Unpopular Audio Opinions: NOBODY Should Advise Beginners To Mix on NS10's In 2024

  Рет қаралды 14,908

Paul Third

Paul Third

Күн бұрын

Unpopular Audio Opinions: NOBODY Should Be Advising Mixing on NS10's In 2024
My name is Paul Third and I am a Scottish youtuber / audio engineer / mixing engineer / audio geek. I mostly cover audio engineering related content ranging from audio plugin shootouts / plugin comparisons (acustica audio plugins, universal audio etc etc) to actual analog vs digital / gear vs plugins plugin tests via access analog and mix analog. I even include ddmf plugindoctor tutorials in my plugin reviews so you can be your very own plugin tester and experiment and understand whats actually going on under the hood.
All of my audio blind tests involving music production software are conducted in Presonus studio one 6 which is my main daw and I also use HOFA blind test 4U as my blind test software. In terms of my audio interface I record and monitor through a universal audio apollo x6 through topping dx7 pro+ dac/amp and use an se dynacaster for all of my voice overs.
Join and also subscribe to the channel to get access to perks:
/ @paulthird
🌠 HELP ME TO KEEP DOING WHAT IM DOING
patreon.com/paulthird
⬇️ MERCHANDISE
paul-third.teemill.com
🏷️GEAR I USE
PAUL THIRD'S GEAR (THOMANN)
thmn.to/thocf/ad7nb8wdro
Topping DX7 PRO+
apos.audio/products/topping-dx...
Topping L30 mk2
apos.audio/products/topping-l...
🏷️ PLUGIN AFFILIATE LINKS
pluginboutique.com/?a_aid=60a...
WORKING AUDIO TOOLS PODCAST
/ @workingaudiotools
🎶 FOLLOW MY DEBUT ALBUM JOURNEY
• MY DEBUT ALBUM JOURNEY
🎤 RELEASING A SONG?
Music distribution playlist: • Playlist
Songwriting playlist: • MIXING SESSION WITH PA...
📖 CHAPTERS
0:00 intro
0:52 History of the Yamaha NS10
3:40 translation of audio systems in the 80/90's
4:58 How engineers learned to trust NS10M Studio
5:58 Why big mixers despised the NS10
7:31 2000's: the change of the consumer sound
13:14 The importance of managing low in the 21st century
17:10 Why neutrality is so important in the modern era
19:20 So what monitoring do you invest in?
22:15 How to ACTUALLY use NS10's in 2024
🖱️CONTACT ME
Email: paulthird.taysound@gmail.com
Instagram: / paulthird_uk
Website: www.taysoundstudio.com

Пікірлер: 326
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
BTW for those who are getting pissy in the comments.. Remember that it's just an opinion. Purposely made to give another perspective. I am NOT slating engineers who still mix or have mixed on NS10's. That's just stupid. I'm not shitting on history, all I'm doing is providing context to those new to the game. Trying to explain why they were or are still popular but at the same time adding a bit of food for thought as so much of the modern community is so dumbed down that they'll genuinely just buy what a youtuber tells them to without any research or context behind it. NS10MS and avantones aren't cheap (£800-£1100) and all I'm giving a different angle towards the product to make people think a bit. I'm shocked at how many people didn't watch the whole video or watch it properly and have decided to go in the cream puff about it and decide that I was stating that experienced engineers who have the journey and context behind them are wrong for mixing on NS10. The video is NOT aimed at you. However if you feel that me giving advice to those starting out affects your credibility then you need to stop being so insecure over an opinion. If you have a solid career mixing on ns10s then this video isn't for you and you shouldn't be bothered about one guys opinion on the Internet. I'm simply sharing the advice that I was personally given by industry professionals in my circle. I think it would be pretty shitty to take that advice and not share it to those looking to invest a heavy whack on them. BUT it is just opinions. No right or wrong answers. If you can't handle one person's opinion or perspective cause it differs from your own feelings then you need to grow the fuck up and learn to be an adult. It's just one guy on the Internet sharing an opinion. Doesn't badly impact anybody, put anybody in danger or intentionally mean harm to anyone. Its an opinion about a speaker.... Let that sink in Saying that, Whats your experience of NS10's? 🤓
@nikolasb8313
@nikolasb8313 4 ай бұрын
It's all about if you know their sound and the room. So many other ways to reference midrange with today's tech
@beatladen
@beatladen 4 ай бұрын
Pair them with a decent 12"Sub, and adjust the sub to only give you the low end that the NS10 won't, make sure to be in phase. Get the speakers powered by a powerful amp, I got mines on a Yamaha P2500. Get them placed like your main monitors, not inside your main monitors. From my experience they work well roughly 1,20m - 1,5m apart. Use monitor stands, decoupled from your desk, and adjust the height of your monitor stands so the tweeter is slightly above your ears. Listen to great sounding mixes on them... and treat them as your main monitors, don't run immediately to find a more pleasing speaker. Use good converters, and don't use room correction software! I think you can get great mixes out of them!
@ermitec
@ermitec 4 ай бұрын
It is great that you actually showed the waterfall plots showing one of the main reason NS10 are useful. Not only mentioning its transient response but supported by facts. It would have been nice though if you had referenced the source, which is a paper written by Philip Newell et al. (the man who recorded and mixed Tubular Bells on top of being an acoustic designer for high end studios for many years, and also speaker designer). Have a kook at Reflexion Arts page, which is the company in which he was working for last years after Virgin Records. They sell equipment, build high-end speakers and design recording studios. They are in my home town. I have got a pretty good relationship with them :)
@ButeSound
@ButeSound 4 ай бұрын
I use my singular ns10 as a mono reference to switch to occasionally. It's basically sports car suspension that shows you all the bump's in the road. Not all about freq response kids. The impulse response is incredibly useful.
