Interceptor Class: Better late than never...

  Рет қаралды 49,617

Venom Geek Media 98

Venom Geek Media 98

9 ай бұрын

Today we take a closer look at the Fan Created Interceptor Class Designed by Stuart Baldwin it has seen many incarnations and interpretations with some casting it as a small frigate and others claiming it as a Destroyer. But today i will discuss the Interceptor as a small Fast Attack Ship. with a modest but effective armament, relying on speed and numbers to defeat its foe in the latter half of the Dominion War.
Sources:
www.deviantart.com/wild-endea...
www.deviantart.com/buzanorbi/...
www.deviantart.com/mavek-cg/a...

Пікірлер: 298
@spartan078ben
@spartan078ben 8 ай бұрын
The Interceptor-class is what happens when a Defiant and an Intrepid love each other very much....
@anonymousplayer4823
@anonymousplayer4823 8 ай бұрын
It's funny when people say "jack of all trades, master of none" because there's another part of that saying; "Better than just one"
@michaelkeha
@michaelkeha 8 ай бұрын
Which in reality we have found to be not true as proof by the countless specialist pieces of equipment because general equipment won't simply do the task well and is part of why the rest of the phrase has been somewhat forgotten
@thomasjenkins5727
@thomasjenkins5727 8 ай бұрын
The original was actually just to call someone a jack of all trades. Master of none was implied. But one of the earliest times it's seen used is as a way to call a playwright a hack. Which playwright? William Shakespeare. Practically speaking, there is need for both generalists and specialists. Generalists have a certain cross-disciplinary perspective that's good for leadership, problem solving, task flexibility, and innovation. But they're never as good at anything as a a specialist at what the specialist does. There's room for both.
@misterlau5246
@misterlau5246 8 ай бұрын
Better than none.. I know how to do some things, and I believe one of those I have lots of experience and I love it and... It's not my first source of income 😔
@joeleek9976
@joeleek9976 8 ай бұрын
From what I hear, the original phrase was "jack of all trades, master of one"
@colinwhite5485
@colinwhite5485 8 ай бұрын
Jack of all trades master of none, better than a master of one
@xarglethegreat
@xarglethegreat 8 ай бұрын
the thing is that realistically the defiant class would have been the attack ship of the federation, it was cannonically designed as a swarming close in attack ship andcould have very easily been modified from the prototype for series production. things like the interceptor class while well conceived and a very nice looking design are post hoc rationalisations for the showrunners choice to not use the defiant class in large numbers on screen so as to not dilute its value as a hero ship, this is one of the areas where babylon 5 handled it so much better introducing the first whitestar as the hero ship for the station and first of its kind, the harbinger of things to come, but revealing later that the minbari had been mass producing them for the rangers after the prototype proved successful
@michaelkeha
@michaelkeha 8 ай бұрын
Except it did actually lower the value of the original and ran into the issue of they are only as good as your plot armor
@gizmo8760
@gizmo8760 8 ай бұрын
Agreed. A pack of Defiant class ships accomplish the same thing. Far more nimble and better armed.
@michaelkeha
@michaelkeha 8 ай бұрын
@@gizmo8760 or or and hear me out just retrofit the excelsiors and mirandas up to current specs and pump out them fucking New Orleans classes like they were going out of style
@DocWolph
@DocWolph 8 ай бұрын
@@michaelkeha In universe, the Excelsior and Miranda were both designed 100 years ago, literally, and were not designed for the roles required nor could they be parleyed into those roles. The New Orleans class was little more than a missile cruiser when combat fighters (Attack Ships) were needed.
@boomer0117zr
@boomer0117zr 8 ай бұрын
the defiant class is a terrible star fleet ship. I love it but its crew accommodations are mediocre your in space in basically a Cold War sub, no holodecks to get your mind off of war limited medical facilities
@spatialgaming1967
@spatialgaming1967 8 ай бұрын
The Interceptor class: A jack of all trades is a master of none, but oftentimes better than a master of one. The full quote is quite enlightening.
@Arbyfig
@Arbyfig 8 ай бұрын
I was about to mention this
@michaelkeha
@michaelkeha 8 ай бұрын
Except in military terms specialist equipment is more valuable and more common place than generalist gear so not really
@spatialgaming1967
@spatialgaming1967 8 ай бұрын
@@michaelkeha You are correct. However, think about the F-15, F-16, F-10, and F-35. While all of them are specifically military aircraft, all of them are able to fill multiple roles. Something that can do one thing with peerless capability is a good thing, but that does not mean that you cannot make devices, weapons, and vehicles that are better than they otherwise would be if made more specialized. One example of a hyper-specialized aircraft that performes with enormous effectiveness is the A-10 Thunderbolt. It is extremely specialized in ground attack, but because the US has such a large military, they can afford to support such systems.
@spatialgaming1967
@spatialgaming1967 8 ай бұрын
@@michaelkeha Also keep in mind that the only absolute statement in the saying is that a jack of all trades is a master of none. The ultimate meaning of the phrase I think is that being so specialized that you lose all flexibility is generally a bad idea, but that such people or devices still can be helpful.
@michaelkeha
@michaelkeha 8 ай бұрын
@@spatialgaming1967 The counter point is things like the DMRs, Sniper rifles, breaching equipment, bridge layers, air defence systems etc etc there is far more specialist gear in a military than general gear because there are far far more niches that need filling
@Relav1364
@Relav1364 8 ай бұрын
You know what, I just love the way Interceptor looks. She looks sleek, nimble, and mean looking all the same. Exactly what an attack ship should be, no? Yay for fanverse shout outs! Love seeing the underloved works get a spotlight, especially from you!
@thanqualthehighseer
@thanqualthehighseer 8 ай бұрын
i can see it being crewed more by Starfleet marines or more Tactical trained personnel it's small size/sensor signature and atmospheric/landing ability would make it hard to detect, perfect as a fast deployment vehicle for a commando team or Anti piracy security
@cpt_bill366
@cpt_bill366 8 ай бұрын
It was love at first sight, before the description even started!
