*didn't come close to taking over the universe *didn't almost take over the world

+Geno actually well Vader almost took over the universe, at least another galaxy or two he could've done. Remember he nearly single handedly took over the galaxy while Palpatine sat on his ass and storm troopers can't hit sh!t. The rebels knew he was building a super weapon that could destroy entire planets, and they didn't sucsessfully stop him, he was pretty powerful and at least took over one Galaxy, you gotta admit that's impressive.

Yeah, Vader only took over a galaxy (which is all he wanted), and even then it was mostly Palpatine.

Galaxy, not universe. Also, the Emperor kinda would have been praised for that.

Technically Voldemort took over Hogwarts (and the Ministry) after Dumbledore had died.

JSpiker178 LOL True. I always wondered why Dumbledore was so aggressive in Goblet of fire, he practically man-handles Harry throughout the whole film

JSpiker178 I remember that meme

I always thought that was out of place considering Dumbledore was always very nice and calm

yea I was so disappointed at that scene

JSpiker178 it's at the end of the video

damn right

Also. In the books when Hermione is tortured, Ron goes crazy screaming and trying to knock out the door. In the movies looked like he barely gave a shit.

That's it im gonna wipe my memory clean of the movies and re-read the books

Ron said that because they loathed SNAPE.. but there's also some truth of em being annoyed with Hermione's know-it-all attitude.. that's just the way she is

@@kcue9466 yeah, he does find it annoying at times but he doesn't see much wrong with having a smart friend around. Plus hermonie actually likes having someone debate her on a topic instead of just agreeing with her.

I thought he just vanished and the Fire Nation began attacking.

You copied the top comment and changed it slightly gg

Wormtail, I-I don't feel so good

Yaaaas

LarryOli 11 stolen comment

AdmiralOctopus same.

AdmiralOctopus not true, it's hinted at, Abeforth says to Harry that mundugus gave him the mirror and says it belonged to Sirus

THIS

Yes, that was largely ignored in the movies. :(

Hated it in the books actually. How he somehow forgot that he had it until after Sirius died and he never stops bitching and whining.

This made me laugh for some reason

Yes, and that reason is his amazing profile pic.

The ending in the film was so anti climatic I actually forgot the ending when I saw for the first time (I hadn't read the books then). It simply didn't have the kind of impact I was expecting.

*explodes into confetti* 😂😂😂

i am your 1042nd like:)

bigbake132 you mean 9 3/4

@@alexifelton1070 nice

In the books he always kept it in his robes just in case and used it always

@@kabirqirati1160 Yup

Bcz movie is movie we need plot convenients And logicless trashs in movies

Omg haha for real 🤣🤣🤣

Fr tho

Frreer

@Aussie Pigeon Man That was his funeral, raising their wands to honour Dumbledore.

Lmao 😭

how sway

Yannick Lourens ginny is very different and loveable in the books... in the movies, she is like Kristen Stewart

I actually dislike Ginny in both the movies and the books. I find her to be quite annoying. (Unpopular opinion, I know.)

^^ dude the comparrison is delicious

agreeeee

Dawe202 So much sass lol

I really missed Harry's sass when I was watching the movies

Dawe202 one of the best Harry comebacks

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH

Dawe202 Daaaaaaamn, best comeback ever

Correct that was the greatness of the book no one not even the main protagonist was perfect

I feel like they gave a lot of harry and Ron's qualities to Hermione

Well, you know how feminists will react if the female protagonist is just as flawed as the male protagonists 🤪

@@wilhelmdietz4023 *feminists without brains

The director was a bigger fan of Hermione and gave her more attention, he talk about how she was his favorite and why she has a bigger role.

Ikr half blood prince movie sucked

Whats won won

@@conserztasfia0078 Lavender called ron "won won"

Yoshi Waker This, forever this!

soooo annoying lol

Irish Dumbledore, one of the many things that I disliked about Michael Gambon's version.

Yoshi Waker So true

Dumbledore said calmly.

i'm a what?

loblit05 XD

Movie version of this line will always be better than the book's version to me. It just sounds cooler when you say it as "You're a wizard, Harry!" No idea why, but it does to me lol

Nyx Nightmare tru tru

FEkitty Fraschilla omg. Me toooooooooooooo

yagappar arulanandam yep he was very angry in that scene.

