Creeps, what’s your favorite part of ‘Mac is a Serial Killer’? 🪚 Have you ever dated anyone on the DL?

Not saying it’s necessary but a guest appearance by Danny Devito himself would be legendary

I know we all like to point out how Glenn is so much like Dennis, but we should also appreciate that he seems like a very sweet, supportive friend. The way he realized Rob was genuinely upset over being late and reassured him it was fine and he should calm down was really nice. Also made me think of how happy he was when Kaitlin showed up for the St. Patrick's Day podcast.

One thing I love about the scene with Dennis having to come back to reality of not actually killing the Waitress is that he says "yeah but it's not actually as fun as [really killing her]" and Dee says "Yeah I know, I know, but it's good enough". It's very blink and you miss it but it carries the implication that Dee also fully understands that it's 'not as much fun' because she also has these fantasies. The twins having these bonding/friendly moments over their mutual monstrousness is one of my favourite background things in the show.

Charlie having Danny DeVito artwork in his office is so natural.

"well there was like an 18 minute delay in YOU showing up, rob" fucking KILLS me

"unlike the victim, you have a life" was a banger of a line lol

Hilarious that Rob and Glenn LIVED TOGETHER and he still didn’t catch on that Rob and Kaitlin were dating. Very relatable 😂

"Pepper Jack love Fraggle Rock." Best line in the entire series.

Charlie as the lawyer, combined with the fact he literally can't read - has to be one of the funniest threads in Sunny.... "He totally besmirched me today and I demand satisfaction from him"

Really like the balance between talking about the show, and just chatting, in this episode. Nice to get a solid chunk of each. Fun to creep on.

Someone strategically placed a pen in Rob Mcelhenney office at 50:30 knowing full well he would instinctively place it in his mouth lol. I love you guys, I love your show and these podcasts, I'm happy to be a youtube creeper. You guys have made me laugh and smile for so many years. Thank you!

Meg saying "Another thing is feeling superior to the victims" is so fitting with the gang

Charlie talking about miscommunication comedy and my mind immediately shoots to the cream pie scene, little kids love cream pies

The part that has me dying laughing every time is when they are chasing The Waitress as a clown and painter, and Dee's shoes are squeaking. But its not that they are just squeaking, its that they are only squeaking when she is on screen. They show a close up of The Waitress and then Dennis and there is no noise, and then the close up of Dee and you hear the squeaking. I start wheezing from how hard I laugh every time!

Love how they each kind of fit their character, as you see Rob's pen that he's clearly been chewing on, "It's okay you can tell me doc, Mac's always sucking on the pens in our apartment"

*love* how quickly Glenn goes from "oh, no" to "should we give them something?" when they start discussing the possibility of people getting off to the podcast 🤣

That "well, Rob, thanks for joining us" had me rolling at the end 🤣

Mac coming in hot as always. Hoped he was going to say he had terrible terrible news.

I LOVE hearing the story about Rob keeping his relationship with Kaitlyn secret, and hear about how she would pass out in yalls like movie futon thing, it really puts into perspective that all of you guys were legit real friends outside the show. I dig it.

Missed the episode this week. Had a heart attack on Monday and needed a stent. Beat 2 cancers and now a heart attack! Finally doing well enough to watch my favorite podcast/KZfaq!! I’m an official Creep!

Megan is just so, so great. I'm so happy she's taken a more prominent role in this

LMAO at the framed picture on Charlie's wall.

