! Yes, the story is rather slow but I did not mind at all because it gives so much more time to get to know the circus and the people in it. The concept of the circus is absolutely unique and I could see it all in my mind, all the tents, the bonfire in the courtyard and all of this under a starry night sky. If this place was real I would be a rêveur. But since that is sadly not the case I will instead reread this incredible book to enter once again Le Cirque des Rêves.

I did love The Night Circus as soon as I finished it, it was automatically one of my favorite books! You make me want to read it all over again just so that I can share that excitement once more! Absolutely loved it!

Thank you so much for recommending this book! I've actually read this book because of your videos and I absolutely loved it!

I FINALLY got my hands on this book and read it after seeing you talk about it for literally years and oh my god it was so worth it! This is my new favourite book. I will cherish it forever and always. What a masterpiece! No wonder you've been talking about it all this time!

I finished this book and I was breathless for hours..i cried and smiled and my emotions were all over the place...i loved it so much..the romance and magic was so great.... I am certainly going to hear the audiobook as well...and it would be wonderful of its made into a movie which matches our imagination while reading it and made us see the entire magical world once again💜💜💜..thanks Hannah for this wonderful recommendation😘😘🤗

Subscribed because this book has been my favorite for years and you perfectly articulated my thoughts on it.

ok i know its been almost 7 years of you uploading this book but I just finished it and I am so in love with it and you just put into words what I could not it is so utterly beautiful I was not able to contain my feelings for it. I annoyed everyone I knew after finishing this book bc I had to talk to someone about it.

The book paints such beautiful pictures in my mind, and I love it.

This is one of my favorite books of all time too!! Its just so hard to express why I love this book...I've never read anything like it!

You reminded me how much I love the Night Circus. You made me read it a third time. I normally, I would never read a book even twice.

I finished this book today after hearing you gush about it since I started watching your channel. I loved it. Not as much as you do, but far far more than I was expecting to. So beautiful and intriguing, with so many powerful quotes that stuck with me. Thanks for bringing my attention to it, because I would not have picked it up on my own.

Don't know if you've heard, her new book is coming out this fall!

Hannah FANGIRLING over this book is A MOOD!

You make me want to read this again and I literally just read this two days ago! 😂

Your reviews are making me want to read these books. I’ve heard you praise the Night Circus book so much that I couldn’t wait, I needed to read it. I’m dying. I’m in love with this book so much, thank you for making me love this book

I just finished this book because of you! I am so glad I picked it up because it is without a doubt my new favorite book of all time. This review is basically me. The book was perfection and I can't stop thinking about it! I want everyone to read it and enjoy it like I did! I've never read a book more magical and breath taking.

I start reading the night circus after watching some of your videos and it is amazing I really loved it i gave it 5 stars like I freaking loved everything. Poppet, widget and bailey are my babies i want to protect them forever

"Love yourself, read the book." I havent picked up this book in 4 years and I keep thinking about it still.

Thank you! I read some bad reviews of this and wasn't going to read it but I picked it up because you love it so much, and I'm so glad! It was just so sublime! When I finished it I was totally emotionally drained; all I could do was text all my friends immediately in all caps to read it ASAP and I couldn't even tell them why, I was so speechless

I keep rewatching this video because it just makes me SO happy! Ready to start rereading it!

i've been watching you gush about this book in so many other videos that i finally decided to read it. i just finished it and oh my god you were so right. i knew to trust you when i read the Monsters of Verity duology on your recommendation and fell in love with it. The Night Circus blew me away. thank you so much for consistently singing its praises and wearing me down lol

I have a problem getting into and along with the book. It's among my unfinished list.

I have to agree wholeheartedly this book is absolutely amazing and by far my favorite book of all time

I picked up this book because of your constant love for it and thank you so much I’m so in love with it and is now my new favorite I can’t even begin to explain just what this book made me feel just idk thank you!

Gosh, seriously, I have never actually commented in any videos, but now I am doing this. Hannah, I couldn't tell you how much I thank you for recommending this book to me. I spent like 3 to 4 days slowly reading it. The book was so beautiful, so well-written and I'm afraid, you know, that the book may end. I took it with me, literally anywhere, open it and read it every sitting. And it's was gorgeous, so gorgeous. I'm ranting here, I know, but I'm just like you, can't make any coherent thoughts about this book. Just can't thank you enough, and our style of reading is soooooooooooo similar so from now on, maybe I'll read any books out there that you recommend, really.