And the only harry crying scene we got in the movies is that lame ass thing from PoA :/

To be honest I laughed during the whole chapter when HARRY throws a tantrum inside Dumbledore's office

Honestly book shows all of them as a person rather than movies in which they are shown as some superhumans

Lol

Not wrong at all

Amy Cao an-I-may-jai

One of the many reasons the fourth movie is my least favorite.

I was waiting for this to be the top 1. 😂😂😂😂😂

So, you're unhappy about the accent someone used to speak the line? What's the point?

Michael Lefort no lmao in the book it says he said it "calmly" in the movie he basically yells at Harry

I came to the comments section to find this one.

konohahurricane07 Mine hasn't arrived yet either🙀🙈

konohahurricane07 maybe someone had a mail-snail... hang in there, it might still get there. dont blame everything on poor Errol.

Errol or Pig?

Errol

When Dumbledore died and Voldemort ruled Ministry of Magic and school, they didn't send any invitation letters to muggleborn kids, so if you are muggle, that I'm sorry, but your invitation wasn't even created :(

Oooh that pissed me off so much when I first watched the movie. Cuz I read the book before watching the movie.

Thank god i didn't watch the movie!

@@youtubeistryingtocensorme oh no no no! Never do that.....you now have to santize yourself by reading the books again

@@Deluluissolulumadman SAME! And I m never gonna watch

Why

You know, there's something about being Pureblood and being Half-blood. I'm not exactly sure what that is, but yes, Lily was a Muggle born while Neville's parents were Purebloods.... there's any reason for what Voldemort chose Harry. And yes, there's one more thing Pr. Tralawney said when she was telling the future- The child who'll born in the end of July and whose parents have fought Voldemort thrice before, which clearly refers the Potters!

@@Longliv_resistance But Neville's parents too fought with the Dark lord in the order of phoenix.

@@Longliv_resistance Yeah and they also fought Voldemort thrice and Neville is born 1 day before Harry.

@@Longliv_resistance harry was half-blood=> Voldemort too. He sees in harry himself(he hated that he was also half-blood=> killed his dad and his grandparents). As for Neville- he was born in pure blood family-voldemord didn't want to destroy such powerful family(I mean blood). When Harry was pretending to be dead(Hagrid carried him- last book) Neville and Voldemort (and bellatrix) had a conversation- vold want Neville to join him because of his blood. Funny thing- despite neville parents resist 3 times Voldemort's offer(to join them)

"Have a biscuit"

PROFESSOR McGONAGALL YESSS The best 👏

Eff slay queen

Greatest plot twist of all time👏👏

Eff the greatest piece of literature to exist

I remember

perfects?

K4t3lyn zm1th x3 no prefects

that plotline didn't really go anywhere though tbh

What's Malfoy doing here...

You mean in the film. In the book she didn't know what Mudblood meant but in the film she did.

Exactly...it was ton who explained her and Harry.....

Also the fact that after Ron told her what it meant, it didn't bother her at all.

That actually doesn't make sense because mudblood is a slang and even if we consider Hermione possessed a lot knowledge by reading books (there was no other way of gaining knowledge for her as she is a muggle born), no book will ever contain that slang.

@@meghdeepghosh7731 she might've read the deep web version of books... or something. maybe a classmate's diary?

then he turns into a shriveled lifeless baby

Yeah even other characters in the film had this happen with wands, in The Deathly Hallows (Part 2). It happened when Kingsley Shacklebolt and Professor Lupin were together defending Hogwarts. They were high up inside the castle. One of Voldemorts lot came in possibly through a window, and I think his and Lupin's wands connected. (Might have been Kingsley's, but I can't remember.)

@@threecats8219 Dumbledore and Voldemort also connect their wands in the battle at the ministry of magic (Dumbledore is wielding the Elder Wand and Voldemort, his Phoenix Feather one, mind you). Even Mr. Weasley had his wand connected with a random Deatheater in Deatly Hallows pt 2. I mean, it's a quite a spectacle to see, much like the connecting kamehamehas in Dragon Ball, but it totally breaks the logic of the books and the statement made after Harry and Voldemort's Priori Incantatem in The Goblet of Fire movie. And it takes away the uniqueness of Harry and Voldemort's connection as mortal enemies.

@@DieysonGomesCC Was it Mr Weasley, when Kingsley Shacklebolt was there. I said above it was Lupin, and I remember that time; am sure it was Lupin. Uness Me Weasley did it too, or I got it wrong thinking Lupin. You're right though. Using the visuals of Priori Incantatum for more than the graveyard fight with Harry and Voldemort, did spoil things somewhat. You sort of had to just allow artistic licence for it. However Priori Incantatum was described somewhat by Dumbledore in Goblet of Fire movie. It's a bit confusing and hard to overlook whne you know it's there.

