i agree, as a town hall 12, i used to get lots of hype until town hall 14. now a days, new town hall feels like everyday things

It would be great if they released new magic items or features instead of townhalls that often

Dysfunctional has some competition 🥶

I think two years between New townhalls would be good

The clash of clans team can get pretty creative with their solutions. I'll just trust that they'll know what to do tbh.

A new townhall once a year means we are currently 9 months away from a new town hall and we only have 2/3 of the town hall 16 update. 18-24 month cycle is good cause it allows players to catch up and gets everyone hype for new town halls.

An often overlooked thing is that when you go too fast from one th to another, you dont get the full experience of the town hall. I remember going from 6 to 7 to 8 to 9 to 10 and every th had its own new troop and hero that you need to learn because you would be on that town hall for some time. Now you just rush from 11 do 16 using only e drags and not getting the full experience like before. There are little to no incestives to using new troops but before you just had to use them, more or less

I assume they are choosing to try and release town halls more frequently because high level players will max out and stop spending money on the game for a few months until another update is released. I think 18-24 months is a good period between town halls but they really do need to start releasing content for lower town halls more frequently. I think Supercell is being pretty greedy choosing to release new town halls yearly, as it is clear that higher town halls are usually the people who are more willing to spend more money on the game, especially when a new town hall is released.

1:28 BLUD attacked with lvl 0 king?

My idea is to have town halls unlock new abilities and content throughout their 1-5 star levels, with thier own requirements making a town hall have more value, as it would take longer to progress if they made an upgrade to for example th13 1 star ---> th13 2 star have a new building/troop, and requirements such as upgrading your cannons and archer towers form level 17-18. This would also prevent rushers, although I know some people like rushing so idk.

They should do more stuff with Clan Capital too and maybe even builder base. Like a builder base gold transfer or SOMETHING that can reflect back into your Town Hall. Add more attacks to Clan Capital, add more districts, they can use that as a sort of testing ground for new troops and ideas

“What’s the point of upgrading buildings just to suffer.”

I remember when i first started playing clash of clans 5 or 6 years back, a town hall 12 max player was considered a respectable top player. Everyone looked up to maxing out their town hall levels in a friendly compensation way. There was really a huge hype everytime a new town hall came but after town hall 14 things kinda changed. It sunddely feels like there's a never ending chain of town halls ahead and you cant really get to the level u want to be at. It's no longer competitive at the lower stages and the essence of clash if clans is almost lost with little to no focus on players spending time on lower town halls

If we're really getting annual townhalls, I'm just gonna rush from th14 - 16. This is getting out of hand

I think the only problem is that free to play players are going to stuggle with the new hero equipments. They need to make it were every attack gives you some ores so that we can at least upgrade more equipment. Not to mention that its ridiculous that equipment is locked behind a pay wall if you don't get it for free when it shows up in the game.

Im pretty sure it has been said somewhere by the dev that they try to keep a consistent 4 year timeline of consistent play to max out, that's why there are such massive reductions. the low townhalls recently are beginning to take a very short amount of time to get through and catching up is not as bad as it used to be.

Yoh, I 100% agree. It should be every 24 months at least... I never get to enjoy a town hall at the end of maxing because just as I do, I have another town hall to grind and it's even more frustrating as a f2p account. I keep up with the town halls and maxing but to enjoy attacking and getting good at the game instead of farming every single day would be nice.

I’d say another big paradox that is the biggest one is that they said they don’t want to increase base sizes for the grid and don’t want to increase battle times also only wanting 4 max heroes. It’s contradictory as more buildings will need more slots to be made

For me the best alternative is making so every low th level takes 1-2 months mid range th takes around 4-5 months and the newest th takes around 10-11 months so low th players can progress fast mid range players can progress 3 th in a year and almost max players can get max just before the new th

as sosmeone whos played the game for the longest time now casually, and finally hitting th15 it was very annoying when they released th16 so early i think they should combine whatever idea they have for the 17 and 18 into one.. and release every 18 months at the earliest

Imagine after a certain TH lvl, you could “prestige” in a way that puts you back to the start but with certain perks like every time you prestige your builders can build a certain percent faster, or imagine adding new content to earlier TH to allow newer players to experience some new updates rather then seeing a bunch of new troops/buildings/spells/hero’s that they can’t even unlock until 5 yrs of play time

There are three main villages it would be cool if they focused on builder base and capital hall sometimes in order to buy more time for people to level up. Of course this could be kinda boring for the top player but at least they will have events and the capitol/builder base content to keep them busy.

