I love the intro. I'm happy to know there's at least one person who played through a level without sacrificing Yoshi.

Your analysis of Crafted world’s gameplay/mechanics limitations was the most thorough I’ve ever heard. Described perfectly. Fully agreed on ranking Yoshi’s Island #1 & Wooly World #2. “BEST NINTENDO NITPICKER ON KZfaq !!” FR

The music in yoshi’s crafted world is sickeningly cute. Listening to it over the course of an entire playthrough is like eating an entire tub of frosting.

YOU DESERVE A LOT MORE SUBS

The original is my favorite videogame to this day. Yoshi's crafted world is my second favorite Yoshi game behind the original, played the whole game co-op with my little sis. We made great memories and the music is always going to bring back nostalgia.

Yoshi will always be my favorite hands down I thank Lord Jesus for giving us such an awesome dinosaur!

My personal favorite Yoshi game is Yoshi's Woolly World, also one of my favorite video game OSTs of all time.

I was working at Toys R Us when Yoshi's island debuted. I was really impressed. I'm playing it for the first time on Switch online and It aged really well!

Awesome list and analysis of the Yoshi games! My top 3 favorite Yoshi games are Yoshi's Island, Yoshi's Woolly World and Yoshi's Story in that order! ^^

Great video, you showed some things i didn't know about Crafted Worlds. (I'm playing it now, that's how i found your video) Hope we get a new Yoshi game this year, maybe a remaster of the Wii U game. I didn't play that one

What I appreciate about Crafted World is that it introduces alot of new ideas into the franchise while still feeling like a Yoshi game. It does stuff like: -foreground and background elements - choosing your own path in the 2nd world map - using coins as currency - score-based levels - flipside levels (or speedrun level as I like to call them) - cute cutscenes before the bosses (Past yoshi games just had Kamek say 2 or 3 sentences and that's it) Also, out of all the Yoshi games, i think this one has the most creative level themes in the franchise. It has stuff like: - an urban area where you find train parts - a desert where you run from a skeleton dinosaur - A ninja house - A town where clown dolls try to murder you with an axe - Avoiding the security system in a museum - Going on a safari hunt - A space shuttle where tiny robots freak out every time a meteorite hits the level -An acorn forest where you put owl dolls back into their nest -etc. I kinda hope some of the new ideas I mentioned in the beginning are used again and improved upon in future games (coin currency, scored-based levels, cutscenes, etc).

hi Yoshi Fanatic i love your top ten video your channel is the best also Yoshi and Diddy Kong are my favourite characters have a fantastic day

you just gained a subscriber. Yoshi is the best =). you are under rated your videos are amazing

I love yoshi too! Glad to see a fellow yoshi-mad Nintendo fan

Your channel is so underrated really good video

Wow, I didn’t even know Tetris Attack was a Yoshi game!

underrated channel

Great Top 10 :D So happy that you put my fav game @ number 1 The soundtracks are timeless & amazing!

I have the same order in the top 3. And Yoshi's Island is the best Jump 'n Run ever made.

Great list!! i agree on like everything :P have a great day!

The moment I saw your channel name, I hit subscribe right away, with no regrets.

Loved the intro!

1:46 personal timestamp

You killed this video dude 👍

My fav Yoshi game is Yoshi’s new island

Yoshi's Story is my favorite Yoshi games. Like Luigi's Mansion its replay value comes from trying to get the highest score possible. In Yoshi's Story tou do this by being a picky eater & only going for melons.

Nice opening 😃

6:03 jeff how dare you, i have that music as my ringtone and i LOVE IT!!

Great video, something i figured out half way through Crafted World was the you could basically double jump while flying and keep going up. (Fly then A and repeat) That was an awesome ability, not sure if it tells you in game. But then i did not see it

Thanks !

I love Yoshi

What? Yoshi has more than 10 games? anyway, the video is incredible man!

Honestly, my biggest problem with Yoshi's New Island is it retconning the ending of Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island. I would've settled for "Mr. and Mrs. Mario are out for a walk with their kids, when suddenly - Uh oh! - Kamek! He snatches Mario and Luigi and takes them to Bowser's Secret Resort on Egg Island!" than "Oopsies, looks like they aren't Mario's parents! Hope you weren't feeling all emotional during the ending of that game, sucker!" I actually don't mind the kazoo soundtrack, but that's probably because I see it as a "so bad it's good" thing. (with the way people kept complaining about it, I was expecting the soundtrack to be like 75% kazoos) XP Also, nice to see another person try to keep Yoshi alive in Super Mario World! I always attempt that myself. There's only one level where I'm kind of forced to abandon Yoshi - Vanilla Dome 2 - but there might be a way to get him through that section that I haven't found.