@chriseash6497
@chriseash6497 8 ай бұрын
The Interceptor would have been invaluable after the war as well. After a big war there are always groups that would try to capitalize on all the instability, the variability of the design would make it perfect as a Coast Guard type of roll.
@venomgeekmedia9886
@venomgeekmedia9886 8 ай бұрын
Yep a key element of peacekeeping is presence
@pike100
@pike100 8 ай бұрын
Role, not roll
@malloryjones5393
@malloryjones5393 8 ай бұрын
I see them as ideal patrol and scout vessels. They’ve small enough to be relatively sneaky, and planetfall ais a very useful feature.
@theodoremccarthy4438
@theodoremccarthy4438 8 ай бұрын
The Defiant is an attack ship, but it’s a heavy attack ship purpose built to slug it out with larger and more powerful vessels. It just got pressed into service as a line breaker during the Dominion War because of its combination of speed, firepower and survivability.
@Earthstar_Review
@Earthstar_Review 8 ай бұрын
It was also a stark departure from Khitomer Accords 24th century ship design. The Defiant class dispensed with the usual "peace ships" of its area, a deliberate philosophy to show other Alpha/Beta powers that the UFP was committed to its play-nice diplomacy. At the same time, it boasted Galaxy-class cruisers which only a fool would mistake for a science ship. However, they got away with it because she wasn't a dedicated warship.
@venomgeekmedia9886
@venomgeekmedia9886 8 ай бұрын
Yeah most other attack ships don't worry about survivability that's where the anti borg DNA comes in.
@AdamKafei
@AdamKafei 8 ай бұрын
I don't think it's a mistake to design warships to the 'Borg Standard', if anything that's a good idea, what is a mistake is to not learn lessons from the prototype and adjust the mainline ships for mass production and crewing while also adjusting the academy curriculum to cover it's newfound shortcomings. After all, if one ship design comes out needing a higher standard of competence then what does that say about the future? It may of course say nothing, but better to account for such a trend and have it vanish than not and have it continue.
@paulzy5192
@paulzy5192 8 ай бұрын
Have you seriously watched all of DS9?? - The Defiant is an extremely manueverable and evasive ship.
@TheMelbournelad
@TheMelbournelad 8 ай бұрын
Not to meantion it being “expensive”. I’m pretty sure it was meantioned as modular and quick to build as meant to swarm the borg. Only thing to make it expensive would be the ablative armour
@richt.2966
@richt.2966 8 ай бұрын
I dont understand why you say the Defiant is not maneuverable. In the shows it is seen manuevering just as fast and tight as Birds of Prey and Jem Hadar attack ships.
@kamenwaticlients
@kamenwaticlients 8 ай бұрын
Yeah I was thinking the same thing and I think it is larger then the size shown, its also very fast at impulse. Also the Defiant by the last season of Voyager was way more common which means easier to build.
@VVeremoose
@VVeremoose 8 ай бұрын
Tighter than BoP, really. The Defiant is the perfect Federation warship, honestly.
@I.Simmonds
@I.Simmonds 4 ай бұрын
I assume he means independent of large fleet action. Especially in regards to Star Trek: Legacy video games.
@admiralcasperr
@admiralcasperr 8 ай бұрын
I'd describe the Defiant as a gunship.
@weldonwin
@weldonwin 8 ай бұрын
I'd describe her as the embodiment of Ben Sisko's long held rage
@nunya3163
@nunya3163 8 ай бұрын
Pocket Battleship.
@weldonwin
@weldonwin 8 ай бұрын
@@nunya3163 Panzerschiffe
@Rustyknife1
@Rustyknife1 8 ай бұрын
Siskos pimp hand
@pike100
@pike100 8 ай бұрын
​@nunya3163 A pocket battleship isn't a good analogy to the Defiant. Pocket battleships were almost as large as regular battleships, but they were more lightly armored so that they could be faster.
@lovenicholson
@lovenicholson 8 ай бұрын
Love your passion for the Star Trek Universe brother, be well.
@jerryc5743
@jerryc5743 8 ай бұрын
5:07 - what would mass production of the Defiant be too expensive? When Sisko first brought it DS9 to make contact with the Dominion before the war, he, then later Bashir, remarked about its very spartan design(Bashir indicated that it did not have a sick bay).
@jimmyjohnjames6397
@jimmyjohnjames6397 8 ай бұрын
It wouldn't be expensive to mass produce. The only reason we didn't see Defiant all over the place was because it was the hero ship of DS9.
@I.Simmonds
@I.Simmonds 4 ай бұрын
I assume in material, the Defiant is supposed to be engines, guns and armor. And ablative are is ment to boil off, and the Defiant's cannons burn through some of it's parts during excessive combat. There is a ceremony placing the parts on a wall in the mess when Sisko is promoted to Ross' adjutant. That where I think he is coming from.
@geekiusmaximus1882
@geekiusmaximus1882 4 ай бұрын
Ablative armor and quantum torpedoes are EXPENSIVE
@cesarespinozaspain
@cesarespinozaspain 8 ай бұрын
I've always imagined the Defiant class as a Heavy Gunship or Attack Corvette. Small and way over gunned. Conceived as Anti-borg I always found it too small to be effective as it was intended. Once its phaser/ pulse cannon frequencies were sorted it would be just be a small annoying gnat to do any real damage to the Borg. Hell the Defiant would of been destroyed if it wasn't for the Enterprise E to save the day. Even the supposed anti-borg ships were losing the battle, until Jean-Luc arrived. One interesting concept though, I wonder why warp speed ramming impacts wasn't a tactic that was used, going with Worf's concept. Use Warp, drones and slam into it like starwars. I'd imagine anything at super luminal velocities would create apocalyptic damage to any borg ship
@keirfarnum6811
@keirfarnum6811 8 ай бұрын
That’s a good idea!
@lyinarbaeldeth2456
@lyinarbaeldeth2456 5 ай бұрын
... until Jean-Luc arrived in the Anti-Borg battlecruiser. And, to be fair, the existing task force had dealt heavy damage to the Cube, as Data stated. It just wasn't enough to knock it out before the Enterprise arrived.
