Seriously i can't understand with the people who complained Eugene was replaced by Seohyun. At the time Eugene was pregnant, for god's sake! And the one who has idea for Seohyun to take in charge of Eugene it was Bada itself, they were very close as unnie-dongsaeng. And there's no idol who suit the most for Eugene's role in here excelt Seohyun. She's part of SM, so did S.E.S so she naturally practicing and look up S.E.S as her role model since she was trainee as lil kid. And Eugene itself was so grateful and happy Seohyun take her role bcs it was their own Seohyun and ofc she did a great job. Our golden maknae always giving her best and always work hard eventought at the time she's also busy with her musical activities.

이 당시 유진씨가 임신중이라 어쩔수 없이 못나온겁니다. 누구 탓할일이 아니죠. 서현이 정말 라이브 잘해서 후배라 잘 뽑았어요.

Seohyun must be happy dancing in the stage with her senior its an honor for her for sure

바다는 무도 나왔다 하면 레전드찍고 가네.. 게다가 각기 다른 종류의 레전드임.

Bada. looks. exactly. the. same. O_O, it's creeping me out really

ten years from now i wanna see snsd performing gee like this with all nine members,it might take longer more years but i'am willing too wait.please let it happen : (

와중에 sm인데는 이유가 있구나 중간에 서현 있는거 자연스럽고 노래도 서현이랑 잘어울림

참고로 바다는 sm내에서도 이수만이 가장 좋아하고 아끼는사람중 한명이였습니당~ 가수로서의 재능과 실력은 그당시 여자아이돌 그룹중엔 최고였죠

Seohyun isn't Eugene, but Seohyun did a pretty good job. Bada said in an interview that Seohyun often studied Eugene's moves and singing in old SES performance videos, even though Seohyun was busy with her musical. Bada is the one who suggested Seohyun play Eugene's role in this. So Seohyun did it, with Eugene's blessing. Seohyun was fully aware for what she was doing, why she was there, so acted accordingly, which should be another thing to compliment. Plus, people who attended this event also said Seohyun did a good job. Finally, SES trio has invited Seohyun to their SES chatting room as a 4th member after this memorable event. :) Love both SES and GG!

비록 서현은 유진이 아니지만, 유진의 빈자리를 서현이 채우는건 바다가 제안한거였고, 서현은 그 빈자리를 채우려고 최대한 노력했고, 슈, 바다와 같이 공연할때 전혀 어색함없이, 아니 잘 어울릴 정도로 잘 해줬으니, 그런점은 박수를 쳐야죠. 게다가 서현은 유진의 빈자리를 채우러 온걸 알고 있는 만큼, 절대 튀려고 하지 않은점도 칭찬받을만하구요 (그렇다고 서현이 원래 튀려고 하는 타입이라는건 아니고). 바다 인터뷰 읽어보니깐, 서현은 옛날 SES 공연 동영상을 여러번 보면서 유진 스타일대로 춤추고 노래하려고 공부를 했다죠. 슈도 인터뷰에서 토토가로 인해 친해진 서현을 여러가지면으로 칭찬했고, 토토가 이후에 SES 멤버들이 서현을 SES 채팅방에 초대해서, 원래 SES 3명만 있던 SES 채팅방에 이제 4명이서 같이 대화를 나누곤 한다네요. ^^

서현 인성 갑인듯. 원 멤버랑 비교당하고 이런저런 말들 나올 가능성이 뻔한데 선배 가수들을 위해 어려운 자리에 나오다니 서현은 정말 모범적이고 마음 착한 연예인이다

서현 유진 빙의 실화냐?? 첨에 독무 할 때 표정연기부터..엄청 연습한 티가 팍팍 나네

Seohyun was the best replacement they could have get, she resembles Eugene a lot.

Seohyun did good. she changed her voice to sound more like Eugene.