Agreed

I’m playing my first Yoshi game being crafted world, it is such a joy and really want to play yoshi’s island if I ever get the chance. I’ve always had a soft spot for Yoshi since mariokart wii. Just a question what’s your favourite Yoshi colour

Currently trying to complete the story for every Mario game since gb sp, yoshi island SMA3 was the first yoshi game I ever played don’t know how I feel about it being number 1, was a bit hard at times, and the levels are so long

Nice Video! What are your thoughts on Yoshi's Story N64?

my favourite yoshi game of all time is yoshis island ds

I got here when searching for anybody possibly discussing the topic of "What would a new Yoshi game need to dethrone Yoshi's Island?". Perhaps a video idea? To me, "Yoshi's Island" had just a wonderful mix of so many things. The level design was clever and varied, the music had lots of charm, the bosses also were different and imposing in their appearance and gimmick, plus you got lots of value in terms of replayability and completionist goals. This can be continued with the fun implementations of Yoshi transformations, the amusing little minigames as well as a surprisingly emotional story and atmosphere in my opinion. I at least felt like the original Yoshi's Island had something rather magical about it, that starts with the toy music box underlined intro scene towards the way the game presents the Yoshis as that bright and friendly folks that embark on a great quest to help baby Mario and his brother Luigi. Not to forget Kamek as a villain felt snarky and well, villainous and each time after Yoshi trampled one of the fortresses it felt like some impressive win. Lastly, the ending is single-handedly one of the most epic moments that pretty much compares to what some Kirby games tend to develop in their final sections to. What I try to say is, I really have fond memories of the game because so many things clicked and reaching the ending for me usually felt wholesome, as the Yoshis not only get to save a baby and a stork but everything comes to a close in such a satisfying way with the lovely ending credits. And that's why to me at least none of the later Yoshi games ever could compare in the slightest. They were fun and had their own quirky ideas but they usually felt so...uninspired...I don't know if that's the right way to phrase it. Will leave with a subscription and keep my fingers crossed for a bunch of fun Yoshi content. Would be neat to see some extra comparisons of levels, transformations, bosses and whatnot.

Yoshi wooly is the best out of the other games

Just started playing yoshi story went into blindly was expecting it to be just like yoshi island but didn't expect it to be about just eating fruit to get through the level. Its not as good as super Nintendo game but still fun to play

Crafted is hands down the best Yoshi game ever created! i hate that people don’t give enough credit to this masterpiece! i have played all yoshi games and crafted is by far the most charming game out there!

I never wanted to kill Yoshi.

There was a Yoshi game I played a long time ago that had the music you hear on the Tetris clip. But it was a platforming yoshi game. I can't find it anywhere.

I have a Yoshi plush.

Great list. I agree with most of it. The only Yoshi games I currently own though are Yoshi's Island DS, Yoshi's Island for the GBA and Whooly World (both the Wii U and 3DS versions.)

I just played through crafted world . I’m not a huge fan of the design but it was obviously very well done. I just hate that with every new game they try to reinvent the wheel when the wheel wasn’t broken. Like just do more of the og yoshi island.

I like yoshis New Island music but the cave music is a little... ಠ_ಠ

Hi guys, maybe anyone of you remember the title of the game of a (i’m not really sure) yoshi or mario games that we move using dice or number and theres a lot minigames inside the game… please if any of you know let me know i’ve been searching that game and haven’t found it yet. (Sry for my bad english)

Super yodhi

I miss yoshies New Island

7:20 wait, cut the rope copied ?

You didn’t even MENTION Plooch and Yoshi's Woolly World! That’s one of my favorites!! HOW DARE YOUUUUUUUU!!!!!! (Lol jk jk)

the best yoshi island is the ds version

I want to get crafted world so bad but the music almost ruins it for me

I don't understand why Yoshis Island is not available on 3DS Virtual Console

SMW2 Yoshis island is so ugly I just can't bring myself to play it. Yoshis wooly world is genuinely beautiful. Love playing it with my wife and can't wait for my daughter to get older so she can play it as well.

I played your rom hack

Yoshis crafted world looks good, but has so much annoying and lazy things in it to artificially extended the game’s length to make it seem longer. The “souvenir” **cough cough fetch quests** are completely unnecessary and if anything ruins the experience for me. I tried to 100% this game, and literally this game burnt me out within the first 10 hours to the point where I didn’t touch this game for probably 6 months. The game also makes you replay the same levels over and over and over again either for the souvenir hunt or the flipside. Like I get the whole flipside thing, it’s neat, but does it really have to be for every single level? All that makes you do is play the same level but oooo now it’s backwards, that totally makes it like a entirely new level right? Right? Right? NOO! My guess, they ran out of time and decided to make the player play through the same damn levels over and over to make the game feel longer. This game is a huge letdown from its previous game yoshi’s woolly world. I found more fun in the first hour of woolly world than the 15 hours I’ve played in crafted world.

And birdo is your least fav

bruh quit talking shit about yoshi's new island that game murdered me with nostalgia