Subscribe if you enjoyed this video! I make stuff like this ALL the damn time lmao

When Dream Smp lore is not enough it's time to research IRL lore.

He’s finally lost it guys, he’s making theories for my fave streamer’s comedy music. Worst part is he’s probably gonna be right…

finally, someone who understands the insane urge to interconnect all his songs just because he says she's beauty she's more than once through them

Can we talk about how wilbur only seems to play characters that eventually just go insane?

The dramatic “THIS IS JARED” cracked me up. Good theory overall!

Can I point out how perfect the name "Pandora" is for the e-girl in this series (assuming this theory is true anyway). I mean, "William" becoming friends with her opened the pandora's box that was his obsessive tendencies. One other thing that I want to mention, is that I've always held the theory that "William" and Pandora were in a relationship when they were teens, but that relationship ended at some point (potentially the Disney World incident), and that's was started a final spiral. Besides intuition, the only other evidence I have for this theory is that according to Wilbur, he based the girl in the songs after a girl he had a crush on as a teenager. And the two did end up in a relationship for a few years, although it ended presumably because the two went different directions in life.

Ive said it in the "Wilbur Soot ARG Explained" video and ill say it again! CCWilbur always makes the characters he plays: 1. Have some kind of a dark past, 2. Have mental issues that DON'T get solved, 3. Be obsessed over something to the point they sacrifice thier life (sometimes they die sometimes they just give everything they own) in order to get that something, And 4. They ALWAYS have some connection to water. Ghostbur can't touch rain, DSMPWilbur had a child with a fish, ARGWilbur has wayyyy too many moments where he stand next to something that is water or is connected to water, in the "Internet Ruined Me" song from the E-Girl trilogy Wilburs character sits in a shower, im not sure but I think that in the official "One Day" video there were puddles but I could be wrong with that one. *ITS ALL CONNECTED!!1!*

WHY DOES NO-ONE SEE THIS - Pandora Braithwaite is the name of Adrian's love in the classic British novel, 'The Secret Diary of Adrian Mole.' I'm not gonna deep dive into all the lore this could uncover, that's Animagician's job, but she's essentially the love of the protagonist's life that he falls in and out of relations with.

The real takeaway here is that Pandora has just gotten the shortest end of the stick in regards to boys

I think Animagician is in love with analyzing lore where there isn't much

I interpreted the "e-girl trilogy" as "I'm in love with an E-Girl" and "Internet Ruined Me" taking place at around the same time but then a few years later when Wilbur's character appears in "Your New Boyfriend" committing suicide at the end based off the motions he does at the end of the music video (like holding the spray bottle up like someone about to suicide with gun in media would do. Can't show a gun on KZfaq doing that so it'd be the next best thing given that it even has a trigger.) But this video was still interesting nonetheless.

oml i loved connecting his songs glad to see an actual theory about this LMAO

My theory use to be that pandora is william's ex and now jared is her current bf and she is an streamer/social media influencer now.

WE GOT WILBUR SOOT CONSPIRACY THEORIES NOW???? HELL YEAH

plot twist: it was a autobiography the whole time

About the yoga teacher, i could imagine that jared was just insecure about another young, attractive guy in Karen's life and demanded she stop seeing him or something, and that led to karen realizing how controlling jared is

HOW DID YOU CONNECT LITERAL COMEDY SONGS TOGETHER TO FIGURE OUT WHO JARED WAS LOL

He's gonna become the next MatPat, he can make a theory out of anything Edit: ladies and gents game theory covered this topic

I can’t wait for when Wilbur comments on this and it’s just like “lol these are just songs that I made”

3:48 this is your MatPat arc, which I go "No way that is possible" and keep watching and explode my mind (no offending)

This is absolutely insane I just have no words. At first when it began I was like oh yeah this is cool, then it went to the Jared part and brain was like 😳😳 ARG

I like how the end was just “Ruined him…FOREVER subscribe!”

funny theory that’s definitely not true but would be cool. maybe an au. Pandora isn’t real. Pandora _is_ the internet. Jared is just some guy who gets william away from the internet. Maybe his boss in his new job. His relationship with the internet runs so deep he sees her as a s/o in a way, and his maniacal mind makes him think “he’s taking her all for himself.”

Wilbur Soot: This is incredible. Even I didn’t know that!

I wish I could see Wilbur's first reaction to this...

Can’t wait till Wilbur sees this and makes a song just to back this up

But consider: William is Jared’s son. Jared watches Pandora specifically because he knows that William watches her (linking to your idea about Jared wanting to connect with his kid/s).