Giirl, when you brought up the infernal devices😂 I love the fact that you put into words the feelings i got after rushing through this like life was on pause. I agree with everything said

Watching your video is just like watching myself as I felt exactly the same emotion after finishing this book, I just couldn’t express how much I love it! Even though I’m a second-language learner, the enigmatic ambience the author creates is out of this world, I particularly enjoy her descriptions of all the smell of food and leaves.But the most impressive part for me is when Tsukiko said that her lover smells like ginger and cream, I suddenly remember several chapters before the description of the her room scent was also ginger and cream! It literally gives me goose bumps! I thoroughly adore these details and foreshadowing:) BTW you are so sweet and cute

This book has a separate fan baseee!!!! You need to make a book recommendation - books to read if you loved and lived night circus!!!!! That'd be wonderful wonderful wonderful ❤️

Ok so I liked the book, but I am conflicted about Marco. Like I loved the few scenes with Celia, but he was a TOTAL ASSHOLE towards Isobel. I just kept thinking about how heartbroken Isobel must be! Am I weird? Idk. I just didn’t have a strong connection to Celia but I loved poppet. The ending was satisfying and I overall loved this book and enjoyed the atmosphere and descriptions of the circus and characters. ALSO when Marco said “I wished for her” WHEN I TELL YOU I SCREAMED

I love how much you love this book. Almost every one of your videos shows you giving it praise. Love that.

I cried a little after reading this. It was too good. I was just like ‘Oh my gosh. *curses in languages* this is so goood’ the entire book. It was soooooo great and I hope I can buy my own copy soon. And I thank you for introducing this to me. I've been watching your videos and every single book you recommend, I have it in my library. Hoping to read more that could give me the "book orgasm".

How many different versions/covers of this book do you have? Enough to warrant a video showing all of the different covers and which ones you like best (and why)?

I actually read this because you recommended it so much and i just wanted to say Thank You!!! Because this book was amazing and heart-wrenching and beautiful and I don’t have words to express how much it meant to me. So thank you for recommending it :)

Here’s me coming to this video two years after you’ve posted it but I’m currently in the middle of it and wow. Just wow. It’s incredible. Honestly, I’m taking my time with it because I don’t want to finish it! But there’s one scene in the book that is staying with me because I believe it’s the most realest thing I’ve ever imagined and that’s when Celia stabs herself with a dagger in the game room of Chandresh’s house. I could literally see the straight face she had when she did that and I saw the healing of her wound take place in my mind and I was stunned and amazed and had chills all at the same time ? Like wow it was so special . It was really like it was taking place right in front of me. I don’t know why that scene stuck with me so much but I gasped when I read that because it felt so real. Anyways there’s so many scenes in this book that are just mesmerizing and this book is really just one of a kind.

Thank you! I was looking for something like this. I feel like the closest i ever got to feeling the way you seem to abouth this book is when i read the Molly Moon books when i was in like year 7 :P Awesome review, gonna give this one a read for sure

OMG, I swear our book types are exactly the same!! Early/late Victorian Era!!!! Yesss, the infernal Devices is quite similar to this story!!!!! I love the night circus solo much as the infernal devices series is amazing too❤❤❤❤

I finished this book three days ago and I liked it a lot. It isn't my favorite, because I had a problem with the pacing. It jumps around a lot and I lost track of what happens when and what didn't happen yet even if I read it happen. You know the thing with Tara... I was confused two chapters later and had to remind myself about the time jumps. But that's the only "bad" thing I can come up with right now, because it was so good. I never read romances because it's often really cringy, but this one is so well written! Even though Marco is a bit of an asshole... I never read a book that was able to keep me interested without telling me exactly what will happen. I didn't know what was going on until maybe I was 70% trough this book and it hit me so hard! I was so upset I couldn't talk about it. I literally read their lifes happening and than this turn! Oh my God! I gave it a 4 out of 5.

Could you please remake this video!!! I think that would be so so cool!!

ohhhh i am surely going to buy this book Hannah u r the best booktuber(100% true) I love as much as i love Harry Potter.......can u tell me which editing software u use??

i LOVE the book so so much, though i think there couldve been more development within the characters, celias and marcos relationship was juse skimmed through and i was looking for more elaboration on how exactly marcos feelings for isobel died....

Hannah, I have read this book on your recommendation and I must say I am so much in love with this book. I love Bailey, poppet, Marco and Celia.....love love love

So glad I'm not the only one that sees similarities to the infernal devices! It also reminded me of the phantom of the opera for some reason. Loved this book!

I read this book on your recommendation Hannah and I just have one word for you.... actually two Thank you! I loved this book so much! Like you said it did have a slow pace but the magic and the setting was just mind blowing!

I picked up the Night Circus based on your reviews of it, I haven't even started it yet but just the blurb on the dust jacket has kinda made me fall in love with it already.

You expressed everything I was feeling ahh thankyou I didnt know how to explain wat im feeling for this book but your review helped

Just finished this book today. Spoilers: i feel like there are no bad guys in this book which is different and i love it so much. Also, i can freaking feel the LOVE marco has for celia. It is so genuine and omg... I feel like i missed out on alot of stuff in the book bc it took me a long ass time to read half the book in 2018 and i finished the other half in 2019(took me a day) i will definitely re-read this again!! Ughh i loved it so much

I bought and read this book because of you, and it is now my favorite book in the world!! It was amazing, I can never thank you enough!!

I actually did wish it was more flowery, but thats because im a sucker for pretty descriptions (my favorite book is the book thief) i thought how everything wrapped up was pretty clever. i didnt get what bailey had to do with anything until the end. i quite liked celia and marcos relationship :)

It’s so nice to see someone else who loves this book as much as I do ❤️

Such an enchanting read. I almost cried when I finished it lol I didn’t want it to come to an end.

