For Crowfeather's part, I meant to add his father died and he was the only kit who survived his litter. My mistake!

I kinda miss someone. I think Mistystar is really in the list. She lost her mother and father & sister really fast. Silverstream, her friend also died and her brother Stonefur and her apprentice Feathertail died. Stormfur, the only thing left, also died. Her three kits died and Blackclaw and leopardstar died as well. Further, its an awesome video and i totally agree with Crookedstar, Bluestar, Squirrelflight and mostly, Mapleshade, she deserved better.

Im surprised BrightHeart wasnt on here! She was attacked my dogs, her best friend DIED, she thought her mate loved someone else for a LONG while, her apprentice left her, and people treat her differently!

I 100% agree with Crookedstar being #1. He suffered more than any other cat, being tricked into making a promise that ended up taking away everyone he loved.

Honestly I don’t think people know how hard it was for Graystripe, he lost his mate, Silverstream, while she was giving birth. Later Feathertail dies, she just vanished with stormfur and never saw her again after that. Stormfur told him that she was dead but that was one of the last times he saw stormfur before he was captured by twolegs. He never got to tell him goodbye before stormfur went to join the tribe. He has lost his mate and two kits. Ravenpaw dies and all he really has left is Firestar and millie at this point. He does have kits with Millie but briarlight becomes paralyzed at a young age witch leaves Graystripe to live in terror that her health isn’t the best. Graystripe has lost so much but it gets so much worse. Firestar dies to Tigerclaw and all he can do is grieve for the rest of the time he lives. He lost everything, everyone, that he loved.

I had a feeling it was going to be Bluestar and Crookedstar. Poor kitties

I somehow can relate to Bluestar because i lost ppl i cared about and got betrayed by most of my classmate causing me to stop trusting them (except my crush and friend)

Crookedstar was one of my favorite leaders for sure

Mapleshade should've been given a chance at StarClan. She was just heartbroken. Her kits didn't deserve to not be with their mother, as Mapleshade didn't deserve to not be with her kits.

Bluestar lived the worst pain.

I have to say you got most of the cats there! good job!❤❤❤

Dustpelt also never had a good relationship with any of his siblings. And his parents died. His best friend also stopped hanging out with him. For violetshine. She was also in pretty much in a camp ful of death, forced to work against the clans, whom she saw as good cats and raised her. And something sad about her is the she has motherly instinct. To all the cats who are younger than her. like flowerpaw, snakepaw, whorlpaw, the skyclan apprentices she helped bring back, and sunnypelt. Why is this sad? She never had a mother figure. Her mom died, and pinenose just wanted to get rid of her. She wanted other young cats to have the chance to have a good childhood, unlike her. Btw I want her to have one more litter. I love grey wing. If I added to this I'd be here all day. I LOVE HIM SO MUCH Hollyleaf's whole life wasn't a lie. She was loved. By many cats. And she came to terms with that thankfully. Goosefeather needs another chance. He was done dirty. So unpopular opinion here. Mapleshade caused herself most of her pain. She was cocky, never thinking about what would happen when she revealed her kit's father, thinking everyone would accept it. If she told oakstar first then there would be no thinking his son was the father. Mapleshade also blames other cats for her mistakes. It was her mistake to bring the kits to the raging river, even though her mate warned her. She could have been accepted into riverclan if she had waited. Or she could have been a loner, cause appledusk sucks. She then killed ravenwing when all he did was be a good med cat and tell his leader about an omen. She killed frecklewish who did nothing. And she tried to kill a pregnant woman and then killed her now ex. She went too far. But it was funny. YES. Squirrelflight. She deserves so much more. I hope she becomes leader! Leafpool's mate also told her he understood then decided to be passive aggressive towards her! Poor shadowsight. He also never had a connection to starclan. Yes ivypool should be here. Yellowfang was also blamed for the death of her siblings and her mate was toxic I wish bluestar would have waited one more night. And it was all for nothing. Tawnyspots didn't even die until her kits would have been apprenticed. And sunstar never even considered thistleclaw.

My girl Squirrelflight deserves better

1000% agree with this list Especially Graystripe

Rootspring was bullied about his father and bristlefrost died making him miserable and just down right sad

dont forget how blustar also lost her best friend redtail and her mate that she truly loved died

Eaaarrlly gang we all love your videos Fuze and I’m sorry to hear that you’re going through a tough time ❤

Finally Crookedstar getting some recognition!

I also think that Hawkwing deserves to be a part of this list. He lost his brother, his father, and his mate; he was betrayed by the cat he thought was a friend, and he and the rest of his Clan had to embark on a treacherous journey to find the other four Clans, losing Clanmates along the way. His own apprentice, Curlypaw, decided to bail on him and SkyClan to become a kittypet.