Kaela Bynoe Ikr, I loved her in the book, but she made me cringe in the movie so much. I don't know if they wrote her like that specifically or if the actress was just bad.

so movie Ginny is like the Harry Potter series

Book: Ginny is seen in multiple movies, trying to flirt with Harry as much as possible. Movie: After the 2nd film you rarely see her again.

This Harry too though.

Like pretty much any other woman in the movies apart from Hermione who is of course off-limits for Harry =D

Ginny was OK in the movie but in the book she was amazing confident and powerful (a little bit of that was shown off in the ministry escape sene) but other than that she was just there for a date for Harry

Lucie Duggan very true- and Rowling deliberately did this to emphasise the strength in women

In the movies, Hagrid tells the headmaster of beauxbatons that his mother was a giant

Marshall Jackson he just told her about his dad

I LOVED Ginny in the books. As she got older, she had more attitude and strength in her. Bonnie Wright did fit Ginny's physical description, but she didn't play her well at all.

Hahaha oh boy yeah and even Ron said that Umbridge would find her nemesis to McGonagall and he was right for she was like "Surely you don't want something for that cough, Dolores?" or "How are you supposed to watch my lesson if you keep interrupting it?" 😂😂😂 I think that scene should definitely had made it to the films! Too bad it didn't!

In The Order of the Phoenix book, they found the locket Horcrux in Sirius's house. At the time not knowing what it was. They could not open it although they tried many ways. I think they threw it away or put it in a pile of rubbish. ... Then later possibly in Half-blood Prince or Deathly Hallows, remembered the locket from Sirius's house.

@@threecats8219 Yeah, I love the small things that make it a brilliant story

And at last also, in the books all the house elfs come and start fighting with the death eaters and Kercher too said that harry was his master and dark lord should fall as if seeling revenge

It was originally filmed, but then edited out.

oh

And I never understood why they took it out. I get pacing and all that but it was such a dear, good moment in the books. I almost cried and was relived to see it even if it was in the deleted scenes.

Aww

Ryan theblaziken101 No, he didn't die. In the books, the Dursleys had to evacuate from the Privet Drive because Voldemort could hurt and use them to get to Harry. And while leaving, Dudley shows concern for Harry and denies when Harry claims that they think he is a waster of space. I cried like a bitch in that scene.

That made me sooooooo angry.

Swim God 26 REETAH SKEETAH

Swim God 26 that's true

Jmo 26 so THATS why the Harry Potter trivia app rejected my answer..... it was based on the movies only.

She turns into a beetle

The Books felt more epic and complete in more way than the movies.

I think the books were better.

That's a good list. 😄 In The order of the Phoenix book, they used coins to send messages about Dumbledore's Army meetings. Text appeared on the sides of the coins telling them meeting times. Draco also used that method I think when he was organising getting death eaters into the castle.

Also...there is a part in the books where neville's parents r shown and his grandmother saying that he should be proud abt them...rather than be embaressed...that was like one of the important scene... I always felt neville was the one they actually did dirty...in the books he was potentially in the place of harry due to the prophecy

Awesome

C0lony X ikr it's so sad

Yeah! =)

+C0lony X I'd say that he was prominent in the 3rd movie: - Fended off the dementor on the train - Taught his class about boggarts - Taught Harry how to use the Patronus charm - Met up with Sirius and confronted Peter Pettigrew - Turned into a werewolf Plus that there was a brief moment where we thought he was a villain (When he first meet up with Sirius)

He's my second favourite character in the book after Dumbledore, but I didn't like David Thewlis's portrayal of him.

also in the first book hagrid kisses mcgonagall and she giggles because they both had too much eggnog

She didn't stop Snape fron taking the points. She stopped him from doing something worse when he was trying to take away points and then realized that Harry's house had no points left, thanks to Umbridge's Inquisitorial Squad. She awarded Harry and his 5 friends a lot of points for their actions at the Ministry of Magic and then let Snape take away the points he'd initially wanted to.

oh yeah oops

Crystal Wolf yeah I remember that!!!

Crystal Wolf

Because that section in the book sucked. harry potter and the order of the phoenix movie is better the books.