@1wibble230
@1wibble230 4 ай бұрын
Always hated the NS10’s, they just hurt my ears, horrible sounding things, and nowhere near as accurate as my PSI
@johanolofandersson8801
@johanolofandersson8801 4 ай бұрын
The most important think when you buy new monitors of headphones: Keep the old one's. Don't throw them away.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yeah that's a good shout
@PIERSBARONtv
@PIERSBARONtv 4 ай бұрын
A very well-researched video; I have NS10s and use them as an 80% mix-down check. The one thing I would say is literally every single American record executives office I have ever been to has a set of NS10s on the table, which they will check your track on, so if that world is important to you, give them a listen. They are great if you have got to dial in a rough mix really fast, but you need to use them with a sub. I have HEDD type 20's are my daily drivers and the mid range is very detailed. Great video, Paul!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I still laugh at how yamaha managed to market a shitty product knowing it was shitty but managed to sell it to the audio masses at the highest level. That's just next level 😂 I can just imagine the board meeting now .. Soooo.... Anybody know how this happened... Anybody.. Dave?.. Sandra?.. ANYBODY!!!! ????? Who gives a fuck boss?? Good point Dave... (I know they would've had Asian names but.. Ach well 🤣)
@annebokma4637
@annebokma4637 4 ай бұрын
​@@PaulThirdsneaking in that asian name line robbed me of a comment just had to comment on that.. participation algorithm yay 😂
@silkroad1201
@silkroad1201 4 ай бұрын
You don't need a sub for NS-10s lol. That defeats the whole purpose
@inthemix
@inthemix 4 ай бұрын
I could make 100 videos in this series. Brilliant idea Paul. I’ve personally never seen the point in mixing solely on NS10s or any other frequency limited system. Might be good for a mix check but I can always just out a HPF and LPF on the master to focus on the mids…
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yeah I'm no paying upwards of a grand for a limited shit sounding speaker haha Worth a punt for like £100-200 as a mix check but I'm with you. There are ways to isolitate your midrange and you have tons of planars with fast tight low end
@midimike88
@midimike88 4 ай бұрын
Thanks, Paul, for the video. I absolutely hated my NS10m's when I first got them. However, when I started listening to my mixes on everyone's stereos and cars, I realized the translation of the mixes were super great. But, it was never about the bottom or the top, but instead the middle. To this day, all of my mixes on my NS10m's still sound great (to me, anyway). You're correct, you can't hear the bottom or the top with the NS10m's, just the middle. I can understand the teacher telling their students to mix first on NS10's. It's difficult to make mixes sound good. It's tough, and takes a lot of work. But, when the mix is finished, it translates well. And it forces you to work on the middle of the sound. I believe the entire art of mixing music is about translation. How the mix translates to what we all listen to music on... earbuds, headphones, car stereos, TVs, and home stereos. Now the added smart phone speakers. To pick a set of speakers that sound good, may be hindering you and your mix. Ask yourself, how does the mix translate? That's the art.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Thats the journey im on now
@reggiestewart1652
@reggiestewart1652 4 ай бұрын
Well said... well said
@silkroad1201
@silkroad1201 4 ай бұрын
No shit
@CalvinMOfficial
@CalvinMOfficial 4 ай бұрын
Agree with everything Paul said, but he said something important, he completed a premix on the macbook pro (100hz cut) and it translated well to other systems. This is exactly why NS10's are good, you dont get mislead on the sub bass and air, which sounds sweet, but really its fooling you into thinking you have a good mix. Also NS10's being non ported is really important, transient detail is crucial to getting those attacks correct. Summary NS10'S are good as a reference just like a macbook, car etc but they shouldn't be your ONLY monitor system. Myself, I prefer mixing on headphones and referencing on monitors 🤌🏾
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@chasehaggard161
@chasehaggard161 4 ай бұрын
Great video Paul! I can tell you had fun making this and am glad your finding more avenues that you enjoy to make videos about. (I remember when you got sick and tired of your great but tedious to make plugin analysis videos)
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I think once you free yourself from the shackles of new product reviews you start to feel a bit more free again to make videos about the current rabbit hole
@inneroutertpril
@inneroutertpril 4 ай бұрын
I watched this video with the sound going through my NS10s. ;) I find my mixes actually translate better when I do most of my mixing on NS10s. The low end obviously needs to be worked out on another system (I have Adam A7s w a sub and check on headphones), but the Yamahas let me hear my mid-range better than the other systems. Probably because the mid-range is pushed on them, but I check in with reference mixes so that's not really an issue (probably helpful actually). I wouldn't write them off. They are a tool and a helpful one at that!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@_mickmccarthy
@_mickmccarthy 4 ай бұрын
I'm looking forward to this the rest of this series!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@eranddroory9987
@eranddroory9987 4 ай бұрын
I got a pair and absolutely love them. I actually even got the original cardboard box they came in back in the early 80'ties. Not every speaker is for every ear and you need to learn them, and it can take a while. Once you have they're actually (for me) a tool I can't mix without... I'm sure a lot of people hate them, but the test of time has proven lots more actually have and still rely on them., than there are haters..
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Dunno, when I say every industry mixer I spoke to advised against them, it was every one. I obviously didn't speak to every mixer but you are talking at least 20 industry mixers However, Horses for courses and all that.
@martinaddison4880
@martinaddison4880 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThird cool - but every? I say it's not how many you know, but who you know. Rhett Davies and Bob Clearmountain used a pair there while mixing Roxy Music's Avalon. Enough said.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
But if you actually watched the entire video you would have seen that Bob now doesn't use them. That's what I'm trying to say in the video but most NS10 guys have either not watched it all, or just hear what they want to hear and perceive it as me saying they should have never been used. When I never said that, I went over the history and gave context as to why they started to become less popular and why for beginners in THIS era it would be advisable to go learn on more neutral full range systems (btw this is from bobs website) STORAGE 2 x Speakers - Mackie HR824 - Originally in Live Chambers 4 x Speakers - Yamaha NS-10M Studio - Old favorites, now standby CONTROL ROOM 1 x Headphones - Sennheiser HD650 - Favorite Headphones 7 x Speakers - Dynaudio BM-15A - Great hi-fi speakers. Used for stereo & Atmos. Quite neutral, to me. 1 x Sub Woofer - Dynaudio S-12 - More bass at all frequencies! 2 x Speakers - Yamaha MSP7 - Better than the NS-10M but discontinued, unfortunately! Its funny that you mention Avalon as an example, a record that was made for that time, for those sorts of playback systems, where if Bob made avalon now he would be using the Msp7 or dynaudio... That's what I'm trying to say in the video. Back then NS10's made a whole lot of sense and was something you HAD to learn for various reasons. Nowadays you don't NEED to learn them starting out. No artist is listening on ns10s, the consumer playback systems don't sound like them and A&R's aren't listening on them. I don't understand why people refuse to grasp the logic behind the video and seperate the mixer of the past from the beginner of today
@angrybuzzy
@angrybuzzy 4 ай бұрын
Don't worry about the people who missed the point of this, Paul. Your intent was very clear and it was a good reminder of how much context matters.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Thank you
@hunternico4810
@hunternico4810 4 ай бұрын
Very well articulated and presented as always!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@Right_in2
@Right_in2 7 күн бұрын
Putting your hands on any speakers is a great way to get a tactile feel of how crazy your transients are in the mix; try it with some commercial mixes!
@SinclairSound
@SinclairSound 4 ай бұрын
We have to understand what the ns10s were used for. NS10s were an analog for consumer bookshelf speakers which was the common listening device of the time. Now we have different consumer preferences.. get some apple earbuds. Edit: don't mix on earbuds.. but it's a better analog to consumer listening
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yeah I couldn't do a full mix on earbuds and trust it
@jorgepeterbarton
@jorgepeterbarton 4 ай бұрын
Airpods and Bluetooth speakers and all that. Unfortunately I feel like an argument should be directed to making consumers use big ass modular towers again, but then I do feel when playing loud (for the system) on either type really shows up what mixes were designed for, even volume level
@hoborec
@hoborec 4 ай бұрын
An addition to the NS-10 history part is that the upgraded studio version also broadened the frequency range in the lows from 85hz to 60hz. So basically a completely different speaker. I had both models and liked checking mixes on them. However I would never have a setup with only the NS-10. So I’m with you there 🙌
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
What speakers are you using as your mains?
@hoborec
@hoborec 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThird At the main recording studio I use Dynaudio M3 as mains and in my home studio I mix on Amphion One18. I like them both very much.