I recently started a new account and was surprised by how quickly you zip past the early townhalls now with the new reduced time/costs. I honestly felt like I was missing out on the low level gameplay.

to all the players complaining that COC is becoming pay2 win or they're just trynna extract money, you guys aren't old enough to understand how difficult the game used to be earlier

I feel like this happens to every company once they figure out how to make colossal amounts of money

with the current rate of things as a free to play each time a new town hall releases you can finish one th and get 10 percent through the next (excluding th 13) this means that you should be one less town hall behind every 10 years

I think the bigger problem is the clear pay grab/wall they are doing by introducing equipments the way they have

I just recently got to th11 by grinding a lot from th7. It is definitely better than it was at the start. But I do believe they might need to do stuff related to gameplay or player experience instead of pushing town halls out for new content. I'm already feeling left out as it is and I might never be able to catch up if they keep doing this. It's not just upgrading the town hall, it's every single building and the walls are just outrageous tbh

Personally one of the most fun aspects for me in CoC is seeing the progression of my base and feeling myself getting closer to the finish line. Just reached TH13 2 days ago. But if TH levels become as frequent as this, I'm afraid I'm never gonna see myself at max lvl, even though that's why I play in the first place.

Im pretty excited for this next gen of commentary KZfaqrs, great content man, keep it up.

I personally think this is just a thing Moving foward but will soon be reverted back to 2-3 years for like TH 18-19. They did say in the Vlog that they want to add more (Blacksmith) like Features in the future for older Town halls. I think a New Troop, Pet, Defense and Theme will be added yearly. The Upcoming super troop event in March sounds interesting. Seems like it's going to be close to the Lunar New Year event but with super troops

Couldn’t agree more, wish this could be shared with supercell to get feedback from us. Me as a player with 5 accounts it is indeed very overwhelming and difficult to keep up with every Th coming out every year even with gold pass and any other accessories as my goal is to max out each base

its good for lower th players, i remember when th12 was long af now it takes like 2-3 months to finish and if they do more cost reductions it will be even faster

as someone who got into COC when i was a young kid back in 2013 having to wait two and a half years to get the new town halls felt like forever. This might just be me being impatient, but a year feels like forever, and I do believe your argument makes good sense if it was like every few months.

A good idea is stopping at a certain townhall, then adding more features. An example would be hero equiptment which came out as early as th8.

I love how from 1 to 11 town hall there are massive game changes. But after that you are playing at the same scale as previous town. If they changed the game from small scale strategy to larger scale it would be cool.

I think they'll add a tech tree or somtin for the upcoming town halls so that each player can have different variations of their own choice for their townhall and possibly different variations for each troops. I hope they go with this idea soon ❤ Edit: I also think they should add a different kind of clan wars where 5 players in a clan with the same TH can merge together and create a bigger base layout where 5 of them can edit their base and defend it, then the opposing clan can attack with 5 members at the same time too.

My solution is simple, CLASH OF CLANS 2

I think it’s fine, bc there’s so many players already that I think it won’t matter if they keep adding town halls

It's just forcing every player to rush if they're a new or mid level player. I think that supercell's best strategy is for a new account to get maxed in around 5 years with all builders down. For each new town hall, the upgrade and resources required for the lower town halls go down to fit the timeframe.

Eventually, there will just be too many town hall levels that supercell will have to find ways to keep updating the game without adding new town halls. A good example of this was the clan capital update, but then again they also can’t just keep adding new village variants like builder base or clan capital. I honestly can’t see a way this problem could be solved really.

They definitely made builder base a lot more fun that what it was all those years ago. I feel like if they did something with builder base that involves more community and collaboration with other clan mates, that would make people start caring about it more

My suggestion is that they add new troops and spells for lower town halls (themed around them). This raises the sentimental value and makes the content accessible to everyone. It also represents a chance to revisit the old themes of past updates, I think that would be really cool.

4:15 is obvious, they will add an expensive "boost" to the shop that will instantly get you maxed. Or maxed 1 TH below current. Mark my words.

They should add stages to each town hall that give a little bit more of the stuff that town hall offers and release a full new townhall every few years

I believe supercell has said that the upgrade times will be constant from now on. Making it so they will only need one time decrease in the lower town halls. I think this is a good solution to it as it will only decrease the sentimental value of lower town halls a tiny amount while keeping the value of higher town halls the same.

