Hearing Emily saying 'bullshit' had to be the best line in the entire show :)

Lanes storyline is sadly realistic. Not everyone succeeds in the music world.

I've always wanted a prequel.. lorelai and rory growing up in the potting shed at Independence Inn etc..

Let’s be honest here Kirk is the true main character

I don't understand why who the father is, is such a big question. Clearly it is Logan. She gives all of this away when she goes and meets with Christopher. She already knew she was pregnant when she was talking to him. Go back and listen to the questions she is asking. She spells it all out right there.

Good grief! Rory needs MORE validation? She has an entire town of people who worship her! So she has to work a bit harder. Life's tough. Get a helmet.

They also need to seriously adjust Lorelai’s makeup to someone who knows how to flatter her changed features

It’s sad Richard past away. The reboot would have probably been better if he was alive, but it did show Emily cope the loss and grow more

Why did they have to ruin Rory's character

I think she should get her masters and teach at chilton or Yale. Love Emily....pure class.

I want more episodes, but I think it's scary because they could ruin it. They definitely needed more Sookie in Year in The Life though.

Most people complain about the revival because Rory didn't end up successful but I loved it. It portrays real life hardships. The fact that the people who are most likely to succeed sometimes don't. It gives us a glimpse of rorys life as if she was a real person and not just some fictional character in a TV show.

This might be an Unpopular Opinion but... I actually really disliked the revival. I mean, it had some good points but it either messed up way too much or undid a lot of development from previous seasons. Yeah...... this is gonna be a reeeeeeeeally long rant. Logan basically did a complete 180 and they literally threw ALL of his previous character development out the window. And I'm sorry but if Rory wasn't ok w/ an open relationship in college why would she suddenly be fine w/ it now? When it's w/ the exact same guy?? Also, she did the whole "other woman" thing before (w/ Dean in S5) and it very clearly sucked and she should've learned her lesson then. There was barely any Lane and practically NO Sookie which is just messed up- they're literally the closest and best friends of the 2 main characters, they should've had their own storylines that we should've SEEN. I did like all the Michel we got tho. I can't be the only one who wanted to see Kirk and Lulu married w/ a lil Kirk Jr. following him around on his various odd jobs because C'MON!! I have no idea what they did to Christopher or why. I get he's not a main, or even B list character (until S7 tho that's kinda pushing it) but like... what was his character's motivation to become like his father when we clearly saw it's not something he wanted in the previous show?? I did like Rory's confrontation w/ him tho. Long time coming that one. What in the HELL was going on w/ Luke and Lorelai?! Why in the world were they STILL not married after NINE FRICKIN YEARS??!!! And why were they still LYING to each other so much?! It's like the show forgot they did a timeskip! After 9/10 years together (if you count their dating history before the big breakup) they should've had WAY better communication skills and they should've AT LEAST BEEN MARRIED!!! You want ~*drama*~ for their relationship?? Then have them trying to have a baby but having difficulties conceiving for whatever reason (Luke not knowing if he wanted kids was literally the stupidest thing- he'd already said in the show he wanted kids w/ Lorelai when he bought the Twickum House and Lorelai agreed to wanting them too). The show could've ended on a happier note w/ Lorelai either discovering she is in fact pregnant or they could agree to adopt (I personally never saw this being something Luke would be against like ??? this was an odd one). You could even keep Rory's surprise pregnancy as a juxtaposition to Lorelai's happy, planned one. How is the father to Rory's baby unknown?? She was clearly having sex w/ Logan fairly frequently and since she and Paul (I literally had to take a min to rewatch the video to figure out his name because I completely forgot) barely saw each other we can assume they probably weren't having sex that much on the regular and there's no way in hell he's relevant enough to the show/plot to be a serious contender as the baby's father. I'm discarding the Wookie thing because seriously? No. It's sure as hell not Dean or Jess. That literally leaves only Logan. Lorelai going on a "journey" to "find herself" was dumb and executed poorly. However, her speech to Emily on the phone had me in tears. Goddamn Lauren Graham can seriously act. I love her. Emily and Paris were perfect. I do wish Paris and Doyle had stayed/will stay together as I do think they can compliment each other well and I really loved how Paris was worried about being a good mom to her kids. (there's probably a bunch of stuff I'm forgetting but this is long enough) *GIVE US MORE LANE AND SOOKIE YOU COWARDS!*

