Hats off to anyone who can hit those high notes. Reba owned this song. I saw her sing it live. Saw Reba alot in the 90's. She was always on pitch. That's when they sang live. Trisha does a very good job, I pity most fools who would even attempt this song.

Love Reba,Trisha and faiths versions of this Absolutely beautiful song,Man....Gets the darn water going...

I have seen Trisha 22 times in concert and met her 9 times in person. She is without a doubt, the most genuine sincere sweetest person you could ever imagine. Once I even made her smile on stage in Seattle and she had no idea it was me. Not a stalker, just a fan who completely loves her voice and her songs. Sadly, she and Garth are retired. I'll never understand why?

This song, and Trisha Yearwood's voice take me back to the early 90's. First started liking country back then. Trisha's voice is rich, smooth and fantastic.

My two TOP Country Favs, Reba and Trisha, WOW... doesn't get ANY better than that! Such Beautiful voice, such Beautiful women... love it! also one of my Most Fav old Reba songs/videos too... NICE!

Best I’ve heard to Reba on this song!❤️❤️

Trisha's gifted voice matches her inner radiance ... I admire Trisha. She pulls from a genuine place of feelings ~ .. keep making music, Trisha !!!

Amen to that brother and sister and amen and here here

Amazing! I love how Trisha sang it from a completely different angle in her voice. :D

Cool Trisha really rocks!! I love her version and Reba is the bomb too!! Two great female country singing artist that are still singing and keeping us happy!!

As I recall the crowd was very appreciative of Trisha performance as was Reba, this was just great singing !!!! Thanks for posting Bree 26

Excellent job as always Trisha. She could sing Pop goes the weasel and make it sound like a hit song!!!

Shes the best one for this song. Love you Reba Girl, but this one, belongs to Ms. Trisha!

NO ONE can sing this like REBA!!!!!!!!!!!!! I don't care how great their voice is............but Trisha did do a great job. So did faith at the CMT Giants Special honoring Reba. In their defense, this has got to be the hardest song of hers to sing. I give them both props! FYI........This was from the 40th annual ACM Awards. The did something special for it, to honor those special artists who have done so much, and accomplished these special awards.

Hits the heart if country ..love Trisha

she did a dam good job

😄 altho i luv luv luv reba's version, i gotta say of the 3 live performances trisha is best. ( the 1st time i heard this song (by reba) i thot my heart was going to stop.

Kudos to her for having the courage to do this song but come on everyone, Reba does kick ass 1000x more than anyone could ever could.

I just Listened to Both Faith Hill & Trisha Yearwood's videos singing Reba "You Lie" and it is totally clear that Trisha Yearwood's rendition is so much better than Faith Hill's. She does an absolutely fantastic job, not to say Faith Hill's version isn't good as I am a big fan of both.

I love Trisha she's my favorite singer

This was a special the ACMs did where they had country artists celebrate other artists who one a certain number of ACMs. Reba was honored for winning the Female Artist of the Year four years in a row in the 80s.

This song is incredibly difficult to perform live. A lesser vocalist would have embarrassed herself, but Trisha delivers as usual. I'd like to hear a recorded version that allowed her to "make it her own," but I think she won't tread on Reba's turf.

Trisha is a doll baby! I've loved her since I was a child!

Same note different tone. Trisha is amazing

@catseye664.....Faith? power and range? I like Faith, too, but Trisha could out-sing Faith on any song, any day of the week. I'm sure millions of people would agree :)

I like Reba's twang and highs better but this version is a close second and to even be compared to Reba is an honor in itself.

The announcer said the song is called "You Lied" haha but anyway Trisha did a very good job covering this. :)

I truly love her voice. Besides Reba and Dolly, she's my favorite country artist.

All in all - I love Trisha's voice. I like this song, though I like other Reba songs much more. Someone else commented that it's a hard song to sing - and I think that's totally right. It's difficult vocally and emotionally to put over. Reba does a great job at both. I think Trisha does a great job with this song (better than Faith Hill did on the CMT Giants special). And while I agree that Trisha did a really nice job on If I Had Only Known, I still prefer Reba's version.

@RyanCooleyFanx Reba sang You Lie in a medley in November at her concert in Louisiana and she did fantastic i cried! she still hits those high notes without a care and beautifully!

as a tribute, she did Reba proud

@bRDwyAnnIe here, here! that super high note reba hits is killer!

WOW

Amazing!!!

I love it I totally forgot about this one thanks for posting it:-)

I don't really know for sure, I think it was 2005 on some kinda of special like "Country Music Honors" or something like that... among the singers honored there were Barbara Mandrell (Reba sang for her) and Reba McEntire.

Where was this taken from? An ACM special?

Love Trisha.

Heart of country women

@meredithchandler73 Reba's version is awesome yet I think Trisha did a very good job, although I still prefer Faith's version over Trisha's (but that's because I absolutely and unconditionally love Faith) :) And yes: this is a very difficult song to sing.

Vert pretty and nicely done!

They have very different voices, Reba's is clearer and a little higher, Trisha has more of a hoarse voice, you can't quite compare them. I do think they both are perfect in their own ways.

no faith hill sang this for Giants Trisha sang If I Had Only Known

NO TRISHA S BETTER VOICE!!LOVE IT

Was it the 40th Anniversary of the ACMs? Or a different ACM special? Was there just the one song for Reba or was there another performance? Trisha is wonderful. :)

Now that was amazing singing. Even Reba Mcantire was impressed.

Didn't think Trisha was retired - just Garth.

Also I guess the person that slammed Trisha Yearwood for singing this song wasn't intelligent enough to realize that The video is from a special "A Tribute To Reba McEntire" and that is where her peers honor her by singing her songs. Also this person apparently doesn't realize just how many of the songs Trisha Yearwood recorded first that were later recorded by another artist. If an artist wants to record a song someone else has released there is nothing wrong with it. It is just personal taste to which version is preferred.

Only 1 Reba.

I have to say Trisha did it better than Faith on this song :)

Very hard song to sing, she laid off a little but still very well done

I like Reba But this is better ...............

yea faith hill might have more vocal range than trisha but thats just one tiny little thing of the whole picture, i like trisha's version more here but by only only slightly bit more than faith

@Bookworm0485 and the super high note... was on a recording...not live !!!

trisha did well.. but rebas reba... not close

O

This isn't Trisha. It's her double

This is good, but its apparent Trish can't match Reba's high notes.

Toughest thing in the world to match up to Reba's voice! Nice try though!

Interestingly better than Reba.

IMO, this is not even a marginally good song. But it was a hit because Reba can take a mediocre song and sell it. I'm a huge Trisha fan, but Reba can sell this song better. Maybe I'm too harsh on Trisha, but Trisha needs a good song to stand out; when she sings the good/great songs, she rocks my world. Check out "If I Had Only Known", a much better song and Trish made everybody cry and "Lying to the Moon" - original by Matraca Berg - the original was haunting but Trish's version makes me weep.

faith to me has never had the best voice....even after her throat surgery somehow improved her voice.....listen to her first album then her third album....her first album faith's vocie kinda shaky but the surgery made her voice sound a bit better

Way out of her 2-note range.

I think Faith Hill sang this song better than Trisha. Faith just has more power and range in her voice, and Trisha doesnt hit the high notes as weel as Faith. And obviously Reba sings this song better than anybody, lol.