@@doffe23gamerhd32 lmaooooo I never knew an opinion could be so wrong 🤡

@@doffe23gamerhd32 film was crap

Neville Longbottom and the Philosopher's Stone

To be fair, it was never mentioned in the Movies, that the DADA Position is cursed at all. And that the teachers changing because something happens "suddenly" to them by the end of the Year is a bit TO eye-catching, people could say "shit happens", despite this seems to be only appear on the DADA position. the thing with Neville and the chosen one is so small, that even his Parents of their fate could be cut from the Movies, but i guess, they needed to deliver a reason for Belatrix to be cruel to him and reason Nevilles anger.

But you're a fucking muggle.

and to fucking old

Tyata Samrat same

Tyata Samrat Same here

You guys Errol is just delivering it that's why

They're now doing for Percy Jackson lol! 😁

Oh how i wish for that to happen

If Alan Rickman was alive yeah definitely it can be possible but now it's not because there is no Potter without Snape (Alan Rickman)

@@fullmoon5799 Not at the moment, I agree! But there will be another actor playing Snape in the future! Remember, Bela Lugosi was the first cinematic DRACULA, then came Christopher Lee, and others...

@@Exodianecross1978 it's not same forget Yr idea it's not possible without Alan but I hope there will be a movie cursed child I know they don't like to make but I just hope I feel they will make it

Dear Alueta saame

Ashlee X dumbledore asked calmly

"Harry, did you put you're name in the goblet of fire?" dumbledore asked Harry calmly and not shouting like FUCKING MANIAC!

He even tries to strangle him 😂

Ashlee X 😂😂😂

Ashlee X He said calmly

Yes definitely. I wish they remake every movie again with every detail from the books on Netflix

yessir

I'd watch it twice ina row

That'll be brilliant!

Briony Drapala YESSS

Thanks, that's extremely well summed up!

"Ron is a bumbling buffoon." *Fred to George* "Say that three times fast."

I completely agree with it all. I love the movies but omg the books are amazing I hate how Ginny is so underrated. Bonnie Wright is amazing but the directors just didn’t give her the justice she deserved she is so bad ass in the books but get to the movies and she’s shy and seems scared

*who*

The inevitable heat death of the universe Any difference between movie and book Draco Malfoy?

bubu birden They should have included that scene from the book

bubu birden vandalized is an understatement. He trashed the place

Nah you’re taking it a bit too far👀

@@YC_001 shit you're right

@@aelina.galathynius6780 i mean i always could

sparkle LPSprogirl I just watched this movie again last night and was thinking the same thing lmao

YES. TOM WILL ALWAYS BE MY BABE

Two words.... GET. OUT.

He’s hotter than Gilderoy Lockhart

No. This isn't a toxic Instagram fandom.

Milek he was originally but was left out of the final cut. He was briefly in the first

Milek whos peeves?

Me too. I was really wanting him to just go around, at least in the second one, saying " Oh Potter you rotter".

He is mentioned by Ron in the first movie when he says that the ogre was probably let in by Peeves as a joke

Alabaster Relter oh

SenseiKisame no harry was very skilled from year 2 to deathly hollows prt 2

Agree... In the first movie he didn't even use a spell

SenseiKisame he mastered snapes spell and nearly killed Malfoy

Harry is really skilled in the movies He's viewed as a hero by everyone

In the Order of The Phoenix, Hermoine was saying how great Harry is but even Harry stopped her admitting he had help and had dumb luck. Snape always said Harry has no real talent. This was during the Movies of course. Like Ron has said they wouldn't survive 10 minutes without Hermoine.

I actually like Tonks. It annoys me how much of her they cut out.

I was searching for it ....and there are some dumbheads out there not even knowing the original story ...and chanting luna is great though she is I don't disagree

I like the movie version more

Wotcher Harry

Omg yes you're the only other person I've ever seen saying that. I thought I was the only one that felt this way. Also it was just this perfect culmination of everything that happened and there was this finality of this huge great war finally ending in front of everyone

My biggest problem with that whole fight was that Voldemort and Harry are literally flying around the school casting spells at each other back and forth continuously, where as is the books its just them circling each other in front of the crowd while Harry is talking and then one spell each. It was the culmination of a whole lot of build up and history and twists and it was supposed to end with just the two spells, but of course they just had to go for a big action scene instead of the nice neat package JK Rowling had written.

I think harry breaking the elder wand was a good change though. It could have caused conflict in the future if someone stole it again.

True but someone would have had to kill or take it from Harry to be its master. Otherwise all they have is a powerful wand that won't work properly for them.

Harry plans to become an Auror. Chances of Elder wand changing allegiances with such a high risk job is quite high. I also think that destroying the wand was a better option.

