Western WAR PROPAGANDA Makes Peace in Ukraine Impossible | Dr. Ulrike Guérot (Part 2)

  Рет қаралды 81,623

Neutrality Studies

Neutrality Studies

Күн бұрын

German original here: • Der Ukrainekrieg im Ko...
Part 1 of the interview here: • Germany Does It Again:...
Ulrike Guérot, one of Germany's most prominent intellectuals, explains how war propaganda in Europe makes peace with Russia impossible, why she is accused of being a "Putin apologist," and what conclusions we can draw from the blatant pro-war rhetoric of public media.
Dr. Guérot is the founder and co-director of the European Democracy Lab. She was a professor at the University for Continuing Education Krems starting in 2016, and from 2021 to 2023, she held the position of professor of European politics at the University of Bonn until her dismissal last year due to plagiarism accusations.
Dr. Guérot has also been a critic of government COVID-19 measures. At that time, she publicly presented important analyses of the social situation, including on the channel of the late philosopher Gunnar Kaiser.
When the Ukraine war broke out, she was one of the first signatories of the Manifesto for Peace by Sahra Wagenknecht and Alice Schwarzer. She has also repeatedly advocated for an immediate diplomatic solution to the war in the German media. For her realism-based analyses, she was harshly criticized.
Personally, I consider Ms. Guérot to be one of the greatest German thinkers of our time. Therefore, it is a distinct honor for me to speak with her today.

Пікірлер: 955
@alanhamford2538
@alanhamford2538 3 ай бұрын
The Basic Principles of War Propaganda: 1. We don't want war, we are only defending ourselves! 2. Our adversary is solely responsible for this war! 3. Our adversary's leader is inherently evil and resembles the devil. 4. We are defending a noble cause, not our particular interests! 5. The enemy is purposefully committing atrocities; if we are making mistakes this happens without intention. 6. The enemy makes use of illegal weapons. 7. We suffer few losses, the enemy's losses are considerable. 8. Recognized intellectuals and artists support our cause. 9. Our cause is sacred. 10. Whoever casts doubt on our propaganda helps the enemy and is a traitor.
@pmkeith
@pmkeith 3 ай бұрын
I am sorry to say this, but I see many strong parallels here with "human expectations" of many cults and religions - most of which are claimed by human adherents to be "divine" in whichever way. Most of the current set of ideas you are highlighting here are those of "western liberalism" - which is fast proving itself to be a cult that strongly opposes the diverse beliefs of all other groups. As an exercise, try looking at your statements in relation to the "war" on "climate change" (whatever that utterly meaningless label - invented by western liberalism - is alleged to suggest). Clearly your statements are not in order of priority - because without exception "our cause is sacred" is always the number one priority.
@blackmagic6
@blackmagic6 3 ай бұрын
Thanks for this information.
@christopheryellman533
@christopheryellman533 3 ай бұрын
Nice summary Al.
@treefrog3349
@treefrog3349 3 ай бұрын
The propaganda is not surprising. The level of acquiescence TO it is very disturbing. Devastating, actually.
@normanlorrain
@normanlorrain 3 ай бұрын
Thanks, you helped me find it. Anne Morelli, 2001 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Basic_Principles_of_War_Propaganda
@robertalexanderho5268
@robertalexanderho5268 3 ай бұрын
Totalitarian state is not on Russia but in the US, UK and EU.
@andre8860
@andre8860 3 ай бұрын
Amen to that Russian guy here
@mediastudiesnetwork
@mediastudiesnetwork 3 ай бұрын
🤦
@horasefu1438
@horasefu1438 3 ай бұрын
ah so naive, as long as people are so, so naive, we're stuck in the same global situation.. so painfully naive...
@Way827
@Way827 3 ай бұрын
Totalitarian elitist clique. It's a real dystopia; the west.
@Way827
@Way827 3 ай бұрын
@@horasefu1438 People in the UK I know feel that Palestinians aren't worth caring about, or Libyans, Syrians, Iraqis, Afghans. That is why the US were able to destroy their countries first. They engineered mass racism in the media. Now they have tried it on Russia and next is China.
@weblitera
@weblitera 3 ай бұрын
a lot of talks about Putin like he is a single person, forgetting that 85% of russians support him and that is almost 130 million people. if you try to understand why these people support him, what their interests are and where, you start to live in real world, where all wars could be avoided
@seeker2118
@seeker2118 3 ай бұрын
If you give thought to the perspective of others then it takes credibility away from the narrative that is being attempted to be imposed.
@dgulakov
@dgulakov 3 ай бұрын
If you take 85% from last election results then count it right - from the number of voters that was something around 90 million.
@stanspb763
@stanspb763 3 ай бұрын
@@dgulakov Which were 87%of the votes of the 114.2 million people who were registered to vote.
@henrik4438
@henrik4438 3 ай бұрын
77% of voters participated. Where else do you see such voter enthusiasm? 🤷🏻‍♂️
@lukasbauer8783
@lukasbauer8783 3 ай бұрын
And this by the way under circumstances where the Russians overall are Not at all inclined to just trust their government nilly willy. Far from it, for plenty of good, historical reasons the Russians tend to be more cynical and sceptical about there own "elites" than most people in the West are. They are not at all going to fall for propaganda easily..
@ForTheSakeOfTheSongs
@ForTheSakeOfTheSongs 3 ай бұрын
Media propaganda is extremely brutal !
@everready800
@everready800 3 ай бұрын
Is even worse than that. They're deleting posts that don't fit the narrative. Propaganda and censorship!
@yaoliang1580
@yaoliang1580 3 ай бұрын
Their lies work very well on the ignorant
@raymondpomfret4214
@raymondpomfret4214 3 ай бұрын
But most people are aware of the properganda from main stream media only the brainwashed belive it
@lioneldemun6033
@lioneldemun6033 3 ай бұрын
​@@yaoliang1580Absolutely. They openly loathe people with culture.
@yaoliang1580
@yaoliang1580 3 ай бұрын
@@lioneldemun6033 the constant ideological attacks on China by the US n its vassal states has nothing to do with difference in ideology n culture but it's purely economics as they are no longer able to compete on equal terms with China. It's all due to economics
@patricklarsen8078
@patricklarsen8078 3 ай бұрын
It is easier to fool a man than to get a man admit he has been fooled.
@klaudioabazi4478
@klaudioabazi4478 3 ай бұрын
Story of Civilization. It happens over and over again. People prefer to be lied and screwed continuously than to have the guts to admit that they're treated like sheep.
@treefrog3349
@treefrog3349 3 ай бұрын
The history of America Government in a nutshell.
@vaska1999
@vaska1999 3 ай бұрын
Serbian liberals in a nutshell.
@spudwesth
@spudwesth 3 ай бұрын
Twain
@grahamhireme9283
@grahamhireme9283 3 ай бұрын
I reiterate. Never underestimate collective stupidity!
@JackGreystoke
@JackGreystoke 3 ай бұрын
Very interesting, thank you. However, when you say “I don’t like Putin”, you keep one foot in the camp of the lie. You haven’t met him. Yet on paper he must be considered one of, (if not , the,) greatest political statesmen in history since the death of Moses. What he has managed to do for Russia in the last 24 years, despite Anglo-American pressure is almost miraculous.
@user-pj5ub5cp9k
@user-pj5ub5cp9k 3 ай бұрын
Putin is a sadistic genocidal psychopath.
@gboete
@gboete 3 ай бұрын
I have not the slightest idea why I would NOT like Putin. Compared to any American president, I admire him so much more. After listening to him for hundreds of hours in evenement, speeches, interviews, I did not hear him say anything that really bothers me, on the contrary. He seems to be a very nice, compassionate, understanding, PATIENT, intelligent, knowledgeable… person, that loves his country, has moral values and supports the traditional family and community live of Russia. Perhaps there is even more freedom in Russia than in our West, where vaccine mandates were often used. I saw Putin say that he would never agree with such mandates.
@ceinwenmoll3097
@ceinwenmoll3097 3 ай бұрын
33:32 I have noticed that everyone feels obliged to say something negative about President Putin when defending him. I think history will be very kind to him for his outstanding work for Russia.