Am i the only one that thinks that the book rory wrote is the manuscript of the OG series. The OG series just seems to paint rory and lor in a better light, their dynamic was better, rorys shortcomings where softened. I know this kind of makes the OG series less likeable but i think the whole "the series will come full circle" thing was about more than just single moms daughter becomes single mom

Wouldn't it be funny if the guy in the wookie costume was Marty?

The reason Logan ended up back working for the family business and lost any character development we saw in the final season was because Amy Sherman-Palladino admitted she never even watched or read about what happened with the characters in the final season. The reason a bunch of the storylines seem wonky is because she just ignored everything after she left. Also, the revival was another case of what happened to How I Met Your Mother, the writers/creators have the idea of how it's going to end from the very beginning, but forget that in between stories/character development might not make that a reasonable ending anymore. ASP had the idea for the Rory being pregnant ending from the get go, but it just seems stupid now that it's so much farther in the future and not right after college. If they end up doing more Gilmore Girls (I doubt they will) I think someone else needs to be writing and Amy Sherman-Palladino needs to stay away from it, or at the very least understand Rory is not longer a teenager, and actually pay attention to the events of the final season. Sookie having limited screen time was due to Melissa's schedule, she didn't have time to do more.

I literally only care about Jess (and his relationship with Rory kinda)

ASP made it abundantly clear that Dean was Rory's first love/introduction to romance. She only got back with him because of the stress she was facing and because he was familiar and comfortable. Jess is Rory's Luke, rough around the edges, but matures over time, and ultimately becomes the dependable one that she can always find herself with and be happy. Logan is Rory's version of Christopher. Rich, charming, and suave, he is not a bad person, but he has a habit of throwing money at problems to make them go away or using money as a way to romance. As much as she cares for Logan, he is not the one she would ever settle with because his personality and station in life set them on different paths despite whatever feelings they share, much like Lorelei and Christopher. ASP had set the show up to prove that ultimately Rory is her mother's daughter, and would follow the same path, albeit with a slightly different course, and has always made it known that she shipped Rory and Jess, and they would most probably be endgame.

The writer had said in an interview that she always knew from the start the last THREE words she wanted to end the show to, the "Mom, I'm pregnant". Amy and her husband actually didn't write the last season of the original series due to inability to negotiate contract aka didn't get enough money they thought they deserved, so that's why the revival was done, to finish how she properly wanted to. The writer wanted to end the story in a way that made it come full circle; Rory pregnant as a single mother, but with all the love, strength, and experiences her mother taught her. Who the father is honestly not important in the writer's eyes, Rory will raise (probably a her) on her own, that's why she had that super random but purposeful conversation with her father at the end, questioning whether it was the right thing that he let Lorelai raise Rory all alone, and his purposeful response of basically "it was just meant to be". The tone of the story was always the bonds of mother and daughter, and more importantly, the Gilmore Girls being strong independent women, each one of them having their own journeys of overcoming hardship through independence and the bonds between them, even Emily!

Everyone keeps forgetting that this was the original ending. So Logan is probably the father and Jess will be like Luke. History continues. The we need more sookie well there were problems so that's why sookie didn't have much screen time. Love to see more shirtless Logan damn.

The baby's father is definitely Logan. That's why Rory had that conversation with Christopher at the end. I'm 100% team Logan, but I think Amy Sherman- Palladino wanted Rory with Jess, for the story to repeat itself

More Sookie it's just a mention?! It should be a big deal!!!! I mean, who don't miss Sookie?! ):

Team Jess, hands down. Milo Ventimiglia plays Jess in "A Year in the Life" as if he were still in love with Rory. He was the most influential in getting her back to Yale, convinced her that in spite of recent poor choices, she still had more value than she believed & suggested & pushed her to wite the book, because he believes in her & has matued IMMENSELY! While it is unlikely that the baby is Jess's, I really believe that like Luke, he would stand by Rory & the baby, no matter what! I don't see Logan doing that. They have FAR more chemistry than Rory & Logan. While Rory DID cheat on Paul (w/Logan & the Wookie, the Wookie bit was priceless!), it was never a serious relatioship. Logan had a fiancée for God's sake! For ALL of the above reasons, TEAM JESS!

like does Lane gets over her crummy first time and actually had a satisfying sex life now?

