merci beaucoup, dylane! c'est très utile pour moi car, nos examens approchent, et je suis très anxieuse! Je voudrais vous dire un grand merci!

I still make a few mistakes when I use this grammar in the negative passé composé. But one day, I'll fully master it with patience.

Dylan you are such an excellent teacher. So thorough. Merciiiiiiii 🤗

thank you so much for teaching this concept so clearly

For those looking for the list of verbs followed by preposition à, P101 corresponds to P132 on the kindle version.

Sorry for being late 😅 The PDF: theperfectfrench.com/shop/pdf-course-books/the-complete-french-grammar-course-french-beginners-to-advanced/ The paperback: amzn.to/2UYD1fd The eBook: amzn.to/3Dv0RAC

Time to relax with your soothing voice! :)

Thank you so much 💖 God bless you

Merci beaucoup pour votre leçon 🙏❤️

Merci pour cette leçon!

Thanks!

What a good job Dylane does at 5:24 in the video which reinforces Lesson 2 and how in French almost always we need an article while in English we can drop it - "Do you often give flowers (no article before flowers) to your wife" becomes "est-ce que tu offres souvent des (mandatory article goes here) fleurs à ta femme ?" - so maybe think of it as do you often give "some" flowers to your wife - now watch what happens to the article in the negative - "no I never give her (no article) flowers" -> "non, je ne lui offre jamais de (NOT "des" which a very common mistake) fleurs" - so even though fleurs is plural, because it is negative the article remains "de" - so maybe in English, "no, I never giver her (any) flowers"

Merci! 😀

I have just finished page 205, ex. 4.8, but the negation with passe composé and Indirect Object Pronoun was giving me a hard time. 😅 For example, figuring out where to put the pas in the sentence. It would be good to provide examples for those ones. Ex.8 Tu ne leur as pas volé cette bouteille de vin. 😊 The pas goes in the middle of the passé composé. 😊 right?

Le verbe demander est un peu difficile car il prend parfois une préposition. In the prior video it's a REDCAP verb for which a direct object pronoun is used, but in this video there's the example in which an indirect object pronoun is used.

Hi mam .... u have to clear the concept in a easy simple way ....

Good job

Merci beaucoup madame 🌹🌷🌺

Just a small thing: at 1:01, although you technically say "an advice" in French, the translation would be wrong in English, because we use advice without an article, so you cannot use advice like that, meaning you can't say "an advice", you have to leave advice by itself. One could say, "a piece of advice"however. Great video though!

Woah!!😃

Hi Dylane, thanks a lot for the great videos, I wanted to ask about the verb "Demander" you've said in the previous video that it's without a preposition, and now you say it's with "a" so how do we deal with it exactly?

Merci beaucoup teacher dylane 💯🥰🙌

Hey at at 5:40 shouldn't Je ne lui offre jamais des fleurs* since it's a plural?

😊😊

👍👍

Bonjour Dylane ! 😚

I’m a bit confused with demander. Wasn’t it one of redcap verbs, no preposition?

I have a question why not the pas in end of this sentence " non,je ne lui offer jamais de fleurs please tell me

So, doesn't it have any specific rule for 'passé composé' for Indirect Object Pronouns as it has for Direct Object Pronouns?

J'ai téléphoné à mon ami hier. Je lui ai téléphoné et il n'a pas répondu.

Oh.. I'm late today😕

😭😑

ENGLISH SPEAKERS BEWARE!! The rules for indirect objects are not the same as in French!! In English, a noun or pronoun in a prepositional phrase is not an indirect object (though some grammar scholars argue otherwise), but would be an indirect object if there is no preposition. For example, in English--- "I gave him a book," "him" is an indirect object. HOWEVER if worded, "I gave a book to him," The word "him" preceded by the preposition "to" is no longer an indirect object (it acts like an indirect object)... confusing, YES. And in some English sentences... the verb "to telephone someone," as in "I telephoned Paul," The word "Paul"... IS A DIRECT OBJECT IN ENGLISH, but not in French. so, French, "j'ai téléphoné à Paul," "Paul" is an INDIRECT object because the verb téléphoner is preceded with the preposition, "à." Be careful!