I deeply apologize for the edit at 20:00 😅 Also, you can't miss the shot.

This was a depressing ending man, Starlo’s ‘Why did I hesitate to fire that last bullet?’ is the equivalent of the Alphys endings ‘I really should have killed you when I had the chance.’ Both lines are raw af lmao

Love how when Ceroba said "Why won't you die" everyone in the chat went STANDING HERE I REALIZED.

I like how you can really understand both sides of the argument of if this was a moral choice or not to kill Ceroba, for a ending that’s just a branched off version of pacifist there’s a lot to think about in it

One thing I've noticed a pattern of in this game is how the endings fit with a theme of justice. Neutral being the worst ending arguably for everyone (the player and Flowey included) because there is little sense of justice being able to go one way or the other. the "Pacifist" ending seems like it fully leans justice towards monsters while "Genocide" leans justice toward the 5 human souls. it makes sense that this ending seems like clovers justice of self and shows that while they are willing to help mosters, they will not willingly give their life to the monsters, and seeing the 5 souls trapped was a wake up call that clover traveled the underground for something they ultimately lost sight of somewhere along the way.

Something I noticed watching this through again: you don’t gain any LOVE when killing Ceroba in this route. I don’t think this was an oversight either. LOVE measures your capacity to hurt others. The more you kill, the easier it becomes to distance yourself. Clover didn’t gain any EXP or LOVE from Ceroba, because they didn’t want to hurt her. This wasn’t an act of senseless violence, or even an act of vengeance. Clover saw a lonely mother weep over losing everything she had left, and decided the best thing they could do was grant her final wish. This was an act of mercy.

Shoutouts to that guy who yelled “THE DENTIST ALWAYS WINS” in the chat after the fight ended

Fucking laughed my ass off when it said "easiest undertale fangame attack" during that undodgeable attack

Honestly I feel both of these endings could be about equally canon to Undertale. While it's implied Asgore killed some of the previous humans they never say he killed all of them, and the True Pacifist ending even goes out of its way to show how Clover's equipment ended up in the dump. I still like this ending, but I don't really agree when I see people saying it's the "more canon" one.

35:51 clover: *pulls out a gun at asgore* asgore: how tense

Fucking Starlo man. The Flawed Pacifist gave me fucking chills down my spine. Because of Clover killing his best friend, Starlo knew that everything could have changed if he could have talked things out. But now, because of the actions of Clover. Starlo really wanted why he hesitate to fire that bullet TO Clover. God. I feel bad for Starlo. This is such a chilling ending even though its a pacifist one.

37:25 why didnt asgore just use the undodgeable fire circle attack against Frisk? Is he stupid?

This is such a neat ending. The outcome makes me wonder if what was done was just, and if now justice is being done against that action or Clover’s own will wavered because they doubted their action

God damn. That line was so raw. “Why did I hesitate to fire that last bullet.” Gives me Alphys and Sans vibes with that line.

As someone who has played only the genocide route, Ceroba is clearly holding back. Spoilers below In genocide run, the attacks remove some of your HP permanently (in the fight at least)

33:48 "You don't get it Asgore, we saved like 3 people" Thanks chat

37:25 I loved that sneaky text at the bottom 😂

It's cool that they actually made a completely different ending for this, when I saw that I thought it was going to be an Asgore deal all over again where basically the same thing happens regardless of choice

Fun fact, your lv does not increase after killing ceroba because your actions were just

Kanako's death really was SOUL CRUSHING.

i think its really weird that Asgore doesnt explain to Martlet thats its just impossible for Clover to leave the underground, even if either Clover or Asgore wanted him to

The Ending is cool and all, but it really makes you think. UT Yellow is a prequel. We all knew that Clover would’ve got their soul taken regardless

He must really like this game. Shayy has posted like 6 videos on this in a matter of days

so called "free thinkers" when ceroba asks "why won't you die:"

Seriously though, "someone tried to brutally murder you and experiment on their child! How could you kill them after they tried to do the same to all 3 of us?!" It really just doesnt rationally work. See, I dont think its the _right_ choice, but Martlets right: it _is_ just. Theres no saying she wasn't still a threat, theres no saying she wouldnt have just tried to kill you once more. Her threat was "neutralised" to you, but not to Kanako, and not at all over the next few minutes. Her masks broken, sure, but we know she can still be powerful regardless. This is the logical route. Not the ethical one, but the logical one.