TheRealTricky i was waiting for some scene involving the St Mungo's Hospital in the 5th movie but they just completely cut it off >.

Is it really called SHIT? That's funny.

Leaving out that Harry's DAD and Sirius and Lupin and Wormtail made the map is so strange, it would have taken one line to have a satisfying sort of plot-twist reveal. Such as when Harry meets with Lupin in his office at the end. The other one is when Harry kicks Lupin out and says the line "Parents shouldn't leave their kids...unless they've got to." The movies focus 100% on the pressure of this future battle with this snakey monster Voldemort and has none of the interwebbing relationships of the past and Harry's emotional resilience (and temper - wish we could've seen more Sassy Harry, like the Snape classroom scene in HPB).

Yeah, Harry's statement was indeed very important to his own personality. Harry, most of all other characters in the book, knows the damage you can experience when you're parents are not there for you as a kid.

Yeah. Not to mention the fight between Dumbledore and Voldemort. In the movies, Dumbledore nearly lost. But in the books, he literally wiped the floor with Voldemort. In the books, the fight was amazing. Stunning and thrilling at the same time. It showed how amazing magic can be once you fully master it. Bringing statues to live and apparating to dodge the killing curse while casting powerful spells. It showed just how powerful Dumbledore was. The reason he was feared by Voldemort. That fight gave us hope. In the movies however... It kinda felt... forced. Dont get me wrong, it was still impressive, but not even nearly as much as it was in the books. Not to mention the scene where Fawkes sacrifices himself to save Dumbledore.

They were In the great hall while everyone watched as they dueled even the deatheaters stand and watch instead of fighting

@@andy34isabor89 yeah, I know

Dude I'm so sorry. I'm so high all the time that you said what I thought you weren't saying.

In the book:Harry and Voldemort didn't fly.And also Harry was in his cloak not in Hagrid's arms because Voldemort said put him at my legs,at his place.And than everyone lost focus at Harry and watch Voldemort fignting againts 3 wizards and Harry put his cloak ans started moving.When Molly killed Bellatrix.Voldemort screamed and aimed at Molly and than Harry removed his cloaked and blocked Voldemort curse.

True

They kind of mentioned Ariana in the last two films, but yeah the whole Kreacher thing bugged me.

Well since Grindlwald is involved with Fantastic Beasts and where to find them I'm sure in the follow up the Dumbledore/Grindlewald story will be told. It'd be a Great way to fill in some of the great stuff from the books that the movies never got to.

TheFantasticJoe Also Barty Crouch Jr's story

TheFantasticJoe truuuuu

TheFantasticJoe I also think Kreacher's backstory is the most important one

Yes! I was so disappointed when it wasn't included.

Maddy Hatter I know. It would've been nice to see it on screen

what did he do?

Carly Larson Harry gave all his money to the Weasly twins for their joke shop.

I wish it had showed the hospital scenes. That hug from Mrs Weasley just broke my heart

bo barfield True

bo barfield 3:13-3:16

And wasn't he held by a spell and could not move also? I havent read them for a while but that seems familiar to me...

M Papa You 're right.

This to me is the biggest difference of all! In the movie he just stands there like an idiot. In the book he is frozen and can't do anything until the spell is broken from Dumbledore's death!

HBO could do it similar to Game of Thrones and they wont run out of material to adapt since the story of harry potter is complete unlike Game of thrones

Abdou Gunner yay i mean i like the movies, but i would really like to see a tv series out of Harry Potter since a lot character look diffrently in the book like Draco is verry feminine andhas long hair and Luna is tall as explained by J.K Rowling before

That'd be lit

I want a Netflix Harry Potter series SO BADLY, you have no idea!! I just... every single time I watch the movies I'm like "... it looks pretty, but the books are so RICH with intricate detail and character development, and this does not do them justice!" I was listening to Prisoner of Azkaban on audiobook again recently, and just started dreaming about how amazing it would be to have an entire hour long episode dedicated solely to the Shrieking Shack scenes. And that's just one example! There's so many moments that could be so much more brilliantly done if there was a lot more room for the scripts to take their time.

and they wouldnt need so much cgi, only for quiddith, the goblet of fire and the final battle, the rest is just spells, making the series more cheap than GoT

Maybe the narrator in the book was being sarcastic?