@user-pj5ub5cp9k
@user-pj5ub5cp9k 3 ай бұрын
@@ceinwenmoll3097 Putin's criminal invasion of Ukraine has poisoned the well of Russian Ukrainian for generations. His Special Military Operation for Demilitarisation Denazification and Liberation is a tragedy for the Russian and Ukrainian people.
@stanspb763
@stanspb763 3 ай бұрын
True, I am an American who has spent time in 92 countries and have lived in Russia since Jan 2000 and have seen the dramatic rise in quality of life, personal freedom, lack of stress, access to culture openness etc in modern day Russia that is missing from Europe and the US. I would have asked her what is actually true that causing you to dislike Putin. She said that because it is essential not to be banned in states that are vassals of the US. She knows if she was objective she would lose her job and any access to media. All public figures in the collective west know they have to stay aligned with whatever is claimed by Washington. Living in fear of saying the wrong thing is one of the great sources of stress and dishonesty in the west. Truth is dangerous and must be punished in the west.
@agunnayaman6300
@agunnayaman6300 3 ай бұрын
Intelligent and brave professor. What a shame that Germany is punishing truth speakers. Kudos to this woma❤
@dag1489
@dag1489 3 ай бұрын
Alina Lipp. Punished by Germany for reporting truth from Donbass.
@wojteks4712
@wojteks4712 2 ай бұрын
No, she isn't. She ignores basic facts and pretends there is bias when people see those basic facts. Russia are brother-killers. That's it. We have all seen it. And when you listen to her you may pretend there are "good people on both sides". Not really
@wojteks4712
@wojteks4712 2 ай бұрын
@@dag1489 donbas invaded by Russia? where russian Strelkin organized fake paid "separatist movement' and created war that took thousends of lifes? Are you so deep into russian lies?
@jossiesh7649
@jossiesh7649 3 ай бұрын
Thank you, Ms Ulrike Guérot, for being brave and fighting for humanity.
@wojteks4712
@wojteks4712 2 ай бұрын
What is brave about spreading meta-bullshit to painf fake simmetries between genocidal invader and peaceful free countries
@metugeekane8454
@metugeekane8454 3 ай бұрын
What is happening to this lady makes one understand why educators across Swedish universities are silent.
@peetsnort
@peetsnort 3 ай бұрын
Shes absolutely brilliant.
@christopheryellman533
@christopheryellman533 3 ай бұрын
Yes, and they lack the honesty, balls and integrity to speak up.
@homayounshirazi9550
@homayounshirazi9550 3 ай бұрын
They have been muzzled !
@johniepatterson3746
@johniepatterson3746 3 ай бұрын
Now Swedens is not such a safe country anymore open borders will destroy Europe slowly dying..
@melsaloj5778
@melsaloj5778 3 ай бұрын
Indeed, a doctor explaining cancer to a patient is not wishing cancer upon that patient; an economist warning about recession is not rooting for it; a meteorologist saying it will rain tomorrow is not hoping for rain.
@marions7423
@marions7423 3 ай бұрын
have he not seen carlson interview. putin explaind that mershaimer with his nato is a fool
@BobWidlefish
@BobWidlefish 3 ай бұрын
You just love Putin! Sorry, couldn’t resist. The blame narrative is just yet another thought-terminating cliche.
@opetelkaaluemaan
@opetelkaaluemaan 3 ай бұрын
wouldn't be so sure about the doctor...
@red-baitingswine8816
@red-baitingswine8816 3 ай бұрын
3 false premises.
@khunmikeon858
@khunmikeon858 3 ай бұрын
@@marions7423where Putin disagreed with Tucker was in respect of the USA focus on China as the new / most important enemy of America ! You are being selective either intentionally or through ignorance.
@brunoschnider1837
@brunoschnider1837 3 ай бұрын
Herzlichen Dank für diesen tiefgündigen Gedankenaustausch! Wie schade, dass derartige Gespräche nicht einer breiteren Öffentlichkeit kund gemacht werden.
@peetsnort
@peetsnort 3 ай бұрын
My goodness. This is the most mature conversation I have heard in ages. Such fabulous rational. If I get some money I'm going to send it to pascal. He's brilliant This is exactly what we are are missing in the leadership of the west
@gregorylumpkin2128
@gregorylumpkin2128 3 ай бұрын
As a 70 year old who grew up in the west and under constant fear mongering with regard to the Soviet Union, followed by the genocide committed by the west in Southeast Asia, and endless wars since then, I would say that corporate fascism is the thing that makes peace in Ukraine nearly impossible. This, and some other interesting issues, also makes peace in Gaza almost impossible. Propaganda is just a tool, a very effective tool, that the corporate fascists use against us, via the principal governments of the western empire.
@Jay...777
@Jay...777 3 ай бұрын
The globalist elites want to control the world. They can't stop or it all collapses. If you're wondering why the US & Europe are doing all this insane stuff right now, that’s the reason why.
@pare5markes909
@pare5markes909 3 ай бұрын
The greatest tool of the western narratives is the stupidity and ignorance of their citizens at a dramatic high decree !
@pawelpap9
@pawelpap9 3 ай бұрын
Interesting. Clearly 70 years is not enough to learn anything.
@rdallas81
@rdallas81 3 ай бұрын
When you figure out who owns the Federal reserve, everything begins to make cents. Obiden Cl in to Bush Rothschild😮
@rdallas81
@rdallas81 3 ай бұрын
​what do you know besides what media and your own deceptions teach you?
@americanexile
@americanexile 3 ай бұрын
Exactly. Any critical examination, discussion or analysis is cast as denial. Denial of a state-sponsored narrative -- and one which clearly benefits an elite few at the expense of many, which also must be denied.
@mljenk21
@mljenk21 3 ай бұрын
#1A #1stAmendment #FreedomOfSpeech #youtube
@goranmarko6205
@goranmarko6205 3 ай бұрын
As I am sure, no German has ever heard the factual story what happened in Kerch in Crimea during the world war II. The bridge today connecting Russia with Crimea is called Kerch bridge, because the bridge ends in Kerch. So, During the second world war the germans occupied Crimea. The people in The town of Kerch were reluctant to send their children to school, as they were scared of the germans. So, the germans told the population, there is nothing to worry, the children will be safe. So, the parents sent their children to school. So, in the first day, the germans took the children for a picnic near the forest. They gave the kids some pastry, sweets and drink. In 15 minutes all 243 children were dead, by the poisoned pastries. 3-4 children didn't eat the pastries, so they were still alive. So the germans gave them poison droplets straight in their mouths. So, those 3-4 children died too after 15 min. When the parents asked were are the children, the germans told them - they sent the children in wester European families, so they will be safe until the war is over. Why am I writing this my dear germans BECAUSE AFTER 80 YEARS OF THAT EVIL MURDER, NOW THE GERMAN MILLITARY OFFICERS WERE PLANING HOW THEY CAN ATTACK THE KERCH BRIDGE. SO EVEN MORE PEOPLE OF KERCH WILL BE HURT. ARE THOSE PEOPLE SANE, HAVE THEY LOST THEIR SANITY AND HUMANITY, JUST TO PLEASE THEIR ANGLO SAXON MASTERS. JUST UNBELIEVABLE
@eriklarsson3188
@eriklarsson3188 3 ай бұрын
*Kazhar masters.