I feel that the decision between killing or not Ceroba resides completely on what you answer to her question about what's your purpose in the Underground. If you answer that it is the human children, then it is only logical for you to surpass an obstacle that us wife to a man that has killed a child and that has experimented on a human soul, for you to meet Asgore. Clover answering that in Steamworks reflects that he indeed remembers what his mission is, and the fact that he is befriending everyone is only due to him not having a just reason gor executing them. If you however don't answer to Ceroba, then it is shown that Clover has forgotten about his mission, and he is now just seeking love and will sacrifice himself for the justice of the monsterkind. In my case, I player two pacifist runs, in the first one I got put of every battle by acting, and spared Ceroba. In the second, I actually fought back against every monster, as it is legitimate self defense, and just spared their lifes whenever surrendered, as it is the just thing to do. In that run I fought Ceroba and killed her. And I felt that Clover pointing a gun against Asgore, meaning that he is also one to be judged for his actions and deserving punishment, was the best possible outcome to the character. I feel genocide just connects with that idea and it is supposed to be a run where Clover, having knowledge of his previous attempts (let's remember Flowey saying that he is solving puzzles faster), knows that he needs to be stronger to fight Asgore, and therefore, has no other way around than getting stronger, and sees his actions as nothing more than a mean to justice. He doesn't think that those actions are actually just in itself, that's the reason we can see that Genocide Clover is much more human than Genocide Frisk. He's able to apologize to Martlet before attacking her, what I think is canon, ad a way of saying "I don't want to do this, I didn't want to do that, but there's just no other way around" The fact that Clover actually looks down when starting a genocide, just reclects how he is not happy with his actions. I think it really is a reflection of Asgore, in genocide, Clover just turns into asgore himself in order to kill him. In pacifist flawed, he goes for true justice in every action, but that doesn't give him the strenght to deliver justice when it matters most. From a moral point if view. Genocide is justified from utilitaristic views. Whereas flawed pacifist is justified from an imperative moral standart. True pacifist, however, would be a strange turn where, still justified by imperativ ethics, Clover decides that the ones that deserve justice are monsters and not humans, or, it can also be seen as Clover abandoning completely the seek of justice, and just doing the best for the friends he has made, even though that is practically the opposite to what is implied in his "revelation". The creators clearly want to indicate that the true pacifist is the canon, but I don't see a problem at all with this one. The only thing off is the gun and the hat in the dump, but the same scene we see for true pacifist could be done by Martlet taking Clover's things after he dies against Asgore and doing the same thing, since Martlet still loves Clover.

Y'know, I just had a thought. Why did the nice humans have to be killed immediately? Why couldn't, say Clover, live out their life in the underground peacefully until the time came when the last human fell?

20:30 that animation gives me chills even though I've seen it like 5 times, such a good game

I dont know if it's my messed up moral compass, but Starlo is NOT justified in saying "why did i hesitate to fire that last bullet", both Starlo and Ceroba try to take advantage of you, and you take pity on both. Ceroba outright asks you to kill her, i cant imagine her actually living with the things shes done. I get Starlo is grieving, but we're a kid who was forced to kill someone for the first time, and instead of comforting us, he basically kicks us while we're down. With foresight, obviously this is the bad ending option because le pacifist, but in the moment i thought to kill her, i kinda wish you just had to spare Ceroba because this end is anticlimactic

out of all the endings, i think i like this one the most, but its hard to pick a favorite. all of them are so well written, but i think it makes the most sense for it to end this way.

Wouldn't be surprised if the creator of this fangame went on to work for toby fox some day. Truly amazing and faithful to the source and that ending hits HARD. LOVE IT.

Watching these playthroughs makes me realize how good of a voice actor our strimmer is, very good shayy ❤️

I just realized: Why is Ceroba worth zero EXP in this? Is… Is it because the world didn’t see what you did as an “execution”? Because you weren’t acting out of violence, but instead in a twisted form of mercy? Is it because she wanted it? Like, did she really *truely* want to die?