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ계속 슈만 나오면 자막이 '세 아이의 엄마'만 인데ㅋㅎㅋㅎㅎㅋㅎㅋ

바다 진짜 완전 똑같다..비쥬얼부터 목소리톤이랑 다시 봐도 뭉클😭

Kpop groups like Bigbang, Suju, 2ne1 and Snsd promise me after 5-10 years you'll gonna do this with the former members! 😭 I'm literally tearing up thinking you'll gonna end your careers anytime soon. There's no forever in this world. Even though it hurts, we do need to face reality. Also i am very grateful that i lived the same century with the legendary kpop groups! May the generation of kpop groups raise the hallyu wave!

Seohyun always tries her best to do everything. Nomatter how hard it is. I appreciate her a lot. Go Seohyun! We Seomate will always beside you.

바다는 진짜 그 시절하고 뭐가 달라졌나 싶을 정도로 비주얼, 노래 뭐하나 빠지는게 없네 정말 감동 그 자체

서현 춤선이 넘이쁘다 눈에확들어오네

Seohyun looks like the most tired one even though she's way more younger than the two lol but even though they still slay!! Especially bada!! I REALLY LOVE HER VOICE 😍😍

C'mon people stop bashing Seohyun for no reason. She just is helping hand to SES member. Now I see how rude and immature koreans fans and non-korean fans. Stop the hate and go somewhere else to hate.

바다누나는 외모도 존예인데 목소리가 너무좋음 진짜 청량함의 끝판왕

메인보컬 그 실력 어디 가겠는가. 한결같다. 그냥 경이롭다

I hope to look as good as Bada 20 years from now. ( Like Bada do you even know how to age wtf?)

legend of 98' (SES) with legend of 07' (SNSD)

서현이 튀지않고 너무나 자연스럽게 그룹에 묻어나서 더 완벽했던 무대

This would be girls' generation in 10 years from now on, they will come back and perform maybe gee and make all us old sones cry, i believe in that future, i hope other 2nd generations group does this too soon in the future

damn i almost cried. memories memories .....i had a crush on Bada. I would still drop every Girl for her without hesitating.

서현 안무 표정 노래 너무 예쁘게 잘하네요.

바다누나ㅠㅠ 저 목소리는 국가차원에서 보호해줘야지ㅠㅠ

Ses 꽤 좋아햇던 사람으로 서현 위화감이 하나도 없어서 너무 좋앗음 잘햇음

서현......... 소녀시대에서는 몰랐는데 이렇게 보니 엄청 예쁘다.... 목소리도 좋고 노래도 되게 잘부름.... 진짜 소시에서 노래를 담당하는 맴버답게 노래도 기본기가 탄탄하다! 진짜 바다 목소리도 좋고^

서현이 청순하고예쁘다~바다,슈한테도 참잘하던데, 역시 어디서든 사랑받는 서현이~♡임신중이라 못나온 유진을 대신해 정말열심히 연습하고 멋지게 춤,노래 참잘한듯~♡서주현 멋져~

서현픽 좋았음

바다 보컬은 레전드다..

Koreans are so good at preserving their youthful looks damnn

이것도 와...벌써 6년전이라니..ㅆㅂ 시간아 안가면 안돼겠니?

뮤직뱅크 본방본다고 얼마나 기다리고.. 저 앨범 사서 늘어지게 듣고 가사집이 다 너덜해지도록 노래 가사외웠는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋ저때는 s.e.s 테잎사는게 인싸..ㅋㅋ

유진이랑 서현 닮앗누 ㅅㅂ 역시 스엠상 정석인듯?

seohyun part is the same like when they perform this song during their debut

seohyun was so lucky to hang out with the 90s legends and even perform with 90s Legends

클라스 바다 넘사벽이다.....보컬의 신이다.

The fact that Seohyun changed her vocal tone to fit and mimic Eugene’s is just straight up amazing. As a fan of her, you can tell she really did her best with his performance.

oh wow, i didnt grow up with SES but this brought tears to my eyes. Just seeing SES and the fans who supported them, just dancing and singing along. it must really mean alot to bada, shoo and eugene! ^~^ if only eugene could've been there :( its okay seohyun did great!!!!

I wish Eugene was there because it will feel more memorial and honour but Seo help replace because Eugene might have some emergency. Love u Seo hater going to hate.