@mhenkelmann11
@mhenkelmann11 3 ай бұрын
Ich habe diese Geschichte in einem Gespräch mit der Sprecherin des russischen Außenminister zum ersten Mal gehört. Dazu muss man die Stelle der Sprecherin als jemand der nicht nur russische Regierungsmitteilungen in die Öffentlichkeit bringt, sondern auch Propaganda und das Böse des aktuellen Feindes, der ja wieder durch die Enkelgeneration die gleich Orte angreift wie die Großvater vor 80 Jahren. Das sind gefährliche Narrative, die man benutzen kann , um den "Feind" in einer Escalations zu entmenschlichen und die Rücksichtslosigkeit in einem heißen Krieg auf die feindlichen Zivilisten durch die eigenen Soldaten zu entschuldigen. Weitere Wiederholungen zu einem späteren Zeitpunkt machen diese Erzählung sah r und Ärger kommt auf, was vor 80 Jahren in Kersch geschehen seien soll- Das diese Erzählung im Bewusstsein bei den deutschen Generälen ein Kalkül war , glaube ich nicht. Das dieser Vorfall in diesem Kontext stattfand oder über wahr ist, kann man bezweifeln . Die Sowjets haben bis 1990 das Katyn Massaker an 30000 polnischen Offizieren der deutschen Wehrmacht unterstellt. Aber es war eine Lüge, und mit den Alliierten USA, UK abgesprochen . ICH halte diese Geschichte mit Vergiftung der Schulkinder für eine Propaganda -Erzählung. Es zeigt aber die mögliche Intension für weitere Eskalation des Ukraine, - Westen - Russland Krieges.
@mhenkelmann11
@mhenkelmann11 3 ай бұрын
@@eriklarsson3188 I first heard this story in a conversation with the spokeswoman for the Russian Foreign Minister. To do this, you have to take the position of spokesperson as someone who not only brings Russian government communications to the public, but also propaganda and the evil of the current enemy, who is once again attacking the same places through the grandchildren's generation as their grandfathers did 80 years ago. These are dangerous narratives that can be used to dehumanize the "enemy" in an escalation and to excuse the ruthlessness of one's own soldiers towards enemy civilians in a hot war. Further repetitions at a later date make this story more visible and anger arises about what is said to have happened in Kersch 80 years ago. I don't believe that this story was a calculation in the minds of the German generals. It is doubtful that this incident took place in this context or that it is true. Until 1990, the Soviets blamed the Katyn massacre of 30,000 Polish officers on the German Wehrmacht. But it was a lie and agreed upon with the allies USA and UK. I think this story about the poisoning of school children is a propaganda story. But it shows the possible intention for further escalation in Ukraine, - West - Russia war.
@goranmarko6205
@goranmarko6205 3 ай бұрын
@@mhenkelmann11 You don't get the point. I can guess, you are german. It is not this story, that is special. There are thousands and thousands of stories similar to that one. Like , what comes to my mind just now. In Kraguevac Serbia, the local partizans were fighting the german forces, and as a result a few germans were killed. So what the germans did, they went to the towns gimnazia ( or high school), and surrounded it, and captured other people they can find in that moment of rage. 7000 people, most of them children were shot in cold blood. You don't have to believe me, go to Kraguevac one day and you will see the monument. But, I know, you germans don't learn in your history books about things like that. It is difficult for you to digest the truth. And, Did Serbia ever attacked Germany. Of course not. But Germany again supported the bombing of YUGOSLAVIA. Did Russia attacked Germany after warld war II. Of course not. What, those german generals were planning, was to attack Russians again. After invading Russia and killing 25 millions, they are planing to attack Russians again. It is just insane. And people like you can't accept the fact and reality. You were not attacked by the russians, but you were attacked by the americans. They destroyed the north stream pipe. It will cost Germans untold billions of damage. I know, your government is scared to mention that, and are hiding the truth. And many people in the world are making jokes with Sholc about that . But if they are so stupid and have slowed the german economy as a result, they did it for their personal reason, not to anger their masters in Washington. The question is why you are so stupid to follow the Washington. Think about it. The russians are giving you cheap gas, and you prosper. But the americans are destroying your cheap gas and are forcing you to pay 4-5 times more expensive gas. And the ukrainians are very happy with that outcome. And you, support the americans and the ukrainians, because your government and german media are telling you to do. So you can't think for yourself. That is definition for stupidity.
@evgen-cy6so
@evgen-cy6so 3 ай бұрын
@@eriklarsson3188 Olaf Scholz is the grandson of Lieutenant General and SS Gruppenführer Fritz von Scholz. The warrior fought with the Russians in both world wars, and personally participated in the executions of Jews in Poland and Ukraine. Thousands of former Nazis after World War 2 found a new homeland in the USA, Britain, and Canada!
@stanley1554
@stanley1554 3 ай бұрын
Bravo. Excellent presentation 👏👏
@user-sm8cg9cr7v
@user-sm8cg9cr7v 3 ай бұрын
My father was Swedish and my mother was half Bavarian from Germany. I was born in Australia i am dissapointed with Germany how they are ruining their country. I think Germany should follow Austria and remain neutral and follow what is best for their citizens.
@reginaldpoofta5
@reginaldpoofta5 3 ай бұрын
Exactly this. What was the problem buying gas from Russia? Nooo, Americans forced Germans to stop it and destroyed nord stream. Americans should mind their own business.
@eriklarsson3188
@eriklarsson3188 3 ай бұрын
Why should they follow German Austria? The issue is the Germans have A: Had bad leadership since the outbreak of WWI to present day and B: They have a habit of following bad leadership that does not have their nations best interest. Not to say this doesn't hold true for most nations.
@user-sm8cg9cr7v
@user-sm8cg9cr7v 3 ай бұрын
@@eriklarsson3188 What you say is true. The problem with Germany and France in my opinion is they have lost sovereignty amongst their political elite.
@carbugnov1952
@carbugnov1952 3 ай бұрын
​Not only in Germany, but also in the USA and UK they have bad leaders. Changing the leader three times in less than a year and each time for the worse explains that. ​@@eriklarsson3188
@pawelpap9
@pawelpap9 3 ай бұрын
Austria became neutral by a fluke of history and the reason was to avoid responsibility for the WWII.
@maitlen4021
@maitlen4021 3 ай бұрын
Extraordinarily impressive, engaging guest. Marvelous discussion.
@AndrewKNI
@AndrewKNI 3 ай бұрын
A brilliant discussion. The saying "if you are not with us, you are against us" springs to mind. With the way society and attitudes are changing I'm glad I'm getting old!
@peetsnort
@peetsnort 3 ай бұрын
But you can impress upon the children in the 25 years old bracket to listen to this video. I insisted that my 33 year old son must make the effort to watch this video for his own future s sake
@AndrewKNI
@AndrewKNI 3 ай бұрын
@@peetsnort Good advice, thank you 🙂 Very important indeed.
@JanWasp
@JanWasp 3 ай бұрын
Pascal thank you SO MUCH for having this interview with Ms. Guérot. This discussion just has to take place, the role of media manipulation and the awful propaganda that´s being force fed to us. What´s incredible is that the mainstream media are 100% in line despite the huge amount of narratives closer to the truth on alternative media. Wonderful contribution from your guest on how linguistic tricks are used to force one-sided thinking.
@richardparker1338
@richardparker1338 3 ай бұрын
The media empires are another example of totalitarianism. Discourse and investigation is not tolerated by the owners and their sponsors aka advertisers. Journalists and editors have to comply with propagating the narrative regardless of any cognitive dissonance, otherwise they become unemployable in their chosen field. In totalitarian regimes people are imprisoned or killed for opposing views. In the "freedom of the West" you are ostracized, coerced, cast out and have bank accounts frozen in Canada.
@7777wilson1
@7777wilson1 3 ай бұрын
This wonderful woman is exceptional. I enjoyed your discussion together immensely👏 God bless you both and let's keep advocating & helping all to reconsider their thought structures before it's too late🙏✌️
@henrik4438
@henrik4438 3 ай бұрын
Agree. That's why she got fired from her job and cancelled
@carolberry2239
@carolberry2239 3 ай бұрын
Thank you a good thinker....thats why she was cancelled. She needs her own platform.