@Evil0tto
@Evil0tto 4 ай бұрын
"Once its phaser/ pulse cannon frequencies were sorted it would be just be a small annoying gnat to do any real damage to the Borg." It's a wasp. One wasp is no threat to a human. A swarm of wasps can sting a man to death. Remember, the Defiants are still Starfleet, and are just as capable of shifting weapon frequencies as any other. In the Battle of Sector 001 we see that the cube has taken serious damage before the Enterprise has gotten there. Starfleet *IS* hurting it, just not fast enough to stop it, and at far too great a cost. There's no sign that the borg are able to adapt to Starfleet weapons in that battle. Defiants were never intended to be lone starships against the borg, or even parts of ragtag fleets. They were designed to swarm enemies. One Defiant is a minor nuisance against a cube at best. What about 50? Ablative armored, heavily armed, and flitting about the enemy while larger ships like Torpedo-boat Akiras pump photons and quantums from a distance. Sure, you'd lose some Defiants... but that would be tough for even the borg to handle. As to your question about warp ramming, it's never a good idea to introduce that in fiction *coughLASTJEDIcough* (even though they did prepare that in "Best of Both Worlds). It become a go-to solution to any threat. If I had to come up with a reason why it wouldn't work just off the top of my head you could say that it's too easy to disrupt a warp bubble. We see that in Deep Space 9 where the Klingons do that against the Dominion, knocking a bunch of their ships out of warp. You might take an enemy by surprise with a ram attempt, but if you don't you're just crashing at sublight.
@jamesabernethy7896
@jamesabernethy7896 8 ай бұрын
I like the way you describe how these ships fit in. Although I like both of your channels, your collaboration with Drachinifel really was a highlight. This is a really beautiful design, it has a very clear design lineage. It also fits in well with the lore and would be believable as a cost effective design for the role it played
@mephistoxarses8585
@mephistoxarses8585 8 ай бұрын
Notable ship names during the Dominion war. USS. Spitfire ( Interceptor class) USS Hurricane ( Defiant class ) USS Mustang ( Interceptor class ) USS Lancaster ( Akira class ) Dominion forces pull a quote from Monty python "Run away! Run away!"
@douglasmiller8607
@douglasmiller8607 8 ай бұрын
USS Thunderbolt USS Lightening USS KittyHawk USS WarHawk
@mephistoxarses8585
@mephistoxarses8585 8 ай бұрын
@@douglasmiller8607 Legends one and all!
@NardoVogt
@NardoVogt 8 ай бұрын
"But the Federation doesn't believe in Warsh..." *Interceptor comes into the room, slits throat, runs out and acts like it did some anomaly research*
@alexandercaires5921
@alexandercaires5921 8 ай бұрын
Been waiting patiently for an Interceptor video. Was shocked that was also about Attach Ship type vessels as the Interceptor seemed more like a simpler Intrepid Class Starship, but fleshing out the use and role of Attack Ships helped understand better a few battles from the Dominion War.
@venomgeekmedia9886
@venomgeekmedia9886 8 ай бұрын
Yeah some cast it as that but you already have the new Orleans...
@alexandercaires5921
@alexandercaires5921 8 ай бұрын
@venomgeekmedia9886 I've pictured the Interceptor as a wartime Intrepid because of a couple starships (Elkins and Yeager) use intact Intrepid saucer sections.
@casbot71
@casbot71 8 ай бұрын
Starfleet once again having to relearn old lessons again _the hard way._ If they had kept the Akayzi class's niche updated with each new generation of ship paradigms, Starfleet would have been far better prepared and just more effective on a day to day basis. They needed a small planetary landing capable counterpart to the Bird of Prey to act as a patrol ship and light general duties ship. And be cheap enough that Federation space was swarming with them. So that colonies and stations have a quick response helper for everything from raiders to weird phenomenon, to light cargo duties. And all the capital ships have a screening vessel and escort in case they run into weird space phenomenon of the week. No doubt Starfleet would retire the Interceptor class a few decades after the Dominion war anyway.
@jeremypace249
@jeremypace249 8 ай бұрын
I've always seen the problem of "only a battlecruiser can hold a M/AM core". In TOS, that antimatter design was huge. By TNG, it was not much better. You could not put a M/AM reactor on a Runabout, or in a Galaxy class saucer section. Fusion reactors didn't produce enough power, yet, in TOS, to warp space past Warp 3, or power a ship-sized phaser bank for more than a split second. By DS9 and VOY, M/AM designs were finally small enough to even consider a Defiant, or an Interceptor. Runabouts were the cutting-edge of power vs. warp nacelle design on miniaturization.
@occultatumquaestio5226
@occultatumquaestio5226 8 ай бұрын
So basically, the interceptor class is an intermediate between the Defiant, Intrepid, Nova, and Saber classes. I can see it doing well. Also, the Defiant class is likely more agile than not just the Hideki, but also the Romulan scout.
@poil8351
@poil8351 8 ай бұрын
the defiant could turn on a dime and was pretty nimble. more a gunship than an a attack ship, i see the defiant as something similar to ww1 british monitors .
@kamenriderblade2099
@kamenriderblade2099 8 ай бұрын
Think of the Defiant Class as a Paladin Knight, but carrying Multiple Gatling Guns that can turn reasonably well. Basically, a Brock Lesnar type if you're into Combat Sports or Pro Wrestling. Ridiculously Fast & Agile for it's size, over-powered, overtly durable.
@vortega472
@vortega472 28 күн бұрын
Brilliant as always. I like your description of how the Defiant works and does not. Whereas the Interceptor class reminds me of PT boat in WWII. They work very well in single patrol - in the right circumstance - but in a formation they can be devastating.
@merafirewing6591
@merafirewing6591 8 ай бұрын
I wonder if the old Destroyers in the Federation could be upgunned as very large gunship.
@samspeed6271
@samspeed6271 6 ай бұрын
The Interceptor is absolutely gorgeous. It has the elegance of the Intrepid and the sleekness of the Sovereign.
