subscribe so i can hit 100k and release the special (i genuinely believe it's my best video yet lol)

When tommy was confronted about this stream he says that he doesn’t remember anything about it. I’m pretty sure it was in his last laugh you lose stream.

For anyone who doesn’t know: Arg = alternate reality game

Wilbur’s becoming a stalker, he’s the tree demon. Also “happy Easter” might be something will or did happen then

"he stared at nothing for 5 minutes, thats not normal" yeah thats a little more than not normal XD edit: why does this have so many likes, it's not even a good comment

Whatever happens with the arg, tommy played his part really well and I'm so hyped for more parts

I wasn’t going to get involved in the new ARG, but now that you’ve made a video i’m curious. Edit: i know it’s not an ARG- this is an old comment

something that was also found is that in the ending of Wilburs MCC stream, he ended it with a black screen, and if you turn up the brightness, you could see that there is something there (?) dont know if it's ARG-related or not but it could be something Edit: There isn't anything there, I've tried looking it up myself on different apps so I was probably just fooled

I don't know if this is also related to the arg but when tommy was doing his ylyl stream, someone sent him a clip of him when he was covered in mud and was just staring. And tommy said that he doesn't even remember doing that..

8:50 in the YLYL stream 2 days ago tommy said that he would do anything for will and follow through, something along thoses lines so it just proves the point of willbur being a controling charactor this time around, for the audieo clip it does sound like something a deamon would have or the boss battle music for when theres a pure evil ghost villan.

Cloverfield: Makes a massive campaign just to get people to play their ARG Wilbur Soot: interferes with one livestream and everyone goes full Grand Admiral Thrawn on the clip

Guys, the Happy Easter was another one of the test runs to make sure Tommy doesn't question anything. He says it so confidently, that it's almost like he has momentarily forgotten that it is Halloween, not Easter.

"he stared at nothing for 5 minutes. thats not normal" me:*Looks at a piece of rock for 1 hour*

The happy Easter thing made me think of when ranboo and Wilbur named a rabbit "dinner" or something on the dream smp on Easter, but I doubt that connects

I was drinking my pencil but this is more important

Tommy putting on the blue coat could be alluding To the “I’m So Cold” line that was famous in the first arg. trying to keep himself warm from whatever is trying to reach him.

This is probably nothing, but I'd like to point out the fact Tommy tweeted about mud on the 16th- a little over a week before the stream happened. But that's just something I noticed when looking for something haha This is a really good break-down! Can't wait to see what else you get as the story hopefully progresses :)

another clue is that when billzo said something, tommy said that ”william” said it and then willbur said ” i don't trust williams”. Billzos real name is bill. Could some william includ?

this ages... surprisingly

Here we go again *grabs paper and pen and starts theorizing with the rest of the fans*

I mean hey at least Wilbur has experience now

The only flaw I find with your theory is that Tommy digs the grave for the body. 5 minutes isn’t enough time. What I think could of happened is that Wilbur had already dug the grave and was wanting to kill Tommy. Tommy gets the mud on his face after running from Wilbur

This just hit different now

this took "-im gonna start stabbing shit" to another level..

A small reason for why I think the arg is legit is that Will teased the possibility of one happening late october/early november and he said that when it was oct 11th. That would only give him 2 weeks to plan it. Why would he tease about an arg, something he said he'd work super hard on, only to give himself 2 weeks?