Omg! Please come back again!! I love the Gilmore Girls!! Seen every episode multiple times!

Amy Sherman-Palladino said, that "who's is the father" is no mystery. IT IS LOGAN! Of course, there was Wookie, but it was too early. Why are people looking for secrets, when there aren't any?!

Logan is Christopher Jess if Luke Rory is Her mom We all know who she ends up with

I need this show to come back only just to see Rory telling Logan and then getting married

Logan is the father (not the Wookiee ‘cause it’s in a different season) and you can clearly tell from the conversation with Christopher. Rory will end up with Jess: she trusts him, he encourages her and they’re kind of “unconsciously” in love, exactly like Luke and Lorelay were for many many years.

Kirk is hands down the best character

My point of view is: the revival is the real thing, what really happens in their lives. The original is the Rory's version (the book she wrote).

Absolutely hated Rory's character in the freaking revival. I know people appreciate Rory having a realistic life but I think Rory's "purpose" was to learn from her mother's mistakes. Her mum was a wild teen who thought she knew better, Rory was always grounded and mature. She made some mistakes (sleeping with Dean while he was married, getting arrested, dropping out of Yale) but why couldn't she then learn from those mistakes and live the life that literally everyone around her set the groundwork for? The townfolk, her mother, her grandparents all wanted and supported Rory's success. Logan was compatible on paper but ultimately his character was too self-centered. Jess was immature to begin with but he grows up and becomes the grounded person that Rory ultimately needs to bring her to her senses in the original series and go back to Yale. I'm still hoping they'll end up together somehow 😭 Also I loved Tristan too even though they were never together 😂

I wish Gilmore girls would come back

No matter who the father is. Jess will be the kid’s dad.

I seriously and genuinely hope they continue the show. We need more shows like Gilmore Girls💕

At first, I cringed at the musical numbers. I thought it was funny for a moment, but lasted way too long... and then, when Unbreakable came on, I wanted to cry just as badly as Lorelai, and everything made sense.

I missed Sookie and Jess and Dean. None of them had enough screen time. But I am guessing some of that had to do with how busy those actors were. Hopefully, everybody will be available for the next Gilmore Girls series.

Did seriously no one realise that its the whole Loop again? Rory being pregnant and no dad, like her mom. And the handsome guy who's in love with her from the start (but is not the father of her kid). Its a Loop so its easy to see whats going to happen!

It's way to predictable if Rory is her mum Logan is Chris Luke is jessy Let Logan and Rory end up together then it would be perfect

Im not done with the show yet, but man I really want Jess and Rory together 😭❤️ From the moment they meant they were meant to be. Just like Luke and Lorelai

I actually cried when Luke and Loralie got married

Definitely more Sookie!!!! I missed Lorelai and sookie-conversations!!!

The father of Rory's baby is probably Logan, since he is like Rory's Christopher (rich, charming, fun etc. can keep up with her, but despite it all fell in line with expectations, and just isn't right for her), with Jess being her Luke. Although if this is how it works out, it might mirror Lorelei a bit too much, but we'll see (if they even do a continuation).

Give us more Paris!

Well, Jess can not have much more screentime because his show "This is Us" is doing very well.

I was soooo happy when Emily finally broke with the D.A.R. Not just the club, but her whole unhealthy lifestyle (not saying it’s unhealthy for other people just for her). It just made me so proud. Also on the fall episode at the end with Emily I cried. It was sad but beautiful.

The musical was dumb

Well if you consider the idea that despite all Lorelai's hard work Rory basicly becomes her mom then Logan is the father. Logan would basicly be Rory's Christopher. Jess I guess is Rory's Luke.