@violao206
@violao206 4 ай бұрын
This sounded like very well reasoned advice that accounts for how the tech has just moved on. I also got a nice affirmation for my decision to buy my Kali LP-6 v2 last year. I also just loved your Glaswegian brogue. It was like listening to Winston, my spirit animal from Still Game. AWESOME! Gone is the notion to even think of some NS-10 as even a reference. I next reference will just be better monitors like a pair of Adam's, or perhaps Neumann's.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@derkultvontrump
@derkultvontrump 4 ай бұрын
I’m gonna mix this up. NS10’s running through a Trinnov are a game changer. Along with neutral speakers like Neumanns and other modern speakers. All being corrected to the room are amazing. Corrected NS10s sound amazing, wide and clear, no dips and bumps. The speakers don’t over react to low end but their response goes down to 40Hz. Presence is clear and comfortable. Hi end rolls off beautifully. With Trinnov and I guess other systems as well, room correction becomes available to everyone. Technology has made old and new speakers on par with each other, thus helping the overall average decisions engineers and mixers need to make in split seconds. Also, in the control room, tracking guitars playing in the control room on NS10s with no correction is so vibey! Feedback wonderful 💥 Also, NS10s used as a speaker in a chamber sound top on drums. Also, did I mention I like NS10s😂 I am not sponsored by Yamaha…. I’ll get me coat!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@derkultvontrump
@derkultvontrump 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThirdAbsolutely. It’s my job helping artists and bands achieve our best. No, I won’t mention No. 1 albums 😂
@mho010
@mho010 4 ай бұрын
Totally agree! NS-10m (driven by Bryson amps) with subs and Trinnov user here. Along with the NS10s being my main monitors, I also use iLoud MTMs and Audeze MM500 to mix and each of them give me a different perspective, then I have ATCs to check for loud volumes; I still think NS10s are irreplaceable for me, many times I thought I could maybe stop using NS10s as I have so many sets, but I just keep coming back to them, I there’s something to do with the phase
@bontempo1271
@bontempo1271 4 ай бұрын
@@mho010 which subs do you use with your ns10s ?
@DJUwU
@DJUwU 4 ай бұрын
Great information as always - keep up the great work!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@user-pe3hl8jg4g
@user-pe3hl8jg4g 4 ай бұрын
i rented a studio in london last summer so i could use their $15,000 Augspurger speakers to dial in my low end. after 5 hours of work playing references and everything sounding PERFECT.....i flipped over to the ns-10's and played my references and my mix was suddenly needing more work! the mid range punch was SO apparently lacking in my mix once i turned on the ns10's that I immediately fly back home and bought a pair of ns10's and a Quad 405 amp....BEST decision ever.....100hz to 50 hz is SO distracting. absolutely love my Focal trio's but the ns10s are just as useful.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I've always found it interesting when people say that low end is distracting when I talk to other mixers like Prizzie Reid or Tim Palmer who will tell me that the mix just falls into place when you get the low end right. I know so many mixers that work so hard on the low end and then others that don't really prioritise it as much. Such a diverse world
@astrarivm
@astrarivm 4 ай бұрын
I still use pair of NS 10's for checking balances and mids. They are very similar to Airpods, but you can use them solo. They are of course not neutral at all, but they teach philosophy of scooping harsh high mids to sound good. I think it's very useful.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@thegroove2000
@thegroove2000 4 ай бұрын
WHERE IT ALL STARTED The NS-10 was first launched in 1978 … but not as a studio monitor. Instead, it was originally designed as a Hi-Fi speaker for consumers, designated the NS-10M, complete with a cloth grille. While it did not do well on the consumer level, it soon became a phenomenon in recording studios (sans grille), thanks largely to engineer/producer Greg Ladanyi (Fleetwood Mac, Don Henley, Jackson Browne), who brought a pair of NS-10s to the U.S. after a trip to Japan and became one of the first early adopters of the speakers. The NS-10M had a modest frequency range of 85 Hz to 20 kHz, and power handling of just 25 -50 watts, yet its admittedly less-than-perfect sound turned out to be a secret weapon in the studio. Almost magically, it exposed any sonic flaws in the audio, allowing for corrections to be made during the production process. You literally had to work hard on them to make your recordings sound great. Music mixed on NS-10s would translate well to the end users listening to playback systems in their living rooms, bedrooms and cars. It wasn’t long before these mysterious speakers started to become a mainstay in recording studios around the world. The NS-10M had a limited bass response, with a rolloff beginning at around 200 Hz, and a prominent boost in the upper midrange of some +5 dB at around 2 kHz, but it did have an extremely fast transient response (that is, it responded especially quickly to changes in level) thanks to its extremely lightweight drivers and unported, enclosed design. Unfortunately, this also resulted in a somewhat over-bright upper treble response. As a result, many engineers were known to tape tissue paper over the tweeters, sparking an endless (and somewhat silly) debate about the brand and ply of toilet paper required. This decidely low-tech correction would, it was felt, not only help tame the high frequencies but also create a quasi-comb filtering effect, with some frequencies reflected back into the tweeter. That's why so many great mixes were done with them as mixing engineers understood their weaknesses foibles and worked round them. Even today nothing is perfect. What is perfect? hub.yamaha.com/proaudio/recording/a-history-of-yamaha-studio-reference-monitors/#:~:text=While%20it%20did%20not%20do,first%20early%20adopters%20of%20the
@gerrydaly5409
@gerrydaly5409 4 ай бұрын
Very interesting video- thanks
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@WolfNFG
@WolfNFG 4 ай бұрын
Really interesting to hear a thought-out opposing viewpoint! I would love to hear a discussion between you and an industry veteran, like say Jordan Valeriote, who swears by NS10s with very some well-founded reasoning. Rock on Paul, this video was a great introduction to your channel for me.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Tbh I think it's important to have all perspectives. In audio there's not really any right or wrong answers, merely differences of opinion of what is right and wrong. Sometimes youtube swings hard in one specific direction and needs to be brought back to the middle. Objectivity is key. There are valid reasons to use and not to use NS10's, it's just about giving the audience that balance of opinion and perspective because as soon as we lose that we lose the ability to make our own informed decision
@WolfNFG
@WolfNFG 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThirdprecisely
@chriskramer9311
@chriskramer9311 4 ай бұрын
Great pacing, tone, and info. Thanks for the effort, enjoyed the video!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@tekis0
@tekis0 4 ай бұрын
I think his mixes are pretty darn good! If I had the physical space, I'd have a pair, but they wouldn't be my only set of speakers. A great mix done on any other speaker will sound good on NS-10's, and a great mix done on NS-10's will sound good on any other speaker. That's been my experience.
@Notinserviceij
@Notinserviceij 4 ай бұрын
Very good video, and good logic 👏
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@RudeRecording
@RudeRecording 4 ай бұрын
As someone that worked in studio and broadcast engineering in the late 70s through the present. We used NS-10s and Auratones for reference back when I started. The studio mains which back then were soffit mounted, calibrated, large, time aligned speakers, were used for mixing. We used NS-10s because EVERY studio had them so if you were checking mixes from another studio you needed them. We used Auratones because they had one driver and no crossover and were all midband mostly to emulate the response of a typical car radio system of the time. MoTown used a typical 6x9 car speaker in an Olsen cabinet to simulate the response of a typical car radio of the time. Auratones were great for checking the guitar/vocal mix balance. We rarely used headphones for any kind of mixing, however that is changing and not just due to the Slate VSX system. Headphones have gotten way better than the Koss headphones that were common in studios when I started.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@FireMoon42
@FireMoon42 4 ай бұрын
Oh and the NS10S were designed for a totally specific market and meant to be used in a very specific manner. They were designed for small Japanese living rooms to be driven by an amplifier with the loudness switch engaged. That is, they're designed for low-level listening and their frequency response was tailored with that environment as their chief usage.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Interesting
@user-xj8yl2dh4p
@user-xj8yl2dh4p 4 ай бұрын
Nice info . I remember when I was a kid and discovering what the loudness button was for :)
@kimseniorb
@kimseniorb 4 ай бұрын
I think it makes perfect sense. I mix with high end rolled off always
@realraven2000
@realraven2000 4 ай бұрын
Excellent, first time I hear about low frequency decay. I wonder how my Kali in8 fare in that area… does frequency room correction like ARC3 also influence decay or is it only phase?
