If Luke Skywalker fought Ahsoka Tano in a one-on-one confrontation. Who would come out on top? Special thanks to Dudufilm for a wonderful intro! 1:26 - Character Introductions 5:01 - Round 1: Physical Abilities 9:30 - Round 2: Force Abilities 14:20 - Round 3: Dueling Abilities 22:35 - The Final Verdict Check out the Star Wars Versus Series kzfaq.info/get/bejne/qd-CdLNjvrW5qH0.html Check out the Which Series! kzfaq.info/sun/PLDFq63aBi3_yGAJNwozcKYs0OfmgMiqu-

Luke: Who are you? Ahsoka: I'm the first padawan of Anakin Sky- Luke: WHY DOES NOBODY TELL ME ANYTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I don't believe this. I'm going for ending 3: Ashoka adopts Luke and takes him out for blue milk ice cream.

I feel like they would just become friends

"Then, I will avenge his death." "Revenge is not the Jedi way" " *BOI I LEFT* Im no Jedi..."

Ahsoka befriends Luke and she trains him, that's how I want it to end.

Not gonna lie... that intro from DuduFilm brought tears to my eyes... absolutely, jaw-droppingly beautiful. This is a very hard match to call, but I agree with you, I might give the slight edge to Ahsoka. It could easily go either way though.

I agree that this match would be a toss up as both are extremely talented but I feel that Ahsoka is a tad underrated as a duelist and contender as a whole. I mean she dueled Maul(oh you know, the guy who contended against DARTH SIDIOUS) to a standstill when she was 17. That's extremely young to be dueling a seasoned MASTER who has killed many other Jedi but she's had a long time to grow since then, her abilities were insane when she was a teenager so honestly she is amazing now. And again in her fights with the inquisitors she beat them in like 2 minutes. That's a really short time for a duel especially since she overcame them so easily. And again she is underrated in her fight with Vader. She is fighting him in a place that is extremely charged with the dark side and after their duel Vader is shown to be heavily injured, limping away from the temple. But another thing that you tend to overlook is Ahsoka's key attribute. Her real strength is her precision, not her speed. In TCW it was her staple mark but she has grown since then and has continued to incorporate it into her style yet now her staple is her precision. In her duels with the inquisitors and Maul she is shown to fight quickly yet her precision is what wins the day against the inquisitors. And in her duel with Maul(which we didn't see finished) she's matching him quickly yet each blow from him has a counter attack from her and you can see her pushing him back. Ahsoka has become a much more powerful and balanced dueler than she is given credit for.

If the two met, Ahsoka would be the level of Master while Luke is just starting to be a Knight.

Third option. They don’t fight instead Ahsoka tells Luke stories about Anakin and they just chill out.

Dave Filoni would give Ahsoka a 10/0 advantage.

Luke had a strong force power called plot defence strongest of them all you cant be killed only injured but ashoka was removable but stronger one and she can't kill vader becaose of plot defence

The very fact that this is a debate just shows how much the fans really love Ahsoka and that just makes me so happy.

4:20 "...and then miserablely failing" well played antoine

I Honestly cant decide on who the victor should be imo. The specific circumstance of the fight and the environment would decide this

If Togrutas could sense people around them. When Anakin stabbed Shaak Ti. Why didn't she just run or something?

I just want to let you know that I'm truly truly grateful for this video and all the work you put into this Star Wars is my favorite show and you put together Luke and Ahsoka two of my favorite characters that I have wonder about if they had ever fought. I'm thankful for your hard work truly thankful please keep up the best work you deliver to us.

what would actually happen according to Rian Johnson: -Luke gets sad. -Luke gets depressed. -Luke Squeezes a alien titty. -Luke drinks some alien milk. -Luke sends his force ghost into fight for him. -Dies.

This outcome makes sense. Luke's adaptability to Ahsoka Tano's novel style is too speculative.

Congrats on a beautiful video , it was a pleasure working with you! May The Force Serve You Well @ahsokalives

If we took in the first canon (or Legends) then Luke would have like the most unfair advantage EVAR!

I really think the fight would end in a draw, neither managing a definitive win and ending in a truce. Unlike Vader or Anakin, their strength is their compassion, not just combative skill.

There was only one person Luke truly feared, that was Luke.

I personally disagree that Luke fought the better version of Vader. Vader was way past his prime and no amount of force augmentation would get him to the strength and speed during revenge of the sith. And since that is closer to Ahsoka’s fight with Vader it is actually quite obvious that Ashoka faced the more powerful Vader, at least when it came to dueling. Also when it came to dueling abilities Luke was fighting someone with the same form while Ahsoka was fighting her counter form. This shows that Ahsoka has enough skill to hold her own, at least for a while, against her own counter form. Like has not shown this.

so, pure legends Luke wins? since most of us here seem to care more about legends...

