I accepted Toad's departure a long time ago because I knew what your transition meant. Toad singing was a wonderful gift you shared with us and it was great while it lasted. I'm glad you're following your dreams and it seems to be working out for you. Keep it up! Though the odds may be small, maybe our paths will cross at a con sometime. I'd be happy to see you perform music you're truly passionate about.

Toad sings being dead because our king is transitioning is honestly the best. Do you have a friend maybe who could do the Toad impression?

While I’ll always treasure the video of my dog opening his Christmas presents while Toad is singing “All I Want for Christmas” in the background, it’s been a delight to watch and listen to you grow as an artist! ❤️

I knew Toad was going away when you started transitioning, the last one you made was a clear goodbye. But I stayed here, and I'll stay here, because I was here because of you, you're really fun, and cool, and really talented, and I'll follow you no matter what. Keep working hard!

I was afraid you were stopping because you didn’t like it anymore. I’m so glad it’s because you can’t do it anymore. We still love you king!

NOO RIP TOAD SINGS, I will always remember the times when I played Toad Sings Chandelier on full volume at the movie theater.

Now do screaming bowser LETTSS GOOOO!! *Jk just do what you are passionate about👍👍😬*

IT'S OK BECAUSE THE MEMORY OF TOAD SINGS STILL LIVES IN OUR HEARTS 🍄

YES, TOAD IS DEAD AND GONE BUT MELAN IS MORE ALIVE THAN EVER 💙 Just yesterday I recommended you to someone, and I hope you continue to grow artistically because your music is amazing 😭😭 Good luck in everything Melan💙 you’re a king

I was gonna suggest something like Toad on crack or sulfur hexaflouride of smoker toad But honestly the screaming bowser comment takes the cake Also mighty impressive how high you can still go, almost like a pro voice actor I'll miss toad and your music is a bit outside my taste (probably in part because i don't understand japanese) But your content and personality are really fun so i hope you can keep doing what you're doing

Honestly, this brought tears of happiness and proudness to my eyes, as much as I loved toad sings, I'm so, so so happyyou found something to do with your life that you love and enjoy, I am happy that you are going all around the states meeting people who admired and loved, you were a person I looked up to, I really, really am happy to see you grow and evolve. Never, ever stop being yourself, keep up the beautiful and amazing work, keep up the fucking amazing songs and keep being the best you that you can be, because no one can take that away from you. PS: thanks for existing, your videos helped me a lot during my depressive stages.

Awww, that’s a shame. I’m glad you’re finding yourself, though!

Its a shame that toad sings is gone. But i’ll still stay for The good memories. Also Damn you cute, boy.

You know, I actually found you through Toad so you even though you can't get to that range anymore, I will always cherish it. Especially since I randomly find the Chandelier song randomly on Tiktok and Instagram and so, even though people don't know it's you, you have millions of appreciators out there.

RIP Toad. Welcome to your heavenly-ish singer voice >w

I loved your old voice but I also love that you're being yourself, finding who you are, and loving yourself. You do you king

Congrats on the transition! Sad to hear Toad is going away, but its obviously necessary. Good luck with your music!!!

Don't be sad that it's going away, be happy it happened! I wish you well in your singing career going forward

I will miss Toad sings, It's totally fine that you can no longer do that impression, you chose to transition and all of us are happy that you're happy! It will forever be in your history, for making my me, brother and so many other people laugh. Thank you for sharing that.

I happened to have one of the toad videos pop in my recommendations, but I thought to click on the channel and I'm really glad I did because your music is great and I'm proud of you for transitioning despite the pressure to make more toad videos. Keep doing what you love!

Toad had to be MURDEROUS for the vocal chords, I can't believe you kept doing it after Chandelier.

Toad brought me here, and I've stayed for you. You're awesome! I enjoy watching you grow as a human and an artist. All the best and lots of love to you!

Don't let the haters keep you down, people want what they want and forget that they are not entitled to it. Best of luck on your EP!