+Nightone No, JK Rowling wouldn't be sarcastic about Dumbledore asking Harry calmly, Dumbledore would put no force on his most prized student.

half the problem is Gambon's interpretation of Dumbledore. He put little to no research in the part and has said in interviews that he didn't want to even try to portray him similarly as Harris, and it shows...this scene is a particularly bad example of his lack of caring for the source material.

TheWonderAnthem That was Richard Harris

L K It wasn't his fault. It was the person who wrote the movie who made Dumbledore seem out of character

Kyra Yung Oh yeah Lupin was acting very strange though tbh I didn't trust him

Yes, and older book!Harry was very anxious about seemingly have to end a life on purpose, even when it was Voldemorts. In many ways he was quite different from movie!Harry

Not really. In the movie Harry killed Quirrel in self-defence. It ended when Quirrel was on top of Harry, and Harry put his hands on Quirrel's face. Voldemort had ordered Quirrel to kill Harry, and that's why Quirrel had advanced and was over Harry.

They left out the whole Barty Crouch Sr smuggling his son out of Azkaban and keeping him under the Imperius curse to stop him going back to Voldemort plot too.

Why would they make a plot point about that when they already have to cram so much shit in 2 hours.

Cool actor who played Bill Weasley in the movies. Laid back and fit right in.

The Book kiss has more emotional impact to it. It shows how much Ron grew up and started caring for the house elves.

robert glasgow Same

I agree, except the dance scene. It's nice

*Fanservice It was just for all those stupid Harry-Hermione shippers on the net. It was stupid...

Honestly I was expecting it to be Harry and Luna, at least until GoF. It was pretty obviou him and Ron were going to become actual brothers (in law) after that book assuming she didn't die.

Dário Alves Disagree, I'm not a Harry/Hermione shipper at all but I like the dance scene. It's clearly just Harry being a good friend and trying to cheer Hermione up.

I still thought he was pretty badass in the film. Also, it sort of makes sense for everyone to be so saddened by the end of the battle for Hogwarts since so many lives were lost to Voldemort and his Death Eaters. I doubt you'd want to celebrate so soon after witnessing several friends and family members get brutally murdered by a madman.

Neville became quite a badass as the movies passed through - especially considering where he started...

Are you kidding me? He made the most riveting pep talk of the franchise and killed Nagini twice as badass.

Navel was as much the Chosen 1 as Harry, it all came down to who Voldemort (who didn't know the last part of the prophecy saying he'd chose who he'd share his power with) tried to kill. Navelle's problem was his emasculating grandma. Harry had his issues but his family shunned him rather than play down his magical abilities. By his 3rd Year, he was as advanced as Harry though they specialized in different feilds. The movies didn't show his progression very well but at least they showed him being as vital as Harry to Voldemort's defeat.

Gemnist in the book he stood up to voldemort face to face and cut the head off the snake while it was around voldemort's neck right in front of him. way better than the movie

I think it's a good change though

@@Jordan-mq4wj Does not make any sense though , he would have know the diary and the ring have been destroyed before Potter began his quest in the seventh year

Shakthi Sathish, I mean, we never see Voldemort’s perspective in the book and it makes sense. He lost a part of himself.

Well I think it's a sensible change though....why wouldn't someone feels weaker while you're killing a part of his soul...

In the films, Voldemort only felt horcruxes destroyed after he realised Harry and co had been in Belatrixes vault. Before then he was oblivious to it, and Harry even asked "Do you think he feels it", or something like that.

Ah you mean the centaur teacher, ya we only got to see a centaur once in the wole fucking series.

I was genuinely pissed they didn't include any of hermonie's elf liberation story line.

Megatron I actually didn't like the elf liberation story line, though it did have some funny moments

MC Cooper Oh right... when the centaurs also took away that women...

Kayla Houvenagle I personally liked it is because of Ron lol...like you said he made that story line quite funny.

Because Daniel Radcliffe turned out to be allergic to the green contact lenses they tried using.

Lol 26 likes in a comment 26 likes too in a reply from that comment :P

Dan was one of the rare people to be allergic to the contact lenses they used, then J.K rowling was insisting that they had the same eye colour yet they still didn't

Yes D.R. was allergic, but so what? CGI anyone? They could've changed the color easily.

Raging Ginger EXACTLY

NekiTamoL1K Thats why i dont like the movie while it is my favourite book of the series

Ron didn't buy Pig. Sirus uses him to sent Harry the first letter after his escape from Hogwarts in the 3rd book and says in a PS in the letter that Ron can keep the bird because he doesn't have a rat anymore (the letter reaches Harry still in the train back). Ron than let Crookshanks decided if he is a proper owl. Pigwidgeon was named by Ginny and Ron didn't liked the name, but it was to late to change it.

