Will Marner (and core guys) be traded if Leafs lose? Comment your thoughts

Why aren't people talking about trading the most overrated #1 d-man in the league. Rielly, doesn't - hit-PK- clear the front of the net- no point shot. He passes the puck to the forward group and picks up assists that any mid d-man that can make an outlet pass could put up similar numbers.

fowler gibson are washed up no thanks

IF Marner waives take anything you can and run !

If Keller was on the Coyotes still, I’d say no deal. Now that he is in Utah, I don’t care anymore.

Ottawa and Mormon Team would have to be out of their minds to trade Tkachuk or Keller for that choker lol

Unless Tkachuk asks for a trade, can’t see why Ottawa would trade him

5:41 As a Habs fan, that Montreal trade is ridiculous. Why would the Habs trade 5 decent/solid assets (including a ~#5 OA pick!) for an “star” known to disappear in the playoffs, PLUS dead weight in Reaves? (also overpaid…). Nobody will pay a ransom for Marner with that contract (and playoff reputation, earned or not), and one year away from UFA. They will be lucky to find a team willing to take him in exchange for a “decent” player, and maybe a 2nd/3rd pick, assuming they retain at least 25%, IMO. And of course it must be somewhere that Mitch WANTS to go, since he holds all the cards with his NMC… My guess is Mitch won’t cooperate, they will be stuck with him next season, then face losing him to FA, or maybe trade his rights after the season for a 5th or something if they can’t afford to resign him. (Probably same story for Tavares). I said from day 1 Tavares signing was a mistake, as they didn’t need another #1C, then the second mistake was giving him the immovable contract. For Marner, they should have moved him (or Matthews or Nylander… at least one of the three, to shake things up) when the new GM came in, before the NMC’s kicked in. (Like what the Habs did with Subban in the trade for Weber, which seemed awful at first, it ended up decent, maybe even a win for Mtl). Last year was the perfect opportunity for Leafs to make a change…. But no. Now they are in an even tougher spot. Good luck, Treliving…

Devils need to get tougher, they need a goalie and they need 1 or maybe 2 dmen so why exactly are they trading 2 young fwds, their best defensive dman and the 10th overall for another soft winger? Makes no sense for NJ.

Marner and our 2024 1st pick and Minten for Brady Tkachuk and Chychrun as Ottawa wants him (Chychrun)off their books as their right side is overloaded and they want him gone as per many insiders.!

No team is going to want to give up quality assets for a guy who completely disappears come playoffs. The best scenario for both Marner and Leafs is Marner gets his s%^& together and produces outside of just regular season.

I know marner would be the guy likely to move but could there stil be a window to move nylander before his new deal kicks in july1?

Yall stuck with marner unless you find someone to retain his salary for you. Going to have to give up extra to trade him

Trade Marner get another defence man. Find a competent goalie and then once Tavares contract is up you can finally start playing with fire. I’m not a Leafs fan but I’m a Canadian Hockey fan and enough is enough.

Here are players I would like in a trade package for Marner: Noah Dobson, Brandt Clarke, Clarke, Wyatt Johnston, Ke’Andre Miller.

Trade Marner and Knies for Brady Tkachuk!

I believe Treliving is gunna go aftr Brett Pesce this offseason to play on the right side of Morgan Rielly. Both 94 bbys too

WHY ON EARTH would anyone trade for John Gibson? I'd sooner target Dostal. God. Gibson turns 31 years old this summer, and his best playing days are behind him. Yes, he plays on a terrible team, but he had a win percentage of under 30% this year, and a Sv% of 0.888. Dostal played for the same team, had a win percentage of 37%, and a Sv% of 0.902. And I know GAA is basically a team stat, but Gibson's was 3.54 and Dostals was 3.33, so make of that what you will. Dostal turns 24 this year, and he started nearly as many games as Gibson did (38 vs 44). I think he has FAR more potential to be a franchise goaltender than Gibson. It is the rare goaltender who can maintain a starter's game frequency, combined with a higher than 0.900 Sv% beyond ~34 years old. So even if Gibson is able to perform better on a better team, for how long? I give it a year or two, maybe, before he is a backup that you play because you have no choice. Sure, his contract expires after 3 years, but I don't think he is the answer for any team looking to find a clutch goalie who will steal them some games (to be fair, I have my doubts about Dostal too, but he if it was a binary choice between those two, Dostal would be my pick, 10 times out of 10).