Some of Tommy’s blinking patterns are believed to spell out stop. Could be true, but many people have decoded it and just found a bunch of random letters, some of the blinks can be deciphered into S T O P, but the people are ignoring the other blinking and just looking at anything that could mean “stop” When people blink, they blink with what body patterns they are using, if your standing still, staring with no need to blink, you’ll either blink slowly or one quick blink. But when you shuffling to one side or moving in your seat you blink faster, also in Tommy’s TeaSeas stream he said, “I’ll say something in Morse code.” And proceeds to press a bunch of buttons that make sounds of Morse code. Which would probably be him mocking us for thinking that his blinking is Morse code and we’re over analyzing. Idk he could have blinked stop in Morse code, we just don’t know yet, and we only have one clue to be jumping to conclusions this quick-

Does anyone else think that theres something up with when Wilbur 'talks' to chat? his words seem really specifically chosen and I reckon there might be something important about that. I dont know though. its just a theory :D

Another thing I saw was that Tommy said somewhere that Wilbur asked him to move a chair and he said yeah right away and even made a TIkTok out of it. He also said he didn’t question it at all so this could be part of the ARG.

AAAAA im so hype! but here are my ideas on this: - happy easter easter meaning the start/birth of something - autumnal trees die...so start of death mayhaps - idk but i think theres something with the 4 seasons here...maybe we'll get something by christmas 😳

It’s probably nothing but hears what I noticed Wilbur takes his glasses on and off throughout the arg.He asks different when he has them on to when he has them off.Throughout them stream Tommy goes from a shirt to a hoodie to a coat and acts from normal and almost in a trance depending on what he’s wearing.

oh wow what a suprise

Animagician: this must be the start of the new ARG!! Tommy: I was just doing a gag

Ah shit. Here we go again.

“She’s beauty, she’s grace.” It’s in all Wilbur’s songs and I think it has something to do with the girl Wilbur killed in his arg he is explaining what she looked and acted like (that’s just a theory tho)

OK imagine this- What if the "body" was the "dead girl" from Wilbur's last ARG- (I have that from game theory's video :D) What if "Wilbur" found her body and decided to get rid of it- and somehow- Tommy figured out about it so he had to help him get rid of it- Meaning he either went digging a grave for it ..OR He was digging it for SOMEONE in the room- That's probably why he didn't want Freddie to open the door- because he would have to get rid of him- That is just my theory :7 Ya know- speaking my thoughts out loud- T>T

Morse code by blinking is called rorse code. (At least, that's what I've heard.)

This is such a well put together video, all the theories are interesting and I can't wait to see where this ARG goes.

Wilbur claimed on stream it had nothing to do with an ARG and “he hasn’t started it yet..”

Me: wonders “is this a lore stream???? or is this serious and what’s wrong with you willbur???”

I find really fun how people are getting so excited with with the arg while we have so little clues about it yet

Wilbur : control Tommy: is controled Tubbo : panic in mind Ranbow: enjoy halloween 🎃

the dbh soundtrack in the backround just sets the mood of this video :D good job

Ok we now that Wilbur said that it wasn’t an arg but like- I still want this to be an arg like I’ve became obsessed with the idea 💀🕺

I'm hoping we'll possibly get another clue on Nov 16, considering that's the day things to go down in Wilbur's town.

This is also further proven by Tommy's recent you laugh you lose stream, where someone donated the clip of him just staring, and he said, "I don't remember doing that." Strange.

I just imagine Tubbo in the corner just like “Phiiillll, Wilbur’s controlling Tommy again-“