I hate answer so late but o think half blood prince had more brutal changes

Uhm, just one thing: Pigwidgeon was a present from Sirius to say soory for trying to kill his pet murderer. And the list goes on: Book: Ludo Bagman has a whole story-arch with the Weasley twins who bet with Ludo at the World Championship, win, he pays them off with Leprechaun money, they try getting the money from him as they bet all their savings and need the money to open up their shop. Ludo functions as a decoy bad guy for some time before being revealed that he's highly endebted with the goblins and can't pay them, leaving a pissed-off set of Weasley twins. Movie: Who's Ludo Bagman? Book: Harry get's 1000 Galleons of price money, tries getting rid of it by giving it to Cedric's father who declines the offer (!having no bad feelings with Harry which is important to mention when you want to explain your hatred for "the lost child") and then gives the money to the twins, making the promise they'll invest it into their shop and also buy Ron a set of dressing robes, stating that they're going to need a laugh now that Voldemort's back. Movies: none of that happens. Book: Padma and Parvati are in different houses. Movie: they swarm around together in the Gryffindor common room and breath "hi harry" every time they pass him. Book: Hermione's teeth get hit by a charm from Malfoy, making them grow uncontrollably and Madam Pomfrey then shrinks them to be normal sized. Before that Hermione had ginourmous front teeth. Movie: None of that happens Book: Both Durmstrang and Beauxbatons are mixed gender schools Movie: Screw that, One's for girls, the other one for boys! Book: Hermione wears dressing robes from a floaty, shimmery periwinkle blue material and Harry sees her immediately Movie: Hermione wears a pink monstrosity and Harry has only eyes for Cho. Book: Everyone's wearing dressing robes to the yule ball Movie: Men wear robes, the women wear dresses, The patils wear Saris and Cho wears sothing chinese-y. Book: Hermione does not eat at the beginning to the term banquet as Nick tells her about the elves, she founds SPEW, later takes up a habit of knitting to free the house elves resulting in Dobby being the only one willing to clean the Gryffindor common room. Winky becomes an alcoholic, we learn that house elves can get drunk on butter beer. Hogwarts house elves wear a towel as a toga as uniform. Dobby equipps Harry with the Gillyweed. Hogwarts House elves later fight in the battle of Hogwarts being led on by Kreacher. Movie: not even sure if SPEW even exists. Book: Harry, did you put your name in the Goblet of fire, he asked calmly. Movie: HARREY! [pushes someone out of the way] DIDYAPUTYA [shakes him furiously] NAMEINDEHGOBLETOFFIYAH!? [looks murderous] Book: Blast ended Skrewts Movie: No Blast ended Skrewts Book: Niffler, because Hagrid wants to prove he's as good of a teacher as Professor Grubbly-Planck Movie: No Professor Grubbly- Planck, no unicorn-lessons, no f-ing Nifflers! Book: Veelas at the World Cup, Fleur is being revealed to have Veela ancestry Movie: What are Veelas even? Book: Black sends Harry letters while using tropical birds, he later moves to Hogsmeade and Harry gets him a loaf of bread, chicken wings and several bottles of pumpkin juice from the kitchens. Movie: No thanks. Not doing that. A fireplace cameo should be enough. Book: Hagrid and Madame Maxime are exactly the same height. Movie: Madame Maxime is quite a bit taller then him. And I could go on for quite some time with this. Even the thing with the firebolt is wrong.

Me (No, not Ashildr, I had the name before Doctor Who, and I'm not changing it!) they ruined Ginny in the movie

That's why it doesn't make sense that they got together in the end loool

sassy stylan That is so me XD

sassy stylan I can totally relate to you!!

Well,I disagree about number 5! I think it´s very similar to the book! Because the reason they are slow dancing to cheer up is that they are mourning the loss of Ron! In the book they also took turns wearing the Horcrux, it wasen´t just Ron who had to go through that test! Harry actually had to wear TWO Horcruxes at once!!! One was always INSIDE of him, remember?...That was why he coulden´t preform a Patronus then... PLUS, when Ron has left them, they offcourse have to wear the Horcrux more often, hence feeling even more sad!

sassy stylan you just discribed my life in one sentence xd

The ONLY movies a fandom can be mad about is the PJO movies

I know. 18 years is too long to not know this.

......it was 2016 when I posted that.

KrazyPrincessRose I know. I'm saying that there are people who don't know this when it's been 18 or so years.