One of my favorite endings in Undertale Yellow. The emotions are just so…raw. Hurts even more because Starlo’s one of my favorite characters

W SHAYT LOVE YOUR VIDEOS THANKS FOR GIVING THE UNDERTALE COMMUNITY A GOOD YEAR!!

Ah , the cannon ending of getting Killed by Asgore. Finally 39:20 It was , you gain no EXP from that fight , just like if you Kill Asgore or Flowey. The character sees it justified so they don't feel the desire to kill more and their LV doesn't increase. They Feel Justified

Something strange I noticed. Right before you land the final hit on Martlet in Genocide, her name is yellow. I wonder, if we spare her, will there be a flawed genocide ending? I haven’t seen anyone do this yet so just a suggestion. Edit: The yellow name on Martlet only seems to appear if you get her to 1 hp using the Justice Soul bullets, otherwise it doesn’t appear.

This is the ending I wish I got. I expected to get. Instead I spared Ceroba unaware that would mean that I would sacrifice myself for monsterkind, which I never agreed to. I watched this video because I was too lazy to replay the entire pacifist route again just to get my preferred ending. I’ll just pretend this is what I did

People may like the true Pacifist more, but i like this ending a lot. It's the one i got at first, and i just like the way it portrays Clover

"Asgore fight is rigged!" Dashing :

Having watched all of your Yellow videos I'm always amazed at how terribly black and white chat is about morality, which is ironic considering the game

Starlo's an idiot. Imagine killing a mad criminal in self-defense who tried to murder you and then having to listen from their relatives and friends how it was your fault. Somebody's not surviving my next walkthrough...

Sparing Ceroba = True Pacifist Killing Ceroba = True Mercy

big W for uploading so much, this made my week so much less awful

Okay Shayy’s voice acting is really good!

I think the reason i hate the true pacifist ending is because those monsters made a child give their soul, that's messed up

Seeing this really cements that Asgore never *wanted* to fight. He shows clear remorse for what he has to do to Clover.

Like if you did true pacifist but then when you tried to go back flowey said “no” and you didn’t feel like replaying the whole game.

Weird. Asgore didn't explain that in order to pass the barrier it requires a human soul and a Boss monster soul, making the fight unavoidable. Was this timeline prior to that discovery? Nah Asriel's backstory exist, so it means that fact existed long time ago. So I wonder what's the explanation to this. And also Chujin's work. It seems I can't make any sense to it.

Definitely weirds me out that Flowey didn’t appear after making such a big deal about getting to Asgore in every other route

Any ending with Asgore getting the Yellow Soul is Canon

Finally got down to watch the last ending... I know that everyone already commented on it, but Star's last speech right after finishing Ceroba is so RAW and in your face, you knew that you could just spare her and forgive her, it was as simple as the click of a button, but that wouldn't be just... would it? Of course, Asgore acting strong on Clover when with Martlet, but being distressed when it's just the both of them on the last room. And also like... CLOVER AS WELL?! How he tried to be polite to Asgore when Martlet was around, just to let Martlet feel safe, and in the last room having enough of Asgore's shit because he ruined their mission since the beggining?! I feel for Clover in this ending... in a sort of regreful way, like Asgore. And also, last thing, how Ceroba said "Thank you" in such a relieving way, like she knows this was the best option to the situation, not trying to brag of as strong to Clover, being happy that she will get to see Chujin again, even though she knows she falied on her own mission. Heartbreaking, that's probably what almost every character felt in this ending, that's all I have to say. As I comment this I have already seen basically everything on the game, endings, secrets, all of it. Might be missing some specific dialogues, like sparing situations in No Mercy routes, etc. But I think that's all for me. Like I've said in other comments, I only experienced this myself one time, and that's how it will stay. If I ever feel like I miss this wonderful world, I'll pop a gameplay on YT here and there, or listen to the banging OST while I study. As my final grand goodbye to this, thank you to all of Team UTY for stayin strong for so many years to get to release this, you all should be IMMENSELY proud of yourselves! I hope in the future you get license to sell merch of this, so you can receive what you deserved by having this free (and also for me to get something cool and memorable from it lol) Also yeah Shayy you exist lmao, thank you for all of the videos on UTY, specially this one since I think I didn't see someone bring it as a full fleshed out video dedicating a thumbnail and title to it, keep up the great content as always :). Probably the longest comment I've ever written... I hope in 30 years time I can look at this comment and see how I cared about this stuff, and find a reason why I should always enjoy and care about it! THE END (fr this time)