I think the last theory is the best one UvU

6:16 I thought it might be the tree demon, Wilbur is quite tall. 7:10 Quackity, he looks like he is being hypnotized and he is trying to fight it. The jackets- the jackets- R. Fakier used to wear a dark blue jacket, and he was a made-up personality by I. Fakier who didn't know anything about the ‘embarrassing’ incident I. Fakier did and Tommy appears to not know anything after he comes back to the stream- and he was wearing a blue jacket. Wilbur can either be the tree demon himself or he is helping the tree demon, and he wants Tommy to kill Tubbo and Ranboo because they were messing with the tree demon, therefore making the demon angry with them and all of the others because they would be witnesses to the incident if Tommy had actually killed Ranboo and Tubbo, Tommy got scared because Wilbur showed him what he is planning to do, after Tommy freaked out, Wilbur or the tree demon decided to possess him so that Tommy doesn't tell anyone about what's going on. Bluejacket!Tommy is Possessed!Tommy. Also, this *is* probably an ARG, Tommy mentioned in a stream when someone media shared a clip of him blankly staring at nothing by saying, “I don't remember doing this,” and he is also said he did not know what an ‘arg’ is. If the tree demon is not Wilbur, then there might be a possibility that Dream is involved cuz' an app used by Ranboo and Tubbo when they were investigating the tree in Tubbo's garden, once said, ‘smile’ and the phone had been on the ritual circle/star thingy then. There was a smile drawn on the ritual circle/star. Just a theory. Happy Halloween! :) EDIT: Wilbur said his new ARG hasn't begun yet, you can go rest peacefully. My effort and everyone else's effort was futile. Also, the reason why Wilbur asked Tommy to tell Tubbo “Happy Easter”, was because if you unscramble those words, it spells out, “Happy Teaser.” He knew all of us would hear that. I have never felt more like a fool in my life.

Tommy be silent. All of us: alright this is super sus

In Tommy's new video he did have a weird flashback at one point, also ended with him not wanting to laugh anymore

Oh man if only Tommy being quiet was normal

In a new vod, the ylyl one, when a clip of someone speculating this stuff was shared, he said "I don't even remember doing that" later followed by "What's an arg?". There's a huge theory about some doppelganger thing, I won't get into it but the "I don't even remember doing that" kind of supports that theory.

How wrong we were

ooh this is great! the audio sample from quackity's stream is actually from uvb-76, a russian numbers station, also known as 'the buzzer'! so probably not arg related but still pretty interesting, i think i looked up the file name of the sample on the day of the stream out of curiosity and found out about it haha

"he stared at nothing for 5 minutes, thats not normal" Me with ADHD: Are you sure about that?

me realising this is going to be a tales of the smp masquerade irl : ah shit here we go again

maybe the reason why he was acting so _fruity_ that stream was linked to wilburs arg too

Honestly the collapse with no hesitation part is just normal tommy I think cuz it’s Wilbur telling him

Wilbur and Dream can be really scary when you think about it

here is some info about maybe why Tommy said happy easter to Tubbo, Easter also celebrates the defeat of death and the hope of salvation, and salvation is the state of being saved or protected from harm or a dire situation. So maybe Tommy was telling Tubbo he will be safe/protected?

7:05 i think the sample Wilbur sent was a morse code thingy as well. I tried to translate it and i think it said "please" im not sure if im right. Im not good at morse codes but i tried my best

1:18 i remember being on twitch like "oh tubbo is streaming" then i joined and 2 min in tommy came with dirt everywhere and then looked like someone stole his soul and i became worried

The Wake Up Call Arg (It’s my nickname for the ARG) is shaping up to be an INSANE ARG so far and MAN theres a lot to unpack 0-0

You’re my only way of keeping up with stuff, thank you so much 😭 🙏

I like this theory, and it does seem to check out for what we’ve got so far for this new ARG, but I don’t think Tommy was trying to keep Freddie from seeing something he’s not supposed to see. He seemed more concerned with keeping the door locked, I think Tommy was trying to keep the door locked to protect the others from whatever’s outside. Note, he says ‘keep it locked’ not ‘don’t come out’, and runs off after a bit, presumably running away from whatever’s outside.

Mr. Magician strikes again! This is a pretty good stuff man!

I know it was confirmed to not be an actual arg but I still love coming back to this video. The way you put everything together and your explanations and interest in it make me wish it was real just so that maybe we'd get a part 2. Good job man!

also at the beginning of the stream at around 5 mins they say something along the lines of "oh, your finally awake, you've been asleep for so long"

IM SORRY I BURSTED OUT LAUGHING AT 5:47 WHEN RANBOO JUST CAREFULLY PLACED HIS PEEPEE PUMPKIN IN VIEW OF THE STREAM

Can’t wait until you get 100,000 subs, you deserve it!

