I think his intention was, youth should aspire to clear UPSC but should not be obsessed with it and forget other options.

📌📌👇👇 Sanjiv sir is 100% right... New bureaucracy social media ke chakkar me pad gayi hai 😂😂😂

He is right I'm a upsc aspirant, wasted 5 years of life,log jinka ho jata hai unko yaad rkte h baaki itne log fail ho jate h koi puchta tak nhi, unemployed,gets old no skill depressed lonely bas yhi milta h last me ,hua to sab kuch nhi hua to kuch nhi, youth are wasting their talent this is true

I very well agree with Sanjeev Sanyal Sir. I also spent several years on upsc prep now i am doing mba from IIFT, now even if I dont call those years wasted its true i didn't learn anything tangible which could earn me a monetary benefit and another thing he talked about is the cult status of upsc created by coaching instututes which very well is true even you quit your prestigious IDAS job to coach upsc aspirants, if it was so good why did you quit your job, and if you did you should motivate people for some skill based learning or entrepreneurial venture which you yourself are doing now, please guide and influence youth with proper care

Even ias kanishka kataria said only 2 attempts !

Wo ek economist hai wo ek economist perspective se bol rahe hai agar economy ko increase karna to young youth ko business, sports pe focus karna chahiye .

Though for the UPSC preparation, the students reads( in deep) the most basic and important book of India "the constitution" for the first time... In fact, more than 70 percent citizens don't know the PIL or the working of indian judiciary, bureaucracy, political system etc... If some people made this a business through their coachings, then why do we blame the UPSC preparation system for this??

Thanks for featuring our video! Glad you enjoyed it. Keep up the great work! :)

I don't care what people says ,mein apna 100% de rahi hu aur crack kar ke hi rahungi..I love studies & am enjoying the journey..hua toh hua nahi hua toh acha teacher nahi toh acha politician ya acha leader toh ban paungi society me...acha mother hi sahi banungi.Apna dil ki baat sunno aur hard work karte jaun...Joh insaan A+ school college me padhke aye hai, woh log kya jane Middle class hum kya kar shakte hai apne sapne k liye

moral of the story: Aspire to become like sanjeev sanyal..... sirf 2 statements se UPSC aur UPSC coaching walo ko hila kr rakh diya.....

Rightly put.Thank you sir👍 Jai Hind🙏

"large parts of bureaucracy are dull and boring" this statement is misleading, because if anyone find bureaucracy is boring then working whole day in Excel and PowerPoint in corporates will be 100 times more dull and boring for him. So I don't think anyone should take decision on basis of this because most of the job (wheather it's government aur corporate) is same in term of nature. If you want an adventurous life go for any profession or start a business.

Maturity is when you realise that every feild need time and hard work.👍

Sir i really want everyone to stop preparing for upsc.. guys please do business.. get a life.. get a private job.. don't ruin your and your family 's life (competition khatam karna hain taki mein ban jau ias😂)

Yes that economist is 101% right. He is talking bitter truth ,be fair to accept it.

Plan b is equally important like plan a...never ignore plan b guys...I ignored it I regret most..so be prepare

Sanjeev said it right.. Mtlb 11-12 lakh bache chand 1000 seats k lie.. Baki bacho k sal add krlo zra kitna time bnta h.. May be some won't agree woth me or Sanjeev.. But everyone knows. . TIME is money Let me clarify the point Suppose average time for a competitor is 5years (preparation).. Which i took here is too low Now number of students who don't make it. 12 00 000(based on 2023 data) 12,00,000×5 = 60lakhs of years which is 52,56,00,00,000 hours of INDIAN Youth.. That too in One single Year

Thank you so much sir😊

Right sir i agree with you 🙏 and it's very helpful video 🙏

Thank you, Sir.

Thank you very much Sir . I liked your positive analysis of the case .

Thank You Sir For showing How Critically should a Bureaucrat Think about Any Topic or Issue❤

Thank you so much Sir🙏 for this important session and for your guidance that we should keep open minded approach and patience to read any important news whether it is in a positive way or negative way. It means a lot. Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Sir 🙏🏻.

May I thankyou for explaining this because my cousin spent four years in upsc preparation without satisfaction and self confidence

Thank you very much

Agar aap ko civil servant hona hain to bohot cheeze avoid karna sikhna hoga. Analyse what is better for your life and future and then decide what to do.

Thank you sir 🙏

Great help...ty sir

Economicst sanjeev sanyal thought he is living in USA...this is India dude,its very difficult to start a business or growth..only the rich will get help from govt

😊 Positive man with positive vibes ❤❤. Love you sir. For this neutral answer...

Mai aj khud ko proudly ek servent jaisa smjh rhi hu ab, over Confident nhi hu, mgr ye sch h,,, aj ke ek sal phle mne mere bde bhai ko yhi bat khi thi,,, I proud on myself now. Ki meri soch similar itne bde admi se❤

Perfect explanation sir love and respect from odisha ❤

Thank you sir for giving your valuable perspective ❤

Namastey Sir

Sanyal ji statement was the need of time because we can direct youthful energy towards better things rather than guide them towards coaching institutes.