@richardguevara8879
@richardguevara8879 3 ай бұрын
Whenever I find myself disliking someone I ask myself 'why?' I set myself the task to identify at least 10 valid reasons in 10 minutes for disliking that person. If I am unsuccessful I then turn inward to repair myself. My dislike of someone unjustly means the problem exists with me. When people say to me they dislike President Putin I ask why. What has he done? Tell me the reasons why? I also seek a comparison. For example ; I ask their view on President Obama. Always there are glowing reviews on President Obama. I then point out that President 'we tortured some folks' Obama is responsible for the death of millions of people all over the world. He was responsible for the overthrow of the Ukrainian government, the Bolivian government, etc. He started the sanctions on Venezuela. He dropped more bombs on African soil than any US President before him. He put the bullseye on Julian Assange. Etc, etc, etc, etc, etc, etc. What has President Putin done? Save his country from the ticks, leaches and vampires of the west? When the Soviet Union collapsed due to the successful plot of the US the west immediately started feeding and feasting on Russia's natural resources. President Putin brought an end to that. He got rid of the ticks, leaches snd vampires. The Russian people used to bow their head in shame at what their country had become. President Putin returned pride to the eyes and hearts of Russians. Is this why you don't like President Putin? Because he got rid of the western ticks, leaches and vampires? Because he returned pride to the Russia nation? Please... Look inward. Evaluate yourself. Who are you?
@sva9550
@sva9550 3 ай бұрын
Bravo. Well said.
@saradash3156
@saradash3156 3 ай бұрын
Really well said
@NapaValleyVegan
@NapaValleyVegan 3 ай бұрын
Thanks for this conversation. I am American and am a minority when it comes to seeing the world through a nuanced lens. We have been propagandized so effectively that we sadly believe anything our legacy media and duopoly tells us. I see similar issues here in the EU. It is hard to think for oneself only to be labelled anti-vaxx, Putin puppet, antisemite, Trumper or many other derogatory terms. But I can start each day knowing that I am at least less likely to be fooled by fear or anger than most of those around me. 🤷
@susanpetropoulos1039
@susanpetropoulos1039 3 ай бұрын
Maybe you (we) are in the majority but effectively kept at bay by aggressive actions of the true minority.
@NapaValleyVegan
@NapaValleyVegan 3 ай бұрын
@@susanpetropoulos1039 Maybe we are! I like that idea.💡
@eksaangoyan9162
@eksaangoyan9162 3 ай бұрын
❤!Absolutely!Thank you, for this brilliant discussion!
@BigLebowski65
@BigLebowski65 3 ай бұрын
To understand the Western animosity toward Russia in general and the Ukrainian conflict in particular one should view Siberia as the grand prize Britain and Russia have been fighting over for a couple of centuries now. Perhaps one goes back to Kissinger and Brzezinski to see how, but to Mackinder’s “The Geopolitical Pivot in History” to understand why.
@Jay...777
@Jay...777 3 ай бұрын
The globalist elites want to control the world. They can't stop or it all collapses. If you're wondering why the US & Europe are doing all this insane stuff right now, that’s the reason why.
@wileyc5824
@wileyc5824 3 ай бұрын
How people cannot see that your discussion is a replay of europe and the world in the 1930's and 40's to a certain extent...is astounding. There is nothing new here except that the nazis aare no longer just the germans, but europe, north america and in general the anglo-saxon world.
@rickmcconnell5093
@rickmcconnell5093 2 ай бұрын
Only the Gov't psychopaths that rule OVER us. Remember that Biden called 1/2 the country domestic terrorist for not going along with their BS. That is a recipe for disaster when we are talking about 100+ MILLION people, many with firearms, that will not accept a illegitimate "president".
@jamesappleton5063
@jamesappleton5063 3 ай бұрын
I like how she thinks and agree, and hope her ideas can be shared with the masses.
@markdimeo7060
@markdimeo7060 3 ай бұрын
Anyone who can get you to believe in absurdities can make you commit atrocities. ---Voltare
@alexanderkovalyov5211
@alexanderkovalyov5211 3 ай бұрын
This explains a LOT - even the mere existence of the EU and its bureaucracy... Thank you.
@duncanmckeown1292
@duncanmckeown1292 3 ай бұрын
Far from being a "psychopath" Putin is one of the few leaders in the world today acting from rational...predictable...premises. As Mearsheimer might have added, since at the latest 2008, and the overtures to Ukraine and Georgia to join NATO, Putin's "red lines" have been clearly stated. The West totally, and often insultingly, ignored these warnings.
@patrickcassidy8594
@patrickcassidy8594 3 ай бұрын
Another brilliant discussion . Blinkered thinking is affecting my friendships . Regards from Gifu
@akap_987
@akap_987 3 ай бұрын
You are not alone. I sometimes feel I am the one who has lost my mind
@yaoliang1580
@yaoliang1580 3 ай бұрын
​@@akap_987don't worry, when you belong to the majority, then start to worry
@akap_987
@akap_987 3 ай бұрын
@@yaoliang1580 Thanks….I need to hear that. I am starting to doubt myself
@sva9550
@sva9550 3 ай бұрын
Ditto. I’ve lifelong friends who were assimilated by the borg without a whimper of resistance.
@akap_987
@akap_987 3 ай бұрын
@@sva9550 Same here. I love my friends and they are great people, so it is disheartening to see they buy all the rubbish and don’t use their critical thinking skills to question what they must!
@nilslarson7532
@nilslarson7532 3 ай бұрын
what a brave and clear headed lady . Thanks !
@jann9507
@jann9507 3 ай бұрын
Fantastic interview; such an original thought leadership should have a much wider audience. - her perspective on diversity of categorical loss ; - fear as a weapon; - one-up man ship by claiming Ukrainian language requirement to study Ukraine; - comparison as a tool between world events; - Covid as a state recuse to removal of thought structures; - The lack of pagination or spatial knowledge path when using the web; - Digitization as a targeted dumbing down of thought.
@SOLOIND
@SOLOIND 3 ай бұрын
never has a hour gone faster, so thank you very much and I look forward to your next conversation. Greetings, an Indian/Norwegian writer.
@aleaiactaest8354
@aleaiactaest8354 3 ай бұрын
Excellent interview.
@TerryWheelyabarrabackApiary
@TerryWheelyabarrabackApiary 3 ай бұрын
Fascinating subject. I'm still very confused is. Why is the world ignoring the last 10 years of genocide committed by West Ukraine In East Ukraine? It's well known and well proven and yet we call the Russians the bad guys for freeing people from constant discrimination and murder by the Ukraine Army. I'm only an ignorant Australian born Russian. I do not call myself Australians because there is no such race called Australia. I still speak a little Russian from my childhood of learning Russian before English. Why do so many people hate Russians? I don't remember doing anything bad to any country or race. What is the real objective? I now live in Canada and I'm frightened to tell anybody I'm Russian descent. I have suffered anti Russian discrimination all my life. I'm either a commie or something else . I didn't create these wars. Why are we all pigeon holed?
@user-nl4bs5xn8l
@user-nl4bs5xn8l 3 ай бұрын
It seems it's really about energy, petroleum and natural gas. The West would have to rely on Russia for affordable energy. By reducing western populations there will be less future demand
@MelvilleSperryn
@MelvilleSperryn 3 ай бұрын
Be proud of your Russian heritage. Russia is defending the world against malicious financial interests (Edgar Cayce prediction)
@harryflashman4542
@harryflashman4542 2 ай бұрын
Half a century of American movies and television where the Russians were always the bad guys. It's an unconscious bias which was easy to tap into.
@ShiShiShiShiShiding
@ShiShiShiShiShiding 3 ай бұрын
Thank you, Pascal and neutrality studies! Excellent work and translation.
@dylanthomasolseadog2803
@dylanthomasolseadog2803 3 ай бұрын
Fabulous level of analysis. Thank you both.
@SusanHopkinson
@SusanHopkinson 3 ай бұрын
This was a brilliant conversation. The Professor was hoping to incite further studies into our thinking processes, and I would like to point out that there is a 2500 year old method that is unparalleled - Buddhist philosophy. The foundation of Buddhism is to question the mind, see that we are not the mind - neither our thoughts nor our emotions. It is the best way to stay aligned with truth and sanity 🙏🏻
@majdavojnikovic
@majdavojnikovic 3 ай бұрын
There is one situation in history that showes how a country turned 180 degrees in a day. Look for 1948 and Informbiro resoulution in Yugoslavia. It is considered higly controversial move and Tito's critics were using it to show his dictatorship, but today, looking at it, it was the only way to avoid what happened to Yugoslavia in the 1992-1999 - destruction and placing the border between two powers in the middle of it, like it was in centuries. Now EU didn't use the destruction of northstream pipe lines to turn it's politic for 180%, or even for 18% :))) It is going to be dismanteled. A country needs highly inteligent leaders. We don't have them, we have only highly corrupt ones.