Lmao I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks the way they're portraying Luke in the new trilogy is meh. Good video. I too am not really sure who'd win, though I'd probably favour Luke due to bias.

As always, wonderful video!

“And then miserably failing *big sigh*” 😂😂😂 hilarious! He didn’t fail though.

Look, she is basically a Sentinel, with her quick fighting prowess, connected with form IV and starkiller style fighting, with a reverse grip and 2 light sabers.

Ashoka would completely overwhelm Luke in the early-fight. Easily a 2-0. Ashoka would use her feigns and acrobatics to quickly slice down a learning Luke. In addition, Luke would be so focused on her lightsaber style that Ashoka could get an opportunity to turn off his blades or disarm him early by way of the force (something Luke has yet to experience). In the mid-fight, I see Ashoka holding a 4-2 lead. She would begin to integrate force based attacks and physical strikes against Luke. This could open up a few opportunities to succeed. However, Luke would begin to tank the physical attacks, using the endurance training by Yoda, but struggle with the force being integrated. After Vader used the force, he moved more methodically against Luke, giving him opportunities to regain composure in their fights. As seen in the Bespin fight, Vader, despite slamming Luke with caroming environmental objects, did not attempt to end Luke when he had the opportunity. On the contrary, Ashoka would chain her force based attacks seamlessly and then immediately pressure or assault Luke before he had time to look up and readjust. Finally, we do not know how Luke would even react to Jar'kai. If her speed wasn't enough to disorientate Luke, her wielding a second blade would amplify the pace of the conflict. In the end-fight, Luke would get an easy 2-0 victory. As a result of the prolonged conflict, her speed and strength behind attacks would be hindered. Luke would deflect nearly all of her attacks while retaliating with heavy, yet quick, strikes that Ashoka could not deal with, as a result of her weakened defenses and flawed Ataru style. The only argument that could be made to downplay Luke in the late fight, would be how he would not yield the same passion and rage he did against Vader in their final fight. Without being tempted with the dark side (and fighting against a holding back Vader), he might not have the same result against Ashoka. I think Ashoka would win. Being forged by the harshest war in all of the Star Wars universe and directly being trained by the most powerful force wielder that existed, has its benefits. Luke would simply be overwhelmed by her speed and integration of both the physical and force attacks. In addition, she has shown the ability to adapt against foes from the quick and speedy, Ventress, to the methodical and powerful, Vader, while Luke simply lacked experience against anything but his father. edit: grammatical and punctuation mistakes

That intro is spectacular, that it pertains to two of my favorite Star Wars characters is just a bonus

Great video, Antoine! Very nuanced and well-thought-out.

The apprentice vs the son

Seeing these two meet in any way shape or form. Would be the best thing ever

Holy shit, that opening though! Damn impressive editing. Bravo!

I honestly think this is your greatest vs video yet! I agree that this is very much a coin toss, and I'm glad it didn't end in a tie. This was a great matchup. Keep up the great work!

Luke's weapon was compassion. TLJ: hold me beer #notmylukeskywalker

I asked two of my friends who would win this fight and both could not decide

By far the toughest versus video you've done. You did not disappoint. Bravo.

This is one of your finest video that you have made Antione. 2 Characters are evenly match makes this even more interesting. Also, the intro is truly magnificent.

Ahsoka now has more feats from season 7 plus the fact that as strong as Luke is Ahsoka has years and years more training than Luke which I think means Ahsoka takes this fight overall. Though like everyone else I love the idea of these two just being friends xp

Rebels Ahsoka Vs Clone Wars Ventress, do it

Wow! What a match up! Wow! Great video. This might become one of my favorites

This is my favorite Video from you Bro,all your Videos are great,but this Video speaks to my soul.

At first my gut reaction went to Luke, but that was mostly because I'm so used to the plot armor being in favor of Skywalkers. If you pretend they're both no-name characters, I agree on Ahsoka's VERY narrow victory

That was awesome. Great timing on this matchup since the mobile game, Star Wars Galaxy of Heroes, is about to release an adult (Fulcrum) Ahsoka, with the highly anticipated Jedi Luke expected real soon.

Whoo! That was a totally badass opening! You're getting really good those!

That intro was amazing! So many feels

Very happy since Ahsoka rarely seems to win. I've always found her to be a much more interesting character than Luke. He's easier to identify and sympathize with I guess but still not as interesting in my humble opinion.

Best KZfaq intro I've ever seen.