I support sanjiv sir and urge all aspirants to get placed in some pvt firm and continue their lives don't waste youthful years in preparing for govt jobs

Finally,i recommend all guys to trained ur mind neutral,it would help not preparation but also carrer🙏

If we see it objectively UPSC CSE preparation is only worth it if the individual gets into the top 3 services: that is Indian foreign service, Indian Administrative service and Indian Police service. Other services are just not worth it. Many individuals working in services apart from the above mentioned 3, resign from their service after working for 10-12 years and join attractive opportunities in private organizations. The growth opportunities, job satisfaction levels and exposure is very limited in other services. For example in the IRS, IAAS, ICLS, ITS, IDES, IDAS, etc after spending a decade the growth opportunities come to a stand still. Remuneration is on the lower side, even if we include all the perks &facilities. Career becomes a joke and depression starts setting in. It becomes a disgusting loop of mediocracy which you are unable to escape. You end up becoming a high end government clerk.

Sahi baat h ,pure duniya bs IAS ki tayari hi kra rhe h. Pura KZfaq bs UPSC preparation channel se bhara hua h

Bhai Maine blindly nhi ki Maine 2.5 years seriously diya hai I m 26 now Written state mains twice Giving upsc this year and uppcs Kya karu pdhai chhor Du Ye sb chochle hai janta ka mizaaz jaane ka ki kaise age reduce kre Waise v Sarkar general walo se nafrat hi karti hai Kya kre hm mar jaaye kahi ja kr

Sir please video on :- good education background is matter for UPSC ❤

I dnt know abt upsc job but Army officer is best ,defence is best .. Love from Assam Regiment

The way of your ❤❤❤❤❤teaching sir mind blowing

Sir you are the best teacher in world 🙏🙏🙏🙏

*I think it's worth it and at the end it's your life your decision your have one life chase your dream* *#Noregret** **#NoCompromise*

Present me upsc exam dene bale me mostly student Village se related hote hai. Village me sports , Olympic games ka infrastructure nhi hai. Good doctor or engineer banne me language problem vi ati hai student ko. Sabhi log iske main causes pe bat nhi krte. Other opportunity ko village tak nhi pauchate.

I think he is right because not prepared for more than 2 yr upsc preparation can't teach any skill if you are not selected what will you do

Sir Why Sachin sir did not become Dhirubhai Ambani , why he become economist . koi bhi kuch bhi bol rha h , I know that he has given some geniune points but it does not mean that running Business is easy

Sir, aapne ekdam sahi bataya

UPSC is atleast 400 in lakhs , Mukesh Ambani Elon Musk is 1 in billion and success rate for IAS is 0.1 percent but success in Billionaire becoming is 0.00001 percent . You want to be jobless whole life!

Low income high income tax....lots of pressure no family life.....don't come in govt Job.....period.

Asli problem yeh hai ke har koi entrepreneur hoga, yah sabko govt milega par private sector me bhi achhi job milna muskil hai, aur agar aap govt sector me bhi contractual ka job laga dete ho tab bhi aapki salary 20k se jyada nehin hoga. jaise ki US me har kisi ke liye ek margin hai salary ka jisse ki woh samaj me ek achhi khasi life ji sake , lekin humare idhar private me salary buhut kam hai . yeh log sarkar ko jo salary dikhate hai utna salary dete nehin. Aur har kisike paas na to zameen hai ki khetiwari kare na ki itna paisa hai ki business kar sake. pata nehin youth ka kya hoga, meri bhagwan se yehi prarthna hai ki har kisiko kam mile.

But I think 2 attempts is enough and even necessary.because it is also kindblike challenge increase our reading style

Gaurav sir is absolutely right and his thoughts and mine are matching at every point of this video ❤❤

Not more than 3 attempts should be given for UPSC/Government job preparations.

Okk thank you sir

Jai Hind sir 🇮🇳

Thank you sir

Okay sir..

Every Career Has Competition. Tough To Make Place __ Engineer . Doctor. CA CS CMA MBA Civil Services. Lawyer's. Creativity. Police, Para Military, Defence. Sport's Etc ...

sir mai sach btata hu mamla kya hai, mere father parliament house me officer hai, unhone ne btaya ki ruling govt, ne jo pay commission laana hai wo bhi dene se mana kar dia, senior officers, steno ko bola aap log VRS le lo tumhari jarurat sirf sessions me hoti hai, baki time kya karoge,, ye ruling govt. govt vacancy kam karke sirf contract staff laygi.. ye hai asliyat,, isliye economic adviser ne bola, jisse youth govt exams ki taraf na jaye,,, so hum logo ko alert rehna chaiye, aage ke saal ye party bhot kuch kar sakti hamare saath

Waste of time when youth is trying 5th or 6th time . Govt should make it 3 attempt at max

Can you please say that which is better between 4th or 5th edition of Oxford Student Atlas?