@ikocadcam1004
@ikocadcam1004 3 ай бұрын
They turned it for 360 :)
@majdavojnikovic
@majdavojnikovic 3 ай бұрын
@@ikocadcam1004 they didn't. They initially used the same method, internally, and briefly, for about 18 months, but then they positioned themselves in the only logical place, in between, and gradually open their borders. They at one moment had a passport that didn't need a visum for almost any country in the world. And they reminded a socialist country for a long time, in kind of socialistic kindergarden :)
@reimei2819
@reimei2819 3 ай бұрын
Excellent discussion. Both of your words free my heart and mind. Fundamentalism is the root of all evil.
@Oganes1968
@Oganes1968 3 ай бұрын
Thank you! Such a pleasure to her calm and smart people. Excellent analysis!
@isao5257
@isao5257 3 ай бұрын
Speaking Ukrainian nowadays in the western political and media circles, means "Can you say Putin is an evil dictator?". The same goes for speaking Jewish, "Do you condemn Hamas?".
@DajeilGelian
@DajeilGelian 3 ай бұрын
Well the Ukrainian civil war was already going on for 8 years in 2022- it started in February 2014 after the empire led coup.
@pmkeith
@pmkeith 3 ай бұрын
Time to burst some the "bubbles" in which certain people reside - Politicians - "sometimes people dislike the fact that we have to make difficult decisions" The people - "No, you are universally despised precisely because you frequently and deliberately make bad and wrong decisions. And accept no responsibility for doing so." Pop, pop, pop !!!
@gordonmorris6359
@gordonmorris6359 3 ай бұрын
Ukrainians everywhereshould call for the reinstatement of President Yanukovych, the only Ukrainian leader that BOTH sides can trust to preside over a neutral buffer state.
@Tina-jh2sk
@Tina-jh2sk 3 ай бұрын
I’d like to say that as a NewZealander it is refreshing to hear such a rational discussion.We don’t get much unbiased coverage down here.
@stanspb763
@stanspb763 3 ай бұрын
None of this matters. Since the foundation is ignored no conclusions can be valid. Europe has made itself irrelevant, by following US dictates Europe is lost its markets, independence, and future. No one talks about the origins of the Ukraine conflict in Europe, since the origins are important and how all events followed from the US regime change and removal of democracy of Ukraine 8 years before Russia responded. No one is addressing the installation of an radical extremist faction that never had more than 1% of support, remnants of the Nazi movements. Russia had legitimate fear of a US aligned Nazi force on its borders while slaughtering the people of Donbas for 8 years before Russian's patience ran out. The US goal has been to break up Russia into smaller weak countries and taking control of resources it seeks. The result has been the entire unipolar world run by the US has broken in two factions, the US and its vassals of Europe, Canada, Australia and Japan, on one side and the the Global South on the other. The later group of nations are almost all growing, produce the majority of innovations and patents, have little debt and majority of world population. Russia is being seen as the defender of this larger portion of the world population which was held back and controlled by European imperialism that impoverished most of the world. The simple fact that trade, innovation and population favors this global south. Europe can argue all it wants but it is rapidly becoming unimportant in world affair, it has deindustrialized, become weak and become a voiceless vassal of a collapsing US empire. BRICS is on track to add 40 more countries into hat is already the largest trade block and which will not use the US dollar or euro for trade settlement. This division between the rising Global South and declining US empire with its declining vassals in Europe shifts the center of trade and innovation east again as it was for 4000 years before European use of gun powder enslaved most of the world and transferred wealth to the small constant warring countries of Europe. All of US vassal states are targeting Russia for destruction and bankruptcy but Russia is too united, strong and adaptive to be destroyed Europe and US, The US force called NATO has been shown to the world as weak so the number of ex-colonies rushing to align with the winning side, such as Africa, Middle East, South America and much of Asia. If a world wide poll was taken, there have been, the most respected leader is Putin, and second is Xi, and 3rd is Modi. No one in Europe is held in high esteem nor is Biden. The sanctions against Russia were not effective to the shock of the US and Europe and only revealed how the rest of the world wants to disconnect from Europe, and to be out from under the boot of the US which still has 800 foreign military bases used to control countries and yet can't reverse the trend of countries moving to become independent of the US. A simple fact is evident, to anyone who has spend time in both Russia and Europe or US, quality of life, lack of debt, security, access to culture, education, personal freedom, low stress life, favors Russia now and that is why Putin was elected with 87% of vote in a society with over 40 main political parties. The vote reflected the true feelings of the people. But even your discussion in this channel suggested that it was not democracy because the people of Russia have a different view. Is there a single leader in Europe that has made life dramatically better? BRICS within 2 years will represent 78% world population and will not be trading with Europe or the US, so Europe needs to solve its own problems and not depend on the colonies for economic support like is has for 450 years.
@henrik4438
@henrik4438 3 ай бұрын
Nobody I know cares about the foundation of the Ukraine conflict. All are parroting the US narrative and everyone who doesn't is in for a lonely life with no chance to pursue a career. These people will only learn the hard way, which is the decoupling from the 'Global South'. A system where the 2 blocks share the same planet in 'tolerated coexistence'. Sad story.
@Fredmayve
@Fredmayve 3 ай бұрын
I hope you are right. Rome had to be overrun several times before it fell.
@pawelpap9
@pawelpap9 3 ай бұрын
You should have stopped rambling at the point you admitted Russia was your favorite place to live.
@showdown66
@showdown66 3 ай бұрын
You think African nations would be at the forefront of computer chip development and other scientific innovation if it weren’t for European imperialism? Ok
@henrik4438
@henrik4438 3 ай бұрын
@@pawelpap9 maybe you should read up on history a little bit 🤷🏻‍♂️
@mitchgingras3899
@mitchgingras3899 3 ай бұрын
The Western propaganda issue is like throwing a shovel to someone stuck in a hole. Two choices...dig yourself out or dig yourself deeper.
@OrwellsHousecat
@OrwellsHousecat 3 ай бұрын
Thanks for the first class translation features btw
@Larkinchance
@Larkinchance 3 ай бұрын
A talking point is a bias directive used in conversation... I live in the States. I am not a scholar but I know something about Europe as a result of the 1919 Treaty of Versailles, the re organization of Europe leading into WW2 and the Cold War from 1945 till 1990. When I try to explain that it is complicated because there is a lot of history here, I am met with hostility. "Well that was then and this is now!" or "Borders are sacred." The US corporate media describes the war in the simplest of terms. The Russian invasion of Ukraine was "unprovoked". What I find difficult and isolating are people's refusal to even listen to another point of view. In 2011, the cover of the New York Post had a full page cartoon sketch of Putin with dripping fangs reminiscent 1916 cartoons depicting the Hun.. I am not necessarily pro-Russian as much as I am worried about my own country..
@pmkeith
@pmkeith 3 ай бұрын
I am quite interested in who is telling you that "borders are sacred". Judging by their policies and actions I would have thought that the idea that "borders shouldn't exist" is the prevalent motivation of the vast majority of politicians in western so-called "democratic" governments - whether national or supranational. Maybe it is only the gullible citizenry that thinks it has a right to national security. Borders are what borders are - mainly artificial boundaries the nature of which is designed to prevent interaction between various groups of people for whatever purpose. Those who claim to be adherents of "open borders" themselves deliberately set up borders using other "means" - employing financial, political, racial and cultural discrimination as their "border protection". It is only genuine freedom of speech and freedom of association that allows us to throw "truth bombs" over the borders so that different "controlled groups" can communicate. But unfortunately, the borders are now being set against people who chose to speak out against injustice on the internet.
