The Ridgeline got everything going for it except true off roading and I dare say that 90% of truck buyers never take theirs off roads. It's the Ridgeline for me.

I crossed shopped both these trucks hard. Plenty of research, and test drives. I went with the Ridgeline because: 1) When comparably spec'd, they are close in price. I got the Pro 4x up to $39k, while my RTL came to $42k (but had a few more options not available on the 4x) 2) Build quality. My research indicated Nissan trucks are actually pretty reliable (unlike the rest of the brand). But Honda quality is legendary. 3) More interior room up front. What most don't tell you is the Honda is wider than any other midsize truck. Plenty of elbow room. Driver and passenger both get their own armrest. And I've discoverd the Ridgleine center console is the perfect size to hold a bag of burgers and fries. (Very important for the all the covid inspired time in the drive-throughs). 4) More inteior room in the back. Not only can I sit behind myself (I'm 6'-4"), but it's the storage man, the storage. The Ridgeline rear seats fold up so flat, and the floor is almost completely flat. TONS of space. Enough you could fit a mountain bike (with the front wheel off) in there in a pinch. I can almost "walk-through" the space. 5) The bed is better (in the 5'-ish version). As it's 5'4" in the Ridgeline, while only 5' in the Nissan. AND, the Ridgeline is completely flat, while the Nissan wheels wells project significantly into the bed space. AND the Ridgeline's tailgate opens like a door, making it super easy to step on the bumper then into the bed. AND, the Ridgeline's lockable, weathertight in-bed trunk is magic bonus space. AND the Ridgeline bed comes "pre-lined". AND, the bed is 60" wide all the way down, where the Nissan is only 44" wide between the wheel wells. 6) All-wheel drive is better than 4x4 for my type of driving. Having driven a Ford Ranger for the past 21 years, I am amazed I put up with 4x4 for so long. For one, the all-wheel drive is "always on", I never have to slow down to under 40mph to swithc into 4x4. Nor does the all-wheel dramatically reduce the turning radius (nor does it 'crab walk' when turning tightly). (Note, I do gravel roads and forrest service roads - no rock or mud crawling). 7) I don't tow. 8) The ride is better in the Ridgeline. It rides like a plush suv. Just got back from an 800 mile (round trip) road trip. Super quiet, super comfortable. - Honeslty, if you don't tow or rock climb - you should really really test drive the Ridgeline.

The BIG item that matters to a lot of us on these small trucks that regularly does NOT get enough review attention is their ability to haul sheet goods. The Ridgeline beats all the traditional small pickups AND the other unibody vehicles. It can haul 48" sheet goods with no adapters or modifications in the bed.

Ordered a 23 Ridgeline. Picked it up last week. I was looking at a Tacoma. I came to realization that I’m a family man who lives in the city. I’m never going rock climbing on my days off. I needed a comfortable vehicle that can haul a sheet of plywood if needed. I do a fair amount of seasonal highway driving, so the awd will be capable. All boxes checked. Pretty satisfied. No stigma regarding not being a “traditional truck”, I’ve owned many half and quarter tons, couldn’t care less.

I'm still enjoying my 08 Ridgeline. Has 185,000 miles. Best vehicle I ever owned. My family of 4 fits comfortably. Taken it on long vacation drives. Plenty of hauling furniture and yard waste in the bed. Absolutely love it

Drove both, but bought the ridgeline. I'd do it again. For my truck use it's perfect. Good payload for road trips, very comfortable, better fuel economy, awesome awd system, way more interior and bed space, in-bed trunk is genius. All that being said, I like the look of the frontier a little better.

The Nissan looks amazing and overall seems like a really nice job on the refresh. With that being said though, I think the ridgeline would make more sense for me and my family with the added trunk.

I'm a Nissan guy but I'll give credit where is due and the Ridgeline has come a long ways in the design and practicality of the truck bed so kudos there. For most folks Ridgeline is the way to go if you can afford the extra cost. Good video, keep up the great work!