I figured it died since when you first went on T and that's fine! People need to learn to respect and accept it when artists go through different endeavors. It reminds me of when Joji stopped being Filthy Frank/Pink Guy. Love your work 💕

Toad sings doesn’t need new entries in the series. I can go back to the existing ones and they never get old. Glad for you that you are moving on and choosing to be your authentic self, despite all the pressure to not do that. Respect.

So... Bowser sings coming next?

I’m so sad that Toad Sings is gone but I’m super happy that you’re exploring and finding yourself and your talents. Best of luck to your music career!

Congrats on the transition! Sad to see it go, but it was fun while it happened. Best of luck in the future!

Thank you for everything, sir. May Toad always remain in our hearts. I wish you the best of luck in your career Melancholiaah!!

I love your toad videos, they were the reason I originally subscribed, but I’m glad you're taking your own music and flourishing with that! I am going to unsubscribe because I did originally subscribe for the toad videos, but I wish you the best with your own music going forward! Sending all the positive vibes :)

i actually first found you through a convention and watched the toad sings stuff afterwards, and i've always had a fun time going "HEY I MET THAT GUY ONCE!" every time someone sends a toad sings meme in a group chat or whatever. the silly vids might have been fun, but ur voice has always been incredible in your personal projects and i am so glad to get to hear more songs from me as u grow and change

love you man, do what you do. It's cool that you're doing all these amazing things with your life. Toad will be missed but you are worth so much more than that.

I love your videos, your the best. Do whatever you want. No one should stop you

You made people laugh with your Toad music. Don't forget that even by not trying you made people happy. Best of luck to you my random friend.

wow I've never actually seen anything of you apart from the Toad sings so I subscribed for that but now I'm staying for the personality (also I'm sorry but I'm kinda interested what Marge sings would sound like now)

Everything is fine, really do what you want to do and seek for, your music is amazing!!

Thanks for all the great work dude. Can't wait to see what you create in the future

Gone but no forgotten

Honestly, I don't even know how you did it before transitioning. Some of the most enjoyable content that I have shared with my friends. Thank you for the videos, and good luck on your journey

R.I.P Toad sings… my words to it are it was the best series on youtube😢

I'm honestly glad that you aren't going to be hurting your vocal cords anymore. Granted, Toad Sings Chandelier is what I listen to to cure my depression.

That's okay, as long as you're happy !

I was wondering where you were, cause there's all these "TOAD" AI covers, and I was like: "Where's the og Toad?". Glad to see you're still doing your thing bestie 😌.

Hey, just wanted to say thank you so much for the Toad era and all the crying laughter and aching stomachs that came with it! Glad to hear your transition went well, and best of luck to your original music ventures (tho I think you’ve got ‘em in the bag) :D

Weak Victorian child 😂😂😂 you make my day. I fell in love with your original music after hearing you live at a convention during the release of your first album. Gonna keep loving your music. You were so sweet and I can’t wait to hear more.

So happy for you man!! Even though toad sings may be dead, it will always have a special place in all our hearts ❤

The impermanence of Toad Sings doesn't make it less spectacular; those videos helped me through some of the worst times of my life. As well, my own transition affected my singing too, despite being MtF. Just holding my voice in a different place for so long has made it so I can't hit several notes I used to be able to, and that's okay; it's a small price to pay for being the happiest I've ever been. Wishing you luck with your music, and I intend to stay subscribed to hear it.

Congratulations brother. Excited to see what music comes next. :)

Just came across this video, thank you for giving me permission 2 years ago to horribly animate your Toad Cover of "Into the Unknown" its the end of an era for you singing songs as toad but I'm glad you made them in the first place. I'll be sure to keep up to date with your channel I honestly love your original music, hopefully we can still be friends :)

You know what, I am a bit disappointed you won’t be continuing it. I had many laughs with it. But that is ok. Your original songs are really good and I’ll continue to support you. Keep up the good work

I am new to the party and want to say: You are awesome. You have a new subscriber

Amazing dude! I really hope everything goes well for you, and while Toad sings was funny what matters is what makes you happy in your life. keep on singing!