I always tell ppl this is one of the best books I have recently read

I will say that this book was really good. I finished it in about two and a half days and it was such a joy. I must thank you for recommending this book, because I probably would have overlooked it. So thank you.

Watching this video after a darker shade of magic. This is adorable! You still love the genre even to this date :D

Rereading this book for the fifth time and came across this. I felt exactly the same way after I first read it. So incredible, still haven't found anything like it. Waiting for her to write another. Have you read any of her Flax Golden Tales? So short yet such atmosphere.

this book made me cry more than any other book i ever read.

This is my experience!!! It's amazing how you're describing this book because I felt the same way. She made me see English as a very beautiful language.

Because of exams I had to take a break from the book half way through but now finally finished and got to watch the whole of this video and oh my god I agree with everything you said! It’s a truly magical and beautiful book, well done to Erin for creating something to incredible ❤️

I randomly picked this book up at my library several years ago and a few days ago I got a rêveur tattoo. I've been a reader all my life so I used to never be able to pick a favorite book but The Night Circus is now my all-time favorite book 😊

I can't believe it took me so long to finally read this book... but at the same time, I'm glad I read it at the right point in my life. And I fell in love.

I’m only quarter of the way through and already am so intrigued with this book, I can tell it will become one of my favourites as well. I read a lot of thrillers and crime but also love very magical books as well, I mean Harry Potter is and always will be my favourite series! 😂❤️

WoW… I can not believe how old this video is😂 I just realised I feel like I don’t know you and checked the date… you have improved so much, not that this one was not good but the progress is palpable and I loved it… loved the book too btw.

I knew I was addicted when I finished the introduction. I literally only downloaded it to my kindle because you suggested it and I’m crying.

I felt like this book was a beautiful medley between Harry Potter and Miss Peregrine's home for peculiar children. Hands down, on my top 5 favorite book list. It was sooooooo AMAZING!!!! I could not put it down! I feel so far behind because I just read it!

I bought this book on your recommendation and even though I’m only half way thru, I fell in love with it. I love this story so far

i discovered your channel late so I just finished it today after i seeing it in your recommendation video and oh boy. i almost cried when i realized i was on the last page. it was so... beautiful. like a dream.

Hiii I'm going to do my research project on this book...i need ur suggestions

I just finished this book and I picked it up because of you! I loved it, Erin is a genius!!!!

Celia was strong character ??? Seriously?

Thank you SO much for introducing "The night Circus" to me. I picked up a book after God knows how many years and I told myself I would only read a few pages but I ended up practically living inside them. I love it SO much. I just finished reading it and I miss all the characters. I miss the Circus the most!

Thank you, thank you, thank you for this review and the multiple (but completely warranted) mentions on your other videos. I read this book because of your gushing, and I am sooooo happy I did. Love it! I heard a rumor she is writing another book? Maybe, pretty please?!?

I love to meet a fellow "I don't have words to say how much I love The Night Circus" 😍🙏 I can totally relate!!!!!!! I carry this book around so much, it is ridiculous 🤣 Best, Nic

I have not related to a book review more in my life. This book was absolutely wonderful!!

I love it so much!!!!!!! I even bought the starless sea because I love Erin Morgenstern's works

Just finished reading! It’s beautiful the detailed imagery and the slight romance was beautiful 😍

Okay, now I definitely have to read this. It's so nice to see your passion about it!

Found your channel about a week ago and decided to go to the very beginning, because I hope to make a booktube soon as well, so I wanted to do some research. Then I found this video. This book is honestly the only book that I can call my "favorite" book. I have read it 4 times, and I even bought Erin Morgenstern's new book The Starless Sea as soon as it was released because I was SO excited to read another book of hers again. I definitely recommend reading that book if you love Erin Morgenstern as much as I do. It is definitely a lot to take in and is kind of all over the place, but man... it's incredibly written. So.... hello! Sorry to delve so deep into past videos and post such a long comment XD

I feel you girl. I feel the same with this. I can't put into words how much I love that book.

couldn’t have said it better myself. the moment i finished the book i had to just sit and process everything that had just happened whilst my mind was utter mush. i have never felt so connected to a set of characters in my life. i was and am still in awe over everything that happened throughout the plot. the romance is everything i could ever want and more within a novel. i typically read YA books, so the thought of this book was slightly nerve wracking for me. picking it up was the best decision i have ever made. i can’t wait to read it over and over again until i have memorized each and every line :)

I've had this book for two years and so, and it's my all time favorite book ever since I first read it. Hands down my favourite

OMG! I snorted tea out of my nose because of your opening

i just finished reading this book based on your recommendation; i can tell i really liked it but at the same time i read it in a matter of hours and feel the need to immediately read it again in order to fully comprehend and appreciate it

What are some other good adult books!?

Ahhhhh!! I love this book, it's my all time favourite! I've read it around 5 times in the past 2 years already

after seeing how much hannah talked about this book i decided to ask for it for easter and just finished it yesterday. wow. definitely my favorite book i’ve ever read as of rn.❤️🖤