@khunmikeon858
@khunmikeon858 3 ай бұрын
Thank you. I’m a retired Irishman living in SE Asia with full access to Russian and Chinese media. All Russian media access is banned in my home country to “protect me” at my tender age 😂. I have many friends and colleagues around the world including in the USA. And I want to tell you that it’s Washington and it’s puppets and sponsors (not the American people) that are the global thugs delivering death and destitution on millions of people around the world. It’s despicable. I wish the American people would force a stop to this mayhem because if you don’t then one of those days the USA might finally have to play a “home game” for the first time in more than a century. I’m with Russia on this one. 🇮🇪💚🇷🇺 With >800 American military bases around the world “protecting” the USA from attack. It’s all about power and greed for the elite.
@nedimramic9001
@nedimramic9001 3 ай бұрын
To be American enemy is very dangerous but to be friend is fatal H. Kissinger
@joe_ninety_one5076
@joe_ninety_one5076 3 ай бұрын
To be an enemy of Russia is dangerous, but to be a 'brother' is fatal (JoeNinetyOne).
@nedimramic9001
@nedimramic9001 3 ай бұрын
@@joe_ninety_one5076 Joe the Cowboy 🤣
@JasonFoster-mq2vi
@JasonFoster-mq2vi 3 ай бұрын
@@joe_ninety_one5076 All the evidence I've seen strongly suggests that if the political leadership of brother Ukraine and cousin Georgia had not offered their countries to western interests to be militarised by NATO right on Russia's doorstep - something Russia made crystal clear that it considered a direct threat to it's homeland security - it's unlikely that the current tragedy would have occurred. Given that the US would not for one second tolerate a Chinese or Russian military presence being set up within striking distance of American homeland soil (Mexico, Cuba etc) - there is no sensible argument I've seen to explain why we should realistically expect the Russians to tolerate us doing something to them that we would never tolerate them doing to us (and did not tolerate it in 1962). Even the Australian government recently made it clear to it's tiny Pacific neighbour the Solomon Islands that it considered the plan to allow a Chinese naval base to be set up on Australia's back fence (nearly 2000km from the Australian mainland) as unacceptable to Australia's security concerns. We westerners seem to engage in an awful lot of "do as we say - not as we do".
@joe_ninety_one5076
@joe_ninety_one5076 3 ай бұрын
@@JasonFoster-mq2vi In 2014, Ukraine was officially non-aligned. It had no membership application, and no membership action plan. Both the Yanukovych government and the interim government declared neutrality. Public opinion was against the idea of joining NATO. There was little chance of getting the required unanimous agreement of 30 NATO states to this controversial notion. France and Germany had already stated their opposition, and it is very unlikely that some other states would have been more enthusiastic. Putin still invaded. Besides, how does annexing territories that are closer to NATO move the 'NATO border' further away from Russia? And his belligerence has brought him more NATO, in the shape of Finland and Sweden. Surely Putin must have expected this? His relatively subdued response to the latter suggests that NATO is not his prime concern. It is not really about NATO, which is no threat to Russia.
@joe_ninety_one5076
@joe_ninety_one5076 3 ай бұрын
@@JasonFoster-mq2vi The analogy with Russia or China is not a good parallel. Both are authoritarian states run by a despot and a handful of siloviki (or the Chinese equivalent) with few check or balances and no requirement to suffer the electoral consequences of their actions. They are likely to be feckless and arbitrary decision makers. Neither the US nor (especially) the collection of democratic states that is NATO are at all the same. The 1962 analogy isn't great either. Since the 1960s America has tolerated Cuba on its doorstep. The missile crisis was about the siting of nuclear missiles in Cuba, not about its neutrality, but when Putin invaded Ukraine in 2014 there was no prospect of American or NATO nuclear missiles in Ukraine. Even in the highly unlikely scenario of Ukraine joining NATO had Putin left them alone in 2014, the NATO-Russia Founding Act of 1997 would forbid the siting of such missiles there.
@galanis38
@galanis38 3 ай бұрын
Excellent discussion (including Part 1.)
@eyeofchorus6313
@eyeofchorus6313 3 ай бұрын
What-about-ism may be used to squelch criticism. Accusations of "what-about-ism" may reveal bias in that, the accuser only wants to talk about one side being guilty.
@michaelmakarevich601
@michaelmakarevich601 3 ай бұрын
Thank you for the great guest!
@OrwellsHousecat
@OrwellsHousecat 3 ай бұрын
Superb, as usual
@metugeekane8454
@metugeekane8454 3 ай бұрын
How can rational choice institutionalism and normative institutionalism be meaningful if we disqualify historical institutionalism? The despotic politicians of Europe are destroying European academia!
@akap_987
@akap_987 3 ай бұрын
Great discussion. We need more analysis at a fundamental level. Thank you!
@lenz6293
@lenz6293 3 ай бұрын
Such a great and immediate translation, what a pleasure to listen to.
@ceinwenmoll3097
@ceinwenmoll3097 3 ай бұрын
33:14 Ms Guerot i wish you well and thank you for your amazing brave insight. Thank you too Pascal
@peberdah
@peberdah 3 ай бұрын
The problem is very simple why NATO had not beeun dissolved in 2'000, at that time Merkel was saying we need TVA paid by US Bases, Germany was in an economic crisis. Schroeder save Hanover by concentring next to the station, Insurance and Wealth company as the Hanover Fair, later he manage to obtain low cost energy from Russia and awake Germany and Europe.If Dombass is returned to Ukrain, what it do of it bombard it again.
@hfdthvd
@hfdthvd 3 ай бұрын
The postulation that explaining the impetus behind Russia's incursion into Ukraine equates to somehow excusing their actions, is rather akin to accusing a constable of complicity in a crime merely for investigating its underlying motives.
@lenz6293
@lenz6293 3 ай бұрын
Sehr erfreulich, Fr.Guerot mit Menschen ihrer Bildung und ihres Niveaus sprechen zu sehen. So bekommt man einen wirklichen Eindruck was diese Professorin gegenüber Sprücheklopfern, Maulhelden und Menschen auszeichnet, die Andere weder ausreden lassen, noch einer sachlichen Diskussion gewachsen sind. Weiter so, Fr. Guerot, wir brauchen Sie in dieser Zeit ganz besonders.
@Diego-fb5fq
@Diego-fb5fq 3 ай бұрын
#1 lesson of German history. Don't attack Russia. Thank you for this reminder in the beautiful language that should be the language of peace for all time to come.
@DBGE001
@DBGE001 3 ай бұрын
For anyone that want to have a bit more of the historical backgroud on the Ukraine conflict and the partizan role the EU played, please have a look at the discussion: "What JFK tried to do before his assassination w/Jeffrey Sachs" on the Real News network KZfaq channel.
@user-lb2eo6zs1j
@user-lb2eo6zs1j 3 ай бұрын
This interview should be on main stream news very logical lady spot on .keep speaking young lady go go
@myla6135
@myla6135 3 ай бұрын
Starting around 2004 my world view began to change (post Iraq) albeit slowly. I recall writing to The Times of London expressing astonishment at their support for the UK intervening in Libya. It was almost jingoistic the way that paper framed the justification for it. That change continued slowly as I tried to get a better understanding of historical events. Difficult given the nonsense I'd learnt at school and the articles I read in the MSM and watching the news on the BBC..... although I never trusted them very much after Libya. It was covid that really started me doubting things and since then it has sped up post Ukraine and now Gaza. I'm no longer the person I was in 2003. My world view has changed completely. In the process I had to give up many friendships. But that does not trouble me. It's more important for me to try to see the world more clearly. Certainly, having different sources of information like this channel is a great advantage in that. And I glance at the MSM but no longer take what they say to be gospel.
@isabelmelladojensen9043
@isabelmelladojensen9043 3 ай бұрын
The last 20 min of this discussion is pure intellectual gold Thank you so much. I wish both of you the best Peace, love and light
@user-fq1xh7bg7gJoe_Frisina
@user-fq1xh7bg7gJoe_Frisina 3 ай бұрын
An illuminating conversation. I remember Porfessor Guerot made a great impression at the Chautauqua Inst. here in New York state around 2015. As a lifelong student of Russian Lit. I have delved deeply into Russian history. I agree with her analysis. You must host her again, Pascal. Her work is very important. - Joe Frisina, BA Pitt (69 year old anti war protester).
@Captain8159
@Captain8159 3 ай бұрын
Hervorragend!