Reast in peace Toad, you'll be in our heraths during eternity, good luck to you melancholiaah, love you toad we'll miss you forever

I think you’ve made a great video here with very good points, i hope that everyone else can also understand that it was funny haha but that its over now and i think you’re doing great right now and wish you succes with the rest of your future music projects

I support you in this 100%! I’m so excited for the future of your music! Thank you for the Toad songs. They brought me a lot of joy. I look forward to hearing your new stuff! The thought of you doing your thing musically gives me joy in another way ☺️💖

I found you through toad and stayed for your music-while you can't do the toad anymore I love the person you are now. Your voice is gorgeous and I've watched yourself open up as you've truly found yourself. I wish you future luck in your career!

There is only a small window of opportunity that exists in anyone's life where they are actually physically capable of doing the Toad Sings genre of music, hahaha. Honestly we all are just extremely grateful that you captured these recordings back when you could do them. =D

I hope you don’t take down your toad vids bcz they are so good & really brought me joy & laughter. Thank you for producing them for us.

dude as a fellow transmasc who can't get his hands on hormones yet i am so so proud of you and i just wanna say that even if you hadn't made the masterpieces that are the toad sings covers then i'd be proud of you anyways. best of luck and best of health!! ❤❤

Glad to see you're finding yourself, dude! Wishing you all the best for rediscovering your voice. Cheers from Germany

This death is unfortunate, but if you deem it's the best course of action that's all the justification needed. Though Toad may sing no more, the songs sung still exist within our hearts (and also digital recordings). May your future be comfortable and happy!

Honestly, it probably is best you stopped just to save the total destruction of your vocal chords.

I got here because of the Toad Videos, and they were cool but I stayed for EVERYTHING ELSE. It's sad that people would comment things about toad in your other videos... I do hope this mitigates that Other than that, it makes me happy everything else is going great for you 💚 and that you are realizing your dreams 💚

You're fucking awesome

YOUR A TRANSFORMER?! Yoooo, what kinda vehicle can you transform into?

bro, your a real artist. So don’t be afraid

Thanks for your fun covers! You always will be a legend

i’m a new subscriber and this is why i subscribed. you rock and i’m glad you’ve shared so much with strangers like me.

good thing that youre able to go in a direction you want to go, im happy for you

Toad: NOOOOOO

I discovered Melancholiaah! from the Toad sing videos. Really glad about that.

Well I was introduced to the toad video and that's where I find this channel and I gotta say it's amazing that you're singing even if you're not doing the toad anymore Congratulations on all your endeavors

I came for the toad, but fully understand why it's not going to happen anymore! Congratulations on your transition, and all your musical success - your original work is pretty cool, not my main kinda jam but it's fun to check out. It looks like you're always having a blast when you preform (just finished watching a couple videos and my goodness you got some talent)

You owe them nothing. Be your authentic self always. 💜

Congrats on transitioning! Will miss Toad , but looking forward to your music!

Just saw the first video on your channel was uploaded in 2006. What an incredible journey to watch, see and listen to you singing throughout all theses years while becoming a completely different person. Very cool stuff you're doing. Wishing you all the best and greetings from Germany!

you seem such like a cool person!! 😊 ily

Hey nothing last forever thats life, the toad stuff is absolutly hilarious please dont delete, thanks for the laughs anyways.

actually now that i think of it… *I shall continue to uphold the honor and legacy of the toad sings.*

Nice transition!

Big hype for the second E.P, homie! Keep doing what you love, we're here to cheer you on!

My friend showed me this like yesterday, I decided to click on the thing to see more of your vids and I see this...WELL GREAT!!!! I'm glad that you're acknowledging this though, it's important to tell people what's what. Even if Toad Sings is gone, we still have the others that will probably be the death of our lungs as we laugh too hard!

Let’s be honest…it was a foregone conclusion. Transition aside If you knew nothing about their personal lives, I don’t think anyone believed that doing that voice was sustainable or healthy for anyone who wanted to use their voice in a career.

Was just reminded of your Toad Sings videos, went to see if there were any I'd missed, and found this video. Just wanted to say that while I have greatly enjoyed Toad Sings, I'm happy that if we have to lose it, it's for a great cause. I wish you lots of happiness and success with your future endeavors.

This is so wholesome actually

I just listened to your Chandelier version, I haven't laughed so hard for ages. Thank you for that.

