The Protestant guy said at the beginning of the video that he did everything in his power to disprove what his Catholic friend said about the canon. That shows that he didn’t search for the truth but rather whatever would fit his bias. He discredited the entire video from the beginning. Great job Alex with bringing out facts and actual history.

A 95 Thesis video AND a Council of Trent video? I say YES to both! 🙏

I actually own a German Lutheran Bible from my Grandma that has all 73 books. You are completely correct.

"3 things our protestant friends will not have without the catholic church" 1: The sacred scripture 2: The doctrine of trinity 3: The doctrine of Hypostatic union short canon history The Bible is a Catholic book. The Magisterium of the Church has the authority to determine the Bible canon. In AD -382 Pope Damasus-I At the First Council of Rome, the first complete canon was promulgated ... All 73 books (46 in the Old Testament and 27 in the New Testament) are included in today's Bible. Pope Damasus declared that not a book should be added to this canon, nor should a book be taken away from it. Council of Hippo (AD - 393) Reaffirmed (state again strongly) 73 books in the Bible. Council of Carthage - Reaffimed the declarations of the Council of Rome in AD - 382 and the Council of Hippo in AD -393. In AD - 419 the 4th Council of Carthage confirmed all the decisions of the 3rd Council of Carthage. The Council of Florence (AD - 1442) reaffirmed the canon. Council of Trent AD-1546 Reaffirmed the canon. St. Jerome's Bible (Latin Vulgate) is officially announced once again. The Purpose of the Council was to counter the false doctrines caused by Protestant heresies. *British Bible society* and Robert Haldane (not Calvin or Zwingli or Luther) was responsible for removing 7 books from the Protestant Bible. Under Haldane's leadership, in 1821, a movement began against the British Bible Society demanding that funds not be given to Bible societies that were printing the Deutero Canon. The resolution was passed in 1822, which means that it has been only 200 years since Protestant churches started using the 66-book Bible. In the Heidelberg Disputation (AD1518) and Theses - 17 and 35, Luther quotes from the book of wisdom, Sirach ( Deutero Canon) for his arguments. Martin Luther debated with Catholic theologian Johann Eck in AD-1519 about the doctrine of purgatory... Luther's Arguments are Debunked... With that moment Luther took a stand the book of Maccabees was not part of the Canon ... (Jewish Canon was Right) Luther who rejected the canon of Septuagint rejected classified Epistle to the Hebrews(as it teaches about the priesthood -Hebrew 13:17), James( as it teaches that there is a reward for man's good works, James 2:24) , Jude, 2 Peter, 2 and 3 John, and the Revelation of John as disputed( The Book of Revelation It is not useful to understand Christ, it does not have the work of the Holy Spirit). The question is But why are these books still included in Protestant Bibles? Some Protestants argue that the Catholic Church established the canon at the Council of Trent. !!! So how did the Deuterocanon appear in Martin Luther's and other Protestant Bibles? Doesn't it sound strange...!!! Huldrch Zwingli published the Bible in German in 1531, Martin Luther in 1534(German), and John Calvin in 1560 (English)All these included 73 books. In AD -1611 the king James version of the Bible was released ... and it had 73 books. The 7 books of the Old Testament were included under the name Deuterocanon....Interestingly, many references were used from these for the New Testament. After AD-1885 the Deutero Canon books were removed from king James Bible... Gutenberg Bible www.gutenbergdigital.de/gudi/eframes/index.html Luther Bible 1535 archive.org/download/lutherbibel1535 Geneva Bible of 1560 Edition: archive.org/details/TheGenevaBible1560 King James Bible of 1611 Edition: www.kingjamesbibleonline.org/1661-Bible/ God bless you brother❤❤❤

I'm guessing the small number of thumbs down votes are Evangelicals that still think the 66-book KJV Bible dropped from the sky when Jesus ascended into heaven. Great video!

Lol, you and Shameless Popery responding to the same video on the same day! Excellent!!! You gotta gives Joe's response a watch also! ✌️❤️‍🔥✝️

Thank you Alex for standing up to the Catholic faith, god bless you brother, dominus vobiscum

I met a “Orthodox” and all he did was trying to prove me Catholics wrong, I proved him Papal Infallibility and Immaculate conception and he couldn’t disprove me, so he said that I had no proof or just responded with “no”. When he realized he was also attacking Orthodox with saying that we shouldn’t ask Saints to pray for us or that Mary wasn’t sinless, he told me he will become Lutheran, just so he could be against me. These Protestants really hate Gods Church.

🤣🤣🤣 thanks for doing this video Alex! I’m Jessica 🙋🏻‍♀️🤣 you’re welcome for telling you what to do 😂

"Easily refuted" the Catholic position. LOL. Yeah, nothing like accessing derivations of 16th century novelties to shoot down something that's been around for 2,000 years. All that time he spent on Adobe just to come out looking incompetent.

