"Why can't I turn on my lights?!", Pastra said calmly.

2:18 It's so cursed to hear Dawko say fuck instead of "Dingle bungo pecky parker sweet summer strawberry pie with a cherry on top, right'o sugar, whats all this then?"

You sound like an alternative reality MatPat who went for chill analytical videos over excitement and rapid paced jokes and I love it, I keep coming back for these

For those who don’t know, FNATI was based off the creepypastas, “Abandoned by Disney” and “Tape from Treasure Island”

Treasure Island was THE game that crawled so that the other fangames could run. It’s truly something that’s of it’s time,sure,but it was one of the most impactful fangames ever to come from this series.

I love hearing Pastra switch from calm and cold narrator to a terrified panicking gamer. Glad that the gameplay video was posted. Also, the "old-timey" music just gives me Pumpkin Rabbit PTSD.

One thing about the lights mechanic that you didn't talk about, that being the fact that it can be used as a last resort of sorts. When you turn off the lights while, say PNM is in the office (Though this works for any character normally deterred via turning off cameras), there's a 50/50 chance for the character to leave or to get a express trip to the game over screen. I feel this should at least be worth a mention, since it can be useful if you happen to have no cameras left and you're feeling lucky.

I'm so used to the original FNAF jumpscares that I just remark flatly on them after all this time (e.g. "Oh. Hi Foxy. Gonna bite my face? Cool.") but these? These scare the crap out of me even though they telegraph themselves so clearly. THAT'S good jumpscare design.

I remember the original demo. I played it in sixth grade, and it felt scarier than classic FNAF. Fan games just felt… different to me. I always had faith that Treasure Island would become a fully fledged idea one day, and my patience definitely didn’t go unrewarded.

I’m glad I wasn’t the only one who was overly invested in Treasure Island and having that faith in that visually dated wonky demo to become a fully remastered and spooky game. Radiance did so much justice to this Five Nights At Freddy’s Classic and so do you Pastra!

Honestly, I really wish he talked more about Mortimer. He’s honestly my favorite fan game character, his design is so unsettling and cool, and him slowly approaching your office while his theme gets louder and louder is one of the scariest experiences of any fangame

Okay but what I love is that, the title screen jumpscare? That’s a reference to the original demo. It happened in the demo first, he says “wanna see my head come off” and then after a few seconds, disappears, then jumpscares the player I thought it was a great innuendo to the Original, a really pleasant surprise :)

I will say that while overall this is kind of a blip on the radar in terms of my childhood and interests, that title easter egg alone is something that's going to live rent-free in my brain forever. Just... Jesus, dude. It's _still_ just as effective.

I remember when it first came out, and I was TERRIFIED of the Face. No joke, that thing gave me nightmares when I was little. I haven't seen the remastered version yet, and I'm honestly kind of scared to because of the Face, but I think this game did have an impact on my view of fan-games, I love it so much.

y'know, usually, people would see being overly-positive or overly-enthusiastic as a bad thing, but sometimes it's just nice to be completely hyped about something and simply enjoying it. keep it up dude, these vids rock, and i don't even see time passing while watching 'em.

Fun fact: jevil was the placeholder for hourglass and the jumpscare he shot the player with a gun

Jesus Christ, I never thought much of Treasure Island, but in recent days, it's scared and intrigued me out of my mind. It definitely gives me the "What you have found should never have been seen" kind of vibe, and would make a killer ARG or analogue horror series or creepypasta, emphasis on the "killer" part.

I love childhood mascots that get turned into creepy pastas or twisted fan creations. But it feels like it has to be done right or else it would just be laughable. And treasure island did the concept phenomenal well that sometimes I forget that these are Mickey mouse cartoon characters. Loved and agreed with everything in the video! keep up the good work!

A really neat balancing factor is that if you prioritize camera characters the timers for ace and undying will actually increase, giving you a larger grace period to shut off a camera and then stand still! Plus, even though it looks like you figured it out in the gameplay, you can let Disembodied sit there until a camera character enters and then get rid of both of them! Theres actually a lot of nuance behind the mechanic priority and its essential to beating the custom night nightmare modes. This is a great review and I love the content you make, excited for the second part!

Pluto's just there to answer the age old question we all have lingering in our minds, "What *is* the dog doin?"

Donald used to be my least favourite on my run, but I found out he was completely harmless when I went to see his jumpscare in the custom night, which made repeat runs much easier. Also, fun fact, it seems the first 'fangame' was some unity shooter set in the fnaf 1 pizzeria with very little relevance to fnaf outside of the setting and enemies. Treasure Island was the first fangame with the traditional FNAF formula.

Fun fact: the easter egg at the start screen when photo negative mickey jumpscares you was actually a feature in the original game!