@blauetoile
@blauetoile 3 ай бұрын
Merci a vous deux! ❤
@jacquitaaffe7104
@jacquitaaffe7104 3 ай бұрын
Loved this insightful conversation we need more of them.
@deanedge5988
@deanedge5988 3 ай бұрын
An essential listen - especially for us Anglo-Saxons. Thank you.
@joaomartins7413
@joaomartins7413 3 ай бұрын
Excellent interview Dr. Pascal Lottaz. The most contemporary mathematics is based precisely on the need for a plurality of perspectives to know or deeply understand a certain mathematical "object". Knowledge of a certain mathematical “object” or discipline is deepened and broadened by the new relationships that we discover between this “object” or discipline and other “objects” or disciplines. No longer a simply intrinsic understanding but an extrinsic one, an understanding of the relationships between “objects” or mathematical disciplines. This broader and deeper understanding is the heart of what we call “Category Theory”. Epistemologically this amounts to saying that relationships determine “objects” and not the other way around. To cite only two mathematicians and philosophers on this subject, I would cite Prof. Fernando Zalamea and Prof. David Rabouin. Greetings (Porto, Portugal)
@EnergyDiscoveries
@EnergyDiscoveries 3 ай бұрын
It's so good to hear intelligent people speak!❤
@SM-df9hm
@SM-df9hm 3 ай бұрын
As I wrote this comment elsewhere before; Putin did not and does not screw up as much as many western leaders and therefore Putin does not need "apologists" but many if not most western leaders do need as many apologists as they can get because they mess things up left and right.
@seeker2118
@seeker2118 3 ай бұрын
Well the western leadership has projected so much of their own personality onto the Russian president, so I guess just another projection.
@ranjitkundu7919
@ranjitkundu7919 3 ай бұрын
Very narrow perspective
@user-pj5ub5cp9k
@user-pj5ub5cp9k 3 ай бұрын
So why are there so many Putin apologists in the West?
@SM-df9hm
@SM-df9hm 3 ай бұрын
@@ranjitkundu7919 Yes? Then enlighten us with your wide perspective!
@user-pj5ub5cp9k
@user-pj5ub5cp9k 3 ай бұрын
@@SM-df9hm There are numerous Putin apologists in the West. The diplomatic apparatus around Putin is constantly constructing a Web of lies to mask Russian criminality.
@coshyno
@coshyno 3 ай бұрын
You are spot on here ! I hate it when people think that explaining Russia's position is excusing it or even supporting the invasion ! They seem to be confused into thinking explaining is excusing ! Very frustrating. If you do not understand why your enemy is doing a certain thing then don't ever expect the war to be resolved not even with brute force because even if you win they will come back stronger for ever until the reason why they came is resolved and nobody attacks another country just because they ''hate you'' or they are ''blood thirsty Russians'', such terms are only good for propagandists who aren't interested in a intellectual debate or conversation. Although I totally understand why the average Ukrainian wouldn't agree and even hate the Russians but I have never seen or heard Russians say they hate Ukrainians but you often see Ukrainians think that Russians hate them and I would think so too if I was being invaded, I don't think I would be taking the time to look into the deeper cause of the war such as for example a group of people in a certain province of my country that would become disillusioned with a regime change or revolution that they did not support because it did not have as much respect for their particular culture or language ( as did those people when they were in control of society ) and got punished as a result of counter protesting by this new government and its supporters who may or may not have been brutal street thugs beating up any counter protesters and coming after them afterwards in the cities were they are most found as in the east of Ukraine for example. I think in the moment of the situation, if you supported the revolution and support the new system because it is a better one you think then its only normal to rally up behind the flag and believe the cause is worth the fight and not worry too much about the details but the devil is always in the details ! The reason why a whole country gets behind a effort to go to war are always profound and not just for land grab, something led to this and it isn't entirely the fault of Russia nor is it that of Ukraine nor is it that of the West, I think every one played a part in the reasons that led to this. It isn't just because ''Putin'', had it been another Russian leader with things playing out exactly the same, I think the result would have been the same ! I think Russia has gone way too far but that is jut my opinion.
@neutralitystudies
@neutralitystudies Ай бұрын
No. The point is that there were countless ways of deescalating this conflict that had been going on since at least 2014 but what the US and western allies did was double down instead of pushing for a proper solution like a federalization and neutralization of Ukraine. This was a very very bad policy choice and has way more to do with using Ukraine against Russia than saving Ukrainian lives. Ukraine is being used against Russia and we know that because top NATO people say so („best investment we can make“ and stuff like that).
@christopheryellman533
@christopheryellman533 3 ай бұрын
PL, please continue to conduct these conversations with Ulrike. I would like to see her continue to go to deeper levels. For example, who benefits financially from the type of information/behavior control she presents? Can change arise from "grass roots", rather than trying to expose the thinking of authorities?
@robertlawson4295
@robertlawson4295 3 ай бұрын
Pagination is NOT gone on the Internet. Open each link in a new tab and - voila ! - you have a set of pages you can refer back and forth to and even print them out if you want to scribble notes.
@richardparker1338
@richardparker1338 3 ай бұрын
Sure, there are ways of using the huge database in a structured way. However, most people just click on links and get drawn down rabbit holes, and then pop up in a different field altogether. It requires a huge amount of discipline to avoid getting led offtrack into KZfaq shorts or TikTok. 99.99% of people don't want to engage and think. They want to be entertained...
@usmanyusuf-hw5gr
@usmanyusuf-hw5gr 3 ай бұрын
If you print them out, they become like pages in a book. 😊
@riccardodececco4404
@riccardodececco4404 3 ай бұрын
the point is that of course you can structure the internet database, but there is no spatial connection of this structuring to our senses. You read a book very differently to internet texts.... That is also a reason why people cannot remember anymore information and where they found it
@sva9550
@sva9550 3 ай бұрын
It seems even those who have the courage to fight against imposed conformity feel the need to defensively qualify their position by way of appeasement. For example “ I think there is a different way to think about Ukraine/Russia- I don’t like Putin” or “We must stop the continuing genocide in Gaza - I don’t like Hamas”. On what evidence do we form those likes and dislikes…and why does it even matter to the discussion. It is somehow ironic to label another country undemocratic when the whole conversation has centered on how western discourse has become so tightly controlled that people are targeted and lose their livelihoods if they don’t march in lockstep.
@siguc
@siguc 3 ай бұрын
28:40: Recognizing the shared responsibility in the conflict is the only way to peace: I find this statement very powerful, applicable to various past and future conflicts, incl. even WW2. Thank you, Dr. Guerot for stating it so clearly!
@zolarichards
@zolarichards 3 ай бұрын
Great conversation 👏🏽.