1:18 I’m so glad you’ve found a way to be both fruitful and edifying!!! God bless, brother!!!

Brought my first icon it's coming tomorrow!

Thankyou brother I’m going to Catholic Church this Sunday

PLEASE MAKE ALL 3 OF THOSE VIDEOS ESPECIALLY THE COUNCIL OF TRENT

On indulgences, i highly recommend people chrcking out shamless popery's video "8 myths of martin luther and the reformation" Joe eviscerates prot arguments in that. He also did a video on rebutting this same prot video too. I appreciate you showing basically the full video and touching on points Joe didn't.

Another canon argument that I’ve become interested in is how undecided it was all the way up to its solemn dogmatizing at Trent. While yes we have many regional councils and even ecumenical councils prior to Trent that corroborate the Catholic canon, we can still see disputes over certain books through history even with cardinal Cajetan in the 16th century. This indicates that the canon was not so big an issue for most Christians that the church had to define it, because they had the church to teach sound doctrine. If Sola Scriptura was the paradigm, we should expect to see the canonizing of scripture far earlier in history and far more solemnly, but we don’t.

I hope i can download this one so that i can listen to it offline. I'm a baptist and i'm open to learning about the catholic faith. The Internet is not stable here in the philippines. 🙏 Blessings 😇

Great rebuttal brother. You gotta love how protestants talk about the early Church but never admit its catholicity. This guy obviously did not go to a catholic to get his explanation. He probably went to James White...lol.

Keep smacking down those lies! Good work!

Alejandro! Alex! 🤣 I love your sense of humor! I'm so glad I'm one of your subscribers! Did I tell you that I have a brother named Alex? Well, we call him Alex, but his name is actually, Alejandro, en español. 😁😊 Nosotros tambien somos mexicanos! ✊🏼👍🏼👏🏼🙏🏼

Do both video ideas. Go over indulgences and Council of Trent. Do it. Also, W video Alex

Its mindboggling how blindly they still reject the deuterocanon without knowing why they do. Especially now with being able to search anything on the internet to cross reference so easily. I want a protestant's reaction to Wisdom 2:12-24, praying it would be along of lines of "Oh wow that is literally prophesying the whole gospel"

I was also going crazy watching this with you.. Gosh, repeated arguments that have been refuted more than a million times

Great video thank you @Voice of reason @Alex GOD Bless your family and you. Robert from Puerto Rico 🇵🇷

Thank you for this video! You are my favorite youtuber, and I watch you daily. God bless you, and as always, PRAY FOR ME, A SINNER.

Bro - you’re the best - keep crushing it 🔥 - god bless 🙏👊

26:22 yes, I want you to do additional videos. Oh, on what topic? Doesn't matter the topic. I just love listening to your voice. #bass

I love it! Thank you 🙏 keep going! Viva Cristo Rey!

Déjà vu for fans of Shameless Popery

Id love videos on the counsel of Trent and indulgences

What does the selling of indulgences have to do with how the bible was put together? His video just went completely anti-catholic bc its not a genuine video about the bible. You know what I think is so interesting? When we start having the debate with protestants about the bible or authority somehow we always start discussing Luther (whether its protestants or Catholics) as if Luther is their "authority". Seems to me whether protestants like or or not they look to Luther as an authority and if they don't they still have an authority at their church whether its a pastor, elders, a board, etc. So why are only Catholics badgered about authority? 🤔 I would LOVE videos over what each of the counsels taught.

I'm a Protestant asking where can I get a Catholic Bible with these seven extra books? Thank you

When it comes to Protestants its a case of, “what came first, the chicken or the egg”, THE CHURCH OR THE BIBLE? If they can ever figure that out we can all move on.

At this point should we even take protestant serious at all especially since he ends the video about running away. You would think he will be humble enough to get feedback.

Yes, please do a video on the Council of Trent!

Protestants should look up Lloyd de jongh if they want to know what kind of man Martin Luther actually was.

Council of Trent vid would be very useful

This is good stuff. I am looking forward to those additional videos.

Excellent video! I have a King James Bible with those 7 books in it.

Oh please do a video on going over the Council of Trent🙏. I'm looking forward to this. I'm also looking forward to you debunking the myths that Protestants make to argue with; keeping my fingers crossed for those two videos🤞. By the way, love your videos man, very inspirational, and very educational too. Keep up the good work and may God bless you🙏.

God bless you Alex🙏

I sometimes get frustrated from all of the lies and false accusations protestants and others hurl at the Catholic church. Then, I derive comfort from it, because I'm reminded that Jesus told us we would be hated: John 15:18-20 18 “If the world hates you, know that it has hated me before it hated you. 19 If you were of the world, the world would love its own; but because you are not of the world, but I chose you out of the world, therefore the world hates you. 20 Remember the word that I said to you, ‘A servant is not greater than his master.’ If they persecuted me, they will persecute you; if they kept my word, they will keep yours also. It affirms to me that the Catholic church is the only true church, because it is being persecuted like her Lord was. 🙏⛪️✝️

Very informative! Can't wait for your follow-up videos!

