The Problem with "Problematic" Anime and Manga

  Рет қаралды 889

Evangaard

Evangaard

5 ай бұрын

We get controversial this time, as I pretend to actually weigh in on a serious topic without actually saying anything at all.
Follow me on Twitter: evangaard
Music used:
Ace Attorney: Spirit of Justice - Turnabout Sisters
Persona 4 - New Days
Making Lovers - Jidaraku de Heibon na Nichijou
Professor Layton and the Curious Village - Professor Layton's Theme (Live Version)
VA-11 HALL-A - Go! Go! Streaming-Chan!
Trails in the Sky - The Byway of Departure
Transistor - Vanishing Point
Undertale - It's Showtime!
Disco Elysium - Precinct 41 Major Crime Unit
Mother 3 - It's Over
Cooking Mama - Menu
Journey - Atonement
Katawa Shoujo - Raindrops and Puddles
Pokémon Balck/White - Juniper's Pokémon Research Lab
Terranigma - Overworld
#manga #anime

Пікірлер: 12
@Erzy33
@Erzy33 5 ай бұрын
Love the usage of the new cam, really switches up stuff from just b-roll. Keep it up🔥
@crunchlaw8575
@crunchlaw8575 5 ай бұрын
New evangaard vid lets goooo
@daianstyle9213
@daianstyle9213 5 ай бұрын
Okay opening the previously established can of worms/beans was hilarious!
@OokamiTsu
@OokamiTsu 5 ай бұрын
I do believe we can and should separate the artist from their work, mainly because we don't know ANY authors personally and we'll NEVER be 100% sure they've NEVER done something bad. That aside, you can stop supporting their work and that's totally valid. I personally will never stop loving Rurouni Kenshin, I believe it's one of the best series out there, but I totally despise Nobuhiro and I hope (since he didn't go to jail...) he did reflect on his life and never watches that shit again, but even if he does I would not consume any new series made by him.
@cuzzbaby
@cuzzbaby 5 ай бұрын
I've always been in the mindset of separate the artist from their work. For example, Jon Berthal, an American actor, love all if not most of the things he's been in, heard he's a massive prick. Now opinions can sway but I still feel you should be able to distinguish from fact and fiction.
@wombat4583
@wombat4583 5 ай бұрын
I think it also matters what the 'problem' is, how aware of it we are, and whether it's something finished or something ongoing. When we already have consumed something in it's entirety, it's already done. It's consumed at it becomes a part of your memory irrevocably. When it's a part of a series, anything ongoing, or new content, I feel like there's more room to question supporting that person even if the work removed could be fabulous. That being said everyone has different thresholds and ultimately more people are going to be unaware of an author or an artitst's personal life anyway.
@ndu-sx3ns
@ndu-sx3ns Ай бұрын
whatever stance the world chooses to take on the art and the artist. I wouldn't care cos no one can tell me what and what not to enjoy.
@CacTzu
@CacTzu 5 ай бұрын
Ah yes watching Evangaard 3 AM > homework > sleep
@ontheriseav
@ontheriseav 5 ай бұрын
You like worms?! My best friend's mother's brother's cousin's nephew's dog ate a worm and died! How dare you!
@juststatedtheobvious9633
@juststatedtheobvious9633 5 ай бұрын
My very first favorite problematic book was a collection of problems called The Bible. How could the same work contain The Golden Rule and Hell? I think that contradiction prepared me to mine the good and potential good from monsters who either wrote or supported horrors like Numbers 31:17, 18. You can learn good things from those who lie to you or themselves, but only after you've built up a healthy skepticism and a good ethical foundation to begin with. That said? While this nuance is helpful when watching WWE, I'm less persuaded there's good to be found in directly engaging with something like Hitler's works. Only one perspective is offered, and it's intentionally deceptive the entire time. The only good it offers is awareness of how fools became goose stepping tools of fascist violence. And you can gain that wisdom elsewhere. So, somewhere between an author who believed in Christ at his best and an author who was just Hitler at his worst, lie the many shades in between. Obviously. Yet, as simple and obvious as that statement is, most people still argue over a single solution to an artificial binary. Thank you for giving your audience more credit.
@NoobertonAnime
@NoobertonAnime 5 ай бұрын
I also have quiet a interesting take on separating art from the artist. I personally think people use it to excuse their actions for themselves than to actually make that separation. I find that "separating art from the artist" is more commonly "not separating art from the artist, unless said artist is problematic". I myself really like separating art from artist, for on reason that a lot of art is often created by many people, films have 100's of people in the credits, anime is similar, a lot of commercial art is made by a cultivation of many creatives and we often see that one particular person gets the credit for all of it. But in cases where the art is made from a smaller source I understand focusing on the artist, even then it might be better to focus on the art as commercial media is just so control and a lot of what we end up seeing is not the pure creative work of a person and rather a pandering to audiences to keep a job. Very few creatives actually make it in a way that they can make exactly what they want. So anyways, I personally separate art from artist in most cases, no matter who the artist is. I just find it hypocritical for someone to say "separate art from artist" with Rorouni Kenshin and then turn around and be a Quentin Tarantino snob. It's clear you actually care about artist so just acknowledge that you like the piece of art even though the artist is problematic, and hey, this is a good case for piracy, if you pirate work from a terrible person so they don't get money, I respect it. Summary of argument, I think the though is used as a mental scapegoat for people and I simply find it a healthier solution is to just acknowledge your feelings. Also good video, very comprehensive!
@wombat4583
@wombat4583 5 ай бұрын
So fun fact : even if you pirate something in order to try and avoid supporting someone monetarily, it still gains cultural influence/power and with today's data mining/collecting, can still be used to prove that demand is there to create new editions, adaptations, issue the creater to create more, etc.
I Tried 100 BRAND NEW Manga from 2023
22:22
Evangaard
Рет қаралды 837
Eden: The Manga that Was ALMOST a Masterpiece
19:49
Evangaard
Рет қаралды 10 М.
Этот Пёс Кое-Что Наделал 😳
00:31
Глеб Рандалайнен
Рет қаралды 4,5 МЛН
Scary Teacher 3D Nick Troll Squid Game in Brush Teeth White or Black Challenge #shorts
00:47
A Beginner's Guide to Visual Novels
16:41
Evangaard
Рет қаралды 27 М.
How One School Shaped the Future of Manga | Manga Minute
5:47
i gave you everything.
0:23
veilsfx
Рет қаралды 3 М.
Anime Has A S3xual Harassment Problem
10:08
The Pedantic Romantic
Рет қаралды 386 М.
Dungeon Meshi - Spelunking On the Spectrum
28:52
Superdude
Рет қаралды 184 М.
The Silliest Manga Lawsuit Ever | Manga Minute
4:57
Evangaard
Рет қаралды 556
Demon Slayer is Extraordinarily Incompetent
1:07:55
Captain Mack
Рет қаралды 1,2 МЛН
Why Perfect Blue is Terrifying
13:29
Super Eyepatch Wolf
Рет қаралды 4,9 МЛН
Why Light VS Johan VS Yuuichi Isn't Close
18:19
Avent
Рет қаралды 221 М.
Джеки Чан лишил наследства всех своих детей! Что акажете?
0:41
Симуляция: МАТРИЦА МИРА
Рет қаралды 9 МЛН
ЕНЕШКА 2 СЕЗОН | 3-бөлім | АНГЛИЯҒА КЕТЕМІН!
28:02