No video

《無間道》Vs《無間道風雲》(二):大幅度加強人物性格和處境刻劃,堵塞了原版劇本漏洞 【只要有電影】第196集(2023-18-01)

  Рет қаралды 2,371

只要有電影

只要有電影

Күн бұрын

《無間道》Vs《無間道風雲》(二):大幅度加強人物性格和處境刻劃,堵塞了原版劇本漏洞
【只要有電影】第196集(2023-18-01)
William Monahan的劇本首先把背景設定了在波士頓,強調了傳統愛爾蘭哥倫布騎士會與本地黑幫的衝突,增強了故事的實感;一方面吸收了原版的優點(雙重臥底的橋段、部分出人意表的情節編排與設計),另一方面則大幅度強化了每個人物的性格與歷史(特別是梁朝偉/迪卡比奧一角,合理化了他被選中做黑幫臥底的理由),有的一分為二(原版黃秋生一角),也有二合為一(鄭秀文與陳慧琳),目的皆旨在堵塞原劇本的一些漏洞,加強衝突和戲劇性,甚至把主題從原版的宗教意味提升到哲學的層次,又不失政治性的諷喻(「整個國家都滿是耗子(意即臥底、奸細)」)…
--------------------------
攝影:林卓謙
硬照攝影:Sam Ng
片頭設計: 葉思進
剪接: 陳衍誥
協力:林澤秋
--------------------------
【只有有電影】
★每逢星期一、三、五晚上9時推出
敬請訂閱本KZfaq頻道
#無間道 #TheDeparted #馬田史高西斯 #MartinScorsese #只要有電影 #電影
Follow 舒琪 Facebook:
/ mikio.scorsese.7
《只要有電影》Facebook:
/ filmsandnothingelse
及《只要有電影》Facebook Group:
/ 401881517991228
All videos on my channel are only used for commentary.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.

Пікірлер: 8
@jono77
@jono77 Жыл бұрын
Btw呢個channel好睇過文雋1000陪, 就好似departed vs 無間道
@jono77
@jono77 Жыл бұрын
The Departed was just a lot more realistic where it needed to be realistic.
@ginnytsang3035
@ginnytsang3035 4 ай бұрын
The bar scene in 無間道風雲 was overdoing, which I prefer the subtle version of 無間道, l ook at Tony and Mr. Tsang. The little moment and the real faking LINES over Tony face is "falessness". Dicabinoo needed a distance shoot.
@billylmtam
@billylmtam Жыл бұрын
根本係橙同蘋果既比較 始終錢同導演都唔同級數 買左劇本返黎改亦可以補足好多之前劇本既漏洞,編劇點都有睇過港版,馬田史高西斯冇根本唔係問題,佢既黑幫片有佢既模式,張力都唔同 另外港產片得90分鐘,唔可以講粗口太暴力變3級 美版改好劇本有2個半鐘咁可以解釋好多港版不足既事,又可以玩盡d,粗口暴力唔會令佢地變xxx級 所以比較真係無得好講,美版絕對會贏
@kennethlau6471
@kennethlau6471 Жыл бұрын
舒生,如果無間道拍第4集,劉Sir應該做咗地區揸弗人
@kennethlau6471
@kennethlau6471 Жыл бұрын
舒生,無間道仍然係上一個代港產片普遍邏輯比較差嘅或無乜邏輯嘅世界,若果放喺而家新世代比較學院嘅編、導,喺呢方面新世代係比較出色!
@leeannie7780
@leeannie7780 6 ай бұрын
滿劇粗口,差得多
@diuleela
@diuleela Жыл бұрын
Well said! Especially about their girl friend 🤟🏻
managed to catch #tiktok
00:16
Анастасия Тарасова
Рет қаралды 48 МЛН
Just Give me my Money!
00:18
GL Show Russian
Рет қаралды 643 М.
wow so cute 🥰
00:20
dednahype
Рет қаралды 31 МЛН
managed to catch #tiktok
00:16
Анастасия Тарасова
Рет қаралды 48 МЛН