@stevenewman1393
@stevenewman1393 8 ай бұрын
🖖😎👍Very cool and very nicely well done and executed and informatively explained in every way shape and form and detail provided on this subject matter and format on the Interceptor class attack starship's of the Federation via Starfleet and on all of its weapons capacities and all of its various functions and abilities and duties, And I myself find it to be a very wonderfully nice looking ship and very cool design indeed!,👌.
@kamenriderblade2099
@kamenriderblade2099 8 ай бұрын
The USS ProtoStar could also be seen as a evolution of the "Patrol Ship" concept. It's slightly smaller than the Interceptor class. Armed well enough, and is adorned with the latest StarFleet tech.
@samuel5916
@samuel5916 8 ай бұрын
I think you might’ve slept on the Defiant too hard. I agree that the Interceptor was probably more versatile outside of combat. It had more internal space for equipment and higher warp speeds. However, in combat I don’t agree that Defiant was slower and less maneuverable. Everything we’ve seen shows it just as capable as other attack ships. In addition, it had twice the firepower and significantly better durability. I would frame them more as a high/low mix of Attack ships due to the cost of Defiant. There are fewer of them but they last longer and hit harder. You send them to do the most critical missions/tasks with the best crews. In real world terms think of them like the F-15/F-16 or F-22/F-35. Both capable but one is more capable and also more expensive. F-16/F-35 are also more well rounded multi-role planes vs their larger siblings that more specialized into Air Superiority. They can all do the same jobs however.
@theodoremccarthy4438
@theodoremccarthy4438 8 ай бұрын
It’s important to remember that the B’rel wasn’t just an ambush ship pushed into an attack ship role. It’s was the ship that saved the Klingon empire. In the post-Praxis empire building and operating battle cruisers enmass was simply too expensive. Fleets of B’rels on the other hand could be built, crewed and operated efficiently and made invading the empire’s territory an extremely costly proposition. By the time of the Dominion war the Klingons were no doubt adept at using the B’rel in all manner of roles.
@venomgeekmedia9886
@venomgeekmedia9886 8 ай бұрын
Oh absolutely the B'rel was a perfect ship for a budget military engaged in territorial defence
@theodoremccarthy4438
@theodoremccarthy4438 8 ай бұрын
@@venomgeekmedia9886 Come to think of it the B’rel was also the ship that saved the Federation during the Whale Probe crisis and in the wake of the Breen entering war. I imagine it inspires a significant romanticism in both Klingons and Star Fleet personnel. It’s arguably the most consequential ship design in the entire setting.
@georgesulea
@georgesulea 8 ай бұрын
I'm so glad to see this; I saw the specs on this ship some time ago, and thought it needed some fleshing out. Thanks!
@potatoradio
@potatoradio 8 ай бұрын
The saw jack of all trades originally was master of 1. It was inserted later. This ship seems to fit the original.
@Marinealver
@Marinealver 8 ай бұрын
looks like one of the 3 tiny ships that got vaped effortlessly by the Borg Cube in the Best of Both Worlds part 2.
@gr8_22-15
@gr8_22-15 8 ай бұрын
Love all your videos.
@MrApplemat
@MrApplemat 8 ай бұрын
Would have loved to have seen more ships like this being used by the federation.
@wedgeantillies66
@wedgeantillies66 8 ай бұрын
That's the one very good attribute of the federation as although they do make use of ship types for far long than they should do. That when the situation or threat warrants it, they are able to adapt and create new ships that fulfil the roles require of; like the interceptor class above.
@cdrocrossdiscovery
@cdrocrossdiscovery 6 ай бұрын
I like this. As a matter of fact, I'm going to incorporate The Interceptor class into the sStar Trek Novel I'm working on. Thank you for this.
@nicholestocker2596
@nicholestocker2596 8 ай бұрын
Love it
@davidponseigo8811
@davidponseigo8811 8 ай бұрын
Great video !
@antifableach
@antifableach 8 ай бұрын
This seems like a pretty awesome little ship.
@trevynlane8094
@trevynlane8094 8 ай бұрын
Basically, attack ships are torpedo boats, and need to be quickly built and cheap to lose. The Federation tends to favor cruisers that can do anything, not cheap expendable ships
@goldeng8073
@goldeng8073 8 ай бұрын
Love the design
@jinsetayinsei4146
@jinsetayinsei4146 8 ай бұрын
The Interceptor is a beautiful ship and I love her. The Federation needs ships of war though definitely in moderation. That said, this is the last ship I would've wanted in large numbers during the Dominion war. Trying to match the Dominion pound for pound was hopeless. Better to swat the bugs than get on their level. The Defiant class was certainly the most important ship of the war for the very reasons you mentioned. If you asked me what ship I would've wanted to have in greater numbers, I'd ask for a ship that can match two or three fighters like heavy destroyers or light cruisers. Anything bigger would turn into a fat prize and a excess dedication of resources to the same scenario. Post war, sure. The attack ship role needs a state of the art fill in. If there's another Dominion war, I wouldn't let these guys out alone at night. They are best effective when they have the initiative.
@zeash482
@zeash482 2 ай бұрын
the interceptor is good enough and in war good enough is perfect
@rubengraham9976
@rubengraham9976 Ай бұрын
That's the best looking ship I've seen by far !!!!!!!!!!
@MrJcn89
@MrJcn89 2 ай бұрын
I'd like to see more on an interceptor class. Interesting concept
@korvusknull1447
@korvusknull1447 8 ай бұрын
💪Strong presentation👍
@haveaknifeday
@haveaknifeday 8 ай бұрын
Thanks!
@Grandtemplar1191
@Grandtemplar1191 8 ай бұрын
While I don’t think the Federation ships would’ve been a good fit for it, I can actually imagine the Interceptor-class being employed in Wolf-pack tactics and convoy hunting
@jasonparis5635
@jasonparis5635 8 ай бұрын
That's a awesome design a small kick ass ship just like the defiant class
@timbradwell3205
@timbradwell3205 8 ай бұрын
Loved playing with the 3d model of the interceptor years ago when it was called the milnium class
@johnn9977
@johnn9977 8 ай бұрын
Best information on Star Trek out there.