It's crazy to think that a unibody truck would give a "traditional" truck a huge run for it's money on so many levels. Great vid as always!

Ridgeline all the way! Great bed storage, dual opening tailgate, speakers in the back, smoother ride. And very cozy back seat. Honda for the win.

I like the Frontier. The frontier imo gives off a styling for the younger crowd like myself. The ridgeline is nice, but it gives off a styling for the much older crowd who likes the comfort plush like vibes..again just my opinion.

I just bought a Ridgeline and I did go look at the new Frontiers. The biggest difference between what I saw at the dealer in 2023 between those two trucks was the price. The Nissan dealer had their list price over $43K for the 4x2 frontier and no 4x4 on the lot, and I got the Ridgeline RTL for $41K but had a list price for $43K. So the Ridgeline was much better equipped.

2019 Ridgeline owner. I road tested a Nissan, but I don't care for their reliability. Ended up trading in a 2016 Silverado for the Ridgeline. Best move I've made. I don't need a full-size truck, gas milage is poor, and it towed way more then I'll ever need to. Honda made an excellent truck/alt truck. They killed it with the engine power, as well as the mpg's. Also, with the right tires, the thing will do whatever the Nissan will do. Might even have to lift it a bit- if your clearance needs are there. With my larger tires, there is slightly more lift and the snow capability is awesome.

Good video. I too am a "large guy" I bought my first ridgeline (first model year of old design) due to the bigger cab space and wasn't dissapointed. While it's not as good offroad it was sufficient in my first Caribou Hunt (-30C northern quebec logging roads in winter) and so I have had two more ending with the 2017 model. Love the drive comfort and I generallly tow a 4100lb travel trailer without issue. I'm all for the ridgeline.

Thank you for doing the car seat test. Not many reviewers do this. I love off-roading but I have 2 kids and your videos are always very helpful.

My wife and I were in the market for a midsize truck and initially we didn’t go with either. Instead we put money down on a Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-road. It was cloth seats and did have the upgraded entertainment system with side steps and a few other features. The dealer had a 1k mark up which started out as 2k and they had some non-negotiable add ons line 300 for nitrogen in the tires and 309 for wheel locks. All and all $49,928. We kept browsing around and found a 2022 Ridgeline RTL-E and it felt so much roomier, the features it came with were so much more useful to us and my wife fell in love with the trunk. The major need that had to be met was towing a 18 foot bass boat, so no issue there. It also had a 1k mark up, non-negotiable front window tint, LoJack 1 year and Permaplate 1 year. Only added accessories was the protection package that seemed like all weather floor mats. All an all $50,200. Driving it was so smooth and not like a truck, and wife loved that it’s base drivetrain was FWD. So sure we lose out on a lot of off-road capability without modding, but it checked every box we cared about. At first I still really wanted a real truck, but a month in I am so glad I went with the Ridgeline.

My husband bought the first Ridgeline from the dealer back in 2006. We treated it like a truck and it did the job. I am surprised by your verdict on off roaming because we didn’t hesitate to drive off the pavement and go over hills and mounds and cross streams and drop into ditches and it always did what we asked it to do, and it behaves as if you are driving down the highway. It never failed to do what we asked it to do and my husband liked to take risks and push the limits. Constantly. He was a good driver and knew too many stunt driver tricks than I could appreciate because he never hesitated to take risks. That Ridgeline didn’t blink, not once. The one think that he never managed to do with that truck, try as he did, was make it lose traction. He was never able to do it. He would go out at 04-0500 before the plows started working on the roads to try and make it slide. In deep powder, with ice on snow on ice, didn’t matter. We kept all season tires on it, no snow tires with or without studs, no chains and it didn’t matter. Even with 1/2in or more of solid ice on every inch of the road and it would not slide, spin or lose traction in any way. He tried until he could no longer get into the truck. Even when we put hand controls on it. It behaved too well for his entertainment. It has 140,000 miles on it and it still behaves like it did new. He died earlier this year and I will possibly sell it. I don’t have any use for a truck, especially one that is not easy to put a camper on. But I will have a hard time getting rid of that reliability. If I could find a camper that the Ridgeline could accommodate, I might not let it go. But I don’t know if there is one that would fit. If I found one, I would take it off road quite often. If….