Add a sandbox mode, kind of like the developer build, have it switch kind of like the builder base where you travel to the different area, where you can attack other “sandbox” bases and build your own, and have heroes at any level, idk how it would work exactly, but then newer players or players at a lower town hall, won’t get left out of the fun of attacking or using the new troops/heroes

Glad someone's addressing this issue

1. They add a new attack stage, (just like builder base 2.0) i think town hall 8 or 10 are a pretty good place to implement this. 2. More features for town halls below 14

as a free to -play for 9 years im still in town hall 10 i was hyped for town hall 13 but now town hall 13 doesn't feel like a high town hall in feels like a town hall 8 of the past

Hmmmmm, after about 13 seconds of consideration I’d suggest tripling the cost of walls

Hearing “Galadon” just made me smile and hit with some intense memories

I don’t think there is an amazing solution here as they will eventually have to introduce a new Town Hall and over the course of time this means things like th20 or th30 will come around. I think the best solution they have to slow down updates for the main town hall and develop out the “secondary” features and ways to play like Builder Base and Clan Capital. By expanding the breadth of content they can at least slow down the inevitable march of th creep. The only other solution I see is something like a th “prune” where they remove some TH levels entirely and spread the list stats throughout the remaining levels. This reduces the number of upgrades required to reach max but at the cost of removing some iconic clash levels. Not a great solution but it is one nonetheless.

i think a prestige system would be beneficial with new th coming every couple of years, that way max level/pro players could start all the way back over again for a sort of perk and new players could also have the time and attention to catch up

When you upgrade to a new townhall you get 5 days of star bonus and other perks, they can add something like a 50% time and cost reduction on upgrades for the 5 days so that players are gonna do the long upgrades first and it will not take 2 weeks just to do a single upgrade

Eventually if upgrades take more time at every town hall , there will be a literal point where it's impossible to stay up to date to the max town hall level

One idea i got is that you could later on combine Townhalls (like th2 with 3, 4 with 5,...) and combine other levels, so that there are just not as many upgrades to do. I mean bringing an Archer tower to level 21 to get the max for th 15 feels like a damn lot to do, but if th 15 isn´t th 15 anymore and more like th 11 and the archer tower is maxed at level 11 (with the stats it got at level 21 right now it doesn´t feel that much.

They need to make something competitive accessable from every th, but which separates each th completely from the other, such that maxing and mastery is incentiviced, which is what gives players the value and sentimental connection.

I think it's not so bad that they'll release a new TH each and every year. We only had 2 new buildings and a new pet with TH16, so if they continue at this pace, it'll be like more frequent updates with less new content which will be better imo cause upper TH levels will be easier to max out. Like I've complete upgrading my TH to 16 yesterday and both of my scattershots are already maxed-thanks to hammers, started building all the 4 merged defences. If I continue at this pace, I'll max this level out even before a new one comes out in 12 months. What actually boring about this game is in TH13 you have to upgrade your defences twice. They should remove it and none of the TH levels should require a player to upgrade same thing twice.

This is actually an easy problem to solve. You retire certain town halls after 20. So you limit the number to 20. That way max is never unobtainable and older players don't feel they've lost because they retain an advantage

I agree, the introduction of a new TH every year could be the Death of clash

A new town hall is the most exciting thing in my opinion

As a player with 18 accounts and 5 of them being th16 and the rest being maxed out 1-9 I can tell you it’s all about dedication they just want the general player base to be in the middle and the pros need the content to keep it interesting and fun if not then you got the big founders of the game not spending and quitting, they probably will figure something out tho to create a new revenue stream and that will hopefully bring back the th hype

maybe some sorta prestige system? like hitting a certain th would allow ppl to prestige and then reset down to th1 but with incentives to keep them interested

I'm a TH 14 player who usually buys the gold pass and I still feel overwhelmed with the town hall updates. They also add so many updates that makes it harder to get back into the game like the blacksmith. I also liked the mashup event because it was refreshing with a gold pass type event, but now they come so often so they don't feel special anymore. If they slow down on the updates it would be a way better experience for new and old players.

theyll probably add like prestige or maybe co-op town halls or something like that

New content from TH7 to TH12 will be an amazing idea since the majority of the playerbase is at that level

my friend started playing 2 months back, rushed to th9 and farmed, is now a th10 max, took me years to do a few years back.

I think there should be an option to prestige like in the game C.A.T.S where you would have a choice to start from the beginning but have OP perks because of that and become much stronger when you reach the same level again.

i think a problem with clash right now is that currently its quicker to strategic rush instead of maxing everything if you want to become a maxed out th16 or even to just keep up with the new th you need to rush to keep up

In any case, is just very bad, you can see how th16 is still unbalanced , so if there is any time where th16 is balanced, it won't matter because th17 would be in the corner. They are just trying to get nore money with all the uogrades and gold pass. They probably did the math and saw that after 12 months people were already maxed and didn't buy gold pass, that's why they are looking to take the time to 12 months

Beaker, Judo, and Godson honestly really made the game blow up imo

I started my account Jan 11 of this year. I am currently TH12 and pushing hard. I think your video only makes sense for players that max each town hall.

I have both maxed th16 and a th14 progression, maybe they should do something more for the weekend players. Maybe something along the lines of maxed troops on the weekends so lower townhalls can test and see how it’s like to play with those army comps.just a thought.

I agree. TH8 was very satisfying to reach before when TH10 is the max townhall. Now, it requires less grind and arent that special as before

I think they should make hammers easier to get. I know you can get them from league medals but there are not cwl battles very often.