@lukasbauer8783
@lukasbauer8783 3 ай бұрын
The problem is the category of evil is not always inappropriate. More so than the category of good at least, in the political field. I certainly don,'t think there are any saints or angels in positions of political leadership (though I think both the catholic and the russian churches canonized as saints MANY people much, much worse than Vladimir Putin, by the way, so there's that). I think though that there are plenty of devils. Metaphorical devils, of course, but I don't think literal ones could possibly be worse. There are conflicts, indeed the vast majority of all conflicts throughout all of history, where there is no particular moral difference between the warring parties. This absolutely is the norm. But it is not universally true. All sides bear responsibility but not always equally. It's logical fallacy to assume that truth has to be in the middle between extremes. This confkict is one of those rare conflicts where there is no moral parity at all. But the problem is that it is the aggressive, imperialist West that deserves the overwhelming majority of blame and stands for what can hardly be truthfully described as anything other than evil. Telling people in the West that it was all just some kind of mistake is just continuing to lie to them. Being truthful would mean to admit that western "elites" have been knowingly, purposefully and maliciously lying all this time. Pretending that mistakes were made or that western elites are trapped in incorrct thinking does miss the point by miles. No western politician believes that Russia attacked Ukraine without provocation, because they know they all worked hard for many years to provoke just this wars. No western politician ever honestly believed they were acting in defense, they always wanted to attack and annihilate Russia, they just didn't want to be seen as firing the official first shot. This is completely typical of aggressors and ruthless megalomaniacal would be conquerors. Even Chinggis Khan thought it extremely important to insist that he never started a war without the other side using violence, breaking treaties or violating the sancticity of emissaries first. Conquering the known world just happened, almost by accident. Similarly the West(ern elites) hides the predatory lust for domination driving it's actual policies. The West never wanted peace, it always wanted world domination like a crazed supervillain and it always wanted to destroy Russia, because Russia refuses to submit to it and is an obstacle on the way to total, eternal domination. To claim that the problem is the population, that the population is what stands between us and the possibility of peace is dishonest and stupid. There is no influence of the population on questions of war or peace in the West. There is no meaningful democracy in the West, none. It's like arguing that Hitler could not have stopped the war because he had so propaganddized the people that the people would not have accepted peace eveh if Hitler had changed his mind, as if somehow the people at some illdefined point had taken over from the leaders as the true driving force behind the continuation of hostilities. But that never happened, not in world war II, not in the current conflict, nor in any conflict in history, period. Making peace now would just mean that the actual psychopaths, in positions of power in the West, presumably realized that they can't win the war they engineered right now and/or that the risk of them being themselves annihilated is for the moment too great. But the emphasis is on "for the moment". They will never genuinely want lasting peace, just time to plan their next attempt. So basically all the accusations against Putin suddenly start ringing true the moment they are turned against our own "leaders". And seeing as they are the ones who are psychopathic criminals they indeed need to be overthrown and punished, not psychoanalyzed or lectured on correct thinking. The talk about propaganda also misses the point, because the people in charge here know perfectly well that they started it and that they are lying and bullshitting all the time.
@shaundudley4576
@shaundudley4576 3 ай бұрын
You stole my comment! Shame on you! AND you used Chat GTP to make so much better than mine. Villain! Anyway, thank you for making this very crucial distinction I would have been too lazy to lay out with such thoroughness. The most egregious and dangerous mistake these equivocators commit is to imply some kind of moral equivalency. How they can know and pretend to understand the grotesque realities of Evil as it materially and blatantly manifests more egregiously by the day and still not get it, shows a moral and intellectual cowardice that dooms them and maybe us all.
@naradaian
@naradaian 3 ай бұрын
Lovely contributions
@audibledarkness
@audibledarkness 3 ай бұрын
Excellent, thought provoking discussion. Many thanks.
@REwing
@REwing 3 ай бұрын
Thank you for explaining all these created lies to dumb down the public, but the public don’t want the truth, it’s too painful.
@OrwellsHousecat
@OrwellsHousecat 3 ай бұрын
"separate the brawlers" demonstrating her parental perspective, rather than a principled one. What about when it really is one side bullying the other?...... and perhaps they use the predictable behaviour of the oversimplified "separate-them/ceasefire" parent to their advantage by attacking the Other in tge full knowledge that the worst outcome is that mummy will split them up for a short time whilst he can sharpen his sword in preparation for his next attack. Jihad uses precisely this method.
@DBGE001
@DBGE001 3 ай бұрын
Is this a reflection you make in the historical vacuum or that one that starts in February 2022 ? If you listened to the history explained in the discussion then you would have know that the root of the conflict started in 1995 under the lead of then US president Clinton.
@hermannschraut87
@hermannschraut87 3 ай бұрын
Socialingenering 🎉🎉🎉🎉
@kostask8851
@kostask8851 3 ай бұрын
And Thank you both very much for this amazing talk. I wish some of the EU leaders find this interview they may learn something.
@cretumarius9616
@cretumarius9616 3 ай бұрын
You are the best Chanel thank you for the work you do
@everready800
@everready800 3 ай бұрын
Zelensky said he believes Vladimir Putin will turn to Kazakhstan next, before moving on to the Baltic states, Poland, and Germany. "For him, we are a satellite of the Russian Federation," he told CBS. "At the moment, it's us, then Kazakhstan, then Baltic states, then Poland, then Germany. At least half of Germany."
@kubhlaikhan2015
@kubhlaikhan2015 3 ай бұрын
MI6 runs the Ukrainian government, the CIA run their armed forces, the IMF own their natural resources. Good to know that Zelensky cares so much about Ukrainian independence.
@susanpetropoulos1039
@susanpetropoulos1039 3 ай бұрын
Putin has been gifted with near immortality to live long enough to conquer all those territories?
@nicolasjuandecardenas7921
@nicolasjuandecardenas7921 3 ай бұрын
Of course he would say something like that. Fear mongering.
@everready800
@everready800 3 ай бұрын
@@nicolasjuandecardenas7921 And the media never call out the ridiculousness of his statement.
@mdizzlero
@mdizzlero 3 ай бұрын
Who is the French psychologist she mentions?
@ranjitkundu7919
@ranjitkundu7919 3 ай бұрын
Ariane Bilheran
@terryl858
@terryl858 3 ай бұрын
@@ranjitkundu7919thanking you
@ceciliawinter3249
@ceciliawinter3249 3 ай бұрын
When all else fails.....they take you to war😢
@karlad4082
@karlad4082 3 ай бұрын
Thank you for such an amazing interview 🙏🏼
@akpanekpo6025
@akpanekpo6025 3 ай бұрын
I believe the real problem is trying to have a meaningful debate with people who are driven by bad faith. What's the point if your opponent's real goal is to distract you from the facts? You see this on Gaza, for example, where you're invariably an anti-Semite by suggesting that slaughtering children in hospitals might be wrong, so you end up defending yourself against a ludicrous charge instead, thus lending credence to utter nonsense. On Russia, the facts (by which I mean the daily, relentless provocations) are undeniable, which is why your opponent's goal is to distract you with nonsensical insults such as "Putin apologist", the goal being (you guessed it) to waste your time defending yourself against a spurious charge instead. So I blame those who naively attempt to engage with such malign distractions. Just report and focus on the facts, and ignore the bad-faith responses. I'm no great fan of Mearsheimer on certain issues (China being one example), but you'll never hear him waste a split second indulging his bad-faith critics' charge of "anti-Semitism" or of being a "Putin apologist".
@SM-df9hm
@SM-df9hm 3 ай бұрын
Well said!
@ranjitkundu7919
@ranjitkundu7919 3 ай бұрын
They can't argue points. So they descend into NAME CALLING / ABUSE. Of their opponents ie Childish Immature reactions. Based On their childish thinking & mindsets
@susanpetropoulos1039
@susanpetropoulos1039 3 ай бұрын
When losing an argument they always go off topic.
@61Willo
@61Willo 3 ай бұрын
One of the most important conversations I’ve heard in awhile. There is a fear of the truth on both “sides”. The need to displace one crisis with another is deep Orwell. That is where we are. Very refreshing and encouraging to hear what I’ve been feeling and seeing verified by worthy thinkers such as yourselves. Thank you . Danke.
@boost4774
@boost4774 3 ай бұрын
An absolutely brilliant expert. Well done.
@denniscurry6464
@denniscurry6464 3 ай бұрын
Thanks for covering this topic. Good luck Ulrike
@ThvonS
@ThvonS 3 ай бұрын
One of the best talks on Ukraine and the media war so far
Дибала против вратаря Легенды
00:33
Mr. Oleynik
Рет қаралды 4,7 МЛН
Was ist im Eis versteckt? 🧊 Coole Winter-Gadgets von Amazon
00:37
SMOL German
Рет қаралды 32 МЛН
Vortrag Gabriele Krone-Schmalz - Eiszeit. Eisenzeit.
1:12:46
kommunalpolitisches forum Land Brandenburg
Рет қаралды 282 М.
LIVE: Nigel Farage hosts Reform UK rally in Birmingham
1:26:16
The Times and The Sunday Times
Рет қаралды 303 М.
Podcast: Wieviel EU steckt in unserem Alltag? | Lanz & Precht
51:01
ZDFheute Nachrichten
Рет қаралды 192 М.
Why Does the US Establishment Hate Russia?
17:36
Vladimir Brovkin
Рет қаралды 200 М.
Дибала против вратаря Легенды
00:33
Mr. Oleynik
Рет қаралды 4,7 МЛН