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I THINK it's more about the speaker design
@Hectagonist
@Hectagonist 4 ай бұрын
You touched on what makes NS10's (and Auratones) so unique and useful for mixing. They're both closed speakers with extremely fast decay and light drivers that are incredibly detailed when driven with a nice amp. As a second reference, they give you a very clear picture of your mid-range transient response I think we get so focused on frequency response that we forget how much more important the dynamics can be. You can have a mix with perfectly balanced frequency response that's boring as hell and a thin mix that's punchy and exciting. That said, I'll pick Auratones over NS10's any day of the week because that harsh high end is just an unnecessary distraction
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yeah if you have learn the sound and create an intended purpose then you can essentially make any speaker work for a certain perspective of the mix
@unclemick-synths
@unclemick-synths 4 ай бұрын
I'm with you on transient response - sometimes it's as if the term "slew rate" vanished some time during the 80s! Some people argue that extended highs equate to speed but I disagree if only because the tweeter handles the highs but expecting an 8" woofer to present mid transients accurately is unrealistic. It's one reason I went to three-way speakers with separate amplifier.
@hisroyalsucculence
@hisroyalsucculence 4 ай бұрын
Absolutely agree with your thesis. NS10s (when I used them) were great to check a mix on and even mix on for a period of time because I also had an additional set of main speakers. I think the main thing with any monitoring setup is to spend enough time getting used to how a good mix sounds on your setup so you have that as a reference point.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@billB101
@billB101 4 ай бұрын
I mixed an awful lot of club music and dance hits back in the 90's on Ns10's and loved them. I found the translation excellent once you knew how to use them. I'm firmly in the "get it sounding good on NS10's and it'll sound good everywhere" camp. I wasn't using NS10's alone though, I was using them with other reference speakers ( Dynaudio M2's for a good while. ) Haven't used them in years now though ( although I do have a pair in my front room ) I now prefer my ADAM A7x's ( with a sub ) and Auratones for mid reference and also use a £10 x-mini from ebay for the whole phone reference thing. I'm also a live engineer so I have access to club/venue/festival rigs to test sub too which is great. You can't deny the amount of hits mixed on NS10's though, they definitely had their day.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yup, HAD their day being the correct statement haha I'm more impressed with the engineers who made them work, fair play
@augustineleudar
@augustineleudar 4 ай бұрын
haha fighting talk! I think you’re focusing too much on frequency response, the reason ns10s are so useful is the time based response, they are really fast at the low end even which makes transient responses easier to judge. Have a look at a waterfall graph of an na10 and compare the time based response of almost any other speaker (time based is how long the speaker takes to stop raining at a given frequency after input) In this regard they measure almost better than anything almost so there’s a reason they were used aside from following the crowd . I’ve used ATC, PMC and now use genelec a bit I’ll get my ns10s repaired and keep running them, the clarity of mixes you get on them is great. It is good to have a rig with sub as well though especially for club music.
@MikeFromDownUnder
@MikeFromDownUnder 4 ай бұрын
Love this! ❤️
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@SuperMax_____0.0_____
@SuperMax_____0.0_____ 4 ай бұрын
Im one of those who touched the ns10s to know how I am on the ball park with the lows, no regrets AT ALL
@mixinginthebox
@mixinginthebox 3 ай бұрын
personally I love them, I agree with everything you said.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 3 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@Skibosski
@Skibosski 4 ай бұрын
7:50 nostalgia days 😂. I remember those times veryy well
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@InFiNiGhTe
@InFiNiGhTe 4 ай бұрын
Just like the Beyerdynamic DT 770/880/990's .. I'll never understand why anyone would purposedly fatique themselves to use them. Too harsh.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Very true, scooped and harsh
@psychedelicelvis-777
@psychedelicelvis-777 4 ай бұрын
I use Beyerdynamic DT 770 and Alesis MKII ELEVATE monitors and my mixes are absolutely fantastic 🔥!!! A trained ear can mix on anything !!!
@InFiNiGhTe
@InFiNiGhTe 4 ай бұрын
@@psychedelicelvis-777 I've used mentioned models for years and I won't disagree with your statement, but they are just harsh for some people, and that's not worth training your ears for... It's a common fact with those DT's. Not to say how much they can damage your ears if they have to be forced to adjust to something overtime. It's important to find the perfect pair that accommodates your hearing to it's best of abilities. The only pair of DT's there ever was to do so, was the Dt 900 Pro X in that regard. But I'm using Hifiman Sundara's in my daily routine, and that's a killing pair for any occasion. Just remember, not everyone's hearing is the same. None is superior or inferior to your hearing capabilities and vice versa. It's just how we are, and how we treat ourselves that leads to our decisions.
@psychedelicelvis-777
@psychedelicelvis-777 4 ай бұрын
@@InFiNiGhTe Agreed 👍!!!
@russangel
@russangel 4 ай бұрын
I bought the 990s they,re not good at all, I prefer my AKG 240 studio or Presonus HD7 ( great).