I would say have a maximum time of construction at a certain point so that as you progress, the time limits do not reach the span of weeks. And walls should be limited to their cost and have a maximum cost where once reached, all future upgrades will be equal in cost.

The crusher in your video cover would literally destroy itself

maybe something they can try out is doing an overhaul of the beginning of the game like basically merging TH 1-3, 4-6, 7-8 those being 1-2-3 now and having a more steamlined start con’s would be overwhelming for new players but at the same time a better tutorial can help understand every troop and how to use research lap and such only relation i can think is destiny 2 did something like this, they scrapped the original start of the game and now everyone starts at a base 1k power/light, and everytime they add a new dlc which increase the max cap-they increase the power/light floor that players start off at, now i think it’s 1.3k range essentially as the maximum TH’s increase then decrease the minimum TH’s by combining them into one

I started playing this game to build up my patience and attention span

As someone who as always had a near max th, the game is still really fun every update, but I could def see how if your around th12 the game wouldn’t be very fun bc barely any updates

if they keep up that schedule it will literally be impossible for free to play players to ever reach the max town hall. It takes 4 months of upgrade time if all 5 builders are running continously, to max out th12 if you just upgraded from max th11, with each TH adding another month of straight building time It's very difficult to have enough resources for 5 builders to run 24/7/365, and that's not including walls which costs hundreds of millions, and above th13, BILLIONS of resources to max

Problems with reductions in time and resources are that, if in 4 5 6 years to go from th1 to lets say th 12 or 13 will be the same as today to go from th1 to 8 or 9, whic is kinda okay but a very discusable topic... indeeeddd

As a vet "2012" I think they should test making another main base but in a different league or group once u hit or max out th16 so u would have different th's for 1-10 again but a lot different from the original with new troops and only super troops and up with this different league

I joined when townhall 10 was added and it was exiting when 11 was announced. The warden was one of the coolest heroes to have but they ruined him when they updated him. In my perspective anything after town hall 12 was just ruining the game.

I think it could be a idea to make a new stage somewhat like the builder Base, its then called stage 2 Base and you could switch to them both and play and upgrade things in both Bases and it would be available at like th13 or something

My solution to the townhall problem is after townhall 20, they should make it so thats when Clash of Clans ENDS, and the players that do beat clash of clans, gets to unlock a new route from the village into a new game (they can return to their clash village anytime). As players play this new game they will be able to unlock new buildings and troops to their now maxed townhall 20 (or whatever the max townhall will be). This way, the players can stay townhall 20 allowing others to catch up, while still being able to progress by unlocking new things (slowly) and still having fun playing the game.

Maybe they could alternate between new Townhalls and builder halls each year.

the 18 months felt so perfect man, why did they have to change something that wasn’t broken

The fact that i'll never max out my base as an f2p is what made me stopped playing this game few years ago. I came back several months ago cause of the free gold pass from play pass that is much cheaper than buying the gold pass directly. Sadly, they've taken that away and my will to play this game. Nowadays it feels like a subscription based game, i'll never be able to enjoy this game to the fullest. Not to mention how they make us choose between hero skin and rare equipment and also how they release the skin series. I'm afraid, but this is becoming more apparent, that they are taking the clash royale route.

I think they should only release a new town hall after the average time it takes to max the last town hall as a free to play player because it would give people a chance to catch up a bit

On one hand, releasing more Town Halls at a yearly rate will mean a good amount of players to be behind, but on the other hand, there's always something to work towards.

to have fun u either have to stay at a sertant town hall for exmaple th9, or play builder hall, tbh its easier to max out and its pretty fun if u play correctly

Clash should make the time between town halls the time it takes to max that town hall. So if they start upgrading at day 1 as a free to play as soon as they max they will have a brand new town hall update

Rushed th 13 here, I have been TRYING to FIX MY BASE for TWO YEARS!don’t rush because of an update, it’s not worth it.

They should add other things like spells, troops, and other stuff to slow down needing new town halls, also to just make it like 2 year of no new town halls

I think they should give more and better free rewards like a book every week of that persons choice (not book of everything) and a hammer of 6 months or so it would speed up the free to players quite a lot but not enough so people won’t have fun and they can still have there other free awards that you have to work for so being in a clan still helps you more then just having more troops

Tbh youre right i was at th13 i never thought another new th was gonna came around so fast when i just got to max 13 there was th16 was like the fuk this feels like im tryna play catch up game now they doing this yearly will make it worst, new players will suffer for sure

think in the long run, its like a trophy. you are older and someone sees you play clash and you show them and youre on th48 or something. you wouldve been playing the game for soo long that should deserve a pat on the back and a small loan of 1 million dollars

town hall 12 was so hype at my school when it came out