YEah that never made sense in the book. seriously wearing the cloak during the battle was one of the dumbest things ever and completely impractical. how does the cloak stay on?

@@youtubeistryingtocensorme Well actually if you will read properly next time....you will see that under the cloak he was safe and was casting spells under it like helping but not properly fighting...his main motive was to kill voldmort and he didn't want to get hurt between the battle that was the reason he wore it!

Elizabeth Martinez more than a badass I think Ginny was an entitled twat in the books. But you're right about the movie adaption of her.

I never really like Ginny, and her movie version made me dislike her even more

I kinda wished Harry would end up with Luna Lovegood.

eciyk That was unexpected...

not really that is a very popular ship

Aaron Martinez well a film doesn’t have the convenience of 1000s of pages of explanation. There is a lot done in books that is inside the characters heads. How does a movie show a characters thoughts? By having them say outloud what they feel? Just let the movies be the movies and the books be the books and stop comparing them

Ryan R I don't know anyone that has read the books and watched the movies and preferred the movies. The movies are great but if you really want to learn the story of Harry Potter you should read the books. It's a whole different experience.

I read the first 5 books in a span of 2 weeks

Aaron Martinez you need to read the book its better than the movie

I’ve read the books but only seen KZfaq clips of the movies. I’ll never watch them fully cuz I feel they screwed them up. Also hermione isn’t done right. She’s super irritating in the clips. It doesn’t seem like Harry is ever brooding like he constantly does in the books. That guy had the worst life. He was locked in a closet for years, barely fed, unloved....serious child abuse. The movies make it like he’s cool but he wasn’t. His only friends ever were hermione and Ron.

Somebody's been watching Movieflame

*book version* Dumbledore calmly spoke,etc-- "Harry,did you put your name in the goblet of fire? *Movie version* "HARRYDIDYAPUTYERNAMEINTHEGOBLETOFFIRE?!?!"

The actor doesn't choose the script. Blame the screenwriter or director.

do you mean script writer, the actor himself has no choise

my memory of the GOF book is foggy but did dumbledore forcefully ask Harry if he put his name in the Goblet?

Robert Erlandson no. It specifically says that he calmly asked harry if he put his name in the goblet of fire.

In the Ministry Harry and Sirius are dueling together and Sirius says "Nice one, James!" (in the movie). It's true that it's very much a Harry thing that whoever liked his parents is fucking god to him.

That's literally the only mention of it though, and he is a completely different character in the films, much kinder and more gentle; in the books he's very gruff and snappish, he certainly never hugs harry or particularly imparts any great wisdom. For example the speech he gave at the end of POA never happened in the book. He still loves harry but he's very faulted.

Yeah I'm not disagreeing with you. I believe Harry responds to Hermione's line "so what if he does?" His love for Sirius is so blind and he also doesn't know that kids aren't supposed to emotionally hold their parental figures together. So all of this really comes down to the flaws in the movies: they focus on Voldemort v Harry in a classic villain and hero story. Of course his godfather had to be sage Gary Oldman. It dumps all the real human narrative and the collective cast we love about the books, which intertwine with Harry and which causes him the most inner (and outer) conflict.

Yeah the film also missed out explaining why Harry destroyed the Elder Wand. He said something like, it has caused enough trouble. It seemed a wise decision to destroy it too. Since if legend worked out harry had it, the Elder Wand would have been a target on Harry. While Harry could not have been killed in battle, he may have been killed for it like The original Peveral was. Killed in his sleep.

I know, it so sad. That was a really good part in the stories, I love that part. The leprechauns and the veela especially.

LukeeBants I remember being super excited about the match and PUF! change of scene. So disappointing!

And he does it all right in front of Umbridge.

Hemanth Swarna He looks at Umbridge, imagines her being sacked, and hence produces a Patronus.

That should have made it into the movie. Would have been a great scene^^ But since they messed up the whole Patronus issue in Prisoner of Azkaban so badly (never even explained the whole stack appearance) it wasn't surprising

pretty much all material related to OWLS is glossed over

I still think they did that because they thought the audience (a good part of which were still in school themselves) wouldn't want to see someone taking exams and thereby be reminded of their own next exam next week^^ Plus the movie already was pretty long, they would have had to cast additional actors for roles that have no meaning to the story (the examiner, additional students...) and have extra coulisses built for very short scenes that don't drive the story. The book is pretty long and when you look at some movies today we are very lucky it didn't get split in two movies^^