I always suspected the mean letter Emily received was from Trix, Richard’s mother. We know from the original show that Trix wrote Richard a letter before they married trying to convince him not to marry Emily. I think Logan is Rory’s baby daddy, but I’ve always been team Jess and think he’s tried to become the man that he thinks Rory deserves. And if they were to do more episodes (fingers crossed) he would be the Luke to her Lorelei. Because Doucheberger is really the Christopher in that whole scenario. And there’s no way she wouldn’t keep the baby.

I know ASP wanted to end it with the 3 words “Mom, I’m pregnant.”, but I really hope they make “A Year In The Life” season 2. It ended in a really weird spot. We can predict Logan is the father, but we don’t actually know. We can predict she will stay single, but we don’t know. We can predict that Lorelai bought the nuns house for the Dragonfly, but we don’t know. Too many cliffhangers and details!! I want to know who the father is and I want to know if she ends up with Jess (I want her to)!!

the whole point of this mini series, and the way it ends, is that Lorelai's story is repeating in Rory. Rory = Lorelai Christopher = Logan Luke = Jess the father is Logan, who is unavailable, Jess is the good guy who secretly loves Rory but doesn't have the courage to tell her and so on...it's a loop

I love love love this Keep it going . Withe being able to see all these terrific flicks. Of the Gillmore girls. And it was Lauralie ..

I think things will come full circle and Rory ends up with Jess but the baby is Logan's (aka Lorelei, Luke, Christopher story) or Rory and Logan work things out (Richard and Emily story)

#SayYestotheJess

yes we need a sequel of gilmore girls !!

I still hope, there is a chance for more Gilmore Girls 💕

I think it's obvious the way they're going to go for this. Have Rory's book become #1, make it into a movie/TV show, and then it goes to show us into the first season of Gilmore Girl's.

The less musical one I don't like. I do wish they did that part shorter but the musical just shows the true colours of the town. It shows how quirky and weird it is but that's why we love it.

I just rewatched the ending of the revival, and that cliffhanger was 😫. They can't not come back!

Pls make more we love u guys all of u big fan off girlmore girls

Someone told me the last episode of the revival was weird and they didnt like it. So I didn't watch it for a long time. When I finally did watch it I cried the entire episode and I absolutely LOVED it. I'm so sad that it ended. I always wanted Logan and Rory to stay together.

It took me a while to process the whole story, and reading all this comments makes it easier to process my thoughts. I agree with most of you about the cycle beginning again with Rory due to her ending the show with being pregnant. It would be nice to watch a 2 hour Thanksgiving or Christmas gathering with all the family and their life updates as a closure to the whole show. Hopefully with a twist of happiness to all.

Excelente historia. Hagan más capítulos.

Would love to see more of this show

What is there to explain about Rory and Jess?? Obviously he is still in love with her!!! Hopefully they do bring back the show and make those two finally get together. I'm dying to know who the father of Rory's baby is as well, they can't just leave us hanging like this...UGH!!!

I agree that jess and Rory should end up together

OMG I agree with this whole list! We need more Gilmore Girls

Agree with all! Also I hope it's a real 24 episode long season like OG GG.

I think in the original girls, Rory was very nice and compassionate to her family and friends, I don't know why the narrator of this piece said she was always cold and lacked compassion, it's just not true of the series years.

i preferred jess in the revival so much more than the original show. I personally didn't find him that likeable because he was way too brooding and frustrating. I didn't mind him but he was too negative all the time. everyone complained about how arrogant logan was but I found jess full of himself most the time in the earlier seasons.

alllllll these questions, no answers ughhhhh they better make a season 2 I want to see more!!!!

Couldn't agree more, we *NEED* a comeback

If it comes back it'll only leave us with another cliffhanger.