Toronto management have locked themselves in the corner with no key! Great job if no one decides to waive the entire team is just screwed , just accept losing forever!

If you don't get top talent in return, what's the point? Put an aggressive forward with a coach who wants to be your friend? Leave Matthews and Nylander to carry a team of youngsters? Or get aged out replacements prone to injuries? No matter how you look at the future rebuild, the next 4-5 years will be no different than they are today: built to lose. The only solution right now is to get rid of all the top leafs for first rounders. Start over.

David Kampf is one of the few Leafs that seems to be on his game this playoff. Either the trades are because his value has gone up or because people are annoyed at his contract. The New Jersey deal is interesting. I think Holtz is a 50 goal scorer waiting to happen, I wonder if New Jersey still buys that.

I think you underrate Necas. He has high potential, he havent got a lot time with Aho and he havent play a lot first line minutes. He is also good overtime scorer. I also think that it dose reduce Marner value in trade markets that he probably will ask huge cap hit in new contract too and that he has No Trade clause make it hard to trade on some teams who could pay more.

Kempe would be huge in the playoffs.

This is such and easy trade. Nashville for Soros and a 1st.

Leafs fans are smoking weed with those "trade proposals". LOL

Makes sense

have a gut feeling marner will be a Penguin.

Nylander does not get his no movement and no trade cause until Jily 01, 2024. So he is tradeable to his list with no say as to where...

they need to find a way to trade tavares too, he's too old. Bring in Kadri or Monahan as your 2nd line center.

Why would teams give up their futures for Marner? Hes going to be a UFA next year. Its obvious Marner wants out of Toronto

Why the F would we trade Minten?!

Ryan Reaves will be in Chicago next year likely

core 5 NTC, coach with non-scorer at 3C and 4C, = no depth scoring. on D, keep Benoit, McCabe, Lyabushkin, keep backup goalie, resign bert and max. Add Monahan at C. as always, for 20 years top D and G. nick, lilly, will only go in a package.

I'll trade you Brady and Timmy for Marner and Tavares.

very evident last year against Florida in the playoffs . Same issues again against Boston this year. When up against a physical team who plays good defense, forechecks well and battles along the boards for the puck. The leafs fluff four can't compete. Until the leafs build a team to compete against Florida or Boston, which should be their primary objective. They better move out of the Atlantic division, otherwise expect the same results next year

Go leafs go ... leafs in 7

JT for Brady … do it

Why do you have a bruins jersey

How can they trade marner with an 11 milly tag, who’d pick that contract up? It’d be nice tho

should be more than just marner unfortunately, but management has to play this right

As a sens fan, there is nothing the leafs could give us that would sweeten that pot enough. Brady is going nowhere, and hes bringing us a cup one day

Three words: NO TRADE CLAUSE. None of the four core are going anywhere. Bertuzzi and Domi are gone next season, though.

Trade Matthews for 5 first round picks. Trade Marner. Trade Nylander too

So glad you are not a general manager

Leaf nation is a tough group of fans to play for. You guys put way too much pressure on your players. If you lose in the playoffs, "trade them all. They all suck". You guys expect at least one of these every year: President's Trophy, a Hart Trophy, a Norris Trophy, The Vezina Trophy, or a Cup. Not all, but at least one of them. Imagine playing for a fan base like that. I understand you are frustrated. 1967 is a long time ago. But hey, if you want to trade some players, the Pens will take Marner, no hesitation. And Edmundson to sweeten the pot.

I highly doubt Bert will return to TO. Demi as well.

Marner isn’t waiving the no move. So

Do a retool video of your own

I dont want Marner... Rod would kick his ass lol

Ha ha ha......friedman reminds me of my Portfolio. Just listen or do the opposite and that's where you'll get the truth or benefit. Expert of the obvious. Makes sense what he says, right? Because teams are lining up for an 11 million dollar player that doesn't show up for the playoffs. How 'bout Joe Sakic for Bill Berg??lol Matthews is gone.... one more year, tops! Forget top notch US players. They want to play in the States, Canada sucks. Taxes too high, weather is brutal, government crazy with fake vaccines while US kids are partying on the beaches in Florida. Where would you want to play????

Do Mitch a favour and get him out of here. He is a spoiled brat and needs a change. I expect the leafs will give him $12mill though lol. Are people starting to realize how ridiculous the Babcock firing was?