@myturningpoint
@myturningpoint 4 ай бұрын
My primaries are a pair of Alesis Monitor One Mk][ and I love them. My secondaries are the PreSonus Eris BT4.5's I've got both run through SonarWorks Reference ID so both are as flat as possible. my headphones are DT990 pros I'm more than happy with my little home studio setup 🙂 It also helps that I listen to EVERYTHING through them as this entire setup is also my primary PC as well so I listen to everything through them, music, movies, tv shows, games etc etc.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@huberttorzewski
@huberttorzewski 4 ай бұрын
I love mixing on CLA10as and they really make me work hard on the correct balance, eq and compression. The translation is amazing
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@KeenanCrow
@KeenanCrow 4 ай бұрын
I like mixing through the NS10 profile in ARC or SoundID to get the midrange sorted. But. I need to hear the low end at some point.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@johnvender
@johnvender 4 ай бұрын
You make really good points. I'd love to hear you speak about Auratones :)
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Sound like old school radio to me, thats all I can say
@donnadi3621
@donnadi3621 4 ай бұрын
It’s easy to be cynical in 2004 about NS10s. Sure, any mid priced monitor today will give you more information than an NS10. That has never been the issue. Back in the day (and still today) most big studios had (have) large wall mounted monitors to check the bottom end, but most of the carving was (and still is) done on near field monitors. It’s precisely because NS10s were originally created for the domestic, home listening environment that their usefulness has been valued over 4 decades. We all know they roll off from 200hZ-70hZ and yes the 2k bump. But that’s exactly why they were so useful. As you pointed out in your video Paul, (short of hifi enthusiast) the majority of listening devices were pretty crappy: radios, boom boxes, shitty car speakers, cheap cassette players, shitty headphones, transistor radios etc. Evaluating NS10s in that context, they had not only a ‘taming’ effect of the harsher frequencies which were an issue with crappy listening ing devices, but a frequency range that represented the vast majority of listening devices. Historical context matters. Thousands of amazing sounding albums were mixed on them. (Roxy Music’s Avalon, Steely Dan’s Aja, Tears For Tears - Women in chains come to mind). It’s a given there are much better, way more detailed monitors today to choose from, and also more genres to accommodate that require a full frequency range. It all changed around 2000 when Dr Dre introduced heavy subs into his production with his ‘The chronic / Snoop Dogg’s Doggy Style albums. Ironically he still uses NS10s as well as well as the Auratones in mono. Go figure, right? Could very well be a case of ‘paralysis by analysis’ Mr. Third
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Tbh being autistic I'm a man that looks for patterns and averages and the pattern was that most engineers have stopped relying on NS10's and moved on to more full range neutral speakers. NS10's had their place but when I say every industry mixer I asked in private advised against them, you are talking at least 20. Its kinda like analog and digital, sure all the classic records were mixed on consoles to tape but that's not the way now for many reasons. As Jaycen Joshua once quoted "you can't mix modern sounding records without modern tools" Its just how the world works, to progress in anything you need one foot in the past and one foot in the present
@captain_black_310
@captain_black_310 4 ай бұрын
I agree, beginners should not mix on NS10's if it's the only speaker they have. They really don't have the low-end today's music requires. That said, NS10's are an INVALUABLE tool when used as secondary monitors. I mix on a pair of Neumann KH-120A's w/ an HS8S sub, but recently added NS-10M Studio's with a Hafler P1500 to my rig (literally a few days ago). If treating my room, snagging a pair of Nuemann's, and implementing some room correction was the best decision I ever made, adding NS-10's is for sure the third-best decision I've ever made (second-best decision was adding motorized faders). They are incredibly revealing in the mid-range. To really get what you need from them, you need to volume match to your mains so when you A/B you're comparing apples to apples. I'm about to release an EP, and I just ran every track through the NS-10s and was able to make them that 3-5% better (where the real magic lives, at least for my current skill level). Cheers.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@SirFreak
@SirFreak 4 ай бұрын
Great video!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@mageprometheus
@mageprometheus 4 ай бұрын
Next you will be telling me I don't need a grot box 😀 Great video.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@Shred_Rocket
@Shred_Rocket 4 ай бұрын
Yes, I agree, I mixed on NS10's in the past and I was able to get great mixes..., in the studio, however, those same mixes were "ugly as sin" in different monitoring systems!!! Now that I am mixing through my BareFoot's and cheap JBL's, translation is heaven! Good video and message, I relate, thanks!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
What's the script with the barefoots? What's the biggest benefit of them? Just cause I see them everywhere
@katyg3873
@katyg3873 4 ай бұрын
If you’ve never heard an ns10, it sounds like a set of loud car speakers in a really good radio reception area.
@foreverthestudent
@foreverthestudent 4 ай бұрын
I love my Kali before that presonus. I like how the focals sound
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@cultivatedmind8352
@cultivatedmind8352 4 ай бұрын
Colt capperrunes trick on cutting pass filters on a master buss eq at 200 and 4k while mixing is a good way to get the mids right without having to buy ns10s
@ocularrecords
@ocularrecords 4 ай бұрын
Paul. Avid viewer here. I was just wondering, where would the Kali Audio sit on your list? I have the LP-6. I love them, but do you suggest another speaker set?
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Depends what your budget is and how well your room is treated
@cristopherjohansson1323
@cristopherjohansson1323 4 ай бұрын
I'm still mixing on my NS10's after 20 years. Checking the balance and midrange on the ns10's and using my old genelecs as my mains, added the air pods recently as a reality check. Tried different monitors throughout the years but I'm always coming back to the same combo. So use whatever works for you, don't listen to others.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
What's your opinion on the sound of the air pod pro?
@mechinamundi8988
@mechinamundi8988 4 ай бұрын
thank you , NS 10 s replaced Aurotones originally in Island Studios end of the 70 s , I was assistant engineer there at the time , Rhett Davis who had mixed Roxy Music in New York with Bob Clearmountain brought in a pair of NS 10 to Basing Street Studios London and they soon became very popular in pro studios , they are good reference speakers and they look nice
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@dannydaniel8975
@dannydaniel8975 4 ай бұрын
12:54 to 13:02. Golden!
@russangel
@russangel 4 ай бұрын
I have the NS10m Studio. I also have the HS5 and HS8. There is definitely a relationship between them and the HS series regardless of what others say, if you do a mix on the 10s then switch over to the HS series you can hear the mix blossom as if it was meant to be.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@ReggieSears
@ReggieSears 4 ай бұрын
In my control room I have 4 different sets of monitors. I mix on the NS10s, it’s where I shape my mids. Once I get the mix sounding good on the NS10s I switch to a different (neutral) set of monitors and tweak from there. Don’t underestimate the NS10s but make sure you have a second pair of monitors.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yeah that's all the video is aiming at, providing context to beginners before starting out instead of just blindly buying something and thinking that they'll be able to get amazing translation out the box. It's a learning curve
@Rhuggins
@Rhuggins 4 ай бұрын
Great video paul!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@lusid_music_uk
@lusid_music_uk 4 ай бұрын
Hi Paul I’m currently saving up for a pair of HIFIMAN HE1000se (I’ve heard lots of great things from yourself and others). Tuning my HD650’s to Harmon was an absolute game changer. Thanks for that tip! But now I’m looking to upgrade. I saw that the Hifimans are already tuned very close (but not exactly) to Harmon. Do you still feel it’s necessary to EQ something as premium as the HE1000se? Seems disrespectful to the engineers who designed a £2000 headphone 😂 are these still the headphones tour’s recommend? Thank you for all the content mate long time fan ❤
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Definitely needs eq'd to harman. Pretty big moves as well
@lusid_music_uk
@lusid_music_uk 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThird thank you for this 🙏 seems a shame that the “ideal headphone” wouldn’t already be tuned to harman
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Cause in most cases there's a difference between an audiophile and an audio engineer. Hifiman is based mostly at the audiophile market which is mostly hifi curves by default
@lusid_music_uk
@lusid_music_uk 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThird Makes sense! So why would these be the headphones you’d personally go for instead of ones designed specifically for audio engineers? Do these exist? I’ve heard that the 1000se are some of the most detailed on the market which is my main priority! But it’s a shame to have to “compromise” by adding an eq to the signal so that they will translate. Especially when you’re willing to spend like 2 grand! There’s got to be a pair out there that can do both extreme detail AND excellent translation out of the box surely? Even if you eq correct for harman, you’re assuming that YOUR specific headphones align with the measurements taken from a different set, which makes me worry the eq will have the potential to be inaccurate. So many questions! 😂 Thank you for responding Paul! ❤️
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Audezes are arguably the most popular in the mixing game and they all need eq correction. Harman is revealing, and not many know about it so manufacturers tend to sway towards hifi curve. Headphones are headphones. The whole "made for audio engineers" thing is a bit of a marketing gimmick. You just go with what sounds right to you and then you mix through it. It doesn't bother me that he1000se and ananda nano arent made specifically with audio engineers in mind cause all they care about is achieving the best resolution and detail retrieval possible which is all that matters.
@MountainViewStudio
@MountainViewStudio 4 ай бұрын
YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY CORRECT MY FRIEND
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@mixphantom0101
@mixphantom0101 4 ай бұрын
My first time in a top studio (late 80s) with a vintage Neve console and all the usual suspects in the racks I was horrified (and disappointed) that the entire mixing session was done on NS10s and the Neve's mono "talkback speaker"! Massive soffit mounted monitors never got a look in. I was extra shocked when the mixes did translate well... so the moral of the story is "familiarity = consistency"
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@larslevinberget9558
@larslevinberget9558 4 ай бұрын
LOL I've been ranting about this since the 1990s ;D Genelec 1030A became the new industry standard back in 1998, and I learned to like them ... Now, how's about the small, cheap Mackie speakers? The black and poison-green ones??