Pastra: (literally looks like a demonic jester that destroys world for fun) Also pastra: *aH! Spoopy disotored mimcky facc scary ;(*

lets not forget: he didnt even talk about the whole underground bunker section

My only gripe with treasure island is, hourglass, just because the only two counters are A paying attention to where he spawns, or B (easier), using every defense until he goes away

Treasure Island got a finished product?! I’m so glad you covered this! It looks phenomenal!

fun fact! during that little jumpscare at the beginning of the game before you enter the first night, the photo negative Mickey says "Hey, wanna see my head come off?" which is a reference to the treasure island creepy pasta where the OP goes into a maintenance room and sees a photo negative mickey costume which promptly springs to life, says that line, and them pulls it head off, spewing yellow blood around the room.

I love it when horror games, but mainly only FNaF fangames it seems, put a jumpscare in the main menu when you do nothing for too long. It's a lovely streamer trap

Dormitabis is probably one of the most vile, grueling, grim fan games I've ever seen. But Treasure Island...that's on another level of scary, don't even get me started on the remastered version

I dont know why people are so scared of this. I think that the scariest FNAF fan game is Five Nights with 39.

The footage of Impure Mouse just...floating around in the office while that off-putting sound plays gives me chills One thing I learned from horror games: If the song has bells in it, get ready for what you're about to face

Let’s be real here. FNAF would have never made it to Security Breach without Fan Games and Scott knows this

I really love that the original creator of treasure island stuck with the game since the original demo

Damn, Pastra really be working HARD to get these great videos out so frequently.

Honestly, I never really had that much close of a connection to Five Nights at Treasure Island, but there's just something charming about seeing someone on the internet talk about something that really interests them. Your content is great and it's been taking me down memory lane when i was big into FNAF, keep up the good work!

I've always been scared of disney characters that are twisted, and this takes this to a whole other level.

Hour glass should be delt with based on where it enters the office rather than it’s starting position And it should mimic the exact positions of the characters to give you the hint of what to do That would be much better because it moves WAY TOO FAST sometimes

I remember watching people play this game on my tiny old android phone. I waited so long for the full game to release and was so hyped when it finally did. Love your content as always, Pastra!

If they were to add a (Better) tooltip for night 6, I feel like something like "Looks can be deceiving, but location speaks only truth." Would suffice.

I remember Gomotion talking about this game too, but I wanted to see what you had to say about it too! It's interesting how different the energy between you and Gomotion is, and the way you explain the game's mechanics. I think a collab between you two would be neat!

I’d love it if you’d cover the Flumpty series. I find it to be one of the most satisfying and unsettling FNAF fan games, and your thoughts on it would be so interesting to listen to.

I didn’t even know Treasure Island got a remake until today. And holy hell they did not disappoint.

Pastra *NEEDS* to make a video for Oblitus Casa. I really think it is just the perfect sequel this game could've gotten, and I think Pastra would really enjoy covering it. Assuming HE liked the game aswell.

Kinda wish we had a place to watch a vod of your whole experience, it'd be a fun way to go through the game without the ability to play it myself

You're getting adept at placing Clyde's bottom corner 'talking-head' bits through the video. It adds a ton of color and personality without overshadowing the focus on FNaTI. Overall, loved the video!

I cannot overstate how much I love your art style. You're able to capture this creepy but fun aesthetic so well. And your color choices are *chef kiss*. Keep it up!

I've only heard of Treasure Island vaguely and what I remember is very minimal, but CHRIST is this game a genuine nightmare. The title screen Easter egg is such a brilliant idea which I couldn't see coming. Seeing You cover a fan game gives me such high hopes that you proceed in more fangame videos Down the road. Great job.

I remember seeing a playthrough of the original back in early 2015. I never even knew it recieved a remake. I may honestly play it, the fan game that took over my life for a bit was five nights at warios.

Honestly, Mortimer's inclusion as a very rare garantuee-death is such a cool inclusion. It pays homage to another creepypasta in a fitting way while also making sure that it's rare enough that it's unlikely to happen twice in the same playthrough. Love it!

I remember when I read the creepypasta this was based on, I was so blown away that I showed it to my dad and made him read it because I thought he would like it, too. He was not impressed.

I didn't even know there WAS a remake- I thought the game was left behind in like, 2015. Huh. Well, that's nice to know it got remade to a terrifying degree ^^;

I wouldn’t say Treasure Hunt is the "scariest", but it’s definitely one of them, and it needs a comeback.

The thing about this game is, with the original Fnaf, it was a parody of our childhood nostalgia for Chuck-E-Cheese. With this, the devs took our real childhood nostalgia for Disney cartoons and mutated it into a nightmare. The effect is quite impactful.

i think the lack of attack from the pluto makes it scarier than the actual threats. like a terrifying spider under your bed, its there and you cant get rid of it easily

Treasure Island and Joy of Creation are definitely the best fan games in my opinion. of course, i like Candy's 3 and Popgoes, but these two are just... especially incredible.