Call me crazy it used to be that all the toxic leaf fans would go after 1 guy like Jaden and say he was the problem / kadri ended up getting a cup. They probably do need to break up the band. No point in talking about trades because these are wet dreams people have in Toronto not based on the any actual knowledge of what’s going on. Yes please take Seth jones and his salary

You are stuck with them. also, Leafs need complete rebuild. If you trade Marner or big moves, it should be all for draft picks. Your rebuild was a failure. See you in 7 years. You should be wanting Shanahan out and their entire upper management fired. Coach has nothing to do with this even he's not great himself.

Bam Son

Have another puff

Who the hell is going to want marner after watching him all these years in the playoffs. Especially this year.

Are you smoking crack? You would give Bertuzzi and Domi $4.5 to $5 million per year? Buddy, you will never ever see the Leafs win a cup with that sort of thinking. Last Stanley Cup 1967, last finals appearance 1967. Here comes a rebuild.

Core 4 are killing leaf fans ,ever year go away heartless players

Trade Marner are you out of your minds!! He will haunt the Maple leafs for the rest of his career!! That's not how you build a great team ! You need everybody to buy in!!!

This could be the last game as a leaf for marner, Gio, keefe, shanhan and samsonov (possiblt JT) ... or instead a serious pay cut for JT ($5M for a 1 year contract is all I'd pay)... we dont need to trade marner for another star player like everone is saying in the media. more likely scenario we can trade him for 1, or 2 decent player(s) that are tougher and 1 draft pick. we could even trade marner for a goalie or star defenceman. Giordano is probbaly retiring or traded for cap space. honestly get no players for marner and JUST GET CAP SPACE FOR FUTURE PROSPECTS SINCE WE HAVE ZERO CAP SPACE !!! NO RUSH TO SIGN A NEW PLAYER !!! leafs need to form a playoff worthy team, we've had a really good regualar season team for a while which I appreciate, but fans want to see a serious playoof run and possibly a cup

Marner's got a full NMC. He's not going anywhere he doesn't want to go to.

Trade marner to ottawa for brady Tkachuk . Lol

I agree with you John

rasmus dahlin for marner would be ideal

Leaf fans u are delusional lol why would anyone trade for a small guy who doesn't do anything come playoff time and who earns 11mil? Retain 50% then maybe you get half decent player back

Anyone like a marner for a Tom Wilson package.. it would make us alot tougher to play against in the playoffs.. also makes it easier if you wanna bury the reevo contract in the minors and gives JT and wily the protection they need on the second line..

Why would any team pay anything for Marner? I guess if Marner could be convinced to go to some team that has a hideous contract they want to dump - maybe. Otherwise just wait a year and pick him up for free. The side benefit is that the Leafs either have to be content to be a regular season team for another year or they buy Marner (and/or Tavares) out. Added bonus in the you still get Marner (and/or Tavares) for free and Toronto becomes even less of an attractive location for free agents.

I see the incentive for Marner to go to Utah because he wants to be THE guy, and in Utah he would be. Give it a go for 1 year and see what happens... who knows, crazy things happen in the NHL

Treveres was the biggest mistake signing. Marner is too talented. Treveres is old and slow.

Mitch Marner to Buffalo for Skinner Savoie and 3 first round picks

Dude, this franchise hasn't played in the Stanley Cup Finals since 1967 - 1967. The Harold Ballard curse still continues. They can make all the trades they want, but this franchise will NOT win the cup in your lifetime.

Why would anyone want Marner?

People and the media put so much pressure on the leafs that they can't perform when always asked so many stupid questions

Be more specific Auston matthews is going nowhere nor Nylander. Marner tavares and all the coaching staff yes.

I would trade RW Marner and C Potus Holmburg and picks or prospects and or G holl for G Jordan Binnington at 50% and LW Pavel Bushnevich 50% and or C Brayden Schenn he good at winning face off and controlling the puck which the leafs suck at big time and Also I if I was the gm I would trade for Mario Ferraro with the sharks I trade Timothy Lijegren and FNick Robinson and pick or two and prospect for D Mario Ferraro and C Luke Kunin and W Fabian Zetterlund.

I’m a Montreal fan I don’t want marner he sucks under pressure and in the playoffs

Why would ANY player go to Toronto? They're in an utter state, the media and fans are a f*cking nightmare for players, and the taxes are high compared to many American markets.

Marner waiving his NMC to go to the ducks lmao get out of here

Fuck, what core guys. And leave Mitch alone.