My Bro the opening music sets the tone for the video. It sets you up for the video by getting the heart pumping. Outstanding!!!

nice video also I saw that nod to Exar kun can't wait for that

*EPIC* Ahsoka vs. Luke Intro!!! 0:22-1:26

Another great video as always, especially since this features arguably the two greatest heroes in all of Star Wars. I'm also happy that Ahsoka won (since she's my all-time favourite Star Wars character), but I definitely think Luke is good enough that this would be a close match.

Great job Antoine!

Amazing video, really smart!

That intro is beautiful

Theoretically, Vader was so slow in ANH out of caution

Wow! What an opening!! 👏👏👏

YAY I'VE BEEN HOPING FOR THIS VIDEO ^_^

When you sighed at the end of Luke's bio I was like yep that sums me up as well

You just earned a sub! Though I feel like from all your videos you favor people over me! p.s im 5'8 not 5'6!

Could you do a Dark Empire Palpatine vs Valkorion please??? Also love your videos. You've given such a unique and informative outlook on these series. Also could you do a McGonagall vs Bellatrix vs video as well?

Wow Antoine! And to think that about 6 months ago I thought your videos couldn't get any better. But Yoda vs Revan (as "obvious" as it was) and this one have really surpassed your past videos. With the "new" intros and the variation of music you've made your videos feel like more than just a half hour rant. Nice work, Antoine, and I agree that Ahsoka would win.

Also guys think about this the original trilogy was made on the 80s so they could do as many flips but in a cartoon they can make it look like a better fight

bruh, anakin's 6'2

This was an awesome video, man! I think I watched it before but sometimes you can't fully appreciate these things until you've watched them a few times. It's really hard to judge the legacy character's actual skill levels due to the limitations of when the original movies were made. According to the novelization, Vader got better (somehow) between Episodes IV and VI yet he is still slower and much less refined of a fighter than what we've seen in canonical things that occurred BEFORE Episode IV (like Rogue One and Rebels). The books and context of the fights would have us believe that we are seeing something truly epic but what I actually SAW wasn't super impressive so I honestly don't know how to call it. Really, I think I need to see some new canonical showing of Luke fighting against other force sensitives post Episode VI (but not super far into the future) to get an idea of how good of a fighter he's supposed to be in canon. Seeing him in Episode 8 won't necessarily do anything as this will be "Old Luke" and we want to know how truly great he was in his prime.

The Mini rant insert was funny AF!🤣🤣🤣

I think that their battle would be almost exactly like Anakin vs Ventress.

Okay so this is actually a tough one for me as well I feel like this is what I like to refer to as a Batman situation. If this were not a singular fight to the death Luke could probably come back and kick her ass but in a one-on-one fight with both of them trying to end each other I think Ahsoka wins due to a combination of her fighting style and overall personality she's more willing to kill someone then Luke is. now that said regardless of whether this is round 1 round 2 or singular fight to the death it's going to be a rough fight for both of them

Thank you for doing my suggestion, I do also think it would be very close but by a very small margin, I have to go with Luke because of his raw force power and as you said, the longer it goes on, the greater advantage Luke has; and I certainly don't see this ending quickly... so battered and bruised, I personally believe Luke would win. Still, great video! :)

haven't started watching the rest, just gotta say, that intro though...goosebumps. as always, quality content. been with you since anakin vs starkiller (whenever that was) and you've quickly taken the place as my favorite KZfaq nerd ranter. edit: just finished. again I say great content. maybe a crossover sometime? Wolverine vs Urai Fenn, both have a healing factor, and urai fenn's blades (going off of shotty early 2000s game machanics) seem to be made of either cortosis or phrik, since I beat the emperor with him in Empire at War.

Thank the lord you didn't use God-tier-Luke-knows-everything legends version. Using experienced Ahsoka and the still new but gifted prodigy Luke was a good match up, I honestly leaned toward Luke but I see how Ahsoka could've blitzed him with speed and experience. I'm glad Snips got the win this round. She earned it.

I listened to all of this, and it truly feels like it just screamed one thing "Plot Armor". Be it Vader, Anakin, or Luke. Luke *is* adaptable, but has always lacked the ability to finish things, as you said he uses compassion. You also mentioned Aikido, in my personal opinion, a person with 2 blades, force abilities, more experience, sleight of hand tactics mixed with speed *and* the note that she uses her enemies inertia against them, hence you have stated multiple times that Luke and Anakin both use *power* strikes. I love the Skywalker's as much as the next guy, but in practicality I truly see her skill set to be above both of them. However, I never agreed with the idea of Vader being a better duelist than Anakin, he was a hell of a lot slower and had to rely on the force imo to make up for his loss of mobility, though I feel his spanking for his prior arrogance did teach him to respect his opponents to some degree. Just an opinion, and only because I felt that your descriptions spelled out a clear win for Ashoka by the fact that she used more than enough tactics to get the job done as well as her entire style was the antithesis of their fighting style, unless Luke refrained from that and shifted into defense, which even then I do believe misdirection and her various methods as a whole would prevail, unless plot armor were to take effect.