@pakese30
@pakese30 3 ай бұрын
Well I mean, the Odyssey got took out primarily due to a kamikaze run, it shows the dominion lack of interest in their people because they essentially pump them out factory style.
@steeltimberwolf
@steeltimberwolf 3 ай бұрын
The issue that the Alpha Quadrant powers had was that the Jem'hadar were disposable along with their fighters. Where every death among the Alpha Quadrant races was a blow, this isn't the same as the Dominion as the Jem'hadar would be fully capable of fighting in 3 days after birth with apparently all the genetic memory needed to function a soldiers and crew. This along with the fact that the Dominion only fielded 3 types of ships allowed them to produce large amounts of ships and personnel in a short amount of time. Every Alpha Quadrant power was playing catch up to the Dominion that was in essence the opposite side of the coin that was the Federation. So attach fighters while great for the Dominion were a horrible idea for the Alpha Quadrant powers as their crews were not seen as disposable with exception being among the Klingons, who viewed death in battle honorable.
@KertaDrake
@KertaDrake 8 ай бұрын
Starfleet really dropped the ball by not trimming down all the extra mass on the Mirandas to make a more compact version or just throwing the Defiant plans at the engineers and order "Make this mass-producible."
@sim.frischh9781
@sim.frischh9781 8 ай бұрын
The Federation´s ideology would never allow them to create an "Attack ship". But purely from the capabilities, the Defiant would be the perfect candidate. Heck, you even have it in your Attack ship sheet. It just never admits to being one, but Sisko and the other designers knew what they were creating. And the DS9 series shows just HOW good the Defiant is in that role, multiple times in fact. And in Star Trek, agility matters not that much as weapons hit pinpoint from ORBIT. Still i have to say, the Interceptor class looks great and makes sense, nice job there, whoever came up with that idea.
@Lookthere167
@Lookthere167 8 ай бұрын
Would like to see that ( attack ship ) Hugging a huge dominion vessel as only the defiant class was capable of pulling off
@raithnor6007
@raithnor6007 8 ай бұрын
So in other Sci-Fi properties, this would be a "Corvette" while the Defiant would be a "Frigate". This could also be used for Anti-Piracy,. (In Trek, this isn't usually an issue given how Warp Drive works) The image of these ships as basically "Coast Guard Cutters" comes to mind. The hard counter to small, highly maneuverable vessels is usually something that would make its mobility/evasiveness moot. Something along the lines of a"Nova"-like ability or using Antimatter spreads as flak cannons. Up until the Dominion War, the fire control of most Star Trek ships were able to hit anything at any size, since it was all just math and weapons that operated at effectively lightspeed. The tactic of small multiple ships is valid in a universe with directional shielding. Captains can't divert power from a rear shield if one of the three fighters can move to hit that weak spot. I like the vid, just adding my own observations.
@Messametti
@Messametti 8 ай бұрын
The Defiant the least manouverable attack ship, did we watched the same series with all the flight manouvers they did with it? To beat that the supposedly better ships would need the ability to turn on the spot like a tank.
@OllamhDrab
@OllamhDrab 8 ай бұрын
I *like it.* :)
@leodouskyron5671
@leodouskyron5671 8 ай бұрын
The Defiant class is very much an attack ship but the issue was it was MORE then just an attack ship because the Federation can’t help but to over achieve. The class could operate to defend bases, lease fighter/runabout missions, undergo rescues and operate with larger ships to make them much more lethal combination then either alone. And that is not counting as a Raiding and recon assault. While there were a many made a reason they did not likely make more war the crew size. Defiant class needed about 25-50 but fighters that were half as effective could be operational with what seems to be 5 or less (I got the feeling they used a Runabout like crew of 2 or 3. That personally is why you make fighters because the Federation was being massively outnumbered and overrun. the defiance class Because of crew numbers could not hold the line alone and is likely to just be overwhelmed with numbers (Which we saw often on DS9 that the Defiant was always had more targets to neutralize then they could get too).
@haveaknifeday
@haveaknifeday 8 ай бұрын
For when the galaxy class goes into a known battle it should just separate the saucer section and go for the battle bridge set up. Buckle up families, it's time to die in glorious battle.
@ralphsexton8531
@ralphsexton8531 Ай бұрын
"A Jack of All Trades, Master of none, but often times better than a Master of One." The Jack may not be the best at any one thing, but can be used for anything. The Master of One is practically useless aside from their specialty. So it is hardly an insult, for those who know.
@Psych1_-
@Psych1_- 2 ай бұрын
One thing I will add is that the smaller fighters only did so well against the larger vessels because the Dominion ships could fire right through their shields as if they weren't there. I think those 3 dominion ships would have gotten their butt's handed to them against a galaxy class ship once the shields had been adapted for Dominion weapons.
@brand8590
@brand8590 8 ай бұрын
Love this ship
@damongraham1398
@damongraham1398 2 ай бұрын
To put a fine point on it. I love this idea. Yes, I understand Starfleet's main mission is exploration. Sometimes you have to kick a$$. Ummmm, how would the Lower Decks crew handle being in charge of an Interceptor class starship. Mariner as captain. Boimler as 1st officer. Tendi as Chief Medical officer. Rutherford as Chief Engineer. I would like a Caitan as the Security Officer. A dolphin at the helm
@HeadlessChickenTO
@HeadlessChickenTO 8 ай бұрын
The main drawback of the Defiant as an attack ship, seems to be more about range than anything else. Its ability to take hits while delivering devistating firepower overshadows its lack of maneuverability. But not being able to do so far from friendly support and infrastructure is the Defiant's greatest weakness, probably a product of it's anti-Borg design principle. The Intercepter class looks to have some range and independant operation features, noting the aft shuttle bay and variable warp geometry. And not having purely forward firing archs feels like a more generalized combat vessel with more wngagement options.
@spencerjones841
@spencerjones841 8 ай бұрын
The interceptor class looks like a design that has a lot more uses in peacetime in terms of being a more balanced design and being able to be out in space for a longer period of time than the defiant which is useful for say patrol work
@rueceless7580
@rueceless7580 5 ай бұрын
Cant say I agree the Defiant is less manoeuvrable, the ship is shown to easily able to keep up with other attack ships in DS9 sometimes even out manoeuvring them on screen.