Who's more insane You connecting songs from a Minecraft player Or me for being interested in it Edit : poor pandora

Wait a second… he… he actually has a point…

A couple weeks ago my friend and I had spent a couple hours listening to Wilbur songs to try and figure out some hidden messages that might be in them, and we found quite a few Dream SMP references and we think the songs could be the key to understanding what might happen next

So now we just need to find a way for “Are you alright?” To fit into the whole thing…

*5:56** truth be told, Wilbur actually punched Mickey Mouse and got himself banned from Disney World💀*

I personally don’t think Wilbur worked this far ahead for these songs *but* I do think he’s capable of it, remember he made an arg that we still haven’t completely figured out, and he was the lead writer for the dream smp for the “first season” if you can even call them seasons (and regardless of your thoughts on the dream smp you can’t deny that handling that many characters/actors and making all the storylines weave together in any particular order much less that particular order is a big feat and definitely not something to be forgotten) In other words I don’t think this is true but I wouldn’t be surprised if it turned out to be true

But....maybe the real Jared were the friends we made along the way

I have a feeling even Wilbur didn’t plan THIS much lore in his songs.

"william" i'm scared this character is so similar to me backstory wise

People, he has a point, take noted, he will probably be right...

The only song of Wilburs I've listened to is your new boyfriend, and I'm gonna be honest, I thought you were a bit crazy until you connected Jared and William

So you are telling me, there was a whole ARG hidden behind these songs for so long and no one figured this out? I'm afraid to know whether this is an ARG or real life at this point. But seriously, I appreciate all the immeasurable effort you have put into this video. *bows* Sorry I forgot to comment on this earlier.

This reminds me of that: Me: Hey what are you watching? * looks into my sister‘s Ipad* The Ipad: * playing ten hour gacha life tik tock combinations*

This is so cool! I've been wondering how the songs connected.

SEEING SOMEONE DRAMATICALLY ANALYZE KAREN PLEASE IS TOO FUNNY TO ME LMFAOOKFDGKJLHDSFLGHDFJSGS

“wilburs genre of songs are comedy” *YCGMA INTESIFIES*

ive watched this entire thing without realising im early, also, why does this make sence, like, why does a guy making a theory on a minecraft streamer's songs ACTAULLY make sence

Hmm, interesting never though I would hear about Jared again

Halfway through, I thought it would be funny if Will just commented “Wrong.”

I just wanted to point out that Pandora Braithwaite is also the name of a love interest in the British Adrian mole book series by sue townsed in which Adrian mole does work in an office as well as being quite nerdy and very smart, maybe the book series has something to do with the overarching story of wilburs song.

I never thought that songs about a creep will be this complicated 😂 I love the video though 😊

Honestly, this is one of my favourite video of yours in a while, great editing, great theory well done! Keep up the good work!

Something that I matched up (and am low key very proud of because I'm usually very oblivious) is: On a Livestream he talked about this girl that he dated for two years. This is the girl that he eventually went on and wrote the album "Your City Gave Me Cancer" about. He talked about how he had a massive crush on and eventually worked.up the courage to ask her out for a drink, but didn't know she had a boyfriend at first and when he did they stayed friends but he would see her texting him with a lot of hearts and get jealous. (You can look it up, it's some irl lore) He didn't mention this in the Livestream, but this connects to the line: "like the amount of f****** love hearts you end a text message with" . Which connects that she was in an irl abusive relationship before him. But ya, not that big but still cool.

We need to get this to wilburSoot to see his thoughts...though it might be a little over thought, but you never know it might be true though.

Here's all the Jared Endings : Good ending : Jared Had a good life B a d ending : Jared met Candice then died to ligma Sus ending : Jared played among us Secret ending : Jared met with a e-girl No u ending : Jared Reversed his life Dude wtf ending : Jared becomes god BLAME HIM! ending : Jared gets voted outta existence Neutral ending : Jared becomes wilbur Dharr Mann ending : Jared watches dharr Mann -INSERT ANYTHING ending : Jared gets to vote on how his life goes- Ghost ending : Jared kills himself, instantly regrets it. L a s t x1 ending : Jared Didn't kill his father Balls

It's sorta funny that you called the character "william" since wilbur, who's real name is just will, calls himself William in real-life lol

My english teacher: Finally a worthy opponent! Our battle will be legendary!!!

day one of asking Animagician to do last life lore

these days everything has a mystery and sometimes we find things controversial, next up we would see on trending are: - murder behind Rick Ashley "never gonna give you up"🕺 - notch did "NOT" create Minecraft🤯 - technoblade fakes cancer "here is why"♋ - write your ideas in the comments 🔽

Welp, i guess we've got more lore now. For comedy songs. That are actually pretty deep and disturbing. YAY!