Timestamps: 0:00 Lice, worms, cannibalism and ghosts 2:20 EPISODE DISCUSSION BEGINS 2:25 Charlie loves the episodes (he's just analytical!) 3:10 Lawyer Charlie, Law and Order, Drakkar Noir 5:57 "Not so young and attractive"/Larry Byrd improv/Kaitlin's improv as Dee 8:10 Pepper Jack 9:21 Farcical humour 10:30 To Catch a Predator (2004-2007) parody 11:00 Dennis and Dee chasing the Waitress 12:53 Gary the neighbour 13:40 Charlie finds the heads/Gary killed some drifters too/Megan's blonde women theory 16:07 ROB IS LATE AND SWEATY 18:20 Mac is funny when he keeps secrets/Mac is rude to Carmen/"Ooh not really into the whole condom thing" 20:30 Set of Mac's bedroom 22:10 Honey Bunch, source music and score (continued at 25:05) 23:36-25:03 ADVERTISEMENT (BetterHelp) 25:39 Rehashing and delays fucking up the conversation rhythm 27:08 Separating dates from personal life 28:47 Glenn didn't suspect Rob and Kaitlin were dating 30:30 Privacy and oversharing 32:35 Differentiating characters from the actor's personality/Appreciation for work vs celebrity and fame 35:00 Charlie loves Sunny memes 36:10 Famous actors get big roles 36:50 Parasocial relationships 38:40 Charlie is conflicted about selling himself to sell his work 39:55 Masturbation (Rob wants to know if Glenn wanked off) 42:42 Who pooped the bed? (Johnny Depp trial) 43:48 Revenge escalation 45:47 Megan likes the guys' honesty in the writers' room 46:46 The origin of The Gang Replaces Sweet Dee With a Monkey/Silliness in Season 3 47:46 Direct communication out of respect "yeah yeah yeah not that though" 49:08 True crime 50:05 MEGAN LIKES TO FEEL SUPERIOR TO VICTIMS cut that cut that cut that 51:27 Glenn has no patience for true crime 52:24 "Because unlike the victim, you have a life to live." -- Megan Ganz (absolute legend) 53:05 Creeps masturbating to the podcast (and David Hornsby) 54:14 Charlie Made a Smut Film (My Erotic Tales 4) 56:32 "Glenn, how many times have you masturbated?" says Mac as he puts a pen in his mouth

I love listening to Glenn because you can hear how active his mind is, he's constantly re-thinking his setences and it's so nice to hear someone similar.

“Drawing a confession out of someone is like doing a beautiful dance, a beautiful dance…with a chainsaw.” 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Rob apologizing for being late and saying things like "my time isn't more valuable than yours" shows how much of a great guy he is ❤️

My single favorite moment in all of Sunny is Frank ripping the chainsaw at the end and the hard cut - such joy on his face!

Megan’s explanation of her watching true crime shows and the moment she feels smarter than the victim is an inside look into the mind.

Dennis being Chris Hansen is hands down the funniest scene in the entire series. I die every single time

The glorious ONGO GABLOGIAN behind Charlie is why I love these dudes.

52:24 "Because unlike the victim, you have a life to live." Megan's input this episode is so great. She's a star! And thanks for getting all the old podcast episodes captioned last week!

Glen gently telling Rob to calm down is perhaps the only time I've heard that phrase said in a way that actually felt gentle and reassuring (as opposed to infuriating)

I'm happy Charlie brought up his Hot Ones appearance. Always felt he didn't want to be in that chaos while most others embrace it. Knowing he enjoyed it in retrospect is nice.

Would love to see Jimmi Simpson and David Hornsby as guests!

The fact that in this episode they revealed right away that Mac wasn’t a serial killer instead of at the end just made it even more funny, because it shows just how worked up the rest of the gang was over absolutely nothing lol

love that you guys spent a lot of time breaking down the episode this time. I love all the distractions and off shoot conversations too, but I really enjoy the longer ep discussions :) especially for this episode which is one of the greats

I like it when the gang has paid sponsorships and they tell me to try the product or service. I feel like I'm getting in on the ground floor of a reverse funnel system with them. Invigaron.

The creampie episode in the restaurant is classic confusion on both parts 🙏🏻😂

Charlie’s numerous “I’ll allow it”s while Mac is on the phone with Dee while she’s inviting him over in a disguised voice.

Megan, you gotta go more off the rails. "unlike the victims, you have a life to live" killed me right away.

I love the scene where charlie is talking to frank about how frank was doing some weird stuff with his genitals one morning and frank says "We can go tit for tat on that one so you better drop that subject" as if they're both big time lawyers who are trash talking each other

Surprised there hasn’t been a DMV episode. Would be a fun context for the gang….Frank does need a new license…sacred place for Dennis, essential for proof of legal age

Charlie's "No one dies when that happens. Not usually," in response to discussing masturbation vs. murder victims was not acknowledged and it probably should have been.