4:50 mentioned the narrow space of the Nissan bed, but didn't mention the Ridgeline can put 48" ply, OSB, or drywall flat between the wheel wells.

Great video. I’m a fan of your “Real world” vs. “The numbers” comparison. This is really helpful for determining which vehicle is the best fit. Thank you for your efforts. Five out of five stars.

I own the Ridgeline. You are correct all you points. But. Statistics show. 90 of owners of pick ups. Do not use them as trucks. I am very happy with mine. Better ride.

Just picked up my Ridgeline RTL this morning. Traded my ‘17 Pilot and honestly can’t feel the difference in driving! Test drove every single mid-size truck (already have a Tundra) and hands down… the Ridgeline is just one of a kind. Thank you.

I call our Ridgeline a minivan with a bed, and that's what makes it awesome. Super comfy, practical, efficient and is more truck than most people ever need. I do have my Tundra for work though...

I absolutely love my 2011 Ridgeline. I don't need a off-road vehicle, and I get good mileage.

Love this review! Truck King you are one of the if not the best go to truck videos on youtube handsdown! 😀🙌 Buy a truck that suits your needs and not what the people would dictate you. At the end of the day, you are spending your hard earned money might as well get the one that would serve your needs best! To each their own as what we normally say! Proud and satisfied owner of 2021 Honda Ridgeline here! 😀🙌

I think you owe it to your viewers to actually take the Ridgeline through the hydro line. Otherwise, you're just speculating. :)

You can visibly see the rough ride in the Frontier versus the Ridgeline, night and day difference. Not to mention you can see how much more room there is in the Ridgeline, there was probably close to a foot of separation between them but in the Frontier, they were basically touching arm to arm. And the road noise was far greater in the Frontier. To me, from the looks, features, size and ride, besides all the other added conveniences, the Ridgeline wins hands down. That will be the truck I purchase.

I appreciate you talking about the baby seats. That definitely sets you apart from other reviewers.

Love my 22 RTL Ridgeline. Your review is spot on.

I would still pick the Honda

The width of the cabin in the Ridgeline compared to all other midsize pickups is a huge selling point for me. It's the only one that doesn't feel cramped. I owned a previous generation model and kind of thought the in-bed trunk and tailgate were stupid ideas - wrong, I used both all the time. And that 1400-1500lbs payload, unbeatable.

I own a 2018 Frontier but have been thinking of switching to a Ridgeline. I just don’t go off-road much anymore since moving to a larger city and commuting to work in something more quiet and smooth would be great for me. I love the idea of having the trunk storage and better under seat storage in the back. This video really helped me think things through more. The Ridgeline also seems totally capable of towing a small camper and going to camp sites up north for fishing trips which is all the “off roading” I plan to do.

Very good video for what I am interested in. Thanks Steve, Matt, and Howard.

You made me a very proud owner of a Ridgeline. I ABSOLUTELY LOVE MY TRUCK/HONDA PILOT!! One thing you missed is that the bed has speakers for a tailgate party!!!

new frontier looks incredible, someone at my gym has a red one with a small 1.5-2" level kit and it looks great

Truck King crew making you ask yourself the questions that will lead you to make the right purchasing decision. ❤️

Major Kudos for putting in child seat info. I have not seen other reviewers do this. It may not apply to everyone, but very nice touch for those who have young kids or grandkids!

Just picked up a 2022 Nissan Pro 4x in alert red, love it!