At the time of Jesus there were already several sectors and disputes within Judaism. It soon becomes invalid to turn to Judaism to discard the books used by the Church Fathers. To justify the demonic Luther.

That is correct. The reason for these three councils is because some used different gospels such as the Gospel of Mary, Gospel of Thomas, or Enoch. That is why those councils were established

Voice of Reason ain't nuthing ta F' wit! Voice of Reason ain't nuthing ta F' wit! Voice of Reason ain't nuthing ta F' wit! Voice of Reason ain't nuthing ta F' wit! 😂 ✋️🤚

That counsel of trent video is a good idea.

The easiest way to refute Protestants on this matter is to ask them, "how many archangels are there? Name at least 3 of them." They won't have a clue if they only use 66 books as the source. 🤭

I would like for you to do a video covering the council of Trent. I have protestant friends who their pastors have sermons on the council and they misunderstand or malign. But the council seems pretty dense for all lay people to just read through

yea the Aussie guy spews a lot of anti-catholic garbage. Yes, Marty suffered from usurpation & scrupulosity. Great video!

Way to tear this protestant argument to shreds Alex! Also the division of Torah, Writings and Prophets in the Jewish Tanak doesn't fully surface until about 900 AD and even then their division doesn't match the modern Jewish Tanak.

Heresy is temporary. Wu-Tang is forever.

From my understanding many of the Jews that held to other text other than the Masoretic Text tended to convert to Christianity a main reason they rejected other texts in the Tanakh.

Wake up it’s another Voice of Reason video

“We are obliged to yield many things to the Papists (Catholics) that with them is the word of God which we received from them, otherwise we would have known nothing about it at all” (From the commentary on St. John chapter 16.) -Martin Luther

"This prominent marketing phrase" for the Vatican in Italy, mysteriously written and rhyming in modern English...

Thank you!❤

I love your videos bro !! God bless you brother 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

He uses Jan Huss to support his argument for indulgences. Huss was condemned by the Roman Catholic church and declared a heretic. On July 6th 1415 Huss was burned at the stake. Huss was the leader of the Bohemian reformation that started over a hundred years before Luther . His crimes included offering the cup to the laity, educating women, translating the Bible into Czech and preaching "faith alone".

Yes council of Trent. We want to learn our faith more and more

Whoever invented Tanach was clearly anti-Christian and took the opportunity to completely redefine Judaism. If you use this book as an excuse to justify Luther, you will also become an anti-Christ.

Great video Alex your so smart

Joe Heschmyer did a podcast on this today

We need the video of the council of Trent and 95 thesis

Another false position of the Protestant is to assume that because the deuterocanon is not found written in the Hebrew language, then it follows that it was therefore not among the ancient Jews… But you see, the Dead Sea Scrolls confirm Deuterocanon books in the Hebrew language and the later Masoretic Text “disappeared” them. Because the Jews did not have a list of books among them. They rejected their King. No central authority = lawlessness.

Do a video on both 95 thesis & council of Trent. People need the truth.

Good on you brother Alex love u from Ur Samoan Christian brother here 🇼🇸☦️🫡

At the time of Martin Luther there was already a translation of the Bible in German before his

I have the 1611 King James Bible and they have those 7 books in a separate section. When I first got it, I wanted the cover to be engraved with my name along with, "faithful Catholic" under it. I got that Protestant Bible along with the English Standard Version as well. And then I found out later that the English Standard Version has a Catholic edition. I got those Bibles so that I can use them with Protestants when I have dialogue with them. I can say to them, see it's here in your Bible version, which by the way, the Catholic Church gave you. 🤣

Thanks for this. How did you learn everything you know?

great video

You remind me of St Francid DeSales with a sence of humor

Nice. Pls create a video about the Council of Trent

Also indulgences weren’t exactly bad either. They were also cheap for that time too. Extremely cheap. And even said that if you had nothing to offer just go into prayer and whether u bought and indulgence or not you had to make a mini pilgrimage. And if you couldn’t you would be assisted in your situation. The church was and always has been very providing.

I would love a video all about the Didichae. How old it is, who they think wrote it, How it is similar to Catholicism and the the catechism.

I am not your boss as I am not a patreon user but I enjoy watching your videos, Particularly the ones in Spanish and I am trying to introduce my mother into the Byzantine, rite Or at least help her understand it, since I have been attending liturgy for the last 2 years. I attend both on Sundays but my mother doesn't understand that they are catholic under the pope as well as many other rites. Can you do a video in spanish about the other rites and the Liturgy and how it is still catholic and not Orthodox?