@montithered4741
@montithered4741 8 ай бұрын
Considering how mass produced the Excelsior and Miranda class were, a smaller, modernized version fusing features of these two ships would suit the aggressive recon/attack ships. Consider how many people in the federation would be familiar with the layout, systems, and interface of the Miranda and Excelsior ships. Additionally, retired or separated members of starfleet with experience on Miranda and Excelsior ships could quickly, easily, and simply be pressed into service as instructors and trainers for FNG crews. Plus, I think it could throw off opponents thinking they were going against an old Miranda or Excelsior ship only to be surprised by a barrage of heavy fire from these smaller, faster, more heavily armed vessels.
@charlesw5919
@charlesw5919 8 ай бұрын
It is kind of strange. In their conflicts with the Klingons and Romulans, Star Fleet had to deal with very effective attack ships, but never developed their own.
@fbi805
@fbi805 8 ай бұрын
so basically the interceptor class would be a WW 2 torpedo boat but on a larger scale. I still prefer the Defiant simply because it could be adapted to mission requirements and still be able to kick the crap out anything getting in its way.
@charlesterry2480
@charlesterry2480 6 күн бұрын
The defiant class WAS the attack ship. Limited crew, heavily armed and armored fast and manuverable this isn't brain surgery she was designed to FIGHT
@Blackrook32
@Blackrook32 8 ай бұрын
@Venom Geek Media 98: I find your theories about the Interceptor class very interesting. I'm going to flesh this out, in a hardpoint model in Bridge Commander.
@Lookthere167
@Lookthere167 8 ай бұрын
The defiant is very very maneuverable And the words you were searching for was a front line breaching attack vessel.. Did you actually watch ds9?
@paulzy5192
@paulzy5192 8 ай бұрын
Exactly! I was thinking the same thing as there is not other large ship out there that can outmanuever the Defiant.
@edwardbell4928
@edwardbell4928 Ай бұрын
You might consider an overview of the DILIGENT-class which is multi-role destroyer escort...and a fan design. Let me know if your interested...
@jonbonda1917
@jonbonda1917 8 ай бұрын
Wonder if this was mass produced during the Ent-C's Yesterday's Enterprise alternate timeline as a stripped down Nova class heavy corvette. Imagine a squadron of them each being able to cloak, initially based on Kirk's BOP as well as having the standard photon/plasma(Romulan) torpedo launcher tech. Since it''s bigger than a BOP, it could have two of the Plasma torpedo launcher tubes that can fire forward&aft, one attached to each nacelles since it won't have that variable warp pylons. Can function as a heavy plasma mortar and pulse plasma torpedo launcher. Also imagine if Kirk had this, he'd use this to travel back in time.
@ycplum7062
@ycplum7062 8 ай бұрын
I know this video is on teh Interceptor, but I would like to propose a different perspective on the Defiant. The Defiant is a pure attack ship, but one specialize for the borg. Attack ships ae analogous to PT boats (or WW II) or fast missile patrol boats of today. Their strategy involves distributed firepower because the enemy can very easily destroy even the most powerful of Federation ships. By distributing the firepower among many small ships, teh loss of one ship does not result in the loss all your firepower. Also, while teh borg seems to have very powerful weapons, the number of targets they can train on at any one time is limited. Of course, you still need a ship that can survive at least a few seconds when captured by a borg tractor beam (which and altornat attraction and repulsion to shake a vessel apart) and it needs to carry weapons sufficiently powerful enough to do more than annoy a Borg cube. Ergo, the Defiant. In many ways, the Defiant is basically a destroyer miniaturized. It needs to be highly automated because there is no room for living quarters for a large crew. There are no facilities (sci labs, holodecks, extra storage, etc.) that is not geared toward fighting the Borg. However, it retains the firepower and the armor (concentrated to protect a smaller ship) of a destroyer. Whereas other Federation ships operate at 90% to minimize wear and tear for a prolong service life, the Defiant sesms to be constantly operating at 120%, much like a PT boat or modern missile boat. Their mission is not to survive, but simply to get off all their torpedoes/missiles before getting destroyed. Of course, when the opponent is not the Borg, some of its attack boat characteristics gets lost.
@lynngreen7978
@lynngreen7978 8 ай бұрын
You just read off the dimensions, and I'm already declaring this a failure. Bird of Prey - Crew 12 (in the 23rd Century, may be less now) Hideki - Crew 5 Tirethi - Crew 5 Jem'Hadar Attack Ship - Crew 4 As a half-sized Intrepid, this is going to have a crew of 1/3-1/2 the Intrepid, so 50-75. Too many people for a one hit kill.
@venomgeekmedia9886
@venomgeekmedia9886 8 ай бұрын
Well a BOP would generally be 36 a full hideki would be like 50. But your getting a lot more capability with this larger crew
@tjfm59
@tjfm59 8 ай бұрын
i am a torpedo heavy fan, always have been. made mods to the nova deck 4 & 5. got rid of the probes. added more storage space on decks 4 & 5, along with 4 more torpedo launchers. 2 in the lower hull. the other 2 just forward of the reaction control thrustors, for a total of 6. main reason is torpedos are energy effiecent.
@lyinarbaeldeth2456
@lyinarbaeldeth2456 5 ай бұрын
I do love seeing fanon ships, but I feel compelled to point out there *was* a cheaper, more easily produced, etc etc alternative to the Defiant. It was the Sabre.
@jimmyjohnjames6397
@jimmyjohnjames6397 8 ай бұрын
The Defiant IS an attack ship. It eas just designed to attack the Borg. Also money and affordability aren't issues with the Federation. They are almost post scarcity.
@patrickjames8050
@patrickjames8050 8 ай бұрын
And it is a damned sexy beast.
@barrybend7189
@barrybend7189 8 ай бұрын
Instead of the Interceptor maybe refitted Nova class ships would be better. Similar scale but bigger than the defiant and can safely house the Defiant warp core without downsides.