I honestly had never seen footage from this game until today, but I have to say… I did a work program at WDW in 2016 and if I had known about this game back then, the night I got lost backstage with my friend would have felt a lot scarier! Awesome video, keep it up!

I would love to see you and Gomotion have a collab or stream together talking about the evolution of the fangames. The love and care you two have for the series would be amazing. The clash of personality would be funny too, the cartoon women is the chaotic, energetic one, and the Halloween demon goul is the calm and collected one. And both of your characters have the ability to stretch your limbs to long distances. [Edit: if any of you transphobic morons go into my comments section being hateful to trans people, I have a suggestion for you DON'T]

My most intense fnaf game is figuring out when to mute and unmute my audio when you show a short clip of your playthrough of the game

I can't handle jumpscare-based horror but your enthusiasm is always incredible.

I love how Pastra is really positive about the games he reviews, even ones many people think are mediocre

I love to be reminded of this game. I never followed it or anything, I thought it completely died after the initial demo that Markipoop played, and then later I found out it went through a bunch of nonsense and drama and someone put gods into the story or something like that. I love seeing it again now, knowing that they still did their best to make something out of it even after it was a mess, and it's probably even worth that wait. Plus I gotta love the Oswald and SuicideMouse representation going on since I think it was initially just based on Abandoned by Disney specifically.

A few months ago, while looking for a new game to play, I decided to install this game and it was a blast! The first nights were definitely the hardest part of the game, not only because ur not used to the sounds but also the mechanics aren't very clear (when I first played I thought I had to turn off every camera Mickey was in lol). However with a bit of practice the game gets pretty easy, to the point where I passes nightmare mode 1st try! All in all, amazing game that I personally think it's a bit underrated

I’m sure you may have heard of it, but… have you ever heard of Oblitus Casa? Because it’s a sequel to Treasure island and expands it even further. It may be similar in turns of the night segments, but HOLY CRAP THERE IS SO MUCH TO OFFER! I won’t force you to play it, but if you haven’t already, please take a look.

I played part of the original demo version of FNATI for my channel years ago, and it was utterly terrifying. Definitely tempted to play this updated version 😯

dudes playing dormidabis the most cursed and disgusting fnaf fangame at the start 💀💀

Okay can I just say that it’s really cool that your videos are creepy as hell (affectionate), but you never use jump-scares without some form of warning. There’s never anything there that you aren’t fully aware is coming. It’s always clear when I can just turn the volume down and look away for a moment and enjoy the analysis. :)

Small side note: Love your character doing a lot of expressive poses! Great job on that!!

I love how you make these videos. Even when I know there's no jumpscares I find myself on edge expecting one٫ even to the point where I turn the volume off if you stop speaking for a certain amount of time. And it feels like I have to listen carefully to what you say the same way you would listen to the phone guy in the first 2 games desperately trying to figure everything out. It's an amazing atmosphere and I love it so much

As a fan of old cartoons I am APPALLED that I'm just discovering this game now! Thank you so much for drawing attention to this game! I look forward to checking it out for myself. ^^

I'm so happy he enjoyed this game. Seeing other people have the same passion for things I love is really cool

I love this channel, I love it when he takes his time to upload his genuinely good content, thank you pastra!!!

I’m so glad to see all these old fan games being redone today like treasure island, five nights at Chuck E. Cheese’s, and one night at flumptys. It is so cool to see these games I loved for years polished.

Fun fact: treasure island was the first FNaF fan game to mimic the style of the original game and is the second FNaF fan game to exist. The first FNaF fan game is actually five nights at fuckboys.

Dude i just wanna add my review with this game because dude this fangame its just SOO good to the point where i think its better than fnac. The first thing i wanna talk about is the lore. Dude the lore of this game is soo horrfying. the fact that there were a bunch of employees that were " abadoned by disney " gets the freak out of me. And it is very deep lore too like you have a lot of questions like " why are they trying to kill me or who resurected them or why did we go there in the first place. some of them are never really asnwered wich keeps the entire mystery of the game. The second is just the custom night it self. The fact that the custom night adds a bunch of new animatronics that you dint even knew in the first place its just perfect. This makes the custom night refresh the entire game, instead of being just " a harder night than the 6 one ". The third are the cutscenes after you beat the night, dude the atmosphere of those cutscenes gives me SOO much freaks, because i died one time just because i saw a thing and instally died or i was not paying atetion and died. its just a such perfect mix of gameplay and it just freaks me out everytime i play it. The last one is that its just everything that a fnaf game ever wanted. it is A LOT more chaotic than fnaf 2, because there are soo many animatronics and they do soo many diferent things, it is a bit scarier than fnaf 1 and 3 atmosphere, the animatronics are soo much sacarier than the ones from fnaf 4 and 6 and it has a better custom than fnaf sister location. with that being said i kinda dislike some things. First one is the night 6, it is just soo ez to the point that i died one time and then i beat it, because once you get what you are supposed to do you just lift up your camera kill one of the cameras and then hold your breath and turn of the light at the same time. it just boring tbh. and the last one is that, it is unfair most of the times, i dint even beat the 12/20 mode of it because there are soo many of them at your screen at the same time that sometimes you die either because you are out of cameras or because too many of them are in your room. anyways that is my review but again i think this game is better than all of the games of the fnaf series ( expect with all of them combined because of the lore ) and the best fnaf fan game ever made.