Aww. Rest easy our dearest singing Toad. You will not be forgotten!

I'm so happy for you! The best thing about making creative stuff is... being creative. Of course you're not gonna do what you did 5 or 10 years ago. Your voice is fantastic, your music is great, AND I would totally watch you do some kind of sketch comedy/stand up. Your "you've GOTTA chill" to your cat had me in tears, lol.

I found your channel like ten minutes ago and I'm totally in love with it. Yes I love your toad videos, but your voice is amazing and you are really nice, so I'm defenitely going to suscribe!!!!!!

I mean yeah, I subscribed for the Toad. And honestly I'm impressed that you even did as many videos. I thought it's a funny meme thing and all memes end some day. So it probably comes to no surprise, I would have assumed, that you wouldn't do this forever.

honestly everyone needs to move on from what they're currently doing at some point, i'm really glad you're making the decision to do that now that your voice is no longer the same as it was! i feel like creators sometimes want to please their audiences so much that they'll go to lengths of hurting themselves just to put that same content out, as well as distancing themselves from what they actually want to do. i'm glad you're putting your foot down, & saying "hey, that's who i was then & i'm glad you guys enjoyed that, but that isn't me anymore, & it's time to move on". congrats on starting t, i look forward to seeing where you'll go as a creator!

To be honest I followed you for your music and then someone told me that you were the one who did the toad sings videos! I had seen those back in the day so it was like wow small world!! Haha very cool and you’re very talented! Love your music

Oh cool, getting where you wanna be gender-wise? Awesome to hear!👍 I love the _Toast Sings_ as I just discovered it, and seeing you created a bunch of these is superb (usually memes only get 1 or 2 songs!). Then I checked your channel and I was glad to see you were doing your own musical things as well, so keep creating what drives you: the content will find its audience, it doesn't have to be memes or super mario characters, there is new fans that will come and support you. There is more fun to be experienced somewhere else, the _Toast_ arc was a success, let's see what the future holds for us 😃

I found your toad sings videos last week and they are gold. I have to pause to wheeze-laugh. I checked your channel to see what else you do and realized you're a trans brother! Keep doing what you love bro. Ya boy subbed to support. I used to be able to sound like the pink and blue unicorns from Charlie the Unicorn, but T made my voice way more like Charlie's. I definitely get not being able to hit the high notes anymore ✌️

nice, gl on future endeavours

Hey, ummm fucking amazing that you're doing what you like. Look, I'm gonna throw a Like here and other at the Toad video and probably not gonna see any more, but you seem like an amazing person, so best of luck form a stranger to you!

I'm both glad you're finishing the process of transitioning and giving your throat/esophagus a well needed break 😭 I sing songs in toads voice just to piss off my friends at work and oh my god the after effect is raunchy 💀

We'll always have the ones we have, thank you for all the glorious renditions. Maybe you can find other parodies to do with a baritone/bass voice? I'm glad you're doing well!

I'm super happy for you and you don't owe the internet anything. The videos that exist stand on their own in perpetuity, and that they reached so many people and continue to is great. But to reassure you, you do not owe people any more of that kind of content, and where you are now is its own thing. Don't feel bad you can't do any more of them, be happy the ones you did were what they were (ungodly levels of funny). That being said, I am not really into the Visual Kei/anime scene, so there's less for me to come back for on this channel? Your original content is well produced and sounds good but it's not really my thing since I basically listen to only western rock and metal/jazz (heresy from the east asian man). I didn't really actively follow before, I just kinda peeked my head in occasionally which is why I am seeing this video 3 months late, and wondered why the toad stuff wasn't coming back. This was a pleasant surprise, and my subscription is probably meaningless in the grand scheme of your career, but I just thought it important to know that if people like me don't watch your stuff going forward, it's just because my interests do not align with the current content, not an attack on you for not producing the same screaming meme content in perpetuity. You rule, man.

I would never expect one to stay doing one thing forever, especially on the Internet. Things on the Internet are both fleeting yet live on forever. I'm very happy you are able to transition to the person you are inside. I will always play your Toad videos as a hilarious ice breaker. Thank you for being your authentic self, you deserve it.