@SteveBlewett
@SteveBlewett 8 ай бұрын
The Odyssey galaxy class was surviving despite no shields. Only the ramming to it down. How much intel did the changelings get to know a weak point? The interceptor is very interesting. Would the nacelle struts swing both up and down? Even mid warp flight. How Venom Geek Media 98 posits the warp coils relation to the rest of the ship matters, that makes it very, very interesting.
@jonbonda1917
@jonbonda1917 8 ай бұрын
Loved this Federation's version of BOP design. It has the space to have the Klingon's plasma/torpedo launcher. Thought that if this was developed in the Delta Quadrant by the Voyager crew, it would be a rebuilt Nova class(Equinox) with a Hirogen Hunter ship especially with the Hirogen weapons. I always assumed that the Hirogen not only used their Transceiver Communication Relay Network to spy on their prey but they also used it to travel between each nodes by something similar to a graviton catapult or geodesic fold that doesn't melt its crew. As an alternative to the Interceptor class or Fed BOP type ship, there's the Wallace class escort. Just needs extra armor&weapons. Post Borg Invasion of Sector001, liked the original version of the Saber class as an attack ship instead of a research/utility light ship like for the Starfleet Corps of Engineers. Also what about a squadron of the Interceptor class using their tractor beams&warp fields to do a Gungnir maneuver by carrying a coronal mass ejection&dragging that stellar plasma in warp and dumping that mass of plasma to a battlefield like a tsunami. Imagine some squadrons coming from different vectors dumping a mass of CME plasma in warp to crash into the Dominion/Cardassian lines like a tsunami. Smaller Jem'Hadar&Hideki ships would be destroyed by that wave of coronal plasma while the larger enemy ships' would be weaken. This will also flood the battlespace to expose any cloaked mines or ships. Actually this would be a great tactic to use against the DS9's wormhole or Chintoka minefields
@davidreeves4556
@davidreeves4556 8 ай бұрын
I like the use of the word "Bespoke" there Venom.
@venomgeekmedia9886
@venomgeekmedia9886 8 ай бұрын
thought you might ;)
@shanenolan5625
@shanenolan5625 8 ай бұрын
Cheers
@Wedgekree
@Wedgekree 8 ай бұрын
On the 'strength' of ships - doesn't the base Klingon Bird of Prey have a crew of ~ 20? Or is there another type of the same general class of ship being used as the main Klingon strike craft for comparison?
@pleb7612
@pleb7612 8 ай бұрын
really cool ship. wish it was in STO
@TheEDFLegacy
@TheEDFLegacy 8 ай бұрын
I think it would make more sense to adapt the Defiant design so that some are built like the Defiant in the show, but others lack the armor and leading-edge technology that makes the main class such a pain to operate, in a package that is both easier and cheaper to operate, and can use a more traditional warp core in exchange for a slightly slower warp speed. I think it could work.
@Hartzilla2007
@Hartzilla2007 8 ай бұрын
Honestly it always felt like after the DS9 crew worked the bugs out of the original it wasn't that problematic any more since nothing really pointed to the other versions being stripped down and idiot cadets were able to operate one for months without blowing up. Its just that was about the time they got weird about having more than one of the hero ship class on screen.
@jessicacolegrove4152
@jessicacolegrove4152 8 ай бұрын
We all know that the interceptors will be tasked with watchdoging Cali class ships
@DocWolph
@DocWolph 8 ай бұрын
The Interceptor appears to suffer from a being the type of Multi-role vessel that has no clear position in the fleet. It is the willful arrogance of Starfleet to build a smaller explorer vessel. During the Dominion War, the Interceptor would certainly be outfitted for combat. But as soon a the war is over the ships would be disarmed and used for explorers. Considering that threats and dangers can literally jump out of no where without warning, it is unwise to have effective combat vessels disarmed just because the skies are currently clear. And we all know this will happen because "How dare Starfleet be prepared for Hell and High Water". The Interceptor would do best being in retinue of a larger command ship, flying in formation with a Galaxy, Sovereign, or Odyssey class, utilizing the Command/Mother ship's facilities to extend the smaller ships over all range and endurance. This also extends the defensive field of the Command/Mother ship as the interceptor can INTERCEPT incoming threats or at least seeing coming patrolling just beyond the Command/mother ship's sensor range but still within communications range. This is something already done with USN Carrier fleets with aircraft extending well beyond the carrier fleet's range to see.
@wolfcraft484
@wolfcraft484 3 ай бұрын
with it's size im honestly thinking Corvette classification real world example would be the Visby class, rather then the flower class which is a slow anti submarine vessel
@pcheintz7264
@pcheintz7264 8 ай бұрын
I've always loved this particular fan created vessel... Starfleet had really let most of its smaller classes to rot over the years leading into the TNG era. I agree in your assessment in attack vessels. I would go so far as to say the Federation really should have concentrated in producing more war oriented smaller classes of ships as soon as they thought they would be in a serious war with someone whom could take out a Galaxy class with 3 ships under 100m long. I do disagree with some of your views on the defiant. As the federation does seem to have been able to produce more of them given the one episode we saw on Valiant... Ships on lower end of size spectrum (
@fallofthewall4661
@fallofthewall4661 8 ай бұрын
i am sure the Prometheus was classed as an attack ship, granted it was large for attack ships, granted its more of an attack cruiser than a corvette which most attack ships are but the fact it split into 3 when attacking it kinda turns from 1 cruiser to 3 large attack ships. defiant class is more of a blockade runner/smasher. also with ST where the idea of money is a thing of the past what do you mean by cost? with mass replicators that makes elements from scratch using protons neutrons and electrons cost in materials is a mute point.