I was expecting Leopardstar here XD

The fact 2 one of my fav characters are on here, MapleShade and yellowfang

Also, what about Stormfur? His mother died giving birth to him, he watched his mentor, Stonefur, die, his sister died and he was powerless to save her, and later on, he and Brook were exiled from the Tribe, with Stoneteller telling them that they were "dead in the eyes of the Tribe". Also, let's not forget that his father was from a different Clan. To be honest, I think that Stormfur is only one of many commonly forgotten characters in the series.

I think that Longtail should also be on this list. The two cats that he thought of as his closest friends ended up being giant traitors, his apprentice (Swiftpaw) died, and he was later blinded by a rabbit, forcing him to retire to the elders' den early.

Love this video 🐱

YES MAPLESHADE IS ON THIS LIST YAYYYY

I have a question, why isn't Clear Sky up here? He lost his mate and unborn kits, then his brother abandoned him, then his mate broke up with him, only for her and her kits to die so then because of the stress and pressure he had to give up his son only to take him back but then his son leaves him again and One Eye kicks him out from his home and nearly kills his adopted niece, then he gets beaten up and on top of that he has to live with the guilt of all his actions. If anyone replies "yeah but hes evil and he caused what happened" HELLO? MAPLESHADE'S ON HERE?

I also think Tallstar also suffered His littermate, Finchkit died, which caused his mother to be traumatized for a long time, and acted differently. His father wanted him to be a tunneler, but when Tallkit became Tallpaw, his father was mad angry at him, and also blamed Tallpaw, because they coulnt finish digging one of their tunnels, because Heathertail though it was too dangerous. BUT IM NOT DONE YET. Some time later, his father dies, and Tallpaw was devastated, and with all of his anger, he blamed Sparrow for his fathers death. Shrewpaw also bullied him, and none of his classmates didn't seem to do anything about it. Tallpaw/Talltail started going crazy with his anger and his clanmates started going against him also, after his fathers death, his mother, who was depressed for his sisters death, became mates with Woollytail, and had 4 kits with him. He starts being mean to him, and sometimes it was like Talltail didn't exist Tallstar is so underrated and deserves better

Greystripe went through so much and people don’t know about it :(

I would rank leafpool lower than squirrelflight, she def deserved more hate from her kits but it’s mainly bc of her having a toxic mate

I think this proves why MapleShade went crazy

Crowfeather shoud be in 1!!!! His father Deadfoot died when he was just a kit, then he was in love whit Feathertail but she dies saving him, then he starts thingin that Leafpool is similar to Feathertail but she leaves him and later dies, then all cats doubt his loyality, he have three kits whit Nightcloud but only Breezekit survived and at the start he really loved Breezekit, but then he promised himself that he woud never love again cause just cause pain, then he discover tath he was the father of Hollyleaf, Lionblaze and Jayfeather at a gathering and his relations whit Nightcloud get worse, then in the fight whit the Dark Forest Hollyleaf and Ashfoot dies, then snow white small animals appers in WindClan territory, stoats, and Nightcloud gets lost, Ashfoot and Feathertail starts appering to him in his dreams and telling him to love again, then he got banished because he called his leader plan mousebrained, then he fall of a cliff and a kittypet find him whit the help of Feathertails spirit, then he fond Nightcloud and became jealous because she befriend a kittypet. I know that I had written somethings wrong but I have only 11 years old and I am from Brasil and I am written in may tablet not computer.

cool video

100% agree!! ❤

Actually only one of bluestars kits died, (while she was alive) one died from the cold, but after bluestar had already passed her son joined her,

I honesty think jayfeather had a harder life than ivypool, when he didnt know how to control his powers he got everyones thoughts right into his head, hus while life was a lie but he still stayed, he was treated differently for a long time, he lost the cat he loved 2 times, his sister died, his mother died he was forced to be a med cat and he had to let go of flametail, he had a very hard life

Mistystars my favorite cat

Poor cats. Mapleshade was an awful cat, but I still feel bad for her, no matter what anyone says. 😔

Where rootspring!??!?!

Graystripe's son, stormfur, is still alive

Second Oh and I agree with everyone on this list

Well stormfur could be on here like he never met his mom, his sister died, and his dad died I think before him

I relate to dark tail but my mom instead

Tallstar had a bad life when he was a app

2:38 And Shrewpaw died too.