I didn't expect the video to go into this much depth, this is actually really cool. Good job :D

I love that this entire thing has hollow knight background music, a game that is the single most lore-theory rich out of any game I’ve played

I am, in fact, pretty epic. Thanks for that. :D Wilbur is so good at hiding story in plain sight. I'd be genuinely surprised if this ended up not being true, honestly. Wonderful theory.

Just imagine wilbur just wanting to make a song instead of making a theory music ((joking around i love it!)

fun fact: the incel trilogy is in fact canon in wilbur's ARG

Love this a lot. Just wow, the analysis is amazing

This was so good! Interesting theory that definitely will have me thinking about the songs differently and more deeply when I listen to them.

Wait does this mean the person who owns the Dream SMP prison is also the one who dumped wilbur?! (The DSMP prison is called "Pandora's Vault")

When you said there's a reason I'm asking this I was ready to say "they put barriers on the tube line"

wild how ive been a fan of wilbur for ages and since everything going down recently with him all his music wasnt a character well it was but like its really how wilbur felt for years. he was basically telling us what was happening with him and it was interesting content but its sad that it was more real than i could ever know. Im glad he's getting help and going to therapy and i also love shubble's content, It sucks what happened to her i just hate how minecraft youtubers always seem like theres something going on

Yo the quality has improved so much since the dreamsmp wars vids! Keep up the good work!

Honestly this would make a great written story

I know Jared, he’s 19 and he never f__king learned how to read.

love the theory!! just a thought though, is it possible that Wilbur’s music is related to the “editor Wilbur” arg he did on jacksucksatlife’s channel?

Okay…. You can get some new avatar drawings on Twitter now…. The png of you showing up no reason is only a small criticism I have. It looks good. You can commission the same artist. I’m sure they’re amazing. If you could send me a page link I’ll make sure to branch out to them.

I know wilburs discord song isn't Canon, but maybe his "discord girlfriend" is Pandora

Man, this is actually well thought out. next video be like: The secret lore of tommys vlogs lmao

that hit too deep for a literal comedy

Love your videos, always lightens my day when one releases.

Wait?, So like Jared Becomes a Soft Boy (im referring to the softboy song , it was scrapped but there is a unreleased ver. Where Wilbur sang it on stream you can find the clip) so like what would've happened if that got released?

I always knew something was there, those songs were too similar not to be connected, but I never really thought past that. Props to looking into it, great video!

i literally love you bro these videos are so cool 👍🏼

This is an AMAZING theory. Instantly subbed.

This is a really cool theory, also I guess tying in with the name of ‘Pandora’s vault’?? :D

Honestly, this makes a lot of stuff make sense when I have no context. Also Wilbur needs to see this and give answers.

Woah youve been blowing up I haven't seen you in a month since that one fundy lore video and you're almost at 100k congrats

One problem with this theory: the nice guy ballad takes place in 1999, and snapchat was released in 2011, and we know that snapchat was out when William was 17 (vape is charged and snapchat's read), which would mean he's at most 5 years old when the nice guy ballad takes place.

Good video, feels kinda odd hearing the character be referred to as "william" tho because that's actually wilbur's name

The editing of this video is great!

holy wow i love your thories so much!! :)

I think the main storyline is Wilbur (character) was with a content creator then Wilbur (character) became too obsessed with the girlfriend and then the girlfriend broke up with him. The rest is just coming to terms that his obsession is unhealthy and not okay. I see Jared as a genuinely good guy that Wilbur (character) is jealous of.

Animagician has officially become the equivalent of Game Theory for the entire MCYT fandom.

Editing is ON POINT

Damn this theory is intriguing as hell man. Awesome job!

KZfaq "Let me make videos about something " Amagician "Lore"

This has been the best 10 minutes and 38 seconds of my life Thank you

Wilbur: I just wanted to write some simple comedy songs ...

Love how he found lore in the simp anthem of all songs💀

i relate to William so much so sad

It's very farfetched but still makes sense! I love it!

The dramatic "THIS IS JARED" ..it sounds too iconic ..PUT THAT IN THE QUOTE BOOK-

Sometimes I want to kind of questioning your videos but now I can’t question your videos