@annebokma4637
@annebokma4637 4 ай бұрын
I remember the first PlayStation, it had a CD player 😂 I also remember using cassettes for data storage 😅 I also remember losing the data every time you needed to turn your ZX 81 off 😢 I am old 😭
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I still can't believe I used to sit and listen to the radio all night just so I could tape one song.. You had to be rapid back then 😂
@annebokma4637
@annebokma4637 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThird two Akai with the famous gx heads (if memory still works) served me well on those days. And most music I liked came on certain hours, the John Peel show 👍😎
@oh515
@oh515 4 ай бұрын
All kind of speakers could be used for different purposes. I do even listen to the mix though the system speakers on my Mac, compared with reference tracks. But I would never use the system speakers, or the NS10 as my main monitoring. It works great for some to use the NS10 as their main speakers, but that’s not a solution for me. I tried, but I suppose I never get to the level to make it work for me. I did sell them for few years ago. It works fine to simulate the NS10s with my ARC setup.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@leiferickson3183
@leiferickson3183 4 ай бұрын
I've never liked the NS-10. Back in the day the only praise that I heard about them was that everyone used them so you could always have a reference that was available at pretty much all studios. I was, however a fan of the LS3/5a's at the time for nearfield monitoring.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@distortion_plus
@distortion_plus 4 ай бұрын
I work on NS10s with a sub, so I think some things, but I will only say I think a discussion about them (positive or negative) would be much more effective if you had mixed on them before.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I did, I want to say 2 or 3 mixes on them about 10 years ago in uni as they had a room I was able to get into on the odd occasion and never liked them. Just always sounded strange to me but that's probably cause I was used to krk's and genelecs. NS10's had this hollow resonant thing I never gravitated towards and when I'd put the NS10 mix up on the krks the balance was completely off cause I tried to make them sound like I wanted them to sound. Just confused the shit out of me due to my inexperience. And then about 3 years ago I was in another studio and heard that same sound I really didn't like. It's like audio PTSD 😂 as soon as I hear them I'm like.. Get off now! 🤣 If they work for you, they work for you, and I know I did a good job showcasing why they were popular and I didn't say people couldn't get good mixes on them, I simply said from the off that I don't understand the logic behind why people would advise a beginner to mix on them. It seems to have hit a trigger with many NS10 users (not meaning you) and their defensiveness has kicked in and they haven't actually listened to a word I've said. I watched it back and I know in my heart of hearts that I was as fair as can be and not once did I say that you can't mix on them. I just disagree with those advising £800-£1100 limited speakers that also require a £500 sub (making it £1300-1600) to those starting out considering you can get a decent 3 way now and still have change left over for room treatment which is more important
@MixedByDotRob
@MixedByDotRob 4 ай бұрын
I bought my NS10s in the late 80s (!). Worked on them till the 2000s. Haha. I still have them ... unplugged in the bookshelf of my living room. They were perfect back then, because 1) they were in every studio 2) they were cheap 3) sub-bass wasn't needed, because sub-bass wasn't possible on vinyl and 4) there were big Tannoys or JBLs anyway. But technology moves on. Some people also buy vintage cars from the 1950s. They may not get you from A to B, but they can be fun to look at. It's a similar thing with the NS-10s. 😃
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yeah I notice a ton of people still keep them for the decoration haha
@MixedByDotRob
@MixedByDotRob 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThird and you have to admit that they are really beautiful! :D
@piscesman54
@piscesman54 4 ай бұрын
Fully agree. Never understood the hype around the NS10s. Why would you want to mix with no low end, especially rock? Makes no sense at all.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@user-xj8yl2dh4p
@user-xj8yl2dh4p 4 ай бұрын
I have an eq preset on my sub bus . If I'm doing low end I get a good result from making it sound the best it can in that and it also reveals a lot so I'm sticking with it but no I would never buy a pair . Better buy another set of headphones
@TylerMarletteNY
@TylerMarletteNY 4 ай бұрын
I just have them for checking harshness and muddyness
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@unclemick-synths
@unclemick-synths 4 ай бұрын
Didn't enjoy my encounter with NS-10s. I can see how they would help as an alternative viewpoint to full-range speakers but I'm more a cube speaker kind of guy. Regardless, the music is in the mids and sparkling highs and rumbling lows are the icing, not the cake. Whatever helps you get the mids right is the right speaker for you.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@AlexNiedt
@AlexNiedt 4 ай бұрын
I find Auratones useful but use them in conjunction with Neumann KH 310s. Can't imagine only working on Auratones or NS10s. On the Barefoot topic, I feel like they're an acquired taste. I was so excited to try a few pairs a while back, but they weren't for me at all.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yeah I've heard that a lot with barefoots. Very hit and miss
@dayzrustream
@dayzrustream 4 ай бұрын
Since I've heard how N-monitors sound in a treated room, there are no other monitors I'd want to have. Glad they're being produced in Russia, so no illegal sanctions would stop me from buying them
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@womagrid
@womagrid 4 ай бұрын
APS Coax 2 with bass extenders works for me
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@XcarnationCenkEroglu
@XcarnationCenkEroglu 4 ай бұрын
KRK E8 was amazing ..which Mike Shipley was involved back then.. E8 was the only true gem by KRK .. I still have em but not working anymore.. miss them
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I seen a pair of 9000b for £700 on ebay but always a risk buying such old speakers
@XcarnationCenkEroglu
@XcarnationCenkEroglu 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThirdThe problem is the tweeters.. no way to find parts ..there are a couple of 3rd party replacement in the US but they are not the same.. I always found the KRK E8 like the big brother of Ns10ms with the right bottom and no spike on the high mids..
@QFXmusic
@QFXmusic 4 ай бұрын
Had the KRK 9000 B amazing monitor ... Still used by peter Gabriel .. You would not believe how good the 9000 B was :) I and the cones in them were made by Focal :) I have Air pod pros and Air pod max and think the Max sound shit but the pro's are OK.... Great content loved what you said
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I seen a pair of 9000B on Ebay for £700 👀
@QFXmusic
@QFXmusic 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThird Most likely had the cone changed at some point :( As the original cones were super rare.. In fact when my got fried by a power surge in the studio i spent 6 months trying to get replacements :( This was how i found out that the cones were made by Focal. But they would only make 100 pairs min to make it worth there while :( The last run of 100 the 30 pairs had been bought up by Peter Gabriel for his 9000b as spares :( So in the end i just sold them as is and moved to Focal Twins :)
@claytonsegelov6914
@claytonsegelov6914 4 ай бұрын
Yeah, they rule I use em every day on major label mixes No sub (I also was trained by Chris (cla) so make of that what you will) I also have Amphion two 18s w/-sub But I probably only spend the final 15% of a mix on them.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Trained by CLA.. of course you are using NS10's haha are you not on the barefoots as well though?