This may be one of my favorite of your video so far, nice work. Also quick Question: While I agree Asohka had better martial experience wouldn't' Luke have picked up some fighting experience and moves during his years in the Rebellion? He was on the front lines most of the time.

This is what I'm being waiting for me :)

I think overall I agree. I think in the early fight Ashoka's speed and duel saber technique would give Luke a hard time... and if Ashoka scored a hit before Luke can adapt... well... that's it.

Bruh I just want the legends universe to make a comeback. Gimme Mara Jade, Jaina Solo, and HK-47 back

Love this close match up! Just wanted to ask if you'd do a Lightsabre Form episode for the Warden/Orochi/Kensei/Peacekeeper from For Honor, just to branch out a little bit from Star Wars, as this has HUGE potential :D

This is one hell of an opening. By the way, I took one look at the title of this video and immediately though Luke would curb stomp Ahsoka. Then I saw you where using him only up to Return of the Jedi, and was happy to see that this would actually be a fight.

I honestly think Luke should've won. He can adapt to things like that, and when he does, it helps him grow.

I feel like the two would just going to a draw at least based on their characters. Would totally like to see Revan vs Anakin. The Prodigal Knight vs the Chosen One.

4:28 LOL You earned the like with that shade alone, man!

done very well. great video. i agree with the outcome the only real advantage is the experience. what i wonder is with both of their force empathy would they even fight?

Me: *sees title* LOL AHSOKA ALL DAYY

Personally, I think Luke has the edge due to his insane reflexes and speed tracking. I don’t think Luke’s feat against non-force sensitives makes him any less impressive, he’s got way too good reflexes

Bravo, man. Let me just say, Antoine as a long-time subscriber, this matchup is easily one of my favorites you have done. And I have to give props to DuduFilm for helping you. You two should do more collaborations. :) Thematically, I love this battle due to how similar, yet different the two are. As for a verdict, I can understand how difficult this could be. And I do agree with you. Luke clearly did not experience Jar Kai dual blades. And while I am confident he could adapt to it, I do not think at the point he was at where he could have adapted as fast. Give us say Luke a few years down the line and in is prime, that is a different story. Also, I always pegged Ahsoka's style as like a leaf blowing in the wind. She always met power and force by deflecting it, circumventing it and getting in critical attacks. And with Luke, while I see him adapting to Ahsoka's style, her experience at the end of the day was going to get her through due to having fought a myriad of opponents during war time. Luke, simply put, did have a hard battle. But against one(arguably two, if you include the Emperor) enemy. A VERY powerful enemy, but still that conditioning and fighting tunnel vision are evident.

Haven't even watched the video yet but I already dropped a like🤙

Luke was a strong Jedi but ultimately was trained by himself while Ashoka was trained by the greatest Jedi Knight in the order at the time.

I heard you changed your original verdict, like, hours ago. I would have gone with that original verdict personally but I do understand how folks would neglect to consider how difficult it would be for Luke to adapt to Ahsoka when all his dueling experiences revolved around Vader.

Awesome vid between two of my favorite characters! Tough call, but I must agree with the Ahsoka win. Luke has a much more limited duelling skill set (at least in Canon) whereas Ahsoka has a more varied range of opponents going back decades. Had to go back to the beginning as well to rewatch that epic intro. Just an overall great matchup. Look forward to more. (Still disagree with you about Padme though) ;-)

Awesome intro

You forget that like tapped into the dark side when fighting Vader. Ashoka never tapped into the dark side

I actually agree with this. It would be a amazing fight but, I do think Ahsoka would win due to her formal training and experience.

This is actually a really interesting matchup.

Personally for a future versus series video, I'd like to suggest Return of the Jedi Luke Skywalker vs Qui-Gon Jinn. Though this video was well constructed and I do see Return of the Jedi Luke Skywalker and Ahsoka Tano as a very even match up for each other as well. Again great video.

I thing Ashoka would win first confrontation. Due Luke lack of experience against dual wielders, but would be able win rematch.

have to go with Ahsoka Tano for sure

ok dude, totally get why it boggled u this time!! can understand ur arguments on both sides, possibly this one should of been that draw i've been waiting for, but yeah, i can get with giving it to Ahsoka under those circumstances

next time hamill is interviewed he should be asked to try a young luke voice.