The Netflix originals should look at this and fix it

I just finish watching the Gilmore girls I love it and you need to make more would like Rory with a baby Lorelei and Luke as grandparents please come back on Netflix again xxx

Please give us moreee😍

I really wanted that Rory and Jess ended up together 💔💔

I hope Rory and Jess end up together ❤❤❤

I wish it would come back Loved it so much

Totally agree with the comments and suggestions for next season or movie....why not? 😀 fsntastic tv show 👏👏👏👏👏👏

I LOVE GILMORE GIRLS 💜❤️♥️💜

While I loved some elements of the revival, mostly Emily's story arc, I was mostly disappointed. I think it was lazy story telling with most of the characters lacking significant development and growth especially Rory and Logan.

Please bring it back!! Love all the people in it...work with zookie she needs too be on show!! Can't wait til u pit them back on!

Awesome and I Love the show I real hope it comes back

"Leave out the musical numbers" 💀😂. Are we sure that the musical doesn't have some hidden meaning?

More Kirk is always top of my list. Jess was always a better partner for Rory. Intellectually and emotionally. They had the best chemistry and his character development was the best. Hoped that the baby was Jess's but I think its more likely Logans or Paul. Loved that Lorelai and Luke were still together. Lane deserved more. I always rooted for Doyle and Paris and was sad that they were divorcing. Hopefully they can continue the story.

agree 100% with all of these!!

As a next level die hard fan I loved everything about the revival, including the musical numbers. And how is the identity of the father even in question, it's not only obviously Logan, it was also declared by ASP herself.

I want more Dean LOL. I know Jared Padalecki is busy with the success from "Supernatural" but I still would like to see more Dean LOL.

Loved the revival. It was in a roundabout way good to see, that their life wasn't as perfect, as I thought. Sometimes, during the series, it felt like, Rory had everything going her way except for the few times, she didn't. Now that I'm re-watching the entire series plus the sequel, I understand Rory, Emily and Lorelai better. Rory had been held up on a pedestal and had everything handed to her, and was treated much kinder by her grandparents, and everyone else, than Lorelai ever was. Ironically, that is what made Lorelai stronger and more mature, while Rory became more and more immature with every episode. Lorelai's star went up, and Rory's star went down at the same time. I was surprised by Emily's change. And Sookie came back :D I love Sookie. Her voice really has changed over the years. I just wish, Lane would be happy and Jess would be happy. It's such a wonderful TV/Netflix series

I hope and pray that it does come back because I miss this show

Definitely need more Gilmore Girls But I found it was all over the place

It needs to be more happy! It was so cold! I was so disappointed! If it does get picked up make it a chipper up beat show like the original

For the revival I really wished they had just made Rory and Logan end up together married and then Rory has a kid with Logan so no one would be wondering all of this!!!

Yes! Please please please!!!! Bring it back!!!!!

So, I was reading online, and eventually, I came across a page. Apparently when they made A Year in The Life they didn’t decide to make until 4-7,8 years into the break. So I kept reading and they honestly don’t know if they’re going to make another one and they don’t know if it’ll be like the last time.

There is no baby daddy mystery. Amy did a good job with separating the storyline into seasons. Rory is with Logan for the last time in the beginning of fall. Rory is staring at the changing leaves out of the window of the bedroom the next morning. She tells Lorelei she's pregnant the morning of the wedding. The sign at the wedding is dated November 2016. She would probably be a couple months pregnant by then. The Wookie was months prior, and Rory would have been pregnant through the rest of Spring, through Summer and into Fall. The timeline is pretty simple.

You know how Richard’s mother hated Emily. My theory is that she wrote that mean letter to Emily.

I'd like to see a Gilmore girls spin-off that focuses more on Rory's life since "I'm pregnant.". I'd kind of like to see a different turn where the baby's father steps up and they get (happily) married. Rory decides to teach at Chilton after all, and while there discovers and develops her strengths. Her adult married life is a cross between Loreli and Emily; upper class but down to earth and not snobbish and controlling. I definitely think Logan is the father. The Wookie happened in spring, and she announced her pregnancy in the fall, so at minimum, she would be about 13 weeks along. She kept forgetting Paul, so I doubt there was much intimacy. We know she was sleeping with Logan. It's slightly possible it could have been Jess, but nothing suggests they were together at all that I can remember.

Can you please make another one of these and petition for Jess and Rory to get together!