@claytonsegelov6914
@claytonsegelov6914 4 ай бұрын
CLAs Barefoots are for client listening only@@PaulThird
@musicsynctank
@musicsynctank 4 ай бұрын
I had a pair of NS10Ms. I tried to tune my ears to them, but they just sounded nasty to me. I knew my mixes were sounding ok when everything just sounded really harsh and painful in the midrange. I sold mine around the millennium and still don't miss them.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
That's just mental to me that you need to mix in a fatiguing way to get a mix sounding right. So glad I'll never have to mix on them
@ButeSound
@ButeSound 4 ай бұрын
They're checkers not listeners.
@musicsynctank
@musicsynctank 4 ай бұрын
@@ButeSound Agreed - It's great to have a 'crappy' sounding (lacking impressive low end) pair or two of speakers to check, but I know plenty of engineers who mix solely on these things, and very successfully. It works for them, and that's great. They're just not for my ears - mixing or checking!
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Tbf that's a good statement. Wish I had checkers in the video now haha
@craigpollock8714
@craigpollock8714 4 ай бұрын
I quit my Yamaha HS-5's and sub for a pair of CLA NS 10's. TBH - I hated them..when i I first got them. Worst sounding speakers I have ever heard. That being said, I pursued using them on the advice of my mentor. He warned me I would hate them. However he did say if you can get a mix sounding good on these, said mix will sound good anywhere. He was right. My mixes sound way better now and translate everywhere. Took me a year to get into the zone. I do use Sonarworks too, and check the low end on Sennheiser HD headphones. I do rate these speakers - not for the sound - it is crap - but translation, a hell yeah
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@elonthebass6870
@elonthebass6870 4 ай бұрын
Time domain performance of NS10’s alone are worth the price of admission.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
£800-£1100..pretty dear price of admission haha
@ferociousmullet9287
@ferociousmullet9287 4 ай бұрын
I used to judge the low end on NS10's by how much the surround on the bass driver was crinkling up. Also, do not buy a pair. You are not missing out on anything. They are objectively offensive to listen to.
@bluematrix5001
@bluematrix5001 4 ай бұрын
I am with you Gordito, to mix on NS-10 specially for a new guy is so counter productive, is a very limited speaker in frequency response that do not work for modern Music,,, and even worse as your main or only speaker...
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@asymmetrymedia9838
@asymmetrymedia9838 4 ай бұрын
And here's my take on the subject: some monitors work for some people, not for others. I know some engineers who make great work on ns10's. Others who swear by them to check their work or specific elements on...I bought a pair and barely if ever use them. So in the end it's just whatever works for the engineer in question.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
True but at £800-£1100 it's not a throwaway thing. It's a substantial investment for something that is pot luck if it works out for you That's why I advise against them. If they were like £150 or something then yeah fill your boots and take a shot in the dark
@djvictornova9188
@djvictornova9188 4 ай бұрын
Maybe in the future we will have mixes that are catered to perform best for your listening system and not the one mix & master that fits all .... The one thing i notice about music that was mixes back in the days of the NS10s was that the music wasn't fatiguing overly bassy or trebly leaving space for the music to breath and sound natural.. Don't get me wrong we all love a song with great bass , But is it natural to get music to go all the way down to 30hz .. Just saying
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Dunno there are some tracks that just work better to my ears with well controlled low end. Especially some of the atmos mixes. As soon as I sorted the low end in my atmos room I could really appreciate the kali ws6.2
@user-dv5ri2no7p
@user-dv5ri2no7p Ай бұрын
How to tell whether it is a refurbished product by its appearance?
@PaulThird
@PaulThird Ай бұрын
You'd probably have to open it up and know what you are looking for
@carldubcats3385
@carldubcats3385 4 ай бұрын
Paul McCartney 1st, Paul Young 2nd and Paul Third. Big respect.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I feel so uncomfortable being anywhere near those names haha
@yucafries7681
@yucafries7681 4 ай бұрын
I use barefoots and auratones. Never learned NS-10s. I imagine they would be useful but I don’t need a third set of monitors
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
How would you describe the sound of the barefoots?
@yucafries7681
@yucafries7681 4 ай бұрын
⁠@@PaulThird Thunderous & clear. I’m currently working on footprint01s and the low end is impressive
@cholkymilkmirage4984
@cholkymilkmirage4984 4 ай бұрын
I think it’s all about learning the speakers and understanding what they are good for and not good for. NS10s (from my experience using the realphones system lmao) are only good to hyper focus on the mid range and find frequencies that should be cut in the mids. That’s about it tho, doing fader balance or compression or other things doesn’t work well cause you don’t get the proper feedback. I feel a different way about the BIG speakers for hearing subs and setting bass. I think it’s great for almost everything when mixing except properly checking the kids for “pokies” and transient designing to shaping is absolutely horrendous on it. You think you hear something happening to your transients and you do some work but when you listen outside it’s completely off and sounds bad. These things are just a tool not a holy grail.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Correct, just a tool, not the secret to amazing mixes, that comes from experience
@ReeWebster
@ReeWebster 4 ай бұрын
Perfect example of a device that more people blindly believe is good, over people who actually know why it’s good.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@stevedoesnt
@stevedoesnt 4 ай бұрын
Yeah, I guess people who use and like ns10s are just posers. You make a great argument there.
@unclemick-synths
@unclemick-synths 4 ай бұрын
​@@stevedoesnt I don't think that's what he meant. I don't think he has anything against anyone who uses them that knows why they're a useful tool.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yeah, for whatever reason NS10 users have basically taken my opinion and perceived it as slander towards them. I was pretty clear at the start that it was aimed more at advising beginners starting out in 2024, not those who started out decades ago. The Audio community is so fucking defensive about everything, see if something doesn't fit their belief, tantrum central
@subterraneanpimpernel9455
@subterraneanpimpernel9455 4 ай бұрын
I sold my 1982s NS10s in the early 2000s and bought genelec 1032s.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@Durkhead
@Durkhead 4 ай бұрын
Forgive me cause i just started mixing (just for myself as a hobbie) but in my opinion it seems like because they are bad speakers it makes them good monitors for mixing cause certain frequencies are boosted so when make your mix on them those frequencies get reduced and your mix sounds better
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
If you mix through a speaker with hardly any low end and a 5db boost at 2k you are gonna have very dull sounding mixes with really boomy low end on today's consumer devices. Unless you learn how a record should sound on it. For a beginner, Mixing through it to make it sound like the mixes of today won't translate to other systems. Nearly all beginners will try and deharsh it and add the low end that it lacks because you don't mix to make things sound bad. It's natural instinct
@Durkhead
@Durkhead 4 ай бұрын
@PaulThird I totally agree with you about the bass, but I still think that if you can make a mix sound flat on these speakers that the midrange dip that would result would be pleasing to most ppl cause that would create what iv always called a happy eq cause it looks like it's smiling 😃. I think paired with a good subwoofer these would be perfect for mixing rap or metal
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I dunno tbh. Every industry mixer I know doesn't use them, and that's at least 20 engineers. I'm a man of patterns and averages and from what I can see, NS10's aren't trusted any more but thats just the engineers I know tbf
@Dadhus1
@Dadhus1 4 ай бұрын
NS10s were really only used as a reference monitor to see what your mix might sound like on a slightly rubbish, domestic speaker. They were such a joke, it was commonplace to see bits of toilet paper Sellotaped onto the harsh tweeters to help calm them down a bit. I honestly think they only 'caught on' due to their distinctive appearance and availability.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Dunno, read some of the comments. We've got some proper die hards in there using them as their main reference I've never seen such a marmite thing in the game. Interesting though as there are many who still swear by them to this day and others who wouldn't reccomend them to anybody, especially beginners
@roderickmims4802
@roderickmims4802 9 күн бұрын
Do you think the auratone5c worth the investment?