Quality of Job opportunities are less in India especially if you don't have professional Degree. This is also bitter truth. Civil services craze will decrease if people get good chances in private sector. 😕

Good evening sir

Yes sir yeh aajkal bohat log bol re gai upsc waste of tym par mujhe nahi lagta hai aaisa.

Bai can you do video on how many IAS are transferred to Karnataka and by where, please 😊

Private jobs me middle aur upper middle class wale ladke hen , gaon ka garib aur lower middle class wala ho sarkari naukri ki tayari karte hen . Wo log kya karen , kyu ki elitist to eng med kar k private jobs me hen

Sahi kaha....

85% educated people are unemployed in India what you want to say ?

You are the best gudge to say the correct result

I feel the present system of many chances and age limit up to 30/33 years is wasting one's future, it should be limited to 2 attempts and age less than 27 years.

100 baat ki ek baat !! Jis logon ko padhne mein maza aata hai vo civil services ki tyaari kare

Actually sabko within a couple of years mai bada aadmi banna hai, isliye sab shortcuts dundte hai

Sir agar hum during Graduation UPSC ki preparation karte hai but humari graduation complete nhi Hui hai toh kya hum graduation ke last year me UPSC me first attempt de sakte hai

Sach toh kaha hai

See it jus another service do not make it life. That's all it is. Those who are working day and night to run this huge country are not Jokers they are actually very underpaid and working day and night. Those who don't have any idea, commenting from their beds and luxury sofas . We need all kind of professions in our society.

Sir make a video on how to study a new book or topic in a limited time... please!!

Sahi kaha

Jai hind sir

Jab ias ips ko social media p khud ko lekar advertisement karte dekhta hun ki lagta hai ki bat sahi kah rahe sanjiv uncle

Thanks

IAS,IPS Officer few are harmkhor..only money no social work..

However mukesh ambani and what his son enjoy is hereditary remember......

1. The first is to listen and understand what the next person told, read the full article, don't go to any final decision fastely. 2. It says don't follow blindly any thing , check your temperament and check this this is made for you or not, and service or career or in also life has some up's and down so dont scare and don't be im mature guy.

Largest population with 141 crore approx. every year only 1000 or 900 selected for upsc..🤔🤔🤔,,????

As an economist ! He is 100% right.

Sanjeev sanyal is spot on.

your vidoes are more informative

I think he wants to say that everyone should focus more on technical education instead of being so obsessed with government jobs.

Honest Question Sir , 10:10 Sir ap apne kids ko Kiya kahenge UPSC korne kehenge Ya nhi kehenge

यूपीएससी - आईएएस - यह सेवा कई लोगों की आँखों में चुभती है क्योंकि कई ऐसे भी हैं जिन्हें अपने जीवनकाल में सफलता नहीं मिली। 😕

Sanjiv sir is the grand nephew of revolutionary Sachindra sanyal

Make sense.

Upsc is only good for coaching walas out of11 lakh+ aspirants only900+ people are selected out of which only for ias&ips we add glamour, have anybody inuk,usa,France,Germany,Jagan etc heard of their category of administrative &police services, in usa there is a saying usa is made from entrepreneurs in us there are crores of entrepreneurs from small to fortune 500 so they are giving taxes to usa so it is flourishing where as in India small &medium enterprises are disencouraged with with own govt policies &our politicians don't let a single opportunity in defaming entrepreneurs the only entrepreneurs flourishing in India are either politicians or those who have good ties with politicians,now India is also changing & a day will come that every responsible citizen of this country will question these so called ias ,ips &public servants about their services to this nation with the taxpayers money

I agree with each and every word of Gaurav sir but ...I don't fully agree with Sanjeev sir ... Upsc can't be a wate of time ...Because without bureaucrats a nation can't function that's why sardar Vallabhbhai patel told bureaucrats as steel frame of the country...and even if one fails to crack the exam he or she will have atleast knowledge about anything and everything and I don't think gaining knowledge is wasts of time ....But I think giving 2 or 3 attempts are ok but not more than that then it will be the wastage of time... And then comes that why Indian youths target UPSC and don't aspire to become entrepreneurs or business man like Mukesh Ambani because most of the people don't have the incentives or that amount of money and resources to start a business and it's like a impossible thing for middle class people and then about sports...well it's our society which gives much respect to a person who is good academically than to a person who is good in sports....so yes UPSC needs some reforms but can't be called as wastage of time atleast Everyone is taking about business and all kinds of stuff but if there's not enough security how's business and all of that stuffs gonna happen and the people responsible for providing security are the IPS officers and the army officers who are recruited through UPSC only

For 900+ posts 11 lakh +people compete what about the remaining 11 lakh who dont qualify &how many years will it take to qualify for those 11 lakh people who don't qualify in upsc

Dhoni ke railway ke job chorne se uska 5000 per month ka nuksan hua par agar job na chorta to kitna nuksan hota usko bhi na pata chalta

That's why you have left services right?

I think intent matters in bureaucracy ❤❤ only interested people should enter in service