Nissan stepped it up with new model. Good review as well, the will be cool to see these trucks in 30 years and how they hold up

Dang, you're good at these videos! Thank you

Glad we got fellow Canadians to preview our models in Canada 🇨🇦 Thanks 😊 Truck 🛻 King 👑

I've driven both and I'll stick with the Ridgeline. Best little truck. I have my Silverado for heavy work, but the ridgeline is my every day basic get around choice.

I love them both, but the roomy interior and payload of the ridgeline are unbeatable for the crew cab, 4wd configuration.

I recently got a 2011 Ridgeline and I LOVE it! All my mechanic friends told me I don't want a Nissan and I'm so glad I listened.

Thank you for this comparison test. Very helpful.

I have a first gen Ridgeline. I have no off roading ambitions. It drives amazing in snow, mud, etc.

Coming from a TRD 07 Tundra I realized I don't actually do much off-roading and my towing requirements changed when we downsized our camper. My 2019 touring Ridgeline has really surprised me. I do a lot of driving for work and it hands down is better than my old Tundra. It handles everything I ask it to do. The payload allows me to haul almost a cubic metre of soil. The trunk is a game changer and I can easily reach into the box without having to jump up on the tires. If I did a lift on it I could do trails but who am I kidding........ I don't want to scratch the paint. Unless something else comes along I will keep this for the long haul like my bomber Tundra. The styling is nice on the Nissan but, it just seems mechanically dated.

Great video, really appreciated the car seat demo!

Good review. Thanks for including a child seat test. Rear and Front facing. Keep up the good work.

Ridgeline! Specially as a daily and just going to home depot for certain things... I like to go off roading, but not on a daily... So for everyday, I think you guys got right on the head... Great review!

It's really going to depend on what your looking to do with your truck. I'm biased I own a 2022 pro4x Frontier think it looks way better by a long shot but that's subjective. If your looking for more towing (1200lbs more plus depending on trim )and offroad capabilities( not TV commercial dirty roads) go with Frontier. You want more payload and comfort go with Ridgeline. That being said for a body on frame the Frontier rides fairly smooth the zero gravity seats are very comfy. I also prefer the interior on the Frontier . I bought my Frontier based on what I do with it, better suited for myself. Many things you can compare but to each their own . Ridgeline has clever designs and in love in bed storage.

I test drive the Frontier. It was rough. I tested drive the ridgeline, and it was smooth. Grant, for those hard-core off-road individuals, the Frontier is the one. For those that like soft off road outing on smooth semi road surfaces and want comfort, the ridgeline is perfect. Good presentation. 😊

Great video, this was exactly what I was looking for! Thanks guys

I would go for the Nissan Frontier, but the Honda Ridgeline is no slouch either. Both trucks serve their owners in unique ways that fit their owners best.

The best part is the mid size options are finally expanding and improving by leaps and bounds. I bought a Ranger Lariat FX4 because I live in Wyoming and at elevation a turbo engine is so much better than NA. That said I had a Tacoma before this and I liked it for the most part (seating position was brutal and needs more power). Love the updated Nissan and this Honda as well. SO good to have great options.

Steve, Nice in depth review of both trucks!

I appreciate this review. Thank you for the details and for thinking about parents. Puting the car seat to demonstrate the space on the backseat was awesome. Thank you

I have owner several Frontiers and was interested in the latest design.I told my saleman I did not want a black interior here in Florida.The new Frontier only comes with a black interior so I started looking at the Ridgeline and really liked it for my needs.I bought a new Pearl White 2022 RTL-E HPD and I'm so glad I did!

I have a Ridgeline. I had two Rangers in the past and loved the Rangers.. especially my tiny 5 speed from 1992. With that said the Ridgeline is very comfortable. I towed a trailer with it on my last move no issue. The backseat is great. The bed is great as is the trunk. Only thing would be off-roading and it’s kind of a pristine truck. I’ve heard it called the Gentleman’s truck.

Got a 2021 Ridgeline. For me, I wanted the highest quality truck and I did not need a full size truck. The choice was clear.

- You two make truck reviews fun! Keep it up.