@NCC-72545A
@NCC-72545A 8 ай бұрын
Axios to the Intrepid class Light Destroyers
@benrogers7935
@benrogers7935 Ай бұрын
The only thing that could make this ship better is for them to make the interceptor class canon
@ultramarinus2478
@ultramarinus2478 8 ай бұрын
Was always a bit surprised, why the starfleet (who does not used raiders at that time), did not utilize simply overwhelming numbers of runaboats, modified for war. Runaboats are probably dirt-cheap and extremely manuevurable and with quicker sublight engines in comparision to Defiant, and in the same tonnage, much more durable AND stronger punching than Akiaze. Shape of Interceptor class is beautifull. Size is extremely overshot. Would be much better, if it is in between 3/4s or 1/2 of Defiant. Lets say lenght equivalent of 4 runaboats behind each other, with 3 runaboats behind each other, height 3 decks tops (in the thickest area). Warpcore, similarily like on runaboat, designed to be in horizontal position, but unlike runaboat protected by armour, in the midle of secondary hull. The warp naccels should be foldable into the secondary hull too, to protect them in combat, by some decent armour.
@myalterego9661
@myalterego9661 6 ай бұрын
The Defaint was by no means the worst of the attack ships. That definately goes to either the Hideki or the Romulan "attack ship". From a pure combat perspective there is no doubt in my mind that the Defaint outclassed all other ships in the "attack ship" category. It's extremely heavily armed - More so than any other ship in the category. It's highly maneauverable at impulse - Only challanged by the Bird of Prey. It's able to take a beating normally reserved to ships in the cruiser or battleship category. However it also wasn't the best ship in that category either. Despite being less powerful in terms of weaponry, the best in class definately goes to the Bird of Prey. The shortcomings of the Defaint are speed at warp, endurance, utility in peacetime and living conditions. Lack of peacetime utility basically relegates the ship to patrol-duty or worst case cargo-duty. With a maximum speed of warp 9 (O'Brian overhaul) and the poor living conditions, it would make for a pretty poor patrol ship, since most Federation ships would be able to outrun it (And I therefore assume most of the Federations neighbours also have faster ships) and it would get rather limited patrol time due to taking longer to get to and from the patrol area, and most of the crew would request transfers pretty quickly if the patrols were longer than 1-3 months. Furthermore the lack of scientific facilities "may" put the Defaint at a disadvantage near - Lets say the Romulan neutral zone, since it may have a harder time detecting ships using stealth measures not previously seen. As such it would make perfect sense for the Federation to take what they learned from the Defaint, and the anti-Borg fleet in general, and put it towards and general purpose patrol ship, that is also very fast to allow it to actually function as an interceptor. In my opinion the best use of the Defaint class, post-Dominion war, would be to have a 3-6 of them at major starbases as an additional layer of defense, within the Federation (Not at the border). The ships wouldn't be permanently crewed, rather taking on starbase personal as needed, and would be used for policing action when better options weren't around (Instead of using runabouts). And when a major threat was to show up there would be more time to group Defaints from multiple starbases into a dangerous defensive pack to protect key assets (Like ship yards or key colonies), despite their lower maximum warp.
@jamessullivan7692
@jamessullivan7692 8 ай бұрын
Always appreciate the videos the Interceptor class seems to be quite well thought out like a good idea however I think you're a bit hard on the defiant-class some of the things that you had said about the defiant-class does not seem to be the case at least from the DS9 shows I would equate the defiant-class to an animal here on Earth known as the honey badger even Lions think twice before they engage the honey badger and usually decided just to leave it alone honey badger screw with me I'll show you what you coming to get defiant I'm going to cram it down your throat
@user-bo7ws4bq8c
@user-bo7ws4bq8c 8 ай бұрын
I dunno if you’ve thought about this or plan on doing a battle space episode, but what exactly happened at the battle of Denobula? Cuz I’m still curious how an unsupported dominion fleet caught and surrounded in a salient was able to successfully defeat the federation’s most elite fleet while defending a HOMEWORLD, and then managing to successfully drive that fleet down an entire sector
@thomasvaldez8566
@thomasvaldez8566 8 ай бұрын
I always have wondered why in the galaxy a Defiant class was used to train cafets when Defiants needed an experienced crew to be usedpeoperly.
@venomgeekmedia9886
@venomgeekmedia9886 8 ай бұрын
That's red squad for you... but yeah a saber would have been better
@jimmyjohnjames6397
@jimmyjohnjames6397 8 ай бұрын
The Defiant was a prototype. The following production models fixed it's issues.
@_robustus_
@_robustus_ Ай бұрын
Love spearhead saucers but don’t cut notches in it. Just move the nacelles out or back.
A Return To Form? The Vor'kang Class
23:33
Venom Geek Media 98
Рет қаралды 45 М.
New Inquiry Variation Class Starships
13:02
Certifiably Ingame
Рет қаралды 150 М.
I’m just a kid 🥹🥰 LeoNata family #shorts
00:12
LeoNata Family
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
MEGA BOXES ARE BACK!!!
08:53
Brawl Stars
Рет қаралды 34 МЛН
The Fastest Starship is Half Engine, The Protostar Class
11:29
Certifiably Ingame
Рет қаралды 117 М.
The BETTER Galaxy-class? USS ROSS - Star Trek Explained
10:48
Trek Central
Рет қаралды 126 М.
TOS Battleships?
18:07
Venom Geek Media 98
Рет қаралды 42 М.
The Better Battleship? The Saber Class
7:40
Certifiably Ingame
Рет қаралды 73 М.
Battlespace 'The Cardassian Border War' Battle of Minos Corva
20:48
Venom Geek Media 98
Рет қаралды 135 М.
The tiny Rebel ship absolutely NOT to be trifled with
5:54
EckhartsLadder
Рет қаралды 235 М.
Why Didn't Starfleet Command Use Starfighters? | Star Trek
4:38
The Templin Institute
Рет қаралды 112 М.
5 маусым соңғы эфир!
2:27:27
QosLike / ҚосЛайк / Косылайық
Рет қаралды 333 М.
Добейти 100000 подписчиков | Тгк- @Rom4ik539
0:28
Парковка ТАКСИ от клоуна!
0:22
Клаунхаус Kids
Рет қаралды 1,3 МЛН
когда повзрослела // EVA mash
0:40
EVA mash
Рет қаралды 2,9 МЛН
Funny cat woke up early 😂👻🥳
0:38
Ben Meryem
Рет қаралды 4,7 МЛН
Живые куклы и злая племянница! Часть 3! #shorts
0:35