바다는 걸그룹 가창력 면에서 역대 최고 중의 하나로 꼽힐 만하다.

Bada is vampire. No change anything. Her voice is still likes a lovely girl. Shoo, I didn't see her in tv show for long time. I'm glad to see her smile with SES performance.

I love Seohyun no matter what people said badly about her. She tried her best here. It's not easy to fulfill people's expectation for such a great legend.

Wow Seohyun is so pretty, she really does pull off any concept, she looks pretty in this!

Both Bada's voice and face remain unchanged, the only difference was that her skin has become lighter Seohyun blended in so well Shoo is energetic for a mother This performance is just awesome

천서진 : 뭐야..너도 대타썼잖아...ㅠ

seohyun looks the same and sounds the same! you guys have no right to bash her cause she wouldnt be there if eugene is able to go! but she just replaced her cuz she needs to! she tried hard and she was really happy and its an honor so pls

하하 랩할때 to the left 말고 to the reft 하는 발음까지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ똑같이함ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

너무 늦게 와서 그런가? 서현 잘했다는 댓글만 남아있는데 도대체 누가 별로라고 말한거지?? 잘만 해줬구만.

서현 머리기니까 유진보다 더 유진같아

Even though this song doesn't have a large vocal range with decent dance moves that Seohyun can DEFINITELY sing and dance to, it must've been so pressuring on her to live up to expectations of SES since they're like. Queens LOL

seohyun is always do a good job when harmonize the song, love ittt

바다는 진짜.. 가수 해줘서 고맙다

바다 목소리는 진짜 어떻게 이렇게 청량할수가있징 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 사랑해여 눈나

OML! I CAME HERE AFTER S.E.S TEASER THAT SM RELEASED A FEW MINS AGO I AM SOOO NOT READY TO DIE >.

seohyun did a great job here. starting from 3:11 you can hardly hear shoo's voice but seohyun kept singing. she got exhausted but still she tried to sing. i'm not blaming anyone. its understandable that its hard for shoo to sing while dancing because of her age and she's not a main vocalist. of course it would be great to see eugene here but seohyuns effort should be appreciated.

바다 음색이랑 가창력은 정말 입 벌어지네요. ㅎㅎ

2:53 슈 누나가 센터로 올때 서로 포지션 맞추려고 춤추면서 자연스레 옆으로 빠지는 서현이 보고 무릎탁 치고 갑니다.. S.E.S.누나들 골수팬임은 물론 SM골수팬인데 각기 다른 세대로 조합해도 완벽한 무대를 만들다니 지금 다시봐도 너무 좋네요..

근데 서현 너무 찰떡

바다ㅏ 목소리 너무 예쁘다

노래가 어쩜 이리 예쁠까 들어도 들어도 안 질림 ㅜ

ㄹㅇ소녀시대 초반 느낌난다. 키싱유 베이비베이비 같은 거...

Bada's still hitting those high notes like there's no tomorrow, geez. I love this so much!

No one should compare seohyun with eugene both women are amazing and seohyun is kindly filling in for eugene.. just enjoy it instead of bringing your negativity

이노래 나왓을때 27살이였는데 정말 무한 반복으로 천번은 들엇던 기억이 나네요... 유진양 사랑햇엇습니다. 저도 벌써 49살이군요... 추억을 만들어 주어서 고맙군요... ㅎ