Good video. Since I dont need to go off road or tow > 5k, Ridgeline is my choice. Frontier admittedly looks a lot cooler though

I love my 21 Ridgeline black edition for big road trips with my buddies white water kayaking. They love it as well, just super comfortable. Had it in the snow this year here in Utah and it just ate the fluff up, zero issues. I also put a Jsport level kit, jsport push bar and front skid plate. helps get that front off the ground and protect it a little more. When we're getting our kayaks situated and all our gear, the in trunk stereo system gets everyone pumped on Van Halen and AC/DC. It really rocks. I can fit an entire two man inflatable kayak with most my gear all in the locking trunk, which makes me feel tons better when I stop for a burger and beer and i can't see my vehicle. Lastly, the higher end stereo system and subwoofer absolutely rock.

Ive got a 17 Ridgeline RTL-E and I love it. Smooth ride, big interior and a nice truck bed for when I need it living in the suburbs.

I greatly appreciate you adding in the child seat portion. Thank you!

I agree with your assessment. Ridgeline is better for 90% of the buyers.

Great review and video as usual ! I honestly think the Ridgeline is a far better truck to live with on a daily basis .

I researched many mid size trucks and for my lifestyle and what my plans are with a truck for work and adventuring i just bought a 2023 Honda Ridgeline. Day 2 and im in love with it.

love all of the space offered by the Ridgeline.

I kind of wished you would have off roaded the Honda...to show it is capable for what it was designed for, which covers almost 90% of normal owners even if you take a wrong turn...and they designed their AWD system pretty well the only major issue like you stated is ground clearance.

70k km on my 2019 Ridgeline so far, only complaint is the 2 ac compressors that have been replaced in the first 50k.

Great clip, really appreciate the baby seat fit test, thanks!!

Great review. As a carpenter I care more about loading supplies at Home Depot then going off roading. I am sold on the Ridgeline.

After testing a Frontier and Ridgeline, I have changed my attitude toward the Honda. Nissan did a great job updating the Frontier, but Ridgeline has more room and better reliability. I will wait to see what the update on the Tacoma looks like, then make a purchase on a midsize, leaning toward Ridgeline currently own 2010 F150 want to go to midsize.

So, given how they did comment on the width difference inside of these while driving, go to the start of the video, pause, and look at how much wider the Honda is, it is remarkable. Then again, this is easy to see in actual numbers. The Honda is only an inch or so narrower than an F150, at 78.6 inches (not counting mirrors), a Ford Ranger is only 73.3 inches (not counting mirrors), and this Nissan only 73.0 inches (not counting mirrors) (all data from Edmunds). 5.5 inches of extra width is no joke, and that extra width carries through to the bed, which is 4 inches longer than the Nissan's in addition to that extra width.

Nice review, you covered everything I was wondering about. For me the Ridgeline is the keeper

Bullfeathers. As a professional Forester and timberland real estate broker my past has been in off-roading, as will be my future as I manage my own timberland. My Ridgelines, since 2005, have never failed to take me where I needed to go in the boonies and return me home safely.

what if the Ridgeline had a 2 inch lift and a front skid? hear and see alot of ppl say it can handle the off road just the ground clearance is killing it.

Nissan knocked it out of the park with the looks of the new Frontier (finally utilizing visual aspects of The Warrior concept). Best looking factory mid-size truck IMO (Pro-4X trim). I just wish the price was a little lower

I love both trucks but I own a 2020 Frontier Pro-4x because I like to hit the desert trails in AZ. However my daily commute is a 70 mile round trip and that's when I wish I had a Ridgeline.

I owned an Xterra and Pilot and both were a couple of the best vehicles I have ever owned. So, I test drove both of these thinking I was going to succumb to the Tacoma mafia in the end anyway. Now I own a Ridgeline RTL-E. It's fantastic.

Have recently test driven both. Ridgeline rides so much better than the Frontier! Back seat much more comfortable than the Frontier also.