If this is about dormitabis I will actually be SO DAMN EXCITED + new pastra video sooooo😳

Knowing the story of the OG story makes sense why there’s so much more out to get you now pople believe bad things are in there with you so they become real

amazing video, I've seen gomotion talk about this fangame but never someone talk about its gameplay and atmosphere in depth. It's amazing how you keep putting these high quality vids out consistently! 😊

watched mark play old treasure island in preparation for this video and it was worth it as usual!! love how you discuss these games

This video definitely could've made a great April Fool's Joke. "There was one which stood out to me more than any other... One which invested me from a very young age and would come back years later as a terrifying, polished product... And that... I Feev Neets at Blees Clees."

God, your thumbnails are amazing

Dude, this is my favourite video of yours. I keep coming back. This game is amazing, and your videos are so interesting and entertaining at the same time. Keep up!

I love watching your videos. I’ve rewatched many of them just to hear you talk about these game.

I have waited for weeks for this video! I yelled out “Yes!” In happiness when i saw it was uploaded is this channel some kind of drug? :(

I've been designing games, and something that it has taught me is that tutorialization is one of the hardest aspects of the execution of a design, as you could have the best design ever but if you don't tutorialize it correctly, i.e giving too much or too little information in the incorrect way (which is an incredibly fine balance) will lead to a frustrating experience where the player feels directionless in the wrong way.

This is still my favorite video from Pastra, good length, good commentary and overall a awesome video.

In all my times of playing Treasure Island, I have NEVER seen that impure mouse Easter egg. Holy hell that is terrifying when you aren't expecting it

Pastra really be grinding those video game essays and turning into incredible videos, before I could notice I was already at the end of the Video. incredible writing

I'm happy to see someone still remembers Dormitabis haha. My (used to be) best friend was the main developer of that game, and he was so dedicated to it it was insane.

I don’t quite know what it is about this particular video of yours, but it just keeps me coming back to watch again, even if I’ve already seen it more than once. Great work!

"Guh-huh"~Mickey Mouse, after jumpscaring a dude

I remember when the demo originally came out, and I remembered it being one of the most anxiety inducing fnaf experiences I ever felt. While yes it was incredibly janky and the numerous weird choices in the later updates were very eh (but there was also some pretty interesting one's tbf) it still gave you that tight feeling in your chest even if was trying in all it's power to do so. And now seeing it be finished with a new and improved coat of paint and it still having that tight anxiety feeling truly makes it a fnaf and I'd even say a general horror game gem. Cheers Pastra, thank you for covering this game!

Fucking loved the intro at 3:12

Dude I love this content you’re pumping out so quick. Nothing but quality keep it up man 👍❤️

Hey Pastra I absolutely LOVE the content you produce, it's great to listen to while I'm drawing, baking or cooking! Very enjoyable!! Also your character looks fantastic!!!

5:23 *The purpose of this jumpscare being in the remake is to serve as a throwback to the original game, where PNM (Photo-Negative Mickey) jumpscares you for waiting on the title screen for too long.*

Hey man, love your videos! Its been good to see your production quality increase as your videos keep coming out :) I feel like it might pay off well to get a good stand-alone mic or to install some kind of sound dampening in the room you record your audio in. Much love

I love your commentary on these videos, the way you explain and word things is perfect. You are so good at putting your thoughts into words, better than many other commentary youtubers I’ve watched. Matched with the way you always create a creepy atmosphere in your videos, it’s just amazing. You are going to be one of those youtubers that people say “I was subbed before he had a million subscribers!!” It’s just a matter of time before you get to a million. Seriously your videos are amazing and I can’t believe I only just found you! I hope you have a great day 🧡🤎

i like how all ur characters and thumbnails are drawn, very nice and effective. videos are great too!

Seeing this channel grow is gonna be fun!

16:33 mascot Photo negative Mickey and sparky want to have a talk with you pastra