Bro I wanted to do this but it just boots you back to the beginning and I was so mad, but thank you for uploading it!

thx for everything shayy :D

makes the line in Undertale Red & Yellow (geno run) hurt even more “Because you’re ‘above consequences.’ Because you ‘need to know.’” - Clover, at the end of the No Mercy run of Undertale Red & Yellow

nice to see daily shayy content ere mate

Love the way Ceroba steals Asriel's leitmotief from "Hopes and Dreams". It's probably symbolic but I just think it's funny.

I always read it as "SER-eb-uh" cuz that sounded the most like "cerberus", anybody else? Also this ending feels the most fitting in the larger context of Undertale, I'd say it's my favorite one.

I think flawed pacifist made me cry more than TPE. Thank you for sharing this story and thanks to the team for making UTY ❤

Waited for it!!!

Starlo almost makes no sense. He is just a fool.

Concerning which end is canon, I think both the pacifist and the flawed pacifist routes are the best candidates but to me, the flawed ending seems the more canon. In the pacifist route, Clover wants justice for the missing children before them. They're looking for the responsible all the way until they finally get sensitized by the Monsters history and the final fight with Ceroba. In a sense, Clover gave justice to the Monsters, accomplishing their destiny by giving their soul while their belongings will be found later on by Frisk in the waterfall. In the flawed pacifist route, it's the same thing but when fighting Ceroba, Clover claims justice for her actions and the horror she committed. While their morality can be questioned, it's part of Clover's character. Plus, the fact that Clover found Asgore to discover that he is the murderer of the children before them and confront him ties in perfectly with the events of Undertale. Especially since ultimately Clover is powerless against Asgore and joins the other souls. We can easily imagine that after that, Martlet gets to collect Clover's belongings to bring them to the falls as a final tribute.

Thank you shayy

for me, THIS, THIS ONE, is the canon ending of vanilla undertale and nobody can make me think otherwise, this is just perfect!

If you sit around at pacifist on creds you see *somebody called.

What I find fascinating is I can’t be mad at starlo. Close relationships and friendships are important to us, it doesn’t matter if it’s right or wrong we’re devistated when we loose them. And he IS right there was an option to spare her and everything was ok and he’s in pure grief so he might not even see the situation tatically, thats why I like true pacifist its more satisfying and clover goes out more as a hero then just a self defense situation. (Also I don’t want starlo to be mad at clover it made me really sad 😢)

I just realised that flawed pacifist ending is the canon ending, because Clover's body ends up in the coffin room.

This is the 93738283th time Undertale Yellow has made me cry 😭

Shayy should become a voice actor 100%

I don’t know why, but this particular ending feels canonical (subjective)

Dang, I was disappointed not to meet Asgore in the normal pacifist route so this is actually really cool to me! Honestly, reads more like how I feel things wouldve actually gone down, rigged fight or not. Also I kinda love that Clover is basically canonically a wimp, even considering Asgore not holding back in the same way as he did facing Frisk at the end. Also Im still surprised an Asgore fight happened, I thought Clover was going to give up their soul directly out of guilt

The worst part of all of this is that there will be no one to take in kanako after frisk completes true pacifist, Starlo is mentally broken because of ceroba’s death and in no condition to take her in and ceroba is literally dead

"you're lower than dirt" hit hard af

I like the Halo Reach-esque "Objective: Survive" ending. Intuition tells you to keep trying but you know deep down that this is the end.

flawed pacifist is such a good name for it idk why i never thought of that lmfao. ive just been calling it aborted pacifist because. you know. tho. i really like this ending for how abrupt it is and how despite it being so empty it can still fit within undertale's canon. maybe asgore throws clover's stuff in the dump after the swift end they meet. i'll always prefer the 'sacrifice yourself for the monsters' end where you get to see your four besties happy. i love them what can i say lmao also just as like. an add-on to this. the abrupt nature of this ending is so... natural to me. they were almost there. they were entirely pure through their entire journey and then suddenly RIGHT at the last moment clover just. refuses to forgive ceroba. and then they finally get to asgore and because of a mixture of doubt and i assume guilt they fail and their soul is collected. it's a horrible ending imo but it's a just one for how abruptly you have clover kill ceroba