Wilbur is just cool

I kinda think that maybe the thing is that easter and halloween are on opposite months of the year, and seem to show some opposites. Also i have a feeling that the happy easter quote might be in itself a clue to the arg

I can’t wait for Wilbur to react to one of these

This is actually A Good Theory!:0

I read the title and thought this was some crackpot theory so thank God it’s another ARG

Its just the start of the arg this is gonna be fun Evil laugh : hahaaahaa

2:16 Lol I zone out all the time am I not considered normal? Everyone zones out from time to time to stare at nothing.

I've heard of it but have no clue WTF is going on with it. Happy you made this

Them: *kind of laughing* The entire chat: *Mentally and physically concerned and worried*

I was doing schoolwork but some “adults” role playing is more important

After the first ARG I couldn’t see Wilbur the way I used to see him anymore ( not like in liking him as in enjoying his personality more ) and now he’s probably controlling Tommy! Man this dude scares the living crap out of me I’m scraped of him now that’s it

Would in a sense Tommy's odd behavior from the apple bobbing bit also in a sense be part of it since he stayed long enough in the water the second time getting the others concerned as well?

Don’t worry. In reality Wilbur just said go outside for 10 minutes and come back in distressed

Idk if this helps but the sound Wilbur sended quackity is the transmission from a Russian radio called UVB that has been playing a buzzer for the past 40 years

2:57 sounds similar to the game board game of Clue. Honestly I'm grasping at any references to anything I can with this, but sounds familiar (Edit: screw it, not Clue. A death game)

as soon as people started theorizing my little fish brain immediatly went to marble hornets (I'm not into that anymore) because it seemed like it could easily fit right in with something like that. It would make sense to me if the tree demon was involved somehow if so.

on god i really think this was just a bit like, sure maybe this could all ~mean something~ but its probably not that deep lmao

WHEN I WAS YOUNGER I LEARNED THE “BUNNY EARS”IS LIKE A MOCK

In spanish, specifically my country, they call Easter and Chrismas the same, Easter of resurrection being the one were you look for eggs, and just easter being Chrismas, so the "Happy Easter" could be a telling that the next big clue will come in Chrismas, and could involve Tubbo

I’m suddenly interested in Arg now…

Not sure if anyone else or even Animagician himself is going to arrive here, but in a Twitch stream where Wilbur reacts to The Game Theorist's video debunking his first ARG, Wilbur at some point did question if he wanted to begin his second ARG in *October.* So that piece of evidence only draws closer to Tubbo's Halloween stream, the stream primarily discussed about in this video, further making it highly likely that Wilbur is beginning the aforementioned second ARG in this stream.

So Wilbur calls Tommy, Tommy gets locked out, Tommy and Wilbur do something bad or commit murder which causes Tommy to run and be chased either by Wilbur or by something else. That’s what I’ve gathered. Wilbur has some massive coercion I see. I think the murder theory, but with Tommy being forced by Wilbur to kill someone, or some people. Tommy might have told them to keep the door locked because Wilbur might have been forcing him to try and kill or hurt his friends, as implied earlier in the stream, and he eventually fought it off and made it back inside. I dunno.

Bro, I am so excited!

8:34 i think the chat agrees its the tree demon-

I mean, I don't know anything about ARGs but the video is interesting never the less, so good job with that!

during the apple bobbing tommy actually tried to drown himself. and further into the stream he blinked 'help' in morse code. and when he went to the bathroom after coming back from being outside with leaves in his hair, he was completly normal.

What the actual fucking shit is ranboo’s pumpkin carving

i honestly love the tree demon theory it seems really interesting

Tommy was like that because the queen passed

What if this stream is actually not the first part of the arg (could be a second part) but Wilbur is gonna make an upcoming video that is the start. He might give a hint for the spectralgram