14:00 Most of Protestants I debated was saying that Synod/Council of Rome 382 is a fictional council, since the document are coming out later in Pseudo-Gelasian Decree (6th century)

I'm a protestant guy and I would like to learn more I'm really open minded

Luther didn't remove books from the Bible . He died before the Council of Trent decided on the canon. The Canon is still open.

did anyone else notice 25:41 the video VoR is responding to spelled council of trent as "cousel" minor spelling error? on the internet? its so over for you

Was the Ethiopian bible canon or was it corrupt? i heard that the Ethiopian bible has more books and was created before the catholic church compiled the 73 books of the Holy bible.

Circular reasoning: the Books of the Bible are inspired and so is the CC which tells us which ones are inspired, therefore the 66 + 7 are inspired.

In that silence, we can discern, in the light of the Spirit, the paths of holiness to which the Lord is calling us. Otherwise, any decisions we make may only be window-dressing that, rather than exalting the Gospel in our lives, will mask or submerge it. For each disciple, it is essential to spend time with the Master, to listen to his words, and to learn from him always. Unless we listen, all our words will be nothing but useless chatter. (Pope Francis, Gaudete et Exultate, 150)

But Tobit 4:9-11 says: 9 So you will be laying up a good treasure for yourself against the day of necessity. 10 For charity[a] delivers from death and keeps you from entering the darkness; 11 and for all who practice it charity is an excellent offering in the presence of the Most High. And Tobit 12:9 says: For almsgiving delivers from death, and it will purge away every sin. Those who perform deeds of charity[a] and of righteousness will have fulness of life; Did not Jesus encourage us to save up treasure in Heaven, in various ways including by helping those in need? Would love to see a video where the quotes of the Deuterocanninical books are quoted in the NT including the bits of Daniel that are missing from Protestant Bibles.

Well done Alex.

Glory to Jesus Christ!! Can u plz make a video abt the Catholic charismatic movement? I grew up Catholic but I was raised also in the charismatic side of my parish. I’ve been hearing a lot of stuff lately that’s been making me question it, mainly bc I had my conversion thru one of those retreats. I just really need helpful information that will clarify things cuz it’s a hard time for me just finding this out and not knowing how to act. Plz pray for me to have light in my life bc as said in the Bible God is not the God of confusion. God bless 🙏🏽🙏🏽

I wonder if he gets the LDS ad that I keep getting.

@VoiceOfReason_ Where can I find documentation that the early church used, as part of its criteria for establishing the biblical canon, that the books of the bible had to have been used in the church's liturgy? I can not find anything that says this.

This is why the books of Maccabees should be ignored as inspired is because the author literally tells you he wrote it and it is coming from him. This is why this book should never be used to draw doctrine from like Purgatory. The Compiler’s Epilogue 38 If it is well told and to the point, that is what I myself desired; if it is poorly done and mediocre, that was the best I could do. 39 For just as it is harmful to drink wine alone or, again, to drink water alone, while wine already mixed with water is delicious and enhances one’s enjoyment, so also the style of the story delights the ears of those who read the work. And here will be the end.

Hi Bro Alex! I started following you after i watched you & Dr White. Will you be my chat friend? How & where? Pls!

Why was the first video trying to make the op debate a Matt Walsh lookalike

Protestants should read thesis 81 and 71

In Maccabees we see the doctrine of resurrection also Hanukkah. Jesus did celebrate the feast of lights John 10? Also the miracle of the menorah.

With the context of the theses that Martin Luther says, you find that he was referencing the pope when he said, “He who speaks against the truth of apostolic pardons, let him be anathema and accursed!”. Thus, Martin Luther did not say that he accepted indulgences. If you do not believe me read the theses 68-76 and tell me where he really says that he accepted indulgences as an act of being forgiven, and where he really says that they will be accursed.

Sheesh you know your stuff and you look young i would expect a man with grey hairs to have the knowledge you have 👏🏽

Jude confirms what he said about the muratorian canon.

A video on SSPX plz

the Bible came to us by Jesus. He gave us the holy book. and King James translated it into English!!!!! That's how it came to be.... Just joking. lol!!!!!!!

Didn't joe heschmeyer do a video on this early today?

i feel like i'm the only one reads apocrypha. the reason they got ditched was because of self sacrifice and putting on the armor of G-d. those 7 brothers that married the same girl got chopped up to pieces with their mom in the Maccabees. the Jews went Greek with Alexander the great. instead of trusting G-d and fighting Alexander, they jacked all the temple gold and made a huge golden shield got on their knees and bellies, crawled to the Romans, licked their toes and asked the Romans to get rid of the Greeks. when the war was over they had to pay taxes for the war. Give to CEASER what belongs to ceaser !!!