This is the ending where I felt most sad, cause it was when I realized that I had consumed all of the Undertale Yellow endings (to my knowledge) and by extension content haha. Great game

I like how this is the only route you can take to be killed by Asgore! Pretty cool :)

This is the ending I wanted to have happen in my play through. I feel like the whole game is being hyped up to fight Asgore, and knowing that we lose was far more interesting to me than just letting Ceroba take our soul. In my head canon, this happens after sparing Ceroba and giving our hat and gun to Martlet and Star. Clover goes to Asgore by themselves and.. dentist visit ensues.

Its so annoying that Starlo is angry with Clover.... Ceroba deserved it and sparing her ends with a child killing themselves and nobody stopping them so no thank you..

Wow, I am damn glad I did not kill Ceroba and chose the better ending…this is really heart-wrenching

What an incredible game. No wonder it took so long to make!

I love that in Asgore, they removed the determination motif. Such a small and nice touch.

ok this is the ending that happens before frisk falls

Starlo be trying to blame everything on clover such an L im glad its clOVER for Ceroba

Incredible

I had an idea of a fangame where your character actually responds, and you get a choice of 6 or so responses. Each response is tethered to a certain color soul, and your own soul changes to match how you respond to things. Each soul form has its own unique gimmick, and there's likely one soul (maybe itll be rainbow or something) that can be used to completely skip fights, simply by talking through them before things get out of hand. There will also likely be a secret soul for genocide, a black soul. It would unlock if you begin a genocide run, and won't appear otherwise. It's obviously gonna be the cold, unfeeling, genocidal maniac that you are when you play genocide. I would love to make a game like that, but unfortunately, I have absolutely zero coding knowledge, nor do I know anyone who knows how to code.

No matter what ending you get Martlet always ends up sad or dead. I want a rewrite where everybody survives.

As always, Ceroba is insanely overdone, Starlo is insanely under appreciated, and Martlet is pretty cool.

When I went through pacifist I cried at least 5 times, I don't know if I'll be able to go through genocide now

2:45 Martlet: lets go, clover! Ceroba: no Martlet: *almost dies Clover: bruh

this should be the "justice" ending rather than just "flawed pacifist"

i have been binge watching these videos on my Nintendo 2DS thanks for making these videos edit: 10 like special: so on my 2DS about a week ago i was looking at some themes. An undertale yellow theme caught my attention (note i don't know what undertale yellow is yet) so i decided to preview it. It was just some game art with the title on it but what really caught my attention was that the title was cut off and it said UNDERYELL. cant stop thinking about that.

Asgore : The one thing these encounters never are is "different." Not in the end. Does that mean Asgore Know That Clover Kill Ceroba In The End?

"Shayy, ... And You!" They were so nice that they decided to put Shayy twice.

What a game, loved to see the entire thing explored. Would love to see Bits and Pieces next, although it's been discontinued. What we do have is a Masterpiece tho, and I'd love to see you check it out. I believe pacifist stops after Mettaton, but Geno is complete.

That means Flawed Pacifist ending is Cannon, bc not Ceroba have Clover's soul, and Clover don't killing Asgore and escaping underground, Asgore is taking Clover's soul, what we can saw in Undertale

Nunca pude jugar Undertale sin spoilers, nunca experimenté una primera sensación de la historia del juego cuando lo jugué Ahora he terminado Undertale Yellow empezando por neutral, después la ruta genocide y terminando con la ruta pacifista Este juego es hermoso, sentí lo que siempre quise sentir con Undertale sin spoilers, y en mi corazón este juego es canon, he llorado con el final

I like how most of the people keep telling that this is actually the canon ending that leads to Undertale, while Undertale clearly states that no human before Frisk happen to reach Asgore, and the true pacifist ending also justifies why you can find Clover's hat and gun in Undertale...

I feel like this is the canon ending. The sacrafice is heroic and all but dying after commiting your worst act (in this timeline) after being so good. Sounds pretty just to me. Its by far the worst, in terms of happiness. Even geno gets a twisted form of justice in revenge. This just feels so wrong but weirdly so right.

the tasgore cheating ending - where tasgore himself starts cheating