I have the 2022 pro4x and 2019 RTL-E. The Honda is overall a better vehicle, and it’s not even close. (Comfort, drive feel, features, trunk, etc.) But, living on an island where sometimes the roads are non existent, the off-road ability is sometimes a must. Both are great but different purposes. Nissan looks way better for sure! If they bring back the Xterra with the redesign, that will be the next car I get.

I own the 2022 Honda Ridgeline RTL-E. Love it.

Thanks for saying your size. I'm 6'2" as well and 270 lbs so size is a big selling point for me. great video

Exactly the type of video I want to see. We are window shopping for a new tow vehicle for our Casita 17 Freedom Deluxe travel trailer (2910 lbs loaded). Love the looks of the Frontier, but we don’t really need a hardcore off-road truck. Beyond some snow and forest service roads, that would be the extent of our off-roading. Given our trailer weighs less than 3000 lbs (loaded), the extra tow capacity of the Frontier is NOT a game changer. In all other categories, the Ridgeline wins. Importantly, its payload is superior to the Frontier. Despite liking the Frontier, I would go with the Ridgeline if I were buying today. It is the best all around midsize truck for our needs. Waiting to see what the new Ranger and Tacoma will bring to the party.

Had a 05 frontier. Best truck I’ve ever owned. Have a 12 titan now. Looked at the new frontier and was a bit disappointed. Didn’t feel as solid. Engine wasn’t as punchy even tho has more HP. I don’t do as much off roading anymore, think the next ride will be the ridgeline.

Drove the frontier. Walked across the street and bought the Ridgeline. Haven’t regretted my decision for a second. 3rd Ridgeline we’ve owned.

Ridgeline will for sure be my next truck

Having owned both, the Ridgeline is hands down more functional for my daily needs.

I've got a 17 Ridgeline RTL with 77K miles. I get (in the US) 20 winter mpg (running the remote start to warm the truck occasionally, better in the non-snow months) and an easy 27+ mpg highway (averaging 78-82 mph on a recent 230 mile trip). It tows my travel trailer, is awesome in the New England snow, safe and comfy and hauls everything I need to. Plus it's super reliable. It's an awesome do everything I need it to do truck. Highly recommended.

Well I just bought the new Nissan Frontier 2022, and I took mine off road right off the lot and it’s the best four wheel drive I’ve owned. I’m only disappointed I couldn’t get the top model or pick my colour especially buying new. I’m an ex trucker and love the solid ride and way it handles

I love the look of the Frontier Pro4X.

Lane keep assist is a pain in the butt! I always turn that off. Both great trucks, but not really apples to apples comparison.

I have the 2021 ridgeline with 2" front lift, with 15k km on it already. My only complaint about it is the auto start and stop is annoying and the small button for the fan control.Other than that great on the high way and awesome in the winter.

Just bought a 2022 Ridgeline. Its much more capable offroad than it gets credit for.

Thanks for the review. Ridgeline for me, no question.

I’ve had both and the power steering in the Frontier is way better. It’s hard to hold the Ridgeline between the lines. Love the steering on frontier. I agree with everything else that you said.

I have a brand spanking new 2022 Rtl e Ridgeline and Ive even taken on a few dirt roads but nothing insane....it handled way better than I thought it would. Yes I am extremely happy with my ridgeline I fill it up with 93 and it purrs on the highway. It handles so effortlessly like your almost gliding on water. Its easy for it too go too fast and you wont even realize the get up and go to this vehicle is phenomenal. I love the gas mileage. I love the the wireless charger. This truck is so teched out it will make your head spin. I love being able to start my car inside my house when im crunched for time and need to keep warm and warm up my truck simultaneously.

Very helpful information, thanks.

The folks at Honda’s HPD needs to talk to the people at Toyota’s TRD. Give it 9” underside clearance, add a shield, beefier tires, and upgraded drivetrain while keeping the Honda magic in drivability. Can this be done? Honda is so close to the perfect truck for people that need a little more.