This podcast is a saving grace to the fans man.. I would normally go to Reddit to find a solid fan community, filled with incredible memes, great one-liners, few zingers, updates on seasons, news and EVERYONE wishing that you guys would eventually do EXACTLY what you are doing right here. This is what the Sunnie's needed. I think I can speak for all your diehard fans when I say thank you guys so much for putting this out. We love it. We just love it. 🤘🧀

This episode has my favorite moment from the show... -- Dennis getting excited to choke the waitress and then getting disappointed when he remembers they aren't actually planning to kill her. It's his genesis as a true psychopath. -- edit: 11:32 - Yay!

Charlie's various lawyerings are some of my favorite moments in Sunny

Love what Megan said about appreciating when people are direct and treat you like an equal vs being passive aggressive and uncommunicative. I also prefer directness and honesty but pretty much everyone I know is a delicate doily that can’t handle criticism

I love how wide their grins get talking to each other. It’s always good to be a part of a group that genuinely enjoys working together.

Keep making Meg more of the show. She’s the voice of the fans.

These episodes just keep getting better. I loved Meg playing the voice of the average viewer giving amazing prompt questions! Going through the episode deep details and talking about what they liked critically and then moving through it to transition to where they were in life then and how they are now. This is so great can't wait to keep watching this evolve.

29:30 Wait, so Rob and Glenn became roommates in real life. That just blew my mind. Totally life imitating art or art imitating life

1. And now we know where Mac being secretly in love with Dennis comes from -- Rob's prurient obsession with Glenn's orgasms. 2. Glenn has been super sweet the past 2 episodes -- is he on a mission to convince us he's not really like Dennis after all? 3. Will I ever be able to watch this show and not attempt to psychoanalyze their relationship dynamics??

I love how Mrs. Mac tells them Mac is guilty just to get rid of them 😂

"Honey bunch" is my favorite track of the entire Always Sunny score so I'm happy that it got mentioned here, but also the rest of the score is so so good!

It was kind of sweet and heartwarming to see how sincere Rob was to everyone about being late. like dude could've just made a bunch of jokes about it, but to be kinda vulnerable for half a minute was wholesome.

I like the spoof episodes cause it mixes it up, and the Dennis making a murderer episode is so funny to me! I think people enjoy those style episodes

Great to see Megan stepping up on stream!

I'm only disappointed you guys didn't mention the final moment, the big payoff to Frank carrying around that chainsaw the entire episode... I can't remember any other time I literally _cheered_ at the cut to credits. -- It's amazing how the gag of the chainsaw constantly being there the whole episode makes that moment at the end last just a beat or two longer and it feels like we realize the obvious action to take _juuust_ as Frank does...

"tell your story faster" I am always agreeing with Glenn on like everything

19:29 "I want to be with you, I just don't want anyone to see me with you." or something like that. It would be funny if you did an episode kind of like that but where Mac's hiding that he's dating a notorious homophobe/anti-gay propagandist and the gang's all criticizing him for backstepping from his sexuality and the guy he's dating treats him exactly the way he treats Carmen. Like at the end of the episode he could just repeat what Mac said to Carmen or something.

0:11 Glenn has that grimey Bill Burr laugh🤣🤣

I 100% thought that it was implied you wrote this so that Gary was only killing blond women BECAUSE of his infatuation and obsession with Sweet D, like the set up that she knew him WELL beforehand, like I'm talking a decade or more (Whenever she moved into her apartment), because she water his plants, she treated him like a dog at the hardware store, the little things that her preexisting relationship with him made him the man that he became, that D's influence on him, whether that be for better or worse, made Gary into that serial killer. And now you're telling me there was no forethought about this whatsoever and that it fit perfectly with the theme of the show without ever intentionally doing so? WOW!! That's genius for ya! lol

Bruhh night man, viet vet Charlie and blowup doll Dennis is priceless 😂

Rob is detailing his fantasies about Glenn while calling us creeps. I liked this one best so far. Can't wait for next weeks episode. It's about happy boys. HAPPY BOYS!