I'm a 60 year old British-American guy who only discovered K-Pop by accident in 2019, through Sisters' Slam Dunk and then Girls Go To School, so everything I've learned about K-Pop has been through SNSD, and their various interview references to 1st Generation female stars such as BoA, Chakra, Baby Vox, ( and 2nd/3rd and 4th Gen stars too), as well the early male idols like G.O.D and Shinwa. So because of SNSD's mentions of them, I checked out S.E.S. What a fantastic trio! They apparently didn't get to be called "The Nation's Girl Group" as SNSD was, but that's effectively what they were, in the late 90's early 2000's. Bada is a great singer, S.E.S harmonize so well, I love their stage fashion and musical style---its often 'cute' but not excessive ( like SNSD's 'Kissing You' which IMHO is objectively nauseating as an MV, but paradoxically delightful live in concert). S.E.S are just charming, properly beloved, and having Seohyun fill-in for Eugene makes an artistically and genuine mutually-respectful connection between these two rightfully influential girl-groups--both of whom challenged, and actually countered, the dominance of male groups in their respective eras ( and both of whom, I think, helped break down male chauvinist norms). But apart from the socio-political influences of S.E.S and SNSD...well.. they are both beacons of delight and positivity in a difficult world( I'm not discounting the many examples of male artists doing the same, I just can't help really enjoying women being being independent of entrenched male chauvinism---thanks to my non-conformist mother, and my father, who statistically should have grown up to be an asshole, but wasn't. (Which is why they married 6 weeks after meeting, and stayed in-love until they died). Anyway... never mind that last bit---S.S.S ( Sea/Bada, Seohyun and Shoo) is a good as the original S.E.S.

i was not even born during S.E.S era but i LOVEE THIS SONGGG SOOOO MUCH LIKE SOO DAMM MUCH...It makes me tear

Seohyun did amazing 💖 Bada is gonna look like a teenager forever. And god she nailed those notes WHILE DANCING and there was no shakiness at all. Just a machine of a woman ilhsm

Seohyun eonni so pretty🥰🥰🥰🥰

Bada really is the treasure from the deep sea. Her voice is so special.

Bada looks and sounds the same!

And now S.E.S. is coming back with Eugene!!!!😍😍

Seohyun ❤️ Eugene.... SNSD Dongsaeng and SES unnis....

Our Maknae🥺🤗

is that wven bada!!!??? Lol she looks like she froze woth time hahaha. she still looks freaking good after all those years. dyum.

it's so much precious time~! i hope some day if snsd all have been married in future... they also comeback again with jessica and perform into the new world

서현예뻐♡

Legends covering Legends. SES really love snsd, just the fact that Bada particularly asked seohyun to be in charge of Eugene's part is touching. We all know that Eugene is irreplaceable but Seohyun did a really good job in covering her senior.

Can't wait for their comeback in 2017 20th Anniversary #Always

Bada slayed that whole performance with her high notes

바다 소리는 국보급이네요..

서현 너무 귀엽다.. ㅎㅎ

♥ Shoo, Seohyun and Bada ♥😊😀😃😄😉😳😍

I miss 90's k-pop music ... they seem to have more heart & SOUL than today's generic k-pop...

바다가 빠졌으면 대체 불가능 , 너무 존재가 뚜렷하고 넘사벽이죠~ 지금 보니 진짜 SES는 바다 씨가 지분이 제일 크네~

Seohyun performing with her sunbaes! Daebak 🔥

I just love the way the audience screamed and even stood up when Shoo started singing 😂 That must be so touching

Sooooo many memories when Dreams Come True came on. For many of the commenters here who don't know or were around when S.E.S and Fin.k.l were solid number one and number two on the charts, enjoy this history lesson from one of the legendary groups.

I believe that through this the first generation of fans really enjoyed and had their own style of enjoying their idol's music at that time, it was so much fun

Man it's just beautiful to see how happy Shoo was performing here. That smile is as genuine as they come and truly infectious. Huge love for S.E.S to this day! WE LIKE S.E.S Y'ALL!

왓더... 바다는 옛날이랑 다를게 없네...

내가 감수성이 가장 예민했을때 내가 좋아했던 그룹.. 이 그룹을 통해 그때의 나를 다시 본다 내가 이들을 기억하고 사랑하는 이유

바다는 예전이나 지금이나 변한게 없네..상큼하고 힘있는 목소리 그대로야

Having followed Kpop since H.O.T. and S.E.S. days, I can tell you that nothing today comes close to the nostalgia that the 90’s kpop music creates. Even without social media, they were HUUUUGE all over the world. Today’s kpop bands are more skilled and perfect in every way (IU and Gfriend fan here). But bands today don’t have the magic that SES had.