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 9 күн бұрын
Not today. There's tons of options and you can genuinely just high and low pass your speakers to get that only midrange sound
@---pp7tq
@---pp7tq 4 ай бұрын
Actually I heard an opinion that it's wrong to mimick NS10 with EQ, or at least it gives different results than real NS10, but I had a hard time finding the source and some more arguments.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
It will give different results but it's just a similar way of isolating the mid range.
@Trollmaggedon
@Trollmaggedon 4 ай бұрын
Speaking of low end. Can someone please tell me how to TAME this damn 808 or synth BASS? Mine always sounds like It's washing over the vocal no matter what I do.
@shamoonkhatri
@shamoonkhatri 4 ай бұрын
Difficult to help without having a listen or having a photo of the eq you got on your 808 or the synth Bass. A high pass or low cut on 60hz tightens most basses up
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Maybe try widening the 808 or sidechain compress the 808 to the vocal in M/S. Find the clashing frequency range and duck that out the mid channel. Or you can use trackspacer or fuser from mastering the mix Sometimes just widening the bass can do the trick, but if these don't help then it may be the sustain of the 808, may need to shorten the wavelength of it using a transient designer or deboom in kickshaper. Just gotta throw stuff at the wall and see what works
@Trollmaggedon
@Trollmaggedon 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThird thanks man. I’ll try widening it. Never in a million years would I think to make it wider. I try to have it as mono as possible in most mixes
@pipelineaudio
@pipelineaudio 4 ай бұрын
I've been getting in trouble for saying this since 1998
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Yeah I didn't realise just how much shit this would cause, thought it was pretty explanatory not to advise them for beginners haha but NS10 users have taken it as I'm talking about them instead of advising those learning in this era. Typical Internet
@FireMoon42
@FireMoon42 4 ай бұрын
It's no coincidence that mixes became incredibly 2D when everyone followed the trend and started mixing on them. One reason many UK studios moved onto them was... They bought huge great monitors and then tried to drive them with dreadful PA amps completely oblivious to wattage has little to do with an amplifier's ability to drive and control a speaker. I've heard several sets of fabulous speakers sounding totally gash cos studio managers don't understand that a 50 watt amp that can drive a 2 ohm load is a far superior amplifier than a 500 watt amp that struggles to push 700 Watts into a 4 ohm load and , in effect, dies trying to drive anything lower. Ergo, they'd "prefer" the NS10s for long sessions. Yes, that's how bad some expensive facilities main monitors sounded cos of not understanding amplifiers.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Just like headphone amps of today "my £1200 audezes don't sound as good through my scarlett hp amp" "that's cause they needed driven properly" "but it sounds loud enough for me" ... 🙈🙈🙈
@Doty6String
@Doty6String 4 ай бұрын
Once I got so genelec’s my mixes go everywhere fine.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
🤓🤓
@PrincipalAudio
@PrincipalAudio 4 ай бұрын
My experience with NS-10s is hearing them in a studio in Manchester. I switched from the ATC 200s to the 10s and I was like "What the heck are these?" NOBODY should EVER use them for ANYTHING. Really awful. You can't mix what you can't hear, and you can't hear most of it. They also can't be used as decent references. They show nothing useful, unlike my JBL Flip 6, a consumer device many people listen on. NS-10s should've died a long time ago, in my unpopular opinion. The only people who should keep them are those who grew up with them and learned how they sound. If someone doesn't have them already, they shouldn't buy them. They'll make you a worse engineer.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
I still don't buy the whole "we couldn't source the right pulp for the cones so we discontinued them" Theres no coincidence that they started pushing neutral sounding monitors after discontinuing them. I think it was hurting their brand after a while and they just cut their losses
@PrincipalAudio
@PrincipalAudio 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThird Aye! They couldn't compete with more modern monitors for sure. Good decision to discontinue them! We're absolutely spoiled today. I mean, I use Neumann KH120As with KH750 DSP here, and I'm always blown away every day I mix on them or listen to music. Can't ever imagine mixing on monitors from the late 1970s. We're almost 50 years on with tech now.
@ButeSound
@ButeSound 4 ай бұрын
Incorrect take. You mix on them and if your mix is good where it matters (mids and dynamically/punch) then playback elsewhere will be good. Don't rely on it for low end obviously or rely on alone. First time I heard I had same reaction..
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
Depends on the mixer. Many an industry mixer told me that the whole "get it sounding good on NS10 and itll sound good anywhere" is complete BS But I read a few big engineers saying the opposite over the years. I'd say if your new to the game then that wont hold any weight as they'll just end up with super dull sounding mixes as they'll fully mix to the sound of them and try and get them sounding like what they are used to
@billB101
@billB101 4 ай бұрын
@@PaulThirdI never found this to be BS at all, NS10 mixes ( if you knew how to user them ) translated really well to other systems. I mean, that's why a lot of engineers used them. Sure, some engineers hated them ( personally I hate Genelec, I find them too "nice" ) but an awful lot in my circle swore by them.
@vicesquadpunk
@vicesquadpunk 4 ай бұрын
Within reason one can mix on almost anything… NS10 were used predominantly by mix engineers back in the 80's and they worked through the next couple of decades using the same speakers bringing the ubiquitous use of Yammies into the 2000's BUT, they simply had years of experience using them. Many worked in the same studios they knew the room and the NS10 speakers and therein lays the unfortunate truth…. There is no substitute for experience and years of practice.
@PaulThird
@PaulThird 4 ай бұрын
All about the journey
КАК ДУМАЕТЕ КТО ВЫЙГРАЕТ😂
00:29
МЯТНАЯ ФАНТА
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
Каха заблудился в горах
00:57
К-Media
Рет қаралды 9 МЛН
Studio Monitors: Too Big VS. Too Small
14:26
SonicScoop
Рет қаралды 21 М.
ALL EQs are the same?! (Almost) Alain Paul and the "EQ Scam"!
30:38
Dahl House Studios
Рет қаралды 809
THE BAD GEAR INTERVIEW
53:01
Weaver Beats
Рет қаралды 18 М.
We Have to Talk About The NONSENSICAL Pricing of Audio Gear ...
29:31
Why YouTube Is Dumbing Down The Future Of Audio Engineering
56:21
The Batsh*t Software Aphex Twin Used
24:17
Benn Jordan
Рет қаралды 1,2 МЛН
Why Do Mixers Use Yamaha NS-10's? FAQ Friday with Warren Huart
11:13
Produce Like A Pro
Рет қаралды 45 М.
akimmmich (feat. Turar) - UMYTTYŃ BA?| official lyric video
2:54
Sadraddin - Taxi | Official Music Video
3:10
SADRADDIN
Рет қаралды 968 М.
Dj Jack SpaRRow - Akbar Ghalta Bahiati ( Slap Remix Arabic ) #TIKTOK
2:21
Duman - мен болмасам кім? (Mood Video)
2:35
Duman Marat
Рет қаралды 187 М.
Taxi
3:06
Sadraddin - Topic
Рет қаралды 240 М.
IL’HAN - Pai-pai (lyric video) 2024
3:24
Ilhan Ihsanov
Рет қаралды 857 М.
Әбдіжаппар Әлқожа - Ұмыт деме
3:58
Әбдіжаппар Әлқожа
Рет қаралды 1,2 МЛН