Omg pepper jack and the fraggle rock thermos is too funny. Love how you guys brought him back for lethal weapon.

Glen should create and sell his own cologne: “Implication by Glen Howerton”

i just want to say, the editing in these episodes is phenomenal and most podcasts dont even bother to edit this much, so thank you.

23:16 Rob says “No!”, but Charlie was totally dead on! Hahaha

Would love to see Rob/Glenn do a Hot Ones episode ! Sean Evans is one of the best interviewers and Charlie’s episode is definitely one of their bests.

Glenn, when Rob finally joins the podcast and you go "Thank you...thank you so much" 😆😆 I was dying.

Glenn would make a wonderful voice actor or impressionist.

Megan just KILLED me dead "Because unlike the victim, you have a life to live." I laughed SO HARD.

“Rob’s hair is looking great today.” -Creep.

The podcast is tremendous helps me get through work shifts as well as lunch breaks and just chillin at home watching

Charlie's picture of Ongo in the background is outstanding.

Meghan is hilarious this episode 😂 I love hearing about the behind the scenes experience working on Sunny!!!

Watching the podcast and then watching the episode they are discussing contextualizes the episode so well. Definitely bring back that style of comedy, the miscommunication style. It’s brilliant. Also Charlie’s lawyerings are top 3 bits of the show for sure lol

Loving Megan's dark side! I say delve. One of my favorite jokes in this episode is when Charlie is asking Mac who all knows and he says "just her" and Charlie says something like "well she isnt gonna say anything." Way too funny.

Charlie and Frank taking photos with the chainsaw breaks me lmao

Glenn going full Dennis at 43:05 while deciding that he's vengeful enough to shit the bed is exactly what I needed this morning, thank you.

There was like an 18 minute delay in you showing up Rob. ZING! Megan is on fire today!

I spent a large part of this episode thinking, "Rob's probably just one simple thing away from fixing that mic and not sounding terrible"

All time favorite episode. I laughed for days after the final scene Neighbor Gary : "what are you people doing in my apartment" *awkward silence* Frank pulls the chainsaw and the sunny music starts as credits roll 😂😂😂

as legendary as the show is, the meme content it has enabled will live on for eternity.

Frank starting the chainsaw in the last 2 seconds of that episode is comedy gold.

28:43 Charlie throwing out some OG Offspring :D

the artwork on Charlie's wall is a masterpiece.

Rob seems like a good dude. It's awesome to us fans to see a show who's cast seem to be truly good friends and it shows in your work as well. Thanks for years of laughs boys!

This the episode that identifies the whole series it literally sets the tone for what’s to come in this series 💯

One of my favorite episodes and absolutely the episode that showcases where the show will go in terms of their writing ability and the kind of stories they will be able to weave together. I was legit blown away by the ending after thinking the entire episode "How are they going to resolve the whole actual serial killer thread they've weaved."

56:33 just mac and his his thing with pens. 🤣

The whole revenge conversation made me think of the Bentley dude in the in-n-out parking lot lol

I always thought Dennis HAD been the killer and framed the guy cuz in CharDee MacDennis, Dennis makes a frozen head in a box stating that it represents love. Also, Dee has the apartment key which Dennis coulda used.

"I'm going to Beat my d... like it owes me money" best line ever 🤣🤣

23:15 Charlie asks if it’s this jingle and Rob says No, then plays the exact clip Charlie just voiced.

The fact Dennis completely forgets that him and Dee aren't actually going to kill the waitress will always gets me. Pepper jack gets me crying every time.

RE: The opening - LOL Charlie, that's exactly what I said in the comments of the last episode! Worms see worm ghosts, humans see human ghosts. Great minds, ey? Great minds ...

I feel like this podcast is going to help them write the new season. I’m so excited to see what happens.

Thank you Rob for confirming Glenn was in a hotel room. We haven't seen inside anyone's home except for yours and Kaitlin's and so that could maybe have been Glenn's house, and a certain sub-set of the Creeps would have questioned his taste in decor if not his life decisions in general.