I absolutely love it I'm jc not Brittany this is my mom's account ❤

So many spoilers! I had to stop the video bc I was crying so hard . I had no idea about squirrel paw and bramble paw, he became leader!? This is why I can’t look up these things just for a drawing.

What about rootspring?

Like i did almost exploud of sadnes when firestar died But i think Firestar he lost Spottedleaf Bluestar Yellowfang Cinderpelt and Squirllflight he lost her dad Firestar her sister Leafpool Her Mom Sandstorm

And for Squirrelflight let's not forget that 3 of her kits died (with Hollyleaf included) 💔

List is correct all the way through

Squirrelflight's life would have been better if Shrewpaw had lived i also think he would have been called Shrewheart

Lmao I remember I saw one of those videos and the person said that Cilderpelt suffered more than Crookedstar and I was like "bitch excuse me? 💀"

Does anyone even understands how Hollyleaf felt?!

Yes crow feather had a bad relationship with my cloud, but that was his own fault for him and be there for him. He could’ve been like a normal. Sorry I just don’t feel like talking about it but instead he pushed her away how many times was she supposed to set her self on fire crow feather warm

The video and the song,, I'm crying :') I agree with the list!

Why isn't bright heart in this!? Her best friend DIED right in front of her eyes, blue star was cruel to her by calling her "lostface" and then she thought cloud tail liked someone else, and her eye got taken out by dogs, AND her other friend ferncloud DIED

Squirrelflight and hollyleaf did it to themselves

birchfall: the last of his siblings and both parents are dead his mate whitewing is dead to... everyone: oh.. poor crowfeather... he lost so much..

Crowfeather had a forbidden relationship with feathertail. Same with leafpool but he was mean to her and their kits which is why everything he went through was well-deserved

I agree with everyone, but I feel like graystripe should be a bit higher on the list. Otherwise I agree, I forgot to say but I don't really think that Hollyleaf should be on the list. She went through pretty much the same pain as her siblings. I respect your opinion to though

leopardfoot or stonefur should be 16th and 17th

Mapleshad expoilted the name of a dead guy and showed zero remorse for her actions. She was a toxic and emotionally abusive partner who only thought of him as an object. She tried to kill an innocent pregnant woman, kidnapped a child, and then went on to groom two kids, all because they were related to people she didn't like. She didn't suffer; it's called karma. Crowfeather is at fault for his bad relationship with Nightcloud. They both sucked; they both used each other for their own personal gain, and their toxicity toward each other had a negative effect on their kids. Squirrelflight's relationship with Bramblestar isn't one-sided abuse. She was just as abusive toward him. Her abuse started way back in TNP. Squirrelflight is equally abusive. She blackmailed him to take her on the journey. She lied to him and used him as a cuckold. Trust was a huge thing to him, and she used him. She acted judgmental and hateful toward him when he wanted to meet his brother, and they weren't built on suspense; they were built on pure jealousy. and tried to guilt-trip him into having more kits when he said he didn’t want any. They both constantly undermine each other's authority, and she does not respect him. She continues to go behind his back. To the point where he cannot trust her.

Incorrect Bramblestar was a better mate ashfur ever could be. And no one start a war disagreeing with me because its true

for people who are siding with mapleshade- I completely dissagree. Im not going to say mapleshade fans dont take murder seriously at all. 1: her novella. OKAY- i just hate mapleshades vengeance. the whole book teaches you nothing. 3 cats get killed and mapleshade doesnt feel any remorse. 2: she blamed her kits death on frecklewish and ravenwing (not just for her deaths but suffering). Ravenwing and frecklewish are ENTIRELY innocent. ravenwing had the vision that mapleshade was lying- and if she kept that secret in, she would be breaking the vow to starclan. and frecklewish wasnt even there at the river in time to save the kits- even if she was there, she couldnt. she'd just drown with em. 3: she learns no lesson. she kills 3 cats with no struggle which is unfair to me. I wish in the end, she failed at killing appledusk and reedshine but no- it does the excat opposite. and i wish she would feel anger that she was in the darkforest and thought: its not MY fault im here! its their fault.. i did NOTHING to be here. but no she never says that. Im just focusing on her main novella for this topic. if you dissagree with me, feel free to argue.

The reason why Squirrelflight STILL ended up with a bad mate is her own fault because Ashfur wouldn't have trapped them, died, possessed Bramblestar, or have died twice. There's no way y'all can change my mind that everything about her mates are her own fault, because technically IT WAS. (No offense to the Squirrelflight fans)

Why is hollyleaf here but jay and lion aren’t? The other two suffered 1000 times more than she did, especially Jayfeather. She didn’t go